India vs Turkey: Why HAL failed and TAI succeeded ?

[@StudyIQEducationLtd]

Use the code ‘RTLIVE’ to get Our Courses at Maximum discount! Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3Vd3Rx7 For any queries please whatsapp on bit.ly/wame8952084937 UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation P2I 2025 March Batch 2 : bit.ly/3Vd3Rx7 Batch Starting on 13th March 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/3Vd3Rx7 UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I March Hindi Batch 2 बैच 20 मार्च 2024 से शुरू हो रहा है | बैच का समय सुबह 8:00 बजे Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/49YoscI UPSC IAS Live GS Foundation 2025 P2I February English Batch Admissions Closing on 12th March 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/47XLChH UPSC IAS Long Term P2I Foundation LIVE 2026 Batch 4 Batch Starting on 21st March 2024 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/49ScJg8 UPSC IAS Live SIP+ Last Batch 2024 Batch Starting on 13th March'2024 | Class Timing - 5:00 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/49Am8ZB UPSC IAS Prelims to Interview ( P2I) 2024 Live Advanced Batch 6 Batch Started on 16th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:30 PM Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/46nl6h4 UPSC IAS (Mains) LIVE Optional Batches : bit.ly/3DrHsmw (PSIR, Sociology, History, Geography, Pub Ad, Anthropology, Mathematics, Hindi Literature) Set of 18 - General Studies books Hurry Enroll Now : bit.ly/416mF1T

[@saharshmishra9982]

Corruption and procrastination are the reasons........

[@shyamraa]

India already has 6.5++ Generation Fighter Aircraft!!

[@saharshmishra9982]

@@shyamraa In which movie??

[@shyamraa]

@@saharshmishra9982 It is kept top secret by Chairman Mo for WW3. 🤫

[@shoto3612]

​@@saharshmishra9982 exactly

[@DJ-xl5td]

😂😂😂😂​@@saharshmishra9982

[@creativeway5785]

Main reason Corruption

[@shyamraa]

India already has 6.5++ Generation Fighter Aircraft!! India is Vishwaguru 🤐

[@ParthSingh-iy7ge]

@@shyamraa hasna hai kya?

[@souvinfinity5773]

We forget that Turkey was a part of F-35 programme 😊😊

[@ohnoanyway7791]

No they weren't ... That's why they have decided to go for their own 5th generation.

[@mainaisakyohukumwara6337]

Forget india was also part of FGFA PROGRAM

[@inf783]

​@prestallar4339 the reason why turkey got kicked out from the programme was because s-400 counters f-22 and f-35... and US would never want that to happen, because it'll greatly impact the reputation and sales of the US jets... so they kicked turkey out

[@Shanu-p1u]

​@@ohnoanyway7791they were after buying S-400 they were not , at that time they got so much information

[@Asif-pz6mp]

F-35 ka operation dedia America ne Turkey ko kya? Jo tom keh rhe woh helpful he

[@shivshakti8r]

Previous Governments priority was to serve a family not the country. Who can forget A.K Antony saying we have no enough money to take Rafael fighter jets and China border should not be developed otherwise China will get angry 😅

[@bibhuranjanpal7935]

True Also we didnt have money for R&D.

[@sjsomyajitviie8397]

​@@bibhuranjanpal7935khangress ka kamal bhai

[@UsefulYoutuber]

BHAI UPA BHI 10 SAAL SE HAI GHANTA KAR LIYA

[@_DHRUV_3906]

​​@@UsefulKZbinrBhai thoda padho likho, tumhe ye bhi nhi pata ki UPA ki nhi NDA ki govt hai, aur NDA ki govt ke under brahmos, brahmos 2 , Agni 5 missiles successful Hui hai. After NDA govt ISRO launching rockets one by one. Because current NDA govt me corruption bahut Kam hai compared to UPA. UPA ke time pe to budget bhi muskil se pass hota tha ye baat khud ISRO ke scientist ne boli hai. Khangress ne jo anti-india ka chasma pehnaya hai na use Utaar ke dekho to dimag me bethega nhi to har jagah adani hi sapne me aayega😂

[@chhayanath7561]

And when inquiry going to happen NDA claims documents are burned of No one ask how it possible 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@adv.arvindshrivastava]

Central government fundings to HAL was very less before 2014. It took more than 17 years to develop Tejas 1…. Now it is evident that since CG has supported HAL and other agencies they have successfully built advance version of Tejas Mk 2 in just 6 years

[@thirdperspectivebyrishabh]

Bhai kyu bol rha h jb kuch pta nhi h tou 😂😂. R&D budget in 2013 was 20, 051 cr R&D budget in 2023-24 was 12,850 cr only. R&D budget is major factor here. Budget hi jb km rhega to HAL kya hi krega? Previous governments, are you sure about that?

[@adv.arvindshrivastava]

@@thirdperspectivebyrishabh theek hai bhaiya ji, aap apni Logic me mast rahiye 🙏🏼 According to your own logic, When budget was more there was less R&D; and when budget got decreased there is an increase in R&D 🫡 State-run plane maker Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) on Monday announced that it achieved the highest-ever revenue from operations of more than ₹29,810 crore for the financial year 2023-24, which accounts for around 11% growth compared to 9% during the previous financial year when the figure stood at ₹26,928 crore - Source: HT 02 Apr’24

[@gauravsharma-eh7sz]

There is a difference between innovation and assembly , hal has made 2 products in 84 years indigenously .

[@priyala-vashu]

सरकारों का ढीला रवैया और अपने लोगों पर विश्वास नहीं दिखाना। भारत में पिछली सरकारों की प्रोजेक्ट्स को लटका कर रखने की आदत इसका मुख्य कारण है वर्तमान सरकार उनसे काफी बेहतर कर रही है लेकिन अन्य देशों की तुलना में हमारी स्पीड अब भी पीछे है

[@neutralmindforsuccess6452]

Speed depends on funds

[@NewCartoonworld28]

No country wants transfer of technology to india And Other reason like low investment in Research Sector, low budget since independence, HAL carelessness focusing only light production like Light combat aircraft, light helicopter they may advantage in hills but not useful in open plan sky

[@mentalx5103]

India has poor research and development sector, we need to improve it.

[@forgottenheroes589]

not fully agree with u bro coz most of our border tensions are from northern region so LCA is must for Bharat

[@Sahil-khan_07.]

Our honorable ex president APJ abdul kalaam hote toh kabka ban chuka hota ...

[@boruto_uzumaki_69420]

Sahi baat bole vai

[@Arvindkumar-pi8vv]

Bhai vo missile department me the unko jet ki knowledge nhi thi.. kuchh bhi mat feko

[@_DHRUV_3906]

​​@@Arvindkumar-pi8vv tumne galti kardi galat insaan ko reply dekar. Kamse kam uska name to dekh lete 😂 Ye wahi log hai jo, jab Abdul kalam sir jinda the tb unhe k@f!r , mushr!k bolte the. Aur jab Abdul kalam sir ki death hue gine chune 4-5 log gye the zanaje me.

[@vishalrajyaguru2597]

Missile technology and jet technology totally different branches of engineering. He was a missile scientist and not a jet engineering specialist. If he could do, he would have already done it as top scientist and also as President.

[@facut768]

​@@_DHRUV_3906tu bkl hai kya ?

[@AdityaSingh-tf6om]

खा खा कर फैल जाने के आदत को पिछली सरकारों की रही

[@alphaonesix2627]

True success lies not in fleeting victories, but in the lasting impact and integrity of what we create, and our ability to uphold and defend it according to our own standards and values.

[@ashokkrmahato9304]

Lack of capital due to small share from budget 😓😓

[@shyamraa]

India already has 6.5++ Generation Fighter Aircraft!!

[@pkmkb007]

@@shyamraa Turkey already has 786th generation Aircraft!!

[@MrStriker0]

​@@shyamraa kaunsa bhaii?

[@shyamraa]

@@MrStriker0 Top secret ... Top secret... dushman ke kaan har tharaf hain!

[@MrStriker0]

@@shyamraa ok bhaiii✅💯

[@tirthmusale6687]

Kaan doesn't have anything in its prototype, It doesn't even have any hydraulics, while AMCA will have hydraulics, radar, and other 5th gen features, which the Kaans first flight didn't have

[@harshpashte4871]

Bhai uska engine tak american made hai 😂 sirf body Turkish hai 😂

[@austrianpainter345]

​@@harshpashte4871Sahi mei😂

[@user-ghtvkisswc34560O]

Dil behlane k liye apne failure ko chupane k liye shi h ​@@harshpashte4871

[@aryansingh8634]

Nahi bhai eek 5th generation structure bana lena bhi bhuta badi achievement hai

[@painkiller1621]

​@@harshpashte4871 Or tejas ka konsa part indian made hai 😂

[@kattarhindu271]

khangress is responsible..

[@mazharshaikh4671]

Aage aage dekho, kya milta he tumko 😂😂😂😂

[@pipipupu5104]

​@@mazharshaikh4671kya milta hai matlab?

[@rajrathore2]

M

[@aryansingh8634]

​@@mazharshaikh4671haa wahf board ban hone wala hai. 😅😅😅😅😅 😂😂😂😂😂

[@yogeshkumarshankariya642]

@@mazharshaikh4671 Teri school madrasa bandh hone vali he

[@naresh15214]

not only govt but some bright mind students going outside for better payment

[@ranakachari4543]

Sahi bola.. agar har institutions me political influence hoga tab us institutions se kya umid ki ja sakti hai.

[@user-vv9pb2rp9m]

We are united more than ever now, future is bright

[@manishvlogs5710]

simple, better engineering mind..

[@hardik-ok4sw]

A struggling economy turkey is making 5th generation aircraft meanwhile we are struggling

[@dexter009d7]

When a foreign defense agreement is done lot of people earn lot of money out of the deal.. Which doesn't happen when products are made in-house

[@knowthyself6816]

India struggle karti rahegi

[@kavyamalik1755]

The issue is funding we are simply not spending enough on research and development

[@sameermishra5970]

इसके सिर्फ दो कारण हैं पहला कांग्रेस ने कभी भी इस देश को मजबूत नहीं होने दिया दूसरा कांग्रेस ने भ्रष्टाचार को देश की रग-रग में बसा दिया

[@rohanagarwal6848]

I read somewhere on the internet that government of India started first semi conductors company in 80s .We were ahead of time in semi conductors but due to our bureaucrats and government corruption we missed the bus

[@djigi2002]

Not just F16, F35 as well.

[@tusharjolly2554]

Yes another reason is the defence budget we need to double up on our budget in next 5 years

[@PankajSingh-nf2tf]

turkey ne abhi khali airframe hi udaya h jo ki itni badi baat nahi h aur amca mk1 ka indigenisation 75 to 80% rakhne ki koshih h jo kaan se bahut jyada rahegi aur kaan BAE system se bhi help le raha h.

[@singhsahab124abhi]

Lack of funds on defence and research .

[@anilrathore4531]

क्योंकि हम विश्व गुरु है

[@ananyasain1241]

Defence Followers Like Me & Others Could Point Out The Real Reason:- "Paisa Ka Chakkar Hai Babu Bhaia Paisa." Time Me HAL Ko Paisa & Engine Dedo Wo Kuch Bhi Bana Sakta Hain. Time Me Funds Sanctioned Nahi Hote Engine Deal Sign Karne Me Government Years After Year Ka Time Barbaad Kar Deta Hai To Aisa Hi Hoga Na!! सत्यमेव जयते 🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏.

[@yatri6329]

Govt job people thinking...... In India

[@manjeetshahare4986]

Trade Unions and Bureaucracy

[@sameerkumar-ry1oc]

Reason: previous gov. Jo abbi 10 saal sai hai uski galti nahi hai aur agle 5 saal laghbhag aur rahegi uski galti nahi hai😂😂😂 wah re chamchagiri

[@rahulece-0197]

Ye chaatukarita krta hai present government Maine bohot saari videos m notice Kiya hai

[@kshitijsolanki3295]

Technology dedevelopers karne me 30 se 40 saal lagte hai fund nahi diya hoga previous govt ne

[@kalubehera7974]

U told the main reason❤❤❤

[@thirdperspectivebyrishabh]

​@@kshitijsolanki3295R&D budget in 2013 was 20, 051 cr R&D budget in 2023-24 was 12,850 cr only. R&D budget is major factor here. Budget hi jb km rhega to HAL kya hi krega? Previous governments, are you sure about that? (dhyan sy funding dekh le bhai)

[@lankadish364]

Hal ko bnd kr dena kyu ki ye kewal ab sarkari daftar ki trh h

[@mithundebnath496]

Why only the previous Government.. Current Government is also the same responsible... If previous government reigned for 15yrs consecutively then the current government has been reigning for 10yrs... In addition 25 yrs.. We're still struggling ...

[@Republic_of_Solatia]

Are you sure the previous government reigned only 15 years.. Secondly the factors are procrastination and corruption.. which according to his statement was higher in margin than today's date.. but overall there's a delay because of the entire situation stated.

[@mdsaikhul4390]

Reason is budget .. 1st year will search for parts.. 2nd year quotes for those parts . 3rd year budget allocation. Unnecessarily one month job done in 3 year.

[@aspirants2618]

Budget on research also

[@Daddy387]

The reason is simple lack of awareness of govt in military jets manufacturing

[@dushyantpardeshi3978]

Jo reason aapne bataya wohi accurate reason hain !!!

[@sadishsh]

Nato member hone ka bahut benefit hai. Turkey is a part of nato defence manufacturing and supply chain. Turkey ko kafi parts ka direct access hai. Indian ko mostly sabhi required systems kudh banane hai. Aur saath me dono programs me farak bahut hai India prototypes final stage me banata hai jisme sabhi required system hote hai, turkey hr stage pe ek prototype banayga abhi jo banaya hai wo sirf flight controls ke saath hai aur koi technology nahi hai usme. Defence programs are complicated comparatively video banana bahut easy hai.

[@rajeshvipra6601]

ऐसे तो भारत ने भी सुखोई बनाए है

[@saikrishnasingh1490]

Lower budget issue by govt on NPDs and metallurgical point of view we are not manufacturing many exotic alloys and titanium alloys inhouse that are used in aerospace industry,thatis the point i think we lack behind , but kudos to this govt we are started focusing now on these issues.

[@lvseditionwala5032]

Lack of awareness to lead the world

[@kk_movies8957]

Fabian policy was the reason

[@then3554]

R&D budget. Pehle se hi itna Kam hai ki fighter jet to bohot dur ki baat,ek service rifle banane me hi kitna time lag jata hai. Koi bhi military project ko kabhi bhi allocated budget me pura nahi kiya ja sakta Aaj ke time me. Cost overrun hoga hi. Budget nahi hone se, innovation bhi nahi hoga.

[@ajaykumar-pf9vd]

There are many reasons for India not being able to come up with 5 gen fighter. 1)Funds not released for it.2)No prior experience 3)only one dedicated design & development team for all projects like TejasMk1A, TejasMk2,Tedbef, AMCA. ORCA.

[@Popdad]

They do have NATO advantage. They have still not finished with 5th Gen kaan. It's just a prototype, it will take time to have a fully functional 5th Gen fighter .

[@harshitkumarsingh6450]

CCS approval, IAF uncertainty to choose type of aircraft. Abhi tak airforce ne mmrca keliye fighter jet hi nhi select kiya hi. To government kya karegi. 😮

[@The_Ashthetic]

Corruption, Reservation in PSUs, absence of timelines, lack of funds, lack of R&D investment, Government job (job security) mindset in PSU.

[@pre251]

nahi apne sahi bola scamgress ka corruption hi tha...abi abi defense me humne invest karna shuru kia h

[@anthonydisouza635]

For how long people will blame previous govt but not existing govt who is still in power for more then 10yrs

[@saurasishkumardas6913]

Reat things takes time bro wait for the right time for the greatest thing ever mad 😊

[@Sobscool]

Bhai AMCA developing phase me hai.

[@akshayhonmane8148]

Sir nice information Apka awaj Rajnath Singh foreign minister jaisa lag raha hai

[@HR-dm5wy]

Previous and current both are same mostly expect 4-5 minister like manohr parrikar sushma savraj n nitin gadkari

[@moksh7122]

Previous Government or Government?

[@wolfop536]

Indian samosa tejas crashed😂😂

[@akshayshingade]

Previous government corruption like??? Examples??? And what about Rafael

[@vijayghunowa183]

Lackadaisical system corruption and moreover the lobbies of western fighter jets manufacturers has deter India to succeed in manufacturing its own fighter jets 🙏 जय हिंद बन्दे मातरम 🇮🇳

[@raunakranjan8809]

Shortage of capable engineers

[@sukhdeepsingh1856]

Not enough funds to test prototype , not enough r&d spending and a need of more testing facilities if hal had all this they can develop any thing under 8 years and mass production in 9 to 10 years

[@shashibhushan9876]

Turkey ke pass f 35 ke parts banane ka bhi experience hai that's why wo itni jaldi catch kr paya

[@SierraHunter2106]

As far as manufacturing is concerned india has manufactured state of art su 30 mki in india and currently manufacture the tejas.. also india has experience with 5th gen tech with russia during the pak fa (fgfa) program... mind you the airforce did spend big bucks on that..

[@Pendupessi-nt2tn]

Assembled not manufacturer

[@SierraHunter2106]

@@Pendupessi-nt2tn MKI.. HAL and Sukhoi were involved in making the specially made su 30 for india with inputs from IAF

[@arjunbharti-zh2vt]

भारत आत्मनिर्भर का तोता रट लगा कर सो रहा है वास्तविक में आत्मनिर्भर से बहुत दूर है।

[@_itz_krishna_5449]

You know That India is ahead in atmanirbhar Jaake dekhle India ne kya kya banaya hai Tota Tera baap hoga 😡😡😡

[@ratulnandi508]

ASLI REASON LAST ME BOLEY, WOHI HAMARA 10 SAAL PAHLE KE 60-70 SAAL 😂😂, JAI BHARAT ❤

[@Dhirajkumar-yq9vo]

HAL ka Junior Researcher ka post bikta hai, that's why

[@AsadKhan-ep2ni]

Bhai budget kon bolega aur R&D pe budget nahi dena . Aur sab previous government and presentation government bhi R&D pe invest nahi karte hai .

[@kumararuny]

Corruption inefficiency in work, mismanagement and all.

[@Tr-pl3cv]

मोई जी😂।। मेरी पढ़ाई बढ़ाई नहीं हुई है दोस्तों😂😂

[@hello64879]

So called educated leaders were the main reason of India's economic crises in 90s

[@aryansingh8634]

Fir bhi aaaj duniya ke one of the most powerful person me naam liya jata hai dostho. Or papu toh चील kavoo ko rojgaar dene ki baat kar raha hai chamcho 😂😂😂😂😂.

[@pyrofanatic6053]

Absolutely, corrupted politicians

[@jatintrivedi5632]

How can we make previous accept the bureaucracy and lethrgic actions?

[@pathan7751]

Jiss din India 5th generation banayega uss din turkey 6th par hoga 😂

[@Aarthshukla]

INDIA'S growth started from 2014 in reality

[@jaishreeram3223]

Government companies😢

[@AdnanStatus]

Studyiq current government ko kuch nahi keh sakta

[@dynamiteon88]

Main reason is previous government policy and funds 😢

[@KoulSumeet]

Bureaucracy is a big hurdle

[@rajatpatel9170]

The reason is we are not honest for anything not for religious not for country not even for himself we just want to put down each other

[@arifsayyad2682]

भारतीय वैज्ञानिको मे बहुत क्षमता है पर हमारे भारत देश में जितने भी आज तक सरकार आई उसमे से ज्यादा तर नेता नॉट इंटरेस्टिंग है our कोरोप्शन बडा खेल है यही कारण है

[@dollybindra9606]

Govt’s irresponsibility and attitude of govt employees are to be blamed.

[@Kabeer98554]

5th Gen is too much expensive..India needs large no. of squadrons to fight a two front war that's why India opter for 4 and 4.5 gen fighters.India needs immediate replacement of Mig 21, Jaguar, Mirage..so India opted for bulk production of Tejas as immediate measure rather than 5 gen AMCA.

[@atishmeher4390]

lack of funding in research work by government

[@AmiyaProfessionalTrader]

Turckey humesha ladhai m dhyaan de rha h and India k pass doosre bade bade kaam h....no comparison....India dhokha nahi deta Turcky yuhin de deta h.......

[@Gshsv-q4t]

Really? Turkey ek NATO member hai aur 2nd largest and 5th strongest army rakhta hai NATO me. To use kya firk ladai ki? Hame China se war karni hai, jiski economy hamse 4times aur defence budget bhi almost 4 times hai.

[@praveshmudgal2973]

Govt should sold out some share part of ownership from this kind of PSU

[@ZeelPatel-k1m]

Bhai Indian education system

[@kunalawasthi6280]

I think 4.5 is better the 5

[@adityaraj2142]

2008 me us time ki govt ne russia se deal todi thi lekin khud banane ka plan nhi banayi thi, isiliye ham 10 saal piche reh gye 5th gen ke aircrafts me😢..... 2023 me jake plan bana khud banane ka AMCA

[@yuvrajsingh121]

previous government??? waah...not only previous governments but every government including the current

[@adityatomar5333]

Not current government. They are highly focused in weapons sector and investing in drdo. Drdo had tested another missile test successfully.

[@rammohammedsinghazad2070]

Baal

[@m....74]

Jhatpa is responsible 😂😂😂

[@RahulNigam-k7w]

quota system of India

[@MrGunnerholic]

Humare goberment fund ke paiso se election me ads chala rhe hai😂

[@tejeshvlogs1848]

I am working with hal as a outsourcing I noticed lot of corruption in hal

[@SierraHunter2106]

You never fail while you are researching about something... plus big thing is that turkey and amca development approach is COMPLETELY DIFFERENT... had the airforce and govt show swiftness regarding engines and had the private companies agreed for the spf model then surely the amca prototype 1 would have been ready by the next year or so.. also the service induction of kaan and amca is almost same. I again repeat myself... you never fail by researching... this only builds capabilities

[@pointofinterest5981]

India needs its own private aerospace companies for truly to become a superpower. India needs its own Boeing, Lockheed Martin etc.

[@humanbeing1551]

Private wle scam kar lete hai bhag jate hai 😂😂😂 yeha pe unko bhi kuch nhi aata

[@ayushmankar4100]

​@@humanbeing1551 To regulations kyun nahi lati Govt ?

[@humanbeing1551]

@@ayushmankar4100 jab scam karke hi bhag jaegi to tu unse piche kab tak padega Usme government ka bhi cut hota hai Yeha ke engineer ko kuch nhi aata theory ke alawa

[@Tradezonetrading]

Another Main reason is lack in R&D.

[@aryeshsingh2038]

Haa previous government not. Current. Government ?! 😊

[@rahulbasurey1937]

Is baar 400 paar 🏹. We will be in top 3 economy at the end of his 3rd tenure....lets male India great again 🇮🇳💪

[@shivu6377]

MIG 21 (which was flown by Abhinandan) was nicknamed as the 'Flying Coffin', because it was so outdated and unsafe And our politicians cry out that the government is wasting money on buying Raphael and all instead of building hospital and colleges 😂😂

[@Virgile-m8t]

Too many QUANGOS in Indian's military manufacturiers they should be a shame of letting the country down 👇 जय हिन्द बन्दे बन्दे मातरम 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@ghostmickey4075]

Sir ne simple bhasha mein bataya kise vote karna hai😂