The Political & Security Scenario in Gilgit-Baltistan and J&K - Part 1

[@ArvindSaharan]

Kindly Note: The show was conducted in a webinar format not a debate. The intention is to make people aware of the ground realities of each region. In the second episode Ashok Bhan Ji (Senior Advocate, Supreme Court of India) will speak on the internal political situation in Jammu and Kashmir and the relocation of Kashmiri Pandits. In the third episode Maj. Gen. BK Sharma (Director - United Service Institution of India) will talk on the security scenario in J&K, Pakistan-China nexus, What should India do to enhance it's security profile and bring peace in the region? Part 2: Internal Political Situation in J&K - Will be published on Tuesday 6th October 2020 Part 3: Resettlement of Kashmiri Pandits - Will be published on Tuesday 6th October 2020 Part 4 - The Security Scenario in J&K and Pak-China Nexus - Will be published on Thursday 8th October 2020

[@Cookingdi-t1e]

U should teach major news channels how to conduct a sober debate hatts off 🤗

[@saranglonkar3050]

Arvindji, thank you for the info. Look forward to watch. Great job.

[@ArvindSaharan]

Sarang Lonkar Thanks for your kind words. The new parts are out now.

[@rambhaipatel7321]

Sarang Lonkar ?

[@puranchandra1465]

F

[@devandernath211]

जुड़ना चाहते नहीं जुडे़ हुए हैं हमारे भाई बहन जय गीलगिट बालटिसतान की जय अखण्ड भारत

[@bkpjaiswal2166]

उयययययययययययुययुयुययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययौययुयुययययययययययययययुयययययययययुयययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययुयययययययययुयययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययययुयययययययययययुययययुयययुययुयययययययय

[@sonu_dewan]

गिलगित बाल्टिस्तान भारत का था और हे और हमेसा रहेगा 🇮🇳

[@divyarathor9992]

This was very informative, and brings clarity about the situation of people in Gilgit-Baltistan. Thank you Arvind for inviting the right people, and moderating this talk efficiently!

[@sanjeevgjoshi]

I really like the way you introduced the panellist and allowed them to respond and not rushing through the Introduction.

[@jayommk6950]

बसानी साहब के कमेंट बड़े नॉलेज और ज्ञानवर्धक हुए हैं वाकई उनका ज्ञान गिलगिट और पाकिस्तान पर या जम्मू कश्मीर पर तारीफ ए काबिल है हम इज्जत करते हैं उनकी धन्यवाद

[@gurusoni4173]

हम सभी का dna भारतीय ही हैं। ये सच हैं जल्दी ही अपनी नदी अपने सागर से मिल जाएगी।

[@renusharma2467]

good analysis

[@apoorv7289]

Bashani saab always talks truth with logic.It is a big treat to listen him.

[@satishbaunthiyal1744]

These people are really intellectual who can guide the society in right direction. Excellent talk. Thank you very much each one of you.

[@vinayaksharma9207]

Dear Arvindji namaskaar. I m following ur program since long. I first heard d views of Bashanisaab on tag tv n later on ur program. Sir i appreciate d format of program ur gdself introduced. This format analysis d complete scenario of current situation. Thank you. Hatsoff to you mr.saharan for this शानदार show. Kind regards.

[@dharmendargoswami4906]

Arvind bhai.. aap ka program bahut hi best hota bcz.. n koe shor n koe kisi ko disturb karta h.. 6th, 8th October ka wait karuga.. God bless you bcz .. aap se bada hu .. so .. Ashirvad ..

[@thakorbhaikharwa9486]

Very good question by Ashok ban

[@indiannapo3485]

Don't worry we will take it right time.

[@umerfarooq6146]

Kab Ayo gay tea tyar karan

[@kandannatarajan9908]

Bhashani Saab is a scholar of this area and knows the entire details clearly.......such brilliant man of understanding history and aspirations of people of GB SHOULD be in limelight And part of every and any solution of Gb

[@rohitm8694]

Thanks for Arvind sir who took this decision to organize this type of event ... Most informative video to indian ordinary citizen ...

[@kalimohansingh6070]

धन्यवाद। बहुत विस्तृत और विचारात्मक प्रस्तुती।

[@rohitm8694]

Welcome Hamid sir .gilgit baltistan hindustan ke saath hi develop kr payega .sachhai sacchayi he .

[@nageshsharma9366]

Mr. Bashaani aap India ke Hero paterkaar hain 🙏

[@manmohansharma4875]

Bashani sb is an excellent analyst

[@mukeshchaturvedi3893]

Very nice informative and straight discourse by Mr Bashani. Thanks.

[@dharmendargoswami4906]

Arvind bhai namaskar... please maaf kariyega kafi month se aap ka program dekhta raha bt aaj subscribe kiya... good night A bhaiji...

[@gordhanbhaichhabhaya1644]

Nice information

[@vinayaksharma9207]

Also plz inform about d next part. Regards. Vinayak@saharanpur.

[@rajeshsingh-rj4jw]

Arvind ji I like way u represent show ,very well jai hind ..

[@sunilpatil8748]

Barrister Hamid bhasin is a REAL OPINION

[@amjadawan4980]

Welcome my dear brother arvind the great

[@ArvindSaharan]

Thanks Amjad bhai

[@harshitrajawat8436]

@@ArvindSaharan watch "Ghalib kamal", "Pakistani Mulhid" and ex muslim Spartacus

[@Saj393]

जय हिंद सर Jay hind sir namaste vande mataram

[@WaqasAli-yx3dm]

jai ma bharti हिंदूस्थानि vande mera L

[@vaadsamvaad3382]

Girgit Baltistan is part of India ... Plebiscite not required....

[@mazhussain3470]

Hari Singh had no writ tin GB, the GB people liberated themselves from tyrannical British imposed regime of Dogras.

[@mazhussain3470]

@su jdv "Wiki" hahahahahaaaaa

[@krishnabhan6098]

@@mazhussain3470 jk purchased by Dogra maharaja.He acceeded to india.

[@mazhussain3470]

@@krishnabhan6098 He had no writ in the state, he was in no position to decide it's future as he had been comprehensively rejected by the people, you're own PM Nehru ran to the UN and stated to the world the people of J&K will decide their own destiny.

[@krishnabhan6098]

@@mazhussain3470 by that logic I can say the farook Abdulla has times and again declared that Kashmir is integral to india. UN is almost redundant.Even by UN terms pakistan has to withdraw from all parts of Kashmir.Pakistan has donated part of Kashmir to China.And that does not pain you.Pelebicite is out of question. World knows what muslims did with minority Pandits.Even that exodus is registered in UN. If the Maharaja who purchased the land was muslm.All of you would have shown your muscles.Thank god it was a hindu maharaja.

[@yawarmehdi1079]

Hello. I am from Gilgit Baltistan. It was good show with actual facts and figures. I just wanted to add something. Kindly discuss some basic issues which need more attention like the massacre in Gilgit , Demographic change, Lands gifted to China, FCR, Schedule 4, Khaalisa Sarkar, Abduction Cases of Nationalists, Baba Jan and 14 Nationalists Incarceration, Resources wildy and unethically distribution. The world needs to know these facts

[@deepakpanwar6204]

Ohhhh people should discuss

[@sudhirkamble2852]

पी ओ के की जनता ईडिंया में सामिल होना चाहते है.

[@balasubramaniamr7511]

Gilgit Baltistan, PoK and Shaksgam Valley legally belongs to India.

[@Tintin-gv9ir]

and Aksai chin and free Tibet too. Thank u

[@gbcilgilgit8467]

آلو کے پٹھو ہم گلگت بلتستان کے باسی انڈیا پر لاکھ لعنت بھیجتے ہیں۔ پاکستان ہماری جان ہمارا ماں اور ہمارا ایمان ہے۔ 15 لاکھ باشندگان گلگت بلتستان پاکستان کی سول فوج ہے۔ تم کیوں بیگانی شادی میں عبداللہ دیوانہ بن رہے ہو

[@balasubramaniamr7511]

@@gbcilgilgit8467 Translate your answer in English

[@ArvindSharma-ts9lf]

There are lot if human rights violations in Gilkit Baltistan as human rights activists have said in UNHRC . This is the first time that we Indians have seen. This is great victory of Indian diplomacy especially after Modiji assumed power. Any way, Modiji has already said that the territories occupied by Pakistan always hurt him.

[@meenarana6646]

Well conversation jai hind akhand bhart

[@QaziAnserAli]

I pushed on like button for this episode today from Pakistan, because it's less baised today with compare or previous episode,

[@ArvindSaharan]

Please watch the full episode. I am sure you will definitely like it.

[@QaziAnserAli]

@@ArvindSaharan yeah surely, I eagerly watcht your programe rather it is anti or pro Pakistan, I like to listen the opinions and want to know your thoughts, soon we will discuss the merit and demerits in the light of history,

[@praneshdixit9353]

Very nice Arvindji

[@swati.pwc15]

The instrumental music in the last of the episode gives the message of peace and positive vibes. Thank you@Arvind Saharan for the debate and music.😄🤗

[@adityajano]

Where is the second part sir

[@ArvindSaharan]

It clearly says in the end of the video that part 2 is coming out on Tuesday 6 October.

[@manmohansahu7984]

आप अन्य मेहमानो को बेकार ही बुला लिया, अच्छा होता हमेशा की तरह केवल बसानी साहब से बात करते। इस मैथेड से अन्य मेहमान ऊब जाएंगे।

[@nirwangope1508]

Ek chiz missing hai is debate me, 1947 me jitne gilgit baltistan ke log yaha the ab yaha kafi demographic change ho chuka hai, mujhe ye v jana na tha ab Pakistan ke dusre areas ke kitane log GB me aake ke rah rahe hai

[@waseemkhan-ms1kt]

Maharaja Hari Singh, the last legitimate ruler of a United Jammu and Kashmir (including my beautiful homeland POONCH) leased Gilgit Baltistan to the British for only one reason in 1935. For the British could keep an eye on Russian activity on Sinkiang, which was part of the great game.

[@sherali529]

Ma gilgit baltistan se hun hamy hamara haq diya jaye india sirof bayan dera ha hay gilgit baltistan hamara hay

[@Value_Pilgrim]

*THE FIRST STEP* For India is to rope in UK and make a representation to : 1. International Court Of Justice, Hague 2. Raise it at the UN. Please involve Barrister Hamid Bashani in the team. Because he has a good grip of this entire situation.

[@iammsk7090]

Whare are other parts if this is part 1

[@ArvindSaharan]

It clearly says in the end of the video that part 2 is coming out on Tuesday 6 October.

[@iammsk7090]

@@ArvindSaharan tq ..

[@bolebam]

Make this to share to more people in India and abroad. The people should know the real truth.

[@maratha101]

Pura episode dalo

[@mohadebsarker3573]

So beautiful analysis video

[@smartmel47]

Great job arvind ji ,

[@SnehaKumari-pc3gq]

🇮🇳Learn lessons from Tibet ......jammu & Kashmir people know this......🙏🏻

[@thakorbhaikharwa9486]

Basani sab Ka interview best 4 India Jai Hind

[@shankargade6165]

Bashani sahab is great.

[@naeemraza647]

Hamain basic Rights chahiyae jo country dae ga hum usi k sath h

[@ashishbhargava540]

Where is part 2????

[@onkarsharma1504]

The program is almost is on end. The other penalists have not had the chance to speak.

[@sachair2701]

yeah thought the same way...until i read part 1 in the description.

[@ArvindSaharan]

The show was conducted in a webinar format not a debate. Each panelist will give us a good understanding of the ground realities of their subject matter areas. Please wait for 2nd and 3rd parts.

[@sachair2701]

@@ArvindSaharan just one request,i respect bashani saheb but if possible see if u can have some more voices on GB...someone like senge sering, who is son of the soil.

[@ArvindSaharan]

Sachin Srivastava Sure. I ll try and reach out to him.

[@romeshchander8424]

What has done by congress party in 70 years with regard to jmu kashmir including GB.

[@indusreaction8664]

Where is gallvan vally ?

[@saranglonkar3050]

Bashani forgot that there are others in panel.

[@ArvindSaharan]

The show was conducted in a webinar format not a debate. Each panelist will give us a good understanding of the ground realities of their subject matter areas. Please wait for 2nd and 3rd parts.

[@praveennegi9608]

Arvind bhai bahut sunta hu aap dono ko.lekin aajtak Hamid sir aaj bhi aajad kashmir hi bolte hai Ye bat samjh nhi aayi Yadi mai galat Hu plz correct.

[@ArvindSaharan]

Pakistan Ke Us Hisse Ko Officially Azad Kashmir Ke Naam Se Jaan Jaata Hai. Isliye Wo Use Usi Naam Se Bulaate Hain. Gaur Karne Wali Baat Yeh Hai Ki Kya Wo Jammu Aur kashmir Ko Makbooza Kashmir Bolte Hain? Iska Jawab Hai Nahi - Wo Isliye Ki Hamare India Mein State Ka Naam Jammu and Kashmir Hai.

[@balluwarasi1883]

Create a new Gilgit Desk and Baltistan Desk in Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Ministry of Defence. Also Ministry of Culture must support Balti culture and language. Balti customs.and traditions must be put on youtube. Also allocate Budgetary support for investments and help to Gligit Baltistan. ..

[@sbgiri7671]

Indian farmers should stopped the agitation against krishi bill because this agitation has been mixed up with the khalistani. This agitation will be blamed due to the entry of anti-natinals and anti-socials with separatists forces in the agitation. We are Indians and we do not act against our country. If anybody is assisting khalistani, we will not spare them.

[@wafiahmed8055]

The majority of muslims in gb is 100 % this is part of pak not ind in any case if gb is not become part of pak then jammu kashmir include kashmir and pak becomee seprate from ind and pak

[@anjham]

There is no politics or security scenario here. It’s Pakistani soil period. End of discussion

[@surinderpal3121]

Good sr jl

[@mohammadirshad8199]

پاکستانی زندہ باد I s I زندہ باد پورا کشمیر پاکستانی ہے ہم بھو لے نہیں ہم لیکر رو ہیں گے کشمی کے بغی پاکستانی نا مکمل ہے

[@WaqasAli-yx3dm]

Mohammad Irshad ❤️❤️❤️❤️😘🥰🥰😍😘🥰😍😘🥰😘🥰😍😘😘🥰😘🥰😍😘🥰😍😘🥰😍😘🥰🥰😍😘🥰🥰😍🥰😘😘🥰😍😘🥰😍😍😘🥰😍😍🥰😘😘🥰😍😍🥰😘😘🥰😍🥰😘😘🥰😍🥰😘😘😘🥰😍🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰

[@rajatsingh109]

Root cause of all problems created by ISI or Pakistani army

[@Khalidgujjar542]

No i think all problems we are facing right now Indian and Pakistanis people's only because Rss don't want peace in the region

[@Tintin-gv9ir]

@@Khalidgujjar542 the root cause is religion of peace which was used to divide our country . Lets be honest here and Jihad continues

[@Tintin-gv9ir]

@@Khalidgujjar542 and u are so illiterate LOL

[@DineshKumar-zj8hb]

Waiting for part 2

[@ArvindSaharan]

It will be published on Tuesday 6 October

[@sranganathaniyer5514]

Good debate.

[@surinderpal3121]

Good sr ji

[@bolebam]

The Indian guests are bored and you continuously talking to Hamid ji.

[@soniwaraich8273]

Arvind ji aj mujhe aj laga sahi debate Hui he nahi to ptrakar mostly khud jyada bolte he or guests ko debate he

[@QaziAnserAli]

It's good talk, But again manipulating Gilgit Baltistan, I think everyone have to right about talking but we have to clear abput inside territory and sovereignty of any Land, Gilgit is Pakistan, today Bhishani ultimately spoke out, hope he had some effects of criticism on him.

[@QaziAnserAli]

@Indian and people are with the state that is why from the beginning that decided to go with Pakistan,

[@sunilpatil8748]

ISKE PAHALE 70 SAL KI INDIAN SARKAR NOT THAT MUCH POWER TODAYS GOVT. IS POWERFUL

[@haritham186]

Yes gun is power. China gun is copy no power

[@ashishranjan1798]

Sir wire k arfaa khannum ko v ek baar m talk show m bulaye

[@jhanavkant3038]

Why our country was divided....?......for Hindu Muslim....... No..... What's the reason.... please make video on it

[@KrupaTrivediThaker]

@arvindsaharan sir, i like the way you conduct the discussion. Sir, I don't know where you live but if you are in Pakistan at the moment then please be careful. They might not like what you are doing.

[@stormiwebster917]

Part 2????

[@stormiwebster917]

Okkie

[@NasirAli-dq3qg]

Hamid has talked about the date and he has spoken

[@NasirAli-dq3qg]

The youth of Gilgit Baltisan want Mahtari themselves at this time.

[@bolebam]

You forgot to ask or react by the two Indian people. Please see how wonderfully Arzoo Kazmi takes KZbin videos when she gives equal time to all.

[@AshokSharma-it4iq]

समझ मे नहीं आता कि जब गुलाम काश्मीर मे सी पैक बना रहा है गिफ्ट मे काश्मीर का हिस्सा ले चुका हो तो कुछ नहीं तो बदले मे भारत ताईवान को क्यों नहीं मान्यता देता और तिब्बत की आजादी की मांग करता हांगकांग मे भी चीनी दमन की निंदा करनी चाहिए मोदी को इस संबंध मे तुरंत कड़ा निर्णय लेना चाहिए

[@badal1001]

Willing for peace is never a weakness,India and Pakistan can't change the boarders.please come to peace for both sides public prosperity.if someone is desagree ,must go personal to boarders to change it with out provocating ,poor population.

[@sherali529]

Hamid bashani sab or arnvhan sab good

[@GaneshKumar-ng9ku]

नाइस

[@taraknathsahani5670]

नमस्कार अरविंद sir

[@thakorbhaikharwa9486]

Modi sab Kuch bhi Karo Gilgit Balistan India me samil kar lo Jai Hind

[@aryanjeetu4843]

Great..

[@muhajir-hindustani]

اسلام و علیکُم🙏نمستے ہندوستان کو سنجیدگی سے گلگت بلدستان کے لیے فیصلہ کرنا چاہیے !اس سے بہتر کے پاکستان سب کچھ چائنا کو فروخت کردے🗣

[@JoydeepBanerjeefilms]

Why did the other panelists not speak. Also if basshani saab is so against india taking up the region let him spk so clearly. Why is he going round n round.aap raho sir pakistan mein Apne ko koi issue nahi. But kam se kam sidhe to bolo

[@ArvindSaharan]

The show was conducted in a webinar format not a debate. Each panelist will give us a good understanding of the ground realities of their subject matter areas.

[@manoharpatil6795]

भाईसाब अपसाबको प्रणाम. आपका हमारा दिनो एकही है. आप सब शांतीसे र हो . लोगोका विकास करो. काम धंदा करो. भारत के साथ छेडछाड मत करो. चिनी लोगोस अपणी बहु बेटीव्यवहार मत करो वरना आप चीनिके गुलाम बन जायेंगे.

[@ramnarayan7523]

Thanks to good subject

[@naeemraza647]

Kashmir na Pakistan ka h na India ka agr Gilgit Baltistan chahiyae toh dono country jang lar ly phr jo jeeta hum usi k sath jayain gy

[@mehrkhan6879]

Peoples of punjab whose left pakistan/ indus valley should work for the unification of iok and punjab with pakistan/ indus valley rather than live with un-natural unification with ganga - Juma civilzation. It is permanent solution sub continent problems m

[@rupohunzai6822]

May Gilgit baltistan ka hon oor yahan k 90% log pakistan may shamil hona chahtay hain.10%log kashmir ka hisa mantay hain.ya jo ap k chanel pay bol raha hy wo Gilgit baltistan ka nahi ic ko wahan k halat ka kuch nahi pata

[@QaziAnserAli]

It's your right brother, and now it's time to legalise your right, and thanks to India who gave you this opportunity after Scraping article 370,

[@taufeeqkhan2629]

Yes your name showing gbness 'hun' people

[@aakashnautiyal4823]

@@QaziAnserAli article 370 nd 35a .. Do you have any idea about these articles... Can you elaborate?? And do you know ground realities of kashmir??? You saw what your media shows to you ... Nd we know what is actually happening thier... Kashmirs are apprearing for upsc exams .. Aren't they getting chance nd rights to do things at thier own ways??? Things are like very different... Our govt abolish these articles they have thier reasons... Nd it's internal matter of india ... Even Pakistan is also a part of india.... And it's about only 70 years old You can't devide lands on the basis of religions ... It's our home we cant give it again and again.... Like you can't give you countries to others ...

[@Amazingview0]

Pura pakistan india ka hissa hai india kabhi bhi ispe claim kar sakta hai legally to tum kis khet ki mooli ho

[@QaziAnserAli]

@@Amazingview0 hahahahaha, beta asal me jab se China ne slap or punch Mar kr apke 50 foji Mar kr ladakh per qabza kr liya ha, or ab finger 4 tak a gaye Hain, or ab Arnacal per bhi claim kr diya ha, to tm log shok se bokhla kr mental hogaye ho, 😄😃😂😁😀😅 ability ziyada claim kiya na to abhinandan bna dengue, pori duniya ko phir bharat mata ki dikha den ge, vese tum logo ki ye halat dekh kr Maza Arha ha bohat,😄😃😂

[@Bluedeskz]

Arvind bha'ji kamaskam ek Gilgit Baltistan ka numainda bhi hona chahiye tha guftagoo mein.

[@asangha182]

I think Senge Hasnan Sering would be a great choice to represent Gilgit Baltistan at any forum.. He is a US based activist who consistently raises the point that GB is a part of India..

[@lonewarrior5827]

Pakistani army establishment and Indian government divided Kashmir , edar tum udr tum..

[@bolebam]

Bring in Senge Sering from Washington who is from Gilgit Baltistan and knows the real facts practically. Saw one interview of Senge Sereng with Arif Jakaria.

[@ajayindian1556]

IPL DREAMS COMES TRUE FOR JAAMU & KASHMIR SENSATION ABDUL SAMAD

[@gulzarshigriofficial1549]

Its a wrong statement by bashani that army alone deciding the future legal status of gilgit baltidtan,but army is being take series the 90% local population demands is province which long standing of people here.

[@RisingPakistan786]

Mr here we all pakistani including great people of GB consider themself as Pakistani and GB is always a part of Pakistan. No second and third opinion is there, Bhashani is a person who is misguiding the Indian keep it up Bhashani

[@bhishmapratapsingh8121]

Stop ur baseless statement which is no where useful to the people of Gilgit Baltistan. Go to gb n meet with people who will tell u reality.

[@bhishmapratapsingh8121]

I am very much agree with the contents of Mr Bashani who delivered clear picture of the fact.

[@itsmemayurpawar]

Arvindji Being moderator it's your job to make sure all panalist get equal time to speak

[@ArvindSaharan]

Mayur Pawar The show was conducted in a webinar format not a debate. We had three topics to be covered by three different experts on the subject.

[@itsmemayurpawar]

@@ArvindSaharan understood sir, my observation was because I saw other panalist were not focused when bashani sir was speaking. Rotating questions between guests would have made all panalist proactively involved into this discussion. But this was just a suggestion and not complain as I always enjoy listening to you and bashani sahab

[@ArvindSaharan]

@@itsmemayurpawar Thanks for your suggestion. I thought they were paying full attention. As I said earlier this was a seminar kind of format where the speakers spoke on the assigned topics.

[@milindupadhye7563]

Jai hind

[@malikilyas9126]

Why India is feeling for GB people now reason is that US backing the India to have fight because US invested in India from long time so now it's time for India to payback.Lets see how India tackles understands this because US frienship is more dangerous than enemity and India will suffer in coming days just like we are suffering from 70 years.