The City | PMV Collab

[@GoldenKranic360]

Nine years and this is still amazing

[@JakeWhyman]

The traffic is moderately tolerable in this city, the shops are nice, and the inhabitants are alright. 9.98/10

[@gavinbroadwater7362]

11/10 would eleven

[@unknownwanabe3437]

I wouldn´t be surprised If both of you were criticians from IGN ͡ᵔ ͜ʖ ͡ᵔ

[@Billaxle]

Gavin Broadwater 7/11 Open all night, but the doughnuts are stale.

[@4d_chesser]

Rly jake

[@11regretful31]

Derpy be derpy

[@MrDeLoop]

So glad to be a part of this. Awesome job, everyone. :)

[@MrBlonde1]

^_^

[@svdkxv]

Hello

[@frostycokeacola5615]

***** I was in your live stream when you made this. It looks great in the final product.

[@MrDeLoop]

brandon jamieson Yeah, I remember. Thanks for the kind words, man!

[@svdkxv]

brandon jamieson cool, but I didn't :(

[@unbxwavez9421]

Who is here for memories?

[@iainhansen1047]

UNBX Wavez me two years later!

[@wolfdeathnogames5314]

back after 5 years, ah the memories

[@ChF-mg2zm]

Me

[@thelionalex1]

Me too. Yeah.

[@MilesProwerFR]

You bet!

[@thecollaboratory9376]

Hi everyone! Is the video blocked in your country? Well, have no fear! We've no uploaded it to Vimeo for your viewing pleasure! vimeo.com/124632972

[@toxickiller13]

Hey I'm looking for some amazing pmv makers to collaborate with. I'm great at 2d stuff and I can learn so much more from pmv's... So if you know some guys making a collab. Please.. And I mean PLEASE notify me... Thanks ~ toxic (or mojo, my brony channel :) not active ATM. )

[@briochebred]

The Collaboratory I have used a snippet of this video audio for an intro on my channel. Is this okay? Please let me know, i don't want to have copywrite issues. I linked this video in the descriptions of my videos if that helps.

[@madysonzink1282]

The Collaboratory Make a collab of Bad Blood, PLZ!!!!!!!!!

[@DigiDoesStuff]

+1ZAAC8 Well seeing how they didn't make the song, I don't think you'll have any copyright issues with them. The link to the original is in the description.

[@ethanm5109]

This from Need for Speed Most Wanted

[@SammiFX]

Oh no I almost forgot to self promote in the comment section. Um... glad to be a part of this!

[@fen9392]

10\10 - IGN Would eat a sandwich again

[@DorkaOwO]

Your profile picture says it all

[@les1609]

oH HELLO

[@airueis]

i still remember watching this 5 years ago and kept it on loop for hours and hours, whoaaa

[@dnproductions9207]

This song really represents why we're bronies (in my opinion) let me explain "There is a place in the distance, a place that I've been dreaming of. No time and space don't exist there." (typically the brony fandom, full of positivity and endless kindness) "We can dance like there's no tomorrow" (this explains how no matter who, what or how you are, you're accepted and we can do whatever together" "I can feel the city crumbling around me" (most of us joined the fandom because our world was pretty crappy.) "can't seem to find my way" (we were lost for a while until) "But I can see a bright light calling through the dark night, hoping to find my way" (we were slowly finding out what this fandom was and slowly liking and slowly coming forward to it) "I had what I wanted, it went away so fast" (Life was perfect before we were bronies until it went downhill) "Had to let go, we can dance like there's no tomorrow" (We found MLP and the fandom, and almost instantly healed from the pain of the past) that's my opinion on what the lyrics mean even if the song wasn't made by a brony, That's my brony perception on this song.

[@Theknobuddies]

Stick what?

[@euan4492]

Is from a guy that makes music of this type, his name is Madeon c:

[@SweetieOpaline]

+Grammar Nazi Then why are you here?

[@cherribomb5422]

+Dee Jay Scratch I agree with you. I'm glad I found someone with the same opinion.

[@One_Chozen]

Describes my thoughts exactly props

[@IRUNASSULT]

These PMVs always make me happy.

[@2007excalibur2007]

Madeon PMVs are always beautiful to see. Astounding work, y'all!

[@OmegaOzone]

You did an amazing job with this and prooved the justice of our culture. Now go and rest our heroes! Seriously though, everyone did a great job in this. Everything flowed super nicely and the visuals were simply awesome. Very impressive stuff!

[@TheeLinker]

Hello yes I helped what's goin' on how are ya.

[@Icanhazmochiplz]

I loved your part, very fluid and played along with the theme well. ^^

[@thecollaboratory9376]

TheeLinker thxx 4 ur help. i'm gr9 how r u.

[@FritzyBeat]

*Wooooooooooooow!* This was an absolute BLAST to watch! I love PMVs, and this one was just BEYOND amazing! Bravo to each and every one of you!

[@ScarletFlight]

FritzyBeat

[@FritzyBeat]

Jack DC 93 ^_^

[@spectrumllive]

Awesome job. The amazing visuals, the effects, the insane editing, the beautiful song, everything. Much love to the fandom! :D ❤️🧡💛💚🩵💙💜🩷

[@Syrenos183]

Man, I love these collabs so much. I really enjoy just seeing everyone's particular style all mixed into one project, especially when it comes to the transitions. They never feel jarring or too sudden and that makes it so much more fun to watch these multiple times for me. Great work to all those involved in this and I look forward to future projects to come. :D

[@scratchytowel8652]

Thank you for existing, mlp

[@pillzh3re]

I absolutely love these collaborations.

[@marshkipgaming1754]

So much nostalgia for this song and this PMV ❤

[@InfinityR319]

I first heard this song on Need For Speed Most Wanted 2012, and I loved it back then. Now you guys just sublimed it and make it into something even better! Great job!

[@Alanj2007Games]

Ryan C.T. Lee Haha! I found this song because of that game too!

[@Makenshi179]

Alanj2007 Games Same here ;)

[@NainBrony]

I heard this song too the nfs mw 2012

[@pikathecat4029]

Same, one of the best games

[@AidanWR]

I feel like pmvs are the best part of this fandom, and it's always great to see all the different styles put together in one video

[@SomniisPMV]

Ah, the Fandom is alive with the sound of collabs! Amazing job all of you!

[@moss6468]

That was the best MLP video EVER!!!!😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃

[@Alanj2007Games]

Props to the artists who worked on this collaboration! This is really awesome! :D

[@MImsrock1]

So unbelievably amazing! Thank you so much to all of the contributors!!! :D

[@JHaller_]

In before everyone else comes here for congratulatory reasons.

[@thecollaboratory9376]

JHaller oh u.

[@destroyers6575]

The Collaboratory Congrats too y'all!

[@andreapaez4248]

Lol

[@phillipanderson7899]

JHaller hi my name is bad (not bad like not good with picture)

[@ZnWrrr]

hey jhaller

[@iplyrunescape305]

The City of Liberty

[@CalebTheGeniusSpy]

Wow, I swear that some of these PMVs - especially the collaborations, are more well-thought-out, entertaining, and higher quality than a lot of high-budget, record label music videos. I'm not saying that all music videos are poorly made. I'm making a comparison between what I see is good there and what I see is great here. Very well done to everypony who worked on this project! /)

[@alisayxu]

who's still here for the nostalgia :((

[@GrayFur]

Now you can also watch it on Vimeo if it's blocked both on KZbin and Dailymotion. Enjoy. :3

[@getyourwish2847]

A M A Z I N G

[@zombieide4life]

I'm so glad that this channel finally picked up! These collaborations are freaking beautiful in every sense of the word. It shows that there's still a couple caring, great bronies (and people) out there. :3

[@gregoryfitzpatrick2468]

I've finally found this song after 6 YEARS

[@chuu_shi]

The transitions between collaborators are ever so smooth. Awesome!

[@willowpets]

OH HELL YES. So glad my favs, thelightleavesthee, mrdeloop, jackdc, and pixel are still there.

[@ScarletFlight]

***** And even if he did want to leave, I wouldn't let him.

[@willowpets]

Jack DC 93 To quote a certain pony, "Yay."

[@superunknown2728]

Man I love this, this was how I discovered Madeon!

[@mclaren_f1_gtr989]

I like this song from Madeon First time I heard it, it was in Need for Speed Most Wanted 2012, and it was perfectly fit for Fairheaven (name of the city in the game)

[@WhinyWortex]

That was amazing, this group is where I go to find out new things in after effects. I'm still learning major stuff, but I am closest to mastering pixelnerd's style. You guys do the best pmv's I've seen in a long time

[@BlueJae]

Great job to all of the talented editors on the team! Amazing work!

[@thecollaboratory9376]

Thomas S Thank you!

[@CrimsonDuskWantsTheGoodSucc]

It was worth the wait!

[@rogerhouses5204]

Button Mash Your face doesn't say that.

[@CrimsonDuskWantsTheGoodSucc]

Roger Houses ಠ_ಠ and you shouldnt +1 your own comments...

[@mashirom3137]

Thanks and have fun

[@colorwisp4007]

Button Mash lol

[@RaidenB]

Beyond amazing. All the parts flowed and transitioned so well, almost like one editor did this whole thing.

[@HyperGamingSquad]

Another well-made PMV! It was definitely worth the wait, but instead of me posting a single sentence comment, I'd like to give some criticism. 1. GrayFur. This was a really good intro, but I think it felt too "Dry". You could've at least added a little color-correction or more contrast. Other than that - molodec, pacan! 2. JackDC93. Very cool idea, something original, but there were places where you could've made the camera movements smoother or places the objects in more comfortable positions. Also the outlines at 0:28 looked really odd, in my opinion. But I'm taking my hat off to you, sir, for originality! :) 3. RapidBeta4. Dat 3D tho. It indeed had a nice camera movement, but you could added a bit more dynamism to your part. And to give it more "3D-ish" feeling, try making those light streaks go around objects as well! 4. pixel3000nerd. Nice motion graphics! I thought the 3D city part was cool! I always see simmilar things from you in every video, maybe you should try something more "Fancy" next time? But I do love your style, man! Cheers! 5. TheeLinker. Something original again! Hooray! I really liked the effects and transitions you made, but I do think you over-used the diffusion and light effects a bit! 6. MrDeLoop. Even though the effects were really repetitive, I think your part was one of my favorites! I especially loved the texture and the cropping you made! 7. TheLightLeavesThee. I can see that you've progressed SO much over these past few months! I'm proud of ya, man! Your camera movement as well as text animations still need a bit of work though! And the mask at 2:12 was a bit rough around the edges! 8. JakeWhyman I liked the little effect on the background clips, but you could've at least animated the text or made some more interesting transitions! And the text font wasn't very clean too! 9. Lord Pony. I liked your ideas, but you need to work on your camera movement a bit and object placement. 10. Sambohh. It definitely looked clean and pretty smooth! But I thought some scenes were empty and could've used better textures or overlays. A good example would be the scene at 3:23. It felt very empty. 11. Racecarghost1. The idea in this one was awesome! And I know you didn't really make it look funky because you were probably busy with other things, but I was actually expecting a bit more in the end, but it was good nonetheless! Man...this shit took me forever to write! But you all did an amazing job! I'm looking forward to the next PMV! ^^

[@GrayFur]

***** Thank you for pointing out what we could improve. As for my part, the goal was to make it smooth and clean and use color correction and effects as little as possible to focus on building 3D scene and animation. I love experimenting. :3

[@SammiFX]

Thanks for the constructive criticism, will keep that in mind.

[@ArchieGamez]

If this was in 60fps i will vote this pmv for top 10 pony videos april like infinate times!

[@ArchieGamez]

***** i agree with you but im saying if this is in 60 fps it would be awesome

[@ArchieGamez]

***** ok,because i know sfm supports 60 fps So 4k would be better than 60 fps Anyways thanks for replying

[@4206-x8g]

derpy is in the wonderbolts and has her own element AWESOME

[@LettuceOnTheSides]

You guys are awesome :3 Love how it all clips together!

[@williambriggs3379]

That rainbow powered Derpy though XD Best part of the video

[@ScarletFlight]

oh shit son i totally helped with this

[@Makenshi179]

Wonderful work everypony!! :D Amazing PMV Collab, you guys are the best!! ^^ Also, this may be a PMV about Manehattan, but with the lyrics "There is a place in the distance, a place that I've been dreaming of, oh time and space don't exist there", I couldn't help but see it pointed at Equestria, or the place we are when we watch MLP. And "It went away so fast" as "Time went by so fast since the first MLP episode", and "We can dance like there's no tomorrow" as "Let's dance and watch MLP now to forget about the inevitable flow of time and feel good". So it was very heart-warming :D Thank you SO much for making this! Again, you all are awesome ^^ Sparkle on! /)

[@calicovision]

And you guys have managed to wow me once again. Great work, each and every single one of you! Amazing song choice, might I add

[@majormax13]

Now that's a PMV! Excellent work on all of this - I have to say that this collaborative idea you all had is really putting out some capital stuff. I especially adored the portion by TheeLinker starting at 1:17, best part of the whole video if you ask me. Good job all around!

[@Askerad]

Oh My Sweet God. The Song, The Rythm, The art style and all ... THAT WAS JUST THE BEST FREAKING PMV I'VE EVER SEEN. AND I THINK MY THOUGHTS

[@GrayFur]

Oh sweet Celestia, we released it! Yusssssss!!!

[@almightysauce8903]

I don't usually comment... But when I do... It's because you've done good... I love your work.

[@SolarFlare451]

Getting a lot of nostalgia from watching this again

[@crystalheartdash1982]

This is by far the coolest pmv i have seen :D

[@pixelvapour1960]

Just turned 24 a few weeks ago but with colabs like these I don't think I will probably "outgrow" the fandom (even though I should have outgrown it ages ago, judging by mainstream, "normal" society)

[@destroyers6575]

Very nice, I really liked your work, I think I'll vote for this at the next PMV selection

[@freiigon6036]

I adored theelinker's part In this, especially 1:30. Everyone else was fantastic as well, though!

[@RueAvenger]

Beautiful, as expected :D I can't wait to see what you guys do for season 5!

[@TechPony]

Just got here from the Top Ten Pony video. I can't believe I missed this. Congratulations! This is really good and you can't go wrong with Madeon.

[@Kutaloo]

Why is it that everything that comes from you guys is just amazing?

[@WolfX1120]

This Collab Is AMAZING!!!! /) i love it ;3

[@bluebelly9932]

HOLY SHIT BALLS THIS WAS AMAZING!

[@thecollaboratory9376]

AquaDub Glad you enjoyed it!

[@bluebelly9932]

The Collaboratory I LOVED IT! you guys did an amazing job!!!! do you know what the name of the song is?

[@GrayFur]

It's Madeon - The City. ^^

[@bluebelly9932]

Gray Fur alright thank chus! and keep up the amazing work!

[@GrayFur]

AquaDub Thanks, I surely will. :)

[@TrebleSketch]

Absolutely amazing! Great job to all those who worked on this ^^

[@anthonywilson6616]

I Really Like Your Collabs

[@KrazyStargazer]

~There was once a magical place boys, and girls, Fillies and Gentlecolts. Where the sky is the limit and anything is possible. All your dreams and aspersions made possible here. It went by many names 'the City of Friendship', 'the promised land', some even referred to it simply as THE CITY ... But to me it will always be Ponyville~ -Spike (Stardate 2140)

[@DiceEnjoyerSgtHops]

"if there was no light. there would be no darkness. no matter how much evil lurks there will always be a light... ....and we all. have a place with that light that will never be extinguished. different or indifferent. we all have a place where we lower our blades, calm our souls, and know that where safe, and we can do anything" -The Speaker (srsly your comments... holy crap... like...whoa)

[@KrazyStargazer]

Starlight Official (bows) Thank you, thank you!

[@DiceEnjoyerSgtHops]

Krazy Stargazer media2.giphy.com/media/dOJt6XZlQw8qQ/giphy.gif

[@KrazyStargazer]

Starlight Official heck i'll do this more if ya like. Like poems/stories in comments :)

[@DiceEnjoyerSgtHops]

Krazy Stargazer just do what you do. i don't want you to change >ω

[@shadowy_dark105]

Great Music, Great Visuals, Great Collaborations. Just Absolutely Flawless. Gotta love it.

[@AnimatronicPony]

Wow I love this video also grayfur's part intro was so good

[@GrayFur]

AnimatronicPony Thanks, Anima. ^^

[@CrimsonRose18]

saw this on a livestream and this was so amazing

[@heyyitsezra]

wow this takes me back. this is how i found madeon and he's how i found porter robinson. looking back, this pmv means a lot to me.

[@mrliminal6247]

I’m really new to the fandom so I’m just finding all these masterpieces

[@duathedoodler]

bootiful video *claps*

[@veronicadecena6895]

I love how you sneaked Derpy in everp place xD

[@alibeksalim7072]

Dat drop is perfect. Like!

[@pixel3000nerd]

Well lookie here, a new collab! ;D

[@IBlazerI]

pixel3000nerd U did gud *calp calp calp*

[@Starlynndust]

pixel3000nerd Amazing Job!

[@ianmitchell5979]

pixel3000nerd AWESOME WORK, MAN! *BROHOOF!*

[@souleater1366]

The City by Madeon is so awesome, and with the ponies, even better!

[@darkflare1810]

great pmv

[@lukymoonowo4703]

The awesome PMV i ever seen!!!,nice work guys!!! n.n

[@Suparpheonix]

This gaved me a tear of my soul... Which I'm dead, but its worth it! ;w;

[@abbyceaseanddesist1197]

Excellent use of the cut-and-dry style in this. I am very impressed with the quality. I give it a like. :)

[@norad_clips]

PMV's are hit and miss with me. This was a direct hit!

[@yoyleb1711]

i miss this era of my life so bad

[@thecollaboratory9376]

I do, and I don't. I miss making stuff with friends. I don't miss making pony content. - TLLT

[@yoyleb1711]

@@thecollaboratory9376 oh shit, hey TLLT! yeah, that's totally understandable. I've definitely moved on from the franchise as well but friends are forever.

[@thecollaboratory9376]

@@yoyleb1711 Took a long time to come to grips with the show ending and the fandom's relevancy fading. I'm glad I was a part of it and am thankful for everything I learned, but god do I wish I hadn't let it consume me so bad to the point that it became my life. But I brought some pretty cool content to this community so I guess it was worth it, lol. - TLLT

[@yoyleb1711]

@@thecollaboratory9376 oh yeah same absolutely! i don't regret my time in the fanbase but i wish i consumed other media at the time, kinda felt like i missed out. but now we can devote time to enjoying other things yknow!

[@ferventshuffling8906]

This is amazing!!!!! I haven't seen any better than this!!!! :D

[@gameboygames8879]

That's alot of dedication to make something like this.

[@FrenchRarity]

Speechless I am.

[@kdfrost159]

Omg I never thought mah favourite song would be the next one. Man you guys are the best. Love the vids.

[@mangofoalix]

Oh boy! This is awesome!

[@aylajacksonelliotabell6439]

this music.... it s amazing. I reccomend you make a 10 or 1 hour version because I would actually finish that video!!!

[@bradygorman]

I LOVE THIS PMV

[@ribps289]

Oh ok so these guys finally upload the second video, let's watch it OH MY GOD THIS IS AMAZING THIS IS THE FUCKING BEST OF THE BEST How are you so great ;_;

[@Feed.It.]

0:01 lyra and bon bon :D

[@EDIAMMUSIC]

Thank you for doing this one, it really needed to be done!

[@wally12031]

Much better than monser high! I LOVE MLP! very much!

[@toxicflare3585]

YYES A NEW ONE AND ITS SO GOOD YOU GUYS ARE AWESOME!!!!!!

[@zombieslayer2262]

Some more awesome shit. Glad to see another collab. Love you guys.

[@brvhtxxbxk]

love this pmv so much!♡

[@shala2296]

The end sounds so beautiful

[@AussieGriffin]

3:12 The moment I added this to my "Fun MLP Stuff" list. ^.^ A.G.

[@aylajacksonelliotabell6439]

I love this song!!!!!

[@ScootsMcGoot]

Awww yeah! The aesthetic of this video is better than All This Time. But I think the song All This Time is better. It's a give and take.

[@rickxhoshinji]

Wow, you really can't stop the urge to dance with ponies.

[@rikuhighwind2498]

Well, youve givin me a reason to make a folder called best videos of all time. Number 1 on my list. Cant wait till the next song. I'll be commenting a few songs that i think would make great collabs like this