The Big picture - Debate, Discussion & Decision

[@shashiketan]

*69: PARLIAMENTARY DISRUPTIONS* - "Disorder, disruption and delay in legislation cannot replace debate, discussion and decision which are hallmarks of democracy": RS Chairman - Both government and Opposition need to function as joint stake-holders and compete in serving the people. Recent Disruptions: - The 16th Lok Sabha has lost 1/6th of its time to disruptions while RS has lost 1/3rd of its scheduled time. (Ref: PRS) - Least productive question hours in last winter session: 8% questions were answered orally in Lok Sabha, and 11% in Rajya Sabha -This session has been productive > 90% Parliamentary discussions importance: - Benchmark for debate in society - Serious deliberations for law making - detailed scrutiny. - When court interpret the law they look into the debates to know the intent of the bill. Reasons for Disruptions - Not getting adequate opportunities for expressing views Mr. Raja only 2-3 mins to speak. comes from single member party - Strategic disruption Rules & regulations to govern the proceedings - Rules of proceedings & conduct of business - Handbooks of members - two sections: 1. customs & conventions. 2. Parliamentary Etiquette (how should they behave) - Directions issued by chairman - Ruling & observation from chair - for maintaining the decorum Way Forward: - Criticism of proceedings or government & not any individual will foster an environment to fix things. - Party president or members reprimand the conduct of their members. - No one enters the parliament to disrupt - hence, concerns should be heard. - SELF REGULATION: Parliament is the highest body. - Since, members don't get enough time to speak: increasing no. of days of functioning. When parliament started it was 150 days avg now 60-70 days. Parliamentary time is precious, it's a commodity in limited supply. Discussions, deliberations & decision making is good for democracy.

[@soniapanwar6698]

Thnku

[@LA_FORCA_PSC_ACADEMY]

Everyday RSTV comes up with an interesting discussion. Really loving it 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳👌👌👌👌

[@Rahulpriye]

no one is better than frank but it is good to see vishal instead of rajat

[@bobminion3438]

Debase, Disruptions & Debacle!!!!!!!!!😉 Though the panelists suggested many reforms now let me suggest a few: 1) Provide a statutory limit for the sittings in parliament. The 16 Lok Sabha sat for an average of 66.2 days, why can't we have at least 100 days? 2)Every MPs get an allowance of Rs 2000 for just reaching the parliament, shouldn't it be disallowed if they create disruptions in proceedings. (They can live on their Salary). Though Fali S Nariman tried but failed & today no MPs have the courage to bring such bill. 3) I feel the main problem of disruptions in the house is that the MPs of opposition party don't get a legitimate space as prescribed by the constitution. So at least some days must be allotted to principal opposition and a few to minor parties either session wise or if not at least year wise. 4)U/ RoP&CoB Lok Sabha Rule 374A there is a provision of automatic suspension but In Rajya Sabha Rule 256 *the house* can only suspend and the presiding officer doesn't have the power to suspend the unruly MPs. This requires an amendment to give power to Presiding Officer of Raja Sabha.🤐

[@bobminion3438]

I disagree with few panelists who have a view that disruptions don't cause a big drain to the house. I think extension surely cause drain of exchequers money. 😅🤑😬

[@AnkitGupta-qi9id]

Nigam sir who died recently was the best anchor we can have,so much information he had that no experts are required

[@captainakanksha8665]

who is nigam Sir

[@AnkitGupta-qi9id]

How fearless Girish nikam was and how well understood he was with most topics,is absolutely amazing....

[@bscrollno.23priyabharti37]

Great

[@hinduagnostic5619]

Gooda discussiona.

[@ErMOHTISHAMALI]

Why not big picture on RTI amendment Bill 2019? Pl make on that!

[@shivangiseth6239]

Rajya sabha tv is the best platform for debate👏👏👏👏👏thank u🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

[@googleuser750]

Vishal ji please let guests speak as you have called them because of their expert knowledge

[@jayshelke5096]

Chakshu Thanks........😅😁😅😅 Jay Maharashtra ♨️♨️♨️♨️♨️ Thanks RS TV

[@ashutoshpaliwal116]

call him sir

[@niharikashukla7774]

Anchor should speak less and let panelists discuss more ..

[@vinod_10]

Rti amendment Bill par bhi debate hona chahiye rstv pr

[@bharatiya-akp]

Madam Aditi Fadnavis is pessimist she always disagree to others.

[@ashwin0309]

True...and she seems very disinterested and arrogant too.

[@AnkitGupta-qi9id]

I really miss Girish nikam ,hats off to him.

[@abrarahelahi2797]

Where is He?

[@viveksamrat3473]

Plz make a big picture on RTI Amendament bill 2019.....

[@AnkitGupta-qi9id]

Frank perara even after 2 years is not able to give us a picture of what is happening,how things are moving etc

[@gagankumarsingh220]

Sif subtitle daal dijiye

[@swapnamahalik5041]

Vgm