The Best & Worst Eyeshadow Palette | 10 Brands

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Would you like to see a full ranking video on any of these brands? The ones I have the most of would be Juvias Place, GlamLite, Morphe, Natasha Denona, Menagerie... 💙

[@ewokallie]

Glamelite please. I want to buy from them. I was thinking about the cake and the burger, but saw the burger had shadows leaking oil.

[@rachelsnodgrass6262]

Juvias place and menagerie would be interesting!

[@yaltazhu9683]

Glamlite please! I just bought the cake palette and it is so good!

[@mysticalmermaid3650]

Amy Loves Makeup would love a ranking video - on any of the brands

[@Barbara-nb8wz]

Yes please except alter ego no interest in the brand sorry

[@lydiam9104]

"money-motivated", the classy shade 😂

[@MiaRBeauty]

"people that were more money motivated" what a classy drag lmfao, i love it

[@leahmiranda8359]

Money motivated.....😂😂 Gently pigmented...😂😂 You have the sweetest way of making a point.💚💚

[@BeatPharmacist]

I’m happy to see that you’re doing well. I feel like the Nubian is a pretty boring palette as well. The Magic palette is my favorite because of the unique blue toned purples.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you! How are you doing? 💙

[@BeatPharmacist]

Amy Loves Makeup I am hanging in there as best I can. This one’s definitely going down in the history books. I’m definitely gonna play with your palette some time this week even though I have no where to go all made up.

[@unabashedlybroken6789]

I love the magic palette. That was my first Juvias palette. That began my Juvias obsession. It's still my favorite too but like Amy I also fell in love with tribe when I swatched that white shade. I was in awe of that shift

[@donandsteph1999]

Amy has amazing taste in color stories! We both seem to share a love of purples, blues, and greens.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you Stephanie 😊

[@diaryofabeautyguruwannabe6306]

This was such a fun video to watch! I would love to see you mix and match your Natasha Denona shadows to create your perfect ND palette like Samantha Ravandahl recently did!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Yes I saw she posted that!! So cool!

[@Sonicman415]

I just can’t w Morphe. There are so many great companies to support. Cool vid! You’ve been knocking it out of the park 🔥🔥🧡🔥🔥

[@thegoodanfamily9817]

I can't either. Their shimmers were horrible. The mattes worked ok, but what a waste if you can't use their shimmers. I'm not buying anymore from them. They are just not good.

[@maellyspichon2697]

6 seconds into your video and i absolutely HAD to stop and tell you how stunning you look !!!! Skin ? Glowing. Eyes ? Fireee and goes so well with your hair color ! Ok imma stop fangirling and go back to the video 😂

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you so much ❤️❤️❤️

[@nima16042]

Do best and worst eyeshadow singles plz!! I’m watching this even though I never ever buy palettes, I only own singles to avoid having duplicates! You look gorgeous, I love long hair on you 💕

[@KarenHarrismakeup]

omg the relic that is the 35O... i was obsessed...xxx

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

😂😂

[@MelBscents]

Every time I see that Natasha Gold palette I want it so bad!!! Gonna just have to bite the bullet and do it already!! Great vid!!❤️

[@Bluelilly40]

I feel the same...I want the Gold and Blue - purple palette, but I just can't bring myself to spend the money!

[@moomooreeves8886]

wait for the beautylish black friday sale

[@kourtney2030]

Theres always the Alter Ego dupe as an option. I mean, if you want the color story but not price.

[@thegoodanfamily9817]

@@kourtney2030 what about the formula? Is it close?

[@kourtney2030]

@@thegoodanfamily9817 I do not know. I dont own either brand. But the reviews I've seen have been good. I'd check out some videos for the alter ego pallete.

[@rachelsnodgrass6262]

You should totally depot that Natasha denona palette!! If it’s like the Colourpop palettes if you just use a magnet you can pop them out and right back in if you change your mind

[@lauralamantia5514]

I don't think I've ever seen you with red eyeshadow, it looks striking!❤ I like it

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thanks Laura!

[@KarenHarrismakeup]

aww thats so sweet that you gave your mom the goddess palette...xxx

[@riverg9677]

happy to hear you’re taking a break from Morphe, they’ve gotten away with being unethical for too long. i feel the same about Colourpop & the owner’s pride in being “fast-fashion makeup” 🤭 thank you for always supporting indie brands that deserve the love!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Yeah I was a bit turned off by Colourpop saying that. However the situation with Morphe not being transparent about a product no longer being vegan really got me. I just can’t believe it. ):

[@riverg9677]

Amy Loves Makeup omg i hadn’t heard about that! As someone who leads a vegan lifestyle that feels so violating. I stopped trusting Morphe last year & probably never will... Cruelty-Free Kitty & Logical Harmony have had Morphe on the gray list for years because they’re not forthcoming about their entire animal testing policy 😣

[@emilynmax]

So much fun to watch 😁 I'm so sad Dream St isnt available anymore 😭 it's one of my absolute favourites

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I know it was shocking they finally took it off the site!

[@luckeygirl023]

You broke my heart with the Nubian lol its one of my favorite palettes and my favorite from Juvias. I really want to get ghe Tribe palette!

[@courtney8504]

You look so beautiful.....yyyyyyyyyyaaaaaaasssss🔥. I am surprised you didn't choose certify pallets. I have a lot of good pallets thanks too you. Have a great day.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

We chose ones that we both had a bunch of! Have a great day! ❤️

[@elfinartist4961]

My favorite pallete I have is the Miracle one!!! I got it cuz of Angelica! I adore it!! Sometimes I swatch the two shimmers you mentioned and just look at em..like omg I love them😂

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Ahhh it’s so good isn’t it!? 💗

[@KarenHarrismakeup]

your brows look snatcheddddd!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you!! I finally did them lol 😂

[@celestecelestial90]

The lemonade palette 🍋 is a great spring palette. I need to use mine again soon.

[@theimperialsage]

There are a few brands on here that I would like to try this year. Videos like this always help me keep an eye on what I would like to try.

[@lillianacanales8562]

Your nails look so pretty 😍

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you!! 💚

[@MakeupwithMariela1]

Fun collab!! I was eyeing some of your worst but now I’m like 🤔

[@marenhohmann8992]

Hi Amy❤ any chance you have a makeup declutter coming up? There are my favorite type of video to watch, because 1. Im obsessed with cleaning and decluttering and 2. My birthday is coming up and I want to treat myself to one beautiful palette, but I just don't know which one lol. I would also love a Collection❤ Love you!! Btw I hope this doesn't come of weird but I actually feel like we are friends because I watch you soooo much. I was so excited when you commented on my last comment!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Hi Maren! I don’t do declutter videos often because I don’t declutter often haha. I think I’ve posted maybe one ever on my channel but you’re in luck because I actually do have another coming this month. But that’ll probably be it for a few more years if I had to guess. I hope you enjoy it! ❤️❤️❤️

[@marenhohmann8992]

@@AmyLovesMakeup awwww thanks for your replyyyyyy! Def looking forward to that hihi

[@annalunde3965]

I just ordered the Juvia's Place The Tribe palette and I am so excited to play with it! It's my first palette from them too 💚

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I hope you love it!!

[@annalunde3965]

@@AmyLovesMakeup Thank you!! The color story just speaks so much to me 💚🧡

[@MakeupByAnnki]

This was such a fun video to watch😍 Paulina palette is deff one of my absolutte faves🥰

[@blipstercravings]

I would love to see a full ranking of a brand. Also, this video has me very interested to see a declutter from you!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I have a declutter coming soon but they are not something I do often just fair warning. ❤️

[@blipstercravings]

@@AmyLovesMakeup yay!!!!!!

[@KarenHarrismakeup]

girrrrrlllllll you look beautiful.. i love that dark eye look, you've been doing so many pastels.. its been a fun switch..wow...

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Aww thanks Karen! This was actually supposed to be a pastel look I used the Sugarpill Fun Sized Palette 🙈😂👀

[@KatieMarie]

This is such a fun video idea 😍

[@juliasgalaxy5985]

Lol every time i I see ND gold I want it again and they are totally not my colors but it’s sooo beautiful and everyone seems to really enjoy it arghh lol . This was so fun 🤗💛

[@gabriellec7813]

Yesterday I was looking for a dupe for limechrome from the ND gold palette and BAM you give me one 👌 too bad I don't buy from Morphe...

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Vanessa’s Vanity samba single shadow is as close as you can get to the real thing in my opinion

[@lillianacanales8562]

Juvias Place Tribe is my fave from them too 💜

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

It’s such a good one!

[@amandawright9790]

Loving ur whole eyelook makeup vibe u got going on today

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thanks 😊

[@themakeuparchivesx]

I really wish I picked up the lemonade palette, such cute colours. Loved the video idea and hearing ur thoughts 💗

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you for watching 💜

[@Barbara-nb8wz]

Is there a video on this look? So pretty love the colours

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

It’s coming next week! Thank you ❤️

[@queenkatara7861]

I lowkey impulse bought Glamlite Miracle right after your video on it and like best impulse buy ever! Absolutely love it and I’m glad to hear it’s still your favorite!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

It’s such a good one! I’m happy you like it as well 💗

[@sinndymorr6358]

My fave palette you mentioned is Tribe by Juvias.

[@mysticalmermaid3650]

So glad to have so much awesome content from you during this time ♥️ thank you for that 😊

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you for watching it!! ❤️

[@aprilglass3183]

Please do more tutorials. Your blush and highlight look stunning!

[@angelab904]

I love the Nubian palette but I'm a neutral girl lol. You should try it. I am getting more into colors tho. I really want the tribe. Going to buy it on Mercari if it's discontinued now. So pretty.

[@JoysBeautyJawns]

Awwww this was so cute and fun!!! 🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷 thank you, Amy!!! 🥰🥰🥰 heading over to check out Karen’s video now ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️💐

[@naomilasby7744]

🤣 I opposite rank the kaleidos palettes! Cyber bronze my fave of the five and for sure most used, turquoise my least. (Close second is the sci fi green though.)

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thats too funny 😂

[@shannonfoster1800]

Amy do you have the Metropolis palette? I feel like you’d love that one. I’m still binge watching your videos as I’m a newer subscriber but I was curious ☺️

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I do! I really enjoy it 😊 Thank you for subscribing Im so happy you’re here!

[@ewokallie]

I am so glad you like the dc lemonade palette. that one gets so much hate, but i do wish the peach shade didn't hard pan on me.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Have you tried using a piece of tape to pick up the hard pan? That’s my go to trick

[@yeyiisz]

Amy, I’ve been subscribed to you for a whileeee and I have to say this makeup, your brows and camera quality in this video is on pointtttt 👏🏼 loving your content lately!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you so much 💜

[@deb.e.mixedmedia]

Hi, great video, thanks! I really love eye shadow palettes so I always enjoy these kind of videos. I would love to see a full ranking video of your palettes. 👍💖✌️💄🌸

[@bansheemuse4794]

Amy, I am a Taurus too, but my favorite Natasha Denona palette is the 28 Purple Blue palette lol. I enjoy seeing what people like and dislike. I do agree with you about Juvias place and I wanted to love the Nubian, but was so disappointed and I am a neutral eyeshadow lover.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Haha yes I saw your comment in Karen’s premier saying you loved it! 💜💜

[@metrini]

WOW!! You rated the Berries and Cream palette the worst?!! That's the one that I love LOL

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

🙈🙈

[@-cerra-5257]

Loved this video idea! Also, I am recently into single shadows, as I have enought palettes and I am looking for key colors. I feel like you are the queen of single shadows, especially from indie brands. A goal from this year was to purchase mainly from indie brands so you have been one of my go to channels :) Iwas searching your videos but didn't see your favorite blues (sorry if I am just blind)... Navy is one of the top colors on my list and would love a recommendation! Thanks!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I haven’t done a favorite blue single shadow video yet but I need to! I did do my perfect blue palette made of single shadows and then a week of looks using the palette!

[@celestecelestial90]

My least favorite CP palette is the yes please. The quality is so subpar. I don’t get the hype. I decluttered it. My favorite would be the good sport palette!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Oh yes I didn’t like that one at all either. I decluttered it

[@celestecelestial90]

Amy Loves Makeup It’s overhyped in my opinion.

[@amandawright9790]

I love the tribe palette and the Warrior 3 I was going to buy the Dolce one thats the only 1 I dont have that I want I am a color girl 2 def not a neutral fan. I think my overall fav shade from julivas is from the saharan 2 the minty duochrome its just beautiful

[@aaflesje]

That distraction during the nubian palette haha, thats me with everyone of my palettes ❤

[@MsMouthy]

Juvias is amazing. Since blush tribe is leaving, at least we still have JP

[@Monicaizpeace]

I would love to see more of this! Also the look you're wearing is breathtaking. Is that the Paulina palette?

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

No it’s the Sugarpill fun sized palette with some Clionadh singles. I have a tutorial coming soon!

[@Monicaizpeace]

@@AmyLovesMakeup YAY

[@MakeupwithMichelle]

Love, love, love, love, love this video idea 😂 and your makeup looks sooo stunning here 💕

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thanks Michelle 😊

[@MissFanVideoMakerin]

excuse me? your eyeshadow look is SO good!! idk if it's the color or the lashes but you look so stunning i can't concentrate on what you'e saying because i'm overwhelmed lol

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you 💗

[@rachelsnodgrass6262]

I was so surprised you didn’t pick killer purr as your least favorite menagerie palette!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I was disappointed by the formula not being what I expected but it’s not a bad palette and I love the color story!

[@Bluelilly40]

What a great list! I've wanted to buy the Natasha Denona blue- purple palette so many times, but I just can't bring myself to spend that kind of money. It's so expensive. I love the look you're wearing today! Are you going to have a tutorial? If not, would you give the details? Its gorgeous!!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Yes tutorial should be coming next week ❤️

[@TheSlimjadey1]

With the Morphe 35O. OMG yes!! It smells doesn't it!? I found mine a few weeks ago too and opened it up and it stank of really strong talc. I've been posting about it around the internet but no one's replied. I'm glad I'm not the only one who's had thing experience.

[@chidoll93]

Did you just make a heart break kid reference?! 🤣 awesome lol

[@amandaapplebaum3288]

Amy!!!!😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰 I have been loving you so much recently! never change love, you’ve been a great outlet and girlfriend for all of us❤️ Your eyeshadow look (as always) is STUNNING🤩 What is on your eyes???!!😋💕

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you so much!! I’m wearing the Sugarpill fun size palette and two single shadows from Clionadh 💗

[@tonyadavis3985]

Luv this ranking videos,,, luv to see more

[@RAINtears91]

I actually decluttered the juvian tribe palette even tho i loved the color scheme idea, the top three matte shades just looked very odd on me, like an off undertone somehow. My favourite colourpop palette is good sport, cause it gives me all my favourite eyeshadow colors, yellow, purple and green :D For kaleidos, i couldnt decide between the purple/blue and green/yellow palette :D The morphe 18b still tempts me, should i get it? It looks so interesting! Its finally available in my country now too xD My ND gold palette is also my favourite ND palette :D

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Ooh thanks for sharing!! I regret never getting the good sport palette haha. I really enjoy the quality of the 18B if you don’t have anything similar it’s really nice especially for the price

[@PoisonPearHFX]

You look so beautiful in this s video, Amy 😊

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you Beth 💜

[@celestecelestial90]

The Whalesong palette from menagerie is my favorite and my least favorite would be killer purr because I’m not a fan of the shimmer in that palette. My favorite palette from Dominique cosmetics is the latte palette and least favorite is the celestial thunder because the shimmers aren’t anything special.

[@KrisLouisa]

Omg Amy I’m so excited to watch this as I don’t move from my bed for the ?? hour in a row 🤪💝

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Perfect timing 😉😉

[@Sashylin]

I actually enjoy my 35o palette from morphe. Whenever I want a very simple and neutral look that's the one I reach for, even though I definitely agree the quality is not the best I tried. It's just that whenever I don't wanna think about what colors I want that one just works. 😂 Maybe it's because the colors work just great with my complex (or I feel like they do). Also I wasn't watching KZbinrs back when I bought it, so maybe it's also the fact that I just liked it a lot when I saw it on their site. 😄

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Yeah it’s not necessarily bad but when I bought it allllll of the big beauty gurus were saying it was basically the best neutral palette to ever exist. The claims were just too high 🙈

[@carrierickwood9775]

I wish I could order Alter Ego in Canada.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I really hope they expand their shipping!

[@carrierickwood9775]

@@AmyLovesMakeup me too!

[@tdsollog]

Another great video. Love from the Pine Barrens in NJ

[@theeluannesantos]

I’m not a fan of Morphe. I did want to try a couple palettes they recently released but I know I don’t like the formula and the last time I used a palette from them it irritated my eyes. It’s been years and I’ve heard the formula is different but I’m not sure? 🤷🏻‍♀️ maybe when Ulta opens again I’ll get it there so I can return it if it’s bad 😂 I love this video idea!

[@gigulina666]

Glam lite is not very known in Poland, we have a few indie Polish brands, and I would rather support them, but i got Miracle Palette in Angelicas Tribe Beauty Box and it's stunning! perfect combination between, oranges, pinks and browns.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

If you have the time and want to share any Polish Indie brands please feel free to link them! I’d love to look into them more 😊

[@gigulina666]

@@AmyLovesMakeup instagram.com/glamshop_pl?igshid=y1icauxhlqx2 ❤

[@minteymouse8045]

Your video quality is really nice!!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you 😊

[@jodymack7018]

No bh cosmetics, huda beauty, colouredraine?

[@agapelovegirl]

Love the idea for this video!

[@cloverzouzi]

love these types of videos! I have to ask: what are you wearing in your inner corner? it looks stunning!!!!!!!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Im wearing a Clionadh iridescent multichrome. I can’t remember the shade off the top of my head but I have a full tutorial coming on Tuesday

[@SofiasOutlet]

Just came from Karen`s video! By the way your makeup is so pretty, love it with the top and earrings

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Yes I saw you in the chat!! Haha! Thanks for coming over and for the compliments ❤️❤️

[@SofiasOutlet]

Amy Loves Makeup Haha awesome! You’re welcome 😄❤️❤️

[@emmkej9096]

Love the daily uploads currently! 🤗❤ Also, maybe link Jen Phelps cause she did the same video the other day. She loves neutrals so her picks and brands are very different so both of your versions compliment each other well.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you! And I’ll have to check out her channel I’ve never watched her. I typically link people when they inspired my video. Karen did this back at Christmas time. 😊

[@carolinecarter5588]

What highlighter are you wearing? It’s mesmerizing ✨

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I can’t remember the name but it’s one from Bitter Lace Beauty. 🙈 I’ll have a tutorial on this full look up next week

[@janvierbalser2849]

pretty earrings

[@TheGuroLOLITA]

Thank you for your honesty beautiful

[@unabashedlybroken6789]

I love kaleidos so much...and on my beauty chat group in fb no one even knows what I am talking about. I keep spamming them with my kaleidos looks...and stressing . These shimmers are UNREAL everyone...but they are all about JSC and HUDA. Oh well. I try.. love my kaleidos...I really want them all. I have Astro pink, the turquoise and the neon...all amazing shimmers!

[@amandawright9790]

I really want a kaleidos palette I know I will love them all the people who love the same type of makeup I like loves them

[@jessierichardson4006]

I really want the cyber bronze and astro pink palettes. Every time I go to the website, I chicken out.

[@unabashedlybroken6789]

@@jessierichardson4006 do it cyber pink is the best. Do the 3 palette bundle it's so worth it.

[@jessierichardson4006]

@@unabashedlybroken6789 you are a bad influence! 🙄💜

[@zebrawarriorpaint2066]

60 collections 😶 😅 lol I own 1 colourpop palette

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

In 1 year!? It’s madness 😂🙈

[@jessierichardson4006]

Ok, I have to ask: which one? Don't leave us hanging! Haha!

[@kourtney2030]

Same! I have Smoke Show. 🖤🤍

[@zebrawarriorpaint2066]

@@AmyLovesMakeup absolute madness!

[@zebrawarriorpaint2066]

@@jessierichardson4006 lol it's blue moon

[@abeilles26]

Wow Amazing eye look!!!!!!!

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you!

[@mariac4327]

So glam😍😍😍

[@meganl.4850]

I laughed a lot when you pulled out your least favorite Morphe palette. I pulled mine out after that and I was like, "yeahhh, why do I still have this?"

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Right. It needs to go but it almost feels sentimental at this point 😂

[@tirshasmith5999]

You look cute! 🤎❤️

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Thank you! I’m so happy to see you here Tirsha I was thinking about you the other day. How are you doing? 💜

[@YuckyMama]

I love Dominique Cosmetics color stories but their shimmers are terrible. I own both palettes you mentioned but damn those shimmers just don’t work for me. Colourpop’s It’s My Pleasure is one of only 3 palettes in my collection that I have a backup for (the other two are limited edition so I bought another before they disappeared). I’m surprised you own the 35O - a 98 pan palette that could be condensed into 6. Some of those ND mini palettes are terrible-weird hard pan, patchy. Just horrible. Love Potion and Sunrise are lovely.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Haha I bought the 35O yearrrrssss ago. I was a different person then 😂😂 Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

[@alivewithabby]

Wow I’ve never been so early to a video! Perfect to wake up to :)

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Yay!! 😊

[@MiniMeags]

Oh the KL.x Morphe 🥺

[@LittleMakeupChannel]

🧢 👱🏻‍♀️ 🧣 🧥👍🏻 👖 👢👢 🎒I was thinking so much of getting a Morphe palette but - there are so many other brands...thanks 👍🏻

[@rachelel9087]

When you opened that 35O from Morphe I was...so not impressed. People tried to hype that?! 😂 Yikes.

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

People were ride or die for that palette haha

[@rachelel9087]

@@AmyLovesMakeup it reminds me of their april fool's palette! LOL

[@brigidabanfelder4015]

Agree with the Morphe 35O palette. This palette is such a bore! And so much hype for not much. It is so monotonous. I gave mine away.

[@amysmithssportsandmakeup1397]

I will never buy from Morphe again. Got my first Kaleidos palette and highlighter in the mail today!

[@sarahmccarty7112]

Fellow Taurus here. I hate that more often than not we get a booooorrriiiinnnng brown. 😭

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Right!! 😂

[@saschachurch1]

❤️

[@wiredayan9719]

At first i thought that this was ranking formulas 😭 Enjoyed the vid anyways tho

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

Sorry for the confusion 💜 That sounds like a fun idea!

[@erikagamboaz]

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@Wmr614]

Just finished Karen’s video, I should be working but...hi 👋🏽

[@AmyLovesMakeup]

I’m happy to have you here 💜💜