Taliban, Afghanistan, Pakistan | Afrasiab Khattak & Pervez Hoodbhoy |

[@mariaali4567]

Two intellects on one plateform. Greatly appreciated. I wish most of our population could understand the deep realities discussed by the duo.

[@paulrobert3325]

Give me a break A bunch of surkhas are crying Their analysis for the past two decade were wrong How can they be right this time?

[@KakarKhanZarak]

Mohtarma ap k comment ne muj mein aik ajeeb sa tajasu piada kiya hai.. dar asal mein ye jan'na chahta hoo k ap kya deep realities samji hai Mohtarm Afrasiab Khattak ki guftugu se.. agar mumkin ho to mai ap se is muamly pr guftugu karna chahta hoo

[@Umarkhan-vh5wy]

Brother i feel pity on our intellectuals,they know no thing

[@bhuvanmittal4977]

PARVEZ HOODBHOI, YOU ARE ONE OF THE FINEST, VISIBLY HONEST, GRACEFUL AND DIGNIFIED EMINENT ANALYSER, PRESENTER I HAVE ADMIRED AND APPRECIATED, THE ONE AND ONLY BRAVE SOUL WHO CALLS A SPADE A SPADE.

[@srmalik]

The one and only intellectual of Pakistan. Sir Parvez Hoodbhoy, what an honour to have the opportunity to learn from you.

[@HaseebKhan-yq8hs]

Yes one and only in Pakistan. That’s one more than Indian and Afghanistan combined 😋

[@bushanmehra9885]

Afrabsiab Khattak is one of my favourite Pashton intellecual.

[@ghazanhussain2070]

You should just produce milk. This talk is not for you

[@ghazanhussain2070]

My response is better Make her do the thing she is made for

[@paulrobert3325]

Afrasiyab is a sold out surkha

[@npbains]

@Abdul Ghafoor you are copied and pasted same comment again and again

[@zardusharyazadraan3608]

جاہل انسان​@@paulrobert3325

[@rizwanyounus1814]

Sir Pervez Hoodbhoy is a great Intellectual and Physicist. Salute for Him.

[@csreddy1518]

I am very much moved by this discussion. very very sane and wise discussion.

[@theplaymakerno1]

The comment section in this video is seriously good. Thank goodness that there are still people in this country that have a brain.

[@papertime482]

12 years ago hameed Gul also said that us soldier are like chocolate cream and will melt like chocolate ice cream on the mountains of Afghanistan which they did . So how did he knew that ? ...

[@sadaqatem]

how these 35 minutes past i do not know but what an intellectual talk. Hats off

[@sadaqatem]

@Abdul Ghafoor you do not know this man how can you make a judgment about someone in 35 mins video. Please do study a friendly advice. P.s: He is pure leftist

[@hirendesai8343]

Super Conversation..Lajawaab 👍👏👏

[@rizwanyounus1814]

سر پرویز ہود بھائی، قوم کو آپ جیسے زہین استادوں کی بہت ضرورت ہے۔

[@hashamakram5163]

Lekin sir hoodboy khabi is mulk ko sirve nahi kr skty

[@hashamakram5163]

Unko ek controversial personality consider Kiya jata raha hai

[@AsBi1]

we need people like Hoodbhoy sahab

[@ankit30572]

I salute you sir 🙏, You are an honest person. Love and respect from India 🙏. May God bless thee Prof.sir😇🙏

[@girijanayak2038]

Very informed discussion . Salute to both the intellectuals.Plz do something for detente between India & Pak. Again my namaskar.

[@pravin3783]

Khattar saab is quite educated. His analysis and future projection of current situations are very valid.

[@anmol7412]

There's only one reason Pak is in a mess today: Pak Army.

[@pankajchauhan3675]

Just learn today that hoodboy is Gujarati,i feel proud to be gujju

[@blindeagle9109]

This is another issue with Indian , Pakisthani & Bangladeshi muslims whose ethnicity is ignored while naming a baby. This is another cause of deep identity crisis of muslims in these countries.

[@adnanibrahim5078]

110 % agreed with you.. May Allah bless you both

[@paulrobert3325]

Lol surkhas

[@kumarnick52]

Dr Hoodbhoy, please keep yourself safe as we can’t afford to lose you to the evil forces that surely have you targeted. God Bless you !!

[@cobaltbomba4310]

He has been doing this for ages, and in Pakistan, we have freedom of speech. No power can harm Dr. Hoodbhoy because he is a patriotic Pakistani and wants to see bright and rich Pakistan.

[@paulrobert3325]

Naaaa Both are useless surkhas Nobody cares

[@UsmanKhan-fq3cj]

Informative talks

[@tauqiralam8532]

Great Afrasiab khatak , very clear on issues

[@sohaibkhan9727]

Great discussion

[@realpolitik6166]

Afrasiyab Khattak, great as ever! A great political analyst...a liberal.

[@toonalaya]

Excellent discussion

[@javed295]

The war is not over for Afghans,it’s just new beginning and will bring a worst kind of slavery.

[@bushanmehra9885]

pakistan is doing exactly the same what they did in Bangladesh in 1971,vanishing the Afghan identity,they did not succeed then and they wouldn't succeed now.

[@GumNaam_Reader]

It isn't same. Bengalis were united from first day to fight against oppression. Taliban are making next government. Ghani has just resigned. It's over. Next chapter is about to begin in Afghanistan.

[@EILF7842]

@@GumNaam_Reader because bengal is not a tribal society like Afghans. Also bengali muslims are probably the only community where there isn't much presence or dominance of feudal minded Ashraf elite, something which is rampant in Pakistan.

[@aashfaq6645]

I don't think they have problem with afghan identity but when afghans claim whole kpk and loy Afghanistan then it causes problem for Pakistan as a state

[@aashfaq6645]

@@GumNaam_Reader not really bro...Bengalis until 1970 wanted greater autonomy and not separation or independence despite the oppression they faced all those years.Its only after 1971 when pak army did operations against common people in east Pakistan and also denied the presidency to Sheikh Mujib then they started asking for Independence

[@PulkitAgrawal1999]

Problem will increase in future for Pakistan as Taliban will one day start claiming Pashtun area of Pakistan, they don't believe in Durrand line. Also they will want to establish Sharia law in Pakistan as well.

[@mariaali4567]

sane voices, indeed.

[@yogeshsawant4934]

If Pakistanis get out of this crazy mentality they will be like south Korea. Very rich. They are bright people. They have less problems than India.

[@EILF7842]

Islam is a big problem, paxtans biggest problem is its lack of identity...has no history so no future.. ideological states don't thrive

[@rajkumarpandey4688]

Jabardast interview dimag aur ankhe khilane wala. Dhanywad

[@gajananranade9429]

The discussion which took place (2years back) is still unchanged, but now it has dwindling... Islaam ha to give up VIOLENCE, and HATRED, if not Allha will not pardon it...

[@VINAY01131]

Pakistan need 1000s of dr.hoodbhoy

[@IMKhan-ze4zm]

great debate ❤

[@dugyan]

Great, sobering discussion

[@success1866]

Deep respect for u two Sir

[@Abdullah-xq2wi]

Two atheists Ya phir aik surkha communist

[@liaquatarain5338]

So what? Both are talking sensible, we should listen regardless where it’s coming from.

[@ahsankamal9170]

Sane voices, I hope people understand these things.

[@spaul2k5]

Sir, it is a great concern for educated people like us to see a person like you in Pakistan. You may be eliminated anyday by ISI, who is the father of the Taliban. Please be careful, or get out of that country. Any country will be more than happy to accept you...

[@zardusharyazadraan3608]

افراسیاب کو میں زمانے سے جانتا ہوں ہیرا ہے ہیرا اور ویدھیا ساگر علم کا سمندر

[@BM-ym5ik]

Excellent discussions by both intellectuals. Pakistan does not deserve you.

[@fareedhussain59]

Mr Khattak's utterances are full of contradictions and muddled headed ideas. I'm not sure what he's trying to get at or how he thinks Pakistan should deal with Talbans? Neither of these gentlemen has charted a way forward for Pakistan from the juncture we are at. Very disappointing!

[@IMKhan-ze4zm]

Mr Khattak's utterances are truthful but you are living in a fools' paradise of Talibanization😂.

[@sciencelife8489]

As always, feel great to listen to Mr Hoodbhoi; anotheer thoughtful coversation with Mr. Khattak.

[@piyushsonone7]

We wish for your safety in this situation

[@dr.asifshah4985]

Excellent.

[@criticalindiananalyser6240]

This is real fact discussion very sensible plz keep it up congrats to both of you

[@nafeesakhtar2401]

Bad days of Afghanistan is coming and Talibans are like unguided missiles which destroy himself also

[@KakarKhanZarak]

Would you elaborate the kind of suffering people of Afghanistan will face in the coming days?

[@muhammadnazeer3906]

Great khattak

[@MuhammadKhan-qd9xr]

زبردست

[@yogeshsawant4934]

I think he should be in west. He is a liberal and scientist. He is an intellectual. Respect from India.

[@paulrobert3325]

Lol He is not a intellectual He was a former hardcore Marxists Both of them were communist And they lost Hence they are crying

[@moizaleem9756]

@@paulrobert3325 that's right, specifically Khattak Sahb has a history of being affiliated with Afghan Govt and Afghan Palace in the past during their earlier time in Khudaai Khidmatgars, he was working for a greater Pashtunistan during PDPA era in Afghanistan. The reason ANP has bad blood with Pakistani security establishment is that it pro-actively took out the ethno-nationalist struggle for merging tribal regions of Pakistan into Afghanistan. During 1951-62 insurgency period in tribal regions, it was so bad that PAF had to bomb insurgent hideouts both in Pakistan and Afghanistan along the Durand Line. It is one of those chapters of history these left wing former Marxists won't tell you. The Great Bacha Khan (I personally respect him alot) himself later on accepted and confessed that their struggle for Pashtunistan was exploited by Daoud Khan and other PDPA Leaders at that time and later dropped when Pakistan exerted pressure.

[@paulrobert3325]

@@moizaleem9756 spot on Please spread this message as much as you can Say no to these corrupt communists

[@shehzadkamal]

My very very dear and beloved Pervez Hoodbhoy , I am concerned about your health. Please decrease calorie intake and do work out. Your flattered tummy is not a good sign. 💕

[@samiselim]

I don’t favour taliban nor their style of government. I’m a strong supporter of liberal democracy, and that is the only way for us to achieve prosperity either someone like it or not. But don’t expect anything good from these pieces of shit, these so called politicians who are born in privileges and have enjoyed a luxurious life, became senators, ruled over the country for some years are now talking about , identity, nationhood and constitution. They have their kids studying in the western world. Tell me how many people from lower middle class are in our parliament . Since 1947 there are certain families who are ruling over our country. These pathetic politicians never really cared about people’s interest they just care about their own interests so that their families can continue to rule over our country. Our country??? Its actually not our country , this country belong to these politicians because in all the Muslim countries if these kings or politicians cared about people then the people would never support those extremist groups like taliban . We have failed our people at all level

[@brachisaurous]

Why do Pakistanis expect Taliban/Pashtun to accept Durand line and live like good neighbors? This is really naive or really stupid thinking!

[@akshayrathore2882]

I agree more with hoodbhais analysis on taliban and usa. If taliban was puppet of usa to stop cpac, they could have done same with afghan govt who were also in control of usa.

[@Mr_ST_720]

M indian .. sir I like your show

[@shagafmemories6801]

Behind on the board standard model of physics but on the front discussion about politics

[@paulrobert3325]

Lol

[@hafeezkumbhar1334]

Good dr sahib

[@simonsher4533]

سوات میں جب طالبان ابھر رہے تھے تو اس وقت فضل اللہ کے ساتھ میٹنگ میں پاک فوج کے کرنل اور برگیڈیر بیٹھا کرتے تھے۔ یہ سب انکا کام ہے بھائی۔

[@dr.naheedziakhan3539]

All need to be very careful in current circumstances. There is a lot more than what meets the eye. I am a Liberal myself and very well versed with the shallowness of so called liberals. Understanding perspectives is important in a world which is full of contradictions, ignorance and hypocrisy.

[@bhuvanmittal4977]

Afrasiab Khattak is very reasonable and candid in his thought process.

[@paulrobert3325]

He is a former hardcore communist He is not reasonable

[@mohammadahmad2389]

We need more intellectual like you sir, somebody needs to teach this nation to come out of dogmas and study and research reasoning in order to be successful.

[@cobaltbomba4310]

I, especially, came here to watch and listen some genuine facts about Afghanistan after watching and listening bullshits on mainstream media of our Pakistan.

[@yogeshsawant4934]

Very daring interview.

[@aleemshah4439]

We are playing with fire. Stuck between the devil and deep sea.

[@ghazanhussain2070]

You should cook food rather than worrying abt this stuff

[@shobhashirole0156]

@@ghazanhussain2070 you are dominant one .

[@ghazanhussain2070]

@@shobhashirole0156 thanks

[@raniriaz4592]

بر صغیر کی داستان اتر میں کشمیران پچھم میں طالبان بھارت میں مودی جان پاکستان میں امران خان عوام بچارے دھان پان خیر کیجو جو ہوں گتھم گتھان

[@maheshmalviya6028]

I am also very much with you Dr. Parvez. Regards

[@shakeelahmedqureshi5198]

Sir from physics how converted to politics inverter

[@shobhashirole0156]

He wants social reform in politics .

[@aamiriqbal5167]

Pervaiz sahab!fighting america aur unke itihadiyon se hai

[@paulrobert3325]

Basically Two surkhas crying All their analysis are wrong It's the same reason, the Afghan Taliban won

[@m.b.nagaraj7666]

The Cold War theory created Today's Taliban problem. Cold War is over but it's Shadow still playing a black game

[@MuqaddasUllah-uv7xu]

But America is the Master of all this

[@zubair80ahmad]

very informative discussion.i hear other side of reality that very different from main stream media.

[@EILF7842]

@Abdul Ghafoor pakistan is also a third party in Afghanistan.

[@propakhtunkhwa2778]

nice

[@blindeagle9109]

Communism and communists are hardly found in any muslim majority country. Lelin said that religion like an opium. True communists can never be thesists.They can only be atheist or agnostic. Dr.Hoodbhoy was a leftist but Islam in clash with communism as well. This is an oxymoron.

[@hashimrasool]

Afsaryab Khattak is intellectually bankrupt.. very profoundly

[@paulrobert3325]

Afrasiyab is former hardcore communist Who is just now crying

[@spacelion6318]

Is Islam compatible with democracy?

[@mrashid7388]

Hoodbhoi ''' tm jitna bhi bhok lo '' prr sachai ye ha k Islam ka parcham buland HOA ha

[@user-bp4db2yq3x]

TTP bhi jaldi Islam nafiz karegi pakistan me insallah

[@read7641]

You should feel horrible professor. Idk what event in life made you hate what you hate. But it’s unfortunate to hear you speak untruths. You know it well. I hope you sleep well at nite.

[@read7641]

@Ravener of Abbadon boohoo 😢 Cry me a River India. You lost Afghanistan.

[@moizaleem9756]

Dr. Pervez you should've also asked him about his past chapter of life in Khudaai Khidmatgars when he and his rest of the kin was working along Afghan Palace for "Pashtunistan". Why doesn't he come out clear about that? Their struggle for merger of Pakistan's sovereign legitimate non-contested tribal territories into Afghanistan through entho-nationalist insurgency during the PDPA rule in Afghanistan. His connections with Sardar Daoud Khan, the 1951-62 period of tribal insurgency. It is very disingenuous to present just one side of the story.

[@vikramchand7205]

True debate 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

[@blindeagle9109]

I always find most of Pakisthani intellectuals avoid to take the bull by its horn. They never mention that Taliban & ISIS want to imprement the purest form of Islam. To do that they follow the verses clearly written in Holy books. All action they they take relate to the specific verses. Nizam a Mustafa....that is the foot steps of Prophet Muhammad they follow. Islam stands beyond reform. All issues stem from that only. Islam is in clash with all civilizations of the world.It is an exclusive religion and unchangsble concept.So will not see ever any light of modernity.

[@ShabirAhmad-wn5jl]

American's puppets, shame on you

[@criticalindiananalyser6240]

Hamid gul has given statement long back about defeat of America in Afghanistan

[@mindscapechronical]

hahahaha

[@RomasaAzhar]

And still peoples support taliban are they dumb or something?

[@m.astudycenter8446]

Biases interview and both are against Pakistan state their argument in this conversation revolving against Pakistan.

[@majeedvayani6341]

Both are looser

[@allahmuhammad225]

Pakistan is a terrorist sponsoring state

[@azizullah3818]

Azizullah Khattak.. پہلے یہ صاحب یو۔ اس۔ اس۔ آرکا پھٹو تھا اب یو اس اے کا پٹھو ھے۔دونوں جگہ مار کھا گیا تو یہ اور کیا کہے گا۔

[@sayandeychaudhuri8588]

Chalo koi ek banda to mila jo bismillah rehman etc bol ke baat shuru nahi kiya

[@khansher5411]

Afghanistan govt or aap so called scholars ka masla hi yahi hy k Taliban ko kabhi own nahi kiya or unhe foreign aided mliltants samja halanke unhy Afghan logo ko support hasil rahi hy Q k wo Afghanistan k religio-Tribal identity se jurrey huye hen...

[@rubinafaryalasif9422]

Stop false propoganda against Talibaan.

[@afzalmalla8711]

a message of Dr. AQ Khan on this treacherous Hoodbhoy "Sir Gen Zia wanted to throw him out knowing that he was a CIA and Indian agent. but hameeda khuro begged him to spare as it would annoy the Americans. I was member of syndicate and so was she. no doubt he was a foreign agent all the time talking against our nuclear program. Nobody knows him for his academic achievements. Students used to say he was a staunch ahmadi. Dr. AQkhan."

[@abhishekuttam8051]

I really like your content, when I came across your channel it was like getting an positive hope from India and Pakistan when radical groups are dominating in both nations that there are still people like you in Pakistan but really don't embrace your thoughts to recognise Taliban as Muslim organisation, because if you recognising it like that then you're also promoting Islam as terror which I think you don't want and I think Talibanis are not muslim anymore, they're now just puppet killers controlled by some power greedy persons disguising themselves in the name of Islam for public support. It's not about muslims or Islam in Afghanistan, you have to see above it.

[@ZaidKhan-o9d]

ماضی کے طالبان حکومت اور موجودہ طالبان حکومت کے حوالے سے آپ دونوں کا تجزیہ غلط ثابت ہوا۔

[@asifkhan300575]

It seems like Indian talk show

[@aamiriqbal5167]

Afrasiab sahab!ideology or materials me bohot farq hai.islam me kaha hai ke kisi dosre ki banayi hoi cheezo ko istimal nahi karna.lekin obscenity paida karne wale tariqo ko adopt to nahi karna.baat ko pori wazahat se bayan kare (shukria).

[@msbalghari3163]

Prof shb ka viewpoint hamesha anti pak kiun lgta he

[@paulrobert3325]

Ye surkha ro rha hai Kyunkeh Taliban jeet gaya Aur iska saraa Analysis ghalt Nikal aya hai

[@muneerahmad658]

آپ لوگ سنگسار کرنے کو اور سر قلم کرنے کو ظلم سمجھتے ھو تم لوگ اسلامی قوانین سے بھی لا علم ھو۔

[@AliAli-gw6fq]

Sir please improve voice quality

[@SalarUZahid]

Little knowledge is dangerous thing

[@chameerhamzasansi4550]

Both r jokers

[@saifullah3864]

Both of them are third class scholars, hypocrite to 1000 percent.

[@nomanamdanivlog2462]

Talban is true and real heroes

[@amnahaque9058]

When they do a bomb explosion near your house, what will uou say then?

[@makdeezee4846]

Alhamdulillah.....

[@nomanamdanivlog2462]

Parvez sb apny jhoot bola hy bohtan bandha