The Atlas of Peculiar Galaxies with Charles Liu & Neil deGrasse Tyson - Cosmic Queries

[@MistSoalar]

The way Charles explains is somewhat mesmerizing. Wish I had a science teacher like him

[@h7opolo]

he doesn't do it for me

[@StarTalk]

You're telling us! 🤩

[@ceaserusa4771]

Just curious - do you mean Charles Darwin - or Richard Dawkins, in teaching or explaining science? Because of you have either of the two - you not really learning any science at all

[@johnyepthomi892]

@@ceaserusa4771 Look what the cat dragged in.

[@TheNickarnett]

Charles Liu, StarTalk All-Star (among many other prestigious accolades!). Love it when he's on the show!

[@ceaserusa4771]

Can you please explain to me just what Charles liu is so great in - is it how he explains the universe, astronomy - what? Because believe me there is no science and what he or Neil Tyson explains. - Sorry to burst your bubble, but they are lying and charlatans who look to their religion which they call evolution - and evolution contradicts science in every way.

[@pandaprophetable]

Charles Lou and Janna Levin ftw

[@hanstubben]

Charles seems already to be in a higher dimension of knowledge! Great to have him on the show!

[@a.j.infowars7582]

He is way past the close minded Neil!

[@the_Acaman]

​@@a.j.infowars7582 I love Niel but I have to agree to some extent- thinking outside the box is what got us here

[@RainingUchiha]

On point with the simulation question. One of my favorite D&D moments. Someone was running a perception check with no real reason as the character could clearly see everything that was going on but they wanted to be sure. So the DM said " for a second as you are searching and checking you notice for a split second you are on a giants table. Your party members appear to be statues not moving and you notice 5 giants sitting around the table. You come back to reality a split second later."

[@aungthuhein007]

Wish this episode was 10x longer seriously.

[@ceaserusa4771]

No my friend - if you knew the truth of what these guys project to the audience - you wouldn't want any of it there is no science between these two - and the whole concept of evolution contradicts science in every way

[@Anpeo]

Man that discussion about the brain lighting up when you're in love and trying to fake it was intense. I was trying to listen to the podcast while falling asleep but it's all too engrossing. What an episode. 🔥

[@James-pl2oy]

Charles Liu and Heather Berlin are my all time favorite guests!

[@alexgonzalezjr6823]

Charles Liu AND Neil degrasse Tyson ARE THE CHAMPIONS OF SCIENCE!!

[@ceaserusa4771]

Sorry to hear that you believe these two - clowns - as champions of the science realm. We could all learn a lot more of the truth - if not for these two clowns and others like them. Four they suppress the truth - and bring about pathetic theory illusions - which they call evolution if you want the truth - look to God and the Bible - then look into creationism, which explains how everything came about - and believe me you will see a great difference - in the end you'll know why you have been cheated and lied to

[@michaelccopelandsr7120]

Neil and Chuck for 2024

[@SiCl-sd2ib]

Sir, you've made me wonder what it would be like to have a duo presidency, and how would that would be ran. That has nothing to do with anything but, Neil and Chuck for 2024! Made me think of that.

[@MaryTongx]

With changes in the economy leading to instability in the stock market, some individuals may face a decrease in their investments in an effort to benefit from the current market conditions, I am considering liquidating my $725k portfolio consisting of bonds and stocks. Someone else in the same situation? Please tell me in the comments!..

[@MaryTongx]

@Joseph Green I have been exploring the possibility of utilizing advisors to help navigate the stock market during these uncertain times. However, I am still evaluating their potential effectiveness in providing the support I need.

[@MaryTongx]

I was considering changing my investment strategy and planning to sell certain positions. As my retirement is coming soon,I became increasingly stressed. After thoroughly researching Christy Vallen D'souza on internet, I concluded that I had made an informed decision. Thank you for this Pointer. She seems very proficient and flexible. I booked a call session with her too. @Joseph Green

[@limppu1337]

I usually watch Startalk to calm myself before sleep. However, when i hear these four doing CQ episode, i grab a beer and laugh my bottom off with the fellas.

[@dingaia]

Love when Charles on the show!

[@teeceefitzgerald8922]

I LOVE STAR TALK…..these conversations make You want more…..Enjoy how anyone can comprehend the explanation to all the questions……

[@user-tc1fw5ms5s]

Charles episodes are so dope! And Chuck is here, top notch episode

[@unicorndragonmike3018]

paranormal activity could just as easily be overlap in the multiverse or interdimensional interaction between alternate realities :).

[@elizondorj]

Charles Liu, Chuck Nice and Gary O'Reilly! Such a party! 🥳 And of course, Dr. Tyson saying he knows what love is... 😎

[@muhammadjon25]

How do you know what's the glitch is, if everything you know is simulated? In other words, how can you tell what's not real when you never knew what reality looks like?

[@pejko89]

My favourite line-up! Charles Liu is amazing!

[@dracomaster4]

The glitches being paranormal was also a point of interest in the second matrix from.

[@StarTalk]

Check out Dr. Charles Liu's podcast, 'Into The Liuniverse': www.youtube.com/@TheLIUniverse

[@dolphinfan65]

Charles LIU I LOVE THIS MAN and his explanations of anything!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@ShutterJunkie]

This episode was Amazing! I wish all people could debate as respectfully as you all.

[@dancooper8551]

Excellent episode!!

[@bradew2]

Charles dropping the sci-fi pop culture references and info. I like it!

[@huldu]

Great episode! Charles was so articulate and easy to understand.

[@mattofalltradez]

Fantastic episode!!!

[@TheRabbitRonin]

I like how Gary has a Cosmic Queries book behind him!

[@TJ-hs1qm]

Dr. Frankenstein.... 🤣 don't mess with The Chuck

[@edwardbontrager9721]

Fantastic guest. My center of the universe “understanding” described @ 32:45 is a marching band. The marchers in the center of the ring march much slower than the ones at the outside of the ring, so naturally because we have to define our view as the center, the universe expansion should appear faster at it’s furthest points from our observations. Am I close?

[@isaackitone]

This was not "Startalk Sports Edition". It was "StarTalk Love Edition".

[@chancemeyers8502]

Neil and Charles just know how to articulate science to science enthusiast or even the common curious person with this amazing velvet touch. They break everything down without getting rid of the wonder and science of what is actually happening. Which is why Startalk is special. ❤

[@chancemeyers8502]

Chuck and Gary are just as important of course. They bring their own curiosity into it. Chuck actually asked that collision question, something Id always been curious about myself.

[@OZtwo]

YES! WE are looking up with AI! I can't wait! And I love all three of you! And also you guys still have the simulation idea backwards! How can we tell we are in a simulation if we are the simulation and the simulation itself created it's own laws of physics!

[@netgnostic1627]

So ... what does the simulation do when the occupants invent things the simulation didn't allow for? If the occupants invent a James Webb space telescope, what happens when the astronomers aim it at an unobserved part of the sky? Do extra galaxies appear into the simulation? Or were they always there? If a young genius cosmologist comes along, with an unexpected theory of the universe that the simulation never included, does the simulation extend with new aspects of physical laws that match the guy's theory? Or is something introduced that will prove him wrong?

[@OZtwo]

@@netgnostic1627 They simply watch and learn to see how they evolve. It all started from a small 'big bang' as they like to call it.

[@Dvergenlied]

I come back to this episode every two or three months just to listen to Charles and Neil argue about love 😂. Love the wild debates on these episodes

[@juliam7056]

That was an awesome episode. Me just binge watching all of them lol. Wonderful job ! Bravo!

[@ceaserusa4771]

Glad you liked it but - sorry to burst your bubble - - - all of it was a lie the base these theories on evolution - a theory in which contradicts signs in every way

[@castagninofabio]

Getting sharper every day Chuck!!

[@thinkingenglish1175]

Interesting talk about love, but I think love is a decision. You can love anyone, no matter how undeserving, if you decide to. Hate works the same way. These emotions aren't caused by others, they are our own reactions to other people. Causation starts, in my view, in the brain and not with externalities.

[@sarang47]

That Black Mirror episode Neil mentioned is legendary!!

[@dimitriosgkirgkiris9486]

oh yeah, absolutely my favorite episode so far!

[@EVILOLIVE341]

Great as usual, I would love to hear. Michio Kaku's View on this subject.

[@netgnostic1627]

For a moment there, I thought Charles Liu was going to say, "Now that the Hubble has been humbled, we use the James Webb." So let's all refer to it as the Humble Space Telescope.

[@wearethefruitoftheuniverse]

AI should categorize all repeated spectrum gradient of frequencies, if it repeats but in multiple distances then we got a new set of what is possible in the universe. Could some of the data show echoes of, say, a black hole, with signatures so scattered it covers a huge portion of the sky

[@Johno144]

I love when smart people argue. Great episode

[@kielabadeaux3135]

This episode was absolutely phenomenal. Listening to intelligent people respectfully debate/cross ideas is so satisfying ❤

[@offaxisfpv]

great content and Charles Liu is a comedian. thank you

[@Michaelthetical]

This was great! Probably one of my favorite Cosmic Queries!

[@ceaserusa4771]

Sorry to burst your bubble - but that was all a lie - the whole concept and theory of evolution - is a lie, based on a mystical fairytale religion - called evolution

[@davidt3956]

neural networks are the basis of deep learning. As Charles said, they're still far simpler than the brain, but we can manipulate them even more easily :)

[@ceaserusa4771]

In a way you're right - manipulating the brain is far easier than know of - just like Neil Tyson does every day - he spews out lies and disinformation about the universe and science altogether - there is no truth no facts of what the states, in trying to explain the universe - that is because the use and go by their religion they call evolution so yes - they to manipulate the brain very easily - the indoctrination starts at grade school - and up to the universities.

[@topspacesource]

Chuck made a very valid point before everyone started talking over him.

[@Paha1725]

Great episode!

[@alexreynoso8867]

Thank you for answering my question!! It was amazing :)

[@CrazyJc2000]

The lightning makes niel look like a super villain 😂

[@justbeingadad2599]

Charles is so awesome!

[@mosesmilliman]

Love cosmic queries

[@JustConsciousStardust]

More Charles Liu!!! ❤

[@englewoodmusic]

Since there was Elon Tusk... there needs to be... Neil DeGrasse Byson.

[@savagepro9060]

I thought Neil DeGrasse was BEFORE Elon?

[@shawnlorenzana2359]

How about Chuck Lice?

[@shawnlorenzana2359]

@@georgestewart8961 well done.

[@ThizzRyuko]

Gary O's-my eye holes?

[@englewoodmusic]

Chuck miiiice lol this is a healthy social media interaction.

[@randomdazz]

I just realised something - We are assuming our reality is something special or realistic or as good as it gets - so anything below that would be glitches - what we call a good enough simulation may be small sauce for a real reality if this was a simulation - it might just be good enough for us.

[@jfreshh330]

Not sure what this has to do with sports but nevertheless this was an awesome episode. I loved when Neil explains the Black Mirror episode 😂

[@ZorellUnderhood]

This is the Dream Team of the channel. They always deliver the best content.

[@WtfYouMeanDude]

Nutty professor,Arsenio Hall and jordan peterson ask uncle roger about the universe😎

[@SheSweetLikSugarNSavage]

❤Charles at 34:00 makes more sense. Others may see it however they see fit, but our basic blueprint that has always been, both when Neil talks how about things -life creation on earth and the ways galaxies give birth to new stars. This is the way our ancestors describe things -As Above, So Below. Our observable universe, and everything within it looks like the design of a living cell and we can see that resemblance. So the mirroring effect that Dr. Levin was trying to compare sounds more like the dividing of cells, and each cell replicating an exact copy of itself for its specific function, but each cell copy being a different universe, each universe a different dimension. That just feels more logical than the balloon theory being a single point that simply expands. Everything that we know in our reality splits and divides countless times. The Zinc Spark wouldn't this be like the big bang, but on a smaller scale? And after this, division of individual (cells) galaxies begins. This pattern is literally in everything. Even in our way of creating societies. So if we are made of star stuff, then this is in our blueprint. You can't say it would be different for the universe, when we are the universe. If my egg just expanded after its big spark, but never divides it would probably just rupture and die. Because it couldn't divide.

[@susanjimenez5500]

19:49 - what if there are people who see glitches but we call them crazy and dismiss them?

[@rezadaneshi]

Asking AI, If there is one, does the antimatter universe have inverse colors to the matter universe if observed?

[@yourguard4]

No, colors are the same.

[@zefmanx]

I wish they had settled the debate on love, that was fun to watch

[@DrewsR6]

I wish these episodes were 3 hours long lol

[@Atmanyatri]

i loved the heated debate about love

[@Sith_420]

I love Charles Liu way of thinking.

[@mollybell5779]

30 minutes in, and uhh... Not sure why it's a "sports edition." Which is way fine with me, but yeah. 🤷‍♀️ Edit: Great video. Learned a few things. I love StarTalk, have been watching for years, and still look forward to each episode.

[@WittyWisdomAI]

@startalk - If universe is expanding uniformly at all directions at whatever speed then how come galaxies are colliding with each other sometimes?

[@colonelkurtz2269]

Albert Einstein made contributions to physics. His brother Frank made well he made a monster

[@ClintonFerrara]

Another great show. The best one until the next one and so on through infinity.

[@rocketRobScott]

I say the wave/particle observer phenomenon is evidence that we ARE in a simulation. And if we are, then we’re all technically A.I., each individually becoming more unique with the accumulated experiences of our “lives.”

[@hotchhotchi4866]

one of the best shows ever

[@johnherron3961]

Excellent one guys.

[@michaelccopelandsr7120]

My idea so I get to name it! Voyager 1 is now in interstellar time or "Mikey's Time." "V-ger's" message has sped up now that it's outside our suns time bubble or, "Terran Time." It will be faster still when "V-ger" sends a message from beyond the Milky Way's time bubble. (That name is still up for grabs.) Then there's Outside the Local Group time bubble, so on and so on until we get to the, "True Interstellar Time Standard." Now that "V-ger" is in interstellar space, it's also in the Milky Way's STANDARD, faster moving, interstellar time or "Mikey's Time." This can be proven by turning off everything except its clock and transmitter. Have "V-ger" read time for as long as possible. They WILL show the flow of time speeds up the further away you get from any celestial bodies. Until you reach the Milky Way's time standard or "Mikey's Time." •Our sun's time bubble: "Terran Time" we know and have measured. •Milky Way's time bubble or "Mikey's Time." The rate/flow of TIME outside any influence but within the Milky Way: We just got there and are still figuring. Wild guess I'd say time will increase in speed, now and until V-ger is outside the Ort cloud .007-.07% faster, maybe. Just for reference. •Local Group's time bubble or the rate/flow of time outside of any influence but within the Local Group: Name still open and unknown. Wild guess .08% to a couple seconds faster, maybe. Used just for reference. •Outside any influence in the, "True Interstellar Time Standard," or...;-P Name NOT up for grabs BUT just begging to be measured. The rate/flow of time is fastest here. (Time flows fastest here so it's best to have your motor boat.) ;-P A minute is a minute in all. It's the rate/flow I'm talking about. The Milky Way's Interstellar Time Standard will be known as, "Mikey's Time." Pass it on, please and thank you.

[@jeffreylevin1566]

The word you were looking for is SOLIPSISM - the view or theory that the self is all that can be known to exist.

[@ManaBDew]

Ty Mr . Charles And, Mr. Gary 🎉🫶🌌💫😎👍🥖🍷🎄🎁

[@ihaveanunorigionalname]

Charles Liu is awesome

[@BayouBreakdown]

Neil, I have to admit that I’m slow on the uptake. I need teachers and others to hand hold me through the learning process. I struggle with remote learning, and math has been too difficult. I need a teacher in the room to hand hold me to the finish line. Life has been too difficult and exacted a high price from me. I don’t even feel like talking to anyone after the Covid crisis. I need teachers and aides who can support me directly through the learning process.

[@Catspeaksart4College]

The description of a sociopath mimicking the performance of love is eerily similar to autistic masking. Emotional abuse victims have funky brain chemistry/performative emotions too. Love is a psychiatric piazza.

[@JoeVanGogh]

I 'love' this episode And could it be considered logical love? like even without empathy you could probably still decide to treat someone a certain way right? Same thing like when your mad at someone and you tell them you love them anyways😂😂

[@savagepro9060]

StarTalk: When Galaxies Collide--- Samsung: 🪦

[@edpotter1491]

I love you guys! Thanks, Charles!

[@jamespatrick5930]

I watched a video about 2 weeks ago that presented a good theory about the Black Hole exiting at high speed & creating stars in it wake was: 3 galaxies colliding & the 3-body gravity interaction to throw 1 black hole out at high speed.

[@willw.3366]

NDT loves having Gary on just to be able to interrupt him. Even interrupts Gary's introduction lol

[@whatareyoudoingoverthere1425]

Omg this was my favorite episode so far❤

[@ZigZagKid_AZ]

Chuck reminds me of the wayan brothers

[@lazaruslong92]

Mind blowing time travel story. All You Zombies, Robert A Heinlein

[@troyhorsman1568]

what is the a amount gravitational curvature/pressure to form a star or planet?

[@teknophyle1]

I think we need a brain expert for some of these questions and statements. Heather Berlin maybe. for example, I challenge that empathy is necessary for love and I'm curious what she or maybe a psychologist would say about it

[@danielthompson9118]

Truly a great episode and could watch another 30 minutes, BUT did they talk about sports at all?

[@schalufu4634]

First time hearing this kind of talk. Love it and almost understand it. ❤

[@stephenarmiger8343]

This is so cool! Some of it reminds me of Star Trek, the Original Series, where the computer is asked to solve a problem!

[@morriemukoda45]

I love this episode when everyone is right but at opposite sides!!!🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@anwaypradhan6591]

How can neural networks help in discovery of cosmos?

[@Nefville]

I've heard a logical answer for the simulation hypothesis, its that if a civilization above us was smart enough to create our simulation, then surely there's a civilization above them that created their simulation. They're in a simulation that created our simulation - a chain of simulations in simulations that goes on and on. That leaves the question if all of them have simulations then why don't we? Statistically speaking if there are thousands of civilizations all with simulations then what are the odds we're the only ones without one? That kind of closed the book on the simulation hypothesis for me.

[@BenjaminCronce]

They're talking about me with love. I've never experienced a feeling of love but I have a desire to "care" for people. My wife and I have been happily together for 20 years and she feels very loved. The kinds of people they're "hypothetically" talking about do exist. My motivation to "love" a person is not because I feel love. It has taken me a long time to figure out how love should "act", as it is not rational. Welcome to the autism spectrum.

[@vaaz_rodriguez]

For an individual with some kind of social disorder, love could be "processed" by a different system in the brain, that is why it does no look like the rest of the people in the scanner... It could be similar to synesthesia... just like a bat that processess images through the sound... of course; for a logical machine, love can be interpreted as an algorithm... that is why right now a computer cannot simulate feelings... this reality will change with the use of quantic computing... that is my hypothesis... this episode was quite good, I love when scientist fight in a argument...

[@frankwestphal8532]

Nice impression Chuck!

[@anwaypradhan6591]

Recent study suggests that quantum computers are much more effective and efficient, are much more faster, reluctant and advanced in exploring universe, finding out every mechanism of thermodynamical process of universe, finding out mechanism of working of universe, sketching it and then representing it towards people, much more dynamically.

[@AndiRAin1]

22:45 The name of the song is Panic by The Smiths.

[@a.j.infowars7582]

“When Galaxies 🌌 collide” Everyone: Not Funny.