The Map Of Philosophy

[@newbygamer]

This makes me want to learn, all the things

[@bertulgar5147]

Bro I appreciate your enthusiasm. I am currently hypothesising something that if a learning goal is more planned, it will create more excitement in learner. What do you think about this?

[@newbygamer]

@@bertulgar5147 I think it could. I think it depends on if the person is already interested in the subject. In our cases, we like philosophy. Seeing a literal map of what there is to explore can motivate someone as it shows a clear direction of what there is left to know. That being said, you want to allow some room for spontaneity, so just how Carneades didn't spend 5 hours on each subject, it allows the learner to dicover new things within the subtopics despite having a really detailed road map.

[@newbygamer]

@Sergio Ascencio that's a wonderful plan and i wish you the best of luck doing so. It wouldn't surprise me if I do something similar later down the line

[@ParadymShiftVegan]

Hahaha you'll need a few lifetimes

[@ben777neb]

@NickyG @Bertulgar You inspire me with hope, for your generation. May your spirit remain untramelled and strong 🙏

[@michaelpisciarino5348]

0:00 History of Philosophy 1:43 *Logic and Philosophical Methods* 2:15 Formal, Classical Logic 3:00 Higher Order Logic 3:52 Modal Logics 4:22 Temporal Logic, Epistemic Logic, Deontic Logic 4:55 *Non-Classical Logic* 5:07 Many Values Logic, Fuzzy, Computability (provablity), Linear, Non-Reflexive, Relevance, Intuistic 6:36 *Informal Logic* Inductive Arguments, Abductive Arguments (the best explanation) 7:59 *Philosophical Methods* (techniques used by philosophers) Thought experiments, Experimental Philosophy, Intuitions 9:43 10:10 *History and Traditions of Philosophy* (Greeks/Romans, Stoicism, Skepticism, Atomism, Epicureanism) 10:56 *Medieval Philosophy* (Scholasticism, Thomism, Aquinas, Anselm, Boethius, St. Augustine) 11:20 *Seventeenth Century Philosophy* (Descartes, Lock, Leibniz, Hobbes, Rationalism, Empiricism, Idealism, Dualism) 11:54 *Eighteenth Century Philosophy* (Hume, Rousseau, Voltaire, *_Kant_* , Bentham) 12:28 *Nineteenth Century Philosophy* (Mill, Utilitarianism, Hegel, Nietzsche, German Idealism, William James, Transcendentalism) 12:47 *Twentieth Century Philosophy* (Russell, Popper, Wittgenstein, Kuhn, Sartre, Godel, Quine Heidegger, Lewis) 13:25 13:32 *Analytic Philosophy* , Native American Philosophy, Colonialism, Afro-Caribbean, Latin American Philosophy, (*Australia and Polynesia*) 15:15 *Continental Philosophy* (Phenomenology, Post-Structuralism, Hermeneutics, Existentialism, Critical Theory, etc.) 15:48 *African Philosophy* (Carneades) 17:08 *Eastern Philosophy* , *Chinese Philosophy* , *Japanese Philosophy* , *Korean Philosophy* *Tibetan Philosophy* 18:23 *Indian Philosophy* , *Islamic Philosophy* 20:47 *_Value Theory_* Aesthetics Philosophy of Beauty 22:32 *Political Philosophy* (Justice, Government, Freedom, Law, War, Political Theory, Human Rights, International Development) 23:34 *Social Philosophy* (Feminism, Equality, Culture, Gender, Race, Sex, Sexuality) 24:54 *Moral Theory and Ethics* (Meta-Ethics, Normative Ethics, Applied Ethics) 28:04 *Epistemology* (Study of Knowledge), Epistemic States and Properties, Social Epistemology (Trust, Social Choice Theory, etc.) 29:24 A Posteriori and A Priori 29:48 Epistemic Theories/ Epistemic Logic 30:36 *Metaphysics* (Ontology, Objects, Mereology, Identity/Personhood, Properties, Realism, 32:30 Interlevel Metaphysics, Time, Modality, Causation) 33:47 *Philosophy of Science* 34:34 Problem of Undetermination, Rule of Induction, Problem of Induction, History of Science, Natural Kinds, Scientific Realism 36:53 So Much More) 37:39 *Philosophy of Religion* Arguments for Existence of God/s (Ontological Argument, Teleological, Cosmological, Problem of Evil) 38:46 _Attributes of God_ (Omniscience, Omnipotence, Omnibenevolent) 39:23 Religious Experiences 39:45 Philosophy of Particular Religions 40:17 *Philosophy of Language* Meaning, Truth, 41:18 Specific Expressions of Philosophy 41:44 42:00 *Philosophy of Mind* Philosophical Zombie, Mental States and Physical States, Perception, 43:31 43:39 *Philosophy of Action* Game Theory, Choices, Free Will/Determinism, Motivations, etc. 44:57 Ending comments of the video

[@kyrlics6515]

Daddy

[@toml1593]

Why doesn’t this have more likes

[@anassyria5176]

Map of Map Of Philosophy

[@machrisomachriso2797]

Thanks your a saviour

[@glimmerinthedust2468]

Thank you.

[@BR525]

I’ve rewatched the first 3 mins around 10 times because my mind fills with thoughts as the video plays. This is going to be one of the best presentations ever. Thank you very much to everyone involved in creating, publishing, and sharing.

[@ricobrawlstars4880]

This deserves a lot of views... The amount of time and energy spent in making this video is immense!

[@levicoffman5146]

I definitely want to study some Antarctica philosophy!

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Haha! Nice catch, I'm surprised no one has caught the other Easter Egg in the video yet.

[@ThalesPo]

Came here looking for "Antarctica philosophy" comments.

[@RogLichKing]

"If a living creature has kneecaps and runs towrads you, run like hell" ~Penguinus Antarcticus

[@mypronounismaster4450]

Does heat exist?

[@michaelgroesbeck8850]

@Brian Gallia Heat is experienced more than it is observed. Particle Dispersion is a more accurate description of what Heat is, since Wave Theory is just a generalization of Particle Theory.

[@Lord_Ackkham]

Very precise,concise, in-depth and captivating

[@benjaminprzybocki7391]

One thing that's missing is metaphilosophy, which includes questions such as: What is the purpose of philosophy? Is philosophy practical? Given that we still debate ideas that are thousands of years old, has progress been made in philosophy?

[@armanke13]

Benjamin Przybocki 27:40 I see "applied ethics" mentioned, but I don't know if it studies some part of that kind of question or not.

[@justinlacek1481]

I majored in Philosophy, and only recently did I realize that our department never had a metaphilosophy class. I.e, there were never any courses offered on the topic of philosophy of philosophy. The closest things I took to it was a series of classes on Kant and a class on the philosophy of science. The book "4 Dimensions of Philosophy " would probably be a good textbook for it.

[@maximilyen]

👍

[@philoalethia]

Of course, then we'll need meta-metaphilosophy....

[@havenbastion]

Academic Philosophy, Truth Wisdom (epistemology, metaphysics), and Practical Wisdom have different tools and aims.

[@Maddlynz]

EPIC. This is something I've wanted to make a while back. I even made a weak attempt at it but gave up. I am absolutely floored that you made this!

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Thanks! It took quite some time and a lot of work. Thanks for watching!

[@lucassilvanogueiragomes420]

When you start studying the highest levels of sciences, getting closer to the edge of current knowledge, the philosophic nature of it all becomes crystal clear. It's basically what pushes scientific knowledge further: there would be no thought experiments or hypotesis formulation without the application of philosophical practices.

[@francisco4493]

I really appreciate the effort you put in this video! It is incredible, thank you for sharing such high quality information.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

No problem! Thanks for watching!

[@vdharma]

Thank you for mapping the various philosophies. As you went around the world, I noticed two glaring omissions - Indian philosophy and that of the Australian aboriginal world. Both are ancient and I believe have profound and original contributions.

[@flyingmonkey3822]

@18:27 even mentions Tibetan If anything he missed communist philosophy since his atheism is largely informed by the anti-religious dismissiveness. If you feel maligned as a religious person by Carneades….

[@CosmicFaust]

Hi Carneades! It’s been a while. I hope you’re doing well 😊. I just had my first philosophy seminar at University and the teacher literally put this video on for the class. This was because we were discussing the question “did the Greeks invent philosophy?” Even after all this time I’m still running into your work even at University lol 😂.

[@thomasperez8558]

U have to add in ur map Spinoza and Marx, they are not marginal thinkers. Hegel said: "no philosophy without Spinoza." But I really appreciate the effort of mapping something that big. Greetings from Switzerland

[@RezaMoussavi]

One of the BEST videos I've ever watched on KZbin. Thank you and I enjoyed every second of it. It feels I am 6 in a candy store with an all-you-can-eat-coupon in my hand.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Awesome! I'm glad you liked it! Thanks for watching.

[@victorcode2075]

Wisdom is said to be realising how little you know. This presentation has made us all wiser...

[@curtis25920]

As an antarctic philosopher, this was very insightful.

[@johnalbertdevadosanselwyn2993]

My dear sir, Thank you very much for this video. I have been blessed by it. The overview is presented so well and any reader will get a slear picture of what it is all about. Thank you.

[@killerdinoblood12]

This is... objectively incredible o.O

[@xXxTERDMUFFINxXx]

Yeah, objectively one of the videos I've seen on KZbin in the past five years

[@nabeelsherazi8860]

Inarguably.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Haha, thanks! Can art be objectively incredible? I don't know. kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJ3YpZ95p7uEhJY

[@killerdinoblood12]

Well, "objectively" not really. The entire concept of Objectivity is subjective in and of itself. Art specifically is, more then any other human endeavour, especially sensitive to dogma and objectivity is dogma. If Art can be objective, then it has devolved into something else (my opinion). That said, I personally find this video to be amazing.

[@ronpaulrevered]

No doubt that knowledge is held by individuals, but 1+1=2 is objectively True for all individuals in existence and True if no individuals are in existence.

[@FerozKhan-ss9nn]

This lecture about the map of philosophy is very interesting and very informative as well as very helpful. It is a great way to learn about philosophy as a whole. More importantly, it is a wonder that you can teach things that are not so simple as to be taught as easily as you can teach them. However, the art of putting so many ideas into such brevity is not only a matter of skill but also a matter of practice. This is also explanatory for understanding how brevity is beauty. Pakistan

[@brennenhrebeniuk9661]

This video is a fantastic synopsis of philosophy better then any philosophy history summary video ive seen yet

[@_WeDontKnow_]

I'm wanting to study philosophy and you gave me a much more complete view on what it is, thanks man. Really wonderfully done, I can feel the passion. Definitely gonna check out more of your stuff

[@davidaguilera2493]

I love how you mentioned Kurt Vonnegut's "Harrison Bergeron." Now that I think about it, the satire is quite philosophic, it's sort of like a dystopoian thought experiment that has some social commentary.

[@B10Esteban]

Wonderful video , thanks for doing this . I don't know how much I truly understood ( not much) but it helps to see it organized in this manner in order to begin to connect the dots and having a broad picture of where the things I've learned so far fit in in the universe of philosophy

[@AlanPhan128]

TLDR: Philosophy connects different disciplines, uses logic to evaluate language, and explores various philosophical traditions and positions worldwide. 1. 00:00 🧠 Philosophy connects different disciplines and uses logic to evaluate language, including formal classical logic, higher order logic, philosophy of math, modal logic, and various categories and types of non-classical logics. 1.1 Philosophy serves as the connecting substance between different disciplines, allowing them to communicate and honor their original connection, as evidenced by the fact that obtaining a PhD in any discipline still requires a doctorate in philosophy. 1.2 Logic and philosophical methods are at the center of philosophy, connecting various disciplines and translating language into something that can be evaluated by math and logic, with formal classical logic being the foundation and including propositional logic, categorical logic, and predicate calculus. 1.3 Higher order logic goes beyond quantifying over objects and includes quantifying over predicates and sets, such as type theory and set theory, which are related to the philosophy of math. 1.4 Philosophy of math encompasses the connection between math and logic, including questions about the reality of mathematical objects, and modal logic is a framework for understanding different ways of speaking, such as temporal logic for the logic of time. 1.5 Epistemic logic and deontic logic are categories within motor logics, while non-classical logics, such as many-valued logics and computability logic, question the basic premises of classical logic. 2. 05:30 📚 Non-classical logics question classical logic principles, informal logic focuses on inductive arguments, abductive reasoning and thought experiments are used in philosophy to form premises and arguments. 2.1 Linear logic, non-reflexive logic, relevance logic, and intuitionistic logic are all non-classical logics that question fundamental principles of classical logic. 2.2 Informal logic is a type of non-deductive logic that focuses on inductive arguments, which use specific cases to make generalizations. 2.3 Every time a rock is dropped, it will go towards the ground, which is an example of abductive reasoning, similar to the watch argument for the existence of God, where the best explanation for finding a watch is that it had a designer. 2.4 The truth of premises does not guarantee the truth of the conclusion, and philosophical methods, such as thought experiments and experimental philosophy, use intuitions and logic to form the basis of premises and arguments in philosophy. 3. 10:01 🌍 The history of philosophy is divided into different eras, with significant contributions from various philosophers throughout time, leading to the expansion of different philosophical traditions and positions worldwide. 3.1 The history of philosophy can be divided into different eras, such as the ancient Greeks and Romans, followed by medieval philosophy with the scholastics attempting to reconcile ancient Greek texts and the Bible. 3.2 Thomism, Patrology, and various philosophers from different time periods have contributed to the development and advancement of philosophy, with the 17th and 18th centuries being particularly significant due to the emergence of new ideas and influential philosophers such as Descartes, Locke, Leibniz, Hobbes, Kant, Hume, Rousseau, and Voltaire, while the 19th century saw further expansion and growth in philosophy with the contributions of Mill, Hegel, James, and Nietzsche. 3.3 New philosophical positions emerged throughout history, leading to the expansion of philosophy as more people became educated, and in the twentieth century, philosophers like Bertrand Russell and Ludwig Wittgenstein made significant contributions, although summarizing more recent periods becomes increasingly challenging. 3.4 Analytic philosophy, which originated from the ancient Greeks, is the dominant tradition in the English-speaking world, but there are other philosophical traditions, including Native American philosophy. 3.5 Native American philosophy focuses on indigenous rights and sovereignty, while Afro-Caribbean philosophy explores multiculturalism and colonialism, and Latin American philosophy delves into social issues and feminist philosophy; in Europe, continental philosophy encompasses various positions such as phenomenology, poststructuralism, hermeneutics, existentialism, critical theory, speculative realism, and German idealism. 3.6 African philosophy is complex and diverse, with a lack of consistency due to the impact of colonialism, distinct differences between North African and sub-Saharan culture, and the influence of Western philosophy. 4. 17:10 🌍 Eastern philosophy includes Chinese traditions like Confucianism, Taoism, and Buddhism, while Japanese, Korean, Indian, Tibetan, and Islamic philosophies have their own distinct beliefs; value theory in philosophy explores aesthetics and the philosophy of beauty in various art forms. 4.1 Eastern philosophy is a collection of various traditions, including Chinese philosophy which encompasses Confucianism, Taoism, and Buddhism, with Confucius being influential in the region. 4.2 Japanese, Korean, Indian, Tibetan, and Islamic philosophies are distinct from each other, with each having its own unique combination of cultural beliefs and influences. 4.3 During the Middle Ages, the Arab world preserved ancient Greek texts, leading to the development of Islamic philosophy, while Polynesian philosophy has a post-colonialist aspect, and Australian philosophy has its own identity within the analytic philosophy world. 4.4 Value theory in philosophy encompasses aesthetics, which includes the philosophy of beauty, art, literature, film, music, and visual art, with each form posing unique questions and perspectives. 4.5 The philosophy of beauty explores aesthetic judgment, value, and cognition, including the categorization of the sublime, humor, and horror. 5. 22:32 🗺 Political philosophy explores questions of justice, government, freedom, and law, while feminism addresses equality and the philosophy of culture explores the relationship between philosophy and culture; value theory explores the nature of what is good and ethics, and normative ethics includes consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics. 5.1 Political philosophy explores questions of justice, government, freedom, and law, including topics such as types of government, power dynamics, and human rights. 5.2 Feminism is a significant part of social philosophy, addressing questions of equality and the need for both equal and unequal treatment in certain areas. 5.3 The philosophy of culture explores the relationship between philosophy and culture, including questions about the creation of culture and its impact on gender, race, sex, and sexuality. 5.4 Value theory in philosophy includes moral theory and ethics, specifically meta ethics which explores the nature of what is good. 5.5 Is good just an opinion or does it exist separate from our subjective views, and how can we divide things into good and bad in ethics? 5.6 Consequentialism, deontology, and virtue ethics are the main theories in normative ethics, with applied ethics being the application of these theories to real-world problems. 6. 27:58 📚 Epistemology studies knowledge and its principles, while metaphysics explores the existence of objects, both of which are relevant to ethical issues. 6.1 Epistemology is the study of knowledge, including its principles, varieties, definitions, and other related concepts such as belief states, wisdom, trust, and collective mentality. 6.2 A posteriori and a priori knowledge are two main distinctions in philosophy, with a wide range of epistemic theories and experiences, all connected by epistemic logic. 6.3 Metaphysics, specifically ontology, is the study of the existence of objects and different ontologies have varying perspectives on what exists and what doesn't. 6.4 Philosophy explores the nature of objects, including their composition, identity, personhood, and properties, which are relevant to ethical issues such as abortion. 8

[@blablabla63923]

Very concise, informative overview of traditional philosophy; however, this is yet another example of a proponent of analytic philosophy bracketing off post-structuralism from the alleged "Map of Philosophy" [sic].

[@thomasbeaumont3668]

Remember this was made by a know at all math major, all of philosophy is a footnote to plato, any map taking into account history would stem from plato. this map could’ve been a visualisation for how thinkers have responded to ideas and how they evolve. How modern thoughts of economics and religion stem from a singular source

[@ahobimo732]

This man has done a lot of study. His knowledge of the field is vast, comprehensive, and seriously impressive.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Thanks! As a philosophical skeptic that does not know anything, I feel like Socrates whenever someone says I know a great deal. :)

[@rainbowghostsplinter]

Although this is very impressive, I think that this is a Western understanding of philosophy. It makes perfect sense for an Occidental orientation of the last 2000-3000 years. However, Eastern Philosophy is poorly represented here. There are many errors showing a lack of knowledge on the relationship between certain 'philosophies' (i.e. Indian-Buddhist-Japanese) and the 'non-dualist' inner nature of such conceptions of reality obliterate the Western tradition which is called 'Philosophy'. If philosophy as we know it, how it's taught at university level and even at schools, is English - then the Eastern tradition is Klingon. The approach is totally different. I wish I knew this when I studied. Also I wish I had a useful map like this describing how all the pertinent things in my courses linked to each other. Great job!

[@Raketemensch-fl3sv]

This was... awesome. As a dilettante with a slightly more than passing interest in philosophy (now somewhat dormant, though), i figured that most of this map would be old hat to me, but *damn* did you get a lot of information crammed in there. Especially appreciated the non-western mapping.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

+Raketemensch 00000 I'm glad you liked it! Thanks for watching!

[@mohammedshihab7292]

Thank you for the phenomenal effort to produce and share this beauty. Forever indebted 🙏.

[@mobina11]

Ok hold on, can we just appreciate this video for a moment? This is spectacular!!! Good job! Thank you very much.

[@SnapSphere360]

Before this video, my thoughts were all tangled, now i see everything in a different perspective!!

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Glad to help! One of the goals of the video is to visualize the scope of the world of philosophy. Philosophy has such a broad discipline, it is rare to look at it all at once.

[@gabriela.pierzynski9923]

A lot of logic on this channel... and I’m loving every minute of it!

[@Pfhorrest]

Theology is kind of an exception to the setup you spell out in the first few minutes. Even way back in the day when "everything" was philosophy, theology was still a separate thing, as were law and medicine, which is why you had DD and JD and MD doctorates in addition to PhDs for everything else.

[@MashMaloCircus]

He was talking the Greeks and you're talking about the big 4 subjects in the 14 century of European University, which is not in the same category, but he should state it more clearly

[@kuhataparunks]

I was looking for something exactly like this and thankfully found it thanks so much

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Awesome! Thanks for watching!

[@wailmohamed8412]

Hi from Libya. this is one of best videos that are on KZbin. keep the amazing work going .

[@abcrane]

the graphics are a work of genius...who's the artist?

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Thanks! They are all created by me. :) I often use references for the faces but the text is done by me by "hand".

[@abcrane]

@@CarneadesOfCyrene extraordinary . Thank you for this, you have paid homage to the philosophical lineage with this art.

[@MrJurents]

I have absolutely no clue about philosophy... But whoa... This is inspiring

[@duckaduck3608]

The meaning of Life is Hope. Without hope, there is no motivation. Without motivation, there is no energy. Everything is made from energy.

[@isamkamel]

That is insightful! thank you! an excellent collection of phiosophical terms

[@HundreadD]

Knew you were an Analytic 5 minutes in the video

[@hihello-sx1sx]

Prickle haha that’s what I was thinking

[@MnemoHistory]

Because he didn’t speak in poetic and metaphorical clouds of fog made of words?

[@marcpadilla1094]

Need to display books or pamphlets on each individual study or branch of Philosophy. Great introduction to wet the philosophical apetite.

[@peteradamson5160]

A good presentation overall, the only part I'm a bit disappointed is the history of philosophy. It's somewhat a bit skewed, just a few example : - Didn't mention about the Pre-Socratic - It overlook Neoplatonism, which was one of the most influential (after Peripatetic) up until 19th century. - Augustine & Boethius is actually from the late antiquity. - It skips the Graeco-Arabic-Latin translation movement which is why the Latin can read Aristotle (and also overlook Islamicate philosophy, a pretty interesting era considering there are constructive discussions between the 3 Abrahaimic faith) - In Medieval Philosophy, although Anselm & Thomas Aquinas is the most famous philosopher. Henry of Ghent was more reflective of this era. And also Dun Scotus was a more interesting figure (although I like Peter Abelard and his intentionalism.) Although it's understandable why it's presented that way, it's the typical undergraduate philosophy course. Most of the things I've mentioned are only known to specialist in its era. The only reason I can point out is because of "History of Philosophy" podcast from Professor Peter Adamson (he specializes in Neoplatonism in Arabic Philosophy, though he's always discuss with his colleagues who specialize in each of the period)

[@geronimohayauxdutilly2136]

The video is already 45 minutes long, it fulfils its job in introducing the subject and summarising what is within it. There's always going to be things you can't cover

[@jaykong1128]

Good critique. Especially the augustine and Boethius inaccuracy. Good info too. Thanks brother.

[@glimmerinthedust2468]

Thanks for this.

[@Mittu91]

this needs to be titled "an attempt at an incomplete map of philosophy " since you acknowledge as much!

[@jerryscripps9707]

is this available for reprints or to purchase? Aesthetically pleasing and would be an inspiration to keep learning about philosophy.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

We currently have it in Canvas Print, Poster, Pillow, and Fleece blanket. :) www.zazzle.com/collections/the_map_of_philosophy-119830152861711624?rf=238568769552007656&CMPN=share_dclit&lang=en&social=true

[@betweenearthandsky4091]

Would be nice to make it in different colours@@CarneadesOfCyrene

[@betweenearthandsky4091]

As well as black & white

[@Pfhorrest]

How could you relegate the vast breadth and depth of Antarctic Philosophy to just a single question-marked mention on a map, not even a spoken word about it?

[@raymond961]

common bro

[@DManCAWMaster]

Also I wonder have you ever done a video on yourself? You could talk a bit about your background and philosophies you hold too or your favourite ones.

[@alijassim7015]

I study physics and mathematics-College degree. I wanted to make a plan for myself to read the best introductory book/textbook in each branch of philosophy. Now, I really don't know where to start!

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

I would start with logic, but that's just me (especially if you have a mathematics background). If you like thinking about time travel and alternate universes, Metaphysics is for you. If you like thinking about the possibility that we are in the Matrix, or dreaming, check out epistemology. If you want to prove something is right or wrong, or figure out what those mean try ethics. Ethics, philosophy of religion, and philosophy of science are very applied, while logic is more "pure" to use the mathematical term. Metaphysics and Epistemology are somewhere in between.

[@dustinchapters]

Absolutely fantastic. Thank you for putting this together.

[@WisdomisPower-10inminute-dn5no]

This is exactly the kind of engaging topic I love to explore. I've shared my take on my channel and would love to hear what others think.

[@rogergalindo7318]

this is the reason why I wanted to study philosophy in college

[@AdianAntilles]

The funniest thing about this video is that it's 45 Minutes speedy talking and not even connect with more than just the topic of these fields. Very good job!

[@BUENHECTOR]

I began studying Philosophy with the two volumes book of Joseph Gredt "Principia de Philosophia Aristotelica Thomistica" where Logic (Organon), Metaphysics (Ontology), Ethics, Teodicea, Epistemologia, Cosmology.. Where the main chapters. Later on, I read Aristotle's Metaphysics and his both Ethics.. Later on I tried to understand the "De Ente et Essentia" from Aquinas.I stop there, for me Philosophy is the reflection upon de ente (ens) as a subject and as a verb.

[@educationexplorer7796]

I upgraded you from my political channel to my educational channel. :)

[@chadliampearcy]

This is my Political channel. :)

[@medictf2349]

This was genuinely interesting and informative, thankyou so much for making this!

[@HealthPoliticsAndProtein]

this is helping me get my bearings in philosophy

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Great! I'm glad to help!

[@stephenperez7168]

Hey! This is Absolutely Wonderful you were Able to Chart this, was Having a Tough Time Navigating. I really Appreciate your Clarity on Something so Broad 👍🏽

[@abdelrahmanmustafa1633]

Carneades, although it was more theatrical than philosophical, I do indeed appreciate the feat you have performed during the visit to Rome. I liked how audiences were wowed by your one time being for and one time being against a subject.

[@tyercuuhbitu2219]

Mohism and Legalism are also prominent in classical Chinese philosophy which I think should have been mentioned here. :) Both Chinese and Indian philosophy series would take at least a year to cover for each, that I'd agree with you

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Certainly. It is why I am never worried about running out of material for this channel, there is just so much philosophy to cover!

[@aritrachowdhury3950]

Thanks for making this video. It is a great primer for those new to this field.

[@pkelly62261]

Thank you for the time and effort to produce and share this video.

[@knowledgenest2769]

thank you thank you thank you so much.I am going to studying philosophy.But I don't have any knowledge about it.This map gave an idea of philosophy. Thank you so much. bless you

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

+NIHAL BADHAI No problem! I'm glad to hlep. Hopefully as you study philosophy you can return here and see how your understanding of these many concepts has grown! :)

[@LECityLECLEC]

I love your content this was a great summary thank you for making this!

[@Luckimee]

Incredible. I was set on being a nurse. This makes me want to study law :)

[@sleeexs]

Study both... You can study as a nurse practical but also probably law online or at the side.

[@Edmonddantes123]

Fantastic video, thank you so much! Not only is the content incredibly illuminating, it also looks great. What type of software did you use to make it, and what's the font you are using?

[@silviapetrova8562]

the fact that we study only 1/100 of this to huge depths at school and nothing else

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

One of the goals of the channel is to make the whole thing available for anyone that wants it. Also, which 1/100th? I'm curious.

[@Orion225]

This inspires me to read more philosophy...

[@hjaltejensen8921]

Thank you Carneades for a brilliant job!

[@basarpulcuoglu662]

Could you please recommend a History of Philosophy book written by an analytic philosopher apart from Bertrand Russell?

[@jonahdavis7833]

Are William James and David Hume two of your favorite philosophers?

[@Dayglodaydreams]

I can't wait to see your video on Postmodernism and Logic/Reason.

[@fernandov1492]

Thank You! Your work is much appreciated 🙇‍♂️

[@NoNTr1v1aL]

Absolutely amazing video!

[@Le_voyage_de_Sappho]

What a wonderful world 🌎

[@Eternaldream13]

Excuse me if I missed it, but are Existentialism and Phenomenology on this map? Specifically, in the philosophy of perception section, I believe both would contain a large body of work. Additionally, I know this may sound a bit insane, but I'd like you to go in depth on the many interconnections within different schools of philosophy - how a certain school's epistemology, metaphysics and view on perception and consciousness are connected (perhaps even how they contradict or contribute to the development of other schools of philosophy). Going a layer deeper, I would like suggestions for literature on the connections between philosophy and psychology - ethics (especially normative ethics), metaphysics (especially answers to nihilism), epistemology - the role of reason and perception in the development of personality (which overlaps with the study of identity). Long story short, I'm looking to go really deep in those questions - perhaps a madman's errand, but it seems of extreme importance to me.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Existentialism and Phenomenology are generally considered Continental Philosophy, and while I briefly mention them in the discussion of other philosophical traditions, I intended this map to focus more on analytic philosophy. In terms of connections, philosophy is so connected that it is mind-boggling. I started out trying to draw all of the conenctions between the different areas, but I ended up just connecting everything. There's a separate field of philosophy connecting just about any spot on that map, and in some of the other videos here I go into more depth on those subjects. Suggestions for literature, that is quite a list. I usually start in the bibliographies of the SEP articles on whatever topics you are interested in.

[@jebidiahnewkedkracker1801]

"Apologies that this video is so long"?!? Are you kidding me? This video was pretty damn GOOD! Not only could I have probably taken MORE of it, not only did I learn a thing or two from it, it was one of those rare videos I watched all the way through in one viewing! (I mean there are A LOT of good videos to watch, but rare is the video on KZbin that I feel compelled to watch in its entirety in the first viewing...Most I squirrel away in the library que for later viewing, but I sat through this one pretty glued to my seat. Granted it was a TOILET seat, but STILL....🤣)

[@debrachambers1304]

That's a long time to spend on a toilet seat

[@brownie9620]

If anyone wants a CHRONOLOGICAL ROADMAP into philosophy, Eastern and Western combined, here's my compilation. - Ancient Indian philosophy - 1. Vedic philosophy (2000 BCE) 2. Samkhya sutras of Kapila (~1500 BCE) atheistic school of dualism. 3. The Principal Upanishads (bw 1000 to 600 BCE) 4. Charvaka philosophy of Brihaspati (pre-1000BCE) - world's oldest atheistic and materialistic philosphy. The original Brihaspati Sutras didn't survive. 5. The Nyaya Sutras of Aksapada Goutama (7th century BCE - World's oldest complete book on logic and epistemology) 6. Bhagvad Gita (~500 BCE) 7. Mimansa Philosophy - the principal text woukd be Mimamsa sutra of Jamini (4th-century BCE) 8. Vaisheshika sutra of Kanada ( 7th century BCE - among others these sutras hypothesised the breakdown of matter into atoms and subatoms - Anu and Paramanu) 9. Yoga Sutras of Patanjali (bw 500BCE - 400 CE) 10. Samkhyakarika of Ishvar Krishna (~350 CE) 11. Jain philosophy - outlined in the Tattvārthasūtra of Umaswati (possibly between 2nd-century and 5th-century CE) 12. Buddhist philosophy - important texts include those of the Mahayana sect - Mahaprajnaparamita sutra, Maha Ratnakuta sutra, Sandhinimochana sutra, Amitabha sutra, Vimalakriti sutra, Lankavatara Sutra, Shurngama Sutra, Avatamsaka Sutra, Mahaparinirvana sutra, and Saddharma pundarika sutra. 13. Sociopolitical philosophy - Arthashastra of Chanakya (4th century BCE) 14. Ajivika philosophy - the original scriptures are lost. Hellinistic - 1. Thales of Miletus (624/623-548/545 BCE) - the father of ancient Greek philosophy. 2. Pythagoras (570 BCE) 3. On Nature by Parmenides (560 BCE - 510 BCE ) 4. Anaxagoras (500 BC-428 BCE) - the first to establish a philosophy in its entirety in Athens. 5. Zeno (490 BC-430 BC) 6. Empedocles (490 BC-430 BC) 7. Socrates (470 - 399 BCE - all of him. This man's THE man ) 8. Democritus (460 - 370 BCE - famous for his atomifc theory among others) 9. Plato, (born 428/427 - 348/347 BCE) 10. Aristotle (384-322 BCE ) Classical Chinese philosophy - 1. Daodejing of Lao Tzu (5th century) 2. Analects of Confucius (475-220 BCE) 3. Zhuangzi (476-221 BCE) 4. Mencius (3rd century BCE) 5. Xun Kuang (314-235 BCE) Classical Roman philosophy - 1. Lucretius (88- 55 BCE) 2. Cicero (106 - 43 BCE) 3. Seneca the Younger (BCE 4- 65 AD) 4. Pliny The Elder (23-79) 5. The Meditations by Marcus Aurelius (121-180) 6. Porphyry of Tyre ( 233- 305) 7. Augustine (354-430) 8. Hypatia (370-415) 9. Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius (470/75-524) Islamic philosophy - 1. Abū Bakr Muhammad ibn Zakariyyā al-Rāzī (854 CE - 925 CE) Famed doctor, chemist, and philosopher. First person to describe smallpox and measles as separate diseases and author of the first book on pediatrics. 2. ArA ahl al-madīna al-fāḍila (The Views of the People of The Virtuous City) by Al-Farabi (872-951 AD) 3. Saadia Gaon (882 CE - 942 CE) 4. Yahya ibn Adi (893 CE - 974 CE) Logic theorist and doctor 5. Avicenna (980 CE - 1037 CE) Persian Polymath that is often regarded as the single greatest thinker of the Islamic Golden age. 6. Ihya Ulum al-Din - The Revival of Religious Sciences by Al-Ghazzali (1058-1111 AD) 7. Ibn Rushd (1126-1198 AD) - aka Averroes. 8. Sohrevardi (1154 CE - 1191 CE) Founder of the Islamic school of Illuminationism. 9. Tafsir Al-Kabeer of Fakhr al-Din al-Razi (1149 CE - 1209 CE) 10. Ibn Arabi (1165-1240 AD) the first Islamic postmodern and feminist thinker. Medieval European and Renaissance era philosophy - 1. Augustine (354-430) 2. Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius (470/75-524) 3. Saint Anselm of Canterbury (1033-1109) - the originator of the ontological argument for the existence of God 4. Scholasticism - 13th and 14th century - Some of the main figures of scholasticism include Anselm of Canterbury (“the father of scholasticism"), Peter Abelard, Alexander of Hales, Albertus Magnus, Duns Scotus, William of Ockham, Bonaventure, and Thomas Aquinas. Aquinas's masterwork Summa Theologica (1265-1274) is considered to be the pinnacle of scholastic, medieval, and Christian philosophy; 5. Humanism - important works include those by Coluccio Salutati (16 February 1331 - 4 May 1406), Petrarch (1304 - 1374), Michael de Montaigne (1533 - 1592), Lorenzo Valla (1406-1457), Rudolph Agricola (1443-1485), Mario Nizolio (1488-1567), Juan Luis Vives (1493-1540), and Petrus Ramus (1515-1572). 6. Marsilio Ficino (1433-1499) - the most important Renaissance Platonist. Modern Philosophy - 1. Francis Bacon (1561-1626) 2. Rationalists - Rene Descartes (1596-1650), Baruch Spinoza (1632-77), Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz (1646-1716) 3. Empiricist - George Berkley (1685-1753), John Locke (1732-1704), David Hume (1711-1776) 4. Political philosophy - Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679), Jean Rousseau (1712-1778), Voltaire(1694-1778), Giambattista Vico (1668 - 1744), Cesare Beccaria (1738-1794), Giuseppe Mazzini (22 June 1805 - 10 March 1872), Karl Marx (1818-1883), Fredrich Engels (1820-1895). 5. Adam Smith (1723-90). 6. The German idealists - Immanuel Kant (1724-1804), Gottlieb Fichte (1762-1814), G W F Hegel (1770-1831), F W J Schelling (1775-1854), 7. Existential philosophers - Søren Kierkegaard (1813-1855), Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900), Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980), Simone de Beauvoir, Karl Jaspers, Gabriel Marcel, Martin Heidegger (1889-1976), Albert Camus (1913-60) 8. Analytic philosophers - Rudolf Carnap (1891-1970), Gottlob Frege (1848-1925), George Edward Moore, Bertrand Russell (1872-1970), Moritz Schlick, Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889-1951) 9. Neoconfucianism - Xiong Shili 10. Neo-Vedanta - Vivekananda, Aurobindo and Radhakrishnan 11. Kyoto school of thought - founded by Kitaro Nishida Contemporary philosophy 1. Martha Nussbaum (b. 1947) 2. Cornel West (b. 1952) - pioneered the school of “neopragmatism” 3. Slavoj Žižek (b. 1949) 4. Gayatri Spivak (b. 1942) 5. Gu Su (b. 1955) 6. Postmodernist philosophers - Jean Baudrillard, Jean-François Lyotard, and Jacques Derrida 7. Structuralism/Poststeucturalism - Michel Foucault, Jaques Derrida I may have missed many but this is all too much to finish anyway. 😂 Good luck everyone! 🙂

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Quite a list. There are few, but don't forget African philosophy like Zera Yacob or Walda Heywat. Here's a playlist on African philosoophy for anyone that is interested kzbin.info/www/bejne/rpOZZpqufstkn80

[@hashamkhan4220]

Cool journey!

[@ahmadsalama6447]

Logic has become wild and that's awesome

[@isaacowen9021]

uhh, why does the graphic for Applied Ethics say "STOP GIVING WELL?" (27:12) GiveWell is one of the best organizations out there..

[@sarahjanequinn1882]

incredible!, such a clear voice, what amazing work, thank you so much wow! :)

[@havenbastion]

Science is rigor (or the body of knowledge thereby accumulated). Logic is a sub-set of science - relationships that always replicate. Math is a sub-set of logic that deals exclusively with rigorous relationships of quantity.

[@dixztube]

boy hats off to the artist

[@marcelfsilva]

It is incrible how much human being can create and think. I get anxiou because how we can handle so many knwoledge and which is the best new ism that are being created right now

[@sami_is_freeYt]

Just a correction idk if u fixed it in a different video or not but Buddhism is also an Indian philosophy, so would love to see a video on how Buddhism went from Indian to all Eastern asia

[@0.381mm]

a great map. i can feel the soul of Philosophy in this map. the more i watch, the more i dont understand. and the more i dont care.

[@صبريبنبوزيد]

It is really interesting to see how the general approach can differ from a country to another. I study philosophy in France, an Analytic philosophy and logic for example are hardly taught here, we mostly study continental philosophers. There are many modern anglo-saxon philosophers after Mill we never mention. For instance, we never hear of William James ! Many do read his work of course, but it would cross the mind of nobody here to count him as a philosopher of the XIXth century whose influence could be compared to the influence of Nietzsche or Hegel ! Thank you for this video ;)

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Continental and analytic are quite divergent traditions, I suspect a lot of it is the language barrier since the analytic styles are fairly ubiquitous in the English speaking world, but continental styles are much more common in Francophone countries. We barely touch on Husserl, Heidegger, or Sartre, but spend a lot of time on Russell, Wittgenstein, Carnap, Tarski, and the like.

[@MinionNoMore]

Thanks a lot! I love your work! and I think this should be mandatory when you arrive at any university :)

[@pursuitsoflife.6119]

From domain of science?

[@Max-nc4zn]

Depressing that they instead throw philosophy out the window and make postmodernism mandatory at any university regardless of the degree.

[@obuyWw]

Absolutely love your tone of passion

[@broxy6350]

As a computer science major I was wandering if you guys do discrete Mathematics . Since alot of course is based on the fundamentals of logic like ours.

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

We do set theory, logic, theories of proof, and their implications. Godel's incompleteness theorems, Tarski's proof of the undefinability of truth etc. So I would say that we ahve some overlap with discrete mathematics, but there are things that they do that we don't and plenty that philosophy, or even logic does which they don't, at least not explicitly (Things like deontic logic, or epistemic logic, though I know some CS gets into temporal logic). Hoepfully that helps!

[@broxy6350]

@@CarneadesOfCyrene Thanks. I have looked into Godels incompleteness theorem it's really interesting I am looking into purchasing his book.

[@TheKievsash]

Great work! Do you plan to make it an illustrated book: Map of Philosophy? Or maybe a video course where all sections covered? Just wanted to add one more item to medieval philosophy - Augustinianiam and Thomism are representatives of scholastic western philosophies and there was also eastern romanian empire (Byzantine) greek philosophers: Basil the Great, Gregory the Theologian, Gregory of Nissa, then pseudo Dionisius Areopagit, sant Maximus confessor and then sent Gregory Palama. 
Western scholastics and eastern philosophers has different view on God’s essence-energies distinctions and Trinity (Filioque for westerners, energy as created power vs energy as God's modus of existance on the east) just FYI

[@hundhund183]

ohhh my god i just saw this pop up in my subscription box. I'm so excited and thankful for this!!

[@FerozKhan-ss9nn]

Great video and great contribution to the watching community…

[@alwaysincentivestrumpethic6689]

Am blown away 👏👏👏 !!! Beautiful

[@CarneadesOfCyrene]

Thanks! And thanks for watching.

[@mitchellstirzaker4694]

This is great, but I can explicitly read that you are an analytic philosopher. I personally don't find Logic to be the centrepiece of philosophy (although I am trained in logic). I would name the centrepiece (if there must be one) as something more along the lines of ontology (explicitly not Metaphysics); I am currently studying 'What is Being' (or, what does it mean to be, or, what does 'is' mean) through the work of Martin Heidegger. I also note that Edmund Husserl saw phenomenology as that study which would be the basis for all philosophy. His claim is debatable, and in fact I'd love to hear others views. I would place myself more in the continental tradition. Why does it always feel so hard (and I mean this in the sense of ones personal thought), to bridge the analytic continental divide. It feels like they are different disciplines.

[@reiusballa]

I totally agree. This is a potentially useful map for analytic philosophy. But I mean, luckily I found out that he said that himself: "Existentialism and Phenomenology are generally considered Continental Philosophy, and while I briefly mention them in the discussion of other philosophical traditions, I intended this map to focus more on analytic philosophy." which solves our point. A lot of people don't recognize Continental Philosophy, I would even say it has less value in the Academic context.

[@havenbastion]

The base of philosophy needs to be divided into three, each with its own tools and aims; a) Academic Philosophy is about organizing people, history, and jargon. Answers and solutions are optional. b) Practical Wisdom is the ordinary meaning of philosophy by ordinary people. It's always contingent on priority (including perspective (including knowledge and embodied experience) and salience) and solutions (custom action plan) are the purpose. It includes axiology/aesthetics, ethics (formalized morality), and politics (ethics + scale). c) Truth Wisdom is metaphysics (including mereology) and epistemology (including logic) and provides answers (actionable framework of understanding).

[@1991jj]

"continental philosophy...if it even is its own seperate thing" Said like a true analytic philosopher 😂

[@WoolleyWoolf]

Intro had a tone similar to John 1: 1-15 (“In the beginning was the Word…”) lol pretty funny, great grand intro ;)

[@L3Di07]

Hi,is this available to download as a powerpoint document?Would be happy if i could get an answer

[@gualmicol6845]

Is the definition of classical logic as formal logic only part of analytic philosophy language and definition, or is it the same in continental philosophy? I mean that sometimes we refer to classical logic and classical philosophy with reference of classical Greece, while we also sometimes speak of formal logics (variuos types of formal logic).