Tally Hall's final concert (for now)

[@AliceInRemnant]

0:00 - Intro 2:14 - & 5:36 - Cannibal 8:38 - Sacred Beast 11:36 - The Trap 16:30 - Turn The Lights Off 19:30 - You 22:27 - Good Day 25:56 - Out In The Twilight 28:53 - A Hymn for a Scarecrow 34:37 - The Whole World and You

[@rainespiano]

Thank you ;;

[@ellie.stargazer]

Very useful, thank you! :>

[@myaccounttolistentowestern5521]

Thanks random stranger

[@DanJFilms]

Hey are you alycat from discord?

[@AliceInRemnant]

@@DanJFilms nope, they have good taste in usernames though

[@coolertheory]

ross has confirmed that this video is the last time that all of them have been together in the same place and now this hurts even more to watch

[@nettashachar8526]

No cap I started crying after reading this

[@robin3746]

That hurts a lot

[@franz.francisco]

what the fuck, my heart man. this shit hurts

[@emlerrrr]

oh god when i heard him say that i burst into tears man i just. MISS THEM SOMUCH

[@rainespiano]

My hEarT-

[@coolertheory]

things that hurt: x being stabbed ✓ this comment section

[@rainespiano]

it hurts so much I can’t-

[@urapape4003]

what happened to my comment and others

[@lunariianna]

audience: "please take a moment to congratulate yourselves" youtube: please take a moment to cry

[@grayanddevpdx]

honestly accurate

[@TypoRaccoon]

Legend has it, Joe's mic is so quiet because he always believes his amp's too high

[@Cherno35]

It’s not, turn it up more

[@kevin_the_noob]

no turn it up more!

[@WheatMuncher3000]

No, TURN IT UP MORE!

[@pretzz3l]

NO TURN IT UP MORE ‼️‼️‼️🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥

[@EmeraldFox11]

the biggest mood are those two people at the front of the crowd who are constantly jumping and waving their hands around

[@remyowenmusic]

was one of those people me? it might've been me. if memory serves, my dad filmed this and I was up front. hmMMMmmMmMm

[@SanrioKyujitsu]

Joe In A Live Performance [2002-2008]: 😊 Joe In A Live Performance [2009-2011]: 🗿

[@farter_snail]

These guys were the Beatles of the 2000s

[@jasonsnusberry3654]

RIGHT?!

[@kakyoindonut3213]

this is the beatles if no one discover their music

[@nanah846]

@@kakyoindonut3213 they deserved more :(

[@intergraphenic]

i more thought of the beatles and queen as the tally halls of the 20th century

[@Plasmariel]

@@intergraphenic bruh

[@RaincloudTheDragonXD]

joe's mic try not to be extremely quiet challenge (impossible)

[@WaningLoon]

he needed to turn it up more

[@childeofepickness]

@@WaningLoonis my amp too high?

[@მჹძიiჹა]

@childofepickness3738 no turn it up more!!!!

[@Doctor_Ks]

we got more than 15 seconds of bora in here

[@remyowenmusic]

ayyyyyy

[@dwyl183]

the universe is collapsing

[@AbsBee863]

(More than) FIFTEEN SECONDS OF BORAAAA🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️‼️‼️‼️‼️🧡🧡🧡🧡🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@zawgtism]

Fun fact: In total, there are 41 &s in the song &.

[@remyowenmusic]

wow very cool, thank you ross federman, drummer of the band tally hall

[@palepelt]

joe looks so nervous and then ross is just vibing in the back

[@ratofthecity6351]

legends say nathan was the last person to hug zubin

[@adamnealon773]

Still waiting for that hiatus to end.

[@swiggaswoody]

me too, man. me too.

[@Whiteliteepic2]

We all are man

[@andyellis8490]

one day (hopefully)

[@EmeraldFox11]

forever holding onto hope

[@iamdoriian114]

Breaking News: still waiting...

[@abbiec2.089]

currently watching this on the final day of the 2010s knowing that this is the last decade tally hall ever performed

[@rainespiano]

I-

[@fam0uslastw0rds37]

shut

[@azekia]

@@user-ym2en4fm8h Technically, they are on hiatus and not really separated. But it's confirmed this is the last time all them were in the same place at the same time and it's almost the 1p year aniversary of this soo...

[@pciphidic]

DONT SAY THAT DONT

[@heelturn2]

this comment being 3 years old is insane to me

[@officialmaxrebo]

Bora gives me strong Willy Wonka vibes, I don’t know why. He has that charm to him, but also a sense of mystery and slight creepiness. The opening especially. Of course, Gene Wilder Wonka, I mean.

[@StaticFanfare]

Bora and the Chocolate Factory

[@Forcoy]

Bora and the 15 seconds factory

[@worstusernameintheworld9871]

15 seconds of Bora's Chocolate Factory

[@kitsune630]

Bora And The Louge Factory

[@Yakkymania]

and joe is the depp wonka

[@Paledoptera]

"for now" that hurts

[@remyowenmusic]

we were all young and naïve once

[@Robbity]

I feel like people named Nathan are the only ones who win Tally Hall contests lol

[@no_eyed_ryan7844]

god this makes me so sad. the comment section is so full of hope that they'd come back this year and 2018 is about to end. none of the predictions came true

[@capybara3668]

2019 now...

[@yeetbigly5827]

And now 2019 is about to end... :(

[@NOTADFIVE]

@@yeetbigly5827 yeeeup

[@geiayanami]

first day of 2020 and still nothing

[@mosaic6225]

third month now

[@PersonThingCreature]

"For now" Its been 13 years now 💀

[@Roll_dude]

11 years

[@ackewtful.]

1) lie down 2) try not to cry 3) cry a lot

[@sharkfin4194]

I used to scoff at other people listening to older bands saying they were born in the wrong generation. I understand now. I was six when that concert happened, I’ve been at that venue 2 years ago. And to think I only live 20 miles away from there, I’m going to go cry now.

[@straenmusikant7402]

i live all the way in germany, but i feel the same. their music is irreplaceable.

[@turtlebunny9386]

Those audio shifts make this 100x better, it sounds so eccentric

[@0ct0b3rt]

it sounds like an old vinyl, i enjoy it tbh

[@ruler_of_everything]

especially during The Whole World and You

[@LucyWest370]

It just sounds like badly done analog horror to me

[@Cadesworth]

@@LucyWest370yeah no it's annoying lmao

[@wangmclovin]

@@Cadesworth i agree it totally ruins "good day", especially the vocals and piano only part

[@thatsdree1350]

Aw man I wish I was there, and I wish I got into their music sooner

[@skittlesmurders8917]

BRO SAME

[@Vvyroa]

Same :-(

[@kamilak.4693]

same...

[@Amber_Greais]

Same my dude...

[@420Crows]

Love bora was an official orange tie

[@irisshimmer.]

someday. maybe not soon, but someday... please

[@emlerrrr]

oh my god this video hurts my heart,, it’s really unfortunate that so many of us are discovering them years later, they deserved all this new attention back then too :( i’d do anything to see them live someday..... not trying to get anyone’s hopes up as there’s no guarantee but back in february andrew confirmed there was still a chance of a reunion and last year joe said he believes the band will tour again at some point. there’s still a possibility for a reunion within the next few years. don’t give up hope yet

[@Vvyroa]

Just found them a few months ago. I feel so sad that they're no longer making music

[@emlerrrr]

me too :( there’s still a chance they could make a third album, things just haven’t really worked out in their favor so far but i’m really hoping they’ll get to make it eventually.

[@Vvyroa]

@@emlerrrr I hope they have realized how many people love them

[@emlerrrr]

me too. i think their fanbase is a lot bigger than they realize, and it’s only getting bigger

[@SwollyMammoth]

My guy, I discovered them last week and I wish I discovered them earlier

[@garfields2ndlasagna]

currently in 2024, so sad i never got to experience a tally hall concert in person. that third album better make up for it!!

[@bloodshotmorgue]

Just knowing this was the last time they were all together makes me cry. They were truly an amazing band and im so thankful for them.

[@robin3746]

I miss Tally Hall.

[@calicocat5589]

Me too bro 😔

[@residentdame2891]

been missing them < = {

[@madlapdog2552]

god speed you sweet sweet boys

[@justinflores6693]

My Chemical Romance got back together faster than Tally Hall

[@მჹძიiჹა]

STOP 😭

[@xliyy]

LMAOOOO i'm so depressed by this information

[@danielgiles2615]

Tally Hall are the only ones who can fix 2020

[@teaerrors5830]

Hope they reunite someday :')

[@Bruh-nr7ci]

They are the only ones who can give us something to look forward to

[@_.div._]

aged well

[@missing3434]

Well..

[@TallHally]

They can still fix it 3 years late, right?????

[@pineappel-qf2fv]

13 years since this very concert. hope everyone going to sonic lunch this week stays safe and has fun

[@Miki-ig3nx]

rips out hair and rocks back and forth

[@thedefaultperson]

don’t worry guys the third album is gonna be worth the wait. ill come back to this comment knowing that it aged well (It will not.)

[@LordHeg]

😔

[@luitpoldss]

Yes

[@RichardSoup]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/fpKup4GkgMeUsMk good News

[@chorigod8341]

Ever wonder

[@NumberOneRatedSaIesman1997]

:(

[@mnemo4528]

10 whole years since the last concert... At least we have footage of their concerts thanks to all the fans before us. Can’t wait to watch this again and sob

[@nomeanlol]

Wow, I was here! Thanks for uploading this. It was probably the heat messing with the camera, it was hot as hell.

[@rainespiano]

You are lucky

[@მჹძიiჹა]

Wow, I bet it was amazing!!! Your lucky lolo

[@mx_walkz4954]

I’M NOT CRYING, YOU ARE!!

[@Stickerznstitchez]

AGMayaLPS Honestly we’re all crying

[@mx_walkz4954]

Eyy Bby Quite true....

[@whoamiatthsipoint]

i am

[@Noodles_Poodle]

Yesterday was Andrew's performance at sonic lunch. I can't express how much joy I felt watching it. However now watching this gives me an empty feeling i can only describe as sadness.

[@pipersqueaks]

I live close enough to Pittsburgh and I almost had a breakdown when Bora mentioned it god damnit.

[@rainespiano]

Man that’s tragic

[@skelly1004]

Damn, I'm surprised they ended on The Whole World and You especially since it's from their first album and this was the tour for their second album.

[@shiyameowo]

i think of it as a farewell

[@pineapplesauce6509]

it was dedicated to the people at the concert

[@intergraphenic]

the '(for now)' part made me cry. at least we got miracle musical and admittedly incomplete demos. still, the hall is no more.

[@მჹძიiჹა]

The hall is no longer here for y’all

[@elijahorsmthh]

​@@მჹძიiჹაthe mini-mall is no longer calling us all in

[@TheRealDanTheManYT]

​@@elijahorsmthh I guess you could say they packed up their mom's car.

[@TerryElSquatchO]

"for now" (dies inside 5 times over)

[@johannakrier6597]

Why did I JUST now realize that in the song "&" they always say "and" on the half beat. Like if you were to count "1 and 2 and 3 and 4 and" it would line up. I spent 8 years in band class how did I miss that

[@rainespiano]

Woah-

[@everythingpizzaandknuckles6268]

That would only work in cut time

[@yourmother1483]

losing my mind over this i’m in concert band how did i not see this

[@flipcartoonstudios]

Gosh, this made me feel all sort of feelings... the moment Good Day (of all songs) started I knew my heart wouldn't handle it, but finishing it off with The Whole World and You? I really wish they'd perform together again ;-; (also, just in case someone needs it:) & - 2:12 Cannibal - 5:36 Sacred Beast - 8:38 The Trap - 11:36 Turn the Lights Off - 16:28 You - 19:31 Good Day - 22:27 Out in the Twilight - 25:55 A Hymn for a Scarecrow - 28:52 The Whole World and You - 34:37

[@kcin8486]

you, sir, are a hero.

[@rainespiano]

Thank you!

[@argelrowanachurra8615]

"AND TALLY HALL WAS NEVER HEARD FROM AGAIN!"

[@brunnojose807]

The Pitch Shift™

[@5catsinatrenchcoat]

2023, still waiting for the hiatus to end

[@Cherno35]

It’s never gonna end

[@kquiwi]

If they started doing touring again, the audiences would go crazy this time. I can already imagine it.

[@tom-on]

They are the type of people that will do a concert when they're all 80

[@elainekincaid7775]

“She’s a racist! Wait a second, I’m thinking of someone else.. Andrew?”

[@Froji]

i remember watching this for the first time at really late hours and i thought the pitch shifting was just me being tired and didnt question it

[@remyowenmusic]

incredible

[@TravisMoore5]

23:47 the whole band just decided to play a half age higher for a second

[@amazingpurplegirl0903]

I was around (I'm older than the guys) when they released MMMM, but they never made it internationally and I'm in the UK. But I firmly know I would have been so into their music if I'd heard it. They fit so well into my tastes. Only discovered them through Friday Night Funkin', of all things. Someone made a mod with Ruler and I was entranced

[@kquiwi]

If they ever go tour again, I am sure this time they would tour the UK, there are tons of Tally Hall UK fans now! :)

[@abbiec2.089]

i hope life was great for nathan

[@rainespiano]

Who’s Nathan?

[@caynix]

He’s a racist. No wait, that’s someone else

[@rainespiano]

caynix oh yeah Nathan Naimark?

[@lovemojiheartkiss]

his hand motions during the trap tho🙌5 stars

[@andyinreallife431]

2025, still waiting for the hiatus to end . . . . Making this in advance

[@luginess0]

Cool

[@kukuromouroseal]

i'd cry if it ddint ended

[@tom-on]

probs not wrong

[@coreythearmadillo]

I mean, there's still one more year

[@Mushroomelixir]

One more year goddamnit

[@yese2769]

I always wonder if they knew before hand that this was going to be their last consert

[@mjedghill13]

this hurts tho

[@rarecrom]

i know right???? it sucks how theyre not coming back dude

[@mjedghill13]

Brodie Abercrombie I'm crying

[@giblebro6898]

They are coming back together, I messaged Andrew on ig and he said there were no plans at the moment, but they still plan on getting back together.

[@littlestsnowy8177]

I really flipping hope they do come back together, I’m going to be spending all my money on the flight over (if they perform) and on their merchandise

[@SpadePyro]

When "for now" becomes a decade and counting with little chance if it happening due to Zubin's career as a doctor and Joe... well I feel like the other guys won't wanna work with him till he gets his head straight

[@remyowenmusic]

😢

[@Veryglupo]

Joe didn't do anything wrong tho.

[@SpadePyro]

@@Veryglupo he’s transphobic

[@Veryglupo]

@@SpadePyro no he's not, he never said anything transphobic the drama was over nothing.

[@straenmusikant7402]

@@SpadePyro I'm trans. I disagree with this statement. the drama was indeed over nothing expect pronouns. the guy is a grown adult, he's a bit rusty to understand twitter terms. we are here to appreciate their music, not dig dirt on our favourite musicians.

[@reallyhardy]

i am emotional this day. please think you're playing in a band again!

[@rainespiano]

They thought they were playing in band

[@მჹძიiჹა]

But they’d love to give you all a hand

[@Wispino]

Just got into there music about a week ago, instantly became obsessed. Now I’m sad that it’s 2020 and they’re still on Hiatus

[@rainespiano]

We are the late gang

[@clorox7623]

us

[@AceofClubsART]

Forever hiatus :(

[@nirradical]

I was there. Drove to Pittsburgh from Columbus. Saw these dudes about 10 times back in the day. We all knew it was somethin special.

[@მჹძიiჹა]

Wow… that sounds like such an amazing experience, I know it was worth it!!! Your quite lucky, hopefully one day I can do the same:)

[@sloop3720]

This made me so sad I can't even explain.

[@bassafratz]

Der's a snek in mah boot. PREPARE TO BE HAPPPPAAAAY www.google.com/amp/s/amp.reddit.com/r/tallyhall/comments/73ox9q/possible_tally_hall_reunion_concert_in_ann_arbor/#ampshare=www.reddit.com/r/tallyhall/comments/73ox9q/possible_tally_hall_reunion_concert_in_ann_arbor/

[@bassafratz]

AAHAHAHAHHH!!!!!!!

[@sloop3720]

BassFartz *_OOOOOOOO_*

[@rainespiano]

BassFartz well...

[@lovemojiheartkiss]

@@bassafratz did it happen?

[@rainespiano]

DONT WORRY GUYS THEY WILL BE BACK IN 50 YEARS!!

[@მჹძიiჹა]

ILL BE FUCKING 63 LMAOAOAOOAOA

[@rainespiano]

@@მჹძიiჹა I’ll be 65 😎just iMAGINE a bunch of 60-70 years olds watching old GRANDPAS oh god they would be very very very old by then

[@zinzamoure]

the last time they were all together. in one place. all recorded. rally hall !!

[@teaganyoumans]

Boy I tried so hard to hold it together until Andy started playing You... that hurt my heart so much cause it is just so dang beautiful T-T

[@azekia]

Joe is always so tense at the beggining of concerts it's actually cute

[@SunflowerSorrows]

God i wish that were me

[@octangulastella]

-Happy- 13 years since this.

[@rarecrom]

2020 i’ve been waiting for years plz

[@asecondhandidentity]

2018, and still on hiatus.

[@dyingsquid]

😔🤙🤙🤙we out here,,, 2018 tally hall stannies 😭

[@asecondhandidentity]

):

[@fastcarenjoyer8008]

I

[@octangula7914]

A reunion is very unlikely this year or next year because Ross is getting married and Rob and his wife are having a baby. Maybe 2020?

[@asecondhandidentity]

Who is Rob's wife? No matter how much I research I can't seem the find their spouses.

[@NOEYEDGURL]

LMAO THE PITCH SHIFTS SOUND SO STRANGE I LOVE IT

[@StaticFanfare]

The reason this video has all those pitch shifts is because it has been transplanted from an alternate timeline by someone who hated how big tally hall got.

[@remyowenmusic]

Most logical explanation

[@cormorantcolors]

I kinda like them

[@Mothpuff]

I wish we lived in that universe.

[@moss5448]

suffering all i feel is suffering

[@stormglory]

i genuinely want them to come back more than anything :( this makes me so sad

[@noromantichero]

when andrew was singing you, i felt so soft and in love

[@bigphatdummie5310]

lovecraftiandancefloor Yo same

[@PT55644]

@@skipandslide 19:30

[@gabriel-ri7hn]

i just recently discovered this band and they're so important to me :(. i know it's kind of unlikely but i hope they come back.

[@EmeraldFox11]

i am on my knees begging and hoping that that (for now) will come true, some day,

[@ashleig309]

22:35 that look Andrew gives Ross :)

[@rainespiano]

Why he do that tho

[@cheifjedi]

2020 still waiting for the haitus to end

[@just-bee-lieve]

thanks my heart hurts now,

[@nikane_]

As Coz said once, I hope another tour happens some day and all of us are able to go

[@icecreamsandwich7522]

I wish coz was able to go :-(

[@capt.robinwood]

@@icecreamsandwich7522 dont make me cry

[@მჹძიiჹა]

I was 1 when good and evil was released, discovered them last year from hidden in the sand randomly showing up while listening to Spotify when they play random recommended songs, I loved the song so I listendes to the rest of their songs and started to get more into the fandom, i really hope they come back, I would pay so much to see them live

[@FR3D0R4T0R]

this makes me v happy. But my heart hurts now :( i love them sm aaa

[@COLONELDYLANE]

still waiting patiently.

[@Alex_Lake_Shire]

Oh boy I can’t wait for the next concert

[@blooberry48]

me too

[@sheepsflan]

me three

[@childeofepickness]

me four

[@kukuromouroseal]

me five

[@AbsBee863]

me sixth

[@kakyoindonut3213]

(for now)... 9 years ago... oh the irony

[@lakinmarie]

“would it be appropriate to define that as epic” LMAOOOOO

[@plutokitty3386]

Joe looks so nervous! I want to give him a hug. :(

[@rainespiano]

He’s always so tense on stage ; - ;

[@plutokitty3386]

This comment didn't age well. I don't like Joe Hawley anymore after I found out he's not a very nice person :(

[@wash8533]

@@plutokitty3386 this is a pretty awkward comment

[@eduardapaes112]

why? I've always admired joe hawley, now I'm confused

[@plutokitty3386]

@@eduardapaes112 Joe has said some pretty mean and transphobic things in people's DMs. I get that he's under a lot of pressure, not very well educated about the subject and has some mental illness problems but it's still not great :(

[@ValeElPatetico]

I'll return to this comment when the hiatus ends

[@groob2204]

have fun doing that

[@dayransilva]

when?

[@ilovetallyhallalot]

Guess we'll never see him again

[@ratrightzIsCoolerThanYou]

This really hurts my heart tbh

[@geor42]

I can't get enough of that intro song

[@rainespiano]

&

[@caynix]

What’s the intro song called anyway

[@nettashachar8526]

Its 20fucking20 and still nothing JUST GIVE ME ANYTHING. A COVER. A SINGLE AN ALBUM, A CONCERT. ANYTHING

[@geiayanami]

i feel ya man 😞😞😞🤙🤙🤙

[@imnotcreative6904]

theres nothing i want more

[@cheesecake924]

Still nothing pookie

[@StrongWorkBand]

I am really happy that this is here. :D

[@arcade3198]

out of all of these mournful comments this is one of the only optimist ones ive seen, ive never looked at it like this before so thank you for that 😔🤘

[@StrongWorkBand]

Absolutely! They deserve it. We're all about giving 110%, too.

[@pulsaurs]

i miss tally hall so much anyways can’t wait to see you guys at 20 years since their last concert (/j hopefully i am never going to lose hope please tally hall come back)

[@rhombicosidodecahedron1653]

I feel sad, but hopeful, that this is only a cliffhanger for the next story. I don't feel like Tally Hall is gone for good.

[@მჹძიiჹა]

Me neither, with all the little things we’ve heard, I don’t think they’re quite done, I hope they atleast do 1 actual final concert, a real closing and I will be there

[@MezzyB0NB0N]

@@მჹძიiჹაhonestly idk ngl especially because of the Joe stuff :/

[@elainekincaid7775]

I want to know where Nathan is now

[@StaticFanfare]

Probably getting mad pussy

[@miqsm]

Still waiting

[@modifiedb0y]

it didn’t happen

[@miqsm]

@@modifiedb0y Still waiting

[@inonze7418]

@@miqsm Still waiting?

[@miqsm]

@@inonze7418 yup

[@arcade3198]

this hurts in ways i can't explain

[@tally_hal]

16:10 JOE SAID THE FUNNY E WORD