TDA: What if Alejandro and Sierra were in Island? CONTINUATION Part 1

[@pankakequeen6080]

Loving this so far! I’m so happy with how you utilized Trent’s 9 Obsession and used it as a way to bring Gwent together rather then tear them apart! That was one of my biggest complaints with canon Action. I’m also loving all the new interactions, I never knew how good a Sadie and Heather friendship or a Duncney rivalry would be! Overall, way better the canon imo. Can’t wait for the next part!!

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! really glad you're enjoying it

[@serenepastel]

The Sadie storyline is such a standout. I wouldn’t have guessed Heather would be able to help her become the person she needs to be, but that is such a nice friendship. Plus, it makes total sense why Heather would know what clothes would look good in Sadie, given her past struggles with her weight. The Gwen and Tyler storylines as also really nice additions. Gwen able to develop relationships, both romantic and platonic, is exactly what she needed. Plus it’s great seeing someone stand up to Chef and properly continue his cheating subplot. Fantastic work all around

[@bunnyribbit-1216]

I love how Sadie is in this what if. I like how you give Sadie and Katie a different personality than them just being the same person. Sadie got to show how badass she was with Heather and Courtney. Showing her a new and improved Sadie.

[@MrGuyDoesStuff]

HELP WHY DID I THINK OF A PARODY OF “Boyfriend Kisser” BEING “Best Friend Stealer” WITH KATIE AND JUSTIN SINGING TO HEATHER. HELP.

[@drouzicz]

LMFAOOO WHAT

[@Days_long_past]

MAKE IT

[@jeremycel3032]

Although Saide didn't get any further than Island, she was definitely one of my favorites this season, all her interactions, being a savage and her friendship with Heather, I really loved what you did with her.

[@TDWonderer]

yeah it was a bit upsetting to eliminate her since I was enjoying writing for her but ultimately im glad that she got to go out with a bang which is better for her since I feel like it shows her growth that she no longer wanted to be a pawn in Courtney's game

[@bossome77777]

thanks for the spoilers ugh

[@Wellratedcharacther]

But u can still bring Sadie back by giving her Courtneys spot (the episode Courtney sues her way in) U can that Chris gave Sadie another chanse since she's the best to bring drama and that makes Sadie a mole (which also takes Owens mole spot) so yea you can do what I said or Bring Heather

[@shadowbladesabre1945]

​@@Wellratedcharactherthe problem is Sadie wouldn't have much to do if she was brought back. Her storyline of growing and becoming her own person is done, and the only thing she'd do is oppose Courtney. I don't think that's enough reason for her to return.

[@kirbattaquesmash5055]

​@@shadowbladesabre1945feel like noah could return and get charatcer developpement

[@Gwen1661]

I can only imagine the amount of notes and things to considerer for this particular rewrite. But so far it's pretty amazing. I especially liked Sadie's development and how she grew in a similar yet different way to Katie in he TDI rewrite

[@TDWonderer]

I went back and checked, the word count for my notes was 21,630.... im glad you say that about Sadie I really liked writing for her in this

[@Cats-yd2gc]

I never new I needed a Heather and Sadie friendship

[@EspaALSC]

AHHHHH IM SO GLAD YOU CONTINUED YOUR STORY!!!!!! I'm dying to know how Alejandro and Heather's relationship will play out in this timeline!

[@TDWonderer]

IM SO GLAD YOU'RE LIKING IT!!!!!!

[@legendiam5536]

FRR ALEJANDRO BETTER GET BETTER EYE SIGHT AND SEE HEATHER IS PERFECT GOR HIM😡😡

[@Fireess]

This is really just outstanding, the fact that this story is almost the complete opposite in terms of interactions is just so interesting to watch. Some things I really love about this timeline is that Gwen and Trent make up, Duncan and Courtney are enemies from day 1, Heather and Sadie’s relationship, Cody finally telling Sierra off, and Owen and Izzy having time to start something. Overall, this first part alone is so rewatchable and entertaining, thank you for making this!

[@elsie1327]

Your version of Gwent is honestly really sweet. And Sadie’s character development is amazing. Honestly better than what the canon did with the characters

[@needlebfdia]

a great rewrite, I always found it annoying that sadie label is literally 'the sweet girls friend' and sadie being her own person is amazing. very in character for sadie to call out courtney. Though I do hope Izzy can atleast help her team in a good way ONCE this season

[@juancruzdiazbravo7338]

I love Heather and Sadie's friendship, I don't know if you plan on extending this to a season 3, but I definitely feel like it's an element that hasn't been closed yet. I also like Tyler and the chef's alliance, although I have a feeling that Tyler will lose because of this which is a shame, since I would really like him to win The truth is that Lindsay and Harold are not standing out much, compared to the original, although Harold's rivalry with Duncan makes more sense here. I'm a little worried that Sierra will be without Cody, her character is difficult to write alone and Alejandro is a great addition to the cast, it would be funny to see how, like Heather, Courtney also beats him at his own game

[@profdeltaruneenthusiast]

Tbh, I’m not sure if he would make this into s3 just because Sierra and Alejandro are in WT, but maybe he’ll do a rewrite with the new character dynamics

[@dizzielizzy]

​@@profdeltaruneenthusiastI hope so too, I hope he just continues off of this season for WT

[@hola24-x3x]

I think he might do All Stars and just say WT played out the same

[@poplioenquintacuenta]

The fan art was so cool

[@TDWonderer]

I completely agree, really love what they did with Dakotas robot suit

[@okkshane]

I absolutely loved this! I love the Heather and Sadie interactions!!!! I wish they lasted longer but I am so content with how their stories ended in this what if. Hoping Lindsay, Izzy, and Harold are able to stick around for a majority of the season!

[@cindy8966]

Another banger video as always! I especially liked Heather and Sadie being friends and Sadie getting a new outfit as a way to show how she's distancing from Katie. I also enjoyed the mini "rivalry" between Alejandro and Gwen, it was pretty funny to imagine Alejandro getting crushed with her big ass platform boots. Lindsay and Gwen is an interesting plot as well, can't wait to see what happens next with them. You've set up a lot of cool interactions for the next part!

[@zsoltgazda6594]

It was definitely worth the wait, this was amazing :) I'm still laughing over imagining Harold on one knee asking for the cloak master to teach him his ways XD That's just so Harold XD

[@milanbeerepoot4260]

I know you’re probably gonna take a break from Island specifically but when the time comes for another big Island event, might i suggest: What if the Gophers went first during the first challenge? This could lead to some gophers not jumping when they originally did, thus making Courtney change her mind on not jumping, etc.

[@yourbuddymaxormaybegingeri2782]

Yes! I’d like another continuation of this series into world tour to see what happens. I’m really glad this is here

[@freebobux1585]

Peak Content as always

[@AverageTdsEnjoyer]

bro this guys is a legend this is better than cannon action

[@travismiddleton8218]

Great storyline. Never knew I needed a Heather and Sadie friendship.

[@CrushAugust]

I'm amazed as always. Its really cool to see Courtney start off in action imo. Can't wait to see what happens in the next part!

[@ethbeatthem4836]

If you want an interesting what if idea, easy one to look into is “What if Lashawna lost against the log roll against the bear?” We would kind of have a villain change from Heather to Eva as she now can go alone and win physical challenges over most characters, and Duncan can take an antagonistic role more. Some characters like Trent, Linsey and Izzy could make it farther and it does impact the season as many auto eliminations will be different (beside DJ likely)

[@lysanderlonshadow8653]

We appreciate that you take the time to do these!

[@Andlfyer]

Content like this is why I love your channel. You tell a great story revolving all the characters and make us all see universes we never thought to see properly. The dedication and love put into your work is outstanding. As a total drama fan and born storyteller, your content is something that I absolutely love. Keep it up my man :D

[@shinnyboppers9802]

LETS GOOOOOOO after finishing, this was so good!!

[@TDWonderer]

thank you! glad you enjoyed it

[@tdtheorys]

MY FAVORITE THING EVER RN

[@alex_21629]

Sadie been an actual character has made her one of my favourites

[@niewiem2419]

Oh my god I waited on it so much!

[@elitettelbach4247]

This is such a compelling season so far!

[@Summer.12Girl]

I'm really liking how the story is going, and I can't wait for part 2. I'm really enjoying the depth that you're giving the characters as well. Overall, great video and I'm really liking the story. Great job again!

[@m4ureee]

Could you do a "What if Dawn's immunity statue was the real one" please? Love your content!!

[@TotalDramaEthan]

This, like usual, was so good! I love the plot development that Sadie got. I’m upset Cody was eliminated since he is my favorite character, but at the same time, it makes sense after all the stress he was under for him to quit. I also thought of something. I bet on the episode where Courtney comes back in the original, it will be Leshawna instead, because she was mad she didn’t get put in the show despite being a finalist. Overall, I really liked this, and I can’t wait for part 2! Also, do you plan to continue this to World Tour?

[@goodtimeswithreo]

I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS OMG

[@Sunny-vp7lr]

Great video! An idea I thought of is “what if Katie and Sadie were in the Ridonculius Race?” It seems perfect for them and I’m confused why they weren’t returnees. I don’t know if you’d do RR content, but I figured since your so good at writing Katie and Sadie to be good characters, it might be interesting.

[@S3cr3t_Qw1rtz]

They weren't returnees because they have no personality. Sadie's title is literally "the sweet girl's friend"

[@jadetheartist873]

I really love this video, and there’s a lot of good things about it! - Chef and Tyler’s alliance - Sadie, just Sadie. - Ezekiel’s speech - Gwen, just Gwen. - Fixing Trent’s obsession - Humanizing and Redeeming Heather -Coderra is interesting On a side note, since I’m pretty sure you’re going to continue this into World Tour, are you going to turn Zeke feral? Because you got rid of Trent being poisoning due to your disgust by it. Although, Feral Zeke was a bit more influential though. I don’t want him to be feral because of the development you gave him. Anyways, great video and I can’t wait for Part 2! (Also I liked the ironic jokes about DJ and Chef’s alliance, and the Gidgette kissing, nice one lol)

[@czerwonystudio6301]

could you do what if Chef got right parachute and Topher fake one in TDPI? i think it could be cool to see this what if cuz it could put Topher on oposite team and i think Topher's orginal spot would be taken by Ella since she had this plushie of bear with parachute so Chris would count it as "the real parachute", it would deffinally change Ella-Sugar relationship cuz Ella wouldn't have oportunity to make Sugar hate her cuz of being on different teams, that would also mean Chris wouldn't find out that Ella song in episode of her elimination

[@TDWonderer]

never really thought about that one before, even went back to see what you're referring to, that ones really creative! also its a pretty manageable/reasonable change but I could see it changing a lot. don't really have a timeline for when I do videos but i'm definitely going to try and get around to doing this one at some point since I really like it!

[@czerwonystudio6301]

@@TDWonderer btw, do you have a discord server? I would love to join there if you have one

[@Paperbag117]

Alejandro IQ is 163 putting him as one of the top 3 smartest people on TD. I love video keep it up :)

[@mihaitavraciu2248]

YOOOOOOOOO IT'S FINALLY HERE, *AND* YOU GOT TO 5K, LET'S GOOOOOOOO! P.S. Dw about the late video-posting, you're just a normal human, like the rest of us. You've got a life outside of KZbin, which I think everyone should respect, I personally do. Take your time man, just make sure to post at least once a month :D

[@TDWonderer]

YESSSS P.S. thanks for saying that, you and many others that support me even when im struggling to get videos out is extremely sweet, I have always sort of struggled being over critical of myself but its nice to hear that my uploading issues aren't interfering in your enjoyment of my videos ❤️❤️❤️

[@mihaitavraciu2248]

@@TDWonderer ❤️❤️❤️

[@Imanerd2]

So happy your continuing this man keep up the amazing work🔥

[@winteruniverse1648]

Let go I was waiting for this video :)

[@bunnyribbit-1216]

I was kicking my feet I found out you dropped a new video. Keep it up man, I love you.

[@karmelIsNotVibing]

Babe wake up td wonderer posted

[@Playandcatty]

HES RETURNED

[@shellos31oeste72]

I LOVE THIS TIMELINEEEEEEEE

[@dankboi_]

Literally just caught up with a lot of your videos the other day and you came back with an upload in great timing. Amazing dude!

[@SCHLOMPY]

What a good morning a new video???!?!!! And some Heather and Alejandro drama??? I love your videos I'm so glad you reached 5K !!!

[@zoeysnr1fan]

This is so enjoyable that i might even try to make fanart of Katie and Heather's friendship here omg

[@lostkoalass]

YOUR MY FAV KZbinR AHH

[@TDWonderer]

THANK YOU AHH

[@lostkoalass]

@@TDWonderer YW

[@MrGuyDoesStuff]

YESS I JUST WATCH THE OTHER TWO YESTERDAY! IM SO HAPPY

[@tobi-swan]

LETS GOO! i’ve been waiting for this

[@bees5450]

I love this so much. Great work as always man

[@sammielopez620]

Loved the fact you actually gave Sadie more time to develop, many people give Katie more spotlight instead of Sadie.

[@johnnypetronel]

Man, I'm low-key shipping Duncan and Harold, and Heather with Sadie. Speaking of the latter two, why is this unexpected friendship all that I've previously needed in life up until now but never knew I needed?🤩 I would love to see your story continue, and see how these four's relationships would continue in World Tour! Also, can I just say that I love what you did with Trent, Gwen and Duncan? Just, beautiful writing all around. Big props! No kidding, I would love to have these Aftermath episodes animated and fully voiced. These new dynamics both here and in your Island take the stakes of this game to a whole new level!🤩 Really looking forward to seeing what you have in store for us next!😁

[@dragon7666]

I’ve been watching your vids for a few months now, and I’m so happy that you reached 5k subs! Love your videos and I appreciate the work you do to make these videos for us fans!

[@shellos31oeste72]

the heather and sadie's friendship i saw every clip in my head 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@SwaggyKitty101]

Kinda shocking that Katie and Sadie aren't BFFLs anymore. Now this makes me even more upset that they're only in one canon season. I guess the writers just didn't care about giving them a storyline 😭😭

[@Daoskyandmyegg]

The return of a legend

[@Ħāťë_pëøpłë]

Finally, I’ve been waiting for them

[@Jp_corporation_1993]

Idea: do the world tour special but this time sierra won’t be a reporter and al won’t be in the other bus. And do world tour, but a possibly switched up cast

[@randomname1924]

Ok a Courtney / Duncan rivalry similar to Heather/Alejandro sounds amazing to me. Also I would make Heather a bit more “delusional” of her friendship with Sadie at first since it makes it more believable for her to act as if she’s just trying to manipulate her on the long run

[@tdciara]

I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS ❤

[@TDWonderer]

THANKS ❤️

[@emucitizen5892]

SO HYPE SO HYPEEE YOUR CONTENT IS AMAZING

[@Nonya._.]

I can’t wait for your juicy writing :3

[@Furbenstein]

LET’S GO! 5K, could you do what if Beth joined in Aftermath Aftermayhem?

[@TDWonderer]

that idea is on my list of ideas so im going to try and get around to doing it, im just not quite sure when

[@rescenergy]

CONGRATS FOR 5KKKK

[@TDWonderer]

THANK YOU 🎉🎉🎉

[@gentlestardrop5636]

Something I adore about your videos is how you also include minor gag stuff, like Owen's confessional about needing all the comfort food he can get, Courtney making a barfing noise as she walks off, and how Harold screams like a girl while running! It makes it feel even more like writing from the show itself, and I think thats a very underrated part of your stuff :D

[@eriklin9541]

I really like this, I like all your videos. Watching them feels like watching a new TD season, even though it’s a what if. I can imagine each character doing what you say they are doing, and it’s so fun! I hope you continue to World Tour and All Stars (which I would love to see, but you definitely don’t have to if you don’t want to). Lindsay and Tyler are my favorite ship and I hope to see more cute moments between them! I don’t know if you would want to do this, it might be pretty short, but TDAS: What if Chef didn’t drop the dynamite on Duncan’s raft. In this universe Chef drop dynamite on a different boat instead (Alejandro’s or Mike’s), and Duncan doesn’t get to blow up the cottage. That might change things up! Btw congrats on 5k!

[@LightningvsLightning]

My opinion (because why not): 8th: Cameron 7th: Alejandro 6th: Duncan 5th: Courtney 4th: Scott 3rd: Gwen Finalists: Mike and Zoey.

[@eriklin9541]

@@LightningvsLightningInteresting. Out of curiosity can you explain why Gwen and Scott swapped places?

[@LightningvsLightning]

@eriklin9541 Because since the mansion doesn't get blown up, Gwen would (most likely) have to break into it and steal the painting (I'm assuming Chris would have Chef guard). Because of that, I don't think she would mess up the painting, and when she eventually gets it back, Scott wouldn't have anything and get eliminated. Unfortunately, Zoey would still be dumb and take Mal into the finale, and Gwen would be eliminated.

[@eriklin9541]

@@LightningvsLightning makes sense

[@joelprince4170]

This was better then the orginal TDA.

[@dantesparrowz1429]

Im really curious how the all stars cast will look like with all the changes Great video, far better than canon action

[@nameless2996]

Before I watch this quality content (I've seen so many similar concepts but yours are always the best), I want to suggest: What if Blainley was the host of Total Drama World Tour? Mostly, this would give Sierra a better storyline than "stalker" since she loves Chris, so she could be working tk take Blainley down. Maybe Chef could make some backhand deals or something. And no one likes Blainely, so it'd be super funny. I know this one is far, but I've been wondering. Alternatively: What if Beth won the Aftermath Challenge in World Tour, and joined everyone at the merge?

[@poplioenquintacuenta]

Omg finally! Love ur vids

[@EpickGamer6920]

Congrats on 5k

[@TDWonderer]

thanks! 🎉🎉🎉

[@BlackSheep_777]

Could you do a what if team victory disbanded before DJ & Lindsay were eliminated? It would’ve been cool seeing which teams they would’ve been on and how it would’ve affected the plot.

[@Teak67Teak]

Total Drama with Alejandro and Sierra elimination orders so far: Island 24th: Courtney 23rd: Eva 22nd: Noah 21st: Gwen 20th: Ezekiel 19th: Owen 18th: Izzy 17th: Sierra 16th: Justin 15th: Beth 14th: Sadie 13th: Duncan 12th: Harold 11th: Tyler 10th: Katie 9th: Lindsay 8th: DJ 7th: Alejandro 6th: Geoff 5th: Bridgette 4th: Cody 3rd: Heather 2nd: Trent 1st: Leshawna Action 16th/15th: Justin/Katie Xth: Izzy 14th: Trent 13th: Heather 12th: Cody 11th: Sadie

[@Julianooks]

In the first aftermath leshawna and noah confirm lesjawna won

[@LightningvsLightning]

​@user-cj8ro5rx4t I feel it's more, so both are Canon, and he just put that in because Leshawna was a finalist.

[@dust_1355]

litterally finished season 1 5 minutes ago. So excited!

[@Channytelly]

YES I HAVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS

[@dylanjohnson3346]

Once again better that the original season

[@danehollyoak4897]

Congratulations!

[@umbreon713]

Another great video, I really love how you give every contestant a fully-realized plot so they're always doing something and always interacting, it really builds the suspense for the season when there's so many moving pieces! I can't wait to see what happens next. My only question would be on Courtney trying to betray the guys and vote out Tyler in the last episode so she can recruit the girls for an all girls alliance by the merge. I love that she's thinking strategically because I always enjoyed that part of Courtney's personality, but wouldn't it be a better play for her to simply boot Sadie then, keep her strong relationships with the team and potentially pull in Lindsay at the merge since she'll want to side with whatever side Tyler is on rather than booting Tyler, alienating Alejandro, and working under the assumption she'd be able to make an all girls alliance at the merge? I can see how that development made the vote a little less predictable, but I do question her logic to jeopardize her game by going gung-ho on a girl's alliance this early into the competition. I love Miss C.I.T. pants and would be curious to hear more of her thought processes and reasoning if she ends up being a power player in the merge. Looking forward to Part Deux!

[@thebois6651]

Can you do a tdlr of this lol

[@umbreon713]

@@thebois6651 Oh , yeah, I was just questioning why Courtney would target Tyler if she was thinking about merge connections since she might be able to include Lindsay in her alliance since Tyler is already in it, and the two of them are both dumb and easy to control.

[@thebois6651]

@@umbreon713 ok thanks

[@whosjoseHOLAAMIGO]

I’ve been waiting let’s goooo

[@IgnoreEverythingISay]

YES! I WAS WAITING FOR THIS MOMENT!! 🗣️♥️‼️‼️

[@CowboyMikeShow]

The fact that Mr. Coconut still doesnt make it to action even in an alternate timeline is upsetting

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

He didn’t even exist in this timeline

[@CowboyMikeShow]

@@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110 he always exists he exists outside of time and space

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

@@CowboyMikeShow well yes, but he was never featured in the show

[@PhazeRoblox2]

I thought it was to good to be true I love this series

[@GWENNN_SUBSEASON]

Congratulations on 5k dude! I’ve been subscribed since 400 subs so I’m pleased to see you come so far, I’m loving this series by the way, and I hope it keeps going. I have a suggestion for future episode. What if Heather never kissed trent?

[@TheDudeNerd]

Probs the best Total Drama KZbinr. Could you consider doing what I'd DJ didn't have his curse in World Tour?

[@worstspytf2824]

This is great, glad your not pushing yourself to keep up with some self assigned schedule and instead just making excellent content. I could say characters or interactions id like but I don't need to repeat comments that have already been made, great video.

[@legendiam5536]

YESSS I LOVE THISSS

[@renatotapia845]

Have you ever thought of a total drama action with the original cast? So with Noah, Eva, Tyler, Katie, Sadie, Cody and Ezekiel? You can turn the reward challenges in elimination challenges. Another idea is total drama world tour with everyone, so including Katie, Sadie, Geoff, Trent, Eva, Beth and Justin

[@LightningvsLightning]

Everyone forgets that Mama DJ was with Geoff and the gang, so she should totally get into the season as well.

[@angelinatheweird366]

@@LightningvsLightning MAMA DJ FOR THE WIN 💪💪💪🔥🔥

[@drouzicz]

​@@angelinatheweird366YESSSS

[@SolarDelite]

LYLER IS GOOD THOUGH

[@dilemma1616]

I AUDIBLY GASPED WHEN I SAW THIS VIDEO. anyways amazing video, worth the wait !!!

[@Td_Justin]

Yay you hit 5000 subs nice job!

[@zanimates7379]

I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS❤!!!

[@TDWonderer]

THANKS ❤️!!

[@LightningvsLightning]

Great video, really loved what you did with this first episode. I originally had more here, but KZbin said I had an invalid argument, which is annoying. Here's my prediction of what will happen. Pre-merge: 10th: Owen 9th: Izzy Merge: 8th: Alejandro 7th: Courtney 6th: Sierra 5th: Tyler 4th: Duncan 3rd: Harold Finalists: Gwen and Lindsay. Love the art with Dakota and Zoey. Edit: Also, two What-If ideas. What If Leshawna and Tyler were the Reality TV Pros? What If Yul never got poisened? (Disventure Camp)

[@Ellipses02]

This was soooo good I’m ready for part 2

[@Kerem_ozzy]

CONGRATS ON 5K U DESERVED IT I did this and my finalists were (island) Heather and Gwen

[@Pichu726]

Here's an idea I have for what if, "What if Alejandro and Sierra weren't in world tour" simple idea, if Alejandro and Sierra weren't in World tour

[@woahbuncherz]

Who would replace them?

[@OrangeHedgehog1991]

@@woahbuncherz i guess two from the tdi cast

[@woahbuncherz]

@@OrangeHedgehog1991 I mean like specifically. Cause I think that Justin could take the role of Alejandro pretty well, and as for sierra, idk.

[@Jake_NekoNekoyama]

For Sierra, it would either be Beth, Katie, or Sadie. I'm going to say Beth since Katie and Sadie would be a mess if they were seperated.

[@woahbuncherz]

@@Jake_NekoNekoyama oh that actually fits

[@SamuelDoherty]

51:46 just to counter this in the London episode of world tour a mask of Cody was able to trick her into stripping the guard when she was literally hugging Cody before she did it so theirs proof I'm the show that her brain can be so delusional she can process two Cody's at once. I do think with the shovel and sierra possible being distracted by her first kiss with Cody the gaffers still win but it would be like only 5 seconds difference max

[@Wutzz23]

Amazing purley Amazing.

[@Brunette008]

I've been watching your channel lately and I have to say, it rules! I was wondering if you could do a "What if DJ never got the animal curse in TDWT?" I think you'll like it since you're such a DJ stan