Sustenance is Responsibility of Allah? | رزق اللہ کے ذمہ ہے؟ | Javed Ahmad Ghamidi

Keep watching-subscribe today: / @ghamidireels
Note: A true student engages in critical analysis, guided by the merits of constructive criticism. Unfortunately, Javed Ahmad Ghamidi Sahib often falls victim to the opposite approach, where people unconsciously criticize conclusions without first understanding the reasoning behind them. If you wish to form an opinion or disagree, please do so after thoroughly understanding the argument, from its principles to its application. This reflects a positive and constructive attitude.
Ghamidi's REELS is a channel run by volunteers to engage the good message to public as much as possible. For any kind of inquiries do contact us on Instagram @GhamidiREELS! Special thanks to @GhamidiCIL

[@rollingroles]

آج اس سائینس کی سمجھ آئی، اب تک کہانیاں ھی سنتے آئے.. شکریہ جناب وہم سے نکالنے کا.. جزاک اللہ

[@عرفانرمضان-ث3غ]

کیا جواب دیا ہے معاملہ اور زیادہ خراب کردیا ہے

[@Hashimahmed4753]

​@@عرفانرمضان-ث3غ Kaise bigda ?

[@drasia6376]

Very well explained

[@mohammadharisfahim6614]

چبھتے ہوئے سوال جو بندوں کو اللّٰہ سے متنفر کر دیتے ہیں، ان سوالوں کا اسان ترین جواب غامدی صاحب کی نشانی ہے۔

[@buttaurangzeb7221]

Javed ghamidi just love it Allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti dey all time great for me I don't think any another better prayer than this prayer Allah qabool farmaye aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤️ ♥️

[@Zakielectric]

اللہ تعالی جیسے خالق ہے اسطرح رازق ہے مگر عزت زلت اسکے ہاتھ ہے

[@zohraimam6597]

ماشاء اللّٰہ ! Well Explained

[@pindigheb100]

Correct explanation mashaAllah

[@syeddanish81]

Bohat aala ghamdi sab 👍

[@KAMALK320]

Ghamidi is unquestionably a great scholar

[@dr.aliahmad6490]

جزاکم اللہ خیراً کثیرا ۔

[@muhammadshafeeq5663]

Jazak Allah

[@Abdullah-eu4dw]

Land reforms and justifief distribution of resources is very essential for alleviation of poverty

[@tariqusman2250]

Musalmanon ko deen ka ilm hona intehaee zaroori hay sahee laha Ghamidi sb. nay. Jitnay loogon say milta hon 99% loog mujhay woh milay Karachi main jo kehtay hain Qismat he sub kuch hay even mehnat kar kay rizq kamana bhee naseeb say hota hay. Buss Naseeb ko he zimmaydar thayra deytay hain. Jub kay kisi kay pass eski sanad nahein kay uski salahiyat kiya hay aur uska naseeb main kiya hay. Gharz mehnat mushakkat say jee churana aur kamyabi hasil baghair jaddojehad kay mil janay par yaqeen rakhtay hain. Jo bilkul ghalat rawaiyya aur sooch hay. Allah nay sub ka intizam kar rakha hay rizq ka laykin koi hay jo uska fazal taalash karay mehnat karay. Main khud sharminda hon kay main bhee es sooch ka hamil reh chuka hon. Allah maaf karay. Ameen.

[@zeeshanbhutta1618]

Boht khob sir ....❤

[@danishm.3417]

Asal sawal yea hay, kay insan apnay faislon main azad hay yan naheen, yan us kay faislay Khuda khud ker raha hay? Agar aisa hay, to Usay yea ijazet kis nay di, aur phir Akhret kay hisab-kitab ka kia jawaz? Agar naheen, to phir Khuda say Dua kernay ka kia maqsad, kion kay dua ki qabooliat ka matlab insani zindagi aur dunyawi mamlat main Khudai mudakhlet ho gi, jo kay asoolan naheen honi chahyea? Hasil-e-Kalam yea hay, kay yan to Khuda insaf karay, yan insan ka peecha chor ker usay apnay faislay kernay day, takay Akhret main hisab-kitab ho sakay. Is waqt Kaenat main toofan-e-bad-tameezi micha huwa hay. Legta hay, Khuda auto-pilot per is Kaenat ko chor ker kaheen chala gaya hay. Kuch log Khuda kay chaheetay kay tor per dandanatay phir rahay hain, jab kay doosray jabr-e-musalsal ka shikar hain. Zaleel hans aur Shareef ro raha hay. Un ki sari qabliatain aur mehnatain barg-o-bar say mehroom rehti hain. Aisa legta hay, kay yea sab insan kay pichlay janmon ka Karma, yani unchangeable hay? Agar aisa hay, to phir Ibadaat aur duaon ka kia maqsad?

[@tauqueeralam3862]

You are right ghammedi sir

[@AkbarKhan-nm7ng]

I respect you and love you Sir, this is the very reason.

[@Respect-qy6ii]

this is the Truth

[@abdulvayani673]

Agar koi berozgar hai us ko kam ne milta aur us ke bachai boke hain to parosion aor reshtedaron ka kam hai us Khana khilian

[@zak10006]

رزق کا اہتمام اللہ نے کیا ہے لیکن تقسیم انسانوں کے ہاتوں میں دی ہے یہ اور بات ہے کہ ہم میں عدل و انصاف نہئ کچھ لوگ بھوک سے مر رہے ہیں اور کچھ اللے ترلے کر رہے ہیں

[@sherkohmazari7047]

Please check Kevin Carter’s Pulitzer Prize winning photo of a starving Sudanese child, and a vulture waiting in the background.

[@AsifRafique_]

struggle mehnat koshish k bd b na mily to

[@naasnaas3821]

With all due respect. Only and only Allah knows. It's not human domain to think and act. Quran already told it very clear

[@ShakilAhmed-gb4eu]

Salam gamdi sahab phir kisi ko taleem mehnat k bad b na mile aur kisi ko apni marzi se be tahasha dedia to phir bazahir ye insaf to nazar mahi aya .. pls clarify

[@ethics_academy]

Acha sawal hai apka. Meri samjh me ye insaf ke khilaf ni hai uski waja ye hai ki insaf ka talluq jaza aur saza se hai, kyuki ye duniya jaza aur saza ki jagah hi nhi hai islie yha insaf aur beinsaf ka sawal hi paida ni hota. Yaha to jisko bi jo kuch mila hai wo sab bator imtehan hi mila hai. Agar duniya me maal ki kasrat aur maal ki killat ko insaf se mutalliq krengr to fir khubsurti/badsurti, zahanat/kam aqali, gora/kala, sehatmand/kamzori tamam chizo me be insaf nazar ayega.

[@m.fawadkhan9753]

He has already explained that this world is azmaish. Those who have lot of resources must distribute it among poor in the form of zakat. Allah has not distributed rizq equally. Second some people always look for high profile jobs. They feel shy to do clerical jobs or small business. Such people remain jobless because of this mindset.

[@rabiajamil1440]

What about people in Palestine?

[@tariqusman2250]

Even deen ke samajh Arabic seekhna Allah ka qurb bhee mehnat say hasil karnay ka jazba hona aur doosron main payda karwana chaheyeh. Kay dekho rizq kiya cheez hay Allah ke raza bhee naikiyan karnay haram say bachnay aur huqooq ul ibaad poray karnay gharz mehnat kay baghair nahein. Alam ul asbab main hain aur sub alam ul asbab Allah nay Insaan ko faida deynay kay liyay hain. Ba haysiyat e qaum khair ko shar bana diya gaya hay yeh keh kar kay haram kamanay main tago do karlo halal kamanay main tagodo kuch kaam na aaygee, Halal ko naseeb pr chor do. Allah kay nabi. Sallalahu alayhee wa alayhee wassalam nay mehnat he kari subha shaam raat, aur hum pata nahein kahan say naseeb ko sub say oper manay ja rahay hain. Mehnat jo na karay culture main usko support ke zaroorat hay ager woh mehnat nahein kar sakta jo kar sakta hay usko motivation ke zaroorat hay aur jo kar raha hay kamyab hay usko tableegh karna chaheyeh sub loogon ko kay dekho Allah sub say bara hay. Allahu Akbar.

[@asifjutt442]

Gamdi sahib aap kia krtay heen Pleess jwab😊

[@musharrafsultan7879]

With due respect the above fails to account for socio economic injustices in most societies. In many societies like Pakistan, desire or the ability for hard work doesn’t always turn into an equal opportunity for gainful employment or just reward for one’s work. Global poverty, hunger and disease are mainly exist due to poor and unjust socio economic stratification n not due to lack food or medicine .

[@sherkohmazari7047]

It was better for him to have said that some things were beyond his comprehension,than to give a logically weak reply. There was no harm in saying that he does not have all the answers - Nobody does.

[@lineofduty-v6j]

It is not a weak answer at all. He has explained it very rationally, try to listen to him again. If you have a better answer, please state it here rather than unnecessarily criticizing a person.

[@mubashirtareen8641]

تو پھر اس رب سے استغفار پر ایسی جگہ جہاں سے گمان بھی نہ ہو اس کے ملنے کا وعدہ کیوں؟

[@hashimali31]

Why does these religious people tend to change their examples in accordance with the prevailing systems and way of living, when what's written in the scriptures is totally different? Conmen all of them.

[@lineofduty-v6j]

What is the point you are trying to make? Why don't you provide a sensible answer Rather than belittle someone?

[@mohdsahil6955]

Allah adil kha hua fr ku garib ke ghr paida kra kisi ko ameer ke ghr 😞

[@fniazi83]

Yehe to imtehan hey, kisi ko ghurbat, beemari, kisi ko dolat, sehat. Aisay he Allaah rabul izzat sub ko azmata hey. Dorsi baat ye kay Allaah rabul izat may rizq کی taqseem insano kay hatho May rakhe hey jo bazat e khoud aik imtehan hey, ab log zalim hey wo insaf nai kartay, zakat nai detay, ghareeb or meeskino ka khayal nai rakhtay, jis waja say unhey akhirat ki zindagi may azab hoga. Baqi jis nay ghurbat, beemari or takleef pay sabar kiya, Allaah rabul izat kay Haa bara ajar payega.

[@gandharaorganicfoods]

Acha or jo munafa khor rizq ko smuggle kar k Afghanistan bhej detay hain jiski wajah sey apnay godaam main qehet parr jata hai or mehngai sey kamar toot jati hai tu mehnat karnay wala muun he dekhay ga.. ghamdi sahab k kuch ilm main sey ye bhe aik explaination hai jis sey mujhay shadeed ikhtilaaf hai..

[@m.fawadkhan9753]

Don't blame Allah for the wrong doings and misplanning of governments.

[@gandharaorganicfoods]

@@m.fawadkhan9753 exactly.!! this is the point. Hamay manna paray ga baharhaal Rizq roti maal daulat har kisi ko phir apnay hissay ka khud ba khud milta hai werna mehnat tu gutter saaf karnay wala bhe karta hai

[@ShahNawaz-ns9vy]

Nyazi fitna pak foj or idaron ki toheen tazlil kra or koi ihtisab bi na ho to yahi hona ha laqanonyat phlana chahta ha project nyazi ka handlers

[@lineofduty-v6j]

What are you saying? This is not the platform for your point. Go back to school first, understand how to speak and where to speak in the right manner.

[@SeemabegamBegam-t9x]

جب سارے نبی کام کرتے تھے لیکن اج کے عالم کؤی کام نہیں کرتے بس چندا چندا جندا اور

[@zaitmirima]

Sawal gandum jawab chana

[@lovebrotherhood]

achha to aapke hisaab se log bhooke is liye mar rahe hain kyuki woh ghar me pade rehte hain.. socho to bhai, k woh sakhs kitna zyada lazy hoga jo bhooka marna to pasand karega lekin kaam me jana nahi.😂😂😂😂

[@lineofduty-v6j]

Shame on you for such a comment. Go back to school and learn some sense before commenting here. Unless you are joker then it is alright for you to post such nonsense!

[@altafrehman5554]

کہانیاں

[@MCQsTown]

Ap bhi aisi kahani biyan kr skty hain? Sirf Aik line main objection lga dia

[@JuttSarkar-nb6nj]

​@@MCQsTown Ye be-iman log hain inko mu mat lagya karo

[@musharrafsultan7879]

With due respect the above fails to account for socio economic injustices in most societies. In many societies like Pakistan, desire or the ability for hard work doesn’t always turn into an equal opportunity for gainful employment or just reward for one’s work. Global poverty, hunger and disease are mainly exist due to poor and unjust socio economic stratification n not due to lack food or medicine .

[@lineofduty-v6j]

Listen to him once again. He has clearly mentioned that it is the society's role to provide opportunities to the people. Allah has given enough resources in this world for the people to survive.