The Miraculous Quran - An Introduction to I'jāz al-Qurān

[@UsamaKhan-xs9do]

A well structured and beneficial lecture, JazakAllah . I have a question. Some non Muslims pose the argument that the challenge to imitate the Quran is (audhubillah) invalid, because who is going to judge whether a piece of literature composed by someone is like the Quran or not? They say that no matter how well of a piece of literature someone produces, Muslims will simply say that it has been deemed impossible by Allah that it can be similar to the Quran, so this is a challenge that is impossible to meet from the get go. So how do we respond to this argument? I'm not sure if I have explained the non Muslim argument correctly though.

[@MuftiNafis]

@@UsamaKhan-xs9do there would have to be a body of experts in Arabic who would act as judges. These experts can be Muslims and Non-Muslims alike on condition they are honest and without bias. They would prove their lack of bias by explaining the eloquence found within the participants entry using the rules of sarf nahw and balaghah.