Steam Engines Full Guide (From the Depths 2021)

  Рет қаралды 25,724

Liv's Lab

Liv's Lab

Күн бұрын

Had to take down the video momentarily to fix an error, I (wrongly) claimed that a large crank can only connect 1 large piston, however they can take up to 3!
Also my RPM/Friction graph is slightly off, since RPM to friction is linear, but the power output scales exponentially to RPM. The point I'm making remains the same, the graph is just slightly wrong.
Few more resources, that have been circling around on the discord for ages:
Summary on Steam building in picture form (source unknown)
cdn.discordapp.com/attachment...
Steam Engine Calculator for piston ratios and more by _Zdex007
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/...
Steam Engine Design by Ao Kishuba:
docs.google.com/document/d/1v...
Turbine Lenth Guide by efhosci
cdn.discordapp.com/attachment...
If there are still questions, theres a ton of friendly people in the comments or on the Official FTD Discord:
/ discord
Join the Odex Campaign Discord:
/ discord
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
00:21 Summary
02:30 Basics
06:52 Boilers
07:57 Turbines
12:52 Pistons (Cranks)
13:30 Pistons (Staging)
16:57 Pistons (Size)
20:57 Pistons (misc stuff)
25:39 Pistons (Propellers)
27:50 Demo Build
34:41 Outtro Ramble

Пікірлер: 126
@chillbuilder101
@chillbuilder101 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for doing this, it's great! There hasn't been many good steam tutorials since the steam update; but the way you explained it is really structured and concise. Actionable intel, as it were.
@revenevan11
@revenevan11 2 жыл бұрын
The turbines seem to be useful for starting out in adventure mode, imo (I'm on my 2nd try of it now, but I used to play FTD more in the past before adventure mode was a thing). At the start of adventure mode, when material *consumption* efficiency is king since you have so little and need it for building, I've been using an RTG or 2 with a battery bank and electric motor, since then I don't consume any resources when running normally. For combat (especially sustained) or emergency GTFO maneuvers though, sometimes your batteries will get run down. In that case, a small steam turbine set to turn on when batteries are below a certain level can be really helpful! It doesn't provide power itself like a fuel engine, but those have volume issues for small&cheap early rafts. The *power* requirements are solved by adding more batteries, since the electric motor/engine actually provides power based on the size of the battery bank it's connected to!
@Klint_Izwudd
@Klint_Izwudd 2 жыл бұрын
Okay now do the cube of steam with the large pistons. But seriously your small engine cube has revolutionised my designs. Thanks
@Oneye.
@Oneye. 2 жыл бұрын
Great tutorial! Now I have no excuse for using injector engines. Also a nice choice of background music. (For those wondering it's the Into The Breach soundtrack by Ben Prunty)
@ravenwiley9918
@ravenwiley9918 2 жыл бұрын
Really helpful to get a grasp on steam, I've been to overwhelmed by it to try so far, appreciate it!
@ILKOSTFU
@ILKOSTFU 2 жыл бұрын
Wow, the most comprehensive guide I have ever seen. Thank you so much!
@RightClickGamers
@RightClickGamers 2 жыл бұрын
This is amazingly useful, thanks for the short version in the beginning, it prepared my brain for the rest of it actually. I have to go back and rework my bombers and single owned ship now. Hard part is making every OTHER aspect of my vehicles not suck now.
@andregaspar7553
@andregaspar7553 2 жыл бұрын
Nice one! Keep up the good work. You make things easy to understand 👍 Love your tutorials
@MrAlbinocreeper
@MrAlbinocreeper 2 жыл бұрын
IIRC perfect staging is closer to 5:4 rather than 1:1, also feel fuel engines are better than you give them credit for. also im pretty sure you can throw multiple large pistons/crank, but that may have been reworked out
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
yes, though the benefit is only a few %, so its more something to cover in Part 2. Any also yes, you can put 3 pistons on a large engine, dont know how I missed that one, already corrected the description
@Flupp1
@Flupp1 4 ай бұрын
thanks man, there was one thing i didnt got but your in depht explanation actually covered that nieche part, you rock.
@thephoenixempyre2300
@thephoenixempyre2300 2 жыл бұрын
Incredible video, explained pretty much everything one needs to know
@KingZelab
@KingZelab Жыл бұрын
Great video style, love the concise information
@Christian-jc6gf
@Christian-jc6gf 8 ай бұрын
Fuel engines are still my goto because of how easy they are to optimise, but your explanation of steam turbines was perfect, so thanks!
@DerHeizmeister
@DerHeizmeister 2 жыл бұрын
Really the best and most easy to understand tutorial on steam engines out there. Can't wait for the next one!
@no3ironman11100
@no3ironman11100 6 ай бұрын
How a from the depths tutorial should look like. Explanation by someone who thoroughly made sure they expertly mastered where every number and interaction works within the system, guided with a basic, short version, and a more in depth but precisely timestamped bigger section.
@chtechindustries4174
@chtechindustries4174 2 ай бұрын
Definitely a great guide, and still very useful. Still, waiting on the part 2… I’m not sure how to use water-tight shafts, and info on drills would be most appreciated!
@rocketdoof1398
@rocketdoof1398 2 жыл бұрын
The best tutorial I could have ever wanted no ramble :)
@hawkeye6854
@hawkeye6854 Жыл бұрын
I'm just gonna add, hybrid engines are still very possible with the addition of the steam pipe vent's pressure limit setting. Place it in between your cylinder output and the turbine assembly and set it to like 8 or so, and it'll keep pressure up for the turbines but not let it get high enough to jam the system.
@CrazyNapalmGuy
@CrazyNapalmGuy 2 жыл бұрын
Liked and subbed. Thanks for outdating all of my ships... Guess it's time for a rework.
@CodeRed7109
@CodeRed7109 2 жыл бұрын
5 minutes in and this is a huge help!
@vikingursigurdsson4985
@vikingursigurdsson4985 Жыл бұрын
Amazing video
@leonardoharman3203
@leonardoharman3203 2 жыл бұрын
I like your words Magic man
@RandoNetizen27
@RandoNetizen27 2 жыл бұрын
Thank you for the tutorial.
@jonaskingofsparta
@jonaskingofsparta 2 жыл бұрын
An amazing video that has helped me a lot! A few remarks\questions: 1) the concept of backpressure was briefly mentioned but never explained or defined. I intuitively understand it,but that's bcs I already knew that piston convert steam based on a pressure difference. 2) what's those bugs with valves you mentioned? I rather like them for keeping boilers pressurized and reducing spinup times. I've noticed some UI issues when you feed a valve directly into a piston (in my case, that first large piston went red bcs it thought it was not connected and the reported ppm doubled), but it didn't seem to affect behaviour keep it up, can't wait for part 2! this was a video the community badly needed. I salute you for making it.
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks! 1) Theres not much to explain, you said it yourself, backpressure means pistons cant develop as much power since the power they can create depends on the pressure difference! I might go into more detail in part 2. Now its true that whatever is causing the backpressure now gets more pressure to play with, but I have never found a case where intentionally causing backpressure by adding turbines or even boilers was a good idea. Its confusing at best and ruins your engine at worst! 2) Some interface bugs related to the pressure being displayed incorrectly. Also pipes behind valves dont vent steam even if they have a leak! Great for damage control since you can have a leaky pipe with pistons at the end and you still dont loose steam. But I built an engine that can switch between 2 and 4-stage mode, so I need to vent pressure that would otherwise have been put back into the system and thats impossible right now because of the bug
@edwardhett4381
@edwardhett4381 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab maybe you could stick a second valve and that vents excess pressure in 2 stage mode?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
@@edwardhett4381 thanks for the tip, but too late unfortunately. The new stable update fixed the bug, so I already built and tested the engine, and it works fine! I just need to make the video, hopefully this year still but no promises
@firehawk5962
@firehawk5962 2 жыл бұрын
Dude this is such a great tutorial! Could you do more please?
@Vivicect0r
@Vivicect0r 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks a lot for this one! Very nice explanations. Your small steam engine is rly the most optimized form I can think of. However comparing small and large systems there is one issue you have not mentioned that I believe is very important - damage tolerance. Small steam can be disabled or reduced in power quite easily by incoming damage and there are a lot of fragile piping without much redundancy. Large steam hides most of the piping inside the pistons and the pistons themselves have a lot of HP and quite some armour. They are good and surviving spalling or HEAT or frags and make your ship more combat stable.
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
You make a very good point! Given my current upload schedule it looks pretty unlikely but I added it to the notes, in case I ever make a part 2 of the tutorial
@SeshSoldier
@SeshSoldier Жыл бұрын
^^Easily one of or the best Steam guides, "like and favourite this shit" as Robbaz would say
@inscseeker401
@inscseeker401 2 жыл бұрын
I’m still wondering why this channel doesn’t get more support
@FuturPlanet
@FuturPlanet 2 жыл бұрын
Very good
@rome2.04
@rome2.04 2 жыл бұрын
Germans talking about engineering is the best ASMR. Change my mind.
@Mernom
@Mernom Ай бұрын
25:36 Turns out a hybrid crank motor/piston prop is possible.
@darth_dan8886
@darth_dan8886 2 жыл бұрын
This must be the best steam engine tutorial out there. I know it was challenging... But would you be willing to also make one for the fuel engines as well? The material is lacking in that area.
@elecbaguette
@elecbaguette Жыл бұрын
they don't seem to understand fuel engines very well, (I don't any better) so it may not be the best idea
@philonetic321
@philonetic321 2 жыл бұрын
I didn't know anything about piston engines before watching your video. Made some; 120 small pistons, 3 pistons per crank. 12 wheels. Material use/sec 97.3 Power output 59743 Power/volume 99.6 Power/material burned 614.1 No valves. 144 small piston version; 11 wheels. Material use/sec 116 Power output 70992 Power/volume 101.7 Power/material burned 612 168 small piston version; Material/sec 133.5 Power output 81512.2 Power/volume 102.7 Power/material burned 610.7 ---- Using this for new ship; 144 piston, 16 wheels, 12 shaft generators Material use/sec 116 Power output 12933.1 Power(or energy)/volume 106.5 Power(or energy)/material burned 655.5 Energy output 63104.2 Sam's Lab is #1!
@nicopence3148
@nicopence3148 2 жыл бұрын
WOW. This is amazing. It took me hours just to figure out the turbines. Also, when did the large pistons change to only being able to connect to 1 side instead of 3?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
Yeah it took me hours to learn steam in general, too! They can still be connected on 3 sides, my bad!
@nicopence3148
@nicopence3148 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab Ahh. I still cant believe that your 7x7 box is more efficient and more powerful than all fuel engines (caps out at 81.1 if you include the required fuel boxes)
@nicopence3148
@nicopence3148 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab Also. If you want to do the same for fuel engines I can give you all the information and equations (except for gas duplication which I found out yesterday) for you to double check.
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
@@nicopence3148 well you do need quite a seizable steam engine until the numbers start to look good, its pretty hard to get that kind of numbers with more compact engines so on a small scale I think fuel engines might be better or at least competitive. Honestly I never built a fuel engine myself so I dont know what numbers to expect!
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
@@nicopence3148 GModism uploaded a tutorial for fuel engines yesterday (great coincidence) wich is quite nice. Though he only went over the theory and didnt really provide a solution for an actual engine. Thats what I regret the most about most tutorials because they go through the theory but dont bother teaching you the actual tetris wich is probably the harderst part. Thats why I showed off how to build the 7/7/x. So if you can throw a few blueprints my way I might just work my way through that topic, too!
@andrelanger8396
@andrelanger8396 2 жыл бұрын
Nice viedeo
@strategystuff5080
@strategystuff5080 25 күн бұрын
thanks :)
@grandfremdling3841
@grandfremdling3841 2 жыл бұрын
Now i saw it with headphones- that is ok. Thanks for editing - #notborderwise
@foodomanthemagnificent2650
@foodomanthemagnificent2650 2 жыл бұрын
I'm currently working on the vehicles for Deserts of Kharak. For the Galssian faction, can you put steam engines on spin blocks? I don't remember
@dogisaurus8430
@dogisaurus8430 2 жыл бұрын
Yes you can :)
@Mernom
@Mernom 7 ай бұрын
I wonder what the numbers are for engine power efficiency, comparing steam turbine into an electric engine, a steam piston setup into generator into electric engine, or a piston engine directly. Will have to run then later. edit: Running some tests, I think that a 3*4+3*4 multi expansion large steam engine gets similar numbers to the small 7*7*x engine you featured. The large boilers actually fit into the 90deg space between the pistons, making it to be quite space efficient.
@Alexander-rx1xy
@Alexander-rx1xy Жыл бұрын
Probably an overclocked 820m particle cannon would demand more power that your engine can provide In that case I could try to make the scaled up version of the engine
@zourin8804
@zourin8804 2 жыл бұрын
Maybe there's been an update I didn't track, but steam engines used to have massive problems with highly variable power loads, such as when out of combat when shields, ammo facs, and high power systems don't need to be on, only propulsion systems. You had to use a control block to adjust fuel feeds to throttle loads, or a dedicated turbine generator to regulate combat power demand. Is this still a thing?
@15nyonker
@15nyonker 2 жыл бұрын
Best I can tell, the issue with steam is they cannot bank energy or shut down like other engines can, because they transfer energy directly to shaft horsepower. This means there will always be times, unless you have extra batteries for energy storage, that a small amount of materials are wasted spinning a engine that is essentially idling. Having extra energy storage for downtime or creating conditions with control blocks to kill the boiler are the only two ways to solve this problem. In my opinion though, steam still beats the tar out of internal combustion overall due to its effortless power output and relatively low material consumption at pressure, say nothing of the fact that no refinery is needed to refuel them.
@dichebach
@dichebach 2 жыл бұрын
Isn't the bottleneck on power per volume and material in a steam engine the number of cylinders connected to each section of shaft? It seems to me that more boilers don't accomplish much.
@grandfremdling3841
@grandfremdling3841 2 жыл бұрын
I think this ist a very good Tutorial, so many famous Deptharians here. But i have some Problems following your words because of the very limited microphone you use.
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
yeah, I am aware of it. Low-end microphone plus a big, echo-ey room, and 0 skills in audio-editing. Though all 3 should change soon!
@IronFist9595
@IronFist9595 2 жыл бұрын
Borderwise has nothing on you, thank you for valuing your viewers time. You rock.
@georgeculver1043
@georgeculver1043 2 жыл бұрын
I don't understand steam that well so I could be completely wrong but for the engine like the one you made at the end wouldn't it be quite advantageous to keep each of the rows of steam feeding pipes and the boilers feeding them separate so that a breach of one does not cripple the entire engine, as to make the engine tolerate damage better or would it not make much of a difference?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
In general it's a good idea. Unfortunately I have an odd number of boilers, and they are different size, so distributing the steam equally is pretty hard. Thats what valves are for, they have the option to automatically close when a pressure loss is detected, which is great! More on that in my 2nd video on the topic, which will get released as soon as a few bugs involving valves are fixed!
@georgeculver1043
@georgeculver1043 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab Makes sence, I played around with valves last night but they seem to add a lot to the bulk, regardless thank you so much for making this video, I learned quite a lot!
@theinventor2866
@theinventor2866 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab True, but they're also weak to EMP, so they can easily cause leaks as well.
@icetea_isgood
@icetea_isgood Жыл бұрын
Hello can you upload the steam engine design you came up with to the workshop? I tried replicating it but am having some issues. Thanks!
@peter4210
@peter4210 Жыл бұрын
I am anoyed that I cant use a large fly wheel on a small crank or piston
@theoffensivelemon2515
@theoffensivelemon2515 2 жыл бұрын
Figure I'd ask this here: Am I remembering things wrong, or was it previously possible to control the burn rate with a vehicle controller? I swear I was able to do that with my first steam engine.
@jadekaiser7840
@jadekaiser7840 2 жыл бұрын
Pretty sure ACBs can still control burn rate. Probably maximum shaft speed as well, but I'll have to check.
@ainumahtar
@ainumahtar 2 жыл бұрын
You can still do this but you don't really have to now, as boilers don't just blindly boil at max (or the rate you ACB for) but only burn what they need to get to full pressure.
@DSIREX_
@DSIREX_ 2 жыл бұрын
I have a very quick question, althought I'm a new player, why didnt you use the excess steam for electric steam turbines? For your small giant engine you showed us to build
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
Like I mentioned at 21:00, turbines create a lot of backpressure, meaning the engine runs at less power. The turbines, running at less than max pressure, loose efficiency, too.
@DSIREX_
@DSIREX_ 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab Yea I kind of tried that like 5 minutes ago right now, Now I know lol.. Edit: either way good video
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
Thanks! Also: small giant engine. Hilarious :)
@kingjustjefgames723
@kingjustjefgames723 Жыл бұрын
are you still thinking of making a second video? if so do you already have any idea on the time when you will upload it?
@livslab
@livslab Жыл бұрын
There have been a few last tweaks but according to the devs steam is going to stay the way it is right now. So Euda who helped me a lot with this vid hit me up and asked if we should do a final version. Though I cant make any promises about when its gonna come since I'm very busy IRL, and you can see my upload rythm (and thats with shitposts who take a lot less effort)
@kingjustjefgames723
@kingjustjefgames723 Жыл бұрын
@@livslab thank you for the quick replie! sorry for my late replie XD. this video was already verry help full. it gave me quite the inside into how to correctly use steam. not to worry! if it happens it happens altho i do look forward to a new vid ^~^ even if it isnt about steam XD
@Debbiebabe69
@Debbiebabe69 2 жыл бұрын
Why do you need *so* much power? Ive built 1.5 million credit battleships, with multiple particle cannons, LAMS, lasers, depthkeeping propellers, shields, and other high-drain items, and never had issues that couldnt be solved with a couple of 3*3*x injector engines - cylinder-crank-cylinder on the bottom, 'jector-cylinder-'jector in the middle, and large rads over the top, with rads capping one end and the engine block and 8 rads at the other, this simple engine has been my go-to in both adventure and campaign. Love playing with steam engines though, they are hard to get the head round, there is no easy way of telling if you have too many pistons, too few pistons, too many boilers, too few boilers, too many turbines, or too few turbines....
@_Zdex007
@_Zdex007 2 жыл бұрын
Gas engine< steam turbines < steam pistons. Also turbines are already figured out (there’s already a chart in the discord for that) while steam piston just has more variables to take into account (well I can boil it down to the number of stages or even one) the equation for steam is just massive.
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
the engine you describe has great density for sure, but a pure injector engine will have awful efficiency. Its the issure of throwing a marauder's worth of resources into the furnace every second. A ship is great but if it uses so much resources you could build another ship for each 10 mins of combat you might want to rething your priorities. Injector engines are great for planes and small stuff where density is important but not for capital ships! You can tell if you are using more steam than you produce or not produce enough steam by looking at the pressure. If the pressure of the boiler is below 10 that means the boilers cant keep up. If it is at 10, the materials per second will regulate themselves down, so you can see at what % of max capacity the boilers are running, meaning you might be able to remove a few boilers if you have capacity left. Though more capacity will mean you can build up pressure faster.
@Debbiebabe69
@Debbiebabe69 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab Where do small and large CJEs come in the efficiency chart, compared to injector engines, turbines, and piston engines (all as pure electricity generators)?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
@@Debbiebabe69 no idea! how about you find out? Just build a few CJEs, press Q on them and see what numbers you get! At 06:49 you can see what numbers to expect from a decent steam engine!
@theinventor2866
@theinventor2866 2 жыл бұрын
@@Debbiebabe69 Low PPV, but really high and easy PPM. I wouldn't use them as the main power source for a craft, only for out of combat.
@elecbaguette
@elecbaguette Жыл бұрын
It's not a bad video, but it misses the point; the reason steam engines are my favorite is that it's very simple and interesting to make them switch modes. For example, on one of my ships I can press a key to make the output of the pistons (all connected) vent steam, which are also connected to medium steam turbines so they can efficiently transfer output steam to energy restarting the main pistons that are having their output blocked if it's not in inefficient mode. (venting the output) With another ABC to manually control the steam boiler burn rate, the ship now has 3 modes; inefficient mode, where it vents output steam for maximum torque from the propeller, maximum power and energy but obviously inefficient. Normal mode, when the boilers and propeller are running low automatically, while the steam turbines convert steam to energy when needed, turning the pistons back on. And finally, silent mode when the boilers are completely off and the last drops of steam are used to charge the batteries, so it doesn't waste materials. This system might not be the absolute most efficient, it is definitely not the most space efficient, but it's certainly more interesting than using prefabs to paste the same engine on all your ships. This video is very informative, but it seems to be made to completely reject any form of creativity in steam engine design and engine choices. I have learned a lot from this video, because before now I've never watched any tutorials, not even the in game one. I now know that medium turbines are most energy but not space efficient, and that the metrics from the menu are not correct when plugging two turbines into one generator. But I'm going to personally test everything, since I no longer trust this video. It truly feels to me that this video was created when they were angry and just wanted to vent. But I feel it's suppressing creativity, the opposite of what I subscribed for, and that is why I'm mentioning this. I am not unsubscribing because of one potentially misguided video though. I hope you, reader, are having a nice day since I do not expect many people to read to the end, this is the longest comment I've ever wrote. I hope I see you somewhere, kind reader that would patiently listen while a teenager rambles about creativity suppression since their first favorite thing in this game is steam engines. o7
@7Tigris
@7Tigris Жыл бұрын
Honestly, I thought this was a good video. Learned a lot more than on other videos trying to explain how to practically do steam engines. Getting a look at some good examples helps a lot more than looking at space inefficient designs that nobody would put into their vessels. With some extra testing of my own I now feel like I understand how they work and when it's a good time to use them.
@bigbadlara5304
@bigbadlara5304 Жыл бұрын
I made an efficient and powerful engine my boat goes very quick now love it. One weird thing is that I don't get the large crank motor to work. When I build my ship using large crank motors it only was producing 60.000 out of 180.000 thrust. So I increased engine power and it didn't change... I didn't know what was going on at this point. I then disabled the engine. And it still produced 60.000 thrust. Then I disabled all engines and turbines and it still produced 60.000 thrust???. I deleted the large crank motors and with a lot of internal reshuffling in my ship I powered it with a standard crank shaft producing 170.000 thrust. Somehow material usage on my ship has gone down by doing that. What is going on? What am I missing? please help!
@livslab
@livslab Жыл бұрын
I think steam recieved an update since this video went up, not sure what changed though. Tbh I'm quite out-of-sync with whats happening in the game in general, haven't played in quite a while, so I cant help you. I suggest you ask over on the official FtD discord server, thery are very friendly and helpful people, I'm sure you'll find your answer there.
@bigbadlara5304
@bigbadlara5304 Жыл бұрын
@@livslab okay, thanks. It was only due to this video I was able to build a steam engine in the first place and I like them more than fuel engines.
@henriks2708
@henriks2708 2 жыл бұрын
Will you upload this to the workshop?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
Im still waiting for an update to fix a few bugs around valves to make a Part 2. After that Ill need to clean it up a bit and write instructions but yea, sure. Just be patient, this stuff takes a lot of work
@stefanhoffmann8417
@stefanhoffmann8417 2 жыл бұрын
So you can't attach multiple large pistons on one crank?
@Valixo889
@Valixo889 11 ай бұрын
I was thinking if you really wanted that .0000002 percent you could add a small turbine for all the excess low pressure steam kinda like the RMS Titanic's steam engine Edit: i hope they make turbines run at low pressure
@twinkyoctopus
@twinkyoctopus 2 жыл бұрын
if you use steam containers as a buffer between pistons and turbines, does it stop any backpressure?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
no idea, gotta test that one
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
no, it doesnt help. Backpressure happens when the steam cant get used up on the output, and since the steam tanks dont actually use steam they dont help with backpressure. In general they are pretty useless (lets be nice and call it niche) at the moment so I didnt bother talking about them.
@twinkyoctopus
@twinkyoctopus 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab that sucks, oh well.
@twinkyoctopus
@twinkyoctopus 2 жыл бұрын
@Henrik Freitag I was wondering if it provided a barrier to prevent backpressure, and thus allowing you to use a turbine with the excess steam
@theinventor2866
@theinventor2866 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab Idk, I've found some uses. They are rather niche, but they work well with steam jets that aren't being constantly used, I've found ways for them to work with valves to increase a system's durability versus EMP, and I expect I can probably find a few more. Plus, they store waaaay more steam than boilers, so they could be useful to keep providing high pressure steam for at least a few minutes after you lose enough boilers than you can't produce enough steam anymore.
@sharpie443
@sharpie443 2 жыл бұрын
Is that platform available on the workshop?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
sorry, not yet. Working on it, I will upload it once I finish part 2
@theinventor2866
@theinventor2866 2 жыл бұрын
SAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAM WAZZAP
@darthirony
@darthirony 2 жыл бұрын
That platform, is it on workshop?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
nope, sorry. I am planning to do a Part 2 with a bunch more info and detail and a few demo engines and upload the platform then
@maslav4241
@maslav4241 2 жыл бұрын
i punk the steam
@Damaddok82
@Damaddok82 2 жыл бұрын
I have to disagree that steam is better in every way. Fuel engines can give you the right amount of power and can do it almost instantly.
@_Zdex007
@_Zdex007 2 жыл бұрын
Just a simple steam turbine can outperform a fuel engine in both ppm and ppv.
@Damaddok82
@Damaddok82 2 жыл бұрын
@@_Zdex007 you're always going to b producing too much power with steam. Power demands fluctuate like crazy especially when running a lams. A steam will make power at a constant rate but a fuel engine is going to give you just the right amount of power.
@Debbiebabe69
@Debbiebabe69 2 жыл бұрын
Thats why I have normally gone for fuel. I know, and the stats clearly show, my standard go-to 3*3*3 fuel engine design gives 3200 power. The 7*3*3 variant gives 8000 power. The 10*3*3 variant gives 12800 power. Every extra 3*3*3 block (its a modular design) adds another 4800 power. I can tune the number of engines and modules to the amount of power and redundancy I need.
@Damaddok82
@Damaddok82 2 жыл бұрын
@@Debbiebabe69 IMO that makes fuel a bit more flexible.
@ainumahtar
@ainumahtar 2 жыл бұрын
@@Damaddok82 That's why I just pump the excess into batteries for buffer. Not to say that fuel engines have no place of course, but efficiency on demand w fuel engines is also a pain in the ass, as making fuel engines that are efficient at whatever load level they work at is hard and very space inefficient as well.
@psykology9299
@psykology9299 11 ай бұрын
Thanks, FTD is my favourite voxel builder but theres no proper literature on most of its mechanics other than "mat make powah"
@micgil4193
@micgil4193 2 жыл бұрын
What are the stats on that small engine?
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
which one? care to provide a timestamp?
@micgil4193
@micgil4193 2 жыл бұрын
The big one at 17:47
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
@@micgil4193 It has 3 variants: the 2-Stage one has 134ppv and 550ppm the 3-Stage one has 110ppv and 670ppm the 4-Stage one has 87ppv and 716ppm
@micgil4193
@micgil4193 2 жыл бұрын
@@livslab ty
@mobius1504
@mobius1504 4 ай бұрын
12:14 Steam turbine Chart
@_Zdex007
@_Zdex007 2 жыл бұрын
Here’s the steam engine calculator: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Pw6dlEfw3uM63UTAxylRZs8q2DSLbdIAvvzWVQZTT3Y/edit?usp=sharing
@_Zdex007
@_Zdex007 2 жыл бұрын
Also got a 890 ppm and 30 ppv large steam engine.
@gregmcmill1798
@gregmcmill1798 2 жыл бұрын
why is it that you want your steam engines pushing at 100% all the time? I understand for the purposes of testing but I can't understand why they'd be worse if they weren't working at full power
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
Yes, it's most important for testing since using less power than you produce will screw up the numbers, making you think that the engine can put out more power than it actually can (when testing without load the engine will spin to a much higher RPM, increasing the theoretical power output, even though in reality as soon as you put the engine under load it will slow down and put out less power). In actual combat its just a matter of efficiency, a huge engine running on snall loads will still loose a lot of power to friction, so the numbers you saw in testing might be inaccurate, to the point where it might be better to run a fuel engine if you run your engine too inefficiently. But worst that can happen is a slightly worse operational cost of your ship.
@MinionNumber3
@MinionNumber3 2 жыл бұрын
Please, stop waggling the camera at everything you're trying to direct our attention to. So motion-sick now...
@livslab
@livslab 2 жыл бұрын
sorry :X
@cockstyle1003
@cockstyle1003 7 ай бұрын
So is the part 2 gonna happen any time soon or is it canceled? Really struggling to get any good ppm with large steam engine parts for some reason
AI Detection Guide - From the Depths
42:48
BorderWise
Рет қаралды 28 М.
одни дома // EVA mash @TweetvilleCartoon
01:00
EVA mash
Рет қаралды 4,2 МЛН
ISSEI funny story😂😂😂Strange World | Magic Lips💋
00:36
ISSEI / いっせい
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
Duck sushi
00:54
Alina Saito / 斎藤アリーナ
Рет қаралды 35 МЛН
4 More Whacky (But Fun) APS Shells! From the Depths
27:06
BorderWise
Рет қаралды 15 М.
Plasma Cannons + Tetris - From The Depths INSTANT Tutorial
22:41
From The Depths Steam Engine Tutorial - All about STEAM!
24:11
Armour 101 - Armour Tutorial, From the Depths
56:33
BorderWise
Рет қаралды 37 М.
Wrench's Way II: Superstructure Construction - From the Depths
25:28
Мальчик гений и ужасная мать #фильм #сериал
1:00
CJ Is Driving, But Auughh...
0:16
mesangedavril
Рет қаралды 47 МЛН
Hoodie herobrine help to other #shorts #minecraft #bones
0:20
Delfino
Рет қаралды 11 МЛН
Skibidi Toilets vs Hammers and Bollards Part 74 #beamngdrive #skibiditoilet
0:10
VS Car Crash BeamNGDrive
Рет қаралды 32 МЛН
Please help Herobrine out of the hole!
0:39
IdeaCraft STUDIOS
Рет қаралды 11 МЛН