What If Leafy Won Dream Island? And Other BFDI Alternate Scenarios

What if Leafy won Dream Island instead of Firey? What if Loser hadn't been eliminated in BFB 7? And what if the cast had been different in postsplit BFB and TPOT? Find out what I think may happen in these scenarios in this video!
-----------------------------------
Music is credited in the video alongside the first five seconds of each song.

[@eda78733]

Tbh, before I got back into the osc in 2020, I actually thought leafy won 💀💀💀💀💀

[@Luminous-722]

Before I got back into it I thought Taco was inside of Box

[@Buglesosc]

@@Luminous-722what

[@thatgumnutguy1781]

@@Buglesosc some weird old Inanimate Insanity theory

[@EpickGamer6920]

⁠When I first watched BFDI on the 1st day of 5th Grade in 2020 with my friend, I thought that Bubble would win

[@Buglesosc]

@@EpickGamer6920 🗿☠️💀

[@PoyoPowerPlant]

I actually theorized that either Leafy or Bubble was supposed to win Dream Island in the finale. They each had reasons to prohibit each other from entering Dream Island over each other, instead of Firey's strung-up reasoning for banning Leafy that they had to go with in the rare possibility that he would win.

[@CupOfMug]

I think the "final 24" would honestly be better than final 14

[@A150butlime]

Agreed

[@oilisfun6891]

mhm

[@cubefromblender]

3 teams of 8

[@MetaOSC]

I feel like black hole would’ve stayed in Four’s show as he probably wouldn’t see value in limitless power since he already the most op contestant

[@RamBoiLol]

“Well Firey, you almost killed me with your invention, and I dont really appreciate that.” “What? Thats rediculous leaf”

[@Hie-ya]

I have some suggestions: What if Loser wasnt popular What if Clock didnt know who was Winner What if Flower was eliminated instead of Taco in BFB 22 What if TPOT didnt had double eliminations What if the Post-Split teams werent color coded What if Spongy and Loser never escaped the EXIT What if there was no team switching in BFDIA Ok i dont any ideas hope you pick one of them if this turns into a series

[@Michul3]

The no switching already exists

[@NiteroiFEC]

If flower was eliminated in bfb 22 was made by “giantsnowball”

[@Hie-ya]

I know some creators also made some of the suggestions i just want to see SuperFunTime's version

[@raphaelhamel5410]

@@Michul3 he said if NO TEAM SWITCHING

[@Michul3]

@@raphaelhamel5410 yeah i know

[@PBJellyBoi]

FINALLY someone did that alternate split timeline! Imo that should’ve been how it was from the start

[@The22ndMoonOfJupiter]

This is actually a simple yet weird one *What if Match got a Red Ball instead of a Maroon Ball*

[@thecringeofficer]

i mean even the small things could be massive

[@jaxonplayz4403]

What if lollipop got the safe totem in bfb 25?

[@cubefromblender]

​@@jaxonplayz4403Woody would still be out and timeline plays out as normal

[@CarsonsPlushiePalooza]

If Eggy Was Eliminated Instead Of Loser, APOY would Have A Stroke

[@Inanimation-BFBR]

DUDE, NOBODY BUT SPONGY WOULD ESCAPE THE EXIT, Loser and spongy could, if eggy can't, NOBODY CAN! Well except spongy.

[@GiantSnowball]

This is a really good BFDI scenario!

[@SuperFunTime284]

Erm actually there's three 🤓☝️ Jokes aside thanks

[@GiantSnowball]

@@SuperFunTime284 I actually hated the other two 🤓 jk

[@RexForEZ]

🤯

[@theganonmastermindcrapprod1798]

For the “What if Eggy had been eliminated instead of Loser?” Scenario, It could impact some things in TPOT when you take it’s second episode into account. First of all, Teardrop would still join and have that conflict with Death P.A.C.T. Again, causing Black Hole to accidentally suck her up, and without Eggy there to recover TD, She would pretty much have the same fate as she did as Profily in BFB 26, which means let’s just say for now, she would be automatically eliminated at the end of the episode, and second-to-last, which is Are You Okay, would be Up For Elimination instead, since Golf Ball had that strategy with only 1 Block, and Liy would be Smart enough to stack more than 1 Block before Time is up. As for Are You Okay’s Elimination in TPOT 3, TV would be Eliminated, as he’s the Least Popular and didn’t have that Arc in TPOT 5 yet. Not sure what would happen afterwards, But the rest of the events of TPOT 3 would probably play out the same, even with 1 Less Contestant, including Two introducing the “Two Teams UFE” Format, and The S and Team8s would still be Up For Elimination, even without Eraser not chasing TD and accidentally zapping Team8s’ Restaurant. Also keep in minds, that both Teardrop and TV’s Absence’s COULD impact the events of TPOT 5 Big Time, because they’re no longer in the Game in this Timeline. Anyway, I do have several interesting What If Alternate Universe Theories and it would be cool if you did them: What if Leafy picked Woody to be on her team instead of Rocky in BFDI 1b? What if Firey rejected Coiny from Dream Island instead of Leafy in BFDI 25? What if Firey was a Host, TV was a Contestant, and you couldn’t switch teams in BFDIA? What if Pencil picked Teardrop to be in the Squishy Cherries instead of Snowball in BFDI 10? What if Blocky and Teardrop were the Team Captains in BFDI, how would the Teams be Different? What if Yellow Face, TV, Donut, Black Hole, Cake, Puffball, Pie, Fries, Cloudy, and Clock switched back to BFB when they found out that Four brought back the BFDI? Meaning if they switched back when they were only 4 Contestants left, and Four had to let them back in? How could it impact the rest of the Series and Elimination Order?

[@aleksandersz306]

Not reading the whole declaration of independence today. 💀

[@RobloxBigFan710]

@@aleksandersz306daz true

[@lankycookiesubfan]

Well everyone in tpot 9 will be doomed if this happened and i jave no idea why i read this :]

[@theganonmastermindcrapprod1798]

@@lankycookiesubfan Actually, Teardrop was the one that caused the Apocalypse in 9 when she got into Barf Bag in 8, causing BB to feel uncomfortable, and put TPOT 9’s Events into Motion, but since Teardrop isn’t here to get inside Barf Bag, TPOT 9 would play out completely different.

[@theunderatedclan584]

I ain't reading allat 😂🤦

[@tabletgenesis3439]

0:12 This image gives me a strange deja-vu. That I don't even know what it is.

[@TheRanimator]

These are the OG voting screen icons. You were top, why not?

[@constantin9220]

Pin this comment: Due to Leafy's presence, Puffball didnt join BFDIA. (its a joke)

[@jencarlos.777]

also you said evil leafys map its leafys map you made a error

[@DeffoNotWoozy]

I got One! “What if Tpot had TRIPLE Eliminations?”

[@jonahwilliams2103]

From the new bfb cast in my theory the top 5 would be flower, gelatin, lolipop, but instead of leafy and teardrop I think it would be tree, and fanny

[@fs2t21linkaiwingp3]

yup metoo

[@KadenzJade6447]

These are fun scenarios honestly (I really wish postBFB had more newbies)

[@gallicadlair81]

Disturbing fact: When the contestants were switching between shows in BFB 16, Balloony immediately switched to TPOT and Cloudy didn’t during the first switch. During the last two switches, Cloudy switched to TPOT immediately as Balloony switched back to BFB. Seems like they aren’t good friends anymore, huh?

[@metal_pipe9764]

Not sure how that's disturbing but ok

[@mfsstudios107]

that's not what disturbing means

[@Squirtle_Squad_Supremacy]

A cloud and a balloon both had different preferences, how disturbing

[@gallicadlair81]

@@metal_pipe9764 Balloony and Cloudy are best friends, so it’s expected that they’d be in the same show.

[@redplanetproductions7785]

Not as disturbing as it is odd.

[@Ladleladleosc]

Could you do Bfdi but Golf ball is the first boot?

[@thekellanator2642]

That would be interesting because there was obviously bias towards keeping the squashy grapes safe, and they only got up once before splitting into 3 teams. So flower would make it fairly far.

[@lcajueiro]

10:40 WHY DID YOU USE THAT IMAGE FOR FOLDY YOU COULD’VE USED ANY IMAGE AND YOU USE THAT ONE

[@YoshiForevz]

Wait in a BFB my way I made a team called Have Pots! :0

[@pac-green6030]

What if Bubble won Dream Island? I believe she would let everyone in except Flower and Blocky.

[@cooperc69420]

I would argue Snowball as well. He was also a really mean character and has also intentionally popped Bubble before.

[@TyZerker]

Actually on one would have expected because looser was the reason he expected

[@pretzelproductions]

4:13 wait until APOY hears this

[@Ichigo_the2nd]

If leafy won, I think that Firey would've made Leafy angry, but leafy would forgive fiery, or because Leafy is really sensitive, she would be mad at Firey. Or Leafy would still care about Firey, and they would both be hated.

[@Haniplayz14]

I got a scenario that was shown in the last one but was never solved : what if loser joined tpot insted of staying in bfb? Questions about it 1: what would loder and winner do 2: what team would loser be on/ solved in vid

[@PalestineandBFDI]

Leafy Should win BFDI

[@RA_0645]

What if Snowball got eliminated instead of Match NEEDS TO HAPPEN

[@VectorJW9260]

I mean, good thing we finally have names for a set of 4 TPOT teams!

[@SixtyStone]

My theory is that Evil Leafy got mad that leafy wasnt allowed into Dream Island and that's why Evil Leafy started to attack and be aggressive agianst the contestants.

[@MasterStartist5]

This Is A Great Video But For The First Scenario I Feel Like Leafy Would Want To Be On Pins Team Due To Their Alliance And Also Feeling Bad They Have Less Members

[@NailaBesni]

Fr

[@Giraffeboi392]

Liy we might be on death pact again because she was part of the original death pact if she gets over all the other teammates, just didn’t prevent death instead of marker or lightning which I feel like both of them they really wouldn’t have any reason to prevent death just because they think it’s a nice thing. One of them would have to go, but who would it be? Maybe both well who knows I mean bottles just wanted to prevent death because it was a nice thing and has never killed someone and the other people like black hole and, someone else I forgot I think it might’ve been the whole team and of course pillow was just for killing, but who knows I haven’t like a whole essay 6:37

[@JimmyJoshBuster]

For the last prediction of TPOT with the teams, didn’t teardrop have her own team as a result of joining late in TPOT 2?

[@rekanimations4628]

One thing i don’t understand in the leafy winning theory is who would buy dream island if leafy let everyone in?

[@julieorchard5361]

Imma make a suggestion: All of BFB & TPOT but the last place and first place teams lose.

[@tailsdollplays]

what if loser joined TPOT ? what if no one switched to TPOT ? and what if there was a split in 3 shows (BFB, TPOT, and another show for the announcer)?

[@xogleeztastexd583]

If Eggy had been eliminated instead of loser APOY will go through 4 stages of greif in

[@SCP-173-CER]

You should do more alternate scenarios Ideas: What if Bubble won Dream Island What if Fanny was eliminated instead of Pencil What if Golf Ball was eliminated instead of 8-Ball What if Bomby debuted instead of David What if Loser rejoins instead of Leafy What if Lollipop was eliminated instead of Dora What if Firey allowed Leafy on to dream island and didn't allow Coiny on to dream island What if Gelatin was eliminated instead of Bracelety What if Pie was eliminated instead of Liy What if Naily was eliminated instead of Firey Jr What if Donut was eliminated instead of Spongy What if Rocky was eliminated instead of David

[@AliTheCoolDude]

He said it wouldn’t change anything for if bubble won dream island

[@BlueGray202]

Tpot name ideas: Team 1: Not A Accident (golf ball names it on accident) Team 2: The STRONG Bunch (Coiny would name it, but Snowball would yell “STRONG” over W.O.A.H) Team 3: BTTBBWWG (Would be named last, and 2 would name it) Team 4: BLEH (Someone would say a name but Rocky would barf them)

[@jaxonplayz4403]

Almost half of the people you listed are currently eliminated

[@tyler-w7w]

I think the grayscale team would be have lots cuzblack whole would just suck up a teams tower and the pink team the have pots cuz flower hit put in a pot for some time

[@JacksonBrittany25]

Mmmm in Tpot with 32 player spongy on team with some hated characters like flody

[@EternalZoroark]

If I could give one, Could I suggest this: What if Blocky survived over Flower BFB 24

[@deez8769]

I got another final 24 theory what if all of the exitors rejoined bfb to make the final 24

[@screwbfbc]

TEAM 4 ARE ALL ARMLESS (not including loser)

[@thatgumnutguy1781]

I have a neat one “What if 8 Ball survived BFB 8”

[@peachland5482]

The reason the greyscale team is the have pots is because cloudy kept his pot collection in the tower

[@Bodgeplays]

If you ever do a second one of please please add if pencil wasn't up for elimination in BFDI boxing ring episode I would like to see what happens because she definitely should not have been up for elimination

[@sheilacoleman3207]

Bottle wouldn't join bfb cuz she said "id totally ditch you"

[@jaxonplayz4403]

“Given the choice,I’d totally ditch you!” -Bottle, BFB 16

[@blackshark3]

It’s He Not She! Firey is not a Girl! He Sounds like a Boy!

[@emefafrank]

I wish Jacknjellify did what Total Drama did and had a alternate ending

[@Monopurp]

10:11 grassy would probably want to be another team’s name, where golf would barge in to say the need a another team name, and tennis ball’s still there to say “are you okay?” So they’d still be are you okay. 10:23 this team consists of funny doers and WOAH bunch, so maybe woah bunch’s funny doings? 10:33 I think this team would still be a big ol’ gabber, this time because they’re arguing over a team name. 10:42 you said it yourself, the leftovers.

[@gyuvingaming8459]

8:26 WHY has black hole flipped 90degrees

[@SM_G8]

Idea, what if bubble cheated instead of stapy in bfb 8

[@he_d0es]

I got a what if: "what if a better name than that and bleh stayed on the moon and could no longer compete"(basically what if a better name than that and bleh were no longer in bfb after bfb 7-9)

[@vernkreutz2078]

hmm would the split happen if 2 came when 4 got penagatid into the desert?

[@lavaboyoh1893]

I have one: what if everyone escaped the EXIT instead of just Loser and Spongy in BFB 16?

[@Jackmoo101]

no way bfdi if the winner was the worst character.

[@pomona_pomitos]

what if lollipop was eliminated instead of dora?

[@skulkyquartz8775]

3:55 I disagree I think bubble would’ve also not allowed flower and blocky from entering Dream island, and that decision would make so much more drama then the original.

[@Red_block979]

Ummmmm. She would be angry at the host

[@Spherius]

Who

[@ThePkmnNerd]

I thought bfb no split was supposed to come out today

[@Latam_C.B_Canal_Secundario]

Id doubt marker wouldget eliminated

[@sage.s]

6:51 NO WAY MY FAVORITE CHARACTER JOINS MY FAVORITE TEAM

[@DemonEyeFDK]

this is a very good vid, and i pondered what would happen if leafy/bubble won, i have different ideas. I think it was planned / wanted for there to be a conflict between two characters, and I think it would go like this: Firey win and mad ay leafy, leafy win and mad at firey/bubble(grudge of lava shower and for bubble not wanting leafy to help her out) it is one or the other though. And Bubble win Bubble Mad at leafy. its wierd but might work.

[@blackshark3]

Winner Winner 😌😐😕🙁😨😱 Chicken Dinner?!

[@cherrysodap]

for bfdia in the first scenerio i think that leafy would proabbly also switch to WOAH bunch along with vcoiny and pin

[@melissaclements4563]

I think marker and gelatin will make the merge

[@moonlights_tt]

LSB EXISTS?????? epo aex fa yk e r

[@starshadicgaming255]

This is a wonderful video

[@Objectsandloresforever]

I Don't Think Td And Woody Would be on the Same Team on tpot I think Pric tag would replace woody or Td

[@denzelhugodragono5371]

Yelllow face is eliminated!!!!!! Woooo!!!!!!

[@xyiux]

I think all the death pact members would join tpot because of 4 and his murders and maybe for the 4 leftover spots add barf bag rocky loser and balloony and maybe fanny because she might get mad about the bfdi getting lost

[@Spikeball2000]

Me and my friend had a theory that leafy was supposed to win as when you think it make more sense (specially when you release leafy is more like able) and firey was supposed to steal dream island. (I think this is what the creator of bfdi intended).

[@MadChristoph]

One thing I wish BFDI did like TDI was that they had alternate endings, in TDI while Owen won canonically, there was an alternate ending where Gwen won

[@Rushro61]

Leafy and furry made a dream islnd

[@drhabit]

what if nonexisty was kept in tpot and price tag never debuted?

[@VasaTheFanmadeClassFan]

Leafy Would Become Topper Guild If She Won BFDI

[@TheBoringD]

I know this will not change much but What if David Survived BFB 10 instead of Rocky

[@kiwile6651]

2h

[@simarsfun2524]

As leafy being my favorite character, this is a W

[@NailaBesni]

Same i love leafy

[@Breccann]

why is it slowed down

[@Joannasunshinegirl]

I wonder what would happen if Ruby survived over Gelatin?

[@CrazyCupcakeOSC]

W vid!!!

[@SussyMarioBros.]

Winner winner chicken dinner!

[@CHEESEGOATS_OFFICAL]

If leafy did win BFDI there would probably not be a BFDI again

[@MadChristoph]

Possibly another Dream Island out there where BFDIA would still exist, but it's a different dream island

[@therealseam]

what if tacoooo wonnnnn

[@DeffoNotWoozy]

Could you do BFDI But 2 Hosted The season?

[@gyuvingaming8459]

9:48 foldy bro 😩

[@espurrman55real]

we should have alternate endings for gelatin and leafy

[@5-27thebest3]

I feel like nickel would have like a 7% percent chance of winning

[@sk5wv]

This aged well I would like to see the teapot thing again

[@DandysWorld-000]

Amazing

[@DanKroast]

NPC

[@jrjdnrdusj]

First

[@semvermeulen7039]

Such a cool idea

[@AaronAcademyOfficial]

BFLI

[@steveimator_m2]

Interesting scenarios!

[@Cam_boom]

Interesting senario

[@Sticky_note_and_friendsy15]

Okay no well why not the exitors join bfb