The Ocean of Churn - A conversation with Sanjeev Sanyal

[@bibhuprasaddash4757]

Great to hear you two praising Odisha

[@srimantmishra2985]

I'm from Odisha, from Childhood i with my family observe Karthik purnima. During this day, we used to wake up at 4 am, have a bathe, with paper boats would go to nearest river and chant which is symbolic like give blessings when sailors departing to Bali and other places. The sailors were called as 'Sadhavas'.

[@sangeetamadhukargodbole4953]

Great to know. Maybe you should explore it more with your elders and write something about it? We need to understand and absorb these things, and who better than someone who has experienced it in some way.

[@mimamsa5557]

90% of India - Fan of Shah Rukh Khan. Me - Fan of Sanjeev Sanyal. If he were a vending machine I'd never stop putting coins in him to hear him keep talking. Soooo much info first hand--driving around the country!!!wow

[@gauravd231]

I get your fascination towards Mr Sanyal, he's a gem of a writer. But comparing him with SRK is not apt. They are entirely from different fields. Regards.

[@mimamsa5557]

@@gauravd231 OMG do u have to be so serious all the time?? Shah Rukh Khan is a metaphor for popularity.

[@gauravd231]

@@mimamsa5557 was not being serious , but felt it to be incongruous. Or maybe I am too stupid to understand such metaphors. Anyway, we both are in awe of Sanjeev sir's writings. We're on the same page there.

[@mimamsa5557]

@@gauravd231 Girls dropping like flies at the sound of k-k-k-kiran and sanjeev Sanyal giving a speech. In terms of first principles. Same thing. God! You just took the fun out of it 😐

[@gauravd231]

@@mimamsa5557 well I am stupid. 🙂

[@SubodhMishrasubEE]

I am from Odisha and I have lived very close to where Amish used to live as a kid, while doing my UG in an engineering school about 10-20 miles from Kansbahal. I love both of your works. More power to you both for writing about Indian history in a way we never read or appreciated it!

[@chirak8635]

ଭାଇ ଆମ ଓଡ଼ିଆ ଇତିହାସ ପୁନରୁଦ୍ଧାର କରିବାର ଅଛି, ଆମର ଇତିହାସ ଆମ ପିଲା ଜାଣିନାହାନ୍ତି।

[@drbiswajitsanyal838]

Mr. Sanjeev Sanyal has done a great work to revive Indian ansient history.His writing is simple and interesting.

[@TheHappyNisha]

It's fascinating to hear about the estuary of Kutch (ancestral lands that my clan comes from). Thanks for this conversation. - I see here many wonderful Identity-‘stretching’ observations and questions through this human struggle of push and pull, through comparison, through give and take, or give and receive - between which something new, balancing, resolving, evolving, loving, and beautiful is now arising. 🔥🌓⛈🌦🌈🌞🌿💫 We may wish to ask the question to our human soul region... “What is this something new and loving that is arising in my soul at this time? show me”. This is the key to the vital transformation from industrialised materialism to altruism (or rather a 'spiritualised' materialism - natural elements inside and out). We are being given an opportunity to process our old memories through feelings, so I must add that it takes individual effort in feeling all our human feelings too, not just to know it as facts, figures, and ideas. Time to churn the 'poison' from our oceans; our bodily waters of the Feminine, where utilised memory pictures reside. - Thank you for bringing this vital inspiration through brothers Sanjeev and Amish.

[@sanjivgupta1418]

What an excellent orator Sanjeev Sanyal is !

[@suchitakulkarni7085]

Very interesting session. Learnt a lot about Indian oceanic history from Eastern to Western. Sanjeev Sanyal is a walkie-talkie historian-cum-geographian, excellent narrator and story teller. Well moderated by Amish Tripathi. Thank you Amish and Nehru Centre for organising it

[@chirak8635]

18:30 credit goes to langula nrusingha deva, kapilendra deva and our veer Paikas warriors..❤️

[@dinkarsirsi3680]

Fascinating hearing Indian views of Indian history

[@Indra6065]

I love how Amish sir is geeking out 😂😍...

[@sachinkhale7513]

The history of the Maratha Navy needs mention in our history books which was built up from scratch by Chattrapati Shivaji Maharaj at the ports of Chaul and Kalyan. his admirals defeated the British the Dutch and the Portugese in many battles along the coast of Maharashtra and Karnataka.The Siddhis at the Janjira fort came from Abyssinia and tried to convert the locals to their religion by force.Many of the locals were taken as slaves and sold in the markets of Arabia.All this came to a Stop with the rise of Maratha Naval Armour.Their Admiral Kanhoji Angre defeated these Foreign Powers with far superior navies at Vijay Durg Fort near Sindhudurg in Maharashtra.His HQ were at Colaba fort near the then Bombay now Mumbai,where huge warships were sunk in the sea.These powers were in awe of the Angres and paid royalty to him to navigate along the coastline.This finds mention in their court documents and edicts.If not for the Maratha Navy our entire coastline would have been dominated by these Foreign Powers.There is a mention of the Maratha Navy sailing right upto the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.Let's try to put more light on their exploits for our future generations to know that we have defeated foreigners many times over. Jai Hind Jai Maharashtra.

[@amritasikdar]

So happy to have come across this channel.. beautiful discussions..

[@tapemaj]

Such a huge wealth of information compiled by Sanjeev Sanyal and of course Amish Tripathi a notable author himself . Sadly , I am watching this in April '21 . Nehru centre - well done ! Shall drop by post Covid .

[@SoniSingh-fl8cf]

Please support Indian Authors like Sanjeev Sanyal, his books are amazing reads.

[@ShivonYoTu]

What an irony is named after Nehru, the very same person who is responsible for the suppression of true history of our great nation.

[@telmukund01]

Well studied & articulated ! Quite interesting facts were revealed about our history. Curious to read his book.

[@umadesai9515]

Awesome work mr. Sanjeev Sanyal, god bless you, keep up your great work

[@sadhnabhatnagar6816]

Very interesting and informative discussion Amishji and Sanjeevji. Need to read all this books now because I kept loosing the time line thread!

[@anupamavuppala9696]

Which is the book mentioned abt Lord Vishnu could someone help me plz …🙏tnq

[@sadashivputra1627]

Amish Sir. Pranam 🙏🏽 Makardhwaj was given Patal Lok by God Ram. Take a globe and pin it from India to the other corner... The opposite end has Honduras. Honduras has the Lost City Of Monkey God. And Patal Lok was considered exactly below the earth. Also Bhet Dwarka ( mentioned by Sanjeev Sanyal as a huge port) has the temples of Hanuman and Makardhwaj, is considered as a way to reach the Patal Lok.

[@TheKhapre]

So many things that we do not know.......... this all should be taught in schools!!

[@pulz1191]

So the idea that an Avatar of Vishnu brought Earth from a sea means that Ocean levels were way too high at a certain point in time... It's like how Dashavtar shows evolution.

[@htww1205]

Shri Vishnu not vishu

[@ETU672]

So happy to see mention of Odisha ☺️

[@sakshiarya9904]

So exciting and fascinating to witness the right think tank gain more eminence

[@arupamsanyal4771]

Amazing!!!! Bengal worked as a guardwall for Odisha.

[@chirak8635]

We are blessed ❤️ ଓଡ଼ିଆ love 💕 বাংলা

[@sitakantahotta6261]

Hmm.. when it could not guard itself, how it could act as guard wall for others?

[@ବିନୋଦକୁମାରବିଶ୍ଵାଳ]

Not true the Muslims invaded all over India except Kalinga they fought many years with kalinga and they got defeated and many temples in odisha made after winning wars against muslims, examples of temples made after winning many wars against muslims are konark temple,ananta vasudev temple etc

[@मनिष_चौधरी]

Romina thapper "Breakfast" intresting

[@gauravd231]

Haha true😂

[@VKMishra]

Great work Mr Sanjeev

[@vishwasaroraiit]

Great initiative, Amish. And of course always a pleasure to listen to Sanjeev. Just a suggestion, maybe next time or if possible even for this video please do a time and map illustration alongside to provide the greater context and much enhanced understanding of the topics being discussed. Kudos to both you !!

[@vijay-1]

Extremely important work

[@saitandale8482]

Love it ❤

[@bearcatsrock06]

great stuff.Thank you

[@sanjivgupta1418]

History that is taught in schools is not about Delhi bias, it is rather about Islamic bias. Since Center of Power of Islamicists was Delhi, our history was written with Delhi bias. This Islamic bias is ailing our entire thought process.

[@prarthanasharma2413]

He has certain similarities with Shashi Tharoor with the difference that SS is likeable.

[@meetankush]

SS is certainly likeable, for someone to look so unfathomed after the loss one’s wife and flirt with countless other women.

[@MayankAdv]

I request you to kindly help us know more about the Indian currency "rupya" which was the currency of many countries. 🙏

[@AnuSharma-kf1sq]

My favourites. Respect both

[@gayathriramamurthy736]

good stuff - loved it

[@ETU672]

Amazinggggg

[@AmanPandey-pf7rq]

Brilliant

[@ashokrajapurkar9816]

Hi , after Martand Verma, Mahadji Shinde, and Tipu Sultan defeated the English, sadly the victories were not conclusive .

[@chirak8635]

Odisha ❤️ ଓଡ଼ିଆ

[@vijay-1]

Very special

[@shshanksharma6371]

The great oriya king he was talking about is Kharvela.

[@kapilgarg159]

Great discussion. Kindly change the name of cultural wing to pandit bhim raj or other suitable personality. What did Nehru ji did that cultural centre is named after him. India has produced so many excellent artists and this is disrespect to all of them. Thanks Amish ji. Great regards for you.

[@desibabaji8525]

Sadly place is called "Nehru" Centre... just like all other places Gandhi or Nehru who assisted in whitewashing real history of India.

[@SaurabhKumar-ej5kw]

Rename this... Let it named after Tagore Or premchand... Forget Nehru... He ruined indian culture..

[@daksh7811]

❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@49jayant]

🙏👍

[@ntkomi207]

Sanjeeb da,you are already contributing much to india as economic advisor...why not appoint bhardwajspeaks to rewrite history...

[@jeandean3070]

plz why play a LOUD 5 SECOND COUNTDOWN BEEP IN YOUR INTRO? ITS LATE AT NIGHT AND IT YOU WILL WAKE MY NEIGHBOR WHEN SHE HEARS THE OBNOXIOUS NOISE. PLZ REMOVE. I SUPPORT YOU. DONT PLY INTRO LOUDER THAN CONTENT DONT WAST YOUR DEAR VIEWER TIME WITH LONG INTROS. 15 SECOND IS A LONG INTRO.

[@chirak8635]

Sir please write odia history ❤️🙏🙏🙏