J vs Ben: The HARDEST Neville Longbottom Trivia Quiz EVER

[@SuperCarlinBrothers]

How did you do? Did you beat us?! Become a Quiz Master and try and stump us at :: www.patreon.com/SuperCarlinBrothers

[@mikeyryan9366]

SuperCarlinBrothers hi

[@baraam7595]

Hey

[@Mjgaming54321]

Ayeeee

[@harrypotterfan6357]

SuperCarlinBrothers I love you guys!!!!

[@c0urtn3y526]

Augusta! And I think it was a Pottermore thing - Neville being Albus's godfather.

[@croisant6142]

I like how the infamous underdog Ben finally wins by a landslide on the quiz about the infamous underdog Neville.

[@critter2]

I am personally happy to see Ben win Jay ususally wins these

[@SereniaSaissa]

Waay to go Ben!!!

[@EnvyNV6]

Yess!

[@jadeneaston]

I shouldn’t have looked at the comments before finishing this video. Got it spoiled!

[@richardchisenhall387]

Came to the comments for the same reason, the irony is beautiful 😁

[@noelle479]

Looks like ben has figured out a way to organize his brain desk

[@KagiWarai]

He got another lamp for that desk!

[@arandomuser9459]

Maybe he got a upgrade.

[@diyanahesat1986]

Maybe he's put in paper organisers

[@itpaynesme]

He mentioned that he has been rereading them and remembering the random little bits of information

[@ina8099]

@@itpaynesme They are always re-reading them :D

[@johncheshirsky8822]

J: Snape! Ben: Snape! Tyler: Severus Snape! Me: DUMBLEDORE!

[@gooftroop9000]

Иван Васильев I’m so glad I wasn’t the only one thinking it

[@louisemtmgdg]

Same!!!

[@hospitalgal101]

@@louisemtmgdg This legit made me laugh out loud, Thank you. I was thinking of that too

[@hospitalgal101]

This legit made me laugh out loud, Thank you. I was thinking it too

[@CovalentNetworkSolid]

Thats a KZbin deep cut.

[@reaganorton1710]

Ben Fans: *screaming for joy Jay Fan:*shocked frozen expression

[@annafuller5310]

Fans of both: *pleasantly pleased for Ben and finding Jays sore loser attitude hilarious*

[@fabiomora6491]

I love how the J fan is an actually fan with a letter J, that J himself put on it

[@coolnerdlll6053]

*Cut to Jeff Goldblum in Thor: Ragnarok* "What?"

[@hallinguyen2169]

“im sorry, J fan” man i died bro

[@SolveigLRue]

J fan = Luke

[@justsomeguy892]

F

[@Rovy83]

Is this how it feels to be a fan of Ben? I can't believe he lucked into all those answers!

[@tes912]

How u not rooting for ben

[@Rovy83]

@@tes912 schadenfreude I suppose. Funny to see how Ben screws it up this time... :p. Plus I love the way J can just pull the answer out of nowhere.

[@The1marije1]

"Are you gonna FIND him?" Ben "was that a hint?" J: * desperately guesses Diggory*

[@6idiotslover2711]

HUFFLEPUFFS ARE PARTICULARLY GOOD FINDERS

[@lindanelson5053]

What the heck is a Hufflepuff

[@lyshalou11]

@@lindanelson5053 Hufflepuff is one of the Hogwart's houses. It was founded by Helga Hufflepuff

[@marctang3802]

Linda Nelson ...you can’t be serious

[@iluvkittykatalot1182]

Linda Nelson why... why are you even watching this video? Also I hate you... no I really dislike you...

[@david1b333]

Ben: Master of the Longbottom

[@Katielovegood44]

DavidB _db i still find Ben trip at the finish line Carlin funny 😂

[@MrGabeanator]

DavidB _db lol

[@brokenstars211]

Can we just applaud the editor for a second, i laughed so hard at all the zooms, truly the unspoken hero

[@arandomuser9459]

BrokenStars Same. Who is the editor he is amazing!!

[@bromodragone8405]

@@arandomuser9459 I think it's either Tyler or Jordan.

[@kinggl0ver9]

Or Scott? From NerdSync

[@crazycrafter1718]

@@kinggl0ver9 Sooo true and wen J just like : there is hope! *zooming in on psyko face*

[@miarockefeller4136]

it is indeed Scott

[@whiskeywine5898]

Ben, you can definitely tell you've put so much effort into remembering the details on your read throughs! So excited for you!Ive always been team Ben on these quizzes, but its so awesome seeing you confident!

[@nabz598]

I always watch these vs videos being team Ben and usually he doesn’t win, so I’m very proud of Ben today.

[@markuswilson872]

So I am creating a Song one about the supercar brothers And one of the lines is hoping on quizzes J gets a better score

[@arion1633]

Yeah - I'm same as you - always team Ben so it's really nice to see him win after Dobby quiz. :3

[@pizeyplayz2137]

Ur name is whiskey and wine

[@petbird19]

@@nabz598 SAME

[@MMDNoroi]

Ben: *finally wins at a Harry Potter quiz* Me: THATS MY BOYYYY!!!

[@Cyrusrm7]

Pretty much was like Leo finally winning oscar!😁

[@skrilllfury2120]

He also got the Dobby quiz

[@Katie-fv6ej]

"I'm sorry, J-fan... I've let you down... the one person" It's Luke, isn't it 😂😜

[@Phelie315]

I'm laughing about the implication that even J's wife is rooting for Ben 😂

[@jostewart3192]

Phelie315 it has been confirmed that is true in the first ever Ben vs j

[@Katie-fv6ej]

@@jostewart3192 yep, Beth's a savage 😉

[@ashleyrobo]

or Beth

[@fabiomora6491]

Everybody knows that the J fan is an actual roof fan with a letter J on it that J himself put there

[@mjgears9953]

J is like the kid in class that wins every Kahoot! and Ben was just like that one kid that slides in and dethrones him😂😂😂😂

[@Mary_Studios]

Fun story. We did a quiz about online safety or something and we could choose nicknames and I went with Moony and I won. Lol.

[@SilviaNight99]

If we were allowed to choose nicknames for Kahoot, I always did something Harry Potter related lol

[@arandomuser9459]

In that case I’ve been Ben a few times and it always feels amazing. Even better if I knew the kid. I wish we were allowed to choose nicknames in my school it was amazing when we could. 🤣

[@marshiemellow3232]

It's the best when you've all chosen nicknames so the will never know who it was!

[@laurakelly8900]

I’m that one kid.

[@hannahmiller09]

Ben and J have switched roles in these. Ben is doing so great. he gets gold start

[@indigopines]

The "times J repeats the question" counter kills me every time XD

[@cambunneh]

Can we please keep the graphics used for the questions and answers. It's just sooooooo cool!

[@quethesparkle]

Pretty sure those are the work of Scott Niswander! Feel free to let him know you like it @scottniswander on twitter!

[@arandomuser9459]

Agreed they are great!

[@Katielovegood44]

The part where Tyler slams J down.. I’ll be the judge You could tell that was the youngest brother vs older brother situation... and middle child Ben just stayed quiet 😂😂🙈🙈

[@itpaynesme]

KateMiles44 which one is the eldest though?

[@timverma]

@@itpaynesme J is the oldest, Tyler is the youngest

[@SG-pu3rx]

@@timverma I think quite the opposite

[@jordan5012]

Sıla Gülcemal no, J is the oldest, then Ben, and Tyler is the youngest.

[@SG-pu3rx]

@@jordan5012 I was talking about what their personalities reflect

[@finnyourhuman2288]

this guy is cool and all but derrick asking the questions were music to my ears he's the goat

[@finnyourhuman2288]

@Zara Hoffman yeah like I said he's cool I just prefer derrick

[@pokedexholderorange8868]

Me too he should come back

[@nerdstorm596]

Pokédex Holder Orange do we now why he left? I couldn’t find any info on it.

[@speedreader2660]

Yeah, I miss him, too

[@Ejmillanv]

true, what ever happened to Derrick

[@norabellerose8560]

I love how compared to the two brothers Ben is basically Neville and in a quiz about Neville, Ben is doing remarkably well.

[@MadiganinPeach]

The underdog: *master of the underdog*

[@KnobleSloth]

Sharpening a pencil as a kid is the adult equivalent of a smoke break

[@ForeverLumoz]

Wow then I've missed something essential as an adult.😳 Or maybe I'll just continue to sharpen pencils 🤔😊

[@KnobleSloth]

Smoke. It puts hair on your chest

[@theunholysmirk]

canonically, there are a lot of ways his uncle tested if he had magic, the only one that worked is the bounce

[@MoonBlinked13]

"How long was Neville's second wand?" Me: Neville had a second wand??

[@Giondi]

His first wand was broken at the Department of Mysteries at the end of Order of the Phoenix.

[@ellaquint]

His first wand actually having been his father's, which could be part of why he struggled with spells with it.

[@simoncooper6752]

I bet Neville has nightmares where he keeps hearing 'Snape, Snape, Severus Snspe.'

[@theillytellez3761]

Ron...ron...ron Weasley!

[@sophiamekoma3916]

Heeerrmioneee

[@venurm1286]

Harrypotter, Harrypotter, Harrypotter, Harrypotter,

[@bort3486]

yeah harry potter

[@sophiamekoma3916]

SNAPE! HARRY! SNAPE! HARRY! SNAPE! HARRY!!! DUMBLEDORE!!!

[@TimeTravelerAlly]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 -For Tyler’s delievery on the Patreon question

[@Schleichhorselover-bk6xq]

My language arts teacher dressed up as Snape for Halloween today

[@jaimelannister1797]

Thats pretty epic

[@ranadahdaly5814]

Schleich horse lover 400 mine was Harry himself

[@francoisrd]

Schleich horse lover 400 must have been terrifying

[@indigopines]

I hope at some point he instructed you to "turn to page 394"

[@lylamarcks]

Schleich horse lover 400 I was Luna

[@sweetpoptropica]

I just so badly want y'all to get into Percy Jackson... The amount of material just ripe for theories and quizzes... Also it just bops.

[@jostewart3192]

Probably they will with the Disney+ series- yay!

[@genesisnaturevideos5427]

You can tell who Tyler's favorite brother is. XD

[@annabrown3337]

Ha! I got Albus because logically James would have Ron as Godfather

[@ameliaparis3222]

Why not Lily?

[@Zo3h-r4m]

@@ameliaparis3222 I think lily would have someone Ginny was close with

[@EllaIngram]

@@Zo3h-r4m i believe Lily had Luna as her godmother? not sure if that's canon or i just read it in a fanfic lol

[@dustingaethje1332]

I had the same line of thinking

[@justmyke7641]

14:17 "Snape, Snape, Severus Snape" Intentional or not, I love the reference to Potter Puppet Pals

[@elemeniahx]

Tyler should have a channel where he just reads all the books from cover to cover - such a nice voice 💛

[@tylergraham2221]

I really hope the way that they said Snape was intentional. Snape... Snape... Severus Snape.

[@reknit96]

Tyler Graham me too.

[@feathersryan8331]

DUMBLEDORE!!!

[@kellysunserenity4068]

Ron, Ron, Ron Weasley!

[@heidilse1046]

feathers ryan I always go there. My daughter has as her ringtone

[@chloebrindle9295]

I can’t believe when Ben said “that was sheer luck” no one said “for sheer dumb luck” 😂

[@lauraeisenschenk9386]

I don't know why Jay's mind being blown at question 11 made me giggle so much😂

[@krystofdayne]

12:21 I had the exact same initial reaction that Ben did here: "Oh that was when we was caught by the Snatc- OH WAIT NO, it was on the Ka-Night Bus!" xD

[@sibanipanigrahy5509]

Oh same. But that was dudley dursley wasn't it

[@grimlocke6988]

Whoever took over editing these videos is doing a great job

[@shelbyb9056]

grimlocke 69 I came here to say this, but I knew in my heart that it had already been said.

[@mjgears9953]

Is it weird that Ben has just encouraged me to study because he did so well after paying close attention during his read/listen throughs😂😂

[@MeTalkPrettyOneDay]

Ben gets the most improved award this year

[@eveemc6949]

“I’ve been listening far more aggressively lately” how does one listen aggressively? Do they just like talk uncalled for smack to the speaker?

[@itpaynesme]

Avery.J a better word would’ve been “attentively” but hey, aggressive.. works??

[@missicequeen2963]

They repeat everything they fear 1000000000000000000000 times when they leave

[@Jake-fq6ir]

Audible

[@gooftroop9000]

Yay!!!, GO BEN, GO BEN, GO BEN!!! I was literally screaming at my tv. OMG, IM SO EXCITED!!! Congratulations Ben!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@MsWillowbayOrelse]

Same!!

[@EcceJack]

Me three!! 😄😄😄

[@augustinemokgohloa9135]

Me 4!!!!

[@charlie8379]

"Snape Snape (The answer is) Severus Snape" Did anyone else add the melody to that?

[@heidilse1046]

Charlie Well My response was Dumbledor

[@bromodragone8405]

Yes

[@Marruby21]

Not gonna lie I really enjoy Tyler's delivery and participation in these videos .

[@maxisatube]

Melanie Lege but Derrick was the man

[@joshuafrendomenendez]

@@maxisatube prefer Tyler

[@21pilotstillidie58]

I gotta disagree to me Derrick was much better. He was way more enthusiastic and made things more interesting

[@bethstowe10]

21pilots tillidie what happened to Derrick??

[@skylerb97]

Beth I feel like he left partially because of the mess his family might have been getting due to the Projared fiasco. Since Jared is his brother

[@dracula66vlad]

I always hated how Neville got only 10 points for standing up to his friends. but Ron got 50 for playing Chess

[@jeffreyroot7346]

Well it was Death Chess!

[@jasminnoble7302]

I know this is 6 months late but I really think Dumbledore should have given Ron the points for his self-sacrifice rather than simply playing chess. Yes, he plays a very good chess game no denying that. But his real moment to shine is his realization that he needs to be taken in order to stop Voldemort and accepting his fate bravely. Even though Harry and Hermione don't want him to do that, and even though he knows he'll be hurt badly, he does it anyway. And he's only 12. So I was always salty that Dumbledore only comments on Ron's great game of chess.

[@dracula66vlad]

@@jasminnoble7302 Exactly, that is worthy of 50 points, but because he just said a good game of chess, it makes it seem as if he only got the points because he was just there and Harry's friend.

[@iluvkittykatalot1182]

Well he sacrificed himself for Harry to move on

[@dracula66vlad]

@@iluvkittykatalot1182 True but the school doesn't know that, so to them he got 50 points for playing Chess... Honestly, I don't really care that Ron got that many points, I just feel like Neville didn't get what he deserved

[@matthewarcher3024]

And Tyler? AMAZING WAY TO INTRODUCE THAT QUESTION. Nailed IT

[@sampaige9468]

Albus Severus Potter, you were named after your godfather's boggart....

[@arandomuser9459]

Sam Paige 😂 I wonder how Harry went about telling Neville that his godsons middle name was his boggart.

[@Liv_Rose02]

When he yelled “Mitochondria” I almost spit out my water 😂

[@ogaccount5186]

14:9

[@babyboybensolo632]

The editing on this video is great. Laughed so many times! XD

[@derekblankenship9137]

J: "I'm sorry J fan... Just the one."

[@kktypescript2137]

Can we get team Ben swag? I feel like we need team Ben swag...

[@mysteriousmsf]

Kathleen Neblett YYYYYYYEEEEEEESSSSSS

[@Mary_Studios]

I would love to buy that along with outer murch. Don't think I'll be able to though

[@arandomuser9459]

Definitely need a team Ben t shirt. Edit: Or something.

[@nnemkin]

Ben killed it this time! I also really enjoyed the editing and Tyler's commentary. Great episode! :)

[@gamerfellow]

This episode was amazing! XD The edits, the jokes, the everything! So great! AND BEN WON!

[@taraswaminathan5095]

Ben is just pure happiness this entire quiz! Love it!

[@chloem48]

*J gets 3 points behind* J: I don’t think there’s any coming back at this point.

[@fishproductions22]

You guys should do "why don't characters in Harry Potter ever get sick?"

[@specialbudgies4217]

JK Rowling has already answered this: wizards are immune or deal far easily with Muggle maladies, but still have their own deadly diseases and spell and potion related health problems. For instance the pepper Up potion can cure the Muggle flue in seconds (for the record there's no Muggle cure in the real world either), but you can still die of dragonpox or spattergroit. We do in fact have mentions of students going to the nurse to take pepper up potion in the winter, Ginny included, and Trelawny even sees in her crystal ball that she'll lose her voice due to a short illness. So the reason it's not really mentioned is that, well, it happens, but it's not relevant to the story to have Harry wake up with a stuffy nose and go to the nurse after potions but before fighting Voldemort.

[@gusteg83]

16:18 Bens question ... almost a direct quote from the character Riley Poole"National Treasure" : "Is this how you feel all the time?"

[@stevenbailey8167]

*new SCB video comes out Everybody: YAYYY Me: THESE SOCKS ARE AMAZING!!

[@arandomuser9459]

Steven Bailey I understand that reference. 😂

[@kaleymcquinn7904]

KitsWorld Me too!👍

[@arandomuser9459]

Kaley McQuinn Hey! It’s great to understand references isn’t it?

[@kaleymcquinn7904]

KitsWorld Yep, Sure is!

[@arandomuser9459]

Kaley McQuinn It’s just satisfying!

[@arianasaavedra5191]

what happened to derrick?? I mean love tyler but derricks voice is just such an experience

[@fatthorstumtum6593]

He left

[@arandomuser9459]

Dvb holland What?? Why???

[@Deviouspinkies]

@@fatthorstumtum6593 Yes I've been hearing this but does anyone know why? I couldn't find anything anywhere. I wonder why neither party is talking about it. I guess we don't really need to know why but them at least acknowledging it would be nice.

[@pannabaranyai7228]

i can relate to J so much because I act in quizzes just like him, but man do I love when Ben beats him at any point really. it's the same feeling when Ron & Harry play chess with Hermione because that was the only thing she loses at and they think it's good for her

[@markuswilson872]

J: Sorry J fan I let you down that one person Me: I can’t believe you did that to me LOL

[@larctiquetern4407]

This was definitely the most wholesome J vs Ben! So adorable.

[@naomi_falk]

Today is the best day ever. My birthday is today, which conveniently is a Thursday, which means SCB uploads! And it's a quiz, which are my favorite kind of video! *Edit: Also Ben won the quiz!

[@cambunneh]

Happy Birthday!

[@minervasalazar3515]

Happy B day!

[@wokeupnew]

AND MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE IS BACKKKK

[@u.s.e.r.2.3.4.]

It's my birthday too

[@naomi_falk]

@@u.s.e.r.2.3.4. Happy Birthday!

[@Debatra.]

The coinflips finally start landing on Ben.

[@HailG3]

Oh my god Ben was on FIRE today!!! And I'm so happy he finally won (and by a landslide, too)!

[@kikilove9333]

That was one of the best J vs Ben ever! Loved all the extra add ons. And yes Tyler's voice is always amazing!

[@tjmuttonchops]

All other J vs bens: This one: MeMe LeVeL 9000000

[@Hashiraecos]

I love Tyler as the question asker. His dynamic with Ben & j is great

[@katsala918]

That scene in the Battle of Hogwarts actually has Dean, Luna, and Ernie Macmillan casting their patronuses, not Neville. In other news, good job Ben!

[@skunkmunkee]

This video made me feel so warm and fuzzy inside to see Ben win

[@madisonpark9935]

"The same cannot be said for Neville Longbottom, who appears to be spiritedly describing the precise manner in which Krum sustained his nosebleed for the benefit of his godson, Albus Potter." from a pottermore article about Neville being Albus's godfather. man these questions really are difficult

[@Kavon94]

PROPS TO THE EDITOR! Killer job! I loved how well this was put together! The #11 flashback was the perfect set up for J’s face!

[@JillInTheBox]

13:05 - “How long is Neville’s second-“ (Huggies Ad Plays.) Me: Welp. You heard him. How long was Neville’s second Huggie. X3

[@nmgg6928]

Tyler is doing a fantastic job hosting the quizzes. Love the content lots of fun

[@christy9868]

Oh no... I stared deep into hedwigs eyes

[@mollychankawaii]

I loved the editing in this. Nice to see all three brothers getting involved too

[@matthewarcher3024]

14/15 yay

[@matthewarcher3024]

I missed #11 lol

[@jake_hintz8470]

11/15

[@pixelraid5742]

12/13

[@kristentinney2000]

The counter slowly coming into screen at 11:32 killed me. I burst into a laugh!!

[@hallinguyen2169]

IM SO PROUD OF HIM

[@mischiefmanaged5757]

Yes! A Ben victory at last and a pretty comprehensive one at that. Congratulations. Could this be a sign of things to come?

[@SPUDog]

I'm a fan of the J-fan, but I'll celebrate the Ben-win!

[@SilviaNight99]

I love when J and Ben do a Harry Potter Quiz! Also can we give Tyler a round of applause for his delivery skills? 👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@smolglowcloud]

was... was that a mysterious ticking noise reference at 14:19?

[@jordanbalke]

I found the source of the ticking noise; it's a pipe bomb!

[@LegendOfHyrule]

Always super fun to watch these! Excellent job, Tyler, and the editing on this video is awesome. :D

[@RedEveTillDawn]

I feel like if Ben loses a point he doesn’t care but if J loses a point he throws a tantrum

[@arandomuser9459]

Rose J is great and I feel bad for saying this is true but it kinda is.

[@DeeSnow97]

Because Ben is kinda accustomed to losing points at this point

[@RageshreeChatterjee17]

Ravenclaw v/s Slytherin

[@thebandit0256]

I wonder how J, Tyler and Ben's mother raised them

[@kamilakocourkova]

He is probably very competitive.

[@nicoleb581]

8:17 that is a Fantastic line reading, Tyler! Maybe even better than what Derrick would've done. New favorite quiz master here.

[@gen4john660]

I think neville not having a patronus is a disservice to his growth. Especially when he had so much to be happy about by the battle of Hogwarts. I mean he stayed at Hogwarts for a year to protect the younger students and continue DA training then he finds out it wasn't all a waste. He should have had a patronus and it should have been a *carnivorous plant*

[@gracieliz95]

As a middle child and a Neville fan, I thoroughly enjoyed this.

[@doodoo3013]

I personally rly like Tyler and the editing of the video!

[@nicoleb581]

Also, whoever edited this, I specifically love your work from 12:47-11:13 well done!

[@jaredbennett7677]

Yay for Ben! Not anti-J, but Ben deserves a win from time to time at least!

[@levid888]

The reactions are killing me! 😂😂. Tyler, great job on those pronunciations. And the number 11 callback was hilarious.

[@kylajuan]

"J fan" really got me good😂😂

[@sabrinamassastein]

Kudos to whoever does the graphics. They're looking really great lately!

[@angeladavidson2350]

13:18 I screamed so loud 😂😂😂 This is Ben's game!!

[@natashamariano2790]

So cool!! I thought I had seen all of their quizzes but this one that randomly popped up for me was totally new!! Highlight of my day ☺️☺️☺️

[@sarailopez3331]

Yay!! Go Ben, Master of Neville Knowledge! 🥳

[@coolguyhino92]

3:28 I'm DEAD!!! Imagining Richard Harris laughing *EXACTLY* like Ben did is the highlight of my day.

[@keriiluv]

I feel like Ben today. I know a lot of random Neville trivia

[@artemisia3138]

Congratulations Ben!!!! I always root for you on these quizzes!!

[@arielsteinsaltz1956]

Only 11/15... not up to par for me... but I'm proud I got the Cursed Child one wrong.

[@SweetSlytherinGirl-Jennifer]

I love you guys. I seriously needed those laughs today. Congratulations Ben! Awesome job Ty! You rock J!