The Amazingly Affordable, Mechanical, Vostok Komandirskie (811275 Review)

[@jcxme]

I have an Komandirskie since 1995 that should be from the 80's and is totally functional. The case has lost part of the chrome coat but it does not matter to much, I became old too. I have an Amphibian too ( automatic movement ). But I like my relation with the Komandirskie,

[@Redant751]

Komsndirskie was my first vostok and I still use it in my EDC rotation. I now have 6 and plan on getting more.

[@vitol45]

I am from Russia and I want to thank you for what you're doing. I owe one of those watches and love it.

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks! Any other cool Russian watches I should look at?

[@muresandaniel3812]

@@RelativeTime poljot or raketa even pobeda watches are awesome

[@tjsogmc]

I find myself wearing my Amphibia more often than any other watch I own. And yes, I wear it with the original metal bracelet. And no, it does NOT pinch or otherwise be uncomfortable when it's adjusted correctly. And yes, my Vostok watches keep very accurate time. And about the bezel: so who uses it anyways? What does it matter that it's bi-directional or not? The lume: it sucks. No two ways about it. Water resistance: I've worn my Komanderski's in the pool, the shower, the rain, to the beach with no problems at all. They are water resistant. So what's the problem? You can wear them around daily without worry. They are rated at 20 meters, which is about 60 feet. So who is going down that deep in the swimming pool? Or your kitchen sink? They are fine for daily wear without worrying about getting them wet- they can handle it just fine.

[@RelativeTime]

I think people focus on the bezel and bi-dreictionality of it too much. I've actually found it to be very useful when making this videos. Especially the time lapse parts. I use it more as a timer, and just advance it 20 min or so to remind me to go shut off the camera. As for the water resistance. I go back and forth on it myself. There is the "conventional thinking" that you shouldn't swim with anything less then 100m. ( en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_Resistant_mark ) And that 20m doesn't really mean 20m, because of extra pressure, wear on the seals, etc, etc. But then there is the more real world / practical side which plenty of people do with watches that are rated for much less. For these videos I tend to err on the side of caution. Mostly because I hate the idea of someone ruining their watch because I happened to say it would be ok.

[@tjsogmc]

@@RelativeTime I fully understand the caution in giving advice in a video like this. Lawyers and such. And I've only recently found your channel and I really like your content, so keep up the good work! I have also looked into the water resistance issue, and while there is a lot of opinion, there is little fact. So how exactly does swimming put more pressure or wear on a seal that is designed to withstand 20m? Can you swim hard enough to mimic 20 meters of pressure? How does a seal that is captured between a backing plate and a clamp ring subject to wear just because it got wet? These are all "concerns" that have been brought up, but never tested apart from those who actually wear the watches and subject them to stress. I fear there is a lot of urban myth surrounding the watches to the point where people just believe things because they've been said over and over again. I wear my Vostoks everywhere. They hold up to rain, mud, swimming pools, camping, washing dishes, or whatever without any issues whatsoever. I've never been diving with one, but who dives with a watch like this nowadays? Every diver I know has a wrist computer, not a watch. I have many other brands of watches as well, and they all have their place- I love my Casio G-shock AND my Seikos and Vostoks. It is permissible to own more than one brand. So my stories are also anecdotal I admit, but through my experience I have to say Vostok watches are in fact waterproof in environments that are considered "normal" for most people. I have my own video concerning this matter in which I publicly state my beliefs, so I'm not just talking out of my butt. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hZ2zc6GrpslolZo

[@RelativeTime]

@@tjsogmc Just watched your video. I love pulling the AK out of fish pond at the end. 👍 But your completely right in the fact that Vostoks in general and komandirksies will do just fine for normal people. As well if something happens, o well. I'd be more frustrated that it would take a month to get a new one then the financial side of it. Unfortunately the internet tends to make urban myths and legends worse. As well as misinterpreting things and blowing them out of proportion. There was a great / semi famous post on Watchuseek where someone used some basic physics to show that moving your arms wont increase the pressure that much. At some point I'd like to examine the issue more closely and try to get a better handle on it myself. Because it is something that comes up time and time again, as well as science is my background. So at some point I'll should try to dust off some textbooks and figure it out. For me it's less about lawyers, but more about realizing my words are starting to have weight. My channel is still very small by comparison, but I'm realizing more and more that people are making decisions based on what I'm telling them. So it's more of a responsibility to try and do right by them. Have you ever bought or taken a look at the newer models of Vostoks? My last video was on the Amfibia (with an f) Scuba. Pretty nice for what you get. Although it does cost about 2.5x more then a regular amphibia. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqjHXqmke9hjhLM

[@tjsogmc]

@@RelativeTime Thanks! I've been working on content for my channel, but with work and "real life", I just don't seem to have the time to play around with it as much as I'd like to. I've lots of ideas, but no real equipment or skills to speak of. Yes, pulling the AK from the pond was a bit dramatic, but I like to give a bit of "value added" entertainment on what would otherwise be a dull video of me flapping my gums. I have seen and handled the new style Vostok Europe and they appear to be good watches, but the style just doesn't appeal to me. And they don't have the Soviet heritage like the traditional Vostoks. Then add in the relatively high cost- they aren't that great of a deal when you consider other brands that you can get for that same money that offer a lot more options. But to each his own- it comes down to a matter of subjective style and I can't make a determination on that for another person if they like something that I don't. It's the chocolate vs. vanilla argument. For the physics of swimming force, here is a link to an explaination of the forces: www.real-world-physics-problems.com/physics-of-swimming.html Fill in a few numbers and the force on a swimmer is roughly equivalent to maybe 2 or 3 meters depth, nothing more. That amount of force wouldn't even be noticed by a Komanderski. I would hesitate to make a blanket statement saying that ALL watches rated to a certain depth can survive because of so many variables like age, maintenance, and manufacturing defects, and whether or not the owner screwed down the crown properly. But at the same time, we can't live in a box out of fear- I put my watches to the test and if they pass that's good, so far none have failed but if the do...well, that's how it goes and they can be fixed or replaced. The worst time to find out if you watch is really waterproof is when it gets wet in a situation when you need it the most.

[@woonfaseng8737]

i didn't know until recently. Komandirskie also have DIVE watch version but they are more expensive ! i was trying to get a 80s era komandirskie with a 2 oclock crown but i think i will get a red dial red bezel dive Komandirskie instead at round 70 to 80 USD including shipping

[@andrewd7586]

I was in the former USSR/CCCP in1990. I bought at least 6 of these as gifts. I still have one & it still works keeping pretty good time! Recently I bought an Amphibia & love it! Well worth it just for the mechanical side plus talking point.👍

[@RelativeTime]

For the price you can't go wrong. Do you remember what you paid for them back then?

[@andrewd7586]

Well being the then USSR of course the Ruski’s loved the US dollar!🤣 For memory I think it was between $10-15 US. I reckoned they were expensive but I didn’t think I’d get back there in a hurry!🤣

[@mercoid]

I’ve had mine since 1990 as well. The wife bought it for me as a consolation for breaking my collar bone. I’ve worn it on and off for long stretches over the years and recently began wearing it again. The lume is dead. The crystal scratched up...., instant shine acrylic floor polish applied with an artist brush fixed that, for now. It loses a minute and a half a day, but I still love it.

[@philipjfry199]

@@RelativeTime Hello. I'm from Russia. What you are looking at is a relatively cheap watch. Usually these were given to schoolchildren for their birthdays. Their price was, depending on the mechanism and design, 40-70 rubles for 1990. The exchange rate was: for 1 dollar they gave 1.6 rubles. We also made expensive watches for 180 rubles and more. And you can not talk about watches made of gold. Here is a link to some watch brands and how collectors rate them today: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eoqQmYeLmst3nLc

[@mauriciotorres5875]

14 pieces in my collection they are like the VW beetle of the watches

[@ustustyler]

5:06 It's not "tank with very oversized missiles"! It's old soviet "Krug" surface-to-air missile system from 60s... And crossed cannons mean russian artillery military branch of armed forces.

[@RelativeTime]

Someone's already mentioned this, although they couldn't remember the name of it. Which makes this watch make a lot more sense, if this was an artillery themed watch. I'm assuming the chevron in the middle is a commanders rank, but could never confirm that. I'm just amazed at the proportions of the missiles to the vehicle. Seems like you would want a larger vehicle to carry, and survive the launch. But I guess they knew what they were doing.

[@ustustyler]

Just google "Krug" system and you'll see that proportions are authentic. And i'm telling you again that chevron mean artillery forces which anti-aircraft forces affiliates to in 60s.

[@RelativeTime]

@@ustustyler O I believe you. Like I said, someone else has already mentioned it. And sorry, the chevron I was talking about was on the GMT Komandirskie at the beginning, not this one. I thought it was on it as well.

[@fakethinksy101]

I was thinking the same thing.

[@robc8468]

@@RelativeTime There should be no recoil off a rocket powered missile just some major heat shielding I would think.

[@DavidUKesb]

I have loads of these magnificent watches, many of which are Soviet era. The Amphibia really is the AK47 of watches.

[@briman2183]

You deserve more subs! I watch all your videos, and respect the time you put into the content.

[@RelativeTime]

Thank You! All the editing takes time, so it's always nice to hear it's appreciated.

[@ryejack]

I'm binging Vostok videos because I just finished my first mod of a Vostok Radio Room Amphibia and have been scoping out my next project. I have a Komandirskie on the way with a different bezel, hands and insert. It's addicting, to be sure.

[@tsarli5819]

Amphibia or Komandirskie? There is no "or", both are great timepieces worth collecting.

[@dodgydruid]

I abs love the Soviet era Amphibia and Komandirskie and the lesser known Commander which were the 70's and had bigger crystals but no bezel.

[@kleanovodust-bin69]

The question will be, "which one should I buy first".

[@jimrees1778]

I have both Vostok models. Both are extremely accurate. My Amphibian is my daily wear. There is something special about Vostoks that only owners can understand.

[@RelativeTime]

Very true.

[@pstamaria]

Thx for this review dude. I got the 38mm Tank Komenderskie for my 12 year old son (changed to a green Nato strap) and I’m waiting for my 40mm Scuba Dude Amphibia! He loves his watch and winds it religiously every night before bed 😁 I’m hoping to get mine by my birthday!

[@eeyyaakk6801]

Philip Sta Maria try not to get the komandirskie wet. It really is a great watch but the the case is brass so it does tend to rust. Mine has. Wipe water off immediately if it gets wet.

[@RelativeTime]

This one is destined to be a gift for one of my nephews. So I think it's perfect for that. Hopefully he likes it just as much.

[@pstamaria]

eeyyaakk thx for the tip. I’ll pass the info on to my son 😁

[@pstamaria]

Relative Time I’m sure he’ll like it! What’s not to like?! 😉

[@vincewhite5087]

Philip Sta Maria it can be learned. I grew up in 60’s, few people I knew could afford autos. By grade one, I had master the simple task of winding & checking my watch just before taking it off to go to bed. But younger crowd has problems learning good habits it seems.

[@sidensvans67]

Excellent watches .

[@seybertooth9282]

05:10 "and a tank with some very oversized missiles" The tank is actually a 60s era self-propelled anti-aircraft unit, perhaps a KS-41. The missiles really were that big. :)

[@КоньВпальто-х3о]

These watches were designed for the military in the USSR, it was impossible to buy them in the store. They donated for good work, this is a legend and not just a watch. This is pure mechanics

[@ШухратАзимов-д5л]

Конь Впальто все правильно сказал)

[@tjwright]

I've got a Komandirskie coming... Green face with red star, parachute and jets.... it kind of makes me think of Heineken with the color and star. I look at these kind of like Swatches.. quirky and odd, something you might want to collect and have a few of. Can't wait to get mine!

[@salamitsunami4712]

Just found out about these watches today I am already addicted to them, the editing of this video is absolutely outstanding

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks. I like to think I've gotten better at editing too. Here is a Special Edition Amphibia I did a few weeks ago. kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4jGeYaJnrlqm7M

[@johnmontgomery3725]

Just bought my first watch and couldn't be happier I think they're solid and reliable.

[@RelativeTime]

For the price it's really hard to go wrong.

[@waktosha7378]

Man! I can't believe I haven't bought one one before. They do have their faults, but the huge negative about Vostoks are you can't buy just one, and are VERY ADDICTIVE! Now I just bought eight of them. They are just absolutely awesome for the price.

[@lappin6482]

just ordered my first Vostok komandirskie, can't wait 👍

[@RelativeTime]

Hope you like it.

[@grogsmash9956]

Thank you. I have seven Vostoks, and this video makes it allot easier to explain why to others.

[@RelativeTime]

Your welcome. The appeal is hard to describe at times. What kind of Vostok do you have?

[@grogsmash9956]

4 komandirskie: new: 211783, 211289, ”pre-owned”: 211831, 431290 (was too cheap to pass on) 2 Amphibia: “Pre-owned” :a 420374, in box and still had protective film on the crystal (Life Aquatic?), a 710??? (what looks like a 710 case but with a bezel from a 420 (dots, no numbers) , a dial that I do not see listed on meranom for the 710 case, and a thick rubber strap with “Amphibian” and a scuba dude molded into it. 1 Vintage Vostok: not signed as a Komadirskie or a Amphibia, It has “Wostok” (yes, with a W) on the beautiful red (light burgundy?) dial. (No screw down crown, but has the ring and plate style back cover.) The lettering is also not in Cyrillic (“made in USSR” ) so I suspect it was made for export. I have also recently acquired a Slava and a Luch. I have a soft spot for things Russian, having owned a Ural Side car motorcycle, currently have a Mosin Nagant rifle and an embarrassing number of Molnija (Молния) pocket watches.

[@RelativeTime]

Michael Sollenberger very cool, and nice collection. How do you like the luch?

[@grogsmash9956]

I like it fine. I got it mostly to have something made in Belarus (why not). I got it off eBay fairly cheap ($15-ish) the same time/ same seller that I got the "Wostok". I am guilty of picking up stuff that is mildly interesting to me just because the price is right. It was advertised as a 1970's build, but I have not researched it much to confirm that. It runs and keeps useful time, it has no second hand (it it not a one handed Luch). it is gold colored with a sorta creamy yellow face. The band was ...well lets just say I swapped it for a OEM Komandirskie band (off one of mine) and that was an enhancement.

[@CitirArt]

Komandirskie is the Kalashnikov of the watches. Affordable and durable.

[@TheGoodwolfe]

Very fair and thorough review! In fact, recently started looking at some of your older reviews and just became a new subscriber! I love the Vostoks, and have seven so far, including both Amphibias, Komandirskies, a SE GMT, and currently waiting for the SE 020 model with unidirectional 120-click bezel to be back in stock. Great job!

[@RelativeTime]

Thank you and thanks for subscribing! I'm waiting on the compressor style amfibia, but taking a little longer then I was hoping. I was also looking at a project watch that some of the members of the Watchuseek forum are trying to make. Custom k34 with gmt hand and compass bezel. Sort of a Vostok version of a Alpinist. Should be interesting, but might be a while before it gets off the ground.

[@joshuasowers3153]

I have a few of these and one Amphibia. Love them all!

[@HarryBunnGRVOTV]

Mine runs -2 spd, I paid £27 with 2 straps in mint condition! I also have an amphibia, both really cool.

[@KrisHandsome]

If I were to guess, it looks like the dial your Komandirski has shows a SA-4 SAM launcher. The configuration of the missiles on the chassis at least matches it. I like the variety in dials Vostok has. You can find nearly anything on the dial, though I've noticed that out the factory the Komandirski seems to have way more dial options than the Amphibia. Another great review once again, and I hope to see many more in the future!

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks! I think your right. I was thinking they were way oversized for artistic effect, but that looks like it could be. Thanks again!

[@BrotherClint-eg7vf]

Been hoping to find a review on this company. Thanks

[@ajones4064]

Thanks for the great video on these amazing watches!! I have fallen in love with these watches and understand the draw for so many people. You are correct, these watches are a great conversation starter and I've also noticed that people have become more interested in wrist watches after seeing, and discussing my collection of Amphibias. Now my son and son-in-law (both of which never wore wrist watches before) want an Amphibia Scuba Dude of their own. I have also enjoyed modding these watches. They are inexpensive and a great way to learn how to regulate and replace internal parts on. My collection includes 4 Vostok watches at this time (#SE420B06, 060334, 420270, 110059) Each is unique in it's own right, and I've enjoyed changing bezels, case backs, crowns, and straps on all of these. Of course, I'm addicted to time pieces in general, so my collection of various brands and styles will continue to grow. Thanks again and enjoy your Vostoks!!!!

[@darrensmith6999]

Thank you wounderful video.😀 Bought my first Vostok Komanderskie late last year out of curiosity and was very impressed with their quality and history I now own about 15 including many Anphibias. They are very addictive . I tend to buy them from a company called moscowtimeseller which can be found on e bay ,I have found them to be very reliable. I have done a limited amount of moding and usually the first thing I do like yourself is swap out the bracelet. Changing bezels and backs make them into a one of a kind watch 😀

[@TheSweede12]

Darren Smith I have 3 from different suppliers. Meranom seems to be the best for cost and speed of delivery. The all keep time around +10 seconds a day. I also bought my first one out of curiosity and it looks like I am addicted too

[@RelativeTime]

They are addicting. And the prices are so low, it's almost an impulse buy. I've ordered one of the compressor stylle amfibias. So I'm eager to see what Votok can do with a more modern design. But still using their older movements.

[@thomasont]

An interesting and informative watch review insights from the soviet era. Not to mention historical too. Another good example of practical watch design approach for effectiveness from the 1940's. With good regards, Thomason

[@RelativeTime]

Practical design is the best description for a lot of Soviet era engineering. One of my favorite stories is about how much money was spent developing the Fisher Space Pen. Meanwhile the Russians were happy just using a pencil.

[@thomasont]

I couldn't have agreed more with you. At times, its just best as it is less is more.

[@christianwilliams1690]

I have an 816307 ("Heineken") in the post to compliment my Amphibiia 720073 ("Sniper"). The rugged feel is my favourite aspect of the design.

[@dylvasey]

I've never owned or even held a Vostock. I'm afraid I just don't find them appealing. I can see why they have the same kind of following as Seiko but they just don't have the same quality or eye for detail. What I wanted to say was this was a great review. You obviously put a lot of effort into your video production and you most certainly deserve a bigger following (which I'm sure will come). Keep up the great work. I've subbed and I'm looking forward to seeing more from you in the future.

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks and Welcome. Yah, Vostoks are not for everyone. Part of the appeal is that they are cheap, so you can buy a bunch on just impulse. For some that roughness is part of the appeal as well. Kind of a throwback to soviet era engineering. Rough, unsophisticated, but durable. I recently got one of Vostoks newer Amfibia (with an f) Scubas. It's using their older movements, but in a compressor style case. Finishing is much nicer, normal case back, no wobbly crown, mineral crystal glass. So it's interesting to see that they are trying to make some newer designs that will appeal to a broader modern audience. Thanks again! Cheers!

[@tjsogmc]

You either like them, or you don't. Seikos are fine watches. Vostoks have a certain quirky appeal and are very tough. But do you know that there are no laws preventing you from owning both a Seiko and a Vostok? I have many watches by many brands- they all are fun to wear for certain occasions or when I feel like it.

[@dylvasey]

@@tjsogmc I wasn't suggesting you could only have one ha. I only brought up Seiko as they also have a good following so are comparile in that regard.

[@tjsogmc]

@@dylvasey No worries. There are a lot of "fanboys" out there that rabidly defend one brand over another, but the truth is the every brand has it's good and bad points. I have many watches from many manufacturers and I wear them when the occasion calls for it. Nobody will judge anybody else if they own more than one brand of watch, and if they do, ignore them. Do what pleases you, that's what matters at the end of the day. Seikos are fine watches, and they have a strong following for good reason. Vostoks as well, although the brand isn't as recognizable outside of Russia due to the lack of retail distribution (they are primarily only available online or occasionally from a boutique). And yes, a Seiko 5 and a Vostok are roughly comparable to each other- to me it's a matter of whether or not I'm in the mood for borsht or sushi.....

[@75thteaster54]

I know it’s an older video but I have the same watch and took it to Myrtle beach and kept it on the whole time and while free diving off the inlet banks and it did just fine

[@jusuftheeagle6772]

amphibia with a p is actually an r as that is how you write an r in Cyrillic 🙂. - I love your videos and your speaking style, great video.

[@angrymoose3383]

I have my own and I can say with 100% certainty you made a good strap choice. The Komandirskie SERIOUSLY levels up when you take it off the truly atrocious leather strap it comes on and putting on a NATO with the dial colours

[@firestormlivingsolutions]

Great vid....looking forward to seeing your new model Vostok

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks. Its the Scuba model with the cushion/compressor case. I've posted a few pictures on my Instagram. It will probably be next month before i do the review. I have a few others I want to get to first. As well as trying to space out brands and types to add variety. So it's not an entire month of the same thing. Cheers!

[@jankay8569]

For me, I'd choose the Amphibia. That scuba dude dial is just so unique!

[@RelativeTime]

Thats why I got one. Although i went for the orange scuba dude rather then the blue one.

[@Feldwaldwiese]

I love my Komandirskie 811783, my first Vostok. Swimming with my Komandiskie was no problem. I think water resistance ist better than 20 meters, but not guaranteed by the factory. The only negative thing: Very thin chrome plating, the back is showing some brass coming through after one week of wearing it. My second Vostok, a Vintage Amphibia 1190046, is on the way from russia.

[@anishg8103]

Loved the review! Thank you!

[@Bigaletto]

Love it. Sick of review videos of thousand dollar watches from other channels

[@RelativeTime]

The ironic thing is you posted this the day I posted a review of a $650. 😎 But generally I like to review watches that are cheaper. 👍

[@davidgdraper6269]

I just ordered a komandirskie K39. Beautiful piece even with its quirkinesses.

[@RelativeTime]

Very nice! I really like the look of the 24hour / gmt verison. Cheers!

[@paulr1917]

I've always heard the Komandirskie's water resistance is highly underrated and probably closer to at least 10 bar.

[@christianwilliams1690]

With a screw down crown and caseback, thick rubber gasket and domed lucite, I think that's a very fair assessment

[@borishume5521]

There is a theory that the brass case of the Komandirskie can better withstand the electromagnetic pulse (EMP) created by a nuclear explosion than a steel case but I don`t know whether this is true. A have a Tissot Visodate and a Certina DS4 but find myself more drawn to my Komandirskie and Amphibia or my older Soviet Pobeda and ZIM (Zavod imeni Maslennikova - Maslennikov watch factory). I wore the ZIM in school and during my military service 1982-84 in an Eastern European country without any problems, still running after servicing it a few years ago.

[@TheSweede12]

I have a 431171 which ihas a white dial marked in 5 min intervals like a flieger B style. It's accurate to 10 seconds a day and it's definitely a conversation starter, all for £20. Based on this watch I bought an amphibian with the Ministery case design. It's a better watch however I think the Komanderski makes me smile a little more. These watches will never take the place of the top brands but for value and fun I think they are difficult to beat. Thanks for the video. I enjoyed it a lot

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks, I'm glad you like it. I'll have to remember that flieger like dial. I've been thinking about getting another and doing a mod project. Cheers!

[@rodzaytsev2103]

Thanks for your review! It made me like Vostok so much that one day I will get one. Speaking of Vostok’s funny dials, try looking out for a Vostok Operation Desert Shield. I’m pretty sure that this one was meant to be the most US market oriented Russian watch that has been made in Chistopol.

[@RelativeTime]

I recently ran across the re-issue one on meranom. I read the story about how to original ones came to be. For a while they were hard to find. vintagewatchinc.com/ussr/vostok/desert-shield/

[@worldofameiso5491]

Very nice voice presentation, you sound like a pro, perhaps a little bit cheesetastic, but very clear.

[@RelativeTime]

Thank you. So we talking Cheddar or Swiss?

[@miked2662]

I had one of these classic Komandirskies while I was in the Army, I wore it for about 2 years but I eventually got rid of it because the chrome plating started coming off due to sweat from daily use. Mechanically it was sound, however.

[@RelativeTime]

That's cool. Although perhaps expected with the chrome. I was recently looking at the Desert Shield / Storm Amphibias. No idea how what came about originally. But Interesting. Cheers!

[@miked2662]

Relative Time ironically, if I would’ve worn it on a NATO strap it would’ve probably faired better because it would’ve been off my wrist a bit more. I read an article about those watches somewhere on the interweb but I don’t quite recall the story, now I’m going to go back and re-educate myself on it haha

[@miked2662]

Alan Smithee Yes but I still have my two Timex watches that I wore on two deployments to Afghanistan, I’ll never sell those. :)

[@steven3379]

Cool that's exactly how I got into them, that and I have a Russian friend who grew up near the Luch watch factory! One of those, one handers is next! Good video thanks!

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks. I have to take a look at the Luch one handers as well. I noticed some on amazon the other day.

[@Mike-yy4ll]

Luch is a Belarusian factory. Belarus and Russia are two different countries.

[@melvinshelton8448]

I'm fighting with my myself over getting a Komandirskie, an Amphibia (Soviet, not with an "f"), or a 1-handed Luch wristwatch. Maybe all three, eventually! The Soviet Armed Forces were using 1-handed wristwatches for a while; do you know how that worked out? I wonder if Luch manufactured them. I'd also like to get one of those sweet and expensive German or Swiss things the cosmonauts were using for a while. It's ironic; like our Omega Speedmaster, it wasn't even made for space travel. Nor were the Komandirskie, the Casio (F35?), or any of the other more economical spacefaring timepieces, which did just fine.

[@steven3379]

@@Mike-yy4ll It is now but WASN'T it part of Russia before?

[@Mike-yy4ll]

@@melvinshelton8448 I highly doubt that 1-handed watches were issued by the military. Probably privately bought, personnel is allowed to wear whatever watches they want. As of my knowledge, 1-handed Luch are relatively new model and 1-handed watches just don't have the accuracy for serious use. Anyways, their are still a cool novelty and, eventually, I'm going to get myself all three models just like you.

[@javierpan2440]

Great review! You really put a lot of effort into the videos. Hope you get many more subscribers soon. I´m trying to decide between an Amphibia and a Komandirskie.

[@RelativeTime]

Growin Slow and steady. I was 500 just a few months ago, so I'm good with it. Seem to be more and more views everyday. Thanks again! Cheers1

[@davidmelhuish232]

Is there an online resource for identifying older models? I have owned a second hand one for a few years and would like more information on it. A local jeweller told me it dated from the 1970's.

[@Barnaby_bo]

I like the idea of the lugs being lower than the case. Never heard of that design before. Subtle but clever.

[@RelativeTime]

I've noticed a few other watches do that since this. The Boldr Venture I recently did took it to an extreme. Sticks way out, and very far down. Supposedly it helps when wearing a Nato.

[@nobody46820]

@@RelativeTime That's what I thought. How does the strap feel?

[@StefaanVdV1961]

I like the Amphibia more because the water resistant of 200m. Great revieuw, thanks for sharing.

[@RelativeTime]

It's definitely a more robust design. Thanks for watching cheers!

[@josepmariaaguascaribot9239]

The russian watchmaking is well-known for the sturdiness of their movements, although with scarce accuracy. Regards.

[@ШухратАзимов-д5л]

I love Командирские K65, better then Амфибия. See for Komandirskie 200 metr. 👍👊🇷🇺 classic Komandirskie for kids) Hi from Russia 👋👋👋

[@ильяфилатов-ц2т]

Hello, I'm Russian,I see the East is popular in the West, and you know a brand like rocket, they have a very cool watch, too, and unique

[@Peter-mz3tx]

Great video as usual

[@volvoturbo1]

Just got my first Vostok Komandiski from a thrift shop for 37 dollars. Is the one with the submarine. I Don’t know how old is it. There is no markings at 6 o’clock like cirílic Text. Is brass. I love it Keeps good time. I put a classic champion gold chain Band. Looks awesome.

[@RelativeTime]

That's very cool. I'm surprised to see one there. They have been building them the same way for decades, so I'm not sure how to tell it's age. You could ask over on the Russian sub forum of Watchuseek. Depending on the combination of case and dial someone may give you a rough idea.

[@volvoturbo1]

Thanks, your videos are very informative. This watches are very nice on their own league. And as you said, Very colorful in a good way.

[@laurianonofrei8847]

I have 2 Komandirskie 100 m wr and 2 Amphibia 200m wr. Both Kom and Amphibia are great watches. Verry affordable. And both can be used on swimming.

[@russellharris5072]

I recently bought a Komandirskie 020711 @ $77.00,still listed as classic 02 style but a far more modern design.All stainless steel and a w/r rating of 200 meters.I put it on a green and blue striped nato and it looks great..........................

[@matthewhornby2333]

I bought my first Konandirskie off a street market stall on the Charles Bridge in Prague in 1992, only a couple of years after the Berlin Wall fell and much of eastern Europe was democratising. That one got smashed a couple of years later, but eBay is still a huge goldmine of original late USSR era military pieces. Love my current one, but I could never reconcile a Russian watch on a NATO strap, you'll burn in Nav for that!

[@danl9161]

I, too, purchased an Amphibia from the sellers at the Charles Bridge at about the same time. I can't remember how much I paid but I think it was about £5 to £10. I had the watch for about 10 years and it took a battering. I seem to remember being able to buy things like night vision kit and other USSR army gear from those sellers although I only got a watch

[@Wasssssuppppppp6869]

Bought the Amphibian KGB One and I would have to say that it’s not a bad deal for the price. I would say that for a automatic watch that works it’s a hell of a deal.

[@RelativeTime]

It really is. You can get some automatic Chinese watches for this price, but I think I'd trust the Vostok more.

[@dodgydruid]

There was a watch in between known as the Commander, a kinda posh Amphibia sharing many aspects like the hands and main dial, lacking a bezel they had an outer ring under the crystal with extra notches for precision timekeeping and a date window. The Commander's sword hands were the same as the Komandirskie's with the Commander's dials not imprinted with various military logo's and emblems and some on Watchuseek suggesting it was an upper echelon "dress" Vostok for those not wanting to advertise they are with the military.

[@gregalonzo747]

On a recent business trip to Vilnius, Lithuania, I was introduced by a fellow watch enthusiast to Vostok Europe. Have you checked out these watches? They are big and bold, and well made. I believe that most of the models use Japanese movements. They are a bit too garish for my taste but check them out. You will certainly find them to be interesting. By the way, Vostok Europe has nothing to do with those watches produced in the Russia.

[@RelativeTime]

I've heard and looked online at a few. I think Meranom has some on his website. From my understanding it's a joint venture between vostok, and some Lithuanian manufacturer. I think at first they were using some Vostok movment't but quickly moved to Japanese. I'll have to check one out at some point.

[@IgorGjurovski]

Vostok with Japanese movement is not a Vostok.

[@gregalonzo747]

@@IgorGjurovski, Vostok Europe is not the same as the Russian brand.

[@wakawaka1976]

Do brass chrome coated cases last? I bought a Fossil watch back in the 90’s and the watch case fell apart and the lugs lost their holes...

[@eliakuiper4266]

"try not to get it wet" - I get mine wet on purpose - baths, showers, drop it in the sink while washing dishes, no problems at all

[@alexandrugrecov8964]

I swam with him in the pool a few times, no problem

[@amphibiousone7972]

My Kamanirskie is a Soviet version. No fancy back or dial for me . I love it 🤣🫡

[@donp2166]

Very nice presentation. I own 2 Amphibians, and just sold my Komandirskie. I know you like Meranom. I've had good luck with komandirskie.com., having bought twice. You select your language; pricing is in roubles, so you will need a currency-converter (easy, online) to know what you are paying...but they take PayPal and all credit cards. I've compared pricing and have saved some money with them. Delivery is comparable to Meranom.

[@RelativeTime]

Thank you. I’ll check it out next time I’m looking. Especially the price. I’ve noticed with melanoma you can change it to roubles, and sometimes it’s cheaper. But I’ll check out komandarskie.com. Cheers

[@Reviews4fun1]

Nice video. I just had to buy 2 amphibians. The month for shipping wasn’t too bad. Fun and unique watches for sure.

[@RelativeTime]

Thank you! The waiting isn't too bad. I just don't like having to sign for it. It's harder to hide it from the wife when there is a note taped to the door. 😎

[@Reviews4fun1]

I first heard of this watch via this book series that I recommend: Ryan Westfield Getting Out: A Post-Apocalyptic EMP Survival Thriller (The EMP)

[@RelativeTime]

Cool. I'll have to check that out.

[@siamwatchaddict9072]

I have 8 Vostoks and Komandirskes. my favorite is the 120 case with a blue sunburst dial. with no military toys.. I added the cosminaught case back Aurora second hand and P.O. bezel and insert .Looks Great keeps good time. And turns heads and asks questions... That said I have the Komandirske K-34 GMT. Thats a different world..

[@RelativeTime]

I know what you mean. I recently got a Amfibia (with an f) scuba. It's a vostok, but it's competently different then the other Amphibias and komandirskes. How do you like the k-34? I joined into a project watch project on watchuseek thats using it as the starting point. I'm eager to get it, but it won't be completed until next year some time.

[@neilpiper9889]

My favourite is the Vostok Amphibia 710 ministry case. My favourite Amphibia with the scuba diver on the black dial.

[@siamwatchaddict9072]

I have the radio room dial in my ministry case looks awesome..

[@siamwatchaddict9072]

You mention you watched my review of the K-34 .. Unfortunately because I rushed the video ,I put in some incorrect information.. 1.. The crown is not screw down. 2. When I opened the case back there was no gasket.. So I would not get the K-34 wet...

[@RelativeTime]

Ahh good to know. Surprised there is no gasket. Is it supposed to be 100m wr?

[@SevenDeMagnus]

So cool. Which russian brand (Vostok, Poljot, Raketa, Pobeda, etc.) has the best technology when it comes to diver's watch?

[@Br0ns0n]

As always great vid and top flight production values. Always a pleasure to see you've posted a new one. As for a preference between the Amphibia or Komandirski? I prefer the Amphibia because I never worry about getting it wet. But at those prices, why not both? And a few of each if there's more than one build you fancy. Although I probably wouldn't recommend either as a persons first mechanical. They have...a lot of "personality" to say the least and the unique quirkiness of them could put a new enthusiast off a bit.

[@RelativeTime]

Agreed, at the price you could try both. Heck order them at the same time, as it will take a bit to get to ya. Thanks again! Cheers!

[@hooya27]

The "cannon fire over sailboats" is likely crepuscular rays, or "rays of Buddha"; not so military as the other motifs.

[@dangerspouse4741]

Woo hoo! The #431306 has a T-34/76 on the dial! Gonna strap that baby on, load up "Girls und Panzer", and sing a rousing chorus of "Katyusha" while watching Pravda get its ass kicked by Ooarai Girls Academy...again. Lol. Another fun, informative review, buddy. Perhaps better than this watch deserved. Still, you made excellent points at the end about watches of this price/quality being great for learning watchmaking, and perhaps as affordable "do I really want an automatic?" pieces. Great job!

[@RelativeTime]

LOL!! Thanks a lot. Doesn't matter how cheap a watch is, I try to treat it the same. This one is destined to be a gift for one of my nephews. So I'm debating getting another one for myself as a project watch. I've seen some nice hands on ebay, supposedly with good lume. And I still have an extra bezel. So I keep thinking about it. Thanks again!

[@bill6634]

Love the vostok watches.

[@vijayrawat8558]

Dear sir i want to buy gmt Vostok watch Please suggested me which model should I buy?

[@darrelbautista9038]

Thanks for sharing well appreciated your videos for these Russian watch brands.

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks! Russian watches are always fun to look at.

[@darrelbautista9038]

@@RelativeTime Yeah very fun to look at and right now I will buy one☺️👍

[@СергейСеливанов-ч2д]

Часы Восток крутые!!!

[@bolandjd]

Hey RT, those missiles aren't drawn oversized; they really are that huge. SA-4 Surface-to-Air Missiles (SAMs) were designed to shoot down supersonic fighter jets. The crossed cannons is an insignia worn by artillery soldiers. Great review of the watch. I want one! Gotta love the irony of putting a Russian watch on a NATO watchstrap :p

[@RelativeTime]

The irony is not lost on me. But it’s the most comfortable way to wear one. Although I did recently see pictures of the amphibias mad for desert storm / shield. With the American flag front and center, but made in ussr on the botttom. Now that’s even more interesting. So I assume the artillery guys would be operating the SAM launchers. In which case the design makes a whole lot more sense now. And is even cooler!😎

[@bolandjd]

LOL. Yes, I dig those Desert Storm Vostoks too. The US and Russia were on the same team back then. There was a lot of optimism right after the end of the Soviet Union. So the crossed cannons is usually more of a field artillery symbol than air defense artillery symbol. In most armies, the two branches share a common lineage, going back to WWI when the first anti-aircraft guns were just light field pieces pointed at airplanes. But I don't know if that's what's going on here. Or if the watch designers are mixing up the symbology. Although the tracked vehicle with the huge missiles looks very much like an SA-4 system, I suppose its possible that its a surface-to-surface missile, which would make the crossed cannons more appropriate. I'm probably reading too much into it. You're right that its a cool picture to indulge your inner 13 yo.

[@robc8468]

I had an Amphibia I did not like it and the stem broke so now it sits in my junk drawer I like the sleeker Komandirskie so I ordered one as novelty for my watch collection of mostly Orient and Seiko watches. One question since this watch is 100% hand winding is it possible to over wind and break the mainspring or does it have over wind protection?

[@FitOutPost]

I like the GMT version above all.

[@RelativeTime]

I actually emailed you about it a few weeks ago, to see if your interested. But I wasn't sure if you got it. email me if your interested.

[@FitOutPost]

For some reason I never received your email, my friend, but I did send you another email about it just now.

[@Pinkchyo]

Nice video!!

[@RelativeTime]

Thank you!

[@1701spacecadet]

Da, Komrade!

[@vincewhite5087]

Have many of both.

[@rashiksharar]

Nice video. Got my Vostok komandirskie today. The issue is I'm hearing a loud ticking sound. Is this normal for all komandirskies?

[@RelativeTime]

There should be some, but it shouldn't be too loud. Should be quieter then most quartz watches.

[@rashiksharar]

@@RelativeTime Interesting... Cause I have a quartz watch from the brand called Earnshaw and it's absolutely silent. Also I own a very cheap $30 automatic which I bought 2 years ago from eBay from a brand called Jaragar, even that has no ticking sound at all.

[@RelativeTime]

@@rashiksharar should be some noise but shouldn't be overly bother some. But everyone is different. Like can you hear it when it's on your wrist?

[@rashiksharar]

@@RelativeTime No can't hear it on my wrist. But when I'm going to bed at night and it's silent everywhere, and the watch is next to me, I could hear the ticking sound. 🙄

[@mrsir1872]

One of the things i love about my ussr watches is how loud they tick. Sounds old school

[@milanvukas2930]

Guys I love the watches. Got both Komandirski and Amphibia. Does anyone know a good place to buy the good leather hand straps similar to the ones on the video. Also I have a big hand and standard leather strap of Komandirski just barely fits. I could not find anything on meranome website.

[@TinBin-Craig]

very nice cheers i like the Vostok Amphibian 710634

[@RelativeTime]

Scuba dude in a ministry case. It's a classic. Cheers

[@nealbeard1]

Thank you very good review.

[@RelativeTime]

Thanks!

[@Robozgraggi]

Excellent video as always! I have both an Amphibia and a Komandirskie and love them so much! I am however confused at people saying, that the water resistance of the Dirskie is limited and not good for swimming. I went swimming with it in rivers and lakes several times and never had an issue with it. I'd say as long as you screw down the crown tight enough you're safe to wear it for regular swimming.

[@RelativeTime]

Water resistance can be a confusing subject. If you check out the Wikipedia article on it, it has a chart at the bottom on what it recommends. The thing to remember is that when they test it. It's in a pressure chamber that simulates preasure at a depth. But the watch isn't moving, and temperature is static. But as you swim the arm movement puts a increased localized pressure on the joints of the watch. But two things to remember, those rating at recommendations are really on the safe side. As well as each watch may be different. Unless it's a dive watch, they only test a few out of each batch. So some may be built better, and some worse. Ultimately do whatever you fee comfortable with. If it's already survived swimming once. It's probably fine to do it again. Cheers!

[@Robozgraggi]

In case you were wondering: The tank with the comically huge missiles is called "2K11 Krug". Gotta admit I was very surprised to find out that something like this actually existed!

[@RelativeTime]

Robozgraggi Very cool. I didn't know what it was called. But someone mentioned that it was most likely a SAM missile launcher. As well as the cannons at the top are a symbol for an artillery division. So the design actually makes a lot of sense. It wasn't just randomly put together. kind of crazy... Cheers!

[@mikeharvey7641]

there are some videos where they freeze the watch in a block of ice,place it on bowling water and run it over with a car and it still runs. I have several and besides how many people have a Russian watch

[@RelativeTime]

I've seen someone freeze them, but I haven't seen anyone run over it with a car. I'll have to find that.🙃

[@NotThatOneThisOne]

There is a quick set date. Go to midnight, so the date changes, go back to 8pm, go back forward to midnight. Date changes again. Not the quickest, but much better than going through 24 hours.

[@RelativeTime]

Not sure I would call that quick set, maybe quicker set. 😎

[@chessoc7799]

My Komandirskie is automatic so they are not all manual unless they stopped making them. Mind you I got mine in the late 80s to early 90s so it may be a old type

[@RelativeTime]

Interesting. I know there are some larger komandirskies that are more built like amphibias, as well as the modern komandirskies. What's the water resistance of yours?

[@DavidUKesb]

These days the Amphibia is a higher quality and much more substantial and rugged watch than the Komandirskie. However, in Soviet times there was little difference in quality other than the waterproof rating. I'd highly recommend these amazing watches, and if you can't decide between the Amphibia or the Komandirskie, simply by one of each!

[@RelativeTime]

I've heard that before, that they were better in the past. Is it the quality of materials in the Komandirskies that's not as good? Or just the assembly?

[@DavidUKesb]

Hello. The old Soviet Komandirskies just appear to me to be more substantial and much closer to the Amphibia than the modern ones (which are still amazing value for money)

[@mcleanblades9234]

Are poljot and vostok related?

[@thomasmargolis3313]

Being so far inland, the komanderskie just made more sense. And then the second. Can an amphabia be far behind?

[@RelativeTime]

Vostoks are addicting. Within a month you will probably be looking at them. 😋

[@dang25272549]

I've got 24H komandirskie a while back... man it just like the AK47 rifle or Mi24 helicopter it's tough... solid.. and do the job very well except one drawback the luminous is not quite bright and last just a few minutes. Other than that it's a great watch and worth every penny! .

[@RelativeTime]

How do you like the 24h Komandirskie? I've thought about getting one a few times.

[@dang25272549]

@@RelativeTime Well .... I definitely Love this watch . Mainly because it's lovely 24H dial make a watch itself looks different (or very different) other than that it has a good price compare to the quality and keeping a good time ...what's else you need from a watch? . Oh.... don't forget this ... it's made in USSR ! .

[@MickyMouseLimited]

I owned this watch over 25 years ago and it was a good watch but something I remember I didn't like. The hand strap was not the most comfortable and the glass was getting scratch all the time. I replaced it with Casio illuminator and never looked back mostly because of Casio soft resin strap and mineral glass .

[@woonfaseng8737]

i didn't know until recently. Komandirskie also have DIVE watch version but they are more expensive ! i was trying to get a 80s era komandirskie with a 2 oclock crown but i think i will get a red dial red bezel dive Komandirskie instead at round 70 to 80 USD including shipping

[@RelativeTime]

I think there are a few that have 200m wr, but they are built more like a Amphibia. Still gives you some good options.

[@neilpiper9889]

I stand corrected. I just checked my Russian instructions that came with my new Komandurskie original model. It says 2atm which is 20m. I think it must be because the case is brass. I put silicone grease on the washer in the case and around rhe stem of the screw down crown. Maybe that's the reason water does not get in.

[@RelativeTime]

I'm not sure why it's only 20. Other then brass, the designs isn't a whole lot different then an Amphibia. Using Silicone Grease is a brilliant idea though. Cheers!

[@NM-ev7pu]

Ordered one, cost me 38€ including shipping^^

[@RelativeTime]

That’s pretty good. Hope you enjoy it.