Systematic Literature Review using PRISMA: A Step-by-Step Guide (PART 2: Hands-on Experience)

Systematic Review: A Step-by-Step Guide (PART 2: Hands-on Experience)
Learn everything about systematic literature review. A shortcut to publish in top tier journals!
By Associate Professor Dr Saeed Pahlevansharif
Taylor's University
Watch the first part at • 💪 Systematic Literatur...
Systematic review is a research method to synthesize the existing body of knowledge. Systematic reviews have been regarded of particular value due to their propensity to reduce biases, increase reliability, and potentially improve the communication of the findings. Systematic reviews have increasingly replaced traditional narrative reviews and are considered the gold standard for synthesizing evidence. This workshop aims to provide a step-by-step guide for doctoral students and researchers interested in conducting a systematic review using PRISMA guideline (The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses).
• Pahlevan-Sharif, S., Mura, P., & Wijesinghe, S. N. (2019). A systematic review of systematic reviews in tourism. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 39, 158-165.
• Pahlevan-Sharif, S., Mura, P., & Wijesinghe, S. N. (2019). Systematic Reviews in Asia: Introducing the “PRISMA” Protocol to Tourism and Hospitality Scholars. In Quantitative Tourism Research in Asia (pp. 13-33). Springer, Singapore.
Associate Professor Dr. Saeed Pahlevan Sharif is Head of Research and PhD Programme Director in Faculty of Business and Law, Taylor’s University, Malaysia. Dr Saeed has published more than 100 research papers in prestigious journals and presented more than 40 papers in international conferences, among them are methodological papers and book chapters on systematic review. He has received Taylor’s University Vice Chancellor’s Research Award and the Iranian Embassy Research Medalist Award in 2017. He serves as the Editor of the Asia-Pacific Journal of Business Administration.
#systematicreveiw #literaturereview #systematic_reveiw #literature_review #research #prisma #publications

[@poonamsahoo7004]

In my entire life I have never listen to any lecture patiently.. Professor your lecturers have some magic.Grateful to you for sharing such informative knowledge.

[@saeedsharif]

In my entire life I had never received such a lovely comment on my lecture. :) Thank you

[@munkhtuyatumurkhuu3924]

This is the best video explaining how to conduct systematic review.

[@yiqiaowang9874]

Life saver! thorough, in-depth, and fun to watch. Thank you prof.Saeed!

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you for the kind words 💓

[@qusay6948]

One of the best video...I hope to complete this series and every part of SLR in a split video.

[@yulypiedrahita809]

Excellent!! I have two master's and second year of Pursuing a Ph.D. and this is the best explanation ever.

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you for your nice comment. And All the best with your PhD! :)

[@saeedsharif]

And I hope you find my new series of videos helpful for your PhD work kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3fPc4WsnqpqZtk kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHbPiqCViaeCpLM

[@kindpeaceinworld7897]

You speak clearly and with well speed . not much need to stop and start. awosome.

[@chanidor]

This is such a usefl video for beginners in research especially for systematic reviews. Thank you doctor

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you so much Chany! All the best!

[@StrideroftheNorth2931]

Thank you Professor. It was very helpful. Not many teachers teach their students with such diligence and patience. Thank you so very much.

[@saeedsharif]

Thanks for your beautiful comment!

[@davismiles2765]

watch the video kzbin.info/www/bejne/eouVlqJ6bsiAias

[@qusay6948]

First of all, we have to scan all related keywords, For example, if my keyword is "smart home" so i have to find the associated words, as "intelligent home" or " cleave home".

[@Oluwasefunmi_Peace]

Thank you so much Professor. I look forward to more videos from you.

[@AbdulRehman-tf9bq]

Dr Saeed, I found this lecture is fruitful for those whose wanna do Systematic Literature Review. Not at all Institutions have access to document search on Scopus, WOS,... how it possible to do SLR. I am eagerly await your response!

[@godwinkatemi5157]

Thanks Prof, It's Godwin from East Africa

[@saeedsharif]

Hi Godwin!

[@phodiemusakamara95]

Very educative and helpful. Thanks for your patient Dr.

[@jubefalana3307]

Thank you, Prof. I wish I had gotten this 2 years ago. Good one sir

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you Jube

[@monikamohanty1686]

Like Scopus how one can search through Google scholar?

[@abdullahal-hashar]

really thanx prof. Saeed it's helpfull good to share your way with your students

[@saeedsharif]

My pleasure!

[@burcu2310]

You are a real teacher. :)

[@kindpeaceinworld7897]

it is a really reeeeeeeeeaaly good work shop. thank you Dr Saeed. could you please share here your other video about SLR?

[@vishwaranjan8652]

Sir please add lecture " how to start writing a report, paper, book chapter and proposal I mean all research articles. How to initiate the writing all these without any plagrisum. And also how to cite journal.

[@nkechiesomonu8764]

Dr your're the best tutor, I must confess. so funny

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you very much. :) 😄

[@nkechiesomonu8764]

Please sir one more question. How can I get access to scopus and web of science libraries

[@saeedsharif]

@@nkechiesomonu8764 You can create an account at www.scopus.com/standard/marketing.uri to get access to Scopus database

[@nkechiesomonu8764]

@@saeedsharif I can't get tired of watching your video. You're still the best. Please my wonderful Dr do you have paid online class apart from this KZbin video. I will like you to be my mentor. You're very intelligent sir. Once again thank you. Am most grateful

[@stanleyeneh1745]

Wawoo I am so happy to watch. I wish to see you face to face

[@najwaabdelhalim9308]

شكرا جزيلا دكتور أكثر من رائع

[@christinamalini4412]

Thank you. It was very informative. Are there any more lectures on the development of SR protocol coming up?

[@saeedsharif]

Thanks for your comment. We will be conducting several courses/online workshops in 2021 and some of them will be on SR.

[@econ_edge]

Hi Professor, I'm a Master student in Agricultural Economics from Sri Lanka. I am planning to do a systematic review in nutrition security domain. My friend from University of Canterbury is willing to contribute to this task. Since this is our first systematic review, we need guidance in doing that. First I watched your videos and also currently watching other relevant videos from the internet. But since it is a systematic review, we need a lead professor (person who is having PhD) to guide us in the process. And hopefully we would like to submit journal, earliest in end of November and lastest would be either end of December or mid-January. Sir, if you know some academic who comes to your mind to do this task, kindly let me know. Thank you for your kind consideration.

[@saeedsharif]

Hi, That's great! What is your name? Can you drop me an email at [e-mail] ?

[@econ_edge]

@@saeedsharif Thank you professor. I'm Githmi Udagedara. I will send you an email.

[@econ_edge]

@@saeedsharif Sir I sent you an email. 🙂 Thank you

[@zuhakhan2882]

Thank you Sir these lectures are very useful to me. I wanted to know how to look for duplicates in excel sheet for data extraction.

[@LeilaAllahqoli]

It was great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! thank you

[@ගණිතවිනෝදය-ඡ7ඨ]

Thank you, sir.

[@mohammedsadique9586]

This is only 30 minutes video, the remaining part is missing.

[@saeedsharif]

Thanks for your message. I understand but actually the main part is the 30 minutes that I've shared in the video.

[@TheSulemanbacha]

The Title is( Effectiveness of self-learning package related to patient safety goals in Paediatric nurses in tertiary care hospitals)

[@saeedsharif]

Interesting. See how many papers you can find then.

[@qusay6948]

Thanks for your efforts.

[@Panu-qi7tm]

No idea he is trying to combine and not sure

[@jamilasitara6351]

nice work sir. kindly can you please share the data anylsis techniques for systematic literature review.

[@belloidris6288]

Thank you Prof

[@fingertip7882]

If I m working on a topic that has two things, for example ( Broca's aphasia and Wernicke's aphasia) and I search them separately, is it okay to combine the number of papers all together in the PRISMA flow chart ? or if I'm using different key terms each time... because I only find around 150 papers per search.

[@strongestvibe]

till now use of scopus has been shown/ plz provide other videos as well. By the way loved your teaching style

[@afsanehdrst861]

it was very helpful. extremely informative. thank you very much

[@peerzadaubaid1800]

Very informative

[@TheSulemanbacha]

Dear sir I have chosen a title for my research work at MS level in Nursing Please review and refine the topic title .

[@saeedsharif]

It looks a bit focused. Check how many records you get to review.

[@abiolavic99]

Prof. Saeed, thanks for your lecture video. It is very informative. Is it possible to screen papers based on "title"? Thanks for your respond in advance.

[@simirbirihan9059]

Thank you very much, Prof. how could prepare PRISMA design for engineering? Could I add additional f;ow diagram item?

[@atulsahu11]

Very effective lecture Thank for your kind explanation :) I have one question it I only take Scopus records is good or o have to web of science for more records?

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you for your nice message. Including more databases would improve the comprehensiveness of your search. So, it would increase the value of your work. But of course, this expansion requires additional resources for completion.

[@smartphonehacks9734]

very excellent lecture

[@mulugetatameneabrha5925]

Thank you professor for your helpful lecture. But how can I access this page? I have been tried many times I could not able to access?

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you for your comment. which page are you talking about?

[@mulugetatameneabrha5925]

@@saeedsharif Thanks again. The scopus advanced search home page you used to select and screen different articles? If i get the home page i will do my resrarch "Diarrhea diseases during COVID-19 Pandemic yrs of 2020 to 2021"

[@hoorsuhail2815]

yes please can someone help I think they have changed this system of search and I cant search specific key words such as Entamoeba or Trichomonas

[@ShohagAhamed-ry6sk]

Hello Sir, My institution doesn't have a Scopus subscription. Can you make another video by using Google Scholar or another platform?

[@hanspeter5502]

When exporting literature from different databases they all have different headings and information of the literature. How shall I join all literature from all the databases together when they don’t have the same headings. Which headings have to be present. Thank you

[@kanchanbagri9971]

sir I have a question - I want to do a qualitative study relating to challenges and solutions sir can I use systematic review approach in this and can I use only a single index like jstor or Elsevier or Scopus instead of using many indexes please help sir...

[@marrosa8708]

Where is the rest of part 2 ?

[@saeedsharif]

I think we stopped at the end of part 2.

[@monikarajak1155]

Thank you so much sir for your valuable lecture on SIR, my name is Monika Rajak, Research scholar, Department of Education, Aliah University.sir actually I have face problems that is I couldn't find out Advance search button in Scopus journal, that why I couldn't download paper and paste in Excel from scopus, so how can I do sir, plz help me.

[@sabitabhagabati5634]

Sir I am unable to find out this page named as "Advanced search " . May you help me.

[@adelowoabimbola5227]

The greatest and most understood lecture I have ever received. Please Dr. Saeed, can you share you mail? Do you have lectures on how to identify gaps and turn them to research objective. I really help on this. Thanks

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you for your comment. I'm making a new series of videos and these topics are among them. My email address: [e-mail]

[@adelowoabimbola5227]

@@saeedsharif I can't to watch them! Bravo Prof.

[@saeedsharif]

@@adelowoabimbola5227 To be uploaded Soooooonnnn :) Please subscribe to the channel and share the videos with your peers.

[@udaykiran-ws8mo]

Sir, prisma statement guidelines is only for medical research or even management studies can use .

[@saeedsharif]

In the video, I have shown the revised PRISMA that can be used in social sciences including management too. I have published the revised PRISMA and you can download it from the link in the video description.

[@adama6912]

can we do this in google scholar

[@sherifshaheen1492]

Is this a course series, so any lectures are coming up?!

[@saeedsharif]

There will be more sessions. If you are interested let me know.

[@sherifshaheen1492]

@@saeedsharif highly interested.

[@saeedsharif]

@@sherifshaheen1492 Please drop me an email at [e-mail]

[@sowgolemirzade8]

Thanks so much for another great video, I do have a question. When you compare two platforms such as scopus and sciencedirect , do you have an specific method to retrieve the duplicated papers, or do you go through scanning the excel file manually one by one. Thanks in advance .

[@saeedsharif]

I sort both files alphabetically based on the title of the papers and then use this code to find the duplicates. =IF(A2=A1,1,0). It means if the information in a cell was the same as the cell above in the same column (the title column), it will get 1, otherwise zero. Then, I after changing the codes to numbers. I sort the results column. Next, I delete all with rows with 1. Hope it is clear! haha.... I should make a video to show you

[@hugorojas1538]

@@saeedsharif Thanks a lot! Enjoying these videos, is my first time doing an SR and this is helping me with each step.

[@samahibrahim5038]

@@saeedsharif Hi, thank you for the wonderful videos, I just started my studying journey on my PhD project. I have no idea how to do the search on database or how to create the results files on the excel to transfer the search data to them. Can you please advise on videos or resources how to do so, can you recommend videos on KZbin to check? my area is sustainable food waste management. I don't know how to choose the terms for my research database? thank you for your help.

[@juve5001]

Can any one help on how to export articles from Google Scholar engine into excel for systematic review

[@udaykiran-ws8mo]

Sir, is PICO and PICo , spider and spice are applicable for management studies. Kindly guide

[@ambikathapa6645]

Sir whenever I try to search in Scopus I'm getting the source or journal search page only not this document or article search page. I'm not able to find out what error I'm doing

[@ambikathapa6645]

Please help

[@saeedsharif]

Hi Ambika, you may create a free account to get access to the advanced search

[@deepakdass5286]

Is it mandatory to register PRISMA systematic review?

[@sunchonyupa115]

I don't have an institutional email to access the Scopus. How can I do it Sir. Anyway, thank you so much for your effective topic. It means a lot to me.

[@saeedsharif]

Can't you make an account with your personal email address?

[@sunchonyupa115]

@@saeedsharif I tried, Prof. But it not working with my personal email and that page requires to fill the institutional email in order to access more articles.

[@andualemdebas5556]

Inverted commas for double quotation

[@naemehsajadi4171]

It was very insightful. Thanks 🤓

[@saeedsharif]

Thank you for your feedback

[@jamilasitara6351]

Dear teacher I cant find its part 3

[@saeedsharif]

@jamilasitara6351 sorry. Other parts haven't been recorded

[@IrfanAli-gz2wx]

I cannot find the link of Scopus from where advanced search can be applied? Help me plz

[@saeedsharif]

Hi Irfan, the platform has changed. You need to create an account first. It's free. Then, you will see the advanced search, etc. All the best!

[@fagadeolanrewaju570]

@Dr Saeed, thank you so much for the lecture sir. It was great. Please what other platform can systematic Literature Review be done apart from scopus and hiw can I get access to scopus. Your swift response will be appreciated Sir.