The Al Is Subaru Theory Just Got Messy

[@Jakez123]

Not sure what's up with the audio glitches in the video, but i talk about EX 5 related information and the weirdest thing regarding Al and subaru in arc 7.

[@Chase14videos]

I think Shult has seen Al's face, I might be remembering wrong, but I think in Pride Prejudice and Zombies, Priscilla either lit Al on fire or pushed him off a balcony into a pond (or both) and he had to take off his helmet to drain the water.

[@okbut3572]

@Jakez123 i got a theory for u what if Al is Subaru uncle and not Subaru and Subaru's parents named him after a star in the memory of Al who went missing at the same time Subaru was born

[@Chase14videos]

@@okbut3572 so Philip J. Fry

[@lordpvt]

@@okbut3572 Interesting

[@ashwinraj2033]

@@okbut3572 Interesting

[@egastar37]

I always think that Priscilla doesn't really forget Subaru but pretends to do so to amplify the "you are not important" idea

[@VaradMahashabde]

Jakez is literally so fired up for this theory.

[@lordpvt]

Fact

[@blatantslander]

Jakez is crazy persistent at this point you have to commend him

[@TruthOfZ0]

He has to support his theory unfortunately…

[@VaradMahashabde]

@@TruthOfZ0 I know, it's like me trying to argue that Rigel would have been the next Sword Saint.

[@TruthOfZ0]

@@VaradMahashabde That’s true actually!

[@anthonyheman4621]

Great. Now I think Al is going to be Subaru's dad. Isekai'd later in his own timeline to an earlier point in the Rezero time line and with some kind of memory block.

[@Pookan228]

Same thing here. Al just looks so similar to kenichi

[@matthewaquino3491]

I personally think al is Subaru’s younger brother that’s been isekai’d to a point before subaru

[@larce021]

@@matthewaquino3491 Subaru is an only child...

[@Tripepdipep]

I think when Subaru was summoned to this world he both appeared 15 years ago and now. So he was cloned. Al is an alternative future Subaru and Subaru won't become Al. Maybe Flugel and Hoshin are Subaru as well but I doubt.

[@lordpvt]

@@Tripepdipep 🅒🅞🅞🅛

[@user-li5cr6wv5b]

IMO, Priscilla not remembering people is just her being sassy. And generally speaking, Al being Subaru is hard to believe simply for the fact that he has no apparent feelings for Emilia and is sticking with Priscilla, her exact antipode. He might be Subaru from a parallel world summoned by mistake, but then again, what makes him "the Subaru" at this point?

[@azureaether1661]

He probably wouldnt feel anything for Emilia because hes lived in Luginica for 18 years, while Emilia was still frozen

[@user-li5cr6wv5b]

@@OkarinHououinKyouma Tbh, "Your luck was bad" is a fairly wide-spread phrase. Both Subaru's and Al's abilities may appear as sheer dumb luck to people, so as taunts go, that one is pretty obvious. "Your stars are bad" might be a vollacian version of saying the same thing, since they predict future by astrology.

[@OfficialFedHater]

He says something about it in the WN when in the demon city, but I don't remember what exactly he says.

[@sebastien-loikntsangou-kan5264]

I think it makes sense from the perspective that Al's mentality is similar to the one Roswaal tried to instill in Subaru during Arc 4: to be someone who can save only one, specific person (that being Priscilla, in Al's case).

[@lucyadam9128]

If it true then Subaru cross dressing in arc 7 is an amazing symbolism, Al is very masculine looking Subaru and natsumi is very feminine looking Subaru. In arc 7 the land of wolves, which I believe will be a coming of story about Subaru growing up where we will stop calling him a boy but a grown man

[@Chase14videos]

So what is the over/under on the Fake-Vincent turning out NOT to be Chisha Gold, and in fact is actually Capella Emeralda Lagunica. Vincent hadn't been on the run for that long when Subaru showed up, only a few weeks at most. But several months passed between the end of Arc 5 and the beginning of Arc 7. It is entirely possible we get a scene in which Al or Subaru manage to injure the Fake-Vincent and then notice he has black blood.

[@doublehit9165]

she wont be able to stay in character. shes crazy you know?

[@duckpig7104]

there is some evidence suggesting chisha has connections to capella, so although I doubt the fake-vincent is capella, capella has a pretty good of being the causation of chisha being fake-vincent.

[@sebastien-loikntsangou-kan5264]

I think it's more likely that Chisha is one of Capella's assassin children since he has the same circle pattern on his clothes like all the other members of her Assassin Organization.

[@doublehit9165]

some interesting infos: the star named Aldebaran has its name from the Arabic ---> al Dabarān ("الدبران"), meaning "the follower", because it seems to follow the Pleiades. its also the brightest star in his constellation. The Pleiades, also known as The Seven Sisters, is a star cluster which represent in the story the 7 witches of sin and the 7 floors of the tower in arc6. So Aldebaran is litterally "the person who follows a witch". Both in theme and etimology. Subaru is the name of the Pleiades star cluster, which is the modern name for it. Subaru means litterally "to gather together" hinting at subaru good point of befriending many people and bring them to his side as well as his ability to pick up witch genes in the story. We have a parallelism from "Al follows a witch" to "Al follows Subaru" here. Finally there are only 9 brigthest stars into the Pleiades star cluster, which represents the 7witches of sin, pandora and Hector in the story.

[@akshatrai7475]

who's hector?

[@doublehit9165]

@@akshatrai7475 warlock of melancholy, its on par on a witch or a sin archibishop.

[@agustl5067]

People who think that Al is Kenichi you are missing a point. Kenichi is actually TALLER than Subaru, while Al shares the same height as our lolimancer.

[@CABRALFAN27]

My best guess regarding the connection between the isekaiers is that they're all different "iterations" of Subaru. They all started out as the Subaru outside the convenience store, but they were just summoned to different times and places, and as a result, became vastly different people. So, for instance, Flugel would likely be the first iteration, summoned over 400 years ago, who Satella fell in love with, and whever events transpired 400 years ago, it led her to summon more iterations of Subaru to come and kill her. We know Satella lacks common sense, so it's possible her love for Subaru - That is, our Subaru - is just her love for Flugel that she's projecting onto him. My favorite part about that theory is that, if it were true, it'd create an amazing parallel between Emilia and Subaru; Emilia is hated for her resemblance to Satella (While the two of them do probably have a connection, they're still different people), Subaru is loved for his resemblance to Flugel, who, again, he's different from, despite sharing a connection.

[@Dan-ks3tr]

Wouldn’t Al recognise himself? Or does his disjointed memories account for that…

[@a5hen]

It could also be that he doesn't want to reveal himself if he is actually Subaru

[@Dan-ks3tr]

@@a5hen true

[@gOnz3r]

@@a5hen Yep. It would be something like- Aldebaran knows exactly what is going on, but is considered a failed version due to not killing Satella. For all we know, Subaru wasn't even called "Subaru" on Earth, and we are just watching the "successful version" of some random Japanese dude who probably triggered it all himself, by getting involved with Satella.

[@mikk818i]

@@gOnz3r what do you Mean its not subaru?

[@gOnz3r]

@@mikk818i I am not sure exactly what your question is, but I will try to assume what you meant and hopefully give an answer. I was asserting that, for all we know, the guy we know as Subaru was never called by that name on Earth. That he is spawning into the Re:Zero world with different star names like Subaru or Aldebaran. On Earth, maybe he was Haruto Natsuki, for example. Maybe he spawned in originally 400+ years ago, some bullshit happened to Satella, they couldn't fix it, so they took some extreme measures, involving Subaru being taken from an earlier point on Earth and spreading him around with different spawn points throughout history. If that is the case, which I am NOT saying it is (just that it could be), then I'd also add that the witch factors probably contain the parts to make "Subaru" whole again. I would also guess, this something along these lines ends up being the truth, then the original "Subaru" is probably quite the piece of shit. Emilia would be just a clone body for Satella. All the clones of "Subaru" would just be dudes they hoped would collect the witch factors. Satella asking to be killed would be her trying to do the right thing and just die instead of taking over Emilia. The Witch's Cult would have been largely acting on the wishes of the Witch Factor they hold, meaning "Subaru" created the damn enemy, at least largely. I don't know how Pandora would fit into all of this, but my guess with Pandora has always been that she is some beezy who is angry over Flugel loving Satella over her. Again, of course I don't believe any of this. Just that it is possible. If there is an original Subaru (Flugel) who originally spawned into Re:Zero world in the past and the whole story is caused by a shitbag thing he did to try save Satella, I don't think that our Subaru will become that person.

[@Pookan228]

As I have previously commented, I think the final reveal would be that Al is Kenichi that got transported back in time to Lugunica after few years that Subaru has disappeared in real world. I'll come back to this comment in few years. We'll see

[@snehapal6903]

Even I have the same taughts but I think it might be parallel world Kenichi (who knows)😅 Al is so misterous

[@agustl5067]

People who think that Al is Kenichi you are missing a point. Kenichi is actually TALLER than Subaru, while Al shares the same height as our lolimancer.

[@Pookan228]

@@agustl5067 no info in novels about his height. As far as I remember

[@Kalossupremacy3356]

Nah no way kenichi ain’t faithful to his wife

[@Doctor_Yiggles]

Tappei being sneaky as always. Love your theories Jakez.

[@ShadowKoto]

It's like the theory with Satella being Emilia or Subaru being Flugel for me. It doesn't work when you compare it to the IF stories, making the entire existence of these "future characters" should be rejected as a result of having these divergent timelines be theoretically possible (Though not canon). It's a Time Paradox. I'd rather take a step back and understand who Al's "Sensei" that he mentioned (After saving a younger Arakiya from Hornet) actually was before also understanding things like his knowledge of Ram's existence and his different ability (Probably an Authority) from Subaru's, which makes no sense to have changed if Al is Subaru when other versions of Subaru have kept the same power.

[@doublehit9165]

would make more sense if satella was optimizing al power making it Rbd, instead of: radom revive in small area with limits of attempts and sometimes you dont even remember the loop.

[@ShadowKoto]

@@doublehit9165It could be that both Al and Subaru are Apostles of Envy, and we haven't seen the Authority of Pride since Typhon (Or possibly Stride, though I doubt it)

[@B10-HAZARD]

Isn't the theory of Al being Subaru already highly unlikely due to Al using earth magic and Subaru using Yin magic? Unless Al is an alternate version of Subaru I dont think they are the same person.

[@blatantslander]

True, you can't change constitution. Al is just another worlder whose speech is closely similar to Subarus

[@doublehit9165]

beatrice stated that if subaru spent efforts into using magic for around 20 years he could get to Ul level. but lets say Al learned earth magic without knowing his affinity was shadow magic, due to stressful situations, to overcome said situations. would it make more sense then. (its a theory like any other of course)

[@blatantslander]

@@doublehit9165 do you have any idea how crazy that theory is, it would require Tappei making a plot about Al, doing all that

[@doublehit9165]

@@blatantslander right? just droppin some thoughts there for fun

[@manuellara9644]

Actually, according to Tappei, Subaru could learn how to use other types of magic if he dedicates his life to that

[@Pompeous]

I still can't take this theory seriously

[@doublehit9165]

want to make it more believable? pandora tried to rewrite subaru later on in arc10 or 9 and he resisted to an extent allowing 2 different subaru to coexist (normal subaru and subaru thrown in vollachia were he end up like al) despite that is obviously impossible (authorities breaks the world rules after all)

[@coolgamer3646]

Same

[@lordpvt]

@@doublehit9165 SMORT👌

[@blatantslander]

Because its crazy plot haha

[@TruthOfZ0]

Me too.. this theory doesn’t make any sense!!

[@vcb2553]

my theory is that every character who was mentioned to be from earth must be Subaru. when he got taken from the convenience store copies of him got placed all over the place and time. with slightly different powers or circumstances.

[@jaredmatheny3996]

Subarus name signifies the Seven Sisters. Maybe there are 3 more sage candidates. Subaru Al Hoshin Flugel

[@MonoReaper]

Which makes Teppeis comment "once Subaru gets all Witch Factors he will become a real human". Almost like Subaru got fractured by the transport between time & space. Heck even RbD literally is killing Subaru double every time it activates. Because if the "failed worldlines" flashbacks are true. Then Subaru literally kills savepoint Subaru every time due the "original" Subaru replaceing the save point Subarus with his counsisneuss aka "death of the mind" due memories being overwritten.

[@CABRALFAN27]

Yeah, this is my current theory as well. I actually wonder if each iteration of Subaru was summoned to kill Satella, but gave into a different Sin that prevented them from completing their task. So, for instance, Flugel would be Pride, which is considered to be the original sin, so whatever he did was likely the inciting incident of the whole thing. This led Satella to summon another iteration, Hoshin, who gave into Sloth (Or maybe Greed?), using his otherworldly knowledge to found a country and live the sterotypical isekai life. The only part I'm uncertain on is what "sin" Al would be. Wrath, maybe? If that were the case, each "iteration" of Subaru would have a connection to their sins' respective IF stories; Flugel and Pridebaru are both connected to the Witch's Cult, Hoshin and Slothbaru are both connected to Kararagi (Or Echidna, if Hoshin is Greed), and Al and Wrathbaru share an antagonistic relationship with Ram.

[@OfficialFedHater]

@@CABRALFAN27 Flugel is Sloth, he ignored his task to kill Satella and locked her away to try and save her through study or just left her there to go his own way. Hoshin is Greed and it's quite interesting that Subaru in one of the if stories basically does the same thing as Hoshin which is bring inventions from his world to the re:Zero world. Al is Pride, he chooses not to be the follower of Subaru which is the correct path to the end goal of killing Satella, this is the easiest path for our Subaru to fall off on imo since he won't want to kill someone, we'll see how he deals with death in Arc 7.

[@echidnanatsuki882]

What if the true answer is actually just that Al is just a look-alike to Subaru? Basically, Taipe trolling us 💀

[@TheDragonCat99]

Satella mistaking Al for Subaru and accidentally Isekai’ing him instead is a hilarious idea to me and will be my headcanon until proven otherwise

[@brendalee1215]

Al is Subaru, Flugel is Subaru, everyone is Subaru. I never thought rezero would be Kingdom Hearts where everyone is xehanort.

[@l.asriel9005]

Isn't Priscilla calling Subaru and Al "clown", only the two of them? I don't really remember so I maybe wrong.

[@vernaltear]

I'm gonna be completely honest. Al is a really cool character and I think it'd be a huge waste of a character if he's just Subaru in the future or an alternate version of him. I always hate these sorts of twists where one character is another one.

[@HelloDarkness-]

Tappei might be throwing random bullshits at us (to confuse us at the mysteries were trying to solve/to make us try to debunk every theories out there.) Then he pulls an uno reverse card, making the theory canon. Really looks like a Tappei style. But then again, we saw him do something that makes us (really) take back the time we laugh at something so ridiculous (and unlikely) while reading/listening to these cracked theories.

[@goldenangel158]

Jakez you just blew my mind great video

[@timwhite1783]

This theory is just stupid for so many reasons. Al is definitely connected to Subaru, but he is also definitely not Subaru himself. - Subaru would never love Priscilla for starters. - Al has a return by like death Authority but that's all, if he's a future version of Subaru how come he never uses the Greed or Sloth Authorities? Subaru would not only need to travel back in time but also have lost the Authorites in the first place. - Also Al has no emotional reaction to Emilia or really anyone from Emilia camp (except Rem which was not a positive one). - Not to mention why the f*** would Subaru go around calling himself Al instead of Aldebran if Aldebran was already an alias? I could keep going btw. This theory didn't 'just get messy' it never made any sense in the first place.

[@kertgp8275]

New Jake release hype

[@OceanFragments]

Geezus, the scars on Subaru and Al's right arms are even in the same place. You might be able to copy clothes, but that's a bit too much of a coincidence.

[@timomarkson]

In season one when they go back to the capital for his healing, is that the reason why she stopped and picks him up trying to get into the meeting with The five Candidates for the crown because Al says pick him up because he knows what will happen and what needs to happen to move the next bit on Paul it’s Bell trying to get back at being betrayed

[@motelmicrowave]

Al being subaru seems so dumb. Al is watching himself failing in a loop? Whoever he is I hope it's not Subaru

[@rajvirmalhans2073]

Older Subaru could look like the leaked picture. If it is him, he could be hiding the phrase with intent. It would be interesting if Al is an If or alternate version. Or could be a Subaru relative

[@doublehit9165]

could it be that Pandora did something later on but it didnt rewrite reality how it should but instead lead to a subaru + Al coexisting where they shouldnt if the aithority worked properly? (like subaru resisting to an extent to the rewrite thing)

[@rajvirmalhans2073]

@@doublehit9165 that could also relate to the connection between Satella and Emilia. Al could have some suppressed memories

[@christianboi7690]

I feel like there’s weird reincarnation hijinks going on, with Subaru’s weird past memories and the witches fascination with him. It’s like an incarnation of him in this world fell in love with the witch of envy and after he died she envied all the other worlds that had Subaru’s and brought them all to her world. Something like that. I don’t know.

[@deepaarya8461]

Love your work bro

[@10100rsn]

It could all be coincidence and you are just seeing what you want to see. I know this can happen from time to time especially with this series. ;)

[@wilhelmvanastrea7344]

Idk why but I really don’t like the al is Subaru Theory. But interesting fact that supports the theory more is that al and Subaru almost confirmed that they came from the same time period but where transferred to different time periods in the re:zero world and so going off this could all people from our world just be Subaru. Because if you look at the know it all sage all the ideas they had came from around our time period but they were alive a 100 years ago

[@doublehit9165]

may i pose a question here? if subaru memories were wiped out in arc6, but not his memories of before isekaied: if those memories are implanted, could they be Al own memories? so since the two of them has this common background they end up saying or doing similar things

[@MonoReaper]

God the biggest twist would be if at some point all the "alternative" Universe Subarus interact with "our" current timelines Subaru and it breaks into a major plot point as to why Subaru had several guidelines that seem like they were placed for him specificlly.

[@doublehit9165]

my personal thought in the matter is that subaru past memories are different from the one he should have and satella/envy forced those memories on him (flugel memories perhaps). this is slightly hinted from arc6 where those memories arent eaten by the authority of glottony which could happen if the memory istn related to that person but magically attached to him somehow. and the same thing is true for Al. so its because of the common basis of knowledge, people, facts and thoughts that this two had come up with the same line. and satella is strongly implied (if the previous statements are true) to be the culprit here.

[@MrIrvash]

Do you want to know a real twist ? Here a seal in Elven forest what do it contain? All major history characters are accounted for even hector perhaps it contains original Subaru and this Subaru here is but a imagine that's putting himself back towards using witch factors as tools

[@doublehit9165]

@@MrIrvash that would be strange. I thought its a part of a set of three seal that holds envy but who knows?

[@cahsahhhhhhhn]

"if Subaru, who is now a kid, bumps into Olbart" yeah that would be a problem, wouldn't it... I will say that Al freaking out, freezing up, and then finally yelling that he wants his Authority back when he can't use it felt like a very "Subaru" moment to me. If Al isn't actually Subaru they are still very much cut from the same cloth

[@mywa8314]

You taking this Crack theory to the next level mate.

[@raitolux6811]

Hmmmm... Satella looks the same as Emilia And Al "looks" the same as Subaru Coincidence?

[@doublehit9165]

its a tappei theme. since you look like someone you may have disadvantages due to the other person bad points

[@L3one3]

I think Aldebaran is Kenichi Natsuki who somehow found a way to follow Subaru into the re :zero world, but also somehow lost his memories along the way. (likely by facing off against one of the gluttony brothers in the gladiator arena, who would naturally be there collecting the fighting abilities of high-ranked fighters) -Many re: zero characters are named after celestial bodies, particularly members of the which-cult and isekai'd characters. Aldebaran is Arabic for "follower" and follows the Pleiades constellation. (Subaru is Japanese for the Pleiades, hence why the car manufacturer logo has 7 stars) -They're both jacked like bodybuilders, both have black hair, have similar personalities and sense of humor. -The leaked concept art w/ face for Al could deff be Kenichi with long hair/scars/facial hair. -Kenichi could harbor feelings of shame/guilt about being unable to protect his son, which could materialize as the inability to keep down mayo (even after losing his memory). -A grieving father would naturally spend time around the last known location of his missing child (especially after 18 months, which is around the time the cops would declare Subaru's disappearance a cold case), and his despair could have triggered the "summoning" similar to how Subaru's desire to learn "why" triggered the 2nd and 3rd witches tea party. -If Satella does truly love Subaru, its unlikely that she wouldn't try to reunite him with his grieving dad and keep him alive via granting of an authority. - This would make for an absolute tear-jerker of a chapter, and is exactly the kind of stunt that Tappie loves to pull. The only hiccup in this theory I can think of is that Kenichi is depicted as slightly taller than Subaru. However this could explained by something like different shoe style, or the fact that many people will gradually lose an inch or two as they age, (Al has been in re:zero for 18 years, and if he was in his early thirties the day that Subaru left, would be in his late forties now) Another thing to consider is that Kenichi is only depicted in Subaru's flashbacks, and Subaru had an inferiority complex to his dad, so he may remember him as literally "larger than life"

[@KaziaGD]

I genuinely wouldn't be surprised if Al turns out to be Subaru's older brother or something like that. maybe tappei is throwing a red herring at us to make us think they're the same person, idk tbh

[@timwhite1783]

I think it would be pretty cool/funny if it turned out his Dad was isekai'd too. It doesn't really make sense though since his Dad probably wouldn't hide his identity right? Plus his demeanor is different.

[@harunbegic9610]

These theories are soo random that I'm starting to believe in my crackhead theory that Al is Kenichis brother aka Subarus uncle

[@vikingsword3485]

Could be wrong but didnt Al show his face durring the royal selection meeting in the novel?

[@LxDization]

There is one more character who saw Al's face. It is Emilia in arc 3 WN. But she is a dunderhead.

[@NeroAngeloTH]

Who even says that in this day and age?

[@ashwinraj2033]

@@NeroAngeloTH Emilia Tan Itself

[@willchalloner6643]

I think theres certainly some link between them But I’m less sure they’re the same person My biggest problem is Priscilla, I’m not saying that surely she would point it out, because I could certainly see her lie But my problem is this; why the hell is Al following Priscilla? And why does he prefer Al over Aldebaran

[@doublehit9165]

aldebaran is a star name. and all archbishops has star names. if he had contact with them, since we know it for sure (arc5 and shop exclusive stories), he might dislike the name and use Al nickname instead. priscilla met al when he was older than subaru anyway therefore the resemblance wont be so obvious.

[@willchalloner6643]

@@doublehit9165 when I talk about Priscilla I mean in motivation Why is he following her so much Subaru described Emilia as his perfect girl and disliked Priscilla Unless Subaru’s just a simp I don’t see why he followed her

[@doublehit9165]

@@willchalloner6643 alis following her since he saw her dying in front if him, felt bad, saved her life, and end up worrying if she will be ok. and so he became a bit affectionate. not that priscilla knows this (she was killed on his first meeting by the gladiators)

[@Sakanade__]

random topic, but why do people think that Kararagi and Gusteko will be involved in Arc 7? I've read all of Arc 7 so far and I've looked for Tappei's QnAs, and I still haven't seen a proof that 2 other countries will be involved in Arc 7.

[@B10-HAZARD]

Ok, I gotta read Pride, Prejudice, and Zombies soon cause I didnit know Pricilla kisses Al. Gotta know how that happens

[@manofgreed7865]

Someone please tell me what happens

[@doublehit9165]

spoiler: gives ram vibes when you read it

[@bilaldemir8712]

Same, didnt expect that one to have such a cool scene

[@doublehit9165]

@@manofgreed7865 i gallantly saves you from certain death and so i got rewarded by a kiss. only, i felt embarassed and try to brush it off only to be kissed regardless

[@jaredmatheny3996]

I am still waiting for Roswaals NAMED chapter. Al knows more than he lets on. He knows something about Subaru that runs deeper than being Japan bros. Al has a witch factor that adapted to his desire to survive in the gladiator arena. Al fears death when his "territory" is run down. Subaru has a witch factor (?) which adapted to his desire to save Satella in the loot house. So... they both have authorities that activated on death after being transported. Al only has one factor, Subaru has two to four. If Al is Subaru, there must be a reasonable explanation for the nature of Return by Death changing, which is unprecedented.

[@jaredsmith7240]

Al and Subaru have different magic affinities, so I've always thought they were different

[@roweginmendoza9703]

at this point I think Aldebaran is actually IS Subaru BUT he's the amalgamation of all "IF" Subaru(a Subaru that failed so many times that he basically did all the IF story and because of his failure Satella just gave up and summon another Subaru)

[@breakmanradio2530]

Al's hair color is black, according to the web novel. The old sketch has purple hair.

[@user-oq4ff7tg5s]

Subaru's foes in Gunray voice: "This is getting out of hand! Now there are two of them!"

[@ghibolaiuandrei4278]

Al is Jakez, he toys with our mind.

[@notme8652]

Al is not Subaru Because Al isn't simping for Emilia

[@TheDragonCat99]

The real thing that kills this theory imo Subaru never stops simping for Emilia, even in timelines where she’s been dead for years

[@Ch1l1C0nCarnag3]

This would honestly be such a waste of Al as a character to just reveal later on he's a different version of Subaru; because if there are multiple Subaru, then what makes our Subaru so special to Satella? There being multiple of him ruins the entire point of her loving this one Subaru in particular. If they want Al to be in any way related to Subaru, have him be his Dad who was transported to the same world at an earlier point in time with something affecting his memory, or a curse similar to Subaru's own which prevents him from speaking about it.

[@saynotololi]

Wait hold on. Because he’s a kid do you think his gate will be fixed. This plot thread still hasn’t been talked about. Still waiting on a mans poisoning talk

[@SilverYPheonix]

HOLY HELL YEA, please fix Subaru, Tappei!!!

[@doublehit9165]

i think that if louis is the healing spirit by this time (after 5 weeks) she should have been able to heal his gate.

[@TheDragonCat99]

@@doublehit9165Idk, can a gate be fixed like that? If so, why is Anastasia trying to use dragon blood to fix hers? Wouldn’t another method be easier, especially with her resources?

[@doublehit9165]

@@TheDragonCat99 an ancient spirit with centuries of experience about healing and immense mana reserve wont be easy to find after all. th eother spirits there are around arent comparable. also, the tecnique to repair a gate is only known to echidna, roswald was healed the same way.

[@edff6890]

That is fishy. Why would they never see Subaru normally? If the arc continues this way, I'll be surprised if Al isn't Subaru.

[@doublehit9165]

since he wants to be in stealth mode, its possible satella here is helping him, just like the fire in arc4, the fights in arc5 (regulus didnt go for a killing blow) and the teleport in arc6 (something bad will happen if subaru get to the top of the tower)

[@dawnstar24]

Personally I like to believe subaru is sortof a clone/fragment of flugel. Same for Al. That also explains why witch of greed spent so many time on developing clones, spirits. And Reid's clone is also in the story. So there might be a connection too.

[@sebastien-loikntsangou-kan5264]

I think Flugel, Al, and Subaru are all alternate universe versions of Subaru Natsuki.

[@klopowisch2707]

maybe Subaru isnt the only one getting younger imagine Al getting younger too and is looking like subaru now

[@planetbirthday6859]

Jakez123 has just released

[@superlepi9330]

my boy jakez diving into complex theories meanwhile natalie is dancing the chika dance (well its frking cute tho)

[@letsplaysaschagd9331]

What? When did that happen? I want to see that too

[@user-vt9bp2ei1w]

I would say no. There is a lot of evidence suggesting that Al is not Subaru. 1. Al has never revealed the ability to cross-dressing, or disguise. This is one of the most powerful ability that the author said Subaru has. 2. The core of Subaru's problem lies in the "hero". There is no clear evidence that Al has similar thoughts. in contrast, the two have very different thoughts on them, so I can't see why Al and Subaru must be the same character. 3. Al and Subaru have different magic attributes, and the RBD operation of the two is not the same. If Al is the future Subaru, it can’t explain why he didn’t use IP and Lion’s heart. 4. It’s sloppy to equate the two because Al’s way of speaking is similar to that of Subaru. In agneau if, Subaru's words and deeds are like Al (or at least dressed up), but this is not proof that Al is Subaru. If you remove the whole story and look at it after Subaru uses RBD, from an outsider’s point of view, Subaru is like Al to deduce that Al is Subaru, But this does not take into account that characters who can use RBD can learn other information from the invisible timeline. Al has RBD, and Aldebaran is a star that "follows" Subaru. Why can't Al imitate Subaru's way of speaking? If the context provided by a plot twist cannot give a different performance to the previous plot, it is just a bad twist. And as far as I see it, "Al is Subaru" plot twist is bad.

[@milord8005]

Just wanted to say we don't know how authority's work just they follow a theme maby al has a different one because he experienced a whole different life before getting his authority or it like the gluttony siblings. I personal think the similarities are just a coincident and there different people. But to be sure get shaula to smell al and see if see think otherwise

[@Flood55]

I think they call that "confirmation by omission".

[@SilverYPheonix]

This just makes me believe even more Al is Subaru, if there's one version of Subaru dressing like that, there's has to be another one OR more.

[@subertin1382]

So what would happen if shaula meet al,is she going to respond like seing subaru, like hiiiiii master, This is for the al is Subaru theory,

[@shadowgarden8557]

al uses earth magic while subaru uses shadow so… Idk dude.

[@doublehit9165]

let assume for a moment that this theory is correct, and then analise only the information we can assume to reach the point where 2 subaru can exist in the same time in 2 different places. now: 0) for al to exist, he must have been summoned to vollachia 1) if subaru was sommoned in vollachia and not lugunica --> then he would have tried to do what he did in lugunica, but it would have gone differently. not enough allies, madness advancing, fear and so on. but this time its unlikely he would find kind people to help him. so sooner or later he would have reached a point where he survives but cannot save everything. so, lets say he lose an arm. 2) he goes on, befriends people, but stay still stuck in that place. at a certain point in time he was heartbroken due to the loss of someone who he consider his guiding light (the emilia of the vollachian empire- same role). he did all he could but just like with the white whale fight his rbd didnt help him and so he broke. and gave up on "following a star" as Al says. 3) he changes his name, since remebering things like "i will be a hero. no one has to die. i will save everyone" and such makes him terribly heartbroken. 4) he met satella even here, she asked him to kill her and he, this time, agree. he went to the shadow garden but wasnt able to kill her. so she let him go keeping rbd for herself. 5) even withouth rbd something similar remained (far less powerful, various rules and drawbacks). realization that satella was making his life oddly easier using that instead of his reset ability which exist since he comes from beyond the great waterfall and therefore cannot reach od lagna. 6) -second point of view- usual subaru - usual story - usual outcomes - but satella remarks about him taking her hand and such (arc4) are now linked to Al behaviour in vollachia years ago. satella knows thats the same person 7) around the arc 9 or 10 subaru fights Pandora, but cannot beat her, the second time when she realized he knew things in advance she use her authority on him and rewrites his past 8) this leads to point 1 - subaru is now not summoned in lugunica but summoned in Vollachia. the entire story changes just like that. 9) but then we see subaru and al in the main story so... subaru must have resisted to an extent the reset ability of pandora. 10) so we have subaru & al, fighting the same enemy, with al doing what he do to avoid subaru to end like him, helping him in fact reaching the answer and defeat her (story and sadness of him explored) 11) probably when he win al and all he did until then will re erased but subaru will remember it. what do you guys think about this? its very long, sorry.

[@ZigKid3]

Interesting detail how she never sees Subaru normally. I sent you an email to your KZbin email since there's a theory I never hear people talk about, I'd like to see what your thought are on it. Rather than Subaru being Al or Flugel, what about Subaru bring Hector? I'd be really looking forward to it.

[@kenken0175]

Just my personal opinion but if the Al is Subaru theory is true I'll be so disappointed.

[@user-ee7nc8bi4n]

Still can't get over smol subaru

[@doublehit9165]

you know. there is a chance priscilla will like his kid form and hug him like schultz. probbly the first kind action we will see her doing

[@mistadrew7513]

Ok, so now Jakez has pointed out details with theories of Subaru is Flugel and Subaru is Al. So if these are true, why the heck they being brought here?

[@okbut3572]

if Al is Subaru could Al be from a third Universe in the story

[@griffinbryant5016]

I think what we can all agree on is that even if Al isn't Subaru Al *is* Natsumi Shwartz

[@gigarmon]

what if subaru and al are flügel but ai is not subaru and subaru is not al what could i only mean by this....?

[@thatsparrow6453]

What if Al is Subaru from one of the If stories?

[@laertlani2826]

Goku black part 3 when?

[@griffinbryant5016]

Boy concept Al looks like Kenichi and boy that lower half of his face also looks like Kenichi

[@doublehit9165]

different height though

[@griffinbryant5016]

@@doublehit9165 but he's the same height as Subaru is what I'm saying, Subaru will probably look a lot like Kenichi when he's older just with his mother's eyes

[@aw2031zap]

Why doesn't Al know how to tell the difference between Rem and Ram? I guess he just would've never met them?

[@MrIrvash]

Al is colour blind i think

[@doublehit9165]

he got the same confusion sensation as ram have when she tries to remember rem or heard about her. its her mind launbhing a signal about "you should know that!"

[@MonoReaper]

There seems to be some sort of memorie manipulation going on but we dont know yet what exactly this means. But its definitly a weird hint towards something.

[@m.j.n6250]

When chapter 40 come ?

[@Muda9090]

Tappei is sus

[@kunalsonwane9740]

Reinhard: -is a hero, and can only become(?) a hero. Rem: subaru-kun is rem's hero Subaru: i am rem's hero Rem2.0: you're not a hero Al: i will make you a hero

[@doublehit9165]

subaru 2.0: i will be my friends hero (not a hero for everyone - i have limits)

[@Af-ei7lh]

@@doublehit9165 he isn’t a hero for everyone rn he only sees himself as Rems hero

[@MrIrvash]

If al is Subaru then how come al himself never bothered to comment on it? He just rolls with it

[@doublehit9165]

time travel shenigans

[@susux9558]

He doesn’t want to be like subaru so he prob wouldn’t say that he’s him or show it idk tho

[@ashwinraj2033]

Jakez Is Indirectly My Father.

[@eran4261]

I very very very much agree on this.

[@deepaarya8461]

105th view 35th like 7th comment Give me heart ❤️!!!!😁

[@patrickjanecke5894]

There's already two universes, why not have two Subarus from different realities?

[@doublehit9165]

because if they touch the world will explode. since that doesnt happen its unlikely ;)

[@patrickjanecke5894]

@@doublehit9165 Only in some cosmologies/fiction.

[@comic2525]

Ok I can’t be the only one that was shocked Al and Priscilla shared a kiss right?

[@letsplaysaschagd9331]

I didn’t know either. But I wasn’t even surprised anymore

[@dott-dude1119]

I mean no offense but I legit hate this theory, it doesn't make much sense, I mean it makes some sense but not much, I wouldn't mind if this turned out to be true, but I just don't like the theory itself just like how I hate the Emilia is Satella theory.

[@tenacious_takakumi2680]

I believe that Al is Subaru's little brother. It was implied that Subaru's mom was pregnant so I think it's possible

[@letsplaysaschagd9331]

What? Where? When?

[@Левонос]

There was a line "Subaru, do you want brother or sister?" from his PAST TRIAL dad in arc 4 17 chapter, but he latter claimed what that was a joke. This scene is more for denying the possobilities of him having brother or sister then confirming it. But it realy something parrents ask in such occasions. Deffinetly would like to AL beeing the Subaru brother rather then his alternative self. That could be important for Subaru emotional uplift. Like the time when Rem said "You are my hero", or Otto "You are my friend" stuff. "You are not alone, to this world becose i am here" moment will be spoiled if AL is something like artificial twin brother broght by magic. But ether way that could work out too, waiting for such moment in arc 7 with open mind.

[@tenacious_takakumi2680]

@@Левонос imagine him needing to kill his little brother in order to attain the Pride Witch Factor. Now that would be tragic and right up Tappei’s alley

[@Левонос]

@@tenacious_takakumi2680 Big part of Re Zero is emotional rollercoaster, and brother on brother clash is something what could make strong emotional response from majority of readers. Even if Al is alternative Subaru they still, by beeng twins(clones), are brothers in some sence. That makes me think that is very likly to happend, but it dreads my to think what Subaru is going to realy kill Al. Tha emotional drown from it will be hard to contourbalance with something possitive. The fact what Al spend half of his life in the other world to become a "Following star", while meeting Subaru, who he suppose to follow only recently is already a sad thing.

[@skeyedrake5929]

What if al isn't Subaru, but is becoming Subaru

[@mndfst9433]

Why does Priscilla keep kissing people? Is it attached to an ability or something?

[@autumnrain7626]

Never been this early lol. Pog

[@somali_pirate2112]

I don’t think al is Subaru he’s too different I think al is another Japanese person that’s somehow related to Subaru

[@MrIrvash]

His forgotten brother? Subaru parents do act a little overwhelmingly odd with him especially dad if you look at them all from side lines

[@zyolid3083]

when u been giving jakez money for the past 9 months :)

[@Jakez123]

Lol

[@zyolid3083]

@@Jakez123 aiming for 2 years

[@willchalloner6643]

5:15 umm what?!

[@geraltissuperman1749]

Maybe Al is Subaru so that's why he didn't like Subaru to cross dress 🤣

[@klopowisch2707]

imagine getting turned on by yourself

[@danneko3434]

i think ai is subaru.s father

[@letsplaysaschagd9331]

Doesn’t olbart know Als face too? At least Subaru was still crossdressing at the time they met olbart Edit: ok . Should’ve watched till the end. Sorry for the unnecessary question

[@brokenparadox9849]

I think Al is Subarus dad

[@angelaguilera600]

Tappai needs to start answering questions instead of making more questions. Getting kind of annoying

[@doublehit9165]

ask me anything, i'll give you spoiler gladly :)