The Bible and Western Culture - Nietzsche and the Death of God

[@jaylxxxi1908]

Michael Sugrue, 1957-2024 RIP

[@Libertybabe]

Nietzche was in some ways like the Donald.

[@TTKDMS]

This man has helped me expand my mind more than any other single person in my life. RIP to a very wise man and a very generous one.

[@billielachatte4841]

Respect from Indonesia.

[@Hjkkgg6788]

He died?

[@SuperP37]

@@Libertybabe you understand neither. mediocre humans always despises the exceptional. Their life will never improve.

[@ds6427]

Michael Sugrue is such a brilliant, passionate, articulate man. It's hard to come by lecturers like him today. He's a gift to us all.

[@jasoncherry3404]

Professor Sugrue has become a virtual mentor for me over the past couple of years. It started with Marcus Aurelius, that lecture came at a crucial point in my life when I needed some strong philosophical guidance. Now I’ve come to appreciate Prof. Surgrue’s because they have helped to open my eyes to much wider and more intellectual world that I desperately needed to find. Thank you Michael Sugrue, I wish I could have attended your classes in person however I can accept these virtual lectures as a substitute. God bless.

[@apollyonkatastrefia1586]

@@jasoncherry3404 i just found the professor tonight through marcus aurelius

[@jessefunk3986]

Just came across his videos, amazing professor. Will watch all his KZbin lectures.

[@fastinbulvis2223]

Michael Sugrue is to Western Culture what the MSM is to current events.

[@scambammer6102]

Nietzsche didn't understand evolution very well. Species succeed at the general level. Outliers (smart people) get et.

[@rickym6301]

He talks so smoothly. Almost like narrating his thoughts in a stream. No ums or uhs. Extensive vocabulary. What an excellent display of public speaking. It’s not often that you find people this skilled.

[@6Sparx9]

First time I heard him was when I was driving to work and he came on via auto play, I thought I was listening to Thomas Sowell who I believe I have mined lectures, interviews and debates of extensively and had to check who this excellent orator was.

[@lnl3237]

​@@6Sparx9I can think of no better compliment than to be compared to Thomas Sowell.

[@dbarker7794]

​@@lnl3237Gee, I can.

[@69adrummer]

LOL there's one at 1:43 and another at 1:45 haha

[@steveschramko2386]

These philosophy lectures are BY FAR the best of their kind on the net. They are without peer. I await each new installment daily, weekly. They have become for me a kind of lifeline during Covid 19 quarantines and isolation. They are an elixir, a tonic, an alchemist's incantation. They are a plasma bottle that drips vitality into my emaciated life and Michael has become my physician. My prescription : MORE lectures and the associated readings. I gulp the medicaments and await my deliverance....

[@thebacons5943]

Don’t follow leaders and watch your parking meters

[@fadyalfons1105]

Pp

[@tomstein7131]

shut up nerd

[@danielbebo8769]

@@thebacons5943 Dylan

[@c.guydubois8270]

So friend tell us how you really feel. Lol...

[@goosewithagibus]

This man gives better talks than anyone I've ever seen. A gem.

[@Dimebag91]

This is gold standard. The channel is a goldmine. Prof. Sugrue the best.

[@janne-valtteri2629]

I agree, modern treasure hunting pays off when hitting gold vein like this.

[@hillerm]

You’re an infidel!

[@russv.winkle8764]

The Best par excellence!

[@cheri238]

The very best !!

[@grumblekin]

Masterful. As a professor myself, I strive to achieve this kind of oratory skill.

[@TransRoofKorean]

I have a dozen criticisms, but his oratory certainly isn't one of 'em... although his pronunciation of 'oxymoron' drove me mad. "Nietzsche is a master of occimeron", you say??

[@drbonesshow1]

@@TransRoofKorean And his large shrimp.

[@theneutralgroundpodcast]

I’m glad I’m not alone in feeling this. I thought I had given good lectures on Nietzsche and the Western canon until I heard these-absolutely wonderful. It makes me want to push myself.

[@bigtombowski]

Very articulate fella

[@B.Pilgrim]

Thank you for your service as an educator.

[@Unobliging]

The section from 29:49 to 30:28 was extremely mind-blowing and incredibly profound. It has given me a new perspective on the postmodern condition. Thank you Professor Sugrue!

[@MrEgo-sl3fp]

Finally, a lecture which correctly shows both sides of this man: The megalomania and insanity and The master of german prose

[@maghrebforever2012]

I don't think its even remotely warranted to describe Nietzche as megalomanic. You misunderstand the essence of tragic character, something Nietzche discusses in The Birth of Tragedy. The overman represents the healthy, radiant expression of mankind in response to the question of: what do you do in face of The tragedy?

[@xelaocsana]

Rest in peace Sir. I am always at awe in the way you deliver your lectures.

[@paradoxdungeon]

we will miss him :( but at least his legacy is preserved thanks to the internet

[@SyvilMedia]

Wow. Just looked it up. Had no idea he passed. 😢😢😢 a master of literature and philosophy, he will truly missed

[@carefulconsumer8682]

Exquisite lecture. Thank you for uploading all of this professor's lectures. I listen to them and listen again a few weeks later and then again later...they are THAT good!

[@JeffWildman-b1v]

I feel blessed that I found Dr. Sugrue. He's added so much to my life. Ive reached the point in my journey where I now disagree with him on a few points. I wish I could have matured to this point while he was still alive. I wish I could have challenged him just one time. RIP Michael I'm forever in your debt.

[@mesartwell]

What an truly profound speech. As someone unfamiliar with philosophy or Nietzsche, this was incredibly engaging.

[@christineclear1557]

Dr. Sugrue is utterly compelling. His range and references are riveting. I'm thrilled 'to have him in my life'! Thankyou. You've opened up Western Philosophy for me. ✨

[@khalid74316]

Stumbled upon this man randomly and within few minutes I was already feeling jealous of those who can get to call themselves “his students”. I hope your father is well and sound and thank you so very much for uploading these gold mines of lectures!

[@saralyons7894]

I stumbled across Dr Sugrue by accident, I was looking for something mildly interesting to listen to while I fell asleep. Sugrue’s lectures had the opposite effect, I could feel the synapses in my brain sizzling with new ideas and excitement. Now I’m fantasising about starting a Masters in bioethics.

[@anywallsocket]

“What are mankind’s truths but irrefutable errors?” This is a spectacular quote that underlines the philosophy of science. Nietzsche will continue to impress.

[@dedskin1]

Black holes , Dark Energy , Dark Mater , Dark Flow .... , Big Bang , Super Big Bang , Mega Bang , Black Hole Evaporation , Space time curvature , Speed of light . Neutron Stars , Gravity Constant , Theory of Relativity , Special relativity , Quantum Entanglement , AI , , you name it . And things like this just spontaneously being imagined being best payed jobs giving best positions giving best living , is not by chance . All of this is a plan to move mans focus in to Darkness , separating him from his tribe and nation , then from family , then from him self , transgenderism , only when you do that can you call choice between A and B , election , when it is selection , select 1 or 2 , and you don't know which is worse . And in all that chaos a shining light Nikola Tesla , Nietzsche changed nothing , but if he was alive today he would use Tesla AC current , radio , and everything that was born from that down to smartphones , now phones are smarter then their users , that is why they are called smartphones , only a dumbuser can use a smartphone , only stupid man needs Artificial Intelligence . None of this is by chance . Including Nietzsche . Powerful people have a way of destroying you if you don't work in their favor ,and if you do , they promote you .

[@mattgilbert7347]

Right. It's like Popper well before Popper.

[@davidjones8043]

It actually just sounds ignorant and painfully pointless

[@anywallsocket]

@ aw does David jones disagree? It only he explained his opinion rather than just uselessly stated it

[@Jahson70]

This is my first time hearing Michael Sugrue. What an amazing speaker. A clear, concise and balanced appraisal of Nietzsche the man and the philosopher. Thank you.

[@bosshog5335]

The way Dr. Sugrue can articulate difficult points is incredible, whether you agree or disagree with any points he or Nietzsche is making, the delivery of said points is irrefutably powerful.

[@guts1589]

He certainly is one of the best professors I've ever came across.

[@Alwaysiamcaesar]

I just want to say that these lectures have added so much value to my life in the past year, or so, since I’ve discovered this channel. Thank you!

[@Jose-oq6kj]

I'm so happy I found this channel. Being able to come back to these lectures after reading the books and getting more and more out of them is truly very fulfilling.

[@Daimerian]

Love you so much Dr. Sugrue. He presents the subject with passion. There is one charactetistic in his lectures, which makes philosophy adorable discipline for everyone.

[@donovanjones7546]

This guy transforms lectures into a work of art

[@tracywilliamsliterature]

... these lectures are pure brilliance... respect from Wales, UK...

[@davidfulton3287]

Another great lecture. The close of "Beyond Good and Evil" beautifully shows the tragic loneliness at the heart of Nietzsche's genius.

[@robertdouglas8895]

Religion comes from the Latin, religio, which means "to bond with God." When we bond with God, we need no theology or morality. Power is what Nietzsche substitutes for morality. It's demonstrated by art or action in the world. When we bond with God, we don't need to prove His power over anyone or anything. It includes love which is unity, not division. By not giving the solution to the wars coming after him. he was saying there was no cure. He left out forgiveness, which is the crux of Jesus Christ's teaching. And we can only truly forgive when we ask God to show us how in every case. That is the true art inspired by God. By finding only fault in religion and substituting his own based on power, he ushered in the World Wars through his influence. Nietzsche was the canary in the coal mine of individual egotism and the belief that science instead of love will bring us to peace..

[@ubet6691]

@@robertdouglas8895 Nietzsche didn’t replace morality with power. I mean, how could he?! It’s a misconception that he disapproved of morality, or goodness. How can someone who preaches nobility be against goodness? What he was against (which he says everywhere in his writings) is reactive morality. He believes that goodness is a natural quality. Nietzsche is a naturalist. This means for instance that a good person does not help others out of pity, but out of nobility.

[@robertdouglas8895]

@@ubet6691 "Egotism is the very essence of the noble soul. " That's power of self over outside power. There is no outside power. There is only one of us here. That comes from love through forgiveness, not egotism

[@ubet6691]

@@robertdouglas8895 I think that is meant psychologically. It merely notes a natural quality, in which sense it is fully accurate and relatable. ”Forgiveness” on the other hand, is a perfect example of what Nietzsche terms reactive morality; that which only may be as a response to stimuli.

[@robertdouglas8895]

@@ubet6691 Forgiveness is acceptance that everything that is in your life is what you put there. You are not ever reacting to an outside world but to the world you have imagined to be against you. The outer world does not exist. It is the ego, the belief that you are a separate body that makes up the imagined need of power over an outside world. It's fighting against an imagined enemy. "We have met the enemy and it is us."

[@patrickskramstad1485]

Domain over any entity demands an understanding of that entity, knowing the limitations and needs of that entity, and imposes a moral responsibility over that entity. Empathy is in us for a reason and everything has a cost or a trade.

[@carlpeterson8182]

I know this video is old. I had this series. Loved his lectures in it the best. I think he did the one on Kierkegaard that got me into him. I do not know Dr. Sugrue's beliefs or worldview but he is a great lecturer. He gives you what the thinker really believed and makes them come alive. He does not ramble about things that do not matter. He is clear but interesting to listen to.

[@thadtuiol1717]

Sadly he went woke in recent years

[@Fujitechs]

Thoroughly enjoyed this lecture. Always had trouble correctly understanding and comprehending Nietzche, but after listening to this lecture a few times I'm starting to understand the gravity, importance, and as you put it, the destiny the man himself held in society. Thank you Dr. Sugrue, I am a big fan and forever appreciative of this content.

[@mileskeller5244]

This man is a hidden treasure of knowledge

[@ggeetika]

What a spellbinding lecture! You are much adored Dr Mike. If there was a magic wand to transform you back into the then you! 😊 Lots of love and good wishes!

[@Reignor99]

Are you flirting?

[@clairobscur7697]

@@Reignor99 no, thats admiration

[@ok-kk3ic]

This man is the best teacher I have ever been taught by.

[@TheKoderius]

Is he still alive? Couldn`t find more from him

[@ok-kk3ic]

@@TheKoderius He is, he does a podcast with his daughter.

[@garethreynolds9061]

@@ok-kk3ic Do you know if this is actually his channel?

[@ryanstrohman7429]

@@garethreynolds9061 It’s run by a child of his I believe

[@bobbyjeangayheart360]

“Mystical explanations are thought to be profound, in fact, they are not even superficial.“

[@MaxIsMyName]

Dr. Sugrue's lectures are the best pieces of knowledge that I have come across in the last decade. I've learned so much, and thanks to him, I now own a fresh copy of Meditations. Thank you, Dr. Sugrue. May your soul be blessed.

[@Zero-iw3tj]

Every lecture is like an invocation of greatness and a blessing to my soul. Thank you Michael Sugrue!

[@ronburgandy1475]

So glad these lectures are on the net. I think I've watched almost everyone now some 3 or 4 times. Just such a great lecturer, he breaks down complexity so well...

[@Jose-oq6kj]

I watched your Marcus Aurelius lecture a year ago and only now have found your channel, excited to binge :D

[@markr4619]

Professor Michael Sugrue is by far one of my biggest inspirations. Such a blessing of an educator and actually actually lectures. A lecture of which I feel no need to bud in because he is consciously keeping me with him with words. Great Stuff. Eternalized.

[@leme3082]

These are so good I'll even do the accompanying assignment

[@al3578]

Thanks!

[@Cosmogenitor]

“It is the destiny of the west to be forced to confront their rational capacities.” Amen, sir. Brilliantly put. Unites every major issue of the 20th and 21st centuries.

[@aplcc323]

Splendid explanation of Nietzche, amazing orator and great setting... Thank you, may God bless you and may you now rest in peace with the Father, the Son and the Holly Spirit.

[@annabradshaw9902]

These lectures are a sheer delight! Where has Michael Sugrue been all these years?

[@marceloonunes]

This is what I want to know too. This man is absolutely brilliant.

[@marceloonunes]

There's a comment by his daughter here, he is retired and unfortunately his health is poor.

[@rilkedev449]

@@marceloonuneshe died

[@marceloonunes]

@@rilkedev449 I'm so sorry to hear that.

[@cheri238]

Dr. Sugrue's and Dr. Staloff are my favorites.!!!!! Thank you.❤

[@clovers-zi5fe]

Very fair and excellent review of Nietzsche, Dr. Sugrue. The problem with Nietzsche is the refusal to acknowledge we are still social creatures--the same with Machiavelli. All great thinkers, but it's the hole in their amoral theories.

[@clovers-zi5fe]

@@Thomas-xd4cx I'm not sure what you mean. He fully "rejects" the idea that humans should be herd animals in "Beyond Good and Evil." In particular, he warns against the herd mentality brought on by Christianity. Because herd mentality brings on herd morality, which prevents one from becoming their own "Ubermensch." As how can one achieve the peak of their individual capacity if their locked into the mentality and morality of the herd that may go against necessary individual values to achieve pinnacle greatness? It's not like Seneca. Seneca warned against mingling amongst the crowd, but accepted we are social creatures. But we should be judicious in who we mingle with. In Seneca's belief, we should mingle with those who will better us, and likewise, we can better them. This is not Nietzche's thinking at all. In his thinking...it's all about "me, me, me" alone to become the Ubermensch.

[@nationalsocialist8382]

He wants leaders to be the leaders of the followers, rather than the followers drowning out any leadership qualities for potential leaders and therefore leading the base life to follow. He is a refiner of thought and courageous in his his pursuit of what, and probably more likely how, consciousness is and it's wielding. He is not of a herd group himself, so herd people won't be able to facilitate his offerings unless they step away from the herd and develop to higher potentials.

[@clovers-zi5fe]

@@nationalsocialist8382 Yes, that is true. It's the positive that one can draw from Nietzsche's thinking in describing the "Ubermensch"; that we are literally capable of so much more than we know, if we just dive into our passions, dive into mental solitude, and strive to the peak of our capabilities. But...if that means doing away with empathy, kindness, pity and compassion toward our fellow man, then so be it. He even tacitly approves of the Greeks at a time when they owned slaves, because should that be suited to the virtues of a slave owner becoming their own "Ubermench," then so be it. This is what I mean, as well as Dr. Segrue, by Nietzche not accepting that we are still social creatures in accordance with science. Not only that, it's a contradiction. As how does one even achieve the pinnacle of their capabilities if they are enslaved? I want to stress that I love Neitzche's work, but there are flaws in his theories. You also have to take into account the man, himself. He wasn't exactly social for various reasons, mentally and physically, yet desired social relationships at times. So even in himself, he was a paradox.

[@nationalsocialist8382]

@@clovers-zi5fe His philosophy seemed to teeter off a tad for himself, that's agreed, and a great configuration in summation of his thoughts by Sugrue here. I like that at least Nietzsche is pointing somewhat in the right direction. He's given people a clue, like Heidegger.

[@clovers-zi5fe]

@@nationalsocialist8382 Oh, no doubt. There is great merit to what Nietzche's saying! I don't want to dismiss that. But like with much in life, there aren't many absolutisms. Another example could be a sports team. The values related to a sports team--still a herd--could facilitate in one achieving the peak of their capabilities. I've never checked out Heidegger's work. I should do so!

[@GavinskisTutorials]

Brilliant teacher, so articulate. The repeated mispronunciation of ‘oxymoron’ is all the more surprising in that context. A petty point, but it jars for me every time I hear him saying the word!

[@romantum]

Must be a torturous fun for you to watch it! Well, I know at least 2 major languages, including the native language of Nietzsche, where this the right pronunciation.. Who says they've got it right in English? ;)

[@CygnusX168]

These lectures along with those of Rick Roderick have been a great discovery and much appreciated that there is a platform that these can live on. Thank you.

[@TremendousSax]

Totally agree about Roderick

[@gershonr5865]

Listening to your mind, explain his mind, has re-organized the way I think. Ergo, listening to you has changed my life. It's wonderfully unsettling. My admiration and love to you Professor.

[@samueldeegan]

We will remember you for the brilliant learned man that you were. Rest in peace Dr. Michael Sugrue.

[@katerynabaibakova5349]

Thank you so much for this at 42 minutes and I start to get really really involved in what you’re doing. It’s incredible your passion for this writer is contagious. I love when you said he’s a dandy that explains so much.

[@nathang369]

Thank you Dr. Sugrue. This lecture has been very informative and galvanizing.

[@TheDionysianFields]

Dr. Sugrue was a one of a kind, and these lectures are an absolute treasure.

[@dvd7211]

*sip coffee *continues dropping knowledge

[@kevinbeck8836]

11:30 . It is clear from the subtitle to Beyond Good & Evil, Prelude to a Philosophy of the Future, that he didnt believe that philosophy was going to end with him. And in Zarathustra, he even states "Like the sun will also Zarathustra go down: now sitteth he here and waiteth, old broken tables around him, and also new tables-half-written." Youre absolutely correct in that he destroys old values and creates new ones, but its an incomplete project intended to be completed by us

[@andytaylor3462]

This channel is getting better und better !! 👨‍🏫👏🏻

[@mikeoh7967]

What a blessing that we have access to all these lectures and videos!

[@af796]

One of the greatest, most accurate, and most concise synopses of Nietzsche. What an incredible teacher, synthesizer, and communicator you are, Dr Sugrue!

[@OceanRoadbyTonyBaker]

I am reading THE GENEALOGY OF MORALS at the moment, and this clears up and number of things. Thank you for the learned perspective.

[@arnalbz9453]

you never fail to amaze me. thank you for sharing your thoughts Dr. Sugrue

[@paulbcote]

Aside from the worthy praise of Dr. Sugrue, we should appreciate the masterful camera that seems to anticipate his every move.

[@kurtisstraub2574]

This was my introduction to lectures on philosophy, and I can’t thank Dr. Sugrue enough!

[@strongfp]

Be careful, he's very biased against anything that isn't Christian or Catholic centered. He regularly calls for a return to Catholic culture. If you jive with that, then have at it.

[@Vaughan2323]

Congratulations you’ve been introduced to a platonic education

[@2Oldcoots]

I feel Joyous when I listen to Dr. Sugrue's lectures--they are that enlightening!

[@JDNicoll]

I’m 13:40 in. I haven’t studied Nietzsche, but it seems his error was to assume that religious philosophy or theology constitutes the existence of God. In other words, what humans have thought, or think now, about God, has some effect on God. And that by finding fault in the the thinking and perspectives of man, Nietzsche thought himself able to single-handedly affect God. His mistake was to mistake religious thinking or philosophy for God Himself. A mistake of excessive pride. And where there is pride, there always lies shame beneath it. The ego wants so badly to be God, to replace God. It’s like watching a comedic tragedy: the fool who wants to be king of all. I see this in other intellectuals like Sam Harris who seem to think that finding errors in religion is some astounding achievement. For truly intelligent, curious people, those errors are merely the jumping off point in the search for truth.

[@entriun]

Marvelous! These lectures are like the flow of a river. Thanks Dr. Sugrue, big respect and I wish you all the best.

[@joy-qq2vp]

The best lecturer ever, period!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thanks a million for enlightening the 🌍

[@bulletsmichael]

Alan Watts takes 1st prize..but this man is also a master.

[@scottgreen132]

This is incredible. Thank you for posting it

[@cch312]

Glad I chose to stay. Very good lecture. It explains Nietzsche's place in the modern philosophical realm. So many think in this way actually and it's somewhat scary... The nihilistic and aristocratic behavior... Very interesting!

[@tylerstamps2786]

You don’t know this, but you’re my favorite teacher. Thought-provoking, articulate, intelligent,..one feels smarter after one listens to your lecture!

[@vishalsagar9605]

Thank you very much for making these wonderful lectures available ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@Vestigefx]

Love these lectures. Bravo Sir, you have made the world a better place by educating us in these historically significant topics.

[@عبدالرحمنالقدسي-ظ8ه]

That was really really interesting. I like your passion and the flowing ideas style you follow. Thanks Sir! ♡

[@theguyver4934]

Are you you a Muslim

[@faridachishti35]

Ohhh, the way so much knowledge flows out so easily, effortlessly. It's like a stream running downhill. No stammer, no fumbling for words. The passion is to share his understanding of the most challenging views n philosophies in the Western world. The lectures have a compulsive hold... you r forced to listen till the end.

[@gspurlock1118]

Wow! I think I need to listen to this a few more times to fully grasp it. I don't like Nietzsche, but that doesn't mean he has nothing to contribute.

[@Fenriz1222]

I can't stop watching these lectures. For all of the troubles that have came with the proliferation of the internet, a hillbilly such as myself would otherwise have never had access to anything approaching this. Watching the one on Kierkegaard next.

[@conquisitorveritas]

Would love to see Nietzsche’s facial expression if he could see in which direction art has taken the world after taking over for God.

[@friedcash9815]

Lol yes.

[@marverickmercer1968]

Modern Art regress into insanity, nihilism and wanton destruction/deconstruction of beauty., meanwhile beautiful arts are become commercialize, selling for hourly rate. There are now more beautiful, more masterful, more artistic and technical complex artworks in video game, movies and Magic the Gathering cards than there are in the the most prestigious museums on Earth. The kind of artworks with such levels of mastery over form, perspective, anatomy, lighting and rendering, etc that Old Renaissance Master would gladly sell their soul for, are available for viewing for free on the Internet. Meanwhile "modern art" consist of random children's doodle made of piss and blood are selling for million.

[@martinledermann1862]

@@marverickmercer1968 Movies and video games are also "art" and in fact a much more powerful one, often playing a much more transformative role in human lives than that of the traditional art. The fact that paintings, sculptures, architecture and to some extent also music may no longer be as sophisticated as they used to be and are a sort of an embodiment of post-modern intellectual trends which aim to rebel against anything traditional (the traditional concepts of beauty included) doesn't indicate any supposed fall of the Western civilization as a whole.

[@MM-op6ti]

@@marverickmercer1968 no, a lot of money is made off modern art via money laundering tax schemes.

[@binary]

He's been proven terribly wrong

[@williambuysse5459]

Excellent and dramatically presented. Nietzsche is summarizing what the early modern philosophers initiated. Machiavelli who launched modernity claimed to be a new unarmed prophet who would succeed. He means Jesus. Hobbes went further. He compared his Social Contract with God's Fiat or creation. So Hobbes creates the artificial man, soul, and state. I could easily add to this with Spinoza too but my point is made. Nietzsche is not just envious of Plato but of Machiavelli too.

[@BaronM]

Well done.

[@dulcamarabuffo]

An excellent lecture which is both articulate and well expounded. At the risk of being pedantic however, at 32:20, the liturgical term that should be quoted is a Requiem (the mass for the dead), rather than the Te Deum (which was always a celebratory hymn).

[@lolitah8560]

I love these lectures

[@aaronwilliams423]

This was so insightful, thanks for posting it!

[@rumination2399]

The idea that science ended metaphysics seems Neitzche’s worst vanity and a common one today.

[@christinemartin63]

It's not enough to chide humanity for its weaknesses, to shock and awe with frightening theories, to mesmerize with lyrical poetry, to dazzle with precocious intellect--not nearly enough ... when you yourself fall woefully short of all you attempt to teach others (oh so haughtily!). We have a word for this type of hubris: hypocrisy. THAT'S Nietzsche. All talk--no action ... at all ... for any reason.

[@mjolninja9358]

This lecture was much more clear and comprehensive compared to JBP’s, Thank you Professor.

[@punchgod]

JBP doesn’t understand a word of Nietzsche, he takes advantage of the ambiguity of Nietzsche’s prose and adapts it into his established view of contrived neoliberal Christian pseudo-individualism. He’s incapable of reading anything outside of that ideological prism, and for that reason he is the exact sort of coward that Nietzsche despised.

[@radthadd]

Fond it 🎉

[@nordini3516]

The way he explains the book is just amasing !!

[@darylallen2485]

I've never heard anyone pronounce it "ox emm er ron" before. I've always heard it as "oxy moron". Did this stand out to anyone else?

[@nightoftheworld]

It did.. like when people say human “yoo man”

[@quincylee2276]

@@nightoftheworld really? I’ve always heard people pronounce it as “hew muhn”

[@lordtugboat]

@@quincylee2276 give a listen to Carl Sagan's reading of pale blue dot and you'll hear plenty of references to yooman beings. :)

[@donheinsohn824]

Embarrassed to admit that I thought I was looking for a word I did not know, like Oxcimmaron or something. So now I know how totally cool people pronounce oxymoron. lol

[@robmorris87]

Feeling pretty dumb right now. , Are there a different amount of syllables when it's pronounced like that or is a word always the same amount of syllables?

[@difenderu]

Splendid lecture. It's so good that cameraman's hands trembling of excitement. )

[@kentuckyproproductions1624]

And yet nietcsche's whole basis apon the thought that God is dead is merely because he says so. He makes the mistake of assuming that God is in the minds of the masses and not the minds of the individual. God lives so long as the last individual believes. Just as the memory of you lives so long the last individual you know or have produced exists.

[@dr.michaelsugrue]

"Well said", said Dad, who almost never says that.

[@Whiskey19841]

“I should only believe in a God that would know how to dance. And when I saw my devil, I found him serious, thorough, profound, solemn: he was the spirit of gravity - through him all things fall. Not by wrath, but by laughter do we slay. Come, let us slay the spirit of gravity! I learned to walk; since then have I let myself run. I learned to fly; since then I do not need pushing in order to move from a spot. Now I am light, now do I fly; now do I see myself under myself. Now there danceth a God in me.” ― Friedrich Nietzsche, Thus Spoke Zarathustra

[@IsaiaInfamous]

Take your metaphysical fantasies elsewhere, don’t argue with Nietzsche’s philosophy when you haven’t the intellectual capacity to understand what he means when he says that God is dead or even to spell upon correctly

[@kentuckyproproductions1624]

@@IsaiaInfamous ok kid

[@mega4171]

Except we also exist through empirical justification

[@eboytc]

This is the most essential Nietzsche I have ever had. Now I began to understand how great Nietzsche was and found the modern western society as we see now. Cheers from 🇹🇭

[@DANTHETUBEMAN]

Nietzsche was the most compassionate man of our times, showing us how to help everyone by raising up the strongest to move us forward as a species, the uberman was greater in every capacity of the human being and that was what would help humanity the most, if humanity can ever escape the monetary slavery system imposed on it, i believe Nietzsche's insights will be the best decisions humanity can make.

[@pearz420]

The Ubermensch has had nowhere near as much presence in Western culture compared to the God-Man that is nearly ten times older. Imagining a superior human ideal will lead you to Jesus Christ every time if you follow it far enough and don't presuppose to negate it. The trouble is that it mostly appeals to people who have never read the Gospel. Nietzsche certainly did, but he stole more than he would like to have admitted.

[@DANTHETUBEMAN]

@pearz420 God is dead and you have killed him.

[@AbdElGhafourAnbari]

perhaps the best lecture ive ever listened to, may your soul rest in peace dr sugrue

[@Daimo83]

I had to spell out "occimeron" before I realised he meant oxy-moron. Otherwise, fantastic lecture as always.

[@robertortiz-wilson1588]

Phenomenal lecture. I watched to the end with great captivating interest!

[@edwardrichardson8254]

Great lecture with one exception. He gets Darwin/Nietzsche totally backwards. in fact I think it's where Nietzsche says Darwin is wrong that you see the thought-provoking brilliance typical of the man (I give examples see below). It was a case of philosophy affecting the sciences, not the other way around. I just read Hegel's "Phenomenology of Spirit" and absolutely agree with Nietzsche that Darwinism is Hegelianism, just served up differently. Nietzsche does not even mention Darwin a quarter as much as this professor and when he does, it's to critique him, and I mean on every point. Even the seed for "God is dead" is in "Phenomenology." Darwin had zip to do with anything in Nietzsche and Percy Shelley distributed his "The Necessity of Atheism" long before Darwin and the French Revolution tried to cancel god nationally 20 years before that (in a massively Catholic country and with a civil war in the Vendee over this issue with extreme casualties never discussed in the context of the Reign of Terror). People were grinding an axe for God (literally, w/ priests forced to leave or be executed in the French Revolution and the appropriation of church land) well before Darwin. Nietzsche on Darwinism in "The Gay Science": "That our modern natural sciences have become so thoroughly entangled in this Spinozistic dogma (most recently and worst of all, Darwinism with its incomprehensibly one-sided doctrine of the his struggle for existence') is probably due to the origins of most natural scientists: In this respect they belong to the ''common people"; their ancestors were poor and undistinguished people who knew the difficulties of survival only too well at firsthand. The whole of English Darwinism breathes something like the musty air of English overpopulation, like the smell of the distress and overcrowding of small people. But a natural scientist should come out of his human nook; and in nature it is not conditions of distress that are dominant but overflow and squandering. even to the point of absurdity. The struggle for existence is only an exception, a temporary restriction of the will to life. The great and small struggle always revolves around superiority, around growth and expansion, around power:...:...in accordance with the will to power which is the will of life." Brilliant, and it echoes Hamlet's soliloquy of nature being "rank and gross," an "unweeded garden." And again in "The Gay Science": "Let us take, thirdly, the astonishing stroke of Hegel, who struck right through all our logical habits and bad habits when he dared to teach that species concepts develop out of each other. With this proposition the minds of Europe were preformed for the last great scientific movement. Darwinism-for without Hegel there could have been no Darwin. Is there anything German in this Hegelian innovation which first introduced the decisive concept of "development., into science?" He's probably talking about Hegel's "Philosophy of Nature" but Hegel's dialectic from Phenomenology applies just as well, and it probably imbued everything Hegel wrote or thought. "Ecce Homo": "Other scholarly cattle have suspected me of Darwinism for this reason..." From "Twilight of the Idols": "Anti-Darwin. - As far as the famous 'struggle for existence' is concerned, this seems to me to be more of an opinion than a proven fact at the moment. It takes place, but as an exception; the overall condition oflife is not a state of need, a state of hunger, but rather abundance, opulence, even absurd squandering. Where there is a struggle, it is a struggle for power"

[@AliasFresh]

👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@2Oldcoots]

Brilliant especially because it is understandable to a layman such as myself. Thank you Dr. Sugrue!

[@sharontalley2155]

I just found this channel. I wish I had found it years ago. Dr Sugrue is fascinating.

[@ilikezmonster]

RIP a real one

[@philosophytoday6518]

This amazing professor turns the complex into the simple, the abstract into the concrete

[@JamieEHILLS]

So good! Michael are you still lecturing these days? What are you doing with your life?

[@tsugrue9013]

My Dad is a retired professor and his health is poor. I am his daughter and I am posting for him.

[@davidfulton3287]

@@tsugrue9013 Thank You so much for doing this. Please give best regards to your Father.

[@angelseye7492]

@@tsugrue9013 I wish All the best and get better soon for your father😇😇😇

[@andytaylor3462]

Please tell your father that he is admired and listened all over the world (in my case from brasil). I thank him for teaching me so many new ideas, reflections... he is a great scholar but firstly he has the gift of teaching, of speaking in plain words and transmit so much. Thanks again and sending my best wishes for his health, you deserve so much good sir

[@gnawnaiq]

Thank you so much for offering us consolation of philosophy in such a hard time!!!

[@petersantospago1966]

Raskolnikov actually commits 2 murders.... The pawn broker and unintentionally her sister who shows up at wrong place wrong time. Great book

[@isaac8228]

42:23 Not gonna lie, this made me burst into laughter. Nietzsche is absolutely based. LMAO.

[@tylerhulsey982]

Very B&RP

[@dububro]

keyed

[@JustHindiFootball]

Nicee