The Big Picture : Centre - State Rights

[@saurav406]

70% of the comments are just for praising Deepak sir...his explainations are so clear he deserves this respect. 🙏

[@arvind_vagadiya]

Some donkey leader of Congress & TMC ko koi explain kro yarrr.

[@saurav406]

@@arvind_vagadiya donkey nahi h wo bss dirty politics kr rhe h...they are just trying to secure their vote bank.

[@jayprakashyadav3319]

Because he is not pseudo-libral

[@hemanthreddyneelapu5250]

more than 70

[@nishuentertainment2784]

L

[@jaihind116]

Sai is hope for future India...we need this kind of sane voices...

[@radhikagupta6421]

@TOM Thub no He makes sense and talks with proof If u can understand English than only watch him

[@IamrajTheIndian-eg2jt]

@TOM Thub Sai spoke as a legal expert with proper proof from constitution for citizen act with all clarity with details. You dont seem to follow him because you are not able to understand. Let us agree that Sai is biased and speaking for the current central government You tell us given a chance to implement CAA and NRC, how will you go ahead and implement? Just saying that , we already have many crores of illegals are already spread and feeding the elections votes of the congress and communist governments. Mind you al these CAB and NRC are mandated by Supreme court and also note that these are pending to be implemented since 1955. You better listen to all Sais videos in you tube. You will be highly enlightened on these immigration, citizen act and the blunders of the previous central and state governments to not to implement them inspite of supreme court orders

[@IamrajTheIndian-eg2jt]

@TOM Thub Yes. He is biased towards truth and does not mince his words unlike pseudo pretending nationalists like us who want to politically correct. The days of being polite and politically correct are over in India as of now and also world over. As we speak here, the world over is slowly away to Islamists, especially in Western Europe, Canada due to the political correctness of leftist politics and liberal society. Unless indian state takes a solid internal security measures like Israil and US, the days of one or more Indian partions are not too far away. May be in another 10 to 15 years. So, let us keep debating about who is left or right or center and thereby giving way for one more partition. Jai Hind🙏🙏

[@jaihind116]

TOM Thub yes yes.. support to nation always..and to govt when it deserves..and on caa we will support this govt wheather hell or high water...study well..

[@Kshastra]

@TOM Thub when you have no point to make, you resort to grammar mistakes they make.

[@geetanjalisingh6875]

J Sai Deepak he is so clear crisp in his vision .. his art of expression is adorable. Gem. Can I as a law student have any chance of working under his guidance

[@mohammedhafeez499]

Jai Hind everyone... Let the spirit of INDIA prevail.. Why CAB breaches article 14 ACC to CAA, only non Muslims, from afg , bang and Pakistan who are religiously persecuted are given citizenship Why it is against article 14.... Firstly the the classification should be intelligible... This classification is not intelligible 1) why only from 3 countries... There is no intelligible reasoning 2) why only MUSLIMS are excluded.... Because sufferings of MUSLIM immigrants is not lesser than that of HINDU immigrants here... 3)WHY only religious persecution? Is religious persecution any different from other persecution? 4) why Rohingyas from BURMA, or UYIGHUR from CHINA are not included.... There is no way to say one persecution is lesser from the other... NOW DON'T get PRE INDEPENDENCE ,Pak and ban are from INDIA... Presently, post INDEPENDENCE post Cutof dates of first CITIZENSHIP bill, These countries are no different from other countries for us Secondly AHMEDIS and SHIAS get persecuted, why they are not included, their sufferings won't be different from others Even though PAK and Ban is no different from other countries, and still you cannot justify the inclusion of AFG... So this BILL highly unintelligibly classified which goes against the article 14 Now coming to the OBJECT of the classification should have rational relationship with the classification... Now what is the object of act, certain people will get citizenship,...BUT what about MUSLIMS who dont get citizenship, if they could deport and CITIZENSHIP in any other countries, object would have been rational ... But that's not the case One particular community will suffer in detention centre and others will get citizenship.... So object of act doesn't have rational relationship with the classification.....

[@shivodastak1717]

I search in every episode " where is J Sai Deepak"

[@PragyaTGupta]

Me ...also

[@mayankbhupesh1073]

Sir J SAI DEEPAK u r true beauty....i request rstv to plz bring him in all constitutional and legel debates in big picture...so that we can be more enlightened.

[@gopinathsuryavanshi5986]

J saie deepak = encyclopedia of indian constitution.

[@sangramkale3375]

Once search for Faizan Mustafa alsso

[@sanjaydubey5382]

Satya sir, is our guest faculty at IIMC for media law and ethics. His classes are really gem for us. A lots of interesting things we have learnt from him. Thank you Satya sir

[@amareshkamishetti]

J Sai Deepak.... You are a Rockstar. Superbbb analysis and insights .... Mind blowing and wowww

[@dishantsharma8777]

Sai Deepak ... I mean .. Speechless ... Absolutely masterclass !!!

[@arshyt1907]

From now ,I will definitely quote him in my mains answer(PSIR+GS2)...He is simply the best ....

[@dishantsharma8777]

@@kanchanalankit2216 yup ... And you are an IAS officer , or SC judge , or upcoming CJI .

[@dishantsharma8777]

@@kanchanalankit2216 and he didn't gave any fact ?? Really ?? ... You really so dumb ?? 1) He stated about not following central legislation is violative of constitution and Articles 356 , 357 can be imposed under that ! This is not an opinion , that's a fact under constitution 2) He stated religions minority are persecuted in pak afg bang ... That's a fact as well , not an opinion . Hindus In pak 1947 - more than 20% , now about 1% In bang 1971 - about 20% , now 9 % 3) He stated we are not a federation in true sense . This is true as well , not an opinion. ( B.R. Ambedkar in constitution assembly stated - We are not a federation in a sense as States of India have not entered an agreement to form a federation. They have been created for administration effectiveness. India is largely Unitary) All above points mentioned are FACTS not opinion ... Get a book and study instead of giving advices to others !

[@dishantsharma8777]

@@kanchanalankit2216 lol 🤣 you wont decide my future 🤣🤣🤣

[@dishantsharma8777]

@@kanchanalankit2216 and mr dumb ... It is not CAB anymore ... It is CAA now !

[@shanukumar9442]

plz don't bring any MP in discussion

[@ajmalmalayil49]

@Sushil Kumar Gupta the else were the pig of whom?

[@ajmalmalayil49]

@Sushil Kumar Gupta bjp doesn't have such people who are convicted of rape and murder hence they won't become gangster. You should learn what is indian constitution and come

[@ajmalmalayil49]

@Sushil Kumar Gupta you don't know anything that's why you are talking like this. First study what is there in constitution and say about it.

[@yeshwant5875]

@Sushil Kumar Gupta nailed it bruh

[@vickkydude]

Dr.L.HANUMANTHAIAH -> *LIVING EXAMPLE WHY POLITICANS HAVE ZERO RESPECT*

[@kannukumar5919]

If it's constitutional debate please bring J sai Deepak and Satya prakash Economics related: Nitin Desai sir and Ajay dua sir

[@namratapandey6083]

I m a simple girl. I see deepak sir and I click on the video.

[@govindkarwariya2994]

Same r u upsc aspirant?

[@arunasai3066]

I too did the same...

[@namangoyal2ct]

haha same here.. We all are simple people and love J Sai Deepak.

[@nikeshkumar99]

Mr. Sai Deepak is brilliant, vocal and legend legal expert.

[@namratapandey6083]

@@govindkarwariya2994 no. But I like the TV debates which make sense. :)

[@antrikshjain4065]

For the first time in my life I watched "the big picture" and I really liked it, going to follow all the episodes now onwards 👏

[@chandanarakshit19]

@@arzunmusic You are an illegal immigrant I suppose. Your days are numbered my friend.

[@saurav406]

@@arzunmusic he never said he would appear for upsc...😅keep your hatred to yourself...we can understand your low level of intellect...i just feel sorry for you.

[@jigyanshumishra4176]

Welcome bhai

[@abusaliroadupdates2903]

@@arzunmusic you're absolutely right Bro! But Sadly No one will support you. We all are government Job thirsty shameless creatures. Our selfishness has consumed our conscience. But what to do? UPSC is the only way for social mobility. Even in Airplane, they safe safeguard your self first before helping others. right? Ashamed to say these words..

[@abxexceptional]

Sai sir ne to aag laga di.....this shows how he is dedicated for his profession.

[@narpatsirenglish]

Before opposing,they must watch it but I'm afraid whether they would understand the insight 😅😂😂

[@Sauravkumar-ig1bc]

I love frank saying at the end of panelists comment "ok alright"

[@iknowimcool2514]

Same 😂❤️

[@proudindian6082]

Don't invite politicians.... Because that Will dilute the quality of the program..... Because the person in this episode itself says the center has to get the permission of states to make law on. Citizenship....

[@advaithg9378]

May be its the chance to know what's on thier head..

[@RS-vu4nn]

@@advaithg9378 -True

[@junkieefreak1266]

@@advaithg9378 Most of them hollow compartments in that portion. If their isn't Permanent Executives these so called People's leaders/Political Executives will start biting the dust & there would be no functioning of Govt.

[@shanmugarao2768]

j Sai Deepak ji...pure knowledge❣️

[@arshyt1907]

Just wow!You nailed it deepak sir! Boom...🇮🇳💪

[@MrAbhishekstunt]

As soon as that MP spoke...I thought i was watching AajTak Instead of RS tv

[@NeurologistIn]

Sandeep Balakrishna should be on this channel. Will be great having him here.

[@Thepatriotpodcast24]

"Sai Deepak is synonymous to Knowledge, Courage and Articulation"

[@amanlakhisarani7619]

Garv it bas pagle rulayega kya

[@AbhishekSingh-oh3gi]

@@guhan4606 of country first!

[@AbhishekSingh-oh3gi]

@@guhan4606 Nope. First country, then anything else!!

[@prakhar6549]

RIP earphones : when the MP started speaking

[@iknowimcool2514]

😂😂😂

[@AJAY95952]

😂😂😂

[@sanjibbera9194]

Hahahaha 😂 Great concern 🙄

[@prakhar6549]

@@sanjibbera9194 obviously earphones are worth more than his arguments :D

[@genaskhongsai]

No politicains are clean. They're involved in corruptions in one way or the other whether small or big amount. He need to consider investment on earphone. 😂

[@anupamsharma1]

J sai Deepak simply brilliant.

[@kuldeepchaudhary5901]

J sai deepak nd satyaprakash sir r giving tough time to few ppl🤣🔥🔥🔥

[@sanjibbera9194]

Fairly and transparently consolidate the contents of CAA as well as Relationship between Union and States. Great job sir 🙏

[@Enlightenwithshubham]

Satya prakash and jai sai Deepak two gems of India 🙏🙏🙏

[@sakshijain1683]

I'm agree ...jai saideepak constitutional understanding is non comparable and satya prakash sir also give point to point arguments which is adorable.

[@kamakshibhalla1435]

RSTV, thank you for inviting the right types of good, knowledgeable panelists who can speak precisely and concisely in an informed manner without shouting over each other (like on various private news channels). I actually learn the facts and valid views from your "Big Picture" and "Desh Deshantar" programs. Keep up the good work!

[@VIKASHMADHUKAR]

Satya Prakash sir is surely underrated.

[@shivamsheoran8777]

J Sai Deepak nails it everytime!!!

[@jitendrathakre9076]

A block blaster prime show Sai Deepak sir and sataya prakash sir with Frank Sir

[@ramkumarmattipelly1385]

Hats off for Sai Deepak sir for his straight forward answers 👌

[@NiteshJha8305]

Deepak sir, your arguments are point blank range but it does give a insight that it is personal to you.

[@anandeceneo]

Wow, Sai Deepak.... Music to my ears... what an orator !

[@munnamonk7608]

Saw full episode just to hear J. Deepak Sai🙏

[@vijaykumaryadav6284]

Sai Deepak just awesome.

[@mr.chatterji6977]

one more episode is needed regarding this CAA. How to determine who are religiously persecuted? why religious persecution & not other persecution, is the act actually violating FRs etc etc.. The unbiased insights from this show are excellent. we need more info.

[@thakurshouryapratapsingh3506]

Search for J Sai Deepak & Harish Salve videos on the topic answering your questions as well...

[@surysama]

Long story short, this is ONE OF THE FIRST relaxations offered in Citizenship. Hence citizenship AMENDMENT act. As for the reasons of only these three countries, roughly speaking, India can claim responsibility for Pak and Ban because of Nehru Liyaqat Pact. As for Afg, the term 'transmigration' is used which refers to migration of population between Col. India and NWFP.

[@pv4768]

kudos to Satya Prakash and J Sai Deepak. Repository of legal and constitutional machinery.

[@aditishrivastava818]

J Sai Deepak has nailed the Discussion as always..Such a Grit and conviction he has...Immense Respect for him...

[@TheRugesh]

Sai Deepak is asking why this much of pbm while including (CAA)which is not there while excluding (NRC). 1-NRC conducted in one state and CAA will be for every state. 2- Why gov conducted NRC and after several pbm in that it's coming with CAA. If you plan Correct you could have come up with CAA directly. 3) The biggest pbm with this govt is not Consulting with all stakeholders before legislation and after that it will blink without knowing what to do for implementation. This is happening from demonetisation to CAA. With your knowledge you can defend easily today but need a responsible answer from you as we are following you. 🙏

[@vickkydude]

TheRugesh Now u are jumping to a conclusion and you want him to respond the way you want !! Sorry to say you are BIASED. I am not against or with govt. But i will just say this “phonepay n things of ease of payment has arrived due to demonetisation”

[@TheRugesh]

@@vickkydude I just answered to his question bro continue with your understanding. All the very best bro.

[@Satyamtripathii]

There are two things you got to understand - 1. NRC is being done on the order of SC. There is this confusion everywhere. This process started in 2013. 2. First we identify the problem then remedy. SC directed to prepare NRC for Assam. As far as problems are concerned wrt to NRC, it is only because of the fact that we are liberal civilization. Had this been the case in China, they would have thrown everyone out of the country in one go. We are giving every chance to prove citizenship hence the delay and problems.

[@Satyamtripathii]

And I am not a supporter of this government. But facts can not be changed at all. There is economic instability in the country Job losses and whatnot. Discuss these matters.

[@Procrastinator12]

I want to see J. Sai Deepak and owaisi debate on same....

[@speedabort2354]

Jahiliyat advocate don't have a chance dude. I hope he don't cry and run. 😆😆

[@markpeterson1399]

@@speedabort2354 owaisi can only do tamasha and politics. He is nt very versed with law and order.

[@garvitsharma3149]

owaisi isn't worthy enough to debate with J.S. Deepak sir

[@swapnilrajkhowa]

@@garvitsharma3149 very true

[@shivaputrabiradar6088]

He is politician bro

[@jayshelke5096]

Satya Prakash Sir Thanks Aa.....👍👍 ♨️😅.....Thanks RS TV.....Jay Maharashtra.....😅♨️ Also J Sai Deepak , Frank Thanks.....👌👌

[@bharatiya-akp]

Stop inviting such stupid politicians. These nonsense politicians will not think beyond politics.

[@getcringe7656]

I was in a dilemma regarding this NRC, watching the quint and NDTV and the wire has been frustrating because they site all self- imaginary consequences and mislead their audience. but with this everything is crystal clear

[@sharathananth2058]

More power to people like you who have the ability to separate truth from propaganda.

[@9-5wala_banda]

Dont worry they will be sued soon....

[@praveenbilagi7851]

Sai Deepak sir hat's of to you

[@niranjangn6320]

It's a kind of joy to watch this kind of intellectual discourse.. thank u rstv

[@dhirajbankar1094]

Good debate. Some points to be mentioned- Though parliament is sovereign in making laws on centers subject, Majority in the parliament doesnt mean 'Majoritarian Polity'.Govt is elected by mere 25-30 crores of indians,not by 130 crores of indians.Its moral responsibilty of the govt to take everyone in confidence. Shaheed Bhagat singh has said that the sanctity of the law can be maintained only if it the popular will of the people.

[@sv1500]

Every Law may be legal but not legitimitate !

[@lokeshkandare5173]

That is why it's a democracy and running it for 70+ years. And if considering you're suggestions than there will always be conflict in a country which is soo diverse in nature and you know how politics run in this country where opposition is always opposing rather then playing a role in nation building.

[@nehaatre5538]

Thank you Frank sir and sai sir

[@trendingnews1948]

My favorite j s deepk.. He has deep knowledge

[@deveshvaishnav86]

j sai deepak ji is gem of india

[@vijaykumaryadav6284]

After hearing this I would say this law is good for country.

[@sharathananth2058]

@@kanchanalankit2216 Why your ancestors never voted in elections? Election cards of your grandparents and parents is enough to prove your citizenship.

[@gajendras7528]

@@kanchanalankit2216 nobody asking you to prove your citizenship. The persecuted minorities have to apply for citizenship and they will get it. Nobody coming to you and will ask you to prove your citizenship.

[@arzunmusic]

Beachse you got influeneced by rss agenda,,, sai deepak is going to get MP ticjet from bjp in 2024 elections... He is unofficial spokesperson of bjp

[@anujsethi7845]

@@sharathananth2058 lol they are asking for land papers or your school certificate. Aadhar card, voter ID card are not for citizenship. Even small errors in documents can declare stateless. And why we need NCR in whole country That's not need of the hour

[@sharathananth2058]

@@anujsethi7845 Check out Assam's NRC documents. you can prove your ancestry via electoral id

[@sirinshah3113]

Very intelligent Depak. India needs talent like you. Raise your voice, we are with you.

[@arzunmusic]

Sai deepak unofficial spokesperson of BJP

[@gabbargabbar5012]

A debate having J Sai Deepak and Satya Prakash is a must watch video....

[@tteerion786]

“Be there as it may” - J Sai Deepak

[@kailasnath2138]

Deepak sir you fentastically delivered all points . how much clear you are about each and every points , I never saw any law personalitys speaking like this and delivering articles in the constitution such way.

[@pranam8307]

j sai deepak sir great reply and well explained the whole matter, thank you

[@hardikmakwana1718]

Mr.Sai Deepak you are the diamond

[@arunnegi009]

jai sai sir you have fully precise knowledge of constitution 🙏🙏

[@prasannapandaga965]

Satya prakash sir explanation is like a child can understand what is the point. Thank you sir

[@hangerasika8851]

Thanks...RSTV plays tremendous job!!

[@mayurpatil2376]

All of us talking around the CAA but NRC is major concern which was not address in this discussion..which is part of the protest..better if this discussion was carried out in holistic manner

[@deepakrathore9175]

J sai deepak you are impeccable

[@siddhantsingh8524]

Yu are awesome, j sai sir, it's always a pleasure to to hear yu explaining various provisions of constitution.

[@sonusinghgariya2875]

J sai deepak sir you always amaze with strong facts. You are definitely right here.

[@vijayraj-hg1bj]

OnlyJ Sai Deepak sir explaination is the best.

[@jonty5902]

J SAI DEEPAK IS ROCKSTAR ALREADY I HOPE HE GETS INTO REAL POLITICS NOT DOING FENCE SITTING . WE NEED MORE SUCH MAN

[@namangautam2323]

J sai and satya prakash: deadly combo.

[@palakmalik8377]

Once again the legend-Jai Sai Deepak

[@dhananjayraj8431]

Sai Deepak sir👍👍👍

[@SACHinsight]

Hanumantayya's arguments are not constitutionally right.

[@shivanikanojia9935]

To say J Sai Deepak is great would be an understatement. Just simply awesome.

[@shivodastak1717]

J Sai is brilliant guy..... N had enough thing to talk about

[@navdeepsingh1914]

Sai Deepak just wow🙏

[@shivajigurjar97]

Thanks RSTV ND Frank Sir nd Salute to Deepak Sir nd respect for Satya Prakash Sir

[@kingsiri17]

Thank you sai 🙏💐

[@100001ad]

Sai Deepak who are you man?? No chance..I will make my child a great lawyer...Extraordinary speech...

[@aishwaryajaiswal5924]

J sai Deepak sir u really command respect through ur knowledge not demand it...a great admirar of urs.. Even Satya prakash sir was very relevant...

[@dawnglianapachuau6433]

the hypocrisy between both the parties when either of them are ruling the centre and states, is my take away from this discussion.

[@VikashKumargupta520]

Jai sai Deepak sir is simply outstanding 🙏🙏

[@anaghasingh1929]

In one voice WE WANT SAI Sir in every panel!

[@ankur0587]

Respect to you J Sai Deepak. Very balanced view and showing the other aspect too. Media only shows hue and cry not the positive side. And absolutely NHRC should chip in for these refugees. Why don't they see Delhi refugees camp and surrounding area they are living in abysmal condition.

[@joginder7673]

🙏sai ...

[@Bharat4Vishwa]

J Sai Deepak rocks again. He is debate Superstar!!

[@92govind]

J sai deepak is pure Gold.

[@ultramaxpro8537]

In the opening statements you can clearly see that the spelling of 'Federal' is wrong in the background. Government channel and such mistakes aren't forgivable. Please correct it.

[@harry2909]

Completely elated with sai's insightful narration. Yet another clear and pin pointed presentation. I think, BJP govt.should find bureaucrats who could present bill with clear information on first hand, like how Sai did to avoid such political discourse in future.

[@sonalisingh580]

Great discussion with clear perspectives.

[@virajturakhia]

Awesome point by Sai Deepak at 22:00.

[@radhikagupta6421]

It's treat to the ears to listen s. Deepak

[@prudhvirajganta7524]

i would rather simply refer j sai deepak than laxmikanth...

[@krishnachaitanya2507]

J Sai Deepak for future PM of India. Atleast should become law minister

[@imprinterchamp8588]

Worth watching episodes 👏

[@theviralcontent4107]

I only watch this program because of J Sai Deepak sir. I am huge fam of him

[@kashyap1396]

Deepak sir ..extraordinary... points...

[@indiamusically]

All I understand is, CAA and NRIC are like giving solution first and then creating a problem. Why create fear, panic in the country. As if everything else is fine, these were the only last issue needed. We were better before all these started.

[@johnsnow1050]

Why did India need independence. Things were working fine anyway. Why so many people sacrificed their lives just to get sovereignty. Why agitate why do anything? Because injustice cannot be accepted just because of possible resistance.

[@SharkCoach]

J Sai Deepak is a genius.

[@madhubansingh2670]

Whenever I see J. Sai Deepak, I have to stop everything and listen to him completely. I don't think there is anyone like him in India. Sharp. Articulate. Deeply insightful. What a man!

[@kism844]

Sai Deepak nailed it.