Become a member of this KZbin channel in order to watch videos ad-free, and get exclusive access to bonus video episodes, available only to members of The Rest Is History Club and members of the KZbin channel: kzbin.info/door/UYK0BJZF3yNb2fw1EdAXUQjoin
@theoldhermit2601Ай бұрын
I'm a young American who was taught startlingly little about this era of history, and am so grateful to be able to learn about it with you guys' energy and perspective! I found your channel from the videos on the 1968 campaign, and have enjoyed the variety of topics I've seen covered so far - I hope you both know that people of all ages greatly appreciate your channel 😊
@restishistorypodАй бұрын
Thank you !
@marys33794Ай бұрын
💯 👍 👍
@fifimspАй бұрын
Agreed. I majored in History and feel I know a lot more British history and have been trying to learn more about French history so was very excited to see this series on here. I would like a documentary series on like the complete history of France, which I know is hard with like changing hands and being part of bigger empires, but it is an interest I've been pursuing lately.
@geofreycrow9663Ай бұрын
@@fifimsp Might be preaching to the choir here, but The Rest is History is ~10 episodes into a series on the French Revolution. Highly recommended, it's where I discovered the channel
@fifimspАй бұрын
@@geofreycrow9663 I actually am watching that one right now, but I actually knew a lot about the French Revolution. I did take modern European history so I do know more about that form like the 1700's up. I guess I should have said I want to know more about Ancient and Medieval French history. The Ancient history I know the most about are Rome and Greece and yes they interacted with European tribes and stuff but we didn't get much into that. I just don't know much about like the Carolingian and Merovingian dynasties and stuff like that in European history. And yes I know about stuff like the Norman invasion but more from a British event point of view. I hope I'm making sense here. So I should have been a little more precise in what I was talking about. LOL. I mean, it's like saying, "I'd like to know more about Chinese History." Well can you be more precise since that's a lot of history! LOL.
@flagpole974Ай бұрын
The animation definetely helped understand the layout of the battle. Was a nice touch, thank you
@restishistorypodАй бұрын
Thank you !
@nilesfairman25146 күн бұрын
@@restishistorypod coulda mentioned the soil tilth
@leighfoulkes72975 күн бұрын
I like the idea that King Henry used a ton of strategies learned throughout the years of Bristish wars. Long bowmen tactics from wars with the Welsh, the Scottish tactics to defeat heavy Calvery with only foot soldiers and etc.
@Lukas-t2o3 күн бұрын
There's been a long history calvary and foot going back and forth There's always bad asses and sociopolitical ramifications, the Landsknechts are a good reading for this reason The Scots produced a famous group of Danish mercenaries that operated in Ireland called the Gallowglas, the Gaels couldn't field expensive heavy calvary so they had Knights on foot with Dane Axes and Great Swords and enterages that could do the job of and directly contest heavy horsemen The British Isles are a great place to begin learning about this stuff
@Voronore20 сағат бұрын
@@Lukas-t2o c'mon, guys. CAVALRY. V before the L. Calvary was the hill where crucifixions were done.
@Wrz2eАй бұрын
I love this animated format and I can't wait to see how it captures the hustle and bustle of Chatham High Street.
@GoBlueGirl78Ай бұрын
😅😅 Actually LOL
@TheLonelyFawnАй бұрын
Hahaha this really made me laugh!!
@Waylander1738 күн бұрын
But where's the big hooped earrings?? 😂
@countdowntorevolution9986Ай бұрын
love how Dom transforms back into a 10 years old boy when he's listening to this stuff.
@rhys-llewellynlewis6178Ай бұрын
Can relate 🤣
@dawall3732Сағат бұрын
33:00 The knights would avoid eating the night before battle. As well as that morning. At most, they would have broth to keep their strength up. To avoid shiting themselves during battle. That's one of the reasons the after battle feast was so important in that time. (Providing you won or at least served and escaped.)
@stuartd5166Ай бұрын
This is a thoroughly enjoyable account of a famous British battle. If only my school could have been so enthusiastic. Thank you
@victornewman9904Ай бұрын
Henry's decision to defeat the French in detail, as well as drawing the French into the killing-ground funnel was brilliant. But cutting his surcoat into fragments and sharing them as a symbol of unity is surpassed by Henry's promise not to be ransomed, just like the archers, is genius.
@paulm3033Ай бұрын
Henry apponted experienced commanders not based soley on social rank , as did Elizabeth 1 in 1588 , unlike the French and Spanish respectively, im sure if I thought long enough i could think of other similar instances, this does seem to have been a particularly 'english' habit and a reason why the english army had the edge over their opponents during these turbulent times.
@ODDwayne1Ай бұрын
Tom your narration kept me strapped in for the ride. Felt like being there. You guys are wonderful.
@manicantclimbАй бұрын
I really appreciate the effort with the animations, editing and audio additions! Much more immersive and visually varied.
@aaronmaynard6019Ай бұрын
I would not say that it was the armours weight, but the fact that the metal is not porus and thus creates a suction to make it harder to put it out of the mud. I remember an old doco that had them test metal vs cloth in mud.
@ajknaup35304 күн бұрын
Interesting perspective
@rhysnichols86084 күн бұрын
Yeah armour was designed to be practical. Battlefields are often rough and falling over was pretty common. If you can’t get up in your armour then it’s not fit for purpose. Knights could move pretty well in full steel armours. It was the mud and suction that made it hard.
@BillGalietteАй бұрын
So well presented gentleman! I always appreciate the story behind the history. One of the “few” who loved history all through grammar school who are now amongst the “many” who appreciate your presentations. Bravo!
@duncannapier318Ай бұрын
The best logical in a nutshell explanation of the Battle Of Agincourt ever. This is a smashing upload and thank you. 👍🇿🇦
@damienbegley8675Ай бұрын
🎉VERY excited!!! Been looking forward to this like it was a movie to be released and I haven't been excited about a movie releaase in decades.
@R08TamАй бұрын
I groaned when I saw that this was an animated version, expecting it to be like a Saturday morning cartoon. But the animation helped with the understanding of the battle and I was impressed.
@arnoldussineamico498Ай бұрын
There is a neighborhood in Toronto called Agincourt, and its chinese translation is "Pavillion of Love and Tranquility". I wonder if the translator knows anything about the battle😅
@canchero724Ай бұрын
Surely someone is playing a prank 😂
@chriscostello9111Ай бұрын
I know those Quebecois hate that Canada is a commonwealth country that still loves their sovereign 🇬🇧🇨🇦
@jamesfranklin836417 күн бұрын
There is no Chinese translation. Keep that crap thought away from history
@TheStephaneAdam9 күн бұрын
@@chriscostello9111 Of course Canadians love their sovereign, They're brits from Wish! Or Americans who refused to stop being a colony. There's a reason why they take pride in being the first post-national state.
@handsomemonkeyking52995 күн бұрын
Chinese have many ways of translating and often they twist the name into a new meaning lol it’s quite creative They translate Australia as ‘big bay little profits’ 😂 Im Aussie and think it’s a hilarious constructive criticism of us lol very apt
@edgarsnake285728 күн бұрын
Thanks for imparting to me a detailed account of Agincourt. I never understood it until today. You are both wonderful to listen to.
@Harry-qu7vgАй бұрын
Listened to this series several times already. Nice to see the animated take on it.
@AmmeeeeeeerАй бұрын
Yes finally have been waiting for this!!!! THANK YOU!!! 😁
@restishistorypodАй бұрын
You're welcome
@1rwjwithАй бұрын
What a great historical recounting of one of the most impressive , inspiring victories by the British. Henry V exhibited great strategic leadership . It seems to be this is an example of an invading army able to use the tactical defense to force a superior force to attack on ground with more advantage to the British in this case. It does come to mind that the British in January 1815 in the BATTLE OF NEW ORLEANS forgot this lesson and made a similar mistake as the French at Agincourt. Great episode!
@youngzoe7492Ай бұрын
You lads bring as much light into my daily joy as much as anyone who not blood, delighted to have found you over the past months and now the animated affect bring a different flavour I quite enjoyed it all, brilliant.
@nickbarton3191Ай бұрын
They must have been extraordinarily tough to march, few provisions, many with dysentery, then fight a battle, and win. Hal must have been quite an inspiring leader.
@sedeslav5 күн бұрын
One detail more about arrows: in a Middle ages archers carried several types of arrows, but most efficient ones was with a steel tips. Those arrows were very expensive, so each archer had maybe 5 or 10 arrows with a steel tip, and the rest (about 30 or so...) were with a tip made of iron (like hunting ones, for example). However, those first ten arrows made a significant difference.
@arnekoets30854 күн бұрын
Sources for steel or steeled tips? Since sheaths were issued with wheelbarrows at a time and commissioned by royal decree by the milion we have fairly clear requirements for such orders and steel heads do NOT seem obviously supplied. We have a few vague mentions, but availability of thousands of steeled tips is very questionable. Also the added performance is really limited. Might make some difference with glass or iron ore covered shields, but i doubt it is that significant
@paulm3033Ай бұрын
Absolutely loved this ,the discussion and the animation really brought this defining battle to life.
@EZEMEAT2000Ай бұрын
Great episode gents
@marys33794Ай бұрын
It is at last here. The battle of Agincourt. What we have been waiting for, for ages, and much appreciated. I will definitely be watching it later. 👍 👍 Cork, Ire., 🇮🇪
@francikoenАй бұрын
The Battle of Angincourt makes me sad. And I'm not even French! However, my great-aunt was a PhD French Professor, so that might be why I am sympathetic to France. The whole Hundred Years War makes me sad. So many deaths... so much destruction... burning of crops and homes... foreign soldiers stealing livestock... and worse. Saint Joan of Arc is the one bright spot. And she was betrayed by the Burgundians, the French King and the British clergy.
@marys33794Ай бұрын
@francikoen I agree 💯. A lot of history of many countries can be sad. Terrible things that happen in wars and still happens today in our times.
@EvsEntpsАй бұрын
By the way, we have little evidence that the stakes were sharpened. In fact, they would have been hammered into the ground and we know they were repositioned at least once before the battle, so any stake with a point would have been blunted down quite quickly from repeated hammering. As such, they probably didn't bother sharpening them in the first place. A blunt stake still does the job though: no horse is willingly charging headlong into one.
@user-ii1iy8fz1d8 күн бұрын
Any man good with an axe can put a sharp point on a log in a few strokes. Moments work. A barrier is a barrier to a horse, you are correct. Perhaps the truth lies somewhere inbetween?
@lawts12406 күн бұрын
Probably sharpened after they were banged into the ground?
@ajknaup35304 күн бұрын
I was thinking the same thing. What if the stakes were pounded in *first*, then sharpened?
@arnekoets30854 күн бұрын
Not only are they shown as sharp in medieval depictions (chronicles of the crusades, for instance) Horses are very bad at seeing things pointing at them, as their vidion is very different than a humans'. Horses will absolutely run into pointy sticks, (including branches) in suicidal ways. There are many other things that make bigger obstacles. Aiming a horse between individual stakes is very doable as well, easier than pikes trying to aim and hit you. They would have to be very closely spaced in order not to do so (closer than depicted in medieval art or as mentioned in primary sources) We also know of such stakes in archeological examples as part of 'landweren', ditch and banks with stakes, subsequently overgrown with hedges used as landscape defenses. But horses will charge into all sorts of things, especially when the lead horse is selected for their prepensity to do so. Water filled ditches (kortrijk, gent, various others) and trip pits and caltrops are a more relibably effective barrier than stakes by themselves.
@williamrizzo85742 күн бұрын
You can also hammer on a stub where a branch was cut. These aren't exactly lathed poles
@johnsimpson8893Ай бұрын
Did you do the animations yourselves? Henry V's eyebrows are great. When his left eye goes up his smile broadens. I think he likes that.
@blastulaeАй бұрын
Waterloo also featured mud. In fact it was critical. Nappy had to wait for it to dry so he could maneuver his artillery. This delay proved costly.
@mtrb1966Ай бұрын
Loving the animated presentation !!
@heavypen4 күн бұрын
I learned about the Battle of Agincourt in a military history class at Claremont College in California (decades ago). The class was taught by a US Army captain who obviously loved history and had a particular fondness for this epic battle. Then, I saw Brannaugh's Henry V and was absolutely blown away all over again. Few battles have elicited so much drama. Your analysis and retelling were brilliant. Thank you.
@nigeh5326Ай бұрын
I have to go out to a meeting with friends now but I look forward to an hour or more of wit wisdom and knowledge later as I enjoy a few beers. 👍🏴✌️
@nicksykes457529 күн бұрын
I'm sat typing this looking out over the "field of arrows" where Henry first won his spurs, and took an arrow to the face. So I've always considered him my favourite Monarch.
3 күн бұрын
No monarch should ever be your favorite. Godamn englishmen
@alixa1258Ай бұрын
Fabulous 🎉😊 can’t wait!! Love this show 🎉
@reubendorman25 күн бұрын
Great video, guys. i love the English archers of the hundred years war. I recently learned Edward the third had prepared 135,000 arriw bags of 24 arrows each as well as 7,700 long bows fie his army, for his crecy campaign would Henry the fifth had done the same?
@cliftonfurney5083Ай бұрын
Very good. Thank you. Your presentation made it understandable
@andydunn5673Ай бұрын
This is brilliant Thanks for pulling it together for us
@nickmac80789 күн бұрын
Thank you for this! A great extremely well read account whilst being thoroughly entertaining!
@kirilmickovski3543Ай бұрын
Loving this channel
@restishistorypodАй бұрын
Thank you !
@SaunajalluАй бұрын
This must be Theo answering. The French space before the exclamation point betrays you!@@restishistorypod
@bradybuschur5995Ай бұрын
Amazing! You guys have a huge fan from Cincinnati, Ohio!
@duncannapier318Ай бұрын
And another huge fan all the way down in Cape Town, South Africa 🇿🇦👍
@Nowhandles2 күн бұрын
Irvine, California here!
@LookEast-p4eАй бұрын
Fantastic - thank you!
@johndavenport8843Ай бұрын
Famtastic as always, and funny too.
@michael7324Ай бұрын
I woke up early to catch this one. Well done boys.
@pauliewalnuts2527Ай бұрын
i think the no pants thing was one archer being cheeky and it just caught on. often running gags and jokes develop in war among armys and cultures.
@rweezy624612 күн бұрын
Subscribed. This is outstanding. I look forward to binging. Thanks from North Georgia, USA.
@annaboo27Ай бұрын
The animation is fantastic! Really helped a complete newb get into this. lol Just have to add, in regards to quite a number of the comments of gratitude, that I Completely agree! I have just been devouring your videos and podcasts lately. There are several history majors in my own family..however I never leaned that way. I rather enjoy English literature (major) much more. However, thanks to these lovely gents, I have a newfound appreciation for the history of our wonderfully crazy world! Thank you for continuing to inspire! ❤
@andreroeck8026Ай бұрын
Excellent series again. Even if you missed out on the crucial role the mud played in the morning of Waterloo. ;) Keep up the great work guys!
@ForetellingАй бұрын
New viewer here, I'm very glad to have found this channel. Great content, gents.
@dangersdaddy2595Ай бұрын
Yes! I've been patiently waiting for this episode. I can't wait to listen to this episode tonight!!!
@martybaggenmusicАй бұрын
I LOVE this channel. Tom and Dominic, please consider a series on the history of Mt Everest, in particular, the Mallory and Irvine controversy. Thank you for your wonderful, wonderful channel that enables the acquisition of the most precious commodity, knowledge.... wrapped in the second most valuable commodity.... humor.
@willjones3406Ай бұрын
9000 men recruited makes sense as about a third of the army were loss to dysentery at the siege of Harfleur by the week before Agincourt
@alyoshakaramazov84692 күн бұрын
33:10 my step father was a nose gunner in a B-24 bomber in the attack on Ploeisti in August, 1943, and he assured me that it is quite true that one’s bowels misbehave in the face of enemy fire.
@sallymae59Ай бұрын
I love listening to you guys!!!!
@tomking58555 күн бұрын
Thank you for such a compelling account of the battle and the historic accounts of the main players, battlefield topography, ingenuity, bravery, and for making this history so alive and interesting. Glued to your account from beginning to end….
@frances7243Ай бұрын
The animated format is great. Well worth visiting the battlefield itself (only 50 miles from Calais) to get a feel for the place which is essentially unchanged. There is a small museum and, I understand, an annual event, a gathering of modern day archers to commemorate the battle.
@GimmeShelterNMКүн бұрын
I've been listening to your wonderful podcast forever and this is the first time I've seen a video. I Imagined you had each others voices lol.
@lisawright8921Ай бұрын
I just recently came across your channel and I am hooked! Keep up the great work on the wide variety of historical content!❤
@GiggleByteMaster2 күн бұрын
No idea why the algorithm fed me this but what an enjoyable listen. Think I found a new podcast to enjoy.
@wukong22826 күн бұрын
Cheers from the states. Excellent recounting fellas, informative with a right bit of quality humour too. You have a subscriber in me 👏🏿👏🏿
@kyliedavies169527 күн бұрын
This was a great! I’m a channel member now and my husband is getting into the podcasts too.
@joaosantos1163Ай бұрын
I’m Brazilian but in my opinion Henry V is the greatest English king !!
@chriscostello9111Ай бұрын
He definitely is one of the greatest he United all the people of the British isles under a sheared identity Irish Scottish Welsh Briton/saxon Briton/norman although the people had different identities based on regions they were the same and United on their sheared isles we are all people of the same isles.....when your a nation of islands you all need to be United regardless of regional differences because if one region gets invaded the rest of them will
@chriscostello9111Ай бұрын
I'm half Irish half English but I refer to myself as British
@Dave5843-d9m4 күн бұрын
I’m English but proud to hold a British passport. I am British first.
@nomaddamon1002 күн бұрын
I did not think I'd listen to all of that, but I was fixated... Great podcast
@robfielding100Ай бұрын
Brilliant rendition from an English Longbowman!
@shealey9763Ай бұрын
"We're probing it" Funniest thing I have heard in an age, well done gentlemen.
@goingbeyondtheillusion24 күн бұрын
What a brilliant episode
@gregoryjclark81Күн бұрын
Man, I was eating my breakfast cereal when the 'The Lay of the Land' played out. Nearly had oats and milk in my sinuses and nostrils with that giant Welshman image.
@gazlatorАй бұрын
As much as Branagh's version of Henry V does portray the muddy conditions, I feel it also downplays too much of the vivid colour and spectacle (which was certainly a feature of medieval armies) which the French army at least - and the English too perhaps to a degree - would have displayed upon banners, coats of arms, jupons, horse-barding, etc.
@johncarroll772Ай бұрын
Oliviers version portrays the more accurate armour and pageantry
@gazlatorАй бұрын
@@johncarroll772 absolutely
@Milverton6828 күн бұрын
Loving the graphics.
@BenNewman17762 күн бұрын
It's a great addition, it drew me in for sure now I am going through the catalog.
@edgarjones68243 күн бұрын
@21:30ish is this the earliest example of led by le donkeys 😅 Great vid, really well presented, thanks x
@leberlin6 күн бұрын
I remember doing this at school but only recall the Longbow Archer part, so this was a very entertaining and very detailed explanation of how ancient battles were played out, I am still trying to picture 75,000 arrows in a few minutes raining down on advancing foes, something I would not want to be in the middle of and definitely would have to “void my bowels” in this situation. Lovely
@nigelmcconnell1909Ай бұрын
Ok so here is my question:- Everyone who went to Sandhurst would know this story inside out and the foolishness of the French Calvary charging against longbows men. So why during the western desert campaign in the second world war did the British army in battle after battle send tanks against German artillery with the same disastrous results? Paper, rock, scissors. Tanks beat infantry, artillery beats tanks, infantry outmaneuver and overwhelm artillery. It took a long time for the allies to work this out
@Richard-d1yАй бұрын
If only it were so simple. Sometimes an action is taken for political reasons, I.e. 'just do something ' irrespective of how effective it is.
@johnleney954120 күн бұрын
It wasn't artillery, but anti-tank guns. The Germans had re-purposed an anti aircraft gun, which had a high velocity and thus low trajectory, as an ATG, and it took the Brits a while to work out what was happening
@DonaldAtherton-l7u9 күн бұрын
It was cavalry,there’s your answer.
@spencersanderson18949 күн бұрын
Because EGO trumps all knowledge and skill one may posses. To be the one who broke through would have his name immortalised, that’s enough to make any man with a weak constitution forget all his training.
@Judahlionheart9 күн бұрын
Absolutely anazing my new favorite channell u guys done a stellar job im in awe such a great job hustory made fun with the cream of the crop of hustorical stories i love it.
@nathanlarson7408Күн бұрын
42:45 I heard "non-competent" and thought 'what a novel way to call someone an idiot'
@MalakAlMaut68602 күн бұрын
Beautifully told. Really enjoyed the video 👍
@Curious-MindsАй бұрын
One of the best history channels
@susanfehr4073Ай бұрын
As Henry won , I can imagine that the sources massaged the numbers down to make it more miraculous. But that Henry wasn't killed was possibly the greatest failure of the French here. If Henry had been tied the while thing would have fallen apart. But Henry's tactics were brilliant. Knowing that the ground is boggy, force the French to come to you and know they will probably be on horseback, so they will be slow and you can pick off the leaders and the front rows making it harder for the rest to advance. Perfect.
@littlelauchie2 күн бұрын
This was awesome, thanks for sharing!
@restishistorypod2 күн бұрын
Thank you very much !
@callusmaximumsАй бұрын
Can’t believe I just found this Time to loose days of my life listening to all the rich history ! Cheers guys merry Xmas
@LynnMcRae-zi6yt6 күн бұрын
That was brilliant, I didn't know the details of the battle. I live overlooking the lands owned by the freemen of Alnwick given to the knights for their bravery at that battle.
@thewidgetmanАй бұрын
This is like old school discovery channel! I love it
@faeembrughАй бұрын
Went there and it's a very compact battlefield. Easy to see how the French were funneled into a killing zone where their numbers were a hindrance to them.
@jonnyandali13 күн бұрын
Great stuff this. Stumbled across you both on Ticktock. Keep up the good work. 👍🏿
@liamjames3680Ай бұрын
Can’t believe Tom visits Berwick and has an estate up here. Being from Berwick myself I can’t get over the fact someone from my favourite podcast even knows Berwick. Would love yous to do a podcast on Edward the first and delve into the siege of Berwick and the wars of Scottish independence.
@msquared66955 күн бұрын
I think having already accepted your fate would bring a sense of “I’ve nothing to lose” which I think would allow the soldiers to focus on fighting instead of being distracted by anxiety
@ChristyOFaghan3 күн бұрын
this was fascinating, but i'm afraid i was so taken by Dominic's "Gent" that i spent most the time listening while looking at watches on the Tissot site really nice piece and exceedingly practical
@RockCorley-im1siАй бұрын
ANOTHER GREAT SHOW!😊
@amcconnell67304 күн бұрын
23:45 Remember that all of these Dukes and Counts are looking at a bedraggled, starving, much smaller force that also contains (literally) a King's Ransom. They are looking at what could be a guaranteed win, and if you capture Henry you'd be wealthy beyond avarice. That's why the French nobility all wanted to push forward.
@billder2655Ай бұрын
nice animations 👍🏼
@restishistorypodАй бұрын
Thank you !
@ethanstrongАй бұрын
Wow, lot of work must’ve went into this!
@gwfranklin14 күн бұрын
Love the animation!!! This was awesome
@ScienceChap4 күн бұрын
Shakespeare! A great start to a video.
@paulm3033Ай бұрын
The English army had been on the march for ages, lost men to dysentry compared the French who were on home ground and whose numbers were being added to up to the eve of battle ,im sure the English were significantly outnumbered .
@henrynoel4223Ай бұрын
My favorite Henry V was portrayed by Robert Hardy in the BBC series "An Age of Kings," with a very young and sweet-looking Judi Dench as Catherine of Valois. My only regret is that the series was condensed for television, and a lot of good scenes were omitted.
@vincentquintiliani66903 күн бұрын
Fantastic video! Great to see Tom Holland with his own channel
@gustavderkits84336 күн бұрын
“Blotted out the sun”, “fighting in the dark”, my aunt fanny. The 75,000 arrows were not in the air at the same time. That was a minute and a half worth of arrows. Five thousand archers put a maximum of five thousand arrows into the air at the same time. But they weren’t split-second timed, so at most a few thousand at the same time and staggered across the 150 yards by 1000 yards air above the battlefield.
@thamzource8971Ай бұрын
Amazing work, greetings from Sweden. I hope one day you guys will do a series about Charles XII :D
@aegirkarl1411Ай бұрын
When comparing the forces it is not only the total numbers but the composition that matters. If the French had much higher proportion of knights and squires they would have outnumbered the English men-of-arms several times even if the total numbers were closer.
@alextaylor297 күн бұрын
Great video, liked and subscribed. What I find amazing is the French did not learn from the battle of Crecy 75 years before this battle where the results were nearly the same with similar tactics.