Superman IV: The Quest for Peace. Not So Super. Not Remotely Duper.

#superman #dc
Stam Fine Reviews looks at the 1987 film Superman IV: The Quest for Peace.
Starring Christopher Reeve, Gene Hackman, Mariel Hemingway, and Margot Kidder; Superman IV is, in a word, yikes!
The film series' original producers offloaded the film rights to Cannon who made what turned out to be the last movie to star Reeve, who in turn wanted a specific storyline in order to appear as the Man of Steel. Budget cuts turned this into a, well, have a look.

[@mrjefe8927]

Went to see it with friends in the theater, so would have been 13 or 14. It started off with an ominous scene on a playground with a plane flying over. Then it cut off, and we had to change theaters as they had the labels switched between Superman and La Bamba. Even at that age we realized pretty quickly we should have stayed.

[@williamjackson6705]

Reeve gave it his all. He took this film seriously despite that massive budget cuts & tried to make it work. When I finally saw it on VHS back in the day, I was embarrassed for him. He deserved so much better.

[@johnbockelie3899]

How did Reeve keep a strait face during this movie being made?.

[@bk14nyc]

Simply HORRIBLE 😢

[@mrmeerkat1096]

Pure greed of Golem and Globus taking half of the 34 million budget they were GIVEN by Warner bros to make the film and spending it on another one of there movies (He man) just so they could make more of a profit. Completely cheated the fans and Christopher Reeve. I'm glad Cannon went bankrupt and they lost everything hopefully.

[@painkiller1968]

No he didn't. He didn't work out for shit. Was way too skinny and lanky.

[@Stansman63]

I remember seeing this on the shelf in my local video store back in the late 80's, after greatly enjoying the first two movies I was excited to see it particularly since Gene Hackman was back as Lex Luthor..that excitement had completely vanished by about 15 minutes into the movie..

[@richmanz447]

I can't stop laughing reading this......

[@Faction.Paradox]

Aunty Beryl's exploits are so proflic at this point she needs her own biography.

[@boomzer10]

They used that ending shot in all the Christopher Reeve "Superman" movies. It was more of a tradition not an insult to injury.

[@raoularmagnac2037]

This movie makes part 3 look like a masterpiece by comparison.

[@jw4499]

I remember watching this at the cinema and some children crying their way through it

[@Althea-M]

Just like the Transformers movie. The 80s were hard on children at the movies

[@neesi1570]

You're a tiny bit nicer to this than everybody else who covers it, so kudos for being different. I also kind of liked Gene Hackman's and Jon Cryer's chemistry. Too bad they never teamed up in anything else. The comics adaptation (which sticks closer to the original concept and doesn't have to worry about having its budget slashed) is actually a good sight better. Superman IV was probably never going to be a "good" movie, but it didn't have to be the disaster it was.

[@SuperMarioBrosIII]

@Denise Bluth🦸🦸‍♂🦸‍♀🧐

[@pitiedvod]

I actually saw this on opening day at the cinema. Oh the innocence of youth so savagely destroyed.

[@HMcQ7891]

Superman's roofie lips aka "The Ol' Kryptonian Knockout". Reeve only agreed to star in _QFP_ to fund _Street Smart_ - a genuinely great film that gave longtime TV actor Morgan Freeman his big break in '87.

[@Yxalitis]

25,000 subs, great to see that number -slowly- but surely rising. Always enjoy your stuff...

[@StamFine]

Thank you very much!

[@Minty0091]

I like all the Superman movies and think Nuclear Man is a stand in for Bizarro.

[@DenkyManner]

Any time a non-comedy movie is 90 minutes you know there was major panic in the editing room. Sometimes it turns out ok, like with First Blood. Sometimes it turns out like Superman IV.

[@ricardocantoral7672]

That applies to major films made during the 1970's onward. In the height of the studio system era, it wasn't unusual.

[@TheNameisPlissken1981]

Absolutely! Always look at the running time!

[@6581punk]

I wish I'd known this was filmed in Milton Keynes when I worked there for 3 months. Probably been into the shopping mall this was filmed in. The grid layout of the town was trying to replicate US cities and the traffic there flowed pretty well.

[@paulsavage9977]

I live in Milton Keynes and know locations of some of the scenes (Central Milton Keynes train station for example). Milton Keynes was, and still is, good for ground level and interior scenes. It does fail with the fact that the buildings in Milton Keynes were low level (at the time there was a hight restriction on buildings). There were no skyscrapers, something that Metropolis is know for. It shows in some scenes with Superman flying off or landing. You see too much sky.

[@tomciura8360]

I always loved to watch this movie especially with Clark Kent in the movie!

[@rebeccathumb9584]

THANK YOU for uploading at such an hour

[@GilgaFrank]

I saw this at the cinema. What a wild night out that wasn't.

[@brianmccarthy8541]

Stam Fine, another Friday treat, you spoil us😀 Milton Keynes and Argos, brilliant

[@thechrisandmikeshow]

The film that makes Superman III look like a cinematic masterpiece.

[@tristandunn4628]

The Salkinds totally mismanaged the whole franchise. Not letting Richard Donner finish Superman II was the first mistake. Richard Lester made that a lot cheesier that it should have been. Donner's work saved that from being the dreadful mess that a 100% Richard Lester mess is (see Superman III). Getting rid of the whole franchise for part IV was an opportunity to reverse that. However, totally the wrong company got hold of it and just kept hammering the nails into the coffin. Learning how this whole project was doomed before it started is tragic. Christopher Reeve was totally screwed over with this. It's interesting how TV shows (Lois & Clark, Smallville and Superman & Lois) can get it right, yet the movie industry seems to find it so hard.

[@RoaryUK]

The Donner cut of Superman 2 is awful for the most part, what Lester did with it was campy in places, but what some conveniently forget is that Donner had plenty of campy stuff in his version too. Some changes Lester did really made a difference too, like replacing Brando with York that makes far more sense to Supermans return, which was ridiculous in the Donner cut, while the ending to that version was just as bad for a number of reasons.

[@robertridley-fj8zz]

Superman outside Argos HQ, ridiculous! What next, the Avengers hanging out at the Sainsbury Centre for the Visual Arts? I look forward in anticipation to my complementary "Stam Fine Stealth Like to Raise Engagement". Or maybe just this one time a genuine Stam Fine like?

[@lancebaylis3169]

Its heart is in the right place, conceptually. Reeve hated the comedy of parts 2 and 3 and only agreed to coming back for a 4th on the proviso he could use it as a platform for a very serious issue he wanted to address, the arms race and nuclear disarmament. Unfortunately the productiom was a nightmare and the budget was tiny, so it suffered the same fate as dozens of sequels and killed the franchise.

[@mem1701movies]

The worst part for me was when that Sun guy had that woman halfway to the moon and she didn’t die. Then screamed as she fell back to the earth...from space.

[@oobrocks]

It appears this film was made for 99 cents; unbelievable 😢

[@dhenderson1810]

Reeve only came back for a big cheque, approval of the storyline idea, and Cannon had to make a movie he was working on, called "Street Smart".

[@ricardocantoral7672]

The money was appealing but he mostly did it because of the creative control. There's no way he would have returned just for the former because he wanted to put Superman behind him.

[@chiefscheider]

Street Smart is one of my favorite movies. Reeve is very good in it and Morgan Freeman is genuinely scary.

[@masere]

I love the soundtrack to this film. Certain scenes with Superman have great music, of course the classic Williams theme but also Nuclear Man's theme.

[@markelijio6012]

Alexander Courage was the film's musical director and conductor who adapted this score and did a good job.

[@SuperMarioBrosIII]

@@markelijio6012 La La Land Records released a two-disc of the Soundtrack which is fantastic!🤗🦸‍♀🌆💽

[@raybearoz]

Keep up the good work... So Superman Returns next???

[@johnbockelie3899]

Superman 4 went the way of the phone booth. Just rode the coat tails of Superman the movie ( 1978)

[@waltersimmons946]

Regardless of the film 🎥 Christopher Reeve was and is still 👉 SUPERMAN 🦸‍♀️

[@Cmdr1962]

Never made it through. Thanks for saving me the trip. I'll just keep watching the first two.

[@TheBeird]

The more I learned about the behind the scenes turmoil of this flick, the more lenient I am toward it. It’s still bad, but it wasn’t through fault of trying

[@thevfxmancolorizationvfxex4051]

Honestly, I think there was still a good film hidden within Superman 4. With some VFX updates and extra cutting, it could actually turn out to be quite decent

[@billg3356]

There's a guy called APRICEPRODUCTION who's done some pretty amazing work sprucing up Superman IV's dodgy FX. Take a look at his channel.

[@dhenderson1810]

This needs a special edition and use better CGI to fix the movie.

[@arcadeassassin7176]

​@@dhenderson1810 I think I'd also fix the pacing and maybe add in bizarro instead of nuclear man. That way instead of taking Lacy into space for no reason he could be taking her to Bizarro World and the third act would take place there. Then we could tie it into the themes of the movie by having Superman discover that the people of Bizarro World are not evil just misunderstood and teach Bizarro how to lead them in a more peaceful direction.

[@dhenderson1810]

@@arcadeassassin7176 I think the Bizarro world idea would have been great. But it wouldn't have happened because were making this on the cheap. Cannon were notorious for buying franchise movies and spending little on the budget, They spread the equivalent of one movie's budget, and spread it across three films ("Superman IV", "Masters Of The Universe", and a Jean-Claude Van Damme movie called "Cyborg", with the majority of the budget going to MOTU). They did this to make maximum profits off tent pole movies and stars, without too much outlay. Of course all three movies flopped, and Cannon folded as a result. So I can't see Cannon spending more money to build a Bizarro World set.

[@jamesstewart7736]

This film reminds me of my first date when I was 13/14 years old. I still remember her name and how excited I was to actually have a date. We didn't have a second date. The film didn't help. I didn't hate it though. 🤣

[@mathewguglielmi8451]

It's a real shame about Superman IV:The Quest for Peace. A storyline with good intentions but was poorly executed and made on the cheap. It really took the gloss off the 50th anniversary of Superman.

[@ricardocantoral7672]

Even with a good budget, the film probably would have sucked anyway.

[@Dohsoda]

@@ricardocantoral7672 I think a bigger budget would have made the presentation more bearable.

[@ricardocantoral7672]

@@Dohsoda I know but the film would still be dumb as hell.

[@TheOther644]

I liked this movie and love Nuclear Man. It's a shame what Cannon Group did to this movie, they cut money, scenes, the script, locations, VFX and just ruined what should have been a classic. Though still better then Superman 3, it should have been a classic and make up for the train wreck of 3 but instead added to it.

[@diverguy3556]

I could never bring myself to watch this one, and this review has justified my decision. Good review, though, as always.

[@Thunderpuddle]

This was the only superman film I had on VHS after my TV recorded copies of the first 3 went out with the Betamax they were recorded with. I always felt that this needs a reedit and a Kingdom Come style story could be hashed out.

[@TheInfinitySystem]

Hey! Don't trash on my man Gopher!

[@YeoYeo32]

In other words, Superman IV was the Batman and Robin of the Superman franchise

[@orangie8426]

Whaa..??? I loved this movie.. God...

[@rdmsh]

Strangely I remember so much of this as a teen and didn’t care

[@kosh6612]

You nailed it. After the huge disappointment when this film was released and a lot of time passed, this film has become a guilty pleasure only because my expectations are so low going into it. It somehow makes the film more enjoyable. Hackman as Lex Luther is also fun to watch no matter how bad the film is. It's easy to see some of the interesting story elements had huge potential, but just failed to come together in typical Cannon fashion. But then, MANY Cannon films are a guilty pleasure for me, so what do I know

[@chriswilkinson7636]

With a big enough budget and better writers it could have been a good film. Nuclear man had potential to be a formidable enemy for Superman.

[@FatNorthernBigot]

I've not seen this movie, but I hope Superman found some peas.

[@masere]

Or piss.

[@Shindai]

Gotta feel bad for *checks imdb* MARK PILLOW?!? for his first movie being this. Too bad he was only in a few things before calling it quits with movies.

[@russellharrell2747]

I think this movie encapsulates the goofiness and charm of the silver age comics (especially Jerk Superman) and with the full budget and better effects could have been a good entry into the franchise, reviving it for at least one more movie. But oh well.

[@mrmeerkat1096]

Im really happy that cannon films went bankrupt and Golem and Globus the owners lost everything possibly. Because they really cheated the fans by taking half of the movies 34 million dollar budget which they were GIVEN by Warner bros to make superman 4 and spent it on another film they were making at the same time (masters of the universe), just so they could make more of a profit. So this film only had 17 million spent on it instead of the full budget. I think if it had the full amount of 34 million spent on getting the best writers, best FX teams, real locations ect, it could have been one of the best because of Christopher Reeves enthusiasm for the project because they promised him he could have some creative input into the film. But pure greed of those two cousins cheated the cast and the fans.

[@TheOther644]

Agree. 17 million back then could have been enough, but Cannon Group not only cut the budget they cut scenes, the script, the FX and locations. If they kept the budget as is and didn't cut all the stuff they did the movie could have been epic. Other then Reeve, the only good thing that came out of it was Mark Pillows Nuclear Man. I mean it would have been awesome to see Bizarro, but they couldn't get the rights so we got one of my favs in Nuclear Man instead.

[@HangoverTelevision]

Nuclear Man could also have been Dieter Bohlen.... or Matthias Reim. XD

[@dhenderson1810]

It is a bad movie when "Superman III" is compared favourably by comparison.

[@jondellar]

Thank you, thank you, thank you, for shaming that maddeningly thick mispronunciation of “nuclear”. 🎉🎉

[@chiefscheider]

Superman IV: The Quest for Quality

[@SuperMarioBrosIII]

@Chief Scheider your quest has been granted here kzbin.info/www/bejne/bHO4inipopuCbK8

[@edcampion3998]

Always fascinated me the making of this film I think it would make a great documentary.

[@beatrixwickson8477]

I think this film is at its best treated as a generous DVD extra. The shitty effects took me out pretty badly but I'd be on board for a special edition.

[@alanfinch8763]

Went to see this at the Cinema when I was a kid, accidently went into the wrong movie and ended up watching Fievel Goes West lol

[@filmdirt]

I too was kind to a point when I reviewed this on my channel. Good review of a flawed film!

[@TheDukeofMadness]

It had a noble idea of nuclear disarmament but it was executed (the operative word) terribly.

[@BruceWayne010]

Superman movies 1 & 2 both are timeless and more better than later Superman films Superman IV Quest for Peace is unusual film and interesting being made by Cannon films 🤔

[@HumbertTheHorse]

This movie killed my childhood. Well, a little bit.

[@retrodealer6495]

When, I was a little kid he was the first Superman I seen. Too bad the last movie when I was like that?. But It was a f****** a try right!?😃. That's gotta count for something?.

[@ivane5110]

As disappointing as IV is, a bad Chris Reeve Superman movie is still more enjoyable than a modern box office hit grim Superman. The closest (though still not the same) I've seen to capturing that Reeve's aura as Superman has been Brandon Routh reprising him for TV's Crisis on Infinite Earth's multiparter. Close enough in fact to almost make me feel like I was back the day.

[@DiverBand]

Amen!

[@christopherdavis8248]

super man 4 was an cinematic atrocity.

[@KyleRDent]

Thank you for dragging Milton Keynes' terrible design. I'm so glad the only times I ever went was via taxi.

[@stuarttacey]

Christopher Reeve looked like he didn't bother working out for IV either. He looks a lot slimmer with less muscle mass.

[@DiverBand]

Yes. He trained differently because his back was trashed from all the flying effects on a harness from the first 3 films. His back discs were messed up so his weight training had to be modified.

[@SuperMarioBrosIII]

@@DiverBand Plus I think his suit at least in the fourth fim had padding to give the illusion of muscle?🤔🤨🤷🦸

[@carlrood4457]

I was almost 20 when this movie came out and it's a poster child form why certain movies shouldn't address complicated political issues. It really should have ended when the kid's classmates laughed at him for the idea because it's a childish premise. It pretty much ignored that Superman set himself up as dictator of Earth. What happens when he decides there's another issue he can "solve"?

[@ricardocantoral7672]

Actually, I think that's an interesting scenario. Superman going too far but not being down right evil.

[@80sNewWaveGeek]

I actually enjoyed 'IV' as a kid. Even if the film was not executed well, it seemed to try to recapture the heart of the first two films that was lacking in 'III'.

[@johnbockelie3899]

Putting on a Superman suit and acting your way through a crappy movie. #4 sucked.

[@ricardocantoral7672]

The first Nuclear Man in the original cut of the film looked like Bizarro with a mixture of Lobo thrown in. Regarding the director, too bad Furie is mostly known for this turd and the Iron Eagle films. He should be better remember for directing the film that made Michael Caine a star, The Ipcress File, and an excellent kitchen sink drama called The Boys.

[@listerofsmeg884]

Oddly, this was the only sups film I saw at the cinema. Even as a 9 year old I thought it was rubbish. Looking back on it now, I guess the idea was decent enough, and the bit where he chucked the nukes into the sun was quite cool. But it was so cheap looking it's hard to take seriously. Milton Keynes trying to be metropolis FFS... Yes, it's the only town in the UK with a US style road grid system, but that's about it.

[@unchainedwiththecapt]

I'd like to see you do the Iron Eagle quadrilogy.

[@bigginsd1]

What about doing the Iron Sky quadrilogy? There were only two films but they were twice the epicness!

[@andrewblanchard2398]

GOOFY NUCLEAR MAN 1.0 was ridiculous

[@TheToonMonkey]

"Milton Keynes is not an awful town"...I mean, I'll believe a man can fly, but I'm not THAT gullible!

[@richmanz447]

The next time my kids do something wrong I am going to make them watch this movie as punishment.

[@tomsenior7405]

Cheers Stam. We caught this film on a rainy Sunday morning. I say "caught", because it felt like catching a really bad cold. Isn't Margot Kidder beautiful. Sorry, my bad: Margot Kidder isn't beautiful. The title was originally going to be "Superman Flies Down". Unfortunately, that idea had already been taken with "Biggles Flies Down", which was later changed to "Biggles Flies Open", before it was shelved. Allegedly.

[@Pocketrocket-pj1us]

You feel like insulting the true Lois Lane? Thems fighting words! Name the time and place. As long as the sun is shining ;)

[@tomsenior7405]

@@Pocketrocket-pj1us Best comment ever. Thank you. Brilliant.

[@richmanz447]

I went to see Superman IV in the theater. What a disappointment. When the scene showing superman gathering nuclear warheads in space to throw out to interstellar space came, my sister & I looked at each other and laughed out loud. So did the audience. Superman III was a burning wreck descending from the sky and Superman IV was the fiery crash ending. I feel sad that Christopher Reeve & Gene Hackman had to go out this way.

[@dtuk22]

Thats an Interesting fact that it was filmed entirely in England i didn't know that. However I'm not surprised, there is a scene shot in what is supposed to be a New York subway station. But even as kid of 12 who'd never been to NYC i could tell that it was blatantly a London underground tube station albeit with a name change.....Thats really pathetic cost cutting.

[@thevoid99]

i saw this as a kid back in the 80s as i was 7-8 years old when it arrived on HBO and it was shit. it hasn't aged well. the science, a subject i was never good at mind you, is horrendous. it looked cheap and i hated the "ban nukes" bullshit. the only thing in that film that is any good is... gene hackman. i've seen him in bad movies but he's never given a bad performance. he's one of those RARE actors that can't suck.

[@sebastiansochanski]

👌

[@crhisduarte9382]

heck when he had his accident back in 1995 he was planning on getting ready to play superman again

[@mikehunt4986]

Margot Kidder looks 20 years older than she did in the first one while Christopher Reeve looks the same. What the hell happened?

[@masere]

Kidder was a druggie

[@joemamma137]

Men age like Sean Connery, and women age like…well, Sean Connery.

[@mikehunt4986]

@@joemamma137 HA HA HA

[@whitleybayman123]

Superman The Movie is my all time favorite movie. Also the greatest comicbook movie of all time in my opinion. I remember really liking Superman 4 at the cinema. Then when it came out on VHS and you get time to really watch...........If any movie could do with a Directors Cut or special edition

[@chriswilkinson7636]

I remember enjoying Superman 4 when I saw it at the cinema, but I was only about 11😂😂😂

[@nelprana5861]

The only American guy that wears his underwear on the out side

[@SnabbKassa]

aka "Superman visits Milton Keynes bus station" because it's not Argos HQ, it's that

[@All2Meme]

Superman IV: The Quest For Cheese (co-starring Wallace and Gromit).

[@Althea-M]

Lois and Clark please. Also I believe I watched this at home but I forgot as soon as it was over. It was a huge let down as an adolescent seeing Superman suck

[@nardpuncher]

I am like you in that I saw this once and about 10 years ago so i thought it was bad....but not AS bad as everyone said especially after how bad Superman III was and I hated that at age 10

[@fortranwarrior8716]

I know it’s terrible, but it’s such an entertaining terrible. I just can’t hate this movie. It’s such a wonderfully low-budget comic book movie, I wish there were more of these. It really feels like the feature film version of the old serials.

[@SB992REBORN]

If you watch this AFTER returns and Crisis Earth episode it works!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@user-bw4lb3py4t]

In both versions of Superman 2. Superman. Destroys the Fortress. Them in 4 it's back. No sense

[@TheEqualizer-iw1bz]

Superman IV was so bad I totally forgot I ever saw the movie! And then a few years ago, I saw it again and then I remembered the scene about Superman’s hair and then realized I’ve seen the movie before.

[@BenSkyLakewood]

UN Building is in NYC.

[@MrSmith1984]

Bryan Singer has made some terrible mistakes in his life, disregarding Superman III & IV was most definitely not one of them! Certainly he had plenty of good reasons to do that.

[@damc8415]

Superman III was OK. Superman IV was awful, although the subplot about the newspaper industry was surprisingly realistic and interesting.

[@CaminoAir]

I honestly think this film is at least trying to attempt a worth while story, as opposed to the third film, which seems to be just throwing stuff at the screen. Yes, it's dispiriting......but at least it failed trying to do something. What is 'Superman III' about?

[@Mattfromthepast]

Are we supposed to hate the guy who points out that if your business hasn't made any money in three years you need to change something? He is just stating a fact everyone else in this movie is too stupid to know.

[@andrewblanchard2398]

👍👍

[@BanthaPooDoo64]

After seeing the first 3 films l was excited to see 4 but not seeing Lex Luther again l want something new Lex had his time in the first 2 films ,the 3 rd film was ok but a lot of slapstick and the 4 one was worse l heard found out many many yrs later they split the budget for two films 2nd one being Heman which was way better story and effects. The forth film could’ve been epic like Tim Burton’s BATMAN in 1989,can u blame Chris not wanting to do another film after Burton’s BATMAN film. And in the late 90’s we lost Burton’s version of SUPERMAN which l be leave would’ve been epic as well ,BUT WE’LL NEVER REALLY KNOW WILL WE

[@garybryant1501]

Started as major blockbuster movies and ended with that tv movie look and budget Planet Of The Apes and Superman it's just the classic franchise losing steam syndrome

[@frankandstein8618]

Yes, it's a $hitty film, but still way better than the Snyder Superman.

[@ricardocantoral7672]

Hmmm, they are both really cringe. I guess Part 4 is better because Superman is actually Superman.

[@dhenderson1810]

@@ricardocantoral7672 Reeve leaves Cavill in the dust.

[@ricardocantoral7672]

@@dhenderson1810 I thought Cavill did a good job in those few moments when he wasn't portraying Superman as a blight on humanity.

[@dhenderson1810]

@@ricardocantoral7672 He had too few expressions. Often he would be standing around, looking and brooding. I'm not questioning Cavill as an actor. In fact, I would love to see him as the next James Bond. Firstly, because he could carry off the role, and secondly, WB could scrap the DCEU and focus on superhero movies that DO make them big money (Dark Knight trilogy, Joker, The Batman).

[@ricardocantoral7672]

@@dhenderson1810 Reeve wasn't that expressive either but he had a great presence. Cavill does too and the brooding is definitely the fault of the script. I think he could have easily fit in Donner's films. As for Cavill as Bond, he would be a good candidate but he's getting up there in years. If they pick him, he would probably be done by his third film. They really should have retired Craig after Skyfall.

[@crhisduarte9382]

dude he kept returning because he knew fans would want it to be him,

[@ronleight9341]

I just pretend 3 and 4 don't exist!

[@The.Last.Guitar.Hero.]

trust me when I say Milton Keynes is a toilet

[@shaggycan]

12:00 there were only two things wrong with the Routh film; the plot of the movie (it was too small, too pedestrian) and the casting of Lois (too young).

[@dhenderson1810]

Having Superman abandoning Lois for years and was a deadbeat dad.

[@ricardocantoral7672]

Routh himself was also a problem. He was an unimpressive figure. The only really good thing about the film was Kevin Spacey's wonderful take on Lex Luthor. Too bad his performance was wasted in Returns.