The Doctor & Rose • My Immortal HD (by seduff)

[@Lorem44]

Here in 2020, self-quarantining at home and bored. Thought of this out of the blue. Still the best fan vid of Ten and Rose.

[@glencocobing]

honestly though i don't think billie piper gets enough credit, i mean the amazing chemistry she had with both christopher eccleston and david tennant. superb, superb

[@KittyCatThang]

This breaks my heart so much. Ten and Rose, AND Nine and Rose. I ship both. :(

[@cathyprice9285]

When you read the comments I am (while crying my soul and all my feels out on these two) am loving that even after all this time doctor/rose shippers are still around. We will never give up out OTP!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@toestealer]

Still love it

[@KatlynnHahn]

2018 and watching this so...

[@iwritearmsracesnotfashions609]

It's been over a decade and they still make me so happy. Hard to believe its been so long. They're timeless tbh.

[@katieblue5051]

2021 checking in and sobbing all the while… It recently occurred to me that there was probably a massive wealth of TenRose fanfiction in existence, so for the past two weeks, that’s pretty much occupied all of my free time. It’s the closest I’ll ever get to filling the TenRose-shaped void in my soul (unless BBC gets their shit together and makes a Metacrisis Doctor+Rose spin-off)

[@mikawhofan]

this vid is proof why The Doctor/River relationship paled in comparison.

[@ninac.5921]

+Marilee Boer i've just watched the episode where eleven kissed river song and that made me kinda angry.. And tbh I didn't see that coming -.-

[@timberleesmith7021]

Marilee Boer Holy shit yas

[@arkytior]

Exactly!

[@harryantino]

Don’t insult people with that silly comparison. 😂 lol

[@mikawhofan]

@@harryantino sorry😄

[@suepetersen8132]

Even after all these years this still reduces me to tears. Seduff you are a remarkable person to create this video which is perfect and symbolises the love that The Doctor and Rose had for each other. Thank you.

[@LaurenRae192]

2024 and started rewatching.. 9/10 and Rose just can’t compare. Truly “the stuff of legend” and this video is literally the best I have seen. Been coming back to it to have a good cry for like 10 years now. Can usually make it until 10 screaming at the Daleks to just take him… ugh my heart. Thank you thank you thank you for this video

[@thatrandomfreak194]

I miss the beautiful way doctor who made me feel, it's just not the same without ten/rose, I still weep now, reading fanfictions (reading the best one ever at the moment) life goes on...

[@elizabethjohnston9606]

+Whispy Wolfy What fanfic are you reading if you don't mind me asking? I have some favorites on Archive of Our Own plus I have written a few.

[@thatrandomfreak194]

+Elizabeth Johnston Ones on Wattpad, from people I follow, my username is WhoniverseFangirl :)

[@thatrandomfreak194]

+Elizabeth Johnston The best fanfiction writer is StarKidFan224 !!!

[@saphstories]

Headcanon: You ever notice that the Doctor rarely wears that blue suit, and only after Doomsday when he and Rose are separated? It's because blue is the color of mourning on Gallifrey. In the first episode of series 3, Smith and Jones, the Doctor wears the blue suit for the first time. (The events of Runaway Bride happened seconds after the Doctor and Rose's goodbye, not enough time to blink, much less process events or change clothes.) It his first proper day without his Rose, the woman that meant everything. His first proper day to mourn his loss in the way he knows how. And everyday after, whenever his grief becomes too much for him, instead of emotionally or vocally expressing it, he succumbs to the lost traditions of his people, and silently dons his blue suit, in loving memory of the Wolf that loved him more than life itself.

[@batfamiliar]

the way this vid still holds up in the year of our lord 2022, its fucking insane. and not only it holds up but is still the best doctor/rose vid out there... the sound editing alone, just wow

[@ree9573]

Still one of my favorite videos. Never fails to draw tears from my eyes and feel that heart wrenching feeling inside.

[@nicoledyer6707]

David played the Doctor too humane that his pain is not something ‘funnily tragic’ - just PURE TRADEGY RUNS IN HIS EYES AND MAKES THE DOCTOR WHO ACTUALLY HUMANE AND IMPACTFUL i really think he was the best casting and this is what nowadays superhero castings don’t have

[@chaoticblake7375]

Even The Toughest Whovans Cant Make It Through This Without Crying

[@Ary_moon]

Audrey L Same with me... Hope im not been turned into a cyber-man and I didn't even know it..

[@emilythezeldafan848]

I didn't. I do, however, feel like I may have a heart attack from feels.

[@ronstewart5945]

My heart hasn’t been broken by enough shows this week, time to add one more.

[@bigtimefans100]

I cried too much... Especially at the "I've tried so hard to tell myself that you're gone."

[@PhantomYouLoves]

This is the best Doctor and Rose video. Ever.

[@zahidekutluay]

I was listening to this clip 10 years ago. but then david is gone. And every time I listen to "my immortal", I think and cry. but I cried again because I came across this clip years later. Today 27.04.2020. Who knows when I will come back to this clip? I love you very much "doctor who" series. i love you so much 10.doc david. Endless thanks for teaching me friendship, love and sacrifice.

[@RainOnTheRooftops]

this is the best doctor and Rose video i've ever seen! it shows how much he changes when he loses Rose and how he always feels she's around the corner then he looks up and she's gone. it's beautiful! stunning! when you hear her talking about dying in battle and he's walking though all those flames and when he hears footsteps and she comes through the door, but then she just fades away! this is incredible, the first time i saw it, it made me cry but now i watch it more then three times every day.

[@ellaliem7403]

9 years later and this is one of the best Rose and Doctor videos I’ve ever seen, really woooow

[@islaythejabberwokky]

This is pure brilliance. All of this. Matching lyrics, the little tiny details in the editing, the perfectly placed voice-overs... It brought tears to my eyes and now they won't stop. This video is perfect.

[@MissinganAngle]

This needs to be shared! Oh my god, I can't stop crying. It's too beautiful and sad. What perfect timing, and the clips just work so well! 2:52 is where I keep bursting into tears. Oh god...

[@mrsiracusa12123]

Every once in a while I come back to this video and just cry at how beautiful it is.

[@ngocanhphung1899]

I love Doctor. I love Rose. I love their love. :( so sad.

[@typicalsunny1234]

Ngọc Ánh Phùng I know right

[@shadowmarvel0737]

Oh wow this is amazing the faded scenes just wow I'm speechless I really miss these two they were so special to me part of my childhood

[@andyeoli67]

Beautiful video mix with the best song ever....

[@kourtniiRAWR]

I promised myself that no matter what , I wasn't going to cry during this. I started off pretty well , but right around the 3:30 mark I burst out in tears . This is beautiful , Doctor and Rose ♥

[@jufliii]

THIS IS THE SADDEST THING I'VE EVER SEEN I'M CRYING SO HARD WYD?!

[@Maiky3]

I can't help it but I am coming back to this video again and again. It is so beautiful and the combination of text and scenes is just perfect. But I am sobbing everytime and I still watch it over and over again.

[@MeMeMcsplosion]

This is the first time I've gotten choked up about this relationship. I'm on the verge of tears right now.

[@MossyBallerina]

That's just... I mean.... every time I see this video, it makes me cry. Because everything about that video is just perfect, and, well... perfect. The clips, the music, the way you edited it all together... simply perfection. Probably the best video I've ever seen.

[@Jlynng96]

I can't count how many times I've come back and watched this video. Its pure perfection. Equal to none other.

[@blackmagic5929]

Omg. So sad, but so wonderfully beautiful!! This has to be one of the best DoctorXRose videos ive ever seen. I love how you have put the song at a different perspective. At 3:17 I almost lost it....it was like he touched her face but he wasn't there...decides to go weep in a corner.

[@thatrandomfreak194]

This has to be one of the most beautiful things ever to exist.....

[@Scaperer]

The tears didn't come until he was reliving losing her and the music climaxed. Got me right there. Great job

[@singingal17]

This video is still perfection! I remember watching this video the first time and I cried buckets!!! It is, by far, the best Ten and Rose video out there. I always watch this after the first episode with Donna. After watching this again tonight, I still cried! I’m so glad this exists! Thank you, Seduff for making this! You are brilliant!

[@SatelliteAlice]

I think that is the first fan video ever to make me cry. I am sitting here crying like a child and thinking how I need to start back at the beginning of Series 1 again because I miss them so much.

[@TheJaeTee]

I just realized that the flash back he has when he says "that's my friends" is one where she is wearing the jacket Donna is holding. You are brilliant. you are.

[@vanessaelfen_oehrchen2132]

I think this is the best Ten/Rose Video on this planet. I watch it everyday and just start to cry immediately.

[@dreamer110480]

Even 4 years later when they separate and he fade out right before he tells her how he feels make me cry every time.

[@1Lestatslover]

Thank you for sharing this wonderful video. I really don’t think The Doctor will ever get over the loss of Rose even though he did the best thing for her. I really loved their relationship. They will always be my favorite couple.

[@walkingoncandles]

I've watched this so many times and it still makes me sob...

[@MossyBallerina]

I still can't get through this video without crying. The video and the song mesh together perfectly, and it fits the pairing perfectly as well. This is one of the best videos I've ever seen on KZbin.

[@LastKupoNut]

This was fantastically done! Right clips at the right time with the right peak of music, great to hear the talking over the music and yeah... right in the feels..

[@AliceCullen12152223]

Watched this so many times now and still flood my room with tears everytime...

[@rachelroberts365]

It doesn't matter which doctor was your favorite, this is amazing.

[@withinthe3y3s]

It hurts so much yet I can't stop myself from watching it over and over again.

[@shilohws3610]

The feels :'( I dying omg ten and rose forever

[@shayleencb]

I've seen this so many times and it still gives me goose bumps... Fabulous wonderful job... The Doctor and Rose forever!

[@maria_lind9745]

Oh my god that was just beautiful.. Never though I was going to love Doctor Who so much, I watched for the first time a few months ago and here I am.

[@mbpokemonrulez]

I am currently bawling. This is so beautiful and it fits them perfectly. The VoiceOvers added an amazing amount of emotion to the overall video. I love it. Absolutely fantastic.

[@xX707Lucky7Xx]

I've never seen anything better, Im absolutly heartbroken and speechless. Best. Edit. EVER. It'll never get old.

[@maes9856]

Lovely video but please excuse me while I rip my heart out.

[@timberleesmith7021]

Saphira Elf Same af

[@greyardwhite2683]

In a way I hated that eleven didn't have such a sadness after Amy left, he just kinda went on to the next companion in one episode, without looking back. (Even though there was an undated distance of time between Amy and Clara in which he probably mourned a lot, you could never really see it onscreen.)

[@ann13nygma]

+Greyard white There was a bit of time cause he lived on that cloud in Victorian England for quite a while judging by how the Paternoster Gang were worried about him. It was covered a bit in the Christmas Episode with Clara.

[@greyardwhite2683]

Annie Brewer I know, but with Tennant it was a very big theme throughout his time, while with Smith it wasn't, which kinda annoys me.

[@ann13nygma]

+Greyard white Yeah they barely mentioned in with Eleven, and then it was like "oh, I've got a mystery girl" and he was off and running. Nothing like Ten handled it at all.

[@bclmtaylor]

Well he did isolate himself from the world for 1000 years alone in the tardis. I think that counts

[@ladycopine]

Yeah but he was in love with Rose... Plus the show runner changed and looks like Moffat doesn't like this kind of stuff... that's why I always say that S1-4 had the more heart and emotion.

[@guacamole963]

This is no doubt my favorite Rose and Doctor video. It's so sad and happy at the same time.

[@QueerMycelium]

I have come back to watch this in the past 3 years at least 100 times. I sob every time. Good work.

[@chibitsukihoshi]

created and this...THIS was GORGEOUS! Twisted me heart right up, but it was done so beautifully. Besides using scenes that many usually don't, the transitions were quite smooth and the whole video was absolutely touching! I have never seen a video that has gotten such a reaction from me and that's saying something because there are a lot of wonderfully creative people here. I could go on and on, but then I'd be quoting a thesaurus for how wonderfully magnificent this video was!

[@MossyBallerina]

Watching this again I'm really struck at how perfect this song is for the Doctor and Rose. Before this, I never really paid much attention to the lyrics, but they're just absolutely perfect.

[@CaitlynAnneReads]

Wow. This video has been etched into my mind for 9 years! I have been hunting it down for so long. Crying.

[@EmilyRamirez]

This remains my favorite video of the Doctor & Rose. I've seen many videos but none are as good as this one!

[@skallywalla]

This video is unbelievable. Heart-breaking, raw, painful, gorgeous and just - epic. The energy behind it, the cuts to the music, the overlay of the audio in all the right places - the way it ebbs and flows to the words and movement of the music - there are no words. Probably the BEST video I have ever seen in any fandom. Ever. You deserved every award you received and probably some of the ones you didn't receive. Just stunning.

[@Katey2004]

That has got to be the most brilliant Doctor, Rose video I've ever seen. It really hurt to watch that it was so sad. I'm adding it to my favorites.

[@princeeverlove]

THE BEST SONG OF THE EARLY MILLINIEUM...AND THE BEST DR.WHO OF THE SAME ERA...HEARTBREAKING

[@xxJaneAustenJunkiexx]

This video gets me every time. I've probably seen it about ten times since you uploaded it and it always gives me hard-core feels. Absolutely and tragically beautiful.

[@Rapunzzel07]

Oh wow. This is an absolutely beautiful compilation- thank you, seduff. Normally I steer clear of "music videos" with cut scenes from a favorite TV show, but this was absolute brilliance. Tears :'(

[@courtneywuerz4374]

I got big goosebumps when he was screaming 'DO IT! JUST DO IT!'. Omg, this is so sad I can't even cry. :( Awesome video.

[@sender2receiver]

I'm in public so I'm refraining from bawling my eyes out. That was the most BEAUTIFUL thing I've ever seen in my entire life!!

[@CorinneStephens]

Oh my god. Beautiful song. Beautiful editing. Beautiful couple. Made me cry shamelessly.

[@TheJaeTee]

I love how you ended it with "oh the stuff of legend." They really are aren't they. The Doctor and Rose. This is my favorite video of yours. Leaves me utterly speachless. I don't know the words to describe the way I feel about this video. You are brilliant. Thank you for this.

[@MossyBallerina]

God, this video is just perfect. The mix of the song and the audio from the show, the way the clips are put together, the song in general... everything. Heartbreaking, but beautiful and amazing.

[@RedHeadLuvGoddess]

I will never not love these two with all the love that my wee, one human heart can hold. Brilliant editing as always. Loved it in HD, loved it in non-HD. Just love it.

[@troybolton14]

this has always been one of my favorite songs ever i lost it at the bridge THIS COMPLETELY BROKE MY HEART

[@The_Eyes_Have_It]

I cry every time. Beautiful piece of work, and a powerful tribute as always.

[@zacandsabby]

Every time I watch this. I get goosebumps and I end up crying my eyes out. It's so beautiful yet...it hurts too much.

[@oliviak1992]

Pretty sure I comment on this every time I watch it. I was at work the other day, and this song came on the radio. Oh shit. I nearly burst into tears.

[@caitrionamurp]

I don't know why I keep putting myself through this heartache. It's just so fricking amazing!!!!!! I'm just going to go weep in a corner now...

[@angelaislove]

Gah. I lose it at her tearful "I love you." Every time. I love that Nine is included in this. Nine was so great, I'm not sure he gets enough credit.

[@mypassionsdreams]

I don't think I can find the words to describe what I'm feeling after watching your video. Suffice to say I'm crying as I'm writing this. I loved The Doctor and Rose so much. So I'll just say simply and completely...FANTASTIC!!!!!

[@TARDISstowaway]

Painful and beautiful. This is the story of the love and loss of the Doctor and Rose, powerfully put together. The clip of the Doctor begging the Dalek to kill him fit really well and hurt like a stab to the heart.

[@KobayashiMaru89]

I'm crying right now...this is so emotionally and beautifully done! Brilliant job!!

[@ElevenMisrule]

Even after all these years - this is still a masterpiece of video editing!

[@PopPrincess7717]

I have never shipped a couple so much until I started watching this show! My heart is now broken after watching this!!

[@singtoangels]

That song is one of the most overused on the planet. That said, the universe must not be tired of it yet because it was the most PERFECT song to use for them. The repeated references to time that I must have just forgotten. Not only that, but the timing and filters were absolutely brilliant. Well done.

[@evezzie]

I think this is the most i've ever cried at anything Doctor Who related, and that is saying something. Everyone wants to be the Doctor and travelw ith him but who could really take all that heartbreak...Love this :)

[@MossyBallerina]

This is without a doubt one of the best fanvids I've ever seen. The editing is brilliant, the song is perfect, and all of it just makes e want to cry, but it's still beautiful. Just... wow.

[@risa-chan3814]

Ugh why do I keep replaying this??? LOVE THIS SONG AND ROSE AND THE DOCTOR FOREVER!!

[@ClaireFox3583]

See, whenever I just want to be in massive emotional pain and cry 10 million rivers, I just come here and watch this video. The bit when he screams at the Dalek to kill him gets me EVERY FUCKING TIME. Ugh. This is so well done it literally hurts.

[@yaten0503]

Oh gosh. Hat vid is perfectly made and absolutly moving. Timing, music and clips are perfect. One oft my absolute favourites. Thank you so much for creating this! I could watch it again and again.

[@yaten0503]

yaten0503 forgot to mention hat it also brought me to tears. *sobs* breathtaking

[@theyseeus]

Seriously, how can someone NOT adore this video? BRB my crys.

[@madeleinejohansen5073]

Oh. My. Word. This is one of the best videos I have ever seen. It is up there with "Tell Her Something - Doctor and Rose" search that, people. I don't know which is better.

[@meggers461]

I never get tired of this video. you did an amazing job

[@Vampirecutie447]

Why can't Rose just come back? I miss her and the doctor so much. This actually made me cry, like the full on tears streaming down my face while I sob uncontrollably type of cry.

[@Marisha1999]

This is one of the best edits to Doctor/Rose . The song is so emotional. Can't get over watching it.

[@batking4342]

This totally describes rose and doctor

[@jennyxvastra5650]

This is perfect... It made me cry so much... Thanks for it anyways... This is like my OTP in Doctor Who and gosh, you wouldn't believe how much I weeped...

[@snurfbee58]

One of my favorite songs and my favorite Dr Who characters. Brilliant! The Doctor and Rose will always be the ultimate relationship in the series.

[@weareMJandR]

This is gorgeous. Absolutely gorgeous. I'm the type who normally just lurks on people's videos (partly, because I share this account with friends), but this was too well done to go without comment. I enjoy watching fanMVs, but almost never do I see something this well done. Excellent song choice, the clips fit the lyrics perfectly, the editing was practically flawless, and the choice and incorporation of dialogue was better than I've ever seen done. Excellent work. ~J (off to cry now...)

[@SapphireSparrowFilms]

I can't believe it's been nearly 10 years since this video was made. I remember adoring it as a young teenager, and now I'm a proper adult and I still love it.

[@salsaru85]

wow. this video makes me fall in actual love with david tennant. He and billie are such great actors, that chemistry will never be matched on doctor who

[@maggielovesrelientk]

My best friend, a fellow Whovian, sent me this video. I watched it... the song is perfect (I know every word anyway)... to say I cried would be an understatement. Tears are still running down my face. I'm sobbing. Amazing job, you captured the pain of their separation perfectly... :'( ♥

[@raupileincb]

Oh my I have really no idea how many times I have watched it but I almost have to cry!! It´s so touching and so well chosen!! Thank you sooo much for making & shairing this video!!!!

[@SpeedosAndTheGun]

I don’t think the show will ever top the rose & 10th dr era