The Kulture Study: ASTRO "Blue Flame" MV

[@nalalala7584]

Ima save my fellow Headphone users pls turn your volume down for this one😂😭💀

[@formoftherapy]

Save a life.

[@smwatertasteslikewater]

Wish you were here when I watched this on Patreon😂😂

[@sxhunbignxse6700]

"THAT'S NOT MOONBIN, IS IT?!"

[@kettlechanuwu6578]

I learnt that the hard way 😂

[@hanie8435]

Noted 😂😂

[@ellymai.]

“dOnt tELL mE tHAt'S mOoNbiN” i was on full volume HAHA but relatable

[@Marie45610]

RIP Headphone users. 😂

[@ingriss14]

Same for me..... With the headphones and the reaction!!!!! Lol

[@solangelacosta8651]

I didnt realize how fanboy PD was until that scream hahahaha i love his reaction

[@KiraBabe18]

Lol Here too 😂😂😂

[@raiza1439]

😂😂

[@taliajourno5658]

ASTRO: H- PD: gorgeous, 10/10

[@aomnomnom]

okay i read the comment before they actually was reacting so i just thought you were being dramatic in that funny way but then they actually said that AND IM WHEEZING BECAUSE ITS TRUE

[@DeyanStrikes]

@@aomnomnom Please try not to use he/him pronouns for PD!

[@aomnomnom]

@@DeyanStrikes oh my GOD IM DUMB SO SORRY-

[@dreamer7837]

Shan Deyan wait why? sorry im new so i dont know much lol

[@niagericameron9708]

@@dreamer7837 They use They/Them pro nouns

[@sxhunbignxse6700]

the reason why moonbin doesn't rule the world is because he doesn't want to

[@jennifervallejo3777]

bc he loves sleep more 🤣

[@elise7079]

Jennifer Vallejo and eat...

[@sxhunbignxse6700]

and be sick 🥺💔

[@yuearoha1485]

totally agree 😏

[@matheussaliba]

it's because sinb doesn't let him

[@desislavakyoseva6251]

"I forgot to look at the lyrics" *ah yah yah yah yah yah* "it's useless now" 😂😂

[@kristensosa5359]

“who is that...THAT CANT BE MOONBIN” oh pd it is, it truly is.

[@jaijaiasis186]

“Uhm... what the fck Moonbin.” issa whole mood. 😂

[@m1nmin028]

"Oh there are lyrics my eyes have been playing attention to their faces" OH MY GOD HE IS SUCH A MOOOODDDD 🤭😂I've never seen him scream and freak out so much it was so funny

[@niabailey362]

Also we all know "paying attention to their faces" was a bold lie LOL

[@armymydaycaratnctzenatinyaroha]

have you ever seen them react to a SVT song? Because they freak the fuck out😂

[@universeinneverland2314]

@@chaoticneutral7829 pd goes by them/their pronouns not he or she

[@chaoticneutral7829]

@@universeinneverland2314 They are MTF, i realize in the stupidity hours of my insomnia i messed up what I wanted to say, ill fix that big oops on my part, but i was correcting the use of him/he pronouns, thanks for correcting me

[@12323Michelle]

Purely Unamused Pd is not MTF, they’re non-binary or gender-fluid, I forgot atm.

[@neptune153]

PD: minding their own business ASTRO: I'm about to end this man's whole career

[@moonshine5647]

Hey PD, just wanted to say I’m proud of you for keeping up with everything despite some people being just cruel. I hope you keep doing what’s right for your mental health. Don’t forget that there are always people supporting you! Sending love your way !!

[@asukabeastgirl]

Wait what happened? I'm not on Twitter that much.

[@violetjade64]

@@teedy151 they use they/them pronouns.

[@yuukokagami]

@@teedy151 That's so fucked up. Wish people would stop hating on others just because of their looks/personality. PD's even got the same bias as me and I've never once thought they were a pedo, jesus. :'(

[@koebiemi2095]

SquidTeedy thread inconclusive and most of it is just op’s opinion. Also PD uses they/them pronouns and she/her pronouns and OP’s “receipts” felt like they were just classic signs of internalized transphobia before they came out; Including but not limited to what OP would consider fixating on younger girls was probably PD grappling with discovering that they’re a woman and all of the dysphoria and possible jealousy that could stem from that/could stem from seeing a bunch of pretty cis girls (bc any girl would be envious ykno). The rest is just like “they’re a little too sexual (on THEIR OWN TWITTER)” or “they talk about their mental illnesses too much (on THEIR OWN TWITTER)” or “hearing about their problems makes me uncomfy 🥺” (I’m paraphrasing don’t mind me).

[@violetjade64]

@@koebiemi2095 yeah basically lol. i read the whole thing and none of it warranted "cancelling"

[@justbeingahuman8109]

Pd: Moonbin button up ur shirt Me:that's literally everyone of us after watching the mv

[@Naturestar44]

"oh i forgot to look at lyrics... 'yaya yaya' okay now it's useless" please my *lungs* i'm dying from laughter

[@noname-og2ns]

pd : *aggresively boppings head* *intensively making loud noises/screams* I felt that.

[@coolgirl312]

Don’t worry, Moonbin’s back got me too. All bias and non bias went out the door when his back shows up. 🤣

[@niabailey362]

Anytime PD screams into the mic you know its a winner 🤣 Hopefully Moonbin feels better soon!

[@Yino_lemmon]

“Oh yeah I forgot to look at the lyrics. ‘Yayayayayaya’ ok that was useless” lmao that got me hard

[@XcuseMyCharisma_]

"THATS NOT MOONBIN IS IT?!" Same PD. Same lmao.

[@stxrcarat9826]

PD: and I’m a really really big fan of- me: astro? PD: Moonbin oh-

[@aishadumbuya3600]

Ohh Astro they’re trying really hard how I wish they can be more famous

[@HallyuHagdom]

twitter is a cluster**** these days . Don't let it get you down. x

[@HallyuHagdom]

ITs me Frankie I just changed my channel name don't be alarmed ahaha

[@violetstarlight5561]

What happened? I’m 😞 ehat shit storm?

[@ash.613]

SquidTeedy Theyre not a pedo lmao. Half of the “evidence” looks HELLA fake

[@rin9139]

PD when listening to other songs: *Relaxed and bopping along* PD when he listens to an Astro song: MOONBIN! *Chaotic Screaming* Haha loved the reaction

[@tiaradwyana845]

"this is a visual beautiful aesthetic masterpiece" -pd

[@CaptainOats242]

my expectations were so high and pd still exceeded them, damn

[@Lucy-Sparking]

Astro has become Moonbin and co for PD

[@bryonyon4452]

PD:’oh yeah the lyrics' Moonbin:'ya ya ya ya ya ya'

[@areumheart4751]

"Sorry my eyes have been paying attention to their-- to their faces" Moonbin's back muscles would like to show otherwise

[@kyrilir]

"And I'm really really REALLY a fan of Moonbin" PFFF me too PD, me too

[@mmyyoonn]

the mv starting: pd: 10/10 moonbin: ah- yt: *AD*

[@ananyagupta6487]

*"MOONBIN BUTTON UP YOUR SHIRT!!"* mood, pd. mood.

[@sayuj.9263]

"Oh there are lyrics. Sorry my eyes have been paying attention to their faces." Well. Same with every kpop MV 😂😂

[@jessporter5122]

I love how expensive the music video looks, some of these aesthetic minimalistic style mvs can come off quite low quality or low budget (even if they weren't) but this one just screams money and I love it

[@fionapenguin]

"WTF Moon Bin". A quote after my own heart. lol

[@christinayeungg]

the ‘wtf moonbin’ is such a mood😂 feel u buddy!

[@kaylagr]

pd yelling into the mic is the best thing ever, my eardrums are having a great time

[@yoyoj]

"THATS NOT MOONBIN IS IT????" absolutely made me laugh out loud

[@teabland2869]

i can't tell you how hard i punched the air when you said always you is one of their best. that song is an underappreciated masterpiece.

[@AshleyGirlBabe]

this comeback was dangerous for astro stans and especially moonbin stans like WHO TOLD HIM that was okay!?

[@mariyam5798]

13:33 an accurate representation of every moonbin stan

[@dawonsf9125]

When he mention is that moobin i just died.. 😍😍😍

[@Void-g2n]

If you are seeing this, let’s remember moonbin like he was. A kind soul🩵 something has to change in the industry

[@bazakoski]

This video was such as mood 😂 Moonbin attacked us this comeback and honestly he may be doing the world a favor by sitting the promotions out. I don't know that we could handle it.

[@castlejunji]

Moonbin’s back muscles belong in a museum

[@OhMyMyMyYeahhh]

PD fangirling over astro y honestly so wholesome I'm-

[@lexiejoyce5803]

regular volume: ooh who is that?? bass boosted: tHaT’s NoT mOoNbIn Is It?!!,!

[@clotilde2368]

first second of the mv : gorgeous...visuals... 10/10 hahahaha same

[@bonniesias5999]

I’ve been waiting for years for sexy Astro. I thought I was ready but I fell out of my chair when I seen Binnie’s back.

[@bribee1991]

I was waiting so patiently for this just to see your reaction to Moon Bin. 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I was not disappointed. I dropped my phone so many times during the mv.

[@siyvek2143]

"Ok the highlights of this video so far is this set, the snappy editing, *and Moonbin's back muscle"* what a mood.

[@miac8240]

Literally LOL-ed at the "wtf moonbin" VERY TRUE. I was listening to that part while doing something else quickly so the change of tone was unexpected HAHAHA

[@sleepyweeb195]

"Oh! I forgot to look at the lyrics. Ah yay yay yay yay.....oh it's useless now". PD losing his shit over this music video, over ASTRO and shirtless Moonbin is the best thing ever! 😂😂❤️

[@juggy4631]

PD's reaction to Moonbin never disappoints. Same PD, same. We love you PD 😂

[@kpotatov]

This is why Moonbin is my bias and HAS BEEN since debut

[@cassiearoha573]

"MOON BIN BUTTON UP YOUR SHIRT" Same bro, I screamed the same thing. This video basically killed all us Arohas Great video btw! I love your reactions and comments about the video editing and angles!

[@brey5458]

ab6ix - blind for love victon - nostalgic nights golden child - wannabe pls react to these underrated kings :(((

[@channie737]

Jan Brey Espia YES Nostalgic Night by VICTON is a masterpiece and i don’t even stan them. I gotta start my research on them soon

[@yikesbro1686]

Jan Brey Espia yesss i want that too!

[@atqh2304]

@@channie737 yes please stan them. they are a bunch of lovely chaotic talented boy. they deserved so much love. you can start by watching their reality & variety show: me7nam, born identity, prelude to war, weekly idol, after school club, dingo loyalty trip, their youtube channel has TVicton & Victon diary & watch their vlive to see their sweetest interaction among themselves and their fans. They are a 7 member group that debuted on 9th Nov 2016. Group name: Victon (VoICe TO New world) Fandom name: Alice (Always we Love the VoICE) Official colors: blue atoll, blazing yellow Han Seungwoo, leader, 1994. 🦊 Kang Seungsik, main vocal, 1995. 🐶/🥔 Heo Chan, main dancer, 1995. 🦖 Lim Sejun, visual center, 1996. 🍓/🐷 Do Hanse, main rapper, 1997. 🐱 Choi Byungchan, subvocal, 1997.🐥 Jung Subin, maknae, 1999. 🐰 Welcome to Wonderland💙💛

[@channie737]

atqh ohmygod Alice is such a cute fan name 🥺

[@imanamir271]

Yes plsssss

[@lan1749]

“DONT TELL ME THATS MOONBIN” “WTF MOONBIN” if this ain’t all of us when we also watched for the first time

[@SaraBendjafar]

i need you to know that you're the best in this game. you seriously make the best content.

[@kpopirl2585]

LMFAO PD's last comment!!! "What the FK, Moonbin?"

[@gordana_194]

PD screaming in my ears about how amazing Astro is ... music to my ears 👏

[@amynguyen3203]

The thumbnail got me AHAHA XD I know PD biases Binnie so the thumbnail reaction got me ROLLING

[@cathlovefti09]

that WTF MOONBIN at the end is relatable totally relatable

[@houachouaher3411]

LOL "THAT'S NOT MOON BIN!!" I was so me when I first saw it!😂😂

[@claranguyen2738]

Stuff on Twitter has been making me sad too (and angry). So I’m just focusing on watching music videos I love and songs I love. When I saw a notification of your video it cheered me up a bit. (Edit: A combination of a lot of bad things on Twitter makes me sad and mad. Just to clarify.)

[@just_a_fangirl]

What happened?

[@pincydeka2548]

@@just_a_fangirl I think they are talking about the widespread hate hashtag #BanKpopAccounts

[@pincydeka2548]

@@thecactusreview568 I am not too sure since I only follow few artist's twt account, but I heard kpop haters on twitter are trending this hastag and spreading hate to all kpop accounts big and small.

[@Saerdna79]

@@pincydeka2548 Wow, I'm glad I don't use Shwitter

[@Nekominaj]

SquidTeedy where is the proof their gf was of age and no young people have come forth saying they have ever done anything or said anything to them.... I saw the thread and none of the messages were creepy dms just random twitter messages about being hot and naked since when is saying I’m hot and naked pedoish?

[@Ad-zw2ib]

I really like PD's style of clothing.

[@shumy_5280]

Your Moonbin reaction is *the best!* Just had to say.

[@carisa0000]

Hey, I'm sorry but THIS IS JUST THE BEST BLUEFLAME REACTION out of all that I have watched.

[@maxmoon9739]

10 out of 10 10 out of 10 10 out of 10 10 out of 10 myghaaaaddd i feel youuuuu 😍

[@Krystal109]

From what I understand, Blue Flame is sort of connected to "All Light"'s MV. With the focus on storybook or fairy tales, which is why there are references to Beauty & the Beast in both MVs. Overall, this is a really strong MV... even tho it's not my favorite track by them.

[@jianortiz2660]

When was the last time we heard pd almost screaming the whole mv? 🤣😆 glad that astro made pd happier compared to the first mins of the vid And that my friends is how u can identify a hardcore moonbin stan

[@orionstorm]

I love love love this song! This is the first song of theirs I’ve really heard and I love it more every time I hear it. 💙

[@dbloskidelros]

You should hear their other songs... Enjoy!

[@alejandraalvarado6788]

I AM SO PROUD OF #ASTRO AND HIS COMEBACK #BLUEFLAME THANKS FOR THIS, MORE NEED HEAR ABOUT THEM

[@shunleileinaing2885]

“My ear buds fell out. WHO CARES?! 10/10!!” Love this reaction.. 💜💜💜

[@zemouraanis4108]

And by the way PD we still waiting for ATEEZ's listening party come ooooon

[@germancardenas1525]

I was wondering where your reaction of Blue Flame was and well, here it is. Thanks for doing it! You made my day. Astro has really grown as a group as well as individually. Plus, in terms of sound and visuals, they are killing it! S T A N A S T R O Y’ A L L ! Btw: hope you feel better. You are amazing

[@diermaycanonigo6780]

I'm ADDICTED to this Song Right Now 😍😍😍😍 New AROHA here 🙋🏻❤

[@binroha5414]

PLEASE LISTEN TO THE WHOLE ALBUM THANK YOUUUUUU I LOVED YOUR REACTION

[@clustar7525]

I hope you’re doing well.

[@kaseybeltran4470]

Pd: "who is that?....THAT'S NOT MOONBIN IS IT?!" That was my reaction when I first watched the video. I literally screamed "OH MY GOD MOONBIN!" And I nearly died. Pd: "Moonbin button up your shirt." You are my spirit animal lol. I was saying the same thing. There's a reason why he's my bias wrecker. Also (last edit lol) I've never seen you fanboy so much. I love it.

[@Gsjskskud]

Thank you for reacting to Astro, they are so underrated but youtubers like you helps in spreading how good they are

[@luciarivero4828]

When Moonbin comes he is so scAndalOus and I'm living for his reactions.

[@hirohiwo]

I felt attacked everytime I saw Moonbin in this MV.

[@nanunanu641]

Literally still their best shit to this day this song is iconic and legendary and just mm perfect

[@fleridaesteffyramos8981]

We love you PD! You bring us happiness you have no idea💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙

[@sydneymclachlan]

No one: Literally no one: Not even MJ: PD: tHaTS NOt mOonBIn iS It!

[@thatsthequeso127]

"My eyes have been paying attention to their faces" pd are you sure it was only their faces tho? 😅

[@Mickey-ze8ls]

As a Moonbin lover I felt that "What the fuck Moonbin." on a spiritual level and reacted the same way lol

[@drinpixeled]

OMG I got into ASTRO via the beginning of this year and I'm a huge stan now...never thought I would go hard on one group but now I've been buying their albums a lot. Love seeing another fan just enjoying the new video! Love you man, keep it up! (Also Moonbin fucking killing it this video gdi be still my heart)

[@ck6136]

Totally agree about 'Always You'....it was so under-promoted but was a really heartfelt track in my opinion

[@jessie-nl8eb]

I’ve been bingeing your reactions and listening party’s lately purely because they bring me joy and make me excited about the artists I love. I don’t have many friends interested in kpop as much so your videos feel like We’re enjoying it together. I don’t watch any other reaction channels, I just like yours because of your respectful approach and genuine passion, so I value your thoughts and opinions

[@rocketfallen]

Been waiting for this since I saw the MV, because oh my god Moonbin. This was great.

[@berryshai_]

PD made me love and appreciate more Blue Flame's mv. I hyped with you too ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@irisa198]

Finally someone talks about how despite being all dark and blue and cold, the song itself and the lyrics are very warm and passionate. Just like with All Night, where, as you said, the shadows and the teal lighting and muted colours give the impression of a sad song, but the lyrics are very sweet and heartwarming. I feel like this is just something that's part of Astro - even when they do a darker or colder concept, it's still kinda warm. It's like they literally can't contain their passion, the only thing that changes is whether that passion takes a light-hearted form or a desperate form. Even Always You is about yearning and missing someone so powerfully you can't take it anymore - and also despite being such a sad song, some of the scenes (notably with Rocky, Sanha, and Moonbin) are very warm in tone and lighting.

[@formoftherapy]

I think the only sad song is SHOULD HAVE HELD ON and even that song is still a bop

[@raquelmorales9052]

Hey PD! Just wanted to say that, your channel is one of the few I still watch regularly even though college and stuff have made my life so busy. Watching your reactions as a fan and also a professional in the industry is fascinating for me (still a little design student) and has a way of making me happy after a stressful or sad day. Thank you for still making KZbin my safe place. Hope you do okay, and also always do what makes you happy and what is good for you! Take care and happy holidays from Costa Rica :)

[@MaissieBrown]

PD - I love your enthusiasm. You are my spirit animal as an Astro fan. You need to re-edit this and insert in your into here what you said back then about not caring for the song Always You itself when you reacted to that MV to show the contrast of how you now totally think it was their best song.

[@Miskymusic]

Your hair looks really pretty today PD 💕

[@lucilam.custodio4377]

Love your reaction to ASTRO’s Blue Flame mv!!! ASTRO is actually the first group I ever stanned. I started to love them after hearing them sing and then finding out how really funny they are. They’re so talented!!! By the way, I was looking forward to your reaction to this mv. Thank you!!!

[@ericalapina2154]

PD, astro already released their 7th mini album 'KNOCK'. Hehehhe, honestly I'm waiting for your reaction. So exciteeeed . #KNOCK #ASTRO #GATEWAY

[@dashingangel20]

Always You will always be THAT SONG

[@charisse7601]

astro is slowly climbing up my list of favorite kpop groups meanwhile i'd like to ask pd, if you could react to golden child's wannabe? i feel like you'll really like the aesthetic they used and the song itself!

[@MelTheMisfit]

I found Astro through their drama To Be Continued which I believe was around the time they debuted but I've been a fan ever since. Blue Flame wasn't what I expected from them but I am so proud of them because I swear they keep getting better and better with each comeback

[@96nieyna]

I hope you can do a listening party to this blueflame album cause all songs in this album are masterpieces 😍