Tally Hall - Never Meant To Know

Tally Hall playing a new song, Never Meant To Know (by Rob Cantor), at the Rugby Store in NYC on October 24, 2008.
Thanks for watching! I'm also a musician/filmmaker. Please check out my official channel: / @dwighteyoungofficial

[@AnaAerophina]

Andrew is some kind of magical keyboard wizard

[@rainespiano]

y e s

[@annecorwin9792]

Seriously, it’s like he is operating (at least in terms of fingers) in that 100 cups of coffee level of reality where the rest of us all seem slowed down

[@Duckgames150]

I mean he does have the keys to unlock the rock

[@Kompressor808]

​@@Duckgames150in the act, if you please

[@rainespiano]

“This is a new song” Man that hurts a bit

[@rainespiano]

*A LOT ACTUALLY

[@x.a.t.u]

@@rainespiano :(

[@mangaprofilepicture5820]

@@rainespiano :(

[@patrickosullivan7783]

@@rainespiano :(

[@multieyedkitten]

:(

[@kwithyco]

I like them because they wear ties.

[@Struggler3831]

You’re a simple man Or woman

[@heh2363]

Same, kid

[@dead_acc_t]

so formal

[@x.a.t.u]

@@dead_acc_t so much very much

[@vertz1515]

Well that’s one reason to like Tally Hall.

[@Sp00kyR0b]

I might just explode from how good they are live.

[@Hotdogbunker]

I even like how they have the bass buzz at the end. It's suspenseful in a way and it collaborates with the meaning of the song. It's really well written and I can't wait to buy this album.

[@yetanotherchannel5516]

did you buy the album mike

[@lizrobbins6623]

@yet another channel idk why this sounds so threatening to me. But did you buy the album MIKE? Hmmmmmmm

[@mangaprofilepicture5820]

Yeah, mike, did you get the album yet?

[@an_animator6577]

Did you buy de album?

[@wrightsmilitaria]

Tallyhall is weird, one day they’ll be on tv, the next in a theatre, then in a clothes shop

[@justaguy4311]

i like the live videos because it shows the chords they used

[@vannishd]

I know this comment was posted 3 years ago but if you're still active, what chords were you able to tell that they were playing ? I'm trying really hard to see but I'm having trouble i really want to learn how to play this song

[@panzerdragon1121]

The good days.

[@tally_hal]

YEAHHH!!

[@bangflashbam]

boys, this is sounding great i am pretty much beyond excited for the new stuff!!!

[@DanJFilms]

this comment aged poorly 🥲

[@fold3316]

@@DanJFilms they released an album after this comment was made

[@DanJFilms]

@@fold3316 what album

[@thespiciestperson]

@@DanJFilms good & evil

[@BC-so5ub]

@@thespiciestperson Damn. That was long ago.

[@dead_acc_t]

phenomenal

[@driftercarbon]

A great performance of one of their best songs.

[@vertz1515]

The audio isn’t gone guys. The KZbin app just… can’t.

[@opedrodubois]

rob's voice didn't need any autotune at all in good & evil

[@SmashThSilence]

SOOO GOOD!

[@user-fj4zo5hh8w]

"14 years ago" video quality checks out

[@georgemalpass9278]

these new songs are great but when are they actually going to record them?!

[@storrentMC]

Pushing the tempo a bit there, Joe

[@LingusDaDingus]

this pains me a little bit

[@RAATlol]

tf tally hall up in the dillards

[@Hotdogbunker]

I was gonna ask the same thing.

[@ludisrr]

like the album version better.

[@EmeraldFox11]

This song still has that echo-y feel to it like the album version, i LOVE IT! and Andrew is a total boss on that piano :D

[@bassafratz]

EmeraldFox11 I KNOOOOOOW!!!!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭🍗😭😭😭

[@rainespiano]

Andrew teach me the way of your pianoing QAQ

[@cttvus]

the fact that these guys all found each other is proof of some higher force. praise the higher force.

[@bassafratz]

muffins ARE YOU STILL ALIIIIVE?!?!?!

[@rainespiano]

BassFartz no they are died

[@naobi666]

Ssup

[@vvsvlogsYT]

I must know if u still exist

[@bobbyvonbobinson1555]

Wow

[@fab823]

Hey, I'm from the future, I guess, I'd discovered this band a few months ago and it's my first favourite band that isn't global knowed. And, it's a shame to see things like this, they're not even playing in a decent site, they deserved more. I'd really like to see them doing new music.

[@rainespiano]

FAB You’re from the future? IM from the future

[@fab823]

Future gang go brrrr. Man I rlly sucked at writting in english lol

[@izzyp.3572]

@@fab823 man I'm from the future

[@Nyacinth]

@@izzyp.3572 Hah, I'm from the FUTURE future.

[@loolinonilool]

Behold the FUTURE!

[@nilslagerberg1273]

Just discovered Tally Hall last month and i'm addicted to this song. How did it take me 12 years to discover this gem?

[@hawhaw6815]

Same

[@mrsb09]

Same!!!

[@maush.]

You were never meant to know

[@PNKEEE07]

i freaking LOVE rob's voice...

[@user-do4kb1pu1w]

Hello Jennifer 12 years later!

[@goopybird]

Here from the future to tell you I ALSO LOVE ROBS VOICE!!

[@siriusylee]

Practically any song Rob sings in brings me comfort, very pretty!

[@sksyes5]

Rob's voice =

[@furiousmagician5912]

ANDREWS VOICE TOO

[@emms_00]

@@furiousmagician5912 SIR DID YOU HEAR ROSS'S VOICE??

[@doingvideogameswrong]

I have always been jealous of Andrew and how he turns into "The Complete Book of Scales, Chords, Arpeggios & Cadences." Also, the juxtaposition of Elevated Song with...clothing store (?) kills me.

[@m0012]

I had to turn this off because I couldn't stop singing long enough to type my paper :3

[@rainespiano]

Put it back up now. I suppose you’re finished with your paper

[@naobi666]

Did you finish your paper?

[@m0012]

@@naobi666 @Raine's Piano i am happy to report that i have since graduated high school but, as for the fate of that particular paper..... there are some things we are never meant to know 👁️👄👁️

[@MindofSimon]

look at andrews fingers... he is a magic man hahaha

[@cojiro7]

Man, they were SO AWESOME that night. I've had this stuck in my head ever since. Haha, and at the end: Paul: "NICE." Dwight: "yeeaAAAAAH!"

[@rainespiano]

*yeeeeAAAAAAH*

[@cozbaldwin]

Check "hidden in the sand" - the fan site - for news and updates on the band and the new album.

[@rainespiano]

New album- aaaaaaaah-

[@thebrutusmars]

Raine’s Piano Oof

[@JAy-vx3vw]

@@thebrutusmars yeah I used to have hope since Joe has brought up a third album multiple times but I really doubt it now p

[@secluded_little_spot]

RIP Coz😢

[@mushroomfog2509]

@@secluded_little_spot it's just a burning memory

[@asecondhandidentity]

This is music my children.

[@irahkins]

I love Tally Hall. They're just the best!

[@undersc0r]

13 years ago

[@meinerHeld]

Shoulda used harpsichord, Andrew. tuttut

[@rainespiano]

tututu

[@inkeldinky]

It might be a higher force, it might be coincidence. I believe we are never meant to know.

[@Struggler3831]

DANG YOUUUUUUUU

[@WokIsAmazing]

I can’t hear it

[@Floofy_Fox_Gal]

It breaks my heart that they’re no longer a band, but it was nice while we had them ❤️

[@SOLAR_INSANITY]

Theyre no longer playing in a band…

[@RickySuave]

I love this song... and Tally Hall.

[@m0012]

I've listened to this song at least 5 times today ♥

[@m0012]

okay nerd

[@AwesomeJediE]

@@m0012 HASDHSHAH

[@athorninhersides]

Robs face makes my life :D

[@DwightTheGreat]

Thanks for watching! I'm also a musician/filmmaker. Please check out my official channel: kzbin.info/door/5YE4mK6g-UYNnargq-DtMg

[@stitchgor3]

LOL it’s even funnier when my device won’t play the sound

[@henryboi_hehe]

not just you, bud

[@stitchgor3]

@@henryboi_hehe damn😞

[@henryboi_hehe]

@@stitchgor3 😔

[@awllypollyas8292]

Tally hall at tiny desk

[@TheAutumnPursuit]

I'm so glad these guys FINALLY made an official release date for their new album. I've waited TOO LONG.

[@Ray0502]

This one hit me a bit too much

[@offtheradar24245]

we've all been waiting too long

[@AnaAerophina]

Love the vests.

[@epicgamer-ur1wg]

I loved this video. Especially the audio

[@soy1119]

Glad to finally find this 13 years later :) Happy new years.

[@rainespiano]

Hi I’m back again

[@rainespiano]

Hi

[@AwesomeJediE]

Hi back again

[@rainespiano]

@@AwesomeJediE hi awesomejedie

[@AwesomeJediE]

@@rainespiano hi rainespiano ‼

[@vannishd]

I swear tally hall finds the weirdest places to perform

[@hellohello-fz6he]

i wish theyd come back

[@bass_on_bass]

i think the audio's gone

[@eriku-chwan]

O mundo parece ter escolhido esquecer eles, mesmo com tantas views a banda não é mais falada, não faz sentido. Arte é realmente sobre conexão emocional.

[@IDKDevvy]

I've been coming back to this again and again for months now. SO excited for the album.

[@sodado6989]

Anyone else feel like they were rushing a bit? Either way, nice performance

[@TVMAN1112]

Are they playing at a gap or something??? haha.

[@ShaneTaylors1Fan]

I love this song, and Rob :D Haha.

[@paulin_greener]

i love tally hall 🔴🔵🟡⚪🟢

[@sphynia-cat8250]

*Happy flailing* aaa!!

[@BrokeTheInterweb]

listen to this at least four times per week.

[@sabekunnaharoishee7009]

I do 10000 times a second

[@wahwahster]

man, I wish I were there

[@youresorobotic]

I ADORE this song

[@miked.3673]

God I hope there’s an archive of the audio

[@AZMindroma]

Forever.

[@rainbowrarity09]

Forever 💕

[@maush.]

If only it was..

[@Fiskiuggar]

They have so much more to sing

[@GorillaFan_32]

why no sound

[@MindofSimon]

Thank You SO Much Dwight!! This is the first time I've heard this song and i CAN'T WAIT for the release of the new cd now!! GAHHH fun times in NYC..i wish i could have gone to this one..

[@bsilfan]

Did they play any other new songs? Post more videos man!

[@Diegol6835]

Thats not Rob

[@Zlash1]

This song is so amazing, it’a even better live in a crowded room. Ugh. Just perfection.

[@Pinkhairedtwerp]

2023 discovered this band months ago I LOVE IT❤

[@engi1394]

My favourites: never meant to know, Ruler of everything, the binding

[@morenzn]

[@TacoKing75]

no sound :(

[@DwightTheGreat]

I still have sound on a browser I'm not signed in on, so it may have to do with how you're viewing it.

[@Schlanket]

@@DwightTheGreatthere’s no sound for me either.

[@DwightTheGreat]

@@Schlanket I just checked on another browser I wasn't logged in on and it still works. There may be an issue with the app you're viewing it on.

[@MadCritter]

YEEEEEeEEEEAAAAAAAAaaaAAAhhhHHHH!

[@dabigtiny123]

I wish I could find the studio version. Listening to this song always reminds me of minecraft too.

[@Jegbmf]

Timothy Price uh. It’s on Spotify

[@3NTR4PT4]

ohh my god I thought I was the only one

[@dan182v]

Lmao I actually played this song while playing Minecraft

[@georgemalpass9278]

i heard that too actually i think i saw that same interview. i was just wondering is there was any update on that.

[@redheadbando]

Could someone please put up a video of this song that is not live? It would be greatly appreciated!

[@SteveProsser-wj7dz]

They are brilliant!