Рет қаралды 197
William Lane Craig's Moral Argument for God's existence is a standard argument widely used by many apologists. In this video, Jeff Lowder (an atheist) shares his take on both its the strengths and weaknesses. Jeff is a strong defender of "steelmanning" arguments and objections and trying to understand them in the best possible light. Atheists and theists alike have a lot to learn, and this conversation is a great start!
If you are interested in a formal course in apologetics or even getting a full blown theological education and a fraction of the cost of a traditional seminary, check out onlinebibletraining.com (still in beta a launch as of the date of this recording)
Jeff's KZbin channel: / @secular_outpost
Philosophy of Religion Stock Issues, Part 1: • "Stock Issues" for PoR...
Philosophy of Religion Stock Issues, Part 2: • "Stock Issues" for PoR...
Blog: naturalisticatheism.blogspot....
Twitter: / secularoutpost
Chapter times:
0:00 - Introduction / Jeff's Background
10:45 - Progress in the philosophy of religion and philosophical theology
17:25 - On honesty in discourse
19:10 - WLC's Moral Argument: Overview and initial thoughts
25:50 - Objective moral values and God's nature
28:54 - Platonism, abstract objects, and objective moral values
36:10 - Ontological foundations/grounding of moral values | notions of "objective"
41:01 - The Euthyphro Dilemma and brute facts
44:41 - "Values require a valuer" vs. Craig's Divine Nature Theory
54:41 - Lowder's live options to DNT to ground moral theories (Platonism and ethical naturalism)
1:07:32 - Two types of subjectivity and moral realism v. antirealism
1:12:09 - Summary of the argument's strengths and a possible reinterpretation
1:18:55 - Lowder's PoR+ taxonomy of arguments and concluding thoughts
Erik Wielenberg's paper, Dawkins’s Gambit, Hume’s Aroma, and God’s Simplicity: philarchive.org/rec/WIEDGH
-----------------------------------
Moderation policy: We try to approve all comments, even those that disagree with our arguments, as I think that spurs honest discussion. Posts containing profanity or unsolicited sales, however, whether for or against the positions presented in the videos will be immediately removed.