The Horrific Murder of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes [True Crime Documentary]

[@strangecreature3793]

Hearing that little boy cry out that nobody loved him absolutely broke me

[@ThePinsay]

💔

[@adamlenham4359]

Unbelievably sad. Luckily life has a way of sorting things out, I pray his parents meet their justice one day

[@lanagroves9480]

nobody will feed him was also heartbreaking 💔

[@maxine3587]

Me too. I avoided listening to it for ages, knowing it would be sad, but when I did listen, it was worse than i could ever imagine.

[@shaystarz1]

The good thing about this case as horrible as it is, is that Arthur isn’t suffering anymore by them two wicked monsters (there’s no other word better to describe Thomas hughes and Emma Tustin)

[@FrankieBhoy72]

I'm a fully grown hairy arsed man.. but wn that little boy cried no-one loves me.. I burst into tears. Absolutely disgusting case... love the channel.

[@ThePinsay]

💔

[@aryaramezanipour9511]

first time i started crying in a true crime case

[@chrismeister77]

Absolutely awful isn't it? Set me off again with the football crowd singing "Arthur we love you" - im an ice block but absolutely finished me off

[@Z3roX-56k]

Same here, so sad.

[@helenhellsbells3170]

❤ it's heart breaking x

[@SerenDipity64711]

To walk past Arthur, with McDonalds and ice creams is a whole other level of evil. I just can't imagine how they could do that. What horrific humans they are.

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@amandaanscombe1813]

You make sure your kids are fed before yourself. Evil people, won't say parents cos they don't deserve to be called that

[@theaveragejosie2638]

Exactly....the starving child smelled McDonald's and did not get a thing...

[@danmac73]

Destroying his beloved possessions in front of him too , how totally cruel and heartless 😞😢

[@SerenDipity64711]

@@danmac73 I know..that poor child must have felt totally heartbroken..

[@racheledwards2352]

Child abusers are a particularly disgusting bunch. I cannot understand how anyone could abuse a child.

[@Rizzawriter]

The very thought of it just baffles me. My son is the best thing in my life.

[@Valentynekittylover23]

once you lay your hands on your child you automatically forfeit your rights as a "parent"

[@P4melaMasters]

I cannot understand it either until I met someone on POF who had rped a 13 year old girl. I obviously didn't know this when I started dating him..but all I can say is that these people are a mix of; Entitlement - kid is there to serve their needs so benefit money, gifts are taken. Resentment - Having kids for money or to keep a partner breeds resentment for the kid. They start seeing the kid as an inconvenience. This is where they manage to start dehumanising. Rather like the nazis did. Reinforcement and Abuse cycle - So now the kid might play up or act odd (justifiably) so this is where the spiral occurs. Punished and abused, the perpetrator(s) felt justified in their abuse. Blinded because they dehumanised the victim so now they see him or her as an enemy. It's how it happens sadly..the vile man that I met simply told me over drinks what he'd done. I was sickened. Very dangerous individual and so I ran as fast and blocked. Please be careful out there. These monsters are everywhere

[@shaystarz1]

@@P4melaMasters that’s such a horrible story love good for you for running for the hills I’d have done the same

[@honeyypainn]

My babies aren’t babies anymore, they are 17 and almost 22 and here I’ve been crying because my oldest got her own apartment and stuff (we didn’t make her leave, it was her choice) and she’s done so amazing especially in this shitty economy with minimal help from her dad and I - crying because even at 21 years of age, I was NOT ready for her to move out and it came so quickly! I’ve cried many times about it and it’s been almost a year and I’m still not used to it. That is how a true mother and father are supposed to feel. How on earth do these monsters do it?! I COULD NEVER 😭😭😭

[@nofacekilluh]

Omg that "no one loves me" put a lump in my throat and covered me in total sadness. That sweet little boy didn't deserve that, how tragic.

[@rhanBo]

Right?! I just wanna wrap my arms around him and say “you are loved. Im sorry so many people failed you”

[@dandugan812]

I'm a grown man and don't really get emotional but when I heard that little boy cry out that nobody loves him I broke down. I'm a single father of a 3 yr old little oy and I could never imagine doing anything to harm a hair on his head. RIP little guy 💔

[@relaxandunwind564]

I literally threw up. This baby calling like that is one of the worst things I’ve ever heard

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@Checker222]

That means you are a good person, and if there is such a thing as a soul- that you have a good one.

[@bellababy50505]

@@relaxandunwind564i also threw up i literally cannot cope

[@tuppy]

My little boys are both big men now and I still can't stand them to get hurt in any way.. Enjoy your darling little three year old.

[@cherryhazard8002]

I wanted you to cover this case for so long, EVERYONE failed this little boy.

[@ThePinsay]

💔

[@peterdonnelly6804]

Except BOTH sets of grandparents

[@aldorfc220]

Sadly we are failing right now think of many kids going to bed hungry right now, been abused, fear for there life's when they should feel save in there homes, sadly there's many Arthur's out there and nothing has changed since baby p 😢

[@marilynwillett804]

@@aldorfc220 SINCE BABY P?

[@cigaretteforamother]

Poor Arthur deserved a million times better than this. Thomas Hughes may not have physically killed that little boy, but he's every single bit as guilty as Emma Tustin. How you can let someone you've known just months turn you against your own child, who you've known and should have loved, for over 6 years is utterly unfathomable.

[@barbaracarmichiel7369]

This child's cry ripped my heart out. You did a wonderful job of telling the painful truth about Arthur's murder. R.I.P

[@ThePinsay]

💔

[@mrCcallan]

This channel doesn’t get the recognition it deserves, very rarely is there any other channel that covers content so in depth and unflinching while still maintaining respect for the victims and occasionally voicing how we all feel about these “humans”. Brilliant as always thank you for all your hard work

[@brendandarkside1207]

We need to get to 100k ffs

[@emo_penguin420]

Love EAU ❤❤ He's an incredibly conscious and compassionate storyteller, and I appreciate him SO much! It's nice to be reminded that there are caring and loving people still left in the world.

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

❤❤

[@mandyjjonesj5541]

agreed ! I'm a new follower to this channel. and staying he covered this story extremely well. in all parts

[@Ann-qf5vk]

👍👍👍

[@Lissybird211]

The recording of this poor angel limping trying to pick up the pillow and duvet along with him crying hurt my heart and soul. They are pure evil monsters. I will say I love you, Arthur every day from now on.

[@tuppy]

and he was limping ... it's so sad ... I don't understand what is wrong with some human beings. Poor little boy. I need a break from the video I can't stop crying

[@jessicaruth5259]

Hearing the recordings of this baby crying “no one loves me, no one’s gonna feed me” literally ripped my heart to shreds. How could they listen to that and not want to love and protect him. My heart breaks for this baby. I pray his grandparents find peace in this tragedy and I pray this baby has all the love and food he could possibly want in paradise.

[@TM-fx2iq]

That poor child, he desperately needed someone to help him. Our world failed him.

[@TransitionedToAShark]

We are all gonna face the same fate very soon. There is no world for us

[@kimmymegs]

Hid parents failed him first!

[@Ann-qf5vk]

It did 😪😪😪

[@afterhourscinema782]

It's TRULY incredible how worthless Social services are. Like...they couldnt be more incompetent if they tried

[@ItzAprilLOL]

They take kids from loving homes, and leave ones in abusive homes. They have it so backwards it's sick.

[@NoBootyBeauty]

They try their HARDEST to be incompetent, I'm absolutely sure of it!

[@TheBASS2DARK187]

Just like the government no one ever gets held accountable

[@idontlikehavingnumbersinmyname]

CPS failed my family too. They're so incompetent.

[@anotherdimension7608]

@@ItzAprilLOL no one takes kids from "loving homes". Removing child is last resort. It it happens there are reasons, you're a typical ignorant

[@sarahlocke3823]

I don't think I'll live a day of my life without hearing this beautiful little boy crying out that no one loves him. It will haunt me. That precious little boy.....just brings me to tears. Very literally crying while watching this horror story unravel

[@SerenDipity64711]

me too Sarah. And at the end with the football crowd..poor little Arthur he was such a shining light and am sure, with the love of his family, could have overcome many of his issues and psychological trauma those two inflicted upon him.

[@Bambimonroe8]

I was trying to be strong for little Arthur watching this but the singing from the football crowd we love you Arthur destroyed me. Poor little soul. Thank you for once again a thoroughly respectful video, you are becoming my favourite crime KZbin channel for your dedication to honouring the victims

[@TheMinni70]

This broke my heart into a million pieces, poor sweet little boy . Thank you for bringing arthurs story so full of respect and love for him ❤

[@ThePinsay]

Same 😢💔

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@anitaford4138]

OMG you covered this case so beautifully!! I've heard this story before, but not arranged and narrated as well as you have!! Your warmth and empathy for Arthur is remarkably expressed with true compassion. The bonus of the making of this video, which is not as great by others, is your concern for your audience. No one does that better than you!! Thank you!! ❤❤ I cried the first time when I heard this story before, but I never heard the audio of Arthur's desperate pleas!! How can a father's heart love and then be manipulated to despise so rapidly?!! Arthur's life is the perfect example that life is so not fair!! Again, many thanks for the extraordinary heart and soul video!!! ❤❤❤❤❤

[@ThePinsay]

I'm crying 😢 💔

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@RhiannaC3]

I completely agree. Such a horrific case, it's hard to say it was covered "well"- but I know what you mean. This is done with grace and tact. Love this channel. ❤

[@colleenhanna5383]

That's a beautiful comment

[@melissalongley911]

Sad thing is if Arthur was left in the care of his grandparents he would have been alive and thriving,poor little boy, Sociopathic Narcissists are everywhere,RIP sweet boy

[@virgo1986ful]

If Arthur was sent to grandparent when Emma would not have he in her house and she would not have to abuse him

[@bujfvjg7222]

And if she hasn't got it up the duff in the first place....

[@shivalishankersharma1562]

Hearing “no one loves me” from that baby send needles into my heart. I have a girl around the same age as Arthur. She is the reason I live each day. I have bipolar disorder so I went through hell during the post partum. My daughter is a blessing to me. This boy was so sweet. I would have loved a little sweet boy like him as a son. These monsters don’t know the value of children. Absolutely disgusting.

[@patsyslade6076]

The audio broke me this case is absolutely horrific. 😢

[@chrismeister77]

The way you tell these stories with such a level of respect to the victim is amazing, it's so important these stories are told so they are remembered and learned from but in the right way

[@talpark8796]

'not sure that I can do this one again. that poor boy's 'voice of despair' has stuck with me for life, from the first time that I heard it. tyvm for another upload (btw: forced prolonged standing causes extreme swelling of the joints, which leads to excruciating joint pain. it's no wonder that he could barely stand after 'sleeping'.)

[@ThePinsay]

💔

[@MsPopeye65]

Absolutely heartbreaking... The level of depravity and wickedness displayed by these two monsters defies belief..... Thank you for giving Arthur a voice... and sharing the story of his life in the manner of detail and respect he desperately deserves..... RIP Arthur..You are loved❤

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@NemesisBeX]

This little boy crying will haunt me forever, its heartbreaking. I really hope that when she has served her time, on her final day, someone takes her out. No freedom for child killers. Absolute monsters! RIP little Arthur, little angel 🙏❤

[@kimmyfreak200]

and the video of him in the living room wobbling trying to stand...reminds me of adrian jones too.... the word Evil doesn't even begin to describe these type of acts...i don't even know WHAT to call it

[@suemcgregor9248]

I hope those inmates are singing "We Love You Arthur" every night at lights out for years and years and years. Rest in Love, little Arthur ❤❤

[@scorpianna420]

Heartbreaking 💔 Hearing him just makes me want to pick him up, hug him tight and never let go. I would tell him how much he is loved 😢❤ How could they do this?!?! 😡 Infuriating!! Sickening!!

[@shaystarz1]

That chant by Birmingham city football fans near the end of the video is honestly a beautiful tribute to a very special little man 🩵

[@HeyDerr-h7u]

I was emotionally and mentally abused during quarantine…but I am a 32 year old woman. I cannot imagine this sweet little innocent boy…the despair he felt…him hobbling in that clip. My heart. I can’t stop sobbing. I promised myself that when I had a child, they would never go through the abuse I had to endure during quarantine. I had no job or money because of a chronic illness that left me in daily pain, and because of that, I was an easy target for my mom. I had been through things with her before when I was a child, but 2020 was unimaginable for me. I wanted to commit every single day. If I felt so alone, I can’t even imagine what this poor baby felt. Now I’m married with a 1 year old. My daughter is my life, my breath, my reason, my everything. I can’t imagine her going through this or not loving her, or simply not feeding her. I’m so so sorry, Arthur. I wish I could have held you and helped you feel love from a maternal figure. Given you all the McDonalds you wanted, given you all the cool jerseys and teddy bears you wanted. Given you a comfortable bed to sleep in, a warm and welcoming bedroom, hot baths at night with plenty of bubbles and big meals morning, afternoon, and night with ice cream every day for dessert if that’s what you wanted. I’ll never forget this case. I’ll never forget you, Arthur. I’m so sorry sweet boy. 😢😢

[@marilynwillett804]

too bad this isnt about you huh

[@bellababy50505]

@@marilynwillett804i know wtf. i’ve suffered sexual, physical mental and emotional abuse and my ex is in prison for it and not once did i watch this and think of me. what a bizarre comment

[@bellababy50505]

this is not about you for fuck sake

[@corynnahardy3099]

I've been crying my way through this entire video. I also just went and hugged my son and told him how much his Mama and Dada love him as he sleeps soundly in his bed. Rest in peace now, Little Arthur, I am so sorry for the pain that was inflicted upon you.

[@Xavierschanclas]

When you said the inmates put salt in her food just like she did to poor this poor baby …. That felt good in my soul knowing she’s getting what she gave … I don’t believe in death penalty but adults who hurt kids make me reconsider that position

[@maury0009]

My heart weeps for Arthur and the unfathomable torment he bore. Words fail to capture the depth of sorrow and anguish I feel for him. May he find solace in eternal rest.

[@sbalsamo410]

I’ve heard of this story before but not what happened with his mother. As always, you bring these reports to us in a dignified way. That doesn’t make it any less horrific. And the boy’s grandparents seemed lovely. 😢

[@tattooedleopard9897]

Hearing that poor baby say nobody loves me, nobody will feed me.. amd watching him struggle just to stand... this broke me. And I watch a lot of these cases. I would have loved that little boy back to a truly happy little dude. Rip little one. Ur safe now.

[@chrislidbury8159]

So sad. I watch this video purely to never forget Arthur Hughes. His tragic chase is reason enough to never go into lockdown again.

[@pinkroxysouthmead]

The recordings of him are absolutely heartbreaking poor little boy :(

[@dream__soda7900]

Seeing and hearing him cry makes me wanna tear down doors to make sure he’s okay. My heart is broken. 💔

[@bee1715]

I wish I could have just swooped in and saved this little boy 😢💔 you covered the case, as always, with such compassion. Thank you for always focusing on the victims. I cannot ever get my head around people hurting children 😔😔💔

[@dougbritton3239]

How come no neighbours ever heard the cries of help from this little boy ??? Are they all deaf on that street??? Remember this was in lockdown when you could hear a bird fart on our street!!! She will not be treated as kind in prison for her behaviour towards any of the children under her care inc. her own.

[@shaystarz1]

Even I asked that question and why didn’t tustins neighbors ring social services or the police just because it’s not happening in your home doesn’t mean it’s not your business but when a child is in distress surely you’d ring the police or social services not ignore a child’s cry for help

[@bellababy50505]

@@shaystarz1her neighbours did ring social services

[@shaystarz1]

@@bellababy50505 makes me wonder why they didn’t get believed

[@bellababy50505]

@@shaystarz1 it’s not that they didn’t get believed - ss are lazy and well known for targeting the wrong families

[@Nous520]

During covid people became extremely selfish and self preservationist. Someone who might’ve cared before wouldn’t have cared one bit.

[@ezrastardust3124]

That audio was thoroughly haunting

[@lindsandkev]

That Emma just looks pure evil 😢

[@nsoul4296]

Sick sadist psychopaths, this was horrific and i am beyond upset by this.

[@inquiringminds6633]

It is so surreal listening to stories like this because you just can't imagine anybody could be so evil towards a child, never mind their own father! She is evil, but he is more of a coward.

[@patriciacook3981]

Children are our gifts from God, I'm a divorced Mom with a 17 year old autistic son, I also have a 27 year old daughter who died from fentanyl poisoning and I'm still distraught over it

[@Veronica-qz7ld]

💞🙏✨

[@furball192]

Thank you for this video, little Arthur deserves for his story to be told

[@elainetirrell1082]

I have heard of this case before, both you and Emma Kenny did Arthur justice 💗 RIP little man 💔❤

[@AllTheCritters]

I had heard of this case before and watched other videos on it, but the way you presented it was quite different. Your analysis was spot on and heart-rending. You gave that poor child a voice. 💔

[@Kris.with.a.K]

Just saw that you uploaded. I got through the intro to 2:16 and I'm already heartbroken and thoroughly pissed off. Thank you for the excellent presentations you produce while defending these innocent souls so as they won't be forgotten. And, you know I LOVE your commentary, especially when it's snarky! Please take care of your mental well being. Now, on to watching the rest of the upload. Much love to you, EAU! ❤❤❤❤❤

[@SewLeigh]

Rarely had a KZbin video me in so much tears. Rest in Paradise little Arthur. Evil Among Us: Love from South Africa and Well done on another great video. I always look forward to them. Thank you for bringing more light to the poor victims

[@anja2716]

To all inmates on her block, fill ya' boots ladies...please.

[@Faizasmith-pj4dz]

I read that they were force feeding her salt

[@nicolataylor8135]

​@@Faizasmith-pj4dzfingers crossed

[@LeandieWilliams]

Thank you so much for telling his story. After 17 mins, I heeded your advice, what I had heard already broke me, and I have never been fortunate enough to be a mom. The cruelty to innocent children bewilders me, these monsters doing this, are everywhere😢

[@stephenbain389]

Watching this now. It sounds like the grandparents did everything they could to save the poor little boy.

[@Rockchick1358]

Aside from physically kidnapping., which I have no doubt those pieces of shit baby makers, they aren't parents. They really did everything they could. The system failed this angel.

[@InvisibleVicky]

They should never get out. Ever

[@jessicawinter2938]

No. They shouldn’t. And they should never give them food and only give them salt.

[@jwithington9347]

I feel this boy was failed on so many levels. For one the monsters who killed him, the social services, the police and even his mother for behaving in a way that led him to being in the custody of his dad

[@queenbeegaming8231]

I agree!This boy was failed by so many people,they will have to live with this for the rest of their lives!

[@andreagibbs419]

This little boy broke my heart. Those two should never see the light of day!! I will never Forget you Arthur. ❤ I love you Arthur ❤️. The Angels are with you now and all their love, and you will never be alone 😇.❤❤❤

[@heyimduffy]

I know it's cropped in a lot of the media, but there's a longer version of the 'no one's gonna feed me' recording, and one of Emma's children says ''Let me give you a cuddle.'' Keep in mind that at this age, empathy isn't even properly developed, and yet a young child had far more empathy for this boy than these two evil bastards ever did.

[@Lovespace2489]

Every time I hear that poor little boy cry out it bring me to tears. Poor baby, he deserved so much better.

[@AHart83]

I am from across the pond and I just found your channel! I have never heard of this case. This case is despicable as are these "monsters" or whatever you want to call them. I call them garbage human beings; However, I still think calling them that, is extremely generous!! 🤮 Also, when his favorite football team honored Arthur like they do at their home games.. it gave me chills and tears in my eyes! Absolutely incredible!!!😭💔🩵 Bless your sweet heart, Arthur! Rest in peace sweet, sweet, boy!😘😇🩵

[@April-kk6bv]

I love what you do. I gave you a thumbs up and a comment. But I only got as far as this little boy's palpable pain when he was crying out that no one loves him. I don't think I'll ever unhear that😭

[@leysanderson]

I'll never understand how people can hurt children. That poor little boy, my heart breaks for all of those let down by everyone who sole job it is to keep them safe and loved.

[@relaxandunwind564]

I can’t imagine how Blake felt hearing his nephew yell for him like that in the video

[@SerenDipity64711]

Can you imagine the rage and frustration he lives with..how would you ever come to terms with it.

[@relaxandunwind564]

@@SerenDipity64711 If my niece died calling for me like that and I found out on video later I think I’d actually die

[@relaxandunwind564]

@@SerenDipity64711 just thinking of how Blake must have been hearing that is like physically painful for me and it has nothing to do with me, oh my god that poor man

[@SerenDipity64711]

@@relaxandunwind564 I know. The guilt at not being able to save him. Poor Blake I really hope he has had support with this.

[@richsuykerbuyk7983]

Oh my god, little Arthur Labinjo-Hughes. Put me in a room with Thomas and Emma, just give me 5 minutes. No weapons, no need.

[@frobbsy27]

Knowing that little boy truly felt nobody loved him as he was starving broke me😭😭

[@katieparsons1629]

Was going to bed, no way could I now. This is absolutely HEARTBREAKING I can't stop crying, wtf is wrong with people???? This world gets worse and worse, IT COSTS NOTHING TO BE KIND. You as always did such an amazing job with this. Your talent for this goes through the roof, mind blowing your such a wonderful person the way you take up and speak for the victims is something I could listen to all day. Along with your voice and accent icing on the cake! Thank you my friend for all your hard work 🙏 ❤️

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@aishalea7508]

god how on earth is any human able to be so cruel to a child. sadly it seems way too common, and what terrifies me is we only hear the worst of cases resulting in death, the number of cases close or equal to this level of inhumanity and cruelty that "fly under the radar" is absolutely heart breaking knowing children are living in such environments, when there are so many ppl who would adore protect and love them :(

[@finianmurphy88]

There are no words. As a dad, even as a human, this has broken my heart. They were supposed to mind him, keep him safe. Such a sweet looking little boy, all he wanted was comfort. I just can’t comprehend it. Going to give my boys an extra long hug before bed tonight. 😔

[@worsethanjoerogan8061]

This case makes my blood boil.

[@paulineerwin7685]

Such a horrific and extremely sad story - but thankyou for sharing Arthur’s tale . It was so well done , thorough in every aspect…and with the depth of empathy and love , that poor Arthur didn’t get to experience in life . Fly high Arthur 🕊️ xx

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@xminireaper]

Its disgusting to see a fully grown women try to demonize a 6 year old child. And Thomas may be worse that her since it was his own child.

[@PaulGallegos07]

No more pain,rip little guy

[@rob9609]

I was also wondering when you were going to cover this. Bravo man. You did a great job!

[@SerenDipity64711]

Little Arthur Labinjo-Hughes' case will haunt me forever. The authorities meant to protect children needs a massive overhaul in training to spot manipulation by caregivers. There were so many red flags and missed opportunities to save him. Arthur's Grandmother, on his natural mother's side, had recordings of Arthur explaining what was happening in that house and photographs of injuries, yet even that wasn't enough for him to be removed from those dreadful people. I despair hearing the details of the cruelty Arthur was subjected to. Bless that little boy's heart he was telling people what was happening very clearly yet was forced to go back to them. Lockdown was the final straw. That poor little boy.

[@aaabucus3104]

Most of these stories I've heard before but when you tell these stories I can't help but not to tear up you have a particular way of telling stories that are very compelling it's almost as if I can feel the tragedy and pain through your voice thank you for not letting these horrible stories be forgotten

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@CoExist64]

This is horrible! That poor, sweet little boy-omg, what evil people they are. How could anyone harm a child, anyone’s child? This is disturbing, but people need to be made aware of what’s going on in this world. May you rest in peace little Arthur, you deserved MUCH better. So very sad

[@baribari9014]

If it were my son he wouldn't be in that predicament cuz their ain't no piece of a*s worth my kids. Unbelievable how some parents love and then hate their children over a piece of a*s or anything else for that matter. Hearing that little angel cry out and seeing him in the video broke my heart. He obviously had grandparents that loved him dearly and I'm 100% positive they would have taken him. Rest in peace little man👼👼

[@peterdonnelly6804]

In the judge's summing up he said they neglected Arthur because it suited them not to look after him. Well I think that is wrong, These pair actually went out of their way to torture Arthur to the point that if the same EFFORTS were channelled into his care he would actually be thriving. This was much much more than neglect it was proactive effort to to abuse him and to keep records of it for their own perverse pleasure 😢 R.I.P ARTHUR

[@RhonaMartin-j4t]

This was so, SO close to my home. I cannot believe neighbours didn’t hear anything. The fact that apparently no one knew. Except his grandma. So many injustices 💔

[@kathleendobens6648]

No way. That must be eve more sickening knowing it happened around you.

[@jaimebaker8592]

I hope Arthur knows now that he was loved 😢 not by those evil monster but by many

[@mekahayla]

failed by his own father, social services, and law enforcement. this case is heartbreaking.

[@whosemansisthis]

This one was a really hard watch. The sheer amount of torture that this poor little boy was subjected to is absolutely heart-wrenching.

[@MaryDoyle-xl2ri]

😢😢😢❤️❤️

[@kylepressonsk8]

I’ve seen everything imaginable when it comes to graphic and violent content on the internet….. but when I heard that poor innocent child cry out “No one loves me” brought chills up my spine and am in physical tears typing this up. That was the hardest thing I’ve ever heard in my entire life. I just wanna hug that poor little boy and tell him “I love you” as if he were my own. I’m truly torn by this and Hope these sick monsters who did this to him will rot and suffer the rest of their lives. Rip little Arthur, we hear you buddy and WE love you ❤

[@robertpigott5312]

At the time Arthur needed help, no one could find time to help him. Then after he died, everyone spent so much time to mourn him. What's wrong with this picture?

[@Missy-tt6mg]

This case truly haunts me.🥺 To hear his cries is hurtful and upsetting😡. I have 2 boys myself, 26 and 18 and getting up and cooking for them brings me so much joy, so to hear that a child was starved by those who are supposed to provide for him, really really angers me. As for the spineless father, I have no words!! What kind of MAN allows someone to abuse his child like this?! He doesn't deserve his gender.....pansy!

[@MichaelGeorge161]

We need to get to the bottom as to how these evil likeminded couples manage to meet. As much as I hate to say it, this will not be the last story like this.

[@ThePinsay]

Exactly! Terrifying! Such evil.💔

[@MichaelGeorge161]

@@ThePinsay There are millions of people in the UK, how these evil people manage to navigate to each other is shocking. I think the logistics of this navigation is more terrifying than the evil acts they end up committing.

[@ASMR-Arboretum]

Well you are attached to people who are like yourself. It's not exactly hard to figure out how 2 evil people end up together.

[@MichaelGeorge161]

@@ASMR-Arboretum It's very hard, how do evil people interact differently to 'normal' people?

[@SydneyBooksMusic]

This case has haunted me since I first heard it years ago. But I must say your take on it is tragically brilliant. You told little Arthur’s story with great detail, poise and strength. Take care of yourself. These cases wear on a kind soul.

[@InvisibleVicky]

I wish I could have rescued him. I would have loved him. Taken care of him and made him feel safe. I am heart broken

[@kathleenwykle736]

So very sad 😢, rest with the Angel's Arthur

[@colleenhanna5383]

Im new to your channel this is so well done im blown away ....what a heartbreaking story 💔 you did that precious little boy justice fabulous job 💙

[@sarahr9894]

I wish Arthur knew a stadium of people would chant about how much they loved him. I wish he knew people around the world loved him. I wish he didn't die feeling alone.

[@captnghosteyes]

I’m sitting here with my lips quivering, as a mom to a six y/o and hearing Arthur crying out NO ONE LOVES ME, just broke me… REST IN POWER ARTHUR! ❤👼🏻❤

[@SHADOWWESKER1]

From the cases you have covered this is up there with one of the hardest to watch, I remember this case but I was unaware of the horror these two caused even prison isn’t a good enough place for them

[@racheledwards3651]

This is awful !! No S*X or relationship is worth turning on ur child. If he truly loved his son it wouldn't have happened. No love their pal

[@alexandercruttenden4401]

I haven't even watched this video yet (I'm about to) but this is a horrific crime. I remember hearing about it just after the case concluded. Absolutely evil pair. Can only imagine what it was like for Arthur going through this. I know you've done this justice EAU. Seen all your other videos. Your truly amazing.

[@dawnevans5755]

I have family living in Birmingham England, I watched this with my heart in hand, I was broken by this. Thankyou BIRMINGHAM for the song we love you Arthur , we here in Canada love you to xxx

[@jayanouni]

If they didn’t want him then why didn’t they leave him with the grandparents?

[@jannewton5951]

they never leave them with loving relatives....??

[@JohntheLNERP2]

The thing that sickens me about this case the most is not what happened to poor little Arthur but instead is how they gave Tustin a nice comfy cell that looks more like a collage dorm room just Google Emma Tustin's prison cell and you'll see what I mean it's disgusting that they gave her such a cell

[@Creeper-X-YT]

This is making my blood boil so much much and I'm so much crying my eyes out watching this😢😢 I need a hug, poor little souls. Rip Arthur.😢😢 Anyway great video and fantastic job on the editing and scripting!

[@jamesbird4956]

Hello mate you cover some of the most Hart breaking crimes it sad to know that these sort of things happen 😢 💔

[@LexyLiscious]

Why wasn’t he helped?! Why didn’t anyone do anything?! The clip of him hobbling just absolutely disturbed me. It’s devastating. Rest in peace sweetheart 💙

[@ColonelBased]

I recently gave birth to my own little boy called Arthur. This breaks my heart, especially as he shared the same name as my boy. May his sweet little soul rest in peace 😞