Sugababes - About A Girl (Keisha Version)

[@rk-sc6zr]

I think keisha voice is an icon for sugababes...

[@user-uz5pk4wd4t]

Keisha gave the song that Sugababes vibe. Without her, the song doesn't feel like a Sugababes song

[@DJRichieSkye]

This is hard. Jade’s voice gives the song a high powered pop sound. BUT Keisha’s version gives us that DISTINCTIVE personality and classic Sugababes sound that you just can’t replicate.

[@naniorossi3067]

Whatever your thoughts are, this IS the sugababe way because Keisha is practically the voice of Sugababes as she contributed to the group since day one.

[@carloschavez453]

Keisha gives the song softness, blend , harmony and innocence. While the two new girls sounded hard, pressured and we can say they just accepted this job.

[@DistantCousin]

Such a great way to describe it!

[@romeosaintsmusic]

Heidi wasn’t new at that time she was in the band for 9 years it was Jade that was the more recent member 😊

[@Skylerjones624]

Apparently Jade was woken up early in the morning to be told about a band opening and was flown to the US not even 24 hours later to film the music video for this song

[@rayoflight6505]

Both versions were great Jade empowered the chorus however Keisha kept the classic Sugababe vibe.

[@gabrielggabriel]

Keisha version is far far superior.

[@Lanadel-oz5oe]

Keisha Is the heart of the sugababes it doesn’t work with out her FACT

[@marquinhosoliveira882]

The best song of Sugababes and the only version that worths!

[@crybibicry]

e, push the button and round round hello

[@thomasfy4]

omg this is so much better than the new version :(

[@anglodoomer5995]

This song was my jam back in the day lol

[@colaplus]

Siobhan, Mutya and Keisha was the original founders of the group and with the most potencial, in my opinion.

[@viktortumpa576]

But second line up with more hits. Many of us don't have an idea hwo Shobian is.

[@loveandpeace_totheworld]

Heidi is the Sugababes Queen

[@wikimiki5765]

secont squad was iconic 💅

[@kristophergracia3162]

Keisha has a richer, fuller voice. The superior version of this record.

[@Starsurfer1988]

I must say I prefer Jade's Version

[@Anonytjuh]

I agree this version fits Keisha's vocals much better. I like Jade's version too (she has outstanding vocals), but comparing with Keisha's version, it's not as good.

[@abdulc5726]

Mutya and Keisha made that group what it was, they gave it the distinctive sugarbabes sound.

[@RRADOMAL]

& Siobhan

[@abdulc5726]

​@@RRADOMALyeah thats fair

[@abdulc5726]

​@@RRADOMALhmm I dunno the other two were in it longer tbf im not saying Siobhan didnt contribute but the other twos voices are what I remember more

[@Martdiva1979]

Keisha 🎵"You don't Know about a girl"🎶 L♡ve it

[@skurinski]

The only version I stan

[@Sloanlake22]

The original with Keisha was already leaked before she left the band and I got used to blasting it in the car. Gaga was at her peak back then with this sound.

[@libordostal886]

Sugababes will always be: Keisha, Heidi and Mutya/Amelle. What happened before and after is no longer sugababes... Change my mind

[@levinlegend5253]

Can’t wait for their new album the original lineup

[@blond0304]

It’s out now

[@pa2467]

​@@blond0304 and it's amazing 😍😍😍😍

[@zeddyzeddyxx]

The ONLY version ♡

[@deiricgraham662]

Sorry but Keisha was the one who made the sugababes. Best voice. Big mistake replacing her with jade. Would of been better replacing the other 2

[@aaronwillis6035]

Heidi shouldn't have gone. The main bulk was with her too, 9 years. Heidi was more of a Sugababe than Siobhan.

[@bekowiczzklanu2851]

@@aaronwillis6035 TRUE

[@ayanp353]

Lol, no. Mutual made the Sugababes

[@music_lover2211]

At some point I agree. It was not so right to replace last remaining OG member. But replacing 2 members at the same time would the band totally change even ruin... I think many people would hate the line up more than the last one. 3.0 was still a typical Sugababes line up. But the record label brought Amelle & Heidi back with a new member... I think everything happens for some reason..😉

[@deiricgraham662]

@@music_lover2211 Yes but keisha had the most distinct voice and also she was still an original connection. I think they would have been better replacing the other 2. At least then the last album would of had a more sugababe feel to it. Even listen to the keisha vocals on sweet 7. 10 times better than jades. No disrespect to her shes a good singer..

[@jackjackson4543]

Jade vocals are impressive... And suit this song.. yet Keisha gives it a great sugababe vibe... without Keisha or mutya they aren't the sugababes.. yet Heidi vocals is included as sugababe.. but you need an original member at least

[@xiPopCat]

jackjackson 4 the original 3 are back together as the sugababes

[@serebrobrasil]

Jade could be replace Amelle not Keisha

[@tamirrrrr]

it would form a vocal powerhouse group

[@ayanp353]

Nah, Amelle gave the group character

[@music_lover2211]

No! I don't think that would ever work...The husky voice would be missed there. That's one of the reasons why Amelle was the only one brought immediately as Mutya's replacement.The girls are a perfect vocal combination wheter MKS or HAJ! One sweet voice, husky voice and melodic voice. As Keisha now belongs to Mutya and Siobhan, Jade belongs to Amelle and Heidi. None of the girlbands have that combo that's why they're so unique....🙂

[@music_lover2211]

@Likedbymany Yeah!🙂

[@stevenrees8903]

K M H for me .. they were the sugababes.. 🎶

[@paidatomriehuja]

I think all of them are talented and all the line ups were nice to listen to. But for me the quality of the songs went down after Mutya left. She has such a unique voice. Also no one ´replaced’ Keisha. She left on her own, just like the others did. And Heidi will always be much more of a sugababe than Sioban ever was.

[@WereGreen]

Keisha didn't leave she was forced to leave. Check out her youtube channel she explains it.

[@romeosaints8500]

She was removed from the group she didn’t decide to leave 🤦🏾‍♂️ also Siobhan is an original sugababes Heidi did contribute her vocal talent and image that made the sugababes successful but you can’t ignore the originals creating the sugababes to begin with 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@loveandpeace_totheworld]

Heidi was in the band for like 10 years. She helped the band to get there succes. Mutya, keisha and Heidi worked 🔥 perfect 3 girls together !!!! We need them back. The ginger one has a great voice but has no oomph about her.

[@loveandpeace_totheworld]

Siobhon is great singer but she is so boring and doesn't add much to the group. Heidi was better.

[@colaplus]

Siobhan is actually a talented singer. And Heidi is an vokally, autotuned amateur, bit thats just my opinion. Siobhan was also a orignal and one of the founder og the grup. They had much potencial.

[@quentin_turc]

Keisha was the Sugababes.

[@emiliolopez3064]

If they only would’ve released it!! 😓❤️

[@danseekings2050]

did Keisha record the whole album of sweet 7?

[@pa2467]

Yes but it was never released

[@Martdiva1979]

This is Better

[@aaronwillis6035]

People bashing Jade: Jade has a great voice, she bought something difference to Sweet 7, bigger vocals (Little Miss Perfect shows that) But I agree Keisha bought a depth to it. Sweet 7 was a good album. I did like a lot of the songs with Amelle too.

[@justschr]

Current lineup needs to do a version of this song. It’s really the only song that fits the group currently.

[@cox78]

That will never happen lol. Keisha has made it clear she hates this album, specifically this song. She said that she was on the way to shoot the video for this when she got the call that she was cut

[@lovelypolishperson5566]

It sounds like Lady Gaga's Poker Face, but I love it.

[@90taetaeya]

Same producer, Red One.

[@Blueknightex]

@kacymay1 - yeah you're so right! It's so annoying how these people are bashing Jade. You haters should STFU! Blame the manager! Not her! It's their fault for kicking Keisha out! Geez

[@jaywest3734]

Jade sucked.

[@marquinhosoliveira882]

VanishedFade I dont hate anyone. Just think Keisha's vocals are better and works well with the other girls.

[@deiricgraham662]

I agree with you. Blame the managers. I just don’t know how they thought that jade sounded anywhere close to Keisha, I mean it was Keishas band , she was the glue holding them together. When she left the band lost their spark.

[@BambiTrout]

Deiric Graham from all the stories, it sounds like she was the TNT that blew them apart. The reason she got replaced was that Heidi and Amelle both wanted to leave, allegedly because Keisha was a bully. Management decided that they would rather replace one member than two and made Heidi and Amelle a counteroffer - stay in the band but replace Keisha. The girls agreed and we got Jade. Ngl I loved the Sugababes with Keisha, and the iconic lineup will always be Keisha, Mutya, and Heidi, but tbh I think this song just slaps harder with Jade. Keisha's voice is just too smooth to work properly in this one. Jade has the power to compete with the thumping instrumental.

[@RARA-ek3yp]

The only legit!

[@r3b3llion64]

Better ❤

[@juliathalbourne6611]

💥💥💥💥

[@MM-fv7hi]

Most Sugababes members 1. Keisha 2. Heidi and Myuta 3. Amelle 4. Sioban 5. Jade

[@simonmutke2852]

Mutya Siobhan and Keisha could re-record this song ❤️

[@U2QuoZepplin]

If I'm honest I would want a six piece lineup with Shevaugn Mutya Keisha Heidi Amele and Jade if I'm alowed to be that greedy. It's not gonna happen but I can dream can't I?

[@cox78]

I don't think Keisha has had a full conversation w Heidi & FOR SURE Amelle in about 15 yrs. And FOR SURE (LOL) Mutya hasn't spoken to Heidi in about 20 yrs.

[@nickyb2864]

👩🏽

[@StephenJHolloway]

The other version is better to be honest

[@saaypark]

Jade ate Keisha up on almost all their songs on Sweet 7 tbh lol, a lot of ppl are stans of her but Jade sings a lot better on these songs

[@iampause]

Yes, Jade ate Keisha up on every song on the album. But "Wait for You" right there... not that one, ma'am

[@saaypark]

@@iampause ehhh THATS opinion. I still think Jade sounded way better than Keisha on Sweet 7. Their older songs, keisha owned

[@rodgerkehl8399]

Who is Jade in this world? Lol

[@levinlegend5253]

Wheres jade now? And the original sugababes are back and i oppps

[@saaypark]

@@levinlegend5253 she’s on this Netflix show where she’s playing Mariah Carey and yeah they were back together but haven’t really done anything

[@newgeneration8083]

Sorry the jade version is way better

[@Bravosbarlaris]

Sorry but Jade version is like it was a Girls aloud/Saturday song...Keisha is the Sugababe style