TGWDLM Characters Rated on their Entrances

Another one

[@fayeclemons5794]

It has come to my attention that I called Macnamara General Hidgens. The next person who mentions it is getting sued.

[@chickenman6233]

they're married

[@eek2079]

You used General Hidgens not MaCnAmArA.

[@junebug6885]

General Hidgens

[@f.i.r.e.5119]

@Tetra Cubia You beat me to it.

[@juliana.sirmans]

Tetra Cubia oh shut up Gary *knees*

[@storm_phoenix13]

i stan general McNamara and hidgens being a couple now

[@Cherry-hu4xm]

It’s canon now. I don’t make the rules. And besides, there is no way that Professor Hidgens is straight.

[@arcadianico]

Cherry that’s definitely true, but also ted is very into hidgens as well. remember show stopping number?

[@ember5031]

@@arcadianico is it even possible for _anyone_ NOT to be attracted to Professor Hidgens?

[@leedraconis5793]

Nick did say McNamara had a husband!

[@jamesbtr6152]

Liam Vic | WHHWHWHWHAT

[@mirajara9149]

I feel like Charlotte should have gotten a couple of points for caressing the phone at 2:32

[@mangoberrysmoothies]

I would have also given her a point because I like her voice but that's my opinion

[@codythebabyarticfox2169]

Or ALCOHOLISM!!

[@chiachimariachi4682]

You’re so right

[@emilyguilfoyle8749]

Any entrance made by Jeff is automatically iconic

[@teenageangstbullshit9523]

Facts

[@mrshcwtime]

Facts

[@leahsmith6568]

Facts

[@verivelvet4777]

Facts

[@Levleup]

Facts

[@shailynstuckey2983]

it hurts me that homeless man didn’t get his time in the spotlight.

[@emensahh]

I made your likes 333 😏 also yea the homeless man deserves more

[@donuted_ace]

ngl hes my favorite

[@versversa8083]

just for that hey he should get at least 10

[@peaches9307]

Shailyn Stuckey the world is his house, the dogs are his food!

[@nacho_girl]

I'm sad that Alice is judged on the very early 10 second cameo

[@imaymellow]

*_General Hidgens_*

[@fayeclemons5794]

CreamyMellow The Art omg

[@birdnoises3338]

This has given me reason to ship Hidgens and McNamara

[@Raequorum]

Well, I mean, they've said McNamara has a husband sooooo

[@Tsuginoselfcest]

Well I mean.. McNamara _does_ have a husband soooooooooo..

[@dmay6637]

Like ur pfp!

[@thekingofratz801]

Savana Johnson wAit whAAT how didnt I know this finally, some good hecking news

[@TiaMat99]

no points for "cuddle night"?? Criminal! You'll be hearing from my attorney, Gary Goldstein, very shortly.

[@dinaandcarson155]

ta vh suffers from a RARE little understood ANXIETY DISORDER and any lasting medical conditions that may arise on t h e s e premises are youur liability siiir. get ready for AUDITS. AUDITS up your EARS. AUDITS in your y i n g y a n g. AUDITS up your WA Z O O

[@levden3368]

Higarygoldsteinattornyatlaw

[@alecmoyes2026]

OOOH RIGHT IN THE suBpOEnA

[@helianthu5]

get ready for auditz-

[@topsoil86]

Get ready for audits. Audits out of your ears! Audits out ya yin yang! Audits out ya wazoo!

[@jandiqar]

I always took the fact that Paul wasn't at his entrance as proof that he's fighting from the inside.

[@m1ck3y.m0us3]

That and the fact that Jeff immediately says “doesn’t like musicals” instead of “didn’t” like he was before

[@Tsuginoselfcest]

*+2 for the hip wiggles* It’s Robert. Of course there’s dramatic hips.

[@ProfessorRed12]

After me trying to learn his dance I can confirm that my hips do nothing, i am a stick 😂

[@jazzhands8493]

Hot chocolate boy better get a good score edit: not disappointed

[@Addy0302]

The first thing Hidgens does is make *three* theatre references, how did we not realise it sooner?

[@wishiwasmaren2608]

Addy 0302 really? what are they?

[@Addy0302]

@@wishiwasmaren2608 "Waiting in the wings" "The Stage is Set" "It's Showtime"

[@wishiwasmaren2608]

Addy 0302 oh, so just general theatre stuff? I thought you meant three references to other musicals or plays

[@howdoesonesocial]

@@wishiwasmaren2608 waiting in the wings is likely Hamilton the stage is set might just be a general theatre reference It's showtime is likely Beetlejuice BUT it could also just be general theatre stuff ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@backroomsaucy468]

@@howdoesonesocial Beetlejuice didn't come out until April though and this was in December

[@Eva-ow7pu]

I’ve decided that it wasn’t a mistake but in fact a bold claim that Macnamara and Hidgens are actually husbands

[@mrshcwtime]

Y e s That's the only canon that I accept

[@matineeman3038]

Accurate

[@max_clout]

Sorry but Ted should get at least a +1 for ‘mah wife’

[@PuppyLove2468]

I always thought I was hearing wrong, like, who is he talking about? definitely not Emma, so who?

[@mikulasalbrecht2823]

@@PuppyLove2468 its a line from borat

[@reginarodriguez1477]

Lo Jurg maybe it was both a reference to borat and a reference to the fact that joey (ted) and lauren (emma, who we assumed ted was referring to) were dating, now engaged

[@cactusbuds2979]

@@reginarodriguez1477 thank you for the info!

[@maddie9602]

@@reginarodriguez1477 oh, I didn't know that. Wasn't there also a line later on about how the "Latte Hotay" he was referring to was vocal rest girl and not Emma, though?

[@zoedaigle6740]

i am partly frustrated at the fact he is labeled general hidgens but am entertained by the sudden ship birthed from this.

[@possums154]

And now I ship it too

[@nevesargeant4919]

i’m sorry, you didn’t give the back up cops ANY points for robert’s INCREDIBLE interpretive dancing? WTF

[@whateveryouhearditwasntme4109]

I know I saw that and got really sad!

[@thisisntlindsey5869]

Yeah and what about his “weee ooo weeee oook wwwooohhhh”‘a ?! Those were the best parts 😭

[@whateveryouhearditwasntme4109]

Yeah!

[@mari-zg9nq]

and for the jazz hands???

[@topsoil86]

I came here to comment this!

[@ElianaKreider]

Where is the +3 for Melissa’s glasses? They’re huge and adorable and she deserves extra points for them

[@plusiegaming8962]

I agree TwT

[@abhiramiprabakar7067]

that "We're the army BAM BAM" guy is non other than wiley that is my theory bye

[@tabbytacocat]

Abhi Prabakar i mean it is joey playing both characters

[@abhiramiprabakar7067]

@@tabbytacocat not just that... Wiley was in PEIP remember?

[@chickenman6233]

i didn't even realize until this video that Jamie lit the fire onstage that girl is amazing

[@sk_eveel]

Just noticed that donna says that peanuts has outgrown his adopted father's pockets (or something like that) and Curt's character in what if tomorrow comes (in black Friday) has a squirrel in his pocket

[@smidgen2450]

And the characters name is apparently Ed

[@kylieb1352]

"Because he feels the need to run everywhere" *The Tall Gays (tm) have entered the chat*

[@Charlie-zw8re]

we stan hot chocolate boy

[@lamarlatrell5045]

I’m just saying: Charlotte deserves at least +1 for stroking the phone and 1/2 for 1/2 of the backup cops not being able to do jazz hands

[@mariabrady4900]

NO! you HAVE to add two points to Dan and Donna for prioritizing broadcasting a story about a squirrel before a literal meteor that destroyed a town building

[@bananaman677]

Wait... Charlotte doesn’t get a point for cuddle night? You’re a tough judge. *i like it*

[@rea_keebz]

i laughed so hard at how quickly professor hidgens got a 10/10 we stan

[@chalkydusty]

Am sad you didn’t include an extra point for “the cute little _ba Rista_ over der”

[@IDontGotThis]

Guys the smoke club won best entrance

[@sarahgent2674]

So McNamara does two "PEIP" puns. One in tgwdlm and one in black Friday. I can only think of one other PEIP joke, so my hope is that in Nerdy Prudes Must Die, McNamara introduces himself, and then offers Grace Chastity or whoever a little marshmallow bird.

[@possums154]

I need this to exist

[@mads9966]

I just realised that greenpeace girl uses Melissa’s clipboard

[@dasty3314]

“+2 for the return of corey dorris” as it should be.

[@PhoenixsNetwork]

anyone else not know paul’s surname until now?

[@spideypoolfan2066]

Same

[@elijahelkwood5459]

Yeah, that really threw me off lmao

[@mrshcwtime]

I thought he didn't had one

[@sdrpicasso1847]

I think it's Matthews but I'm not really sure

[@ezelfrancisco1349]

@@sdrpicasso1847 it is. It was said when he introduced himself to McNamara

[@brightoff]

I know it’s been addressed that you called Macnamara Hidgens, and I really don’t wanna get sued. But can I just say that I am completely here for the Macnamara and prof Hidgens are married head cannon.

[@AnarchistOwl]

The fact that BAM BAM we’re the army didn’t get a rating (which obviously should be 10/10) is criminal

[@Toon4mi]

Charlotte should’ve gotten five points for the old timey 1930’s hollywood judy garland accent

[@chaoticbean]

I'm sort of disappointed smoke club didn't get a 420/10

[@logicallyanxious]

I love this. I love the zoom on hidgens' eyes. I love all the zooms. I love all your commentary

[@thatonepersonyouwontremember]

Since TGWDLM is the first Starkid musical I ever saw, you do not understand the immediate admiration and joy I felt for Jeff's chaotic amazing falsetto self

[@stormforeveryspring]

I didn’t realize how small the mug was til you pointed it out and now I can’t stop laughing

[@michigangarnet3804]

I aspire to be at Paul’s level of honest. “No, I don’t want to”

[@camilleb51]

this made me realize there’s only 3 actresses in this show

[@suzannahe.h6596]

no points for *JAZZ HANDS???!!!!!?????!?*

[@snailwhisperer9603]

anyone ever think about how Joe says "My Wife" when Lauren Lopez really is his wife...

[@ameliaddlc6107]

The "LAAATTAY HOOOTTEY" killed meeehhh I can't stop laughingggg

[@JustAnotherLittleHuman]

5:31 giving hot chocolate boy an 8/10 just cause he's so adorable and Robert Manion

[@xavierfoord5356]

1:47 “+ 1 for the grimace” That is something I live by

[@Valiant_Requiem]

"Yeah prove it, asshole, we're the army" is hands down the funniest line in the entire show and it's ALL SO GOOD

[@krizz8m.425]

*Shipping McNamara and Hidgens now*

[@lilyhoenicke9253]

Somehow the smoke club has scored the "highest" of all of them but to be fair they should have given the homeless guy a score

[@COFFEEWSUGA]

Prof. Hidgens is always 10/10, whoever thinks he deserves any less is a dirty liar. You truly know your stuff

[@edgyspaceunicorn7215]

I guess Charlotte's flask is supposed to come from a mimed backpack, however I love the idea that she had it strapped to her chair for emmergancies.

[@isleofdead1337]

“-1 for being a snitch”

[@shyan6671]

I just want to say how much I love the character Ted, he just doesn't get enough attention XD

[@AnarchistOwl]

I can’t believe Charlotte didn’t get +1 for the way she says cuddle night and strokes the phone

[@madisonholt399]

As someone majoring in theatre, it does require a EXTREME AMOUNT OF BRAVERY.

[@charlotte5209]

i thOROUGHLY enjoy these videos keep making them please

[@clairegillingham1768]

General Hidgens has me rolling 🤣

[@kwibzi]

I came here just to see Hidgens get a 10/10. I knew it was going to happen, but I still felt happy to see it.

[@fivehundredlux]

Professor Hidgens deserves a +1,000,000 just for the sheer gay panic his character holds.

[@annawolff3135]

I was wondering why you called him general hidgens and then I thought there was some secret Hidgens x McNamara fanfic you were referencing

[@helgw458]

4:37 no, that's the Coffee shop guy or whatever they call him, Man in a hurry appears later ( 6:00 ), they just use the same trench coat great video btw

[@mydarkstrangeson2691]

Melissa is actually in two scenes: the first one and the one before what do you want Paul. Love the vid 👍

[@caspercascade4623]

"+1 for moving away for privacy and then continuing to talk at a normal volume" i just.......love her sm

[@raeosunshine24]

i only watched this show all the way through one time, so i never really grasped how absolutely fucking HYSTERICAL hidgens' entrance is. thank you for this!!

[@phhrogg8065]

this absolutely needs to be a series of all starkid and tcb shows I love it

[@jeanpiolo5841]

I honestly want you to make an entrance ranking of avpm just because of one "particular" person.

[@kenziegarbiel1692]

DID SOMEONE SAY DRACO MALFOY?!?!

[@musicalcherries13]

I actually said, OUT LOUD, "wip higgles!!!" When I saw the cop's hip wiggles

[@monamibaji]

I love the fact that I thought you were just gonna have Paul being called "eat shit " and then proceed to give him points BUT nope you just went through the whole number sung about his existence. good job!

[@ameliamorgan2287]

When I first watched it I thought the whole “where is he?” bit was just them covering up for Jon Matteson being late for his entrance.

[@mango_cheese37]

HELP SO DID I

[@wtfjackaboy]

I was expecting for the back-up cops a 1000/10 for Robert's dance.

[@jacknorth7427]

Mariah's hat falling down in Show Me Your Hands should have been at least a +1, but maybe I'm just biased because I want the backup cops to do well at all times

[@dragonheartlover123]

So, this was just on my recommended and I had no idea what the anagram stood for, so my brain helpfully supplied "The Girl who Didn't Live Mas." and I felt like this needed to be shared.

[@chloedavies3699]

HOT CHOCOLATE BOY DESERVED A 10/10

[@galactic7458]

+1 point for Charlotte stroking the phone with her finger while saying _“But Sam... it’s cuddle night”_

[@magnus8361]

I shall be sued because general hidgens

[@minceroft3710]

Melissa deserved extra points for her lil skip as she walked away and also being the most polite sweet cute lil cinnamon roll in the workplace in this essay I will--

[@hanakoakamoto8919]

"being the most polite sweet cute lil cinnamon roll in the workplace" I get this comment was written before "Hey, Melissa" 😀

[@emilyrose4320]

Thank you for pointing out how long that handshake was because I genuinely never noticed

[@trashboat9848]

'+1 for this woman's laugh'

[@abby4034]

I love these videos so much! I don’t want to force you to do one for every show but, Please do one for every show ☺️

[@adamdao4826]

I’ve now just noticed that in both of the hatchetfield musicals, Jamie’s main role has an off voice

[@AllTheGoldfish]

This is a way more detailed rating than I expected and I love it, thank you for this

[@harpykrates]

I just wanna draw some attention to the split second look on Emma's face after man in a hurry tells her shes supposed to sing, because it's so great

[@marinarasauce5701]

i just realized that dan & donna are voiced by one of them (i really cant tell which but i think it's robert) & lauren and that made my day a lot better

[@MetalheadRazorblade]

joey

[@Ali-kg6mu]

I love this. This is amazing. This is correct. This is fact.

[@musicandloveismylive]

We stan the 1000/10 for the smoke club!!

[@moeflamelord6900]

I was about to say you better give the professor 10/10

[@scootscoot919]

Are we gonna talk about how they totally stole the name John Macnumara from John Mulaney's show?

[@betsycarwile4788]

If Professor Hidgens doesn’t get a 10/10 or higher I will riot He got a 10/10 he is perfection and I love him

[@lydiacaskey485]

Idk why but 6:04 was one of my favourite parts of the show

[@starkidstuffiguess]

I love this series too much I need more.

[@swims11torches]

It was confirmed in a livestream that cofee shop guy isn't miah

[@Xhalph]

Tipping for a song would be out of character for someone in a hurry anyway.

[@minnie4705]

I feel like Charlotte deserved 10/10 points just because she is AMAZING

[@youngestredi_9369]

Ok, but holy musical b@man characters rated by entrance?

[@thecatcult9199]

I think the back up cops should get +2 for aggressive head bobs

[@depressedhobo9296]

HOW DID I NOT NOTICE PAUL SAYS HIS LAST NAME O N C E

[@panainpublic]

The cops should've gotten a point for making sense, and the wee oo wee oo

[@nithila9243]

i’m sure hidgens is devastated that you didn’t include alexas entrance

[@rebeccaklakulak3357]

His name is john McNamara. The professors name is professor Hidgens

[@cmonkaratechamp533]

didn’t you see the pinned comment, they know this already

[@cmonkaratechamp533]

it was an accident

[@spookytoad]

omg wait he does look like man in hurry

[@cmrm11]

Totally is the man in a hurry. Such a good musical