Timestamps 0:00:00 - Intro 0:00:40 - Rating Tamil Cinema of 2024 0:04:44 - Pan India Problem of Tamil Cinema 0:23:58 - Biggest Surprise of 2024 0:34:16 - Justice for Meiyazhagan 0:45:00 - Biggest Misfire of 2024 0:45:44 - Indian 2 0:55:58 - Kanguva 0:59:22 - Indian 2 vs Kanguva 1:03:24 - Shankar withour Sujatha 1:07:43 - Fav or Best Films of 2024 1:08:11 - Kottukaali 1:10:58 - Marco is here 1:11:50 - Kottukaali is something else 1:13:12 - Amaran 1:14:19 - Sai Pallavi Malayalam 1:17:03 - Meiyazhagan 1:19:14 - Vaazhai 1:23:09 - Raunaq Recommends 1:25:40 - Cool Comments 1:26:15 - Meiyazhagan part 3 1:29:52 - Film take we are in Minority for 1:30:38 - Captain Miller 1:33:20 - Bloody Beggar 1:35:47 - Joshua 1:37:09 - Dhruva Nachatiram 1:38:06 - Raayan 1:38:26 - GOAT 1:39:24 - Confusing Praise for me 1:39:35 - Vidhuthalai part 2 1:44:59 - Special Mentions 1:51:07 - Best Non-Tamil film 1:59:34 - Tamil Cinema in 2025 2:07:09 - Thangalaan 2:08:00 - Roundtable concludes 2:09:35 - chatting with Raunaq 2:10:30 - Telugu Roundtable? 2:11:00 - Malayalam Roundtable 2:11:10 - Conclusion
@jayarajcg20534 күн бұрын
Manjumal boys worked in tn, premalu worked in Telugu states and now Marco is doing great in the Hindi belt. On top of it having hits in every month. This was the year of Malayalam cinema
@rainfire37984 күн бұрын
The fact that meiyazhagan, lubber pandhu, kootukaali and vaazhai came so close to each other really affected their box office potential eventhough meizhayagan, vaazhai and lubber pandhu had a decent start.
@Im_SiVA3 күн бұрын
This was a surprise nona ! These are the people i follow along with you. Enjoyed the whole "Round table".
IMO, the comparison of how Telugu became ‘pan-Indian’ is a good one. I think it broke the Hindi vs regional binary for good and we now see everything as Indian cinema. But beyond that, box office should be looked at slightly differently, not across film industries but: 1. Which producers got how much box office - this tell Ms us which producers are healthy and which aren’t. 2. What genres made how much money - this tells us what the people want to see. Within this also we should consider which heroes can command what box office - because a super star movie is a genre in itself in India.
@RjRam93 күн бұрын
It is Movie Buff's round table >>> Critics round table. Loved it, it was excellent discussion.
@ppgamerbucket336410 сағат бұрын
As a telugu guy Tamil big budget movies are bad Small budget movies are too good and not promoted well. Failing to catch pulse of audience. they are not promoting well in Hindi. My fav Tamil movies are Meizhgan , lumber banthu, Maha raja
@bharathkumar.vbharath93923 күн бұрын
As a critic box office numbers may not bother you guys. But as a industry with so many people working behind the sets like light man, those who prepare sets etc those who gets paid on a daily basis. Getting industry a give box office number is very important to fight inflation. So a bigger reach and box office success from rest of India is something which will help everyone who works in creating a movie.
@RM-gq5jv2 күн бұрын
You really think those industries pay these people more than they do in Tamil? 1000 crore films only benefit the producers no one else.
@sheetalkathreya4 күн бұрын
Very good discussion YOU KNOW!
@dineshghilli19 сағат бұрын
Meiyazhagan was relased between 2 big movies,.bad release. They expected 2. Weeks enough to recover. Sep 5th - GOAT release. Which was the biggest opening of 2024 and biggest collection in TN. It was no.1 for 3rd week. Spe 20 - Lubber Bandhu - That was suprise one. Noone expected the movie would have big run. Its first weekend GOAT was no1 then next week onwards it took the no1 till vettaiyan. Sep 27 - Meizhagan - it was bad release. When Lubber bandhu was running well, this movie was not able to hold the screens. It was month end as well. People must not need to spend for movies.. Oct 10 - Vettaiyan replaced the screens.. Before GOAT, no big movies came. They should have released before.
@Kannanv203 күн бұрын
The list is missing: 1. Pogumidam Veguthooramillai 2. Deepavali Bonus 3. Jama
@Tamizh-ArasiyalКүн бұрын
01:04:12 Nonsense lady. Sujatha Mama himself stole the story from 1997 short story
@subbunittala2012Күн бұрын
Actually heros ..i.e telugus makes less noise on interviews and more on box office
@v.jshaarugshan60652 күн бұрын
Amaran disappointing movie?🙄.One of the best tamil movie of 2024
@balakrishna-ro1cc4 күн бұрын
The timline twist is inspired by Westworld I guess, not that i watched or planning to watch.
@maxl20624 күн бұрын
Why don’t you address the elephant in the room? 1. Hindu scriptural references which gives an emotional connection, eg. Kantara, Baahubali, RRR and Pushpa 2. Women sentiment- mother/wife/sister. 3. Same old underdog story. These have all been tried and tested in Hindi, Tamil & Malayalam. They are looking for fresher ideas. B&C centres are not ready in the North. They want what’s familiar to them. Also, Tamil does not have mass heroes anymore. VJS and Dhanush are actors first. Vijay & Ajith are too old. Telugu will rein for the next 10 years. No doubt.
@NilsCh-k7x4 күн бұрын
lol
@veenasudheer85322 күн бұрын
Cinema is beyond your stars. Get out of that delusion and then call your industry as superior...
@tnstock742Күн бұрын
Funny comment don't comment again 😂.
@All_is_well262Күн бұрын
Bro you don't know anything about the Cine industry I think😅
@yashaswinikrishnan187811 сағат бұрын
ykw, this makes sense, idk why you're getting so much hate
@jayarajcg20534 күн бұрын
I have great hopes on coolie and thug life. I think these both movies would set any benchmark
@randombytes233 күн бұрын
but the question is why did you not watch enough Telugu movies?
@dineshghilli110 сағат бұрын
You know I think What to say...
@OverPowered662673 күн бұрын
Mukunde Mukunde...😂 She was going on and on..
@yashaswinikrishnan187811 сағат бұрын
still not as annoying as alia in brahmastra. indhu rebecca atleast felt like a central character and not just a side character
@pvikramadithya2 күн бұрын
I've noticed that this Vishal Menon always has only negative things to say about tamil cinema.. He even had negative to talk about Meiyazhagan and not the positives.. needs to change his attitude.
@பாயிரம்ஆயிரம்4 күн бұрын
No one talked about Vidamuyarchi and Good Bad Ugly for 2025. Ajith had 2 releases in 2025 😊
@krizzkarthick23114 күн бұрын
cos they r 2k critics who thinks they r best of best but they r brat
@S.NAVEENKUMAR-gl5mw3 күн бұрын
Lot of good movies in Tamil cinema✨💕 example more national awards more international awards no rights to talk about Tamil cinema telugu qualities 💩
@NutsY_082 күн бұрын
10:00 if she said GOAT didn't performed well outside TN becouse of CSK culture or rooted to TN i literally laughed sorry to say If u tale CSK culture as a whole TN will not even be 15% if im not wrong when u take india as whole north even other states pf south has CSK culture bcoz of MSD and all Thats not the reason for sure may be it needed to be more crisp in screenplay and story telling
@PK-pz9kuКүн бұрын
Asha Meera is not fit to be a reviewer.
@balakrishna-ro1cc4 күн бұрын
Guys and lady, i get it meiyyazhagan is a really good film but my god...
@rahuljig17312 күн бұрын
I am not seeing telugu industry people in roundtables may be telugu cinema speaks loud at box office not round tables😂😂 I am seeing tamil and hindi industries people are showing up more on roundtables than in theatres😂😂which shows they are only interested in defending themselves at roundtables than making successful films😂😂
@tnstock742Күн бұрын
One 1000 cr film and then rest flop movie jokers you guys are funny 😂.
@rahuljig173115 сағат бұрын
@tnstock742 abey clown not one so many bahubali rrr pushpa animal kalki so many will come in future too and you guys keep crying as usual 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@rahuljig173115 сағат бұрын
@tnstock742 Bahubali RRR pushpa animal kalki now start crying again as u do forever in your life 🤣🤣
@Tamizh-ArasiyalКүн бұрын
26:32 Much better than your husband's Movie "Sardar" Aashameera Aunty
@nareshchandra51594 күн бұрын
Why you guys are not conducting Telugu cinema roundup table. You guys only conducting Malayalam or tamil cinema roundup table 👎👎👎👎. Discrimination across cinema.
@professor.georgekutty4thst754 күн бұрын
Maybe Language issue
@பாயிரம்ஆயிரம்4 күн бұрын
@@nareshchandra5159 they should do. I am a Tamil but yet support you
@rainfire37984 күн бұрын
The number of good films coming from telugu and kannada is not that high except few obvious ones. Smaller intimate telugu films are not reaching them and outside telugu because even in telugu it's not working except hardcore cinephiles
@mohammedirfan8023 күн бұрын
Coz balayya is beyond criticizm
@bharathkumar.vbharath93923 күн бұрын
🤦🏻@@mohammedirfan802
@abhiradh16544 күн бұрын
Meiyazhan is hit kerala..
@harshanamburi31453 күн бұрын
Telugu Cinema is ruling India because we are masters of Creative commercial cinema. But we produce good content films too, but they are not getting publicity. Top content films in Telugu 2024 are: 35 china cinema kadu Ghani Pekamedalu Commitee Kurallu Lucky Bhaskar Swag many more..... Marketing Problem
@KS-pc2fb3 күн бұрын
This is not look like movie roundtable.. Look like minority political people industry roundtable..this guy not getting from telugu industry and kannada industry because this people had agenda because this both industry celebrities hindu richvall
@markivwilson28913 күн бұрын
They didn't even talk about anything political. But go on, chirp.
@maheshkondepudi71923 күн бұрын
Why you guys are not conducting Telugu cinema Tamil sambar 😂
@balakrishna-ro1cc4 күн бұрын
Let ashameera talk men
@NickyEmDeeКүн бұрын
You know you know you know you know
@balakrishna-ro1cc4 күн бұрын
Jai hind bro lets go home
@roboticsforlife3 күн бұрын
Tamil cinema is too focused on its own politics (Dravidian political bullshit). When they get out of that and make cinemas that are relatable to regular people, then Tamil cinema will rise.
@Sanad-uq8db3 күн бұрын
🤣🤣🤣🤣 you know shit about Tamil cinema
@NickyEmDeeКүн бұрын
lol. That’s not the case. Even if it is, it’s our story. Step away.
@All_is_well262Күн бұрын
Believe us bro we don't give a damn for political skits 😂
@harshanamburi31453 күн бұрын
As a telugu guy . I liked only Meiyazhagan from Tamil cinima. Classic . 96 director is super. Rest all are overrated.