Steven Wilson (Luminol Live Mexico City)Kel-n-RIch First Reaction

[@melvingrendlestretcher1321]

A few people have already mentioned 'Routine' by Steven Wilson, it is one of the most artistic and emotionally pulling videos you will ever see, be warned though-it is a difficult watch.

[@fuerzabestial5070]

I was there !!! Best day of my life god bless you all people here .viva mexico!!

[@spiral2012]

#painintheask! Steven Wilson - Deform to Form a Star

[@JesperHellvik]

Staniel Wilsenlöw beautiful song. One of my favorites!

[@marshman96]

Nick Beggs of kajagoogoo on bass. He is a beast and i've met him he is one hell of a nice guy. Adam Holtzman on keys. he was at one time the band leader of Miles Davis' backing band. Marco Minnemann on drums one of the best drummers in the world today

[@ChrisPage68]

Who can forget Beggs' poodle hairdo when he was in Kajagoogoo? 🤣

[@bikerbuncle]

All top shelf musicians. Guthrie Govan on lead guitar-another beast can play any genre

[@franckbizouard3357]

You really should try "Routine" by Steven Wilson.

[@DavidJones-lz4io]

The live version, via The royal Albert hall, is almost too much, especially when you know the context. kzbin.info/www/bejne/qn7JeKNtbst9ebM #painintheask

[@snowpuppy77]

He is right. I have never been hit so hard by a video and song. I would watch the official claymation music video first before the live version. Have a box of tissues ready: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qZmYnoqwgNGbh7s

[@BoardGameBill]

This. And definitely do the claymation video first, for context. ...and have a box of tissues handy, seriously. But don't let that warning dissuade you, it's an amazing song and video.

[@scifimonkey3]

@Franck Bizouard @ David Jones @ snowpuppy 77 @ William Bass - Guys I don’t think with their particular history this is the right song to recommend for a reaction. It’s bad enough for most of us but it may be too close to reality for these two great people At least you need to flag that the subject matter of the song is the loss of children! Rich and Kel this is an amazing song and if you choose to do it it would be great but given its subject matter it might be one to listen to privately. Love the channel, some of the best reactions on KZbin!

[@franckbizouard3357]

@@scifimonkey3 I think they did, I know about their history, but it's not incompatible to listen to sad music about the loss. Sad music is often the most beautiful thing to heal the soul.

[@thecheif00]

Bruh... the Watchmaker live in Frankfurt

[@bits6996]

this..

[@DariArenero]

Yeah! You beat me with this song and listened to it before I asked for it...awesome guys! Now I will have to change my recommendation. The album We’re here because we’re here by Anathema is quite an option. It was mixed by Steven Wilson and it doesn’t dissapoint

[@musicmademejester]

#Painintheask Steven Wilson - The Watchmaker (Live from Frankfurt, Germany) If you like this song, then you will love The Watchmaker. Defiantly one of his best!

[@rockonileva]

11:05... my favorite musical moment EVER!!! this is just sublime!!!

[@Yufri]

#painintheask Thank you for this joyful reaction. Now you‘re ready for „The Raven That Refused To Sing“. This song is in my opinion his greatest achievement yet👍

[@dheerajnataraj6379]

He hasn't been honored with a Grammy because Grammy awards you based on Genre. Steven Wilson's genius sexy brain transcends musical Genre. His creation is just unlike anything else. How easy is it to fall in love with him! :))

[@sanclemente1156]

Right about being a Musical genius Wrong so wrong about what has kept him off the main line Music Radio Dj Radio Playlist Well he does not have a 1 2 3 minute song So the station can't sell advertising To make revenue But Steve has said as much No on nobody will play or break down any of his music to 1 2 3 minutes They have to play the whole thing or nothing! So the radio except for KLOS Jim Lad and a few others payed his stuff when we were all asleep But mostly why he hasn't won Grammys or been Promoted is cause he went through suit after suit and so on! Because musicians were jealous of his talent and they sued him saying that that was their music No it was not as Roger Waters had to take a step back and Metallica Garth Brooks just to name a few The judge rules the No this is his music and noone owns a Note Just because there may of may not be a note used in his music does not conclude that you may claim its yours So put you Irrogants aside and he may continue to do what he does! But Radio Stations did not like that so they did not play Porcupine Tree Steve Wilson Music! Steve is the original Orchestrator and Organizers of all the Publications and he holds all of the rights to it. Now that was as of 2000 or a little before when Gavin and the Bassist tried to recoup there musical Genius in the live and the music aswell which they did. It was mostly because they would have to go after Steve himself and not anyone else to sue if they so stupidity choose to! Anyways do your HOMEWORK! RESEARCH INSTEAD OF FALSE Narrative. I do believe the that copyrights deal was overturned in some degree so the Members could use there Creativeness!!! I understand. But you can cue me in as to the new Processing!!! All that each one of the Individuals do is out of this world! There are still talented Musicians all around But it was the Force of Steve that they all reach their best and become Challenged in their Music abilities And they did and they were thankful to being Pushed so hard Some not all but some of them never even knew thay had it in them to be so Great!!!

[@marshman96]

wanna see Steven wilson from one extreme to the next. watch routine (the video) and then watch Permanating. Permanating will shock you words can not describe that 4 minutes of music.

[@stephenhaunch3468]

Missed the plane for this tour. Great song. Still waiting on Marillion Neverland live.

[@talaniel]

Studio or live, I think does not matter. Such a great song, that is! I believe it is on their list already! :-)

[@waynewofsey4209]

Steven Wilson was nominated for a Grammy in 2012 for Best Surround Album for "Grace For Drowning". He didn't win & it's no wonder since The Grammys have veered far from Rock, Progressive Rock, Metal etc. It's a shame since he's been around for over 30 years & is still relatively unknown by the mainstream. I think he's one the best in modern rock today. Another great progressive band is Big Big Train. They are more of an ensemble group, with many instruments & all members contributing, where as Steven Wilson does most of the work & just hires great musicians. Big Big Train just posted a new live clip which is a great sample of their sound. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nKPFn6N6hLKnq7s

[@roadwarrior1450]

I'm a rocker from the 70's.But this the music I gravitate towards these day's. Steven Wilson Porcupine tree. And the like. My ears cant handle the loud crazy music anymore.I just came across your channel. I like it. I'm here to stay.👍👍

[@Redefinedacoustic]

My top three bands are Dream Theater, Steven Wilson and Porcupine Tree so as you can imagine, I'm glad I stumbled across your channel! Thanks guys I'm really enjoying your reactions.

[@snowpuppy77]

Yes you nailed it, Mastery. I have heard some people say that everything Steven Wilson touches turns to gold. Often seems that way to me. You two are such a blessing. I know you had to go through a lot to get to this point.

[@satellite_anomaly]

Steven and this song in particular pay such excellent homage to the classic prog bands like Camel, Yes, and Van Der Graaf Generator. I'll always appreciate what Steven has done for music.

[@proteusblack8913]

I know I'm just one person requesting this, not a whole bunch of people, and I haven't been around that long, and I know you've got such a long list, but this is why I keep (and will keep) persevering with my request until you finally get to it, or I grow old and die hahaha (because you guys just don't understand how underrated and beautiful it is, but I hope that soon, you'll find out). #painintheask Porcupine Tree - Lazarus Can we get more requests for this please? If you know the song, it's gotta be a no brainer to you! Can we promote it please?

[@talaniel]

#MetalChickPick Lazarus by Porcupine Tree, yep, Steven Wilson is a Master of Melancholy :-)

[@docwobbles]

Lazarus makes me cry each time I hear it.

[@rockonileva]

Luminol was the first Steven Wilson related stuff I listened to... It's Just PERFECT!! And you listen to the next song on the album, and it's PERFECT, and them the next, PERFECT... and so on! Until the end! The next album also... and I listen to Porcupine Tree stuff and it's perfect! SW IS GENIUS!

[@thedreamcastle]

#painintheask listen Steven Wilson Ancestral!

[@mahmoudharmel1569]

Another one for AncestraI! Best one

[@bits6996]

yes ! Steven is definitely one of my fav musician/producer/artist. please do checkout Steven Wilson - the watchmaker.

[@Wedigar]

I'll just refresh my request for OSI - Shutdown, with the wonderful Steven Wilson on vocals 😁 #PainInTheAsk

[@donaldanderson6604]

I was listening to the studio version of this in the car today. The track has the original King Crimson mellotron and is awesome. However, this version is insane. I've heard bassist Nick Beggs several times with Steve Hackett and the rest of the band are magnificent. Superb choice.

[@musicmademejester]

Steven Wilson has been nominated 4 times for a Grammy award. But I don't think the Grammy's hold as much honor as they use to. There is a lot wrong with them now. Still would be an honor tho. Its nice that Tool has won a couple. Steve has done amazing things in music besides creating it. He has also a producer and has produced for a number of bands , for example Opeth being one. He is also a musical sound engineer and has done something I think is really awesome and gone back remixed and remastered albums from bands such as King Crimson, Jethro Tull, and more. The is also an area where he earned his nomination for Grammy's for "Best Mix For Surround Sound" for albums such as "Fear of a Blank Planet", Grace for Drowning", "The Incident", and "Storm Corrosion" . He defiantly very gifted and talented!

[@JesperHellvik]

Three songs by God Wilson that there is just no way around: Routine, Drive Home and The Raven That Refused To Sing. Your list isn’t complete until you have those three down!!! You’ve already got Wilson under your skin so you know you have to do it 😉

[@UmmaGumma6]

Best Concert Ever, I Was There !!!

[@lkeslinke]

Some Of "Porcupine Tree" Top Studio Songs From Each Of Their Albums In My Opinion: 1) The Incident Album: Time Flies & Octane Twisted 2) Fear Of A Blank Planet Album: Fear Of A Blank Planet & Way Out Of Here 3) Deadwing Album: Arriving Somewhere But Not Here & The Start Of Something Beautiful 4) In Absentia Album: Blackest Eyes & Lips Of Ashes 5) Recordings Album: Buying New Soul & Disappear 6) Lightbulb Sun Album: Hatesong & Russia On Ice 7) Stupid Dream Album: Even Less & Don't Hate Me 8) Signify Album: Signify & Dark Matter 9) The Sky Moves Sideways Album: The Sky Moves Sideways & Dislocated Day 10) Up The Downstair Album: Fadeaway & Burning Sky and other Albums and Songs...

[@swinetrek]

Drummer has now joined Steve Hackett's band. Bass player has also played for Steve.

[@anthonymiller5750]

Y’all killin it tonight

[@buckfuttler2877]

may we all find someone who looks at us like Kel did at Rich at 9:30!

[@mobiuspaw494]

Steven Wilson is a genius.

[@asmrob2986]

He's had 4 grammy nominations. 2 with Porcupine Tree, 1 with the Storm Corrosion collaboration and 1 solo. He should have been given at least half a dozen so far but such is this world...

[@nepabum]

nominated for a few grammy's for surround sound production i believe. #stevenwilsongrammy Welcome to the SW family

[@nepabum]

otherwise, completely ignored by the mainstream. Shame really. Huge back catalog including many side projects.

[@dukeofhazard1142]

#painintheask Opeth - Dirge For November

[@DocSardo]

A lot of influences are apparent in this song, from Camel to Traffic (Low Spark of High Heeled Boys, with CSNY-like vocal harmonies) to Trick of the Tail era Genesis to King Crimson.

[@pasit1738]

Ooo, yeah! Next song could be Detonation, Drive Home or Routine (with the original video!).

[@anuragiyer2427]

#painintheask #ThePorcupineTreeWaveshouldcontinue 1. Cheating the Polygraph (Live) 2. Buying a new soul (Live)

[@stevechesney2498]

No he hasn’t received a Grammy. Mostly because he doesn’t fall into the mainstream. He’s not Imagine Dragons or Greta Van Fleet or whatever else the sheep are listening to. Steven is our little secret of immense talent. If they only knew what they were missing! Thank you for reacting to SW. please do his video to Routine and have some tissues on hand. 😢

[@docwobbles]

An excellent T-shirt,Rich! :) Oh, and artists of this caliber rarely get nominated for Grammys because they cater to record sales of pop tunes.

[@skippermullet69]

You made me smile when you mentioned Greyboy Allstars. You gotta check out Grammy award winning band Snarky Puppy. One of the best concerts I've ever attended. Please review their track Lingus live. It will not disappoint

[@Kel.N.RichReactions]

LOVE SP!!!!!!!!

[@skippermullet69]

@@Kel.N.RichReactions one of the best unknowns out there! You have gained a new level of respect from me for knowing of them. Side note: I find the love you two share to be inspiring.

[@mattridgley9095]

If you fancy something a bit different they try Bass Communion live from Mexico (another Steven Wilson project)

[@rodrigozamo]

I was at this very show :)

[@michaelbradley7447]

It's like aTool song mixed with a Pink Floyd song very good

[@alanalanis2257]

Could you put this list up to the camera?? I didn't see my request on it. Lol!!🤣🤣 Just kidding.

[@sevans1966]

That was performed before being released on a studio album so that was just their 'demo' version.

[@elbaterojuan]

"Myrath - Under Siege". Prog with arabic influence. I think you´ll love it. If you can, go for the official video. #painintheask

[@davguev]

#PainInTheAsk Celestial Elixir, by Haken! Love every song in that album.

[@louiegarcia1848]

Rich n Kel besides SW you should look up #SpocksBeard A Treasure Abandoned. They're just as hardcore Prog Rock as Porcupine Tree.

[@mhagnemae5202]

#painintheask Raider II by Steven Wilson from the same concert is an epic eargasm. Give it a try!

[@ledrushmore1503]

Now i here this and i think of Yes as a influence

[@mzed561]

Yes, Camel, King Crimson, it's all there.

[@anurag750]

More Porcupine Tree please please please. I have exhausted all your PT/SW reactions at least a dozen times.

[@danp9080]

#stevenwilsongrammy won't happen because the grammys recognize industry darlings that represent popularity and sales. It's a big music industry circle jerk! SW and other quality artists are rarely recognized because unfortunately the masses don't know or care about art.

[@stevefromlondon4949]

Oh, so you like flutes, hmm? Then you need: #painintheask #pennypennypenny #notgivingup Cellar Darling - Insomnia Cellar Darling - Death Oh yeah, and I absolutely love Luminol, and the whole of the Raven album in general.

[@Wesley-kp3ju]

Keeping on the "prog rock+jazz fusion" train #painintheask Seven Impale - Oh, My Gravity! Seven Impale - God Left Us for a Black-Dressed Woman Album: City of the Sun (2014) Hiromi Uehara (a.k.a. Hiromi The Trio Project) - Alive Album: Alive (2014)

[@thinkingkind8675]

Please check out some Joe Satriani - The Forgotten (Part 2), Until We Say Goodbye, Always with me, Always With you. Truly one of the greatest guitar players to ever live. He plays his instrument like an extension of himself and is one of the most expressive players. He gave lessons to many big name players, Kirk Hammett of Metallica, Alex Skolnick from Testament, and Steve Vai.

[@rockonileva]

Luminol = like before watching...

[@STARS99991]

react to steven wilson the watchmaker (live in frankfurt) , one of his most underrated songs

[@PankajKumar-is2md]

#painintheask The Contortionist - Language I: Intuition

[@watchtheskies]

Hi Kel, Rich, are there any recordings or videos of Kel performing in concert!

[@michaelrue1400]

Here I thought Jethro Tull's Ian Anderson was the only one who incorporated a flute into rock music.

[@billyblunt63]

#StevenWilson The Raven that refused to sing from the album of the same name.

[@kph1034]

I really wish someone would do a reaction to this song. It’s so beautiful...someone ( kel) would be in tears

[@peeweekitt]

"A flute, nice!" Might I suggest Famine by Opeth or Aqualung by Jethro Tull? #painintheask

[@franckbizouard3357]

Another masterpiece of song!!!! enjoy ;-) I assume you to be already fans of Steven. He desserves. I know him since Porcupine tree "Signify" (1997), seen him live first time in 1999 in Bataclan, Paris. I buy anything which has Steven Wilson on it. TRY ALL STEVEN WILSON : PORCUPINE TREE-STEVEN WILSON (solo)-BLACKFIELD (another side group with Aviv Geffen)-.NO-MAN-BASS COMMUNION.... I promised you multiple musical orgasms ;-) And no he has not been nominated at Grammys (what the fuck?)... but at prog awards every year ;-) And he won lots of prog awards.

[@buckfuttler2877]

this song is a baby of Rush and Pink Floyd.

[@michaelmoran2421]

You guys bold enough to try voyage 34 (porcupine tree) it's a song nearly 1 hour long.

[@michaelmoran2421]

Oh, and when you do routine, please do the music video version. The live at the Albert hall is good and moving but the video should be your first experience. It makes so much more sense.

[@louiegarcia1848]

Yes! Brian and his friends have a fantastic voyage after they have eaten sugar cubes saturated with LSD lol

[@grahamhowes6904]

Anesthetize - Porcupine Tree live in Holland

[@Claubata2007]

It 's so ..KING CRIMSON and Genesis alike !!!!

[@VerifiedGroove]

#painintheask Fates Warning - Leave The Past Behind

[@Wedigar]

I requested their song One back when they had 300 subs lol I think they will be getting to it sometime :)

[@somewhiteguy3043]

#painintheask Steelheart- She's Gone- Unplugged version.

[@michaelbradley7447]

Daris Cook said hi she's my nanny

[@michaelmoran2421]

I think he has been nominated twice for best surround sound album but didnt win either. To know why listen to porcupine tree the sound of musak

[@michaelmoran2421]

Muzak*

[@davidthomas1467]

Try puncture wound by insurgentes

[@Shigawire]

The reason why Steven Wilson hasn't been nominated for a Grammy is because that particular award infrastructure is a capitalist establishment. And he hasn't exactly sold as many albums as the musicians who have been marketed more heavily. Unfortunate. The Oscars for movies, or IGF/GDC for games, are not like that. Reviewed by peers, unbiased by financial pressures. But they're all vulnerable to become like the Grammys at any given time. Just at the moment they're not.

[@Hatingmeisconforming]

#painintheask react to btbam "Extremophile Elite" live in studio.

[@ChrisPage68]

A little too jazzy in the first movement for my liking. I kept expecting Ron Burgundy to pop up on the flute. It doesn't take to places like Devin Townsend does.

[@ChrisPage68]

*take me

[@sanclemente1156]

Porcupine Tree "MOTHER & CHILS DIVIDED live" Fo for it!!!

[@sanclemente1156]

So if you will please play the reaction of Mother & Child Divided Live Version That would be a Pleasure! Thank You!

[@michaelbradley7447]

It's like aTool song mixed with a Pink Floyd song very good