Super Mario Bros. Wonder: Honest Review

[@ashishxgupta]

Great Breakdown and review!

[@GameListPlus]

Thanks so much! Thanks for watching!

[@Katie-hb8iq]

I think your review is pretty solid and reasonable, but I do question giving the game a 9 when the only negative is, "If you are not the target audience for this game, it might not be for you". That's literally true for every game ever made. It's not the job of a reviewer to hold a genre against it, or to predict if said genre will be popular or not. If a game is a 9.5 or 10 for the target audience, even if that audience is 10 people, then so be it.

[@GameListPlus]

Well I did mention those flowers being a bit annoying, I feel like a 9 is as good of a score as I can give unless I consider it a true masterpiece. It's close! But not quite! Thanks for the comment and thanks for watching!

[@Katie-hb8iq]

​@@GameListPlus But you can turn the flowers off! How is that a negative? "If I were the game designer, I would have never put the flowers in at all! Screw the people who actually liked the flowers!" Seriously, that's not how you review games. This is a very bad standard to empose your preferences onto a game and exposes how junior you are at this. You're pointing out negatives when the game designers literally catered to your preferences in advance. You sound like you're just complaining merely about a default setting... I think a 9 could be a valid score for this game, but I just don't think you did a very good job justifying it. By how your review reads, it's a 10 because you didn't point out anything that would genuinely drop a game's score. Sounds like a perfect game if your only complaints are, "If you are not the target audience for this game, you might not like it" (which again, is true for ALL games in existence) and "You might be annoyed with the default setting of the talking flowers, even though the game lets you turn them off."