191: When Ayesha Accused Maria al-Qibtiyya of Committing Adultery | Our Prophet

This episode is from Chapter 8 of Our Prophet -- the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s) by Sayed Mohammed Baqer Qazwini.
View the complete Chapter 8 (His Other Wives) here:
• Chapter 8: His Other W...
Links to previous Chapters:
Chapter 1 (Prelude):
• Chapter 1: Prelude | O...
Chapter 2 (Birth to Revelation):
• Chapter 2: Birth to Re...
Chapter 3 (The Mission Begins):
• Chapter 3: The Mission...
Chapter 4 (Struggles in Mecca):
• Chapter 4: Struggles i...
Chapter 5 (Road to Medina):
• Chapter 5: Road To Med...
Chapter 6 (Foundations of Islamic State):
• Chapter 6: Foundations...
Chapter 7 (Badr & Uhud):
• Chapter 7: Badr & Uhud...
Things you'll learn in this episode of Our Prophet:
00:00 - Accusation on Maria of committing adultery
01:22 - Shia Version of this event
02:42 - Prophet commanded Imam Ali to kill Jura'ih
05:32 - Imam Baqir's hadith regarding this event
07:15 - Wisdom behind Prophet's command to kill Jura'ih
Join us in creating the most comprehensive life story (seerah) of Prophet Muhammad (s). Dedicate episodes in the memory of your loved ones by visiting
thaqlain.org/ourprophet.
#ProphetMuhammad #PropheticBiography #OurProphet
================================================
► MAKE THAQLAIN REACH 100K SUBSCRIBERS:
bit.ly/SubscribeToThaqlain
► BECOME A MEMBER ON KZbin:
/ @thaqlain
► HELP US CREATE MORE CONTENT:
thaqlain.org/support
► CONNECT ON WHATSAPP:
wa.link/hfcf0g
► FOLLOW US:
Facebook: / thaqlain
Instagram: / thaqlainmedia

[@Thaqlain]

Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on KZbin & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support

[@Wajeeha_M.K]

Why did jireh did not had any private part!? What was the point in it please explain completely

[@rifatara917]

Exactly I have heard this same episode by Marhoom zameer Akter naqvi in urdu.such great scholar.May Almighty give him best place in jannah.

[@samuelhpardew751]

A Soloman-like situation, peace and blessings of ALLAH be upon Soloman, Muhammed and the family of Muhammed.

[@sonabarnes6670]

Subahanallah! Once you begin seeing, you can't unsee it! So much falling into place. Jazakhallahu khairan.

[@2AN3M]

How scholars twist stories. So easy for them to make the apparent conspicuous and the conspicuous apparent

[@2AN3M]

The rulings are for common people not the elite

[@angelamaanaki6769]

Bless you

[@samir.mahmodi6971]

❤❤❤❤

[@hassanainalhelou9843]

sayid i find this hadith really troubling, 1) i just find it hard to believe that the prophet will order imam Ali and imam ali would following blindly. 2)i also find it hard to believe that the prophet protecting half of his wife's and publicly announcing that those others give him trouble. 3)also very troubling that the story goes that imam ali would jump over walls like some other so called companions did and the Quran rebuked that action.. i dont know whats the answer to all of this, but the holy prophet and imam ali have the highest levels of akhlak and i find it hard to say any of this happened..

[@Thaqlain]

It is not necassary to accept every narration. The reason this narration was shared was to provide an alternate viewpoint as found in the books of tafsir.

[@adamnouri23]

One of the reasons why Allah Almighty allowed His prophet to have that child - Ibrahim a,s - from that believing woman at that point in time WAS TO CLEAR HIM FROM ANY ACCUSATION OR DESCRIPANCY . 'Aisha and Hafsa along with both their fathers were wishing and counting on having the prophet's progeny in their lives. To have the prophet' s children and grandchildren in their lives, these four devils would have taken advantage of Islam and Muslims ,, and the whole world. Allah Almighty did not allow 'Aisha nor Hafsa to have children with the prophet of Islam. The four-wheel satanic engine vehicle - Abu Bakr, 'Omar, 'Aisha and Hafsa got desperate. They accused the prophet of old age and NO LONGER ABLE TO HAVE CHILDREN . Now what ! He has a new born - WITH A LADY OTHER THAN 'AISHA ,, The she-shaitan 'Aisha would come up with another ACCUSATION ,, " the new born Ibrahim does not look like the prophet ,, so, Ibrahim's mother must have done something wrong ". Yet, some viewers / commentators wished forgiveness for 'Aisha. In surah / chapter at-tahreem Allah Almighty has already put 'Aisha and Hafsa in the same category as the two disbelieving wives of Nuh and Lute . * ،، و قيل ادخلا النار مع الداخلين * . * ،، and it was said [ to them both ] : ENTER THE FIRE [ ALONG ] WITH PEOPLE ENTERING [ IN THERE. ] *.

[@Wajeeha_M.K]

Why did jireh didn’t any private part when a child is born there are only two sex!! And there were any surgeries or something please explain!!

[@yumnaakhtar6793]

Can we have a word with sayyid over some issues and important events, via letter or email? If there's any possibilities?

[@Thaqlain]

You can reach out to him on Ask Those Who Know app.

[@angelamaanaki6769]

In my humble understanding the Prophet Muhammad ( pbuh ) would not have differed to Ayesha to make such critical decisions . It seems she may have a jealousy of even his sorrow for another . Islamic laws protests one’s innocence until proven guilty this seems very odd and off to me

[@m.m4999]

can you also tell us the reference of the hadith in the Sunni books? as I'm a Sunni and want to read the ( authentic ) Sunni hadith myself thanks in advance

[@Thaqlain]

Here are a few references that mention this story: www.al-islam.org/ask/topics/10585/questions-about-Maria-al-Qibtiyya

[@rumanaadam7604]

Asalamunalıakum Alahuma sualıy ala Mohammed waalı Mohammed wa'ajılfarahum

[@sarahdakhlallah9019]

Im still having trouble understanding how, if the Quran says that 4 witnesses must be procured before accepting such an accusation and 4 witnesses were not present, that the prophet could order imam ali as to kill him. Even if he wanted to teach Aisha a lesson, how could the prophet directly go against the Quranic ruling in this situation? Even if he knew the outcome of his order and that it would clear up Maria's name, to give such an order publicly without following the precedent of the Quran as the prophet could be seen as permission for others to do the same, could it not? I'm having trouble accepting both this story of ifk as well as the accepted sunni version.

[@Thaqlain]

Firstly, we don't need to accept the story as it is presented. Maybe the nitty-gritty of the story differs from the story that came in the books. However, the facts that all clues point out are: i) The Ifk incident was about Maria instead of Ayesha ii) Ayesha herself had a crucial role in the accusation against Maria. As for the Prophet's reaction, it seems that Prophet wanted to make Ayesha understand the gravity of accusing a Prophet's wife of adultery to the extent that she bore a child other than that of the Prophet. Wallahu alam.

[@sahnazpatel717]

​@@Thaqlain ASTAGFIRULLAH such FALSE and SHAMELESS ACCUSATIONS against OUR BELOVED MOTHERS , FEAR the day you will face The SUPREME CREATOR , pray for guidance before its too late

[@Thaqlain]

These are present in Ahlas Sunnah books more than in our books. A lot of Sunni scholars agree that it was Mariya who was accused by none other than Ayesha and Hafsa.

[@maheshk4657]

I have one question. When it was proved that Ayesha falsely accused Mariya, why didn't prophet Mohammad punish Ayesha with 80 lashes? (defaming a chaste person) I came across many instances that, the ones who were close to prophet Mohammad got pardoned for their wrong doings.

[@Thaqlain]

We have covered this in episode 192 in detail. Prophet never gave special status to his family members. His mercy and forgiveness was equal for everyone.

[@kas7344]

Shia isnt Islam…stop spreading lies…you can pray from now til day of judgement and you’ll never be muslim for the lies you say about the prophet Mohamed’s family…shame on you

[@Thaqlain]

Thanks for dropping by :)

[@baharbanu9852]

a quetion? What does Ahlulbait mean here in this story? Prophet's wifes or Fatima, Ali, Hassanian, Prophet himself? If he meant his wifes then Aisha is also his wife

[@Thaqlain]

Sunni and Shia all scholars agree that whenever the Prophet recited the verse of the purification of Ahlulbayt it was meant for those regarded as Ahl al-Kisa.

[@aamirrafiq1679]

You didn't mentioned the Sunni hadith very strange just showing basis regarding this

[@Thaqlain]

The proceeding episodes go into further details.

[@angelamaanaki6769]

Even with regards to Ayesha and the accusation that big of a lie seems gossip at best

[@anonymuser95]

You are referring to Ali ra as Ali alejhi selam. Aren’t only prophet’s supposed to be referred like that?

[@Thaqlain]

No. Alaihis salaam means Allah's peace be upon them.

[@anonymuser95]

@@Thaqlain you are supposed to say ‚Radi Allahu anhu‘ (may Allah be pleased with him).

[@Thaqlain]

That is for the companions. For the progeny of the Prophet, alaihis salaam is used as its is Allah who sends His salaam on them.

[@MultiAmmar2000]

@@anonymuser95 Even Bukhari originally referred to Ali and Fatima using "Alaihim Al Salam"

[@ahtishamrana1361]

When Aisha R.A got accused of Adultery and the accusation proved wrong, prophet S. A. W gave an order to kill the ones who accused her. But why The prophet S.A.W didn't give such orders against Hazrat Aisha R. A when she proved wrong about the allegations on Mariya Al-Qibtiya ??

[@Mary-st1zd]

Because aisha was the daughter of abu bakr who is one of the closest companions of the prophet.

[@Thaqlain]

We have covered this on why was the Prophet at times lenient on his companions in another episode.

[@ibrahimharith9878]

​@@Mary-st1zdthis is a very stupid reason Wallahy you think closeness to the prophet SAW will make him turn a blind eye to a grave sin ,Plz think Mary plz it's important

[@Mary-st1zd]

​@@ibrahimharith9878the prophet never hit his wives then how can he even think about killing aisha.

[@angelamaanaki6769]

With regards to Ayesha it’s seems hard hearted not to forgive a child she was so young and as we see not every human being matured at the same rate

[@HAmmar0121]

Was she still a child when she raised an army and faught the caliph of her time Imam Ali (a.s)?

[@angelamaanaki6769]

@Hussein Abdulla aye I hear you but if you read Sura Al Buruj maybe we better understand the scope of Gods forgiveness however hard it may be

[@HAmmar0121]

@@angelamaanaki6769 God's forgiveness is for those who realise their mistakes and truly repent not those who continually hurt the Messenger and his Household after him. Those who faught and went against Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthmaan are branded apostates or kuffar but those who faught Imam Ali (a.s) and his sons have excuses made for them and we are told they were good.

[@angelamaanaki6769]

@Hussein Abdulla I’ll let the best judge sort it out that is best

[@ibnbasraa]

She literally accused someone of zinah and put a mans life at risk. She was the Prophet's wife she knew the punishment for adultery. Stop defending her actions.

[@alishaali198]

Lets keep everything aside, I have a serious question. If Juraih had no private part , how he was able to pee?

[@Thaqlain]

Medically, it is called Aphallia. Details are available online.

[@syedmahmud8214]

Non-sense

[@user-nf1jk7ei2k]

You spreading lies.....

[@Thaqlain]

We are here to stand corrected.

[@mudaseer21]

You are misleading people aisha is very generous girl she cant blame another woman u r wrong here

[@Thaqlain]

We are here to stand corrected but the matter is presented from Sunni books :)