Steel Phantom VS Phantoms Revenge, Side By Side POV | Which Is Better?

[@eriklakeland3857]

The fake screams are absolutely absurd. I remember them from a roller coaster VHS I watched religiously as a young lad

[@reminiscer15]

Yep I know exactly what you’re talking about and the screams really are absurd. Even back then I found them annoying.

[@insaneiaq]

I still have that VHS. Not the 3D glasses though lol

[@MattPico-i1p]

Thats the same video.

[@ryanstatewicz4568]

Honestly, Kennywood is my home park and i road them both hundreds of times. I would say I like them both equally when i was riding them but my tolerance for pain was much higher when i was a kid riding steel phantom. Nowadays, I would probably much prefer revenge. I think steel curtain is better than both. I rode front row of steel curtain 2 days after riding steel vengeance at cedar point. I found many similarities considering there is so much going on in both rides. Curtain is a front seat only coaster.

[@pittsburghthrills1281]

Wait... it is much better in the front and only rideable in the front, but the middle was still amazing? No wonder why it’s my #1!

[@acceleratedcreative]

Steel Curtain aint better LMAO

[@acceleratedcreative]

@@theGemiknight people 👏 can 👏 be 👏 wrong 👏 🤣🤣🤣

[@acceleratedcreative]

@@theGemiknight I’m sure you wouldn’t.. you can’t tell I’m joking 🤣

[@ryanstatewicz4568]

I only rode Steel curtain in the front multiple times. After an amazing front row ride and rumors that others seats arent even close to the same experience. But I'm like the people that ride banshee or diamondback so many times the buzz wears off. That's kind of how I feel about phantoms revenge. It definitely gives stronger ejector airtime while steel curtain has a few floater airtime but with amazing smooth elements. It's my opinion and I respect anyone else's.

[@jimmyplenderleith9471]

As a Pittsburgher, its always cool to know we had, if only for a moment, the fastest and biggest dropping coaster in the world. The Steel Phantom did bang the hell out of you, but I was a teenager then so I loved it...I will say being considerably older now, I prefer the Phantom's Revenge....you still get the thrill of those first two hills and then get impressive air time throughout the second half.

[@germxv]

Steelers suck. Go Browns

[@coments101]

​@@germxv0 Championships since segregation ended.

[@Sithari66]

My neck still hurts from my senior trip in 1997.

[@HyBr1dRaNg3r]

They neutered it by taking out the inversions…Just imo. It was a punishing ride, but that was part of the “charm” of the originals. At least both of them kept the 2nd hill being the largest drop, going down between the Thunderbolt and into the ravine/valley is still awesome! Just so ppl remember, the original was a 200ft drop and close to 90mph, it was certainly a hypercoaster back in the day!

[@Thelightning1out]

It still is one they actually made it better with phantom as it’s much smoother and much smoother means less headbanging, and no inversions and small hills equals insanely good ejector.

[@HyBr1dRaNg3r]

@@Thelightning1out I know, just not the same imo since I grew up riding the original…Haha the roughness was part of its charm!! I agree the new one is smoother, but it doesn’t push the envelope for me and feels like a step back imo. I’m sure it allows for a wider audience to ride it, so it probably helps the park…Just doesn’t have as much “enthusiast ride” vibes to me anymore after the changes. lol all imo of course😂

[@Duffster115]

Steel phantom had a top speed of 80 while phantoms Revenge has a top speed of 85 with a longer steeper drop

[@HyBr1dRaNg3r]

There was no difference in the 2nd drop between the 2. Look it up, SP was faster before a break trim was installed…

[@Duffster115]

@@HyBr1dRaNg3r no it was the steel phantom gone to a top speed of 80 miles per hour they didn’t install breaks on that second drop just like phantom’s revenge where it reaches 5 miles per hour faster it reaches its top speed at the bottom of that second drop and was 80 miles per hour while revenge reaches 85

[@wickedsickfunkyfreshroller2037]

The fact that Steel Phantom is shorter in length yet they finish at the same time shows how trimmed it was during the inversions to try and keep it bearable.

[@marny129]

Steel Phantom. Not even close. To this day - one of the most intense rides I’ve ever ridden, and I’ve been to a ton of amusement parks.

[@judiplaz]

Steel phantom was way to fast for the elements in a compact area. Taking out the inversions and keeping the speed with added airtime, made it a more enjoyable ride. SP was really rough! Fun, but rough. My dad rode it with me when I was young. He couldn't move his neck for 3 weeks afterwards. I def couldn't ride it now at my age

[@nikkibaby222]

I feel like they could’ve at least kept the corkscrew

[@judiplaz]

@@nikkibaby222 I think they did the right thing. Plus arrow didn't redo it, Morgan did.

[@nikkibaby222]

@@judiplaz I know Morgan re did it and I know it’s good the way it is but at least one inversion would be cool

[@judiplaz]

@@nikkibaby222 I wish there was a small air hill in the flat part right after the 1st hill.

[@nikkibaby222]

@@judiplaz that be cool too! I feel like if they didn’t have all 4 inversions right after one another maybe it never would’ve been a problem. If if there was just 2 and not 4 it would’ve been less rough. Idk I’m just always thinking of ways it could’ve been changed lol

[@camtheman1655]

Phantoms revenge

[@frizzletits8511]

Never been on the steel phantom so I’m gonna have to give it a point ,sry phantom revenge

[@Thelightning1out]

⁠@@frizzletits8511phantoms revenge is better then steel phantom, phantoms revenge is smoother while steel phantom was rougher.

[@HockeyGUY66871]

I never rode Steel Phantom but from my experience on other Arrow custom loopers I guarantee i would have absolutely hated it. I have ridden Phantoms Revenge 316 times. It reopened as Phantoms Revenge a few months after I was born.

[@jeremynolan4681]

It was extremely unique and not at all like other Arrow looping coasters. Yeah it had some whiplash but it was worth it in my opinion.

[@Thelightning1out]

I have 2 arrows at 2 of my home parks, Carolina cyclone, Carowinds (fury goes crazy at night and Carolina cyclone sucks don’t ride it) and Tennessee Tornado, Dollywood (Tennessee tornado is the most underrated arrow looper

[@Duffster115]

It opened the same month and year I was born May 2001

[@NicoWashowich]

The steel phantom had an amazing layout but it was just so rough. If the smooth arrow coaster era happened back then, then it would’ve survived a lot longer

[@HugeRMCFanBoY-bx3od]

Good Layout? Neither Steel Phantom Or Phantom's Revenge Had A Good Layout But Kinda Like A B&M Hyper Ok Layout But Amazing Ride

[@amyhartman6786]

I was 9 years old when they opened steel phantom. My mother and I waited 2 hours to ride. Then a man put a stick up against me when I got to front of platform line right before being seated. He tried saying I was too short to ride when line entrance attendant lady already said I tall enough to ride. Mother and I switched shoes right in front of them I put on her wedge sandles she put on my flip flops suddenly i was allowed take my spot at front car front seat in which i rightfully waited for. Loved all other coasters I been on was never tall enough to experience the old Laser loop truly loved this one other then the train's exit of the last loop that was cranially painful only because of the restraints. That ride would of been so much better if it just had the lap bars.

[@orionplayzgd5227]

0:05 kids be like on a mack xtreme spinner my ears are now bleeding

[@jeremynolan4681]

I really miss the original phantom. Mainly because as a kid it was the first "big" roller coaster I had ever ridden. Got about 3 years out of it and then they renovated the second half and made it boring as hell compared to the original. Sure it gave you some serious whiplash but it was totally worth it.

[@Gwazi325]

No the second half gives some of the craziest ejector out there

[@nikkibaby222]

Lol nothing about phantoms revenge is boring. 😂 you get air time the whole 2nd half, badass.

[@jedidiahproud]

STEEL PHANTOM FOREVER!!!!

[@nikkibaby222]

I like the coaster going under thunder bolt twice but then after that there could’ve been a couple more smaller hills leading up to the cork screw and then the same ending. Or if they where to keep all the inversions maybe they could’ve spread them out a bit more. Idk I love the foster just wish they kept one inversion in

[@BradWoodburn]

Steel Phantom. Why? Because it actually had inversions, and I'm a sucker for those on coasters. 🤷‍♂️

[@cancelled148]

That second drop tho

[@timothystark4475]

I like both. Phantom's Revenge is smoother and faster. Kennywood should have two Phantom versions together.

[@dyadonh]

I've ridden this still phantom coaster at a mart in front of my house called "4D Rider Experience". The name of the place was Phantom Loop. It disappeared now and became impossible to ride. It was my friend when I was young. so i like normal steel phantom !!!!!!

[@coasterp2199]

Steel Phantom hands down. NOTHING beats the drop into the gully at night.

[@jdonovan74]

The Revenge and Steel Phantom both have that drop still, so I'm confused on why you say it was better before when it is nearly the exact same up until the helix.

[@coasterp2199]

@@jdonovan74 It's slightly different. Original Phantom was an INTENSE 180 turn back up into the top section. Revenge is less intense. Plus NOTHING beat the turn at the bottom of the gully, in pitch black, before rising back up into lights on a night ride. Revenge is a good ride but for pure intensity, original Phantom was better. probably too intense though. Thus the reason for the rebuilding the ride.

[@jimmyplenderleith9471]

@@coasterp2199 The ride is the exact same until you hit that bend after the big drop...that's where they started changing it, removing the inversions and adding air time hills. Its the same coaster from start until you come through that left turn at the bottom of the big hill,

[@coasterp2199]

@@jimmyplenderleith9471 It was the climb back up the hill at night that was the big thing for me. Something about dropping into the gully pitch blackness before rising back into the lighted area was amazing. I put a few non-coaster people on that ride at night and all had the same experience. They were speechless when the train pulled into the station. Admittedly, it was probably a little to intense for most.

[@coastingalong]

@@coasterp2199that all still happens on phantoms revenge…..

[@aidenleya2215]

Damn kennywood needs to put a flat ride or pavilions on the phantoms walkway I hate hot it’s just closed with picnic tables

[@kotchapakmaneechote2062]

Phantom's Revenge is smoother, So I'll chose that.

[@Charles-tt3dr]

I rode both & personally i prefer the original over the newer one.

[@DavidSmith-qo1se]

I prefer the Potato Patch.

[@aaronsteindler3245]

Ejector airtime >> Vertical loops

[@FlyingHawlucha]

So it no longer goes upside down

[@pitbullcanelo1835]

Is the phantoms revenge smooth? Bc viper has been real quiet

[@halemedin9834]

Phantom's revenge is pretty smooth

[@Quit3Cut3]

Smooth, but if you’re small, you’ll lift outta your seat on the hills and get slammed back down!

[@robertbinz2716]

If the steel phantom hadn't been such a rough ride, I would have enjoyed it more. So I have to go with phantoms revenge.

[@JordanCS13]

I can't believe the people saying Steel Phantom. It makes me wonder if it's just the sting of nostalgia fogging their memories. Steel Phantom was PAINFUL. I rode it in its first season, and got off it with the worst headache imagineable due to how much headbanging there was in the inversions. Phantom's Revenge is a MASSIVE improvement in ride experience, and I don't think loses anything in intensity...the back half of Revenge is just pure ejector airtime and speed. The 'intensity' of Steel Phantom was simply due to your head being smashed against the OTSRs, which also reduced the fun of the first two drops.

[@michaelaschenbrenner5251]

Phantoms revenge always,

[@Gigidag77]

They should have just retracked Steel Phantoms layout

[@TrevorHaist]

Yeah that would have been cool but I don't think Morgan had ever built an inversion, and i think we'd all prefer the airtime

[@Stagnant_Gravy]

The layout was too intense for most riders so they changed the ride.

[@jdonovan74]

It wasn't just the rough track. The speed it was carrying (almost 70mph) into the loop was hurting people's necks. To fix that they added trim brakes, which then just started adding more time with the train on the supports, damaging them to a point of Kennywood deciding to close the ride. After announcing it was closing they got A LOT of backlash, leading to them to look for a company to renovate the area completely. Morgan, who had the son of the engineer who built the Steel phantom working for them, purposed redesigning that entire part of the ride. If not for Morgan, and a father and son engineering team, the ride would have been gone completely in 2000.

[@triangulism]

@@jdonovan74 in all honesty, if they had made the size of the first loop bigger, then i think the original phantom would still be there

[@nikkibaby222]

@@triangulismthat never would’ve made any difference because the trains still went to fast through the other inversions. It literally was either get rid of phantom all together or change the 2nd half. And I’m happy for the decision they made cuz it’s still the best coaster there. They could’ve just kept the loop or the cork screw get rid of the others and then design it the rest of the way it is now.

[@AarOnCoasters]

Ditch the headbanging loops and replace them with airtime hills. All in favor?

[@Ace_mp6]

When I went on the phantoms revenge it was purple and had a loop

[@deathcheater9303]

Should have kept the loops #thelaserloop 😂

[@christag93]

The stealth phantom hurt my back while was on it so I like the new one better

[@Joel-np9vl]

One of theses I did ride seven times in one day not sure what one 😆

[@michaelaschenbrenner5251]

Who knew that phantoms revenges track got repainted?

[@missm7526]

Steel phantom all the way!

[@jaystarr6571]

*Revenge Of The Phantom's Steel!!* _Coning in 2035_ Only at Kennywuud!!

[@christag93]

I like the new one better

[@HarbingerOfBattle]

Steel Phantom is much better. The speed with the crazy inversions, twists, turns and corkscrews all make for an intense and scary ride.

[@nikkibaby222]

I keep saying they could’ve at least kept one of the inversions. And maybe put other hills or something in place of the other two inversions or some how spread the inversions out and not had them so close to eachother. Definitely could’ve had the loop at the bottom of the first hill before going up the second hill would’ve been cool.

[@ksk_2606]

Which one is which? 😅

[@theGemiknight]

Left is the new one: phantoms revenge!

[@Thefury325]

Not hard to say here it’s obviously phantom’s revenge the coaster is better than any ride in the park if you haven’t visited this park I suggest it phantom can sometimes get a wait but the day I went phantom was mostly a walk on

[@IndyCoasterCreator]

Steel phantom 100% better

[@acceleratedcreative]

FUNNY

[@TheCycloneHunter]

Good joke

[@oofintic5734]

@@IndyCoasterCreator I mean Steel phantom does have more elements than PRevenge

[@thomasdembecki1139]

Steel phantom is way better

[@GoudLoodje]

While I think steel phantom LOOKS cooler at first glance, because it goes upside down, the headbanging on the ride made the inversions very painful I heard, I haven't ridden both, but since I've never heard complains about headbanging on Phantom's Revenge and it looks like it has some very solid airtime, I would say Phantom's Revenge is better.

[@Offical_lilmoney]

When I rode the phantoms revenge no one screamed

[@Necrostoner]

I’d like to enjoy a coaster ride without getting whiplash, so Phantom’s Revenge takes the cake for me personally. Sometimes less is more.

[@jonb7700]

Yes but if less is more, then think of how much more "more" is!

[@blakeurban1004]

Steel phantom I'm 11 so I never got to ride it tho

[@wolfdaddy5215]

steel phantom was longer....shocked

[@TomFeldpausch]

But faster. They end at the same time.

[@chrismitchell1859]

Steel phantom

[@enthusiastJD]

Steel eel at sea world San Antonio

[@ghostriderfanboy6618]

Mamba at Worlds of Fun

[@Stagnant_Gravy]

Steel Force at Dorney Park

[@TheCycloneHunter]

West Coaster at Santa Monica Pier

[@Mattia_Genuardi]

Blue Tornado at Gardaland

[@ghostriderfanboy6618]

@@Mattia_Genuardi y u ruined it with an SLC

[@tyreerussell8041]

Steel phantom look way better

[@CoasterShardark]

YOU BETRAYED ALAN

[@jonb7700]

The old one destroyed your head and neck. The new one finishes the job and destroys your lower back with that cheeky little double down toward the end. The Steel Phantom was better. BTW, here in Pittsburgh, we don't accept name changes, so it's still called the Steel Phantom.

[@thomasdembecki1139]

Steel phantom is way better

[@GoudLoodje]

While I think steel phantom LOOKS cooler at first glance, because it goes upside down, the headbanging on the ride made the inversions very painful I heard, I haven't ridden both, but since I've never heard complains about headbanging on Phantom's Revenge and it looks like it has some very solid airtime, I would say Phantom's Revenge is better. But that might be just my opinion ;)

[@Stagnant_Gravy]

My older family members all rode SP, and I hear nothing but ear pain from head banging. PR is glass smooth 20 years later and zero pain at all.

[@YeetCat]

Fakest screams ive ever heard... nevermind i read the top comment, they are

[@mochi_cheoo]

Steel phantom would feel way better

[@HurricanePatrick]

Can you stop freaking screaming?!?!

[@luukxd123]

I think Both layouts suck big time. Those Wonky drawn out drops really kill the thrill for me. At stell Phantom at least there were some inversions to entertain the riders but phantoms revenge is ready for the chops. Melt it down into something interesting

[@TheBigScreenPictures]

Ooof you're one of those "ewww it sucks if it doesn't go upside down" kinda people. You people are fucking awful

[@wannaplaythisdavid]

you havent experience ejector airtime?

[@nikkibaby222]

Lol oh my 😂😂😂