Who was Responsible for the Security of APS Peshawar? | Episode 2 | The APS Files

[@filmyprofessor_99]

My Father when went to the war I asked him that you will take revenge of kids of APS and he told me yes and I also going to told you how He send me a picture of a machine guns and missile and they righted on it "this is from the martyred kids mothers for the enemies" My Father Martyred in that war Lance Naik Subhaan Afridi Khyber regiment

[@newguyat77]

sorry for your loss

[@core2reveal]

Untill how long we will remain emotional and impractical? Enemies are inside. Enemies of pakistan are inside. It is obvious, it is clear. Still we are living in dreamland. Your father is martyred. Sorry for the loss.

[@Saifei757]

Stop the cap. Send us the pictures

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@Saifei757 it's on ISPR I don't have his picture because he died in 2015 actually fun fact I bought this phone 1 month ago

[@Saifei757]

@@filmyprofessor_99 bro tf?

[@xtenxion]

It was a complete failure of pakistan army and the intelligence. Its a shame that we haven't learn from our mistakes. We are still negotiating with those who killed our innocent children.

[@gulkhan7451]

Strongly agree with you Bro it was inside job like 9/11

[@SunGsam-rd7tu]

So sad. Who killed these little kids and who is Pakistan still negotiating with? Sorry I don't know the whole story. But this is heartbreaking 💔

[@enterthelegions]

Pakistan was losing it's funding from their American daddy so they sacrificed few of our own for dollars. ISI , MI both knew. Just how they sold out our national heroes like AQ Khan for please their American fathers for dollars. Just like at what deep state is doing to a nation that was built on foundation of unity, faith and discipline.

[@SunGsam-rd7tu]

@@enterthelegions thats is very sad. So it wasn't the taliban?

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@gulkhan7451 lol America planned to attack Afghanistan 2 months before 9/11 And when Aps attack was occurred army was already doing operation in Waziristan which was started in June after Jinnah Airport attack

[@darkmoon5292]

APS stands for Army Public School. I myself have studied in APS throughout my whole life. Almost 70% of the children belong to Army officers or soldiers families. Imagine the grief of those families too. The feelings that they were supposed to be the protectors of their, as well as all the other children who studied at APS.

[@af-vx6bm]

Army is too occupied in their business activities- real estate, logistics, etc- to counter any major security threats. No wonder we are on brink of being collapsed and yet army generals have amassed billions of dollars .

[@newguyat77]

The APS incident incidents raises the following questions. 1. Though TTP is mainly pasthun organisation , why is no pashtun was not involved in the attack? 2. why it was foreign terrorists ,who were most likely stand out without knowing Pastho or Urdu , was involved in the attack? 3. why was that 90 percent of the school children who passed away were children of civilians and why less army officer's children was killed? 4. who was the retired Brigadier who was named by the Ehsanullah Ehsan ,TTP person as the mastermind of attack? 5. How did Ehsanullah Ehsan miraculously escaped and reached Turkey? 6. why Pakistan is not getting Ehsan from Turky (with whom has an extradition treaty with pakistan) , if he is a wanted criminal? 7. why was security persons removed from the APS days before the incident? 8. How did the terrorists Car reach peshwar without stopped at the Numerous check posts ? 9. what is the meaning of words "No agency, no matter how capable or equipped, could effortlessly counter an attack "when infidels are within the inside". mentioned in the justice Mohammed Ibrahim commission report"? 10. why did QRT was not able to respond on time in a cantonment area, when QRT never reached the destraction area ? 11. why was askari Guards , a company of army welfare trust , in charge of security was not made accountable?

[@chetanx]

Sorry for losses. But you missed main pt. TTP got power from ISI. And ISI played double game here but they didn't know this will hurt them in future. Hope your govt should get some lessons and hopefully they will stop funding terrorist.

[@Unknowneditszzszz]

still remember this day 7 years ago 16 dec 2014

[@direwolf7903]

This channel is doing great work 👑

[@rimshaawan7425]

U unfolded many realities on those bold topics which one can't talk openly due to fear of being caught by security forces

[@islamiclab4648]

میں نے اس ویڈیو میں ایک بات نوٹ کی ہے کہ جن والدین کے بچے شہید ہوئے ہیں وہ ابھی تک ہماری گورنمنٹ / سکیورٹی اداروں سے مطمئن نہیں ہوئے. یہی سب سے بڑا المیہ ہے. اس کے محرکات پر غور کرنے کی ضرورت ہے

[@gamingworld3428]

TCM doing great job love you guys show the truth to the peoples of pakistan ❤

[@shaantanuasthana5942]

45to 18 reduced army personnels Army removed from back side just days before the attack what does that mean

[@mir3877]

I would like to know how much terrorist attacks got foiled by our security forces. Those should also be highlighted.

[@sanjaykandari3722]

Normal humans were not responsible, neither were your security forces. The responsibility lay with the minds which were brainwashed into believing that they were participating in a JIHAD by slaughtering little children. May Allah give you justice and peace.

[@seharnoor645]

This is not Jihad,its terrorrism. Dont mix jihad with terrorrism

[@ManishMishra-mv5fp]

@@seharnoor645 what you are saying and believing (seeking difference between jihad and terror due to your religious beliefs) is exactly the root cause of the problem which leads to such horrible incidents. Ye jihad alag, terror alag type ki soch hi Pakistan ne paali posi hai, peedhi dar peedhi. Jo aaj uske apne fool se masoom bachho ka mustaqbil kharaab kar chuki hai. And you still behave like ostriches stuffing your heads under the ground. I'm sorry for harsh words but this is a brute reality of Pakistani society and cultural development of last 70 years.

[@seharnoor645]

@@ManishMishra-mv5fp itna lamba paragraph likhnay se phlay jihad ka matpab search kr lena tha,stop mixing jihad with terrorism

[@ManishMishra-mv5fp]

@@seharnoor645 Attack was carried out by Fazlullah. And the execution is done by Haji Kamran. Mulla aur Haji ko bhi nahin pata aapki "difference between Jihad and Terrorism"!? Kisi ko nahin pata. Bas terror apologists ko pata hai Jihad aur terrorism alag hain.

[@seharnoor645]

@@ManishMishra-mv5fp I will again say you instead of writing useless paragraphs go and search what jihad really is

[@annusrasool]

Who was responsible for security lapse ? Why was security taken away from APS even after the threat ?

[@kaprivenom5316]

Unforgettable tragedy 😢😢😢😢

[@tahirali-is1kx]

15:13-15:33 i don't know whether to laugh or cry my heart out.

[@misha.k8565]

A thorn which will always inflict us 💔

[@saniaaisha5108]

when is 3rd episode coming ?

[@user-gs7cr7pu9s]

Speechless 💔💔

[@mbganesamoorthy7773]

It is not a security lapse, it is an operation planned by the Pakistani establishment to erase the memory of loosing east Pakistan to become Bangladesh from the minds of the people , Pakistani establishment felt that Pakistani people needed a new event to remember on 16 - December.

[@syedarkhamkhan]

Well nobody here gives a shit about east Pakistan to be honest bruh

[@shoukatalipanhwar2113]

@tcmorginals please give us more information like these videos and also make on Iqbal Javed

[@hafizhamiz9148]

We have one more problem When any civilian is asked for checking at army check post. 98% of them start fighting with the soldier on duty that why are you checking us. This attitude also needs to be curbed

[@khalidabaloch8875]

Can Anyone tell us the name of that ex-general of Pakistan Army who was involved in that attack and he was among those who were the masterminds of APS attack. Arrest that general you will get the result. I know the Taliban was the part of that attack but our own person i.e Army person ( who take oath for safety of us and this Country) was part of that plan made for attack. #APS_attack #Pak_Army #Peshawar_attack #16_december_2014

[@filmyprofessor_99]

If Pakistan army was behind this attack then there was 75 dead children belongs to the army men

[@filmyprofessor_99]

If Pakistan army did this attack what was there motive

[@khalidabaloch8875]

@@filmyprofessor_99 I am not blaming the whole Army. There are many brave army men to whome I call the real petriots and several black sheeps are also in Pakistan Army. I am asking about the ex-general who was involved in the masterminds of this attack.

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@khalidabaloch8875 OK then what about the video of Mullah Fazalulah video available on dailymotion You should know that was not a first failure that an army area was attacked I also want to tell you a PRADE Lane mosque in with Majority of army in Jumma Mubarak blew up by the terrorist when they were in prayers in 2009 In Lahore Wagah Border which takes 79 innocent lifes

[@core2reveal]

@@filmyprofessor_99 I am sorry for the loss of your father but you need to accept and understand the truth. Not all but many are involved in this game. Since many years, there are terrorists, we kill them, then they come into being, again and again. What is this? How is it possible? Many soldiers are fighting, they are martyred, but terrorists keep coming. Many agencies, intelligence departments, money, protocols, operations, expenditures are continue on and on and on.

[@maikada4831]

jinho nay Intelligence failure kiya whi responsible hain is brutel attack k liay and they are enjoying abroad 😢

[@ShahidKhan-rc6yb]

I want a share a story here ,one day I was moving by car whom the driver was Afghani ,when we reached at gora qabrastan , there I found some army soldiers where they were deployed for the checking but here I was very shocked when the soldier asked him (driver) ,that where u want to go ,he said Peshawar but he didn't ask from driver to show him his identity and also didn't ask car's paper and that soldier even didn't search other passengers and that soldier was a Punjabi. So this is the responsibility of army and agencies . Agencies and army are responsible of that tragic nightmare.

[@ahha351]

Why you highlighted Punjabi....I mean you can just say a soldier....what is Punjabi soldier

[@KhalidTheConqueror]

​@@ahha351 well we all know Punjabi are in the army ....... I agree he shouldn't have mentioned it we know all Punjabi are in Punjab army I mean Pakistan army

[@AyazAli-cc1vh]

10 years and a month😢 2024. May Allah gives all the souls a place in heaven 😮😢

[@mr.pakistan1975]

I was in 1 class back then i studied in APS sialkot then and even now. I remember that army took control of school and also came with dogs and like this because at that time the APS peshawar attack was going and we didnt know about what was happening and after ,y parents took me ftom school they told me that APS peshawar has been attacked by terrorists and . That really was worst day for Pakistan and humanity. I still remember each and everything and afterwards the attack army was given the security of APS in Pakistan and until now.

[@materockk1579]

What security ? 400 children dead you fool

[@shraddhagupta7045]

@@materockk1579 126

[@shraddhagupta7045]

Shame on u

[@mr.pakistan1975]

@@shraddhagupta7045 144

[@mr.pakistan1975]

@@materockk1579 i said they improved after the attack. Read carefully.

[@affanity.x9268]

9:27 agreed.

[@umersultan2229]

for all those blaming the govt and Army in comment section, the dynamics were different back then. we were at our worst .. the terrorism was at peak from 2005 to 2015 .. we have lost alot of blood.. civilians.. army.. everyone has been martyred in various attacks across pakistan. May Allah Help us Counter terrorism and all the internal and external enemies once and for all.

[@Arsalan.Sarwar]

Please don't mix this incident with whole Pakistan, This was an Army area which was suppose to be safe, in the video it was said Army was removed before attack and where is master mind Ahsan ullah ahsan? He fled from Army custody. Why not action taken against people who are responsible for security lapse and negligence and lastly terrorism was not at peak in 2015.

[@umersultan2229]

@@Arsalan.Sarwar I'm Not saying that those who were responsible for APS security lapse shouldn't be punished, but drawing a stetch that in those times.. no one was safe.. airports, airforce bases, universities, markets, cantonments every place was equally vulnerable. even ghq got attacked.. police lines got attacked.. but this was the lowest point for sure.

[@Arsalan.Sarwar]

@@umersultan2229 2014 was not lowest point, condition was much better. Lowest was 2010 or 2011. After 7 years still no one punished. And there is zero return. Even CM of KP is Federal Minister and was not held responsible.

[@aliammar5651]

Huh Huh Huh, Pak Army involvement is getting obvious

[@filmyprofessor_99]

Hahahah 😂 my father was martyred in this war and he told that we in this war they write on their missles and bombs that "This from Pakistani mothers of APS for the enemies" Lanat 🖐️ 🖐️ 🖐️ 🖐️ 🖐️

[@filmyprofessor_99]

If Pakistan army was involved in it then there were 75 children of Pakistan army And what about Wagah Border blast it was another failure of Pakistan army killed 79 innocents

[@aliammar5651]

So Pak Army hired puppets for social media too. Stop defending these corrupt generals for the sake of a small amount. Go and get a life man and stop licking ISPR A**

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@aliammar5651 First tell me if army was really involved what was the motive

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@aliammar5651 My Father is Lance Naik Subhaan Afridi martyred in Mohammand Agency What about Mohsin Dawar PTM wise chairman who appreciated American drone strikes in the Tribal region his tweets are still in the backyard

[@zunairazaini6118]

Still remember that day😢😢😢

[@thegreat1330]

In begairato sey karobaar karwa lo ya zameeno pay qabzay karwa lo bus

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

1 fojy bhai jan ke clip viral ho choke hai ye k asal kahani kya te be es clip me shamil kre honest journalism ka taqaza hai ?

[@shahrukhdetho]

Wipe out the tears yaaarrr Pakistanis are again friends with TTP, TLP .. happy end .. get ready for tragedies like we Shia's are used to crying

[@zahrahaideri6100]

Agreed. 💔

[@alijee6319]

APS So Sad & Painful Incident For Every Pakistani

[@justshorts7780]

Never Forgot Nor Forgiven

[@alijee5811]

It's Was Completely Failure Of Our Intelligence Agencies 16 December 2014 Black Day For Pakistani History When APS School Terrorist Attack In Peshawar

[@asadali1382]

TCM❤

[@aylaahmed5905]

how bad it been seven years ??? feels like yesterday

[@ahsanzaheer5636]

Negligence was due to forget dhaka falll

[@ronydev4982]

This incident was no doubt performed with help of traitors in high commands 😔..... According to my research... ☹️

[@bulbaly62]

😢

[@ANkhan314]

Any one who involved in this ALLAH will punishe them in this world and also in akherat

[@unsung1926]

Despite warning and alerts why they did not evacuate the children from school

[@AhsanAhsan-x4q]

😢😢

[@khizriyaat..5423]

I hope main ink lie kch kar sakta....Just crying...But Inshallah one day...😊

[@iftikharhussain1454]

Qayamat ka hisab khuda nai isi liyai rakha hai, khuda inn jaanwaron ka hisabb laiga.

[@et8759]

One of the child said they were speaking pushto but there were afghans chechnian and arabs! How come Arab knew pushto??!!

[@keepsmiling5937]

Sad

[@THE-CONSIGLIERE]

The Property Developers were to busy buying up land and selling homes…

[@KhalidTheConqueror]

May be did that for funding and stuff ..... Can't expect something good from them

[@adnanmuhammadWali]

TCM presents reality

[@sehrishzahir6745]

Whether it's the army or TTP, what's the point of targeting innocent children? I mean why? Just cannot understand that..

[@baoali3098]

Aslamoalikum...

[@trixie2561]

I just believed and loved only 1 thing in this country and believed that to be loyal and that was our army.... These videos totally ruined that and changed my perspective.. Its now very safe to say that confidently that Pakistan is a lost cause, no hopes.

[@52nooruddin]

Lumber 1 agency

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

imran khan khalifa riasat e Madina sharif ka Dhrna jb khtm howa aur ghar phonchaa tu reham khan ko kya bola vo be shamil kre es clip me pls ?

[@IrfanAli-sn8uz]

Pakistan ki agencies ny bhuat Koshish ki ky katloon ko pakren unhon ny din rat bhaut mhnat ki lekin jab kuch nah Mila phr ISPR ny mili nagma release kr dia "Mujhe dushman ky bachoon ko purhana. Hy"

[@IrfanAli-sn8uz]

Sir Pakistan me kisi ko koi insaaf nah milna liquat Ali Khan sy ly kr Arshad Shareef Tak kisi ko koi insaaf nah Mila.

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

azaz syed be nawa e Waqt ka saat de rha hai ?

[@abuqasimafridi6903]

Who was realy behind those inocent and mass asacinating and according to centence bodies of that time .reply

[@Faraz70]

Na - Pak fauj Murdabad Na - Pak fauj Murdabad Na - Pak fauj Murdabad

[@filmyprofessor_99]

Ttp Murtadeen murdabad

[@quratdelulu]

🙌🙌🙌

[@Islamandjihad]

Napak america ki gulam foj murdabad

[@mythbusterUSA]

16:41 they attacked the school only because it is Army public school. Their target was military personnels kids.

[@filmyprofessor_99]

Absolutely I was also in APS 8th standard but not in Peshawar Mullah Fazalulah video is still available on dailymotion

[@tariqbj622]

But still majority of the victims were civilian kids. Such a lame narrative you've adopted

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@tariqbj622 OK then what about a PRADE Lane mosque attack where our armed forces were offering Jumma prayers and the Whole jamaat was blew up by the bomb in 2009 Rawalpindi

[@tariqbj622]

@@filmyprofessor_99 Still making lame arguements, we're talking about APS attack not that other one which might not be causef by military etc, whatever, at the moment we're concerned with the APS victims that must be addressed, which no doubt was bcoz of the blunder & negligence of the intelligence & secuirity departments, specially pak army bcoz that specific cantt region was under the resposinsibility of the 102 brigade of army.

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@tariqbj622 bro you should know that was not the first time that an high profile Army areas were attacked and intelligence failure was part of it...... Wagah Border Prade Lane GHQ rawalpindi FIA building Lahore Etc Late. Saeed Saleem Shahzad in his book have written that the bloodshed between army which was stopped during the Coup of Musharraf in 1999 was again started after Pakistan joining a so called war on terror I believe that some Pakistani Local troops were used in all this

[@Abdullahs_World]

I was doing B.A that time...

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

tahira qazi the principal jo ke mere class fellow be te ko be Vardy terrorists safe passage b dena chahe but she refused to budge ? unke azmat joraat ke lei surkh salamunas

[@jack.sparrow994]

Bkwas krty hyn yeh k Attack mulla fazlullah ny krwaya TTP ne krwaya Awam ko yeh na sunao k kese hua, kiu hua, kab hua, kis ne kia Army, Police, Agencies, Govt. Of Pakistan tum sb responsible ho. Bs TV pr bkwas krny a jaty ho

[@Islamandjihad]

Bilkul sahe yae awam ko bus pagal banatae hae

[@arAyeshaa]

😣😞😞😞😞

[@Imran_khan1781]

💔💔💔💔

[@shahjhanwagarpal7120]

terrorists hai kon yre jo aap onhe social media par aane se rokte ho ?

[@Maximushira]

Sir plz make a detailed video on target killing and bomb blast on hazara people of quetta It start s 1999 to 2018 2019 Non of them get caught yet and same lollypop they use Plz i kindly request u Thanks

[@ayankhan4653]

Why gvmnt was ignor the thrates Or warning about APS😥why they dont give a perfect security to Aps y....???

[@supergamesvideos8450]

Is mei Zaroor army k log involve hogey

[@filmyprofessor_99]

Lol yeh koi pehla army ka failure nahi thaa Jaahil Wagah Border ka area bhi army ka hi thaa jahan dhamaka hoa wahan bachay borhay jawan sab shaheed hoay

[@filmyprofessor_99]

Acha takreeban 75 bachay kay army kay hi thay unn ka kya woh bhi shaheed hoay

[@supergamesvideos8450]

@@filmyprofessor_99 absolutely👍

[@aliyanshah4592]

@@supergamesvideos8450 he is everywhere defending defense nobody is against army but he can't accept truth it seems by his statement

[@quratdelulu]

@@aliyanshah4592 and repeating the same lines

[@rohitsuri5982]

Very. Unfortunate happening

[@neo6183]

title should be changed from "Who was responsible for security of APS PEshawar?" to "Waiting Justice for APS Peshawar" . Very lame to blame army whose own kids were martyred in this heinous incident.

[@tariqbj622]

No way, the Question will still remain the same as it is no doubt the negligence of secuirity and intelligence departments, and still they shamelessly never admitted their blunders. We didn't actually say that they were involved (Allah knows that better), but atleast the resposibility of secuirity was of them, and there is confusion about that ..!

[@filmyprofessor_99]

@@tariqbj622 bro you should know one more tragic incident was held in Rawalpindi that our armed forces in Prade Lane mosque where army men offer prayer of Jumma was blown up by the terrorists

[@aliyanshah4592]

@@filmyprofessor_99 ahhh sometimes forces are divided they use terrorist to attack army places so blame is directly on Terrorist Its a strategy

[@neo6183]

@@aliyanshah4592 sadqay jaaoon apki uqqal pr ....chor ka Pata bhi Hai or phir bhi uss say dobara chori krwao ..... bauht hi chawwwal insaan ho yaar tum

[@aliyanshah4592]

@@neo6183 bro accept it or not at that time my uncle who was a major General told us how may kids of army guys were present and many army kids were absent at that time Then how could terriost with heavy weapons ieds easily passed from checkpoint army one Its a cant area not civilian area Upto u truth is always hated

[@zjroman1705]

I don't know how can someone blame army and called this army failure.... there were hundrends of students they did save rest of them

[@shraddhagupta7045]

Army ki glti h government ki glti h. Aur pak ab bhi vhi glti kr rha h

[@mercilessjury...1841]

Geo k reporter ko ye nahi pta k agr koi compromised person highest level ki national security committee meeting Mai ho tu phir sub agencies fail ho jati hain is liay zaruri hai ISI ki clearance ... Ye geo ary express war nahi national security ka matter hai .

[@shahbukhari6649]

yeh cantt area ma ata hai kisi ko kya khabar thi yahan bhi attack ho jaye ga.............

[@filmyprofessor_99]

Yeh pehli baar is a nahi hai kay Kent area mein hamla hoa hai 10 baar hoa hai different cities different sectors even GHQ

[@aliyanshah4592]

@@filmyprofessor_99 are u the guy from establishments who is trying to against the true story and not letting it out Everyone loves army our pride But let the truth come out

[@shraddhagupta7045]

Pakistan ne avi v apni glti nhi sudhari aur sbse badi problem ki glti manati bhi nhi h

[@trixie2561]

wow... APS ko protect nai kr paye India k lye bari bari baten krtay hn, These videos totally destroyed my respect and changed my views for our army.

[@aribaanjum5761]

having an opinion in general makes sense, but claiming that one online media publish destroyed your views or respect makes you sound a foolish already! am not saying this might or might not be true, but believing in something from hearing one side only wether wherever you are in life is totally absurd.

[@mir3877]

@@aribaanjum5761 This is not one side. This is the other side. One side is the one that is shown by all the media etc and shows what we would like to believe. Before someone has seen this other side he lives in a fools paradise. But we simply like to ignore this ugly other side.

[@HamzaKhan-jb9jz]

No doubt Pak army is best

[@carpakistanofficial449]

Why are you blaming army dickheads? Astagfirullah . Army kis kis jaga ko sambhalay ? agar aik fouji jump na karta tou ye shootin kaafi dair tak chalti rehti

[@trixie2561]

kia matlab army kis kis jgha ko smbhalay.... Its Army Public School and College, It comes under no govt but Army and Army only..... Agar Army apnay institution nai smbhal skti phr ye to pakistan h pura.

[@shraddhagupta7045]

U fool this is a army school sudden army ko hta diya kyu