The Most Extensive Study Yet of 'Havana Syndrome' Turns Up… Nada?

The people with this mysterious group of symptoms are suffering, but from what? Two new studies try to find the answer.
www.medscape.com/viewarticle/...
-- TRANSCRIPT --
Welcome to Impact Factor, your weekly dose of commentary on a new medical study. I'm Dr F. Perry Wilson of the Yale School of Medicine.
Imagine you're a diplomat, or analyst, or an intelligence officer stationed in a country that's hostile to the United States. You're in your room at the embassy, or hotel, or safe house, trying to get some rest when, suddenly, you feel a pressure in your head, perhaps accompanied by a high-pitched ringing. You feel dizzy, disoriented. The strange part? A clear sense of directionality - the sound and pain seem to be coming from somewhere. Weirder still, as you stand up and move about the room, the sensation changes; certain places in your physical space make it worse, certain ones make it better. Are you under attack?
The cluster of symptoms I'm discussing has an official name: "anomalous health incidents (AHIs)," which is about as descriptive as "unidentified flying object," but you probably know this condition by its original moniker, Havana syndrome.
It was 2016 when the first cases were reported by US personnel stationed in Cuba, though over the years US government employees stationed in China, Europe, and even Washington, DC, have reported similar symptoms. The case count rose into the hundreds, and then above 1000.
The news media were quick to suggest that there was a foreign enemy involved. If you look at the headlines at the time, it appeared almost as a given that this syndrome was due to some kind of weapon:
- BBC: 'Havana Syndrome' Likely Caused by Directed Microwaves - US Report
- National Defense: Doctors Reveal Details of Neuro-weapon Attacks in Havana
- The New Yorker: Exploding Mojitos: The First "Sonic Attacks" Targeting Diplomats in Cuba May Have Taken Place 30 Years Ago
But as the cases increased, the case for the mysterious ray gun hypothesis diminished. Would countries all around the world be sharing this technology? Beyond that, what was the purpose of a weapon like this? It didn't kill its target; it didn't even really incapacitate them (although some affected individuals had symptoms persist into the long term). Was it just supposed to mess with us? The idea of secret weapons became relegated to the tinfoil-hat crowd.
There are, of course, other explanations for the syndrome besides ray guns of unknown provenance. The affected individuals are under a tremendous amount of stress, doing jobs that many of them can't even give us details about in territory which is potentially hostile. Could these events be manifestations of that stress? Some have suggested that Havana syndrome itself is a form of mass hysteria, a boogeyman syndrome propagated not by pulsed energy weapons but by word-of-mouth and word-of-media from diplomat to diplomat, from intelligence officer to intelligence officer. The very stories of the syndrome heighten the stress in those environments, putting these people under more pressure, making them more susceptible to the syndrome.
The distinction between psychosomatic disorder and attack on our own personnel could not be more important. One calls for support and treatment; the other, potentially, for counterattack. Figuring this out is not only of scientific interest but of national interest.
And figuring this out has proceeded across multiple fronts, including animal studies. The pentagon has reportedly been testing directed energy weapons on ferrets to see if they can recreate the syndrome.
But for today, we are going to examine the latest report of the National Institute of Health's AHI Intramural Research Team, who measured, well, almost everything you can think of among patients with Havana syndrome. Their results appear across two papers appearing this week in JAMA.
- Acute onset of head-auditory symptoms
- Nearly simultaneous vertigo or pain
- Strong sense of directionality
- Absence of alternative medical conditions
The rest had less typical presentations. The study also included 30 "vocationally matched" controls who were asymptomatic.
The cases were pretty severely affected: 33% had a reduced capacity to work because of ongoing symptoms. It's worth noting that the cases and controls were not perfectly matched at baseline. Prior to the AHI, those who would go on to develop Havana syndrome had higher rates of depression, tinnitus, and peripheral neuropathy. Of course, as you can see, the rates of these conditions went up dramatically after the AHI.
Transcript in its entirety can be found by clicking here: www.medscape.com/viewarticle/...