The Most WTF Christmas Performance Ever? (Analysis)

[@deanantony8620]

Dinah deserved so much more from the group. One of the best vocalists in any girl group.

[@vellbariaofficial]

Dinah has a strong ear ❤

[@krisrose6329]

She had great vocals but crappy breath control and looked too old for the group… she should have been a soloist from the jump and she would have been better

[@raythornton5218]

@@krisrose6329 she has asthma and they were always making them dance

[@krisrose6329]

@@raythornton5218 I had no clue 😂

[@Xoxo0xx0]

@@vellbariaofficial She's always wheezing in their live performances tho lol

[@lisamarieagain]

Lollllllllll “oh, thanks Camilla”

[@WonderKingE]

Me every time she tries to harmonize 😂😂

[@wildnfearless9840]

*Camila

[@nekokurokawa6684]

Honestly same

[@Hisdaughter92]

I was like "Shut up Camilla...you had your chance." 🙄 "Go ahead, Dinah!' She was the ONLY one on point! She saved that intro.

[@RD-oo6yq]

Like that was absolutely not needed but thanks I guess

[@tajsimms8976]

They really sang this song as 5 soloist in a group lol

[@VideosForYou90]

Dinah really saved this whole performance. Btw not surprised, I saw them live in concert back in 2015 and I've been to a lot of concerts - none was as MESSY as theirs lol. Dinah carried them back then as well and tbh Camila did alright too. Lauren looked bored like she wanted to leave the whole time, she barely danced, Ally sang well but kept messing up the choreo and Normani got overshadowed the whole time. It was still kinda fun and these girls have a special place in my heart haha :)

[@richmaxmchalliwchester1984]

Dinah absolutely slaying every part she had, she was perfect in this performance and kept us alive during this mess. Ally had some of her weaker days, what she did was fine, something good, something ok, there wasn't anything really bad but compare to her standards no. Camila is in her own world this whole performance and her voice is there with her, some peppermint Christmas rainbowland probably, because that's only scenerio that makes sense to me after some sounds that came from her mouth this performance, she took some risks which is fine but she probably shouldn't, and this was top of possible nasality, Girl, you and your voice own my heart but this nasality is killing me, it was too much even for me and that says something. Lauren was out of breath and little rough this performance, she was probably tired, they were performing a lot around this time so i give her a pass. And Normani girl, i barely noticed you there and you were pretty pitchy almost whole time. I love Fifth Harmony, i'm big Harmonizer, these 5 girls own my heart and they always will, but i can't be biased, i have to be honest and i think in this performance they showed everything a girlgroup shouldn't do. Every single one of them is trying to steal the moment for her, there's no balance, they do and fail unnecessary note changes just to outshine each other. Lauren and especially Normani are overshadowed by Mila, Ally and Dinah. Non of them maybe except Dinah is focused on what they're doing. They're not very much in sync whole performance. And line distribution could be little more fair but that's not really a problem because everyone had lines that suited them, but still.

[@nathanielgao8771]

Lowkey the line distribution didn't always suit them... like a loooot of camila lines could have been handled by dinah and they did NOT make use of Lauren's tone

[@bydivadream]

@@nathanielgao8771 they all clearly have their unique gifts which is why their distributions rarely made sense. Camila has texture and attitude but if you want soaring clear high notes, Ally is perfect and if you want soulful chesty belts, Dinah is your girl. Lauren and Normani have such rich low notes too so with Camila, it's like she was decent at everything but not the best at anything

[@nathanielgao8771]

The problem was we didn't really neeeed camila's texture and attitude every single second of every single song, which is pretty much what happened 😬 the "pop voice" excuse also doesn't quite work, because ally has a good pop voice and dinah normani and lauren are very versatile

[@Luca-hb5xs]

Dinah absolutely did not slay every part, every falsetto was weak and shaky, and that one upper belt she did was sharp af. But out of them all still the best in that performance

[@kattjeans]

“Oh thanks Camila… back to Dinah” I’m screaming 😭😭😭

[@DDQ96]

Dinah saved the performance. And Ally too

[@neilwritesstuff]

Ally and Dinah really carried them vocally omg

[@lamine428]

Watching dinah’s face during Camila’s part had me dead 😂

[@anothermixer]

Which part?

[@ellesnzeyimana6893]

​@@anothermixeryo if you're still wondering, it was the very first part at the intro. Her face behind camila 😅

[@NIJEECAPRICORN23]

Dinah and Ally were ready to perform this song

[@irvins25]

you should make more videos analysing dinah, she always was, is and will be the best vocalist of fifth harmony by far.

[@Leigh-Anneisthebestinlittlemix]

Ally was the best then Dinah in second place

[@irvins25]

@@Leigh-Anneisthebestinlittlemix no, dinah has better vocal range and vocal technique even since she was in xfactor.

[@soprano2087]

@@irvins25 Ally have better belting technique and head voice Lmao

[@irvins25]

@@soprano2087 but her low register is bad honestly, dinah improved a lot on her lows, but ally i don't feel she has improved on her lows.

[@llllll7686]

@@irvins25 dinah's lower register is average and the gap between her n ally in lows is too slim but ally's belts are way better than dinah's and ally has solid headvoice

[@AM-dd6dx]

Off topic but Patti still served incredible vocals despite everything working against her in that performance.

[@tajsimms8976]

Patti?

[@aintnootherfan]

Professionalism and talent in its purest form!

[@damyanthelion]

@@tajsimms8976Loool if you don’t know then you need to watch. It has to be one of the most hilarious Christmas “performances” of all time😂 Type in “Patti Labelle ‘This Christmas’”

[@AM-dd6dx]

@@tajsimms8976 Patti Labelle's "This Christmas" performance. He shows a flash of it at 0:25.

[@iremhatipoglu9536]

I honestly can't understand how Camilla was the fan favourite in this group lol

[@lepidoptery]

i never paid attention to this group before she grabbed her opportunity for a solo career and just ran for it, but i have to assume because she's the thinnest

[@cookiejar111]

I would love more videos in this style! They're entertaining, giving your knowledge of singing, and hilarious! 💖

[@jesusgarcia5197]

Dinah and Ally were always the best vocalists ... when they were all standing still lol.

[@niccole3542]

They should have just had Dinah sing the lyrics and the rest just do background vocals cause she was carrying this performance.Love the energy Ally had though.

[@nathanielgao8771]

As always, dinah carrying again... 🤭 any of yall remember her on the psa tour 😍 I'm a harmonizer and I didn't think this performance was horrible but uhhhh...wasn't great to be completely fair I do think Lauren sounded mostly fine and for the most part ally sounded solid 😩 normani wasn't horrible, camila kinda was but it's ok we all have off days!

[@SuperPianogirl123]

I don’t understand how Fifth Harmony lasted so long because this performance was the quality that they were at consistently. No harmony, just chaos.

[@tatum635]

Nah they had a lot of great performances ppl just point out the ones that were chaotic lol

[@Xoxo0xx0]

@@tatum635 they were always so messy

[@anjalitamang6511]

@@Xoxo0xx0 their destiny child tribute ,I'm gonna love you I'm gonna loose you cover are some of the examples of their great vocals bias creators never highlighted them while making videos about 5h

[@tatum635]

@@anjalitamang6511 and just to add their “let it be” and “anything could happen”performances on X factor Today show “worth it” “Work from home” aria hotel And “thinking about you” and “they don’t know about us”covers are amazing too

[@anjalitamang6511]

@@tatum635 yes these are were amazing .let it be is my fav

[@bydivadream]

Dinah just owns the chest voice and of course Ally is their queen of high notes no matter what. Also - this was filmed at 7 in the morning so it's understandable why there was some shakiness

[@annaliseyhowe7874]

Dinah rolling her eyes at Camila gets me everytime😭😭

[@notyou666]

Dinah & Ally were and always will be the best VOCALIST of that “group” that once was 😂 the whiny voiced one had her days too, but ya know…

[@WonderKingE]

Dinah and Ally suit songs like this! I wish they had better management so they could have done more unit songs and promotions and even given Camila a solo since she cannot work with other people 😂😂

[@edu.8552]

mark my place as first, gonna edit later. Dinah has a golden voice, really stand out. She saved this performance! Merry Christmas, everyone ~

[@Sloppyjoey1]

Nothing like some FESTIVE tea for the holidays! Dinah - is the only one who's ever in key. It's tragic how little she got to sing in the group because she's by far the most versatile and consistent. Camilla - Great gowns, beautiful gowns. Ally - Same issue I have IRL, just a brassy big and loud voice naturally. We over support and shout because the voice is naturally "belty". If she pulled it back just a tiny bit she'd be in a great place. Normani - So much untapped potential, she sounds like she's close to a very unique but "good" style but she's just inconsistent. However I'm surprised how much she sounds like Mariah here. Loren - Ugh I love her tone but why is she alllllways horse?? I wonder if she has vocal damage. Her pitch and intonation are good but her voice seems so weak and fragile even in the middle. IMO they were doomed to fail, they just sound wayyy too different have seemingly had no interest in working together. They should've been forced into practicing choir principles.

[@guardianofthegalaxy2051]

Not the ‘beautiful gowns’ 😂

[@allanmhanson]

American groups used to dance and make great choreo before kpop. TLC, Destiny's Child, 3LW of course PCD slaying the world. Not to mention the late 90's and the whole 00's were a dance floor, BSB, NSYNC, Usher, Britney, Chris Brown, Omarion, Ciara, Etc, and it all started with Michael and Janet. So i don't think their dancing was trying to emulate kpop, they were always making covers of clsssic girl groups.

[@ashkanmirani2625]

Dinah really carried

[@jesusgarcia5197]

Starting off a song completely a capella is hard asf.

[@rhanna12]

“That was a choice” 😂😂

[@willgpb_]

Of course the best Fifth Harmony member saved the day

[@alclark3771]

Him : "Ain't no other fan" Also him : "Fifth Harmony's haters" I agree with his opinion. But, he never makes positive videos about 5H. I mean watch "Like I'm Gonna Lose You", "Destiny's Child Tribute", etc.

[@buddhibahadurtamang1295]

True he never did he is a 5h hater that's clear

[@anjalitamang6511]

Yes literall fifth harmony hater

[@billiekyle]

it is somehow strange how they made us think that camila was the best vocalist in the group but dinah was actually the ace of the group, always carrying flop harmony in her back, yes camila is great now but in her 5H days mmm great is not the word i’d use to describe her

[@annaliseyhowe7874]

I would also this shows a lot more especially on their last album, dinah was doing a great job on almost all of the songs too

[@dovrilo]

She just had a distinct voice. So everyone thought she was like the beyonce of the group but, her distinct voice goes so far when autotune and studio production is not involved! She sounds like a child singing with a cold. No doubt her voice makes her unique and stand out but she didnt train it to be a power house like the others. Her runs sounds like it's her first try going at it lol

[@f3rzz476]

@@dovrilo considering the girls successes, Camila is definitely the Beyoncé of the group 😅

[@mkaeganhall3545]

fr camila is horrible

[@dovrilo]

@@f3rzz476 lol true 🤣

[@timn11.04]

You should analyse more of their performances

[@hiatusmode989]

Camilla was a whole mess in 5th harmony, i dont get why people were obsessed with her…She is a whole lot better now( Good for her)

[@lamine428]

Let’s be honest most kpop groups don’t have the mic on

[@lisadinahson2002]

@@debutriah2854tbf this is 5H with 0 back track just live vocals groups like itzy and Nmixx who sing live still have backtrack and itzy last few encores have been weak chaeryeong has been carrying their live vocals in their encores

[@debutriah2854]

@@lisadinahson2002 they’re also doing choreo that is a thousand times harder lol 💀

[@lisadinahson2002]

@@debutriah2854 encore is literally them just standing and singing with no back track and they struggle. They sound better when performing with choreography and backtrack

[@debutriah2854]

@@lisadinahson2002 whatever you say lol

[@lisadinahson2002]

@@debutriah2854 so salty and for what💀

[@mixerscarlet9762]

If some kpop idol gave that same performance this man would have praised them

[@anjalitamang6511]

Same he is so biased since he literally 5h hater and too much on kpop ass

[@GetWellSoonR.E.M.]

Not middle school talent show 😭😭 I’m crying

[@nathanielgao8771]

Im ngl tho they have a lot of great performances that I really think u should acknowledge more instead of only showing the bad clips

[@millieboon]

Even dinah was like what’s that annoying sound when she is singing as her eyes shift 🤣was she expecting Camilla to join in🤔

[@Kevin-rg3yc]

I knew from this performance that they weren’t gonna last tbh 😂

[@MultiStan1516]

Dinah has the best ability and that’s one thing you must have to cover Mariah’s songs

[@ilovemusic7840]

Love the shameless plug for kpop haha nice singing in the end btw

[@timn11.04]

I think they did a better job at the Christmas Tree Lighting performance

[@maloneaqua]

I don’t get the issue with Ally… she did the best IMO, vocally she was perfect with the exception of one part. Dinah’s good but she is so falsetto dependent and I don’t get it Camila… ?! Why does she always attempt a flat note?! Its not a pretty sound

[@imuzz]

Dinah enjoyers go watch her last 2 performances on her channel she's so slayful

[@imuzz]

Dinah is and will always be the main slayer.

[@hi.im.kstina]

After watching this video, I will urgently go to watch the performance of Little Mix - Babe please come home, I urgently need a dose of a good performance

[@LuisGustavoSO]

They have a live performance of this song and it's equally good

[@mixerscarlet9762]

​@@LuisGustavoSOlittle mix is still better

[@LuisGustavoSO]

@@mixerscarlet9762 I was talking about Little Mix

[@anjalitamang6511]

@@mixerscarlet9762 5h also had amazing vocals performance but unlike little mix they were never highlighted And don't say little mix is better until you see 5h real potential on vocals

[@nachobaeza]

Ally slayed idc idc

[@125loopy]

I feel like only the last 2 kpop groups you linked did well. The others sounded... kinda bad? And they're not even singing anything vocally complicated. When I discovered Little Mix, 5H made me so sad. They're definitely 5 soloists vying for control. Their breath control was also really bad. Dinah was great in this performance, though. She's been terrible in some others...

[@jlolxd]

the ending omg you slayed

[@mixergend5998]

not you posting this as the same day as camila left lmao

[@aintnootherfan]

The fact I had no idea makes it even better😆

[@xsctar_kpop]

*"i love camila's old voice"* camila's old voice:

[@plaguedoctor2k]

Camilla could've saved that baby goat voice to her self. No hate just criticism.

[@brandoncole5533]

3:33 you can't say that and then throw up a clip of NMIXX that's not fair 😭😭🤣🤣 When you know damn well what they're talking about 😭😭😭🤣

[@FranRoseV]

The SLAY at the end though 😍

[@aintnootherfan]

Oh wow, thank you!😇

[@mcgradyazul5667]

this was one of their "not best days". but i disagree with other people saying dinah was the most consistent member of the group. she was a hot mess on 7/27 promotion and tour.

[@sobaito]

yesss, i love her and she's amazing but dinah was not consistent. her breath control during the reflection and 7/27 eras... we harmonizers even created a whole ass narrative saying she had asthma to kind of justify it lmao

[@mcgradyazul5667]

@@sobaito in terms of agility, I must say Dinah is the most consistent. but performances in general, Camila takes the cake with her breath control and amazing stage presence.

[@iosashes2087]

I have to disagree here. She was very off during their promotional stuff especially earlier in 2016 but she NAILED the 7/27 tour every single show. Breath control was great, energy great, and the only member to not lip sync a single note. I think because she seemed to get nervous and breathy on most of their television performances that year (BGT, BBMAs, Kelly & Michael, etc) that people remember her as constantly struggling, but when I go back and watch the tour videos she was actually killing it.

[@iosashes2087]

@@sobaito she does have asthma. There are literally videos of her saying she had to leave to go use her inhaler and then using said inhaler. Nobody made that up. Some of the other girls’ fans just started randomly saying it was a lie bc they didn’t like how people praised her voice over the others because as much as ppl think 5H hated each other, their fans were the ones that actually did lol. What people don’t remember is she was instructed to change how she sings by their label during the 7/27 recording if she didn’t want to get left off most of their songs. That’s why she sounded lighter and thinner for the next few years. If you followed her post-5H, she’s talked about it and having to learn how to sing with her old voice all over again, among other lowkey horror stories from when she was in the group.

[@sobaito]

@@iosashes2087 I'm not in any way against Dinah, in fact I agree she's the best vocalist in the group and she's definetely one of the best performers. Yes, she delivered great vocals on the tour and showcased an insane growth from her reflection and better together performances, but during tv promotion she was constantly stuggling with her breath (which is normal considering the tight schedule the girls have with almost no rest). That's why I said she was off during the 7/27 era, because although she was great on tour, on the broadcasted performances and the award shows ones she wasn't at her best. I also know the producers told Dinah to "baby up" her voice because it was too soulful, which ended up in her not singing in Boss and Sledgehammer (and half of Reflection), and the many other horrible experiences that she and the girls had to go through when they were in 5h. About the inhaler I've also believed it was from when she got bronchitis back in the day (which caused her to have breath control issues at that time), but everyone started to say she had asthma and I sort of run with it, but I never knew if it was actually true or a made up story from that. I LOVE DINAH, and I still support her to this day, I'm hoping she drops some new music soon because I love her entire repertoire, my faves being Heard it all before, 1501 and Missed a spot. Anyways this wasn't intended to be a hate comment in anyway, I love and support the 5 of them and it's undeniable that Dinah was the one who slayed this performance (and many more)

[@tayab5575]

The only good Christmas performance they did was when they sung Sleigh Ride at Disney after Camila left

[@sahm6192]

It like you only highligh bad fifth harmony vocals.

[@daytonsouthall1137]

Because they're not the strongest live vocalist

[@iosashes2087]

@@daytonsouthall1137 they literally have tons of examples of strong live vocals. People just choose the messier performances to highlight.

[@tajsimms8976]

@@iosashes2087 they have very few

[@iosashes2087]

@@tajsimms8976 not true. Most people who didn’t follow the group very closely have not seen the majority of their performances. People cherry-picking videos that highlight them in a negative way isn’t actually a reflection of the group as a whole.

[@tajsimms8976]

@@iosashes2087 if you have to follow them super close then they don’t have many videos

[@haritamang6763]

I mean you're indirectly saying 5h is worst vocal group ever.always down taking them

[@plaguedoctor2k]

Each one of them tried to do their own thing. But...they might as well have done...nothing. 😬

[@mixerscarlet9762]

He shows us the kpop girl groups like we were supposed to be impressed like most of them except mamamoo had legit speak sing and still was pitchy like little mix and mamamoo are the standard

[@tatum635]

Why is he always dragging 5H. They have so many amazing performances

[@shaquilleheadley5759]

I mean Mamamoo kills it everytime

[@iosashes2087]

Been a little heavy handed on the 5H criticism lately but you gave Dinah her flowers so I’ll allow it lol. One thing I’ll say about Fifth Harmony was that you had to be following them closely to really appreciate them as a concept. Those girls’ main goal was for their fans to have FUN (and we did). Comparing them to K-pop groups, Little Mix, DC, etc doesn’t really work because that’s not what they were and not what they tried to be, and that’s why a lot of the criticism is odd and overly harsh. I often think about what Simon Cowell said almost everytime someone asked him to describe the girls and the main thing he always said was they were very “excitable”. And I think that’s reflected in a lot of their performances especially when they were younger (most of them are 17-18 here). They’d get very excited during bigger performances and sometimes that was good and sometimes it wasn’t. Overall for this performance, I think Ally and Lauren sound fine/good in general, but not their personal best. Camila has a lot of ease and creativity, but she’d sound better if she knew when to dial it down. Self awareness is key.

[@ndndndbdndnd3318]

But they’re singers so obviously bad vocals are critiqued

[@iosashes2087]

@@ndndndbdndnd3318 I never said they shouldn’t be. The only issue with 5H is people tend to only highlight their worst vocal moments while highlighting other groups’ best. If we’re comparing good to good and bad to bad, that’s a different story.

[@RichRichification]

@@ndndndbdndnd3318 ok but this man brought up groups like itzy nmixx and dream catcher and red velvet when the 5h girls are clearing every single girl in all those groups minus Wendy and maybe Lily plus if we can it's not hard to find bad vocal clips of RV and itzy especially.

[@RichRichification]

Also kpop groups are extremely manufactured and inorganic they practically have to perform how they do because it's so competitive

[@soprano2087]

@@RichRichification Ally and Dinah are better than lily the only would be Wendy, and both Ally and Dinah are equal to her.

[@RenaG]

3:51 they're barely singing along with a super loud backtrack though. it's realy not comparable to raw live vocals sorry

[@sofiaxanat]

oh wow, this is a Mess mess

[@ActingAndy]

Compare this to their Disney world Christmas performance pls 😭

[@annaliseyhowe7874]

One thing that annoyed me when fifth harmony would do live performances is the little runs Camila would do idk why but it just irked me. Don't get me wrong tho in some songs it fit the tone and sounded good but in others it was needed at all. The one that I dislike the most for some random reason is the note the she would do in the beginning of 'Like Mariah' whenever they would perform it.

[@lombardorbit4099]

when it's a group project but the grading is individual:

[@Xoxo0xx0]

Camila didn't even do bad, she was the second best in this performance but you seem to be anti Camila and too into Dinah's ass lol.

[@annyeong.]

3:37 oh thank you!

[@maxstellars]

all of their performances were chaotic, confusing and awkward. let's state the truth

[@daytonsouthall1137]

3:17 I'd take those "shaky" vocals over any k pop singer any day.

[@DeeDeeDeeeee]

You’re racism is showing hun

[@tajsimms8976]

And Kpop singers train since birth

[@jesusgarcia5197]

@@DeeDeeDeeeee Nah they just suck at singing live for the most part.

[@DeeDeeDeeeee]

@@jesusgarcia5197 not really, when doing complex choreos you’re going to sound breathy, shallow, or shouty it’d be impossible not to. Sure some groups aren’t the best vocally but there’s literally hundreds of Kpop groups out there.

[@jesusgarcia5197]

@@DeeDeeDeeeee There are only a handful of kpop groups out there that are displaying actually difficult choreography that would be excusable for having mid vocals live. Fifth Harmony did pretty good here overall for actually singing live without a playback. Not to mention it's extremely difficult to open up a song Acapella.

[@ayeshas5823]

I 💞 Fifth Harmony, this song and this performance, but l totally understand with your statement. (I’m not offended at all). Normani is my favourite member of FH!!♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@Leigh-Anneisthebestinlittlemix]

Same Normani all the way

[@ayeshas5823]

@@Leigh-Anneisthebestinlittlemix 😘😘 She’s the best. I love your username, l like Leigh-Anne too from Little Mix, but Perrie is my favourite.💞

[@darwinwatterson6865]

It's Christmas. Let's go home. wait.. wrong channel.

[@chaoticsoul1606]

Ig just stan little mix!!!!!!

[@Leigh-Anneisthebestinlittlemix]

Ngl Fifth harmony was a mess completely, they had a Great friendship and that but they're best solo

[@herrerah5169]

What are your thoughts on their Silent Night Shazam Session Performance?

[@phillinsogood]

Even tho I couldn’t stand this group, I will say I did like that they all had solos for most of their songs unlike other girl groups

[@kevinnguyen9268]

Dinah reminds me of Leona, Ally reminds me of Nicole, Lauren reminds me of Ariana (esp in tone), Even Normani here reminds me of another singer but I can't put my finger on it. This was so messy as a whole haha mostly on Camilla's part.

[@pedroramos-rd6dh]

There will ever be a video showing love to these ladies? It's been like 7 years since they don't even exist anymore, I don't understand the point. Nice video tho

[@renatogenesjosejr.8843]

this is y i stick to little mix

[@anjalitamang6511]

Because you don't watch 5h since most of the time they slay but got ignored but one time they fail biased people like him attacks but you do you little mix still has failed vocals as 5h at the end of the day

[@anjalitamang6511]

Can you like appreciate 5h vocals for once although this is not their best vocal moments but you heavily criticizing and comparing 5h to kpop groups who use back track to hide their breathe and shakyness and lipsyncs somuch. We would take 5h natural shaky voice than kpop back track noise.and would you criticize if it was little mix or other grps ? You never gave 5h their flowers for their amazing vocals you always highlighting their worst vocal moments when their are ton of great 5h vocal moments why didn't you make videos about them and appreciate them.5h is amazing vocal grp Ally is proficient vocalist while no one in little mix is proficient.dinah and ally are above average while only perrie is above average in little mix .

[@krisrose6329]

Little Mix had wayyyyy better vocals than Fifth Harmony ever did.. yes they did have good performances but they weren’t a good group and their vocals were highly inconsistent. Vocally as a whole 5H wasn’t good unless they weren’t moving around a lot even then that was questionable. I agree with the Kpop statement although alot of them are regarded as some of the greatest vocalist there are right now. These girls had hella potential and could have been one of the greatest groups Ever but sadly they were mismanaged and underwhelming/inconsistent performers and singers. They all should have been soloists

[@anjalitamang6511]

@@krisrose6329 as a group little mix had amazing vocals with great harmonisation but 5h as a group never blended well with harmonies and also this bias creditor highlights 5h bad vocals and never appreciated 5h vocals even little mix had many vocals fails but he never highlighted them according to their vocal techniques 5h is better than little mix because there vocal ranking are Ally ( proficient) Dinah / perrie ( above average) Lauren ( average to above average) Jade ( average) Leigh Anne ( average) Jesy / camilla ( average) Normani ( weak ) Ally has best mix and techniques out of all the girls in little mix and 5h.have well developed head voice and consistent resonance Perrie regressed and lost sense of resonance and stability Dinah improved her Lows have developed head voice best agility among All of little mix and 5h girls and carry resonance Jade has no head voice support and strains too much In 5th octave and don't carry any resonance even lauren is one tier above her .

[@krisrose6329]

@@anjalitamang6511 when you’re right you’re right

[@anjalitamang6511]

@@krisrose6329 yep because I stated facts that delusional small mix fans can't handle

[@krisrose6329]

@@anjalitamang6511 and I think for the time that they were both groups LITTLE MIX was better but they’ve all improved and declined over the years so that’s not the case anymore

[@maifolau6996]

may you do a video focusing on Dinah Jane?

[@OfficialMashArt]

DINAH JANE!!!!

[@KinnyKinKin4]

It’s just hard to take your critiques seriously when you constantly make comparisons to k pop groups who lip sync aloooooott as you can see in the videos you shared

[@jesusgarcia5197]

I will never understand the comparisons lol. Especially when it comes to live vocals

[@xylypotatohead3947]

Mamamoo and Red Velvet weren't lip syncing in that video the same applies to Dream Catcher. Not all Kpop groups lip sync all the time. Especially at concerts (the RV clip was from a concert)

[@anjalitamang6511]

@@xylypotatohead3947 but they do use backtrack a lot .only mamamoo and Wendy comes toe to toe against 5h dreamcatcher don't stand a chance

[@_birdie]

each of them is great in their own way, but in this performance it feels like they’re all just trying to out-sing each other.

[@stimo7060]

Ur outro was a choice but we appreciate it

[@christopheraguilar911]

Well when u sing like almost one of them then well talk

[@chhanadamnking7888]

Thats not bad at all... Especially the Intros

[@fajar4741]

Dinah ate Camila, as usual did the pick me thing Others were confused

[@jhaleriestebanbranes6931]

I'm the only one who thinks that they look more like a group when they were in TXF

[@kaelynsmith1242]

I always felt like they were constantly trying to out sing and dance each other and it shows on stage they always looked like they were soloist collaborating instead of a group performing

[@bre_me]

I love 5H

[@d1amondsproduction]

Can you react to the Girl Group of sisters named Cimorelli. They have unreal Harmonies. It’s mind blowing. You should react to their acapella covers from back in the days

[@heyhiimchrisnevejj7380]

Little mix, spice girls , destiny child, great representation of western gg 5H is not , music wise maybe but anything else NO

[@lyd2460]

Not spice girls they suck live .

[@heyhiimchrisnevejj7380]

@@lyd2460 oh 💀

[@GuysLuvJeonghan]

Nmixx are cackling I'm sorry 😭😭

[@vellbariaofficial]

Hun, they started semi tone lower than their backing track’s key

[@luukassl]

Tbh dinah’s head voice are a bit flat but she sounded good with chest voice

[@rotta_rotta]

Mariah does a lot of riffs and these girls do very good riffs too but def too much lol

[@littlemixwillsurvivelittle976]

Listen I've enjoyed fifth harmony's music but when they perform I cringe of embarrassment. Seriously Camila is the worst person to be in a group with, she wanted her moments each and every time with her messy riffs and runs and annoying chipmunk voice. They all didn't sing well live most times but Dinah and Ally were pretty decent. They had no business being in a group together... zero chemistry.