the standard for a KPOP sub-vocalist

tags: do, kyungsoo, xiumin, minseok, suho, junmyeon, lay, yixing, baekhyun, chen, jongdae, chanyeol, kai, jongin, sehun, exo, irene, joohyun, seulgi, wendy, seungwan, joy, sooyoung, yeri, yerim, red velvet, karina, jimin, giselle, aeri, winter, minjeong, ningning, aespa, superm, nct, girls' generation, snsd, fx, girls on top, sm entertainment, smtown, sm stan, talent, singing, vocals, runs and riffs, k-pop
All videos are used for entertainment purposes.
All videos and pictures belong to there rightful owners
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.

[@zhejiwooinkwangya]

She starts singing like this live consistently then we got another aespa member in A tier 🗣

[@foreverinsfired]

Giselle was good on Bb4 and Karina up to B4!! If only we got more of Giselle around B4/C5 to see how she holds up there

[@owbicstay]

💖💖

[@vietanhtran8241]

please do a vocal range video for Girls 💜

[@eternaldandaniexol]

not sure if I'll be able to but I'll try, I'm very busy these days lolol

[@himi_]

@@eternaldandaniexol i was waiting for your showcase but if you're busy i might do it myself 🧍‍♂️

[@eternaldandaniexol]

@@himi_ oh do it, wanna see aespa from you 🤠 and it's still early people haven't gone for them yet 😂

[@naviscalling2069]

I want to ask u abt something please please answer me - 1. Since karina has better lows, better agility, fuller support, wider range, better vibrato, better chest development, and giselle is more relaxed and cleaner, WHO IS BETTER SINGER??? - 2. Is karina D+/ C-, or C-, or D+ close to C-? - 3. Is giselle D+ or D/D+? - 4. In life’s too short live performances Karina has a high note in the end of the song, did she support the note live? And what note was that?

[@d.n.n2267]

1. very close between giselle and karina, but giselle seems a bit better because she has the least problems compared to karina.

[@d.n.n2267]

2. D+, Mid-high W-A

[@d.n.n2267]

3. Higher W-A (D+) same like karina, Karina's biggest problem is Shallow and giselle less shallow so Giselle better

[@d.n.n2267]

4. studio version its great but if she singing the runs she is messy! especially in they concert in LA

[@naviscalling2069]

@@d.n.n2267 but wasn’t she D+/C-? Many people told me that too? And her vocal range is C material but bc of shallowness?

[@bleblebelb]

Can someone tell me What does sub vocal mean?

[@eternaldandaniexol]

a sub vocal is technically a vocalist positioning without any special roles in the group unlike main vocals or lead vocals who take on more challenging parts and represent a group's vocal identity positions aren't indicators of how good amount of skills but they can do fine for estimations, however it may be inaccurate as some idols are more talented/untalented for what they are thought to be

[@bleblebelb]

@@eternaldandaniexol thanks!!

[@PureHoneyBoo]

Are Nayeon and Rosé D or D+?

[@eternaldandaniexol]

Rose is a D for me, Nayeon too she might be passable D+

[@Seulgi_bff]

can you write their supported range.?

[@d.n.n2267]

AESPA (Update) • Ningning: G3/G♯3 ~ C♯5 ~ Eb5 | C+ • Winter: A3 ~ B4 | C • Giselle: G♯3/A3 ~ A4/Bb4 | D+ • Karina: G♯3/A3 ~ A4/Bb4 | D+

[@eternaldandaniexol]

@DANIEL DN Bb4/B4 for Giselle is kinda a stretch considering we barely hear her sing that note let alone support it

[@d.n.n2267]

@@eternaldandaniexol ohoky 🫡✨✨ so based on support karina more stronger than Gigi but why in chart Sootzubae Gigi higher than karina? i know Gigi more cleaner but just it.

[@Sylvaincks]

@@d.n.n2267 - Karina had some more shallow moments, so Sootzubae dropped her to mid-high W-A - Giselle seems more consistent, even in fansign clips where Karina is shallow. - Giselle is cleaner, she has less issues

[@Seulgi_bff]

@@Sylvaincks Giselle low average?