The Terror On Stinson Avenue

March 2023 UPDATE BELOW ⬇️
On October 19th, 2021, a woman fled from a house on Evansville's west side. 1801, Stinson Avenue. She flagged down a police car with a frightening story to tell. A story so shocking, everyone found it hard to comprehend...
In March 2023, Heidi Carter was sentenced to a total of 65 years in prison for her part in the crimes:
www.14news.com/2023/03/16/wom...
Our email is for business enquiries only.
linktr.ee/trulycriminal1
Sources 📝
controlc.com/1570eebf
Patreon 🖤
/ trulycriminal1
Buy Me A Coffee ☕️
www.buymeacoffee.com/trulycri...
Thank you to Jupiter Productions for making all of our original music 🎵
open.spotify.com/artist/2rLqq...
/ jupiter-productions

[@lindamclarty3774]

At her 2nd trial, she was found guilty on all charges and sentenced to 65 years. However, she still maintains her innocence, which is nuts.

[@ewarrior9776]

Her boyfriend committed suicide by cop and left her to face justice for their crimes by herself. I hope she stews on that every day in prison.

[@MakeCaliNiceAgain]

She's just praying for a miracle. Although she won't ever get parole unless she fesses up and shows remorse. Which sucks for people who are actually innocent but it's great otherwise.

[@jjjks5]

Thank you for this update 😊

[@TheKnives777]

My wife and I felt bad and let a pregnant woman rent out our basement apartment, well it wasn’t too long before this guy calling himself her boyfriend started coming over and staying and it was fine at first until the problems began. We were out of town for the weekend and when we came home on Sunday they had trashed our house, there was blood on the walls. As I’m getting my stuff out of the car my neighbor comes up to me and tells me they had to call the police on my roommate because her ‘’boyfriend’’ beat the crap out of her! Plus the loud party they had that lead up to the incident. She gets out of the hospital the next day, tells me she doesn’t want to ever see this guy again and wants us to help get his stuff out of the house. This is when I find his bag that’s filled with broken crack pipe stems ,syringes, and empty bags of crack! Five days later sheriffs department breaks down my front door and serves me paperwork with a warrant for her arrest for jumping bail and not showing up to court six months before she moved in with us! She’s hiding downstairs and refuses to open the door and since I am the homeowner the police need to ask my permission to break down another door, but she finally emerges from the basement! Since then, we have never let anyone rent a room from us unless they provided background checks ,credit checks, and all the other credentials needed. because you have no idea who you’re letting in your house and that was a huge lesson for us.

[@trolojolo6178]

Horrible

[@sandrafaith]

Yikes! No good deed goes unpunished. Sorry you had to go through that!

[@poutinedream5066]

As someone with a less than stellar credit report, I'm gonna suggest that maybe - well, I guess it would tell you if they've taken out credit, run it up, and never looked back 50 times. Yeah, that would be a red flag I suppose.

[@TheKnives777]

@@poutinedream5066 Having bad credit doesn't necessarily make you a bad tenant, it's just a list of precautions that we decided on and it weeds out most people. sometimes people with bad credit just can't make their rent in time so it shows us that they are willing to go along with those requirements and possibly going to be a better pick then someone who doesn't pay their bills on time or already has financial trouble.

[@Oceans11.11]

Wow!!!! That’s scary!

[@AuthenticallyAlvarez]

Only guilty on ONE of the charges? Where the hell did they find such incompetent jurors? Jesus. That's awful.

[@SnarkierThan-U-R]

This was in the midwest? If the answer is YES, then NO wonder.

[@brooklyn8376]

Indiana. Doesnt surprise me

[@NoJusticeNoPeace]

It only takes a single irrational juror with a strong political bias to result in a mistrial. In fact, that's nearly always the case of a mistrial, because otherwise they are instructed to continue discussion. A mistrial only occurs when there is a deadlock which absolutely will never change.

[@LeeBv9983]

Mostly what you get for jurors are people that are on the dumb side. Smart and, especially, wealthy people can always find a way to get out of jury duty. For example, anybody having anything to do with the legal or law enforcement fields are automatically exempt as are those in medical fields. If you have kids under 12, you'll be excused. The reasons just go on and on, and the court never verifies any of this. You're left with -- bozos.

[@Leader-fq1dq]

The only other incompetent jury I can remember is the o j Simpson murder trial

[@cewe2003]

I am shocked there was a mistrial on all the other charges. The victim said she was an active participant throughout the whole thing. The witness also said she had possession of the gun. I don’t see how she can say something different and people go ‘oh maybe it was all the boyfriend.’ There was a victim AND a witness!

[@loveforeignaccents]

Yep, but hopefully the next jury will be capable of rendering the correct verdict.

[@jonnylumberjack6223]

I think it's more likely they felt that she was acting under extreme duress, and therefore shouldn't be found guilty, as opposed to thinking the victim and witness lied. With the level of detail given in this video, it is impossible to say how much of a victim she was or was not. I'd need much more information about the relationship between her and her boyfriend, as well as her own history, to come to a conclusion about that.

[@goblin-night]

Some juries are unbelievably gullible. Maybe the defence lawyer did a rain dance in court and the jurors were putting their hands on their heads out of concern for getting wet. How juries forget about smoking gun evidence and can't even get it right during deliberations is beyond me. Didn't the smart one realise the dimmies had forgotten what was revealed early in the trial and remind them?

[@loveforeignaccents]

@@jonnylumberjack6223 And who do you suppose would be providing info about their relationship when the man is dead? And it was stated they both had criminal histories. This case was and is to be judged on the facts and evidence presented as to what happened that night, not what had occurred in the past. Hopefully you won't be on the next jury.

[@loveforeignaccents]

@Last Chance Exactly.

[@richardmcgowan1651]

The man wanted to die by cop. Maybe because they knew they had been "found out". Also very much doubt it was the first time they did this.

[@fredajordan5704]

Richard i agree so much. At least 1 thug made the right decision here and saved society/tax payers lots of money.

[@sidstovell2177]

​@@fredajordan5704 Except leaving Heidi to cost the taxpayers....

[@brucej.willson4764]

​@@sidstovell2177She got one charge. She got female privilege.

[@spf_500]

Who has a dead body in the house and then INVITES someone over?!

[@coopasdad]

Exactly. Nobody does. For me, the whole story is hard to swallow..

[@HeyGirlHaaay]

For real.. at least leave it in the dryer if you're gonna use fabric.. 🤢 I'm aware of the bs that will follow this comment so before hand... 🤷‍♀️ deal with it? (The comment)

[@camillefields7443]

Who doesn't

[@coolhandcurtj7055]

Jeffrey Dahmer and Anthony Sewell come to mind. Both men had dead bodies decomposing in their homes, while continuing to invite "new friends" over for a stay.

[@yolandascholten2012]

For pizza!!

[@jeanieviola29]

I watch your channel because you tell the story. No background or carrying on about the city, state, or what everyone had for breakfast. Just the story, the facts. Thank you!

[@loveforeignaccents]

LOL. Right?!?!!

[@sugakookie7985]

True crime creator's are all different some do include facts about the victims, this is done to give them back their humanity, to put others in their place.

[@randal_gibbons]

@@sugakookie7985 crime victims also have family and friends that may be watching. It's good to try and soften things up.

[@randal_gibbons]

Warm blooded victims deserve more than just cold hearted facts.

[@Johnieboi]

Right? I hate the geography lessons in crime stories.

[@wendyatkins7945]

The fact that she left the house and went back without getting help, tells you she's guilty.

[@Justuravfrogmom]

Well... there's that and there was an actual live, thank God, witness, who said she did it...

[@reneegoode1155]

Agree 💯💯💯 F-ing A-right, she's guilty 🤦😤 It's incompressible to me, that a Woman could participate in such a VILE, DISGUSTING, & EVIL Act on a fellow female, at THAT !*!*! GROSS. IMO, they BOTH Deserve the damn Firing Squad, & Absolutely NO MERCY Shown to them,, the Same EXACT WAY, that they chose to not show a single OUNCE of Mercy to these Victims, here.... 🤦🤦🤦 SPEECHLESS 😶😶😶 Somebody PLEASE WAKE ME UP from this HORRENDOUS NIGHTMARE !!!

[@rullmourn1142]

A jury with no common sense.

[@blast3613]

@@rullmourn1142 The same people that vote for our leaders.

[@TheTimmynp]

@@blast3613 The same people that could judge you at trial. Scary....

[@altavanrensburg9423]

What a waste of time and money to save this terrible woman from prosecution. What more did the jury want? She is as guilty as sin and not worth saving. She will continue with her criminal activities.

[@fredajordan5704]

Alta : So very very true. Seems as if the worst kind of ppl. have the most luck. It`s all so utterly frustrating and depressing.

[@gordonaliasme1104]

She got 65 years at the retrial. She should have got lethal injection, but she will die ìn prison. Good riddance.

[@SnarkierThan-U-R]

Looked like a gun to me, and if it wasn't a gun he was certaingly holding it like it was a gun.

[@msvoyeur]

Thanks for the video. So much murder and mayhem in the news it's easy to miss stories like this one...

[@polarodriguez2924]

I use to bring in people who didn't have a place to live help them out as much as I could. I haven't done that in a long time, I don't think I can be that vulnerable again when shit like this happens ☹️

[@blairkimberlin3447]

the world is going to hell in a handcart and picking up speed. it sucks that people can't show compassion because it may cost them their life. i grew up in the '70's and remember the huge push to not hitchhike. i never did until a few years ago when i was almost 50. the lady that picked me up was about 75, i figured i could take her if i had to

[@ahzar4384]

​@blair kimberlin lmao correct. It's so many scary disturbing missing person/murder/assault cases from the 70s & 80s from ppl hitchhiking.

[@brandyyolidio4213]

That was kind of you, but we just cannot do things like that anymore too dangerous. All I can take in now are cats.

[@kaylakeefer1340]

I used to do the same. NEVER AGAIN. The last time I did, my apartment ended up in a huge raid by law enforcement bc apparently the guy had literally lied about everything, even his name, & was actually a big drug dealer wanted in ATL that was on the run. There's nothing scarier than having a bunch of men with guns kicking your door in while you're on the toilet.. 😩

[@fredajordan5704]

@@blairkimberlin3447 Let the good doers do that from now on! And all the CHristian church goers, then there should be no more needy soon.

[@waleedqamar39]

Happy new year everyone 🎉 Love and respect each other 💕

[@damionpalmer1011]

I'm so confused on how she only received one charge. The witness told them what she did and the fact that she left and came back without saying anything should prove guilt. You can't claim you were keeping up the act when you had every opportunity to report what was happening. This is just wild.

[@louiseboutin4266]

Anyone else wondering what the father and two teenagers saw and witnessed ? Very strange.

[@debrapaulsonphotography-da4857]

Yes very strange, and I'm also wondering if the 2 kidnap/killers had the same plan in mind for the "friend" Heidi called to help her clean-up. I'm guessing she would probably have been their next victim.

[@loveforeignaccents]

@@debrapaulsonphotography-da4857 She definitely would have been had she not been able to escape.

[@loveforeignaccents]

If they didn't see what had occurred, I bet they heard a lot of the torture and ultimate demise; something they will never be able to erase from their minds unfortunately.

[@narcawareness]

@ 9:12 is exactly why women are continuously murdered by their stalkers, boyfriends, husbands etc. So called law enforcement simply just “don’t take us serious” and that is fucking sickening as all hell.

[@mitchellriley433]

Happy new year everyone stay safe a truly brilliant channel!

[@commonsense571]

Happy Healthy New Year to you too🎉

[@lucyfruge]

The narrator/truly criminal team should be hired by the innocent project, experienced attorneys when they have a high profile, wrongly convicted, etc cases. The way they take the evidence, and present it all in order with such detail, there is zero doubt in my mind they could go on to change the world of criminal prosecution/criminal court. So much talent, and the narrator is just amazing. I love their voice, how calm, yet direct they are. Thank you for all the hard work you put in. The way you tell the story of the victims in every episode, I’m just astonished by. I have been a long time subscriber, but once I logged in with my other account, I had to sub again. Thank you for bringing such grace, respect, and kindness to every case.

[@sparkfadingspark]

How the eff did it end in a mistrial?! Were the jury members all brain dead?? I'm sorry, the fact that Heidi left the house and then returned without alerting authorities is enough proof to me that she was an active participant in the crime. Not to mention the living victim said she was actively participating and she has no reason to lie, unlike Heidi who has every reason to claim victimhood. A huge error in justice here, I hope the next jury has more sense.

[@ayladibiasio5927]

she was guilty on all charges

[@wc5436]

​@ayladibiasio5927 yes. 65 yrs

[@minervasowl7658]

​@@ayladibiasio5927 thanks! I was just going to look for an update and thought to check the comments first. 👍

[@Ekinnajay]

@Thou Swell All you have to do is google it and you can see for yourself. That's what I did.

[@sheribrougham4863]

Totally agree, the victim told them what happened what more do they need. Idiots.

[@dawnyg2951]

Best time of the day when a Truly Criminal notification pops up 😊

[@meddy8216]

There is a surviving victim!!! She straight up told them that this evil woman was involved. I know it's one persons word against another but come on...there was a witness to back parts of the victims testimony and I'm positive we all know who was telling the truth. Whoever on that jury that couldn't see the truth is absolutely useless. Hope she is convicted and serves whatever maximum time is allowed.

[@georgiastewart4479]

2 living witnesses

[@NatureLover-62]

How they couldn’t find Heidi Carter guilty on all counts is baffling to me. She was apparently an active participant and was willing to follow through on all of the crimes that were committed against that poor woman and man who lost his life from a drug fueled POS. I hate that juries tend to disbelieve women of rape when it has clearly been committed against them and the only saving outcome is that she survived physically(possibly) but emotionally she will need a great deal of therapy and unconditional support and love.

[@lc86_65]

Female privilege... right there!

[@broeheemed32]

"...disbelieve women..."? LOL You're delirious. There are countless men in prison for decades over women's False Accusation Culture. Women casually accuse men of rape for any number of trivial reasons, and their "testimony" is routinely considered fact.... no actual evidence necessary.

[@ar4203]

@@lc86_65 not being believed about rape that actually occured is female priviledge?

[@nothotdog1488]

"Apparently" isn't fact now is it? As for the rape thing, kinda hard to prove unless there is DNA evidence, even then you have to prove that it wasn't consented in the first place. You can't just go on the words of a woman, that's hearsay in definition. No jury should convict purely on a woman's word alone, there has to be evidence beyond doubt. There are many liars that bring doubt on real victims, that said no man deserves to go to prison for something they didn't do either.

[@calmislamly]

Women aren't held accountable in our society.

[@KhanaHatake]

Never could have guessed that drugs were involved /s 🙄

[@Tragic_Magic23]

Definitely looked like a gun

[@partytimejew3771]

I saw this comment THEE SECOND she said it

[@tinyGrim1]

Suicide by cop . You don't mess like that.

[@tinyGrim1]

@@partytimejew3771 freaky. I've had similar times like that. It's cool actually. Make a wish 🙂

[@honorladone8682]

Yeah!

[@briannastruble98]

It was an object made to look like a gun. Like, he had twisted something in the shape of a gun.

[@ShadowyFigure83]

Love the Channel, keep up the amazing story telling.

[@Karenanneseven]

Ditto 👌

[@AS-rk5zz]

Poor victim not being believed ,shocking

[@emke9326]

Sometime a jury just doesn’t get it. That’s why I’m not a big believer in a jury panel. How can 12 people who have absolutely no experience in law can make a decision? Casey Anthony is the perfect example. I’m having a hard time believing that sometimes the jury doesn’t base their decision on their emotions.

[@ahzar4384]

Casey is an example of what having a WEALTHY family with status can do for you. Seen it several times over the years. These wealthy families can pay off judges, investigators, police, ect.

[@MK1_games_other]

Sooooo true I’ve always wondered the same

[@brucej.willson4764]

​@@ahzar4384It's a female thing.

[@Sharonmxg]

I enjoy your content. Your narration is easy to listen to and well composed.

[@CourtneyTunbridge79]

These girls are wonderful aren't they, I love the calm cadence of this ladies voice.

[@ohhkayy0919]

It even looks like a gun in that grainy video shot.. if he would have come out like the first guy he wouldn't have been shot.. Definitely justified

[@commonsense571]

It looks exactly like that.

[@underwearmaintenance]

I wonder what is was?

[@tessfabled4115]

@@underwearmaintenance Maybe a toy gun/airsoft gun?

[@maxhonneger2761]

Sounds to me like a case of suicide by cop. Take a good look at "Carrie". Looks as though he'd been in prison before and was determined to never go back.

[@Celeste-Momstuff]

@@underwearmaintenance piece of plastic bent up and held to look the way it did. He was not going back to jail.

[@Karenanneseven]

Keep up the great work. It’s wonderful seeing your channel doing so well. 👌

[@PrincessPink433]

This is why you don’t rent out your home without doing extensive background checks on potential tenants, ESPECIALLY if you have a family with kids living there too. People can be smart and charitable at the same time. Had he took the time to look up her long rap sheet, he may have second guessed his decision in letting her stay. This case was all over the place and doesn’t make much sense but then again not all true crime cases do. There’s too many people involved and too many different things going on but maybe the truth will be revealed in time. I guess the court is trying to decide whether she willingly participated in the crimes with her boyfriend, or whether she really was forced to, as she claims. One of the suspects is dead so they can’t go to him to verify Heidi’s story, they have to rely on her to share what happened and she could be lying to save her own skin, since her partner in crime is not alive to refute or agree with what she says. If the teenage sons were found alive, they should testify too, because they probably witnessed some things as well. Hopefully the evidence, as well as victim/witness testimony, will shed some more light on what actually happened in the house.

[@docsamarra682]

Yes and no...I'm from SC and imma tell ya, I'd trust most Gs I know with my child long before some church goer without a record. JS

[@victoriajones9964]

⭐️Thanks for covering this!⭐️

[@LegumesEtFleurs]

This is one of the reasons why some people don’t help some people ‘in need’ anymore. You do not know these people. If you invite them into your home out of the goodness of your heart, you could end up brutally killed in your own home. Very tragic. The owner’s teenage children will forever remember the things they have heard on that unfortunate night.

[@windsofmarchjourneyperrytr2823]

Yup. Never hand druggies/alkies $$$. Bad idea.

[@jennifersaunders5547]

💯👏

[@supme7558]

Duh that clould happen even if you dont help anyone but the odds are very small you would more likely win the lotto

[@supme7558]

The one reason..no

[@sophiaisabelle0227]

Happy New Year. God bless everyone

[@jasminerussell9732]

same to you 😊

[@ollieandchloe]

Why did Heidi ask Cynthia to arrive at the home, so she can be killed, too? This was a bizarre case to say the least.

[@loveforeignaccents]

That was my thought, but luckily she was able to escape; or else she probably would have been a victim as well.

[@sugakookie7985]

Yes I believe those two wanted to do the same to her, if they'd managed to hold her the other young woman would have been murdered and they'd have don't the same sick actions to her.

[@dawnatkinson7704]

What I don't get is Cynthia said she thought she had sat on a body so whose body was it if Ivy's body was in the bathroom? And how did Jason not know someone was being murdered and tortured in his own home whilst he is there?!

[@Celeste-Momstuff]

@@dawnatkinson7704 she sat on Tim’s body, his girlfriend was the one in the bathroom. It’s a house split in two separate apartments. Jason and his kids lived upstairs.

[@loveforeignaccents]

@@Celeste-Momstuff No shit, Sherlock. That was stated in the video and was not the (rhetorical) question the OP posed.

[@alteridolriley]

Never thought I'd hear my childhood local news castors on this channel. I moved recently so I hadn't heard about this case but the fact that it happened in Evansville is not surprising. It is not a very good place anymore especially the west side.

[@JustAnotherNerd850]

Evansville was never a good place to begin with.

[@mattbarneveld815]

Update: Found guilty at retrial of “aiding and inducing murder”, “aiding and inducing rape” as well as “criminal confinement”. Sentenced to "65 years collectively" although I can't find if "collectively" means concurrently (and therefore what the actual minimum/maximum time to be served is) or consecutively (i.e. total 65 years).

[@chilenapromedioRU]

Thank you. I didn't understand the rape charge, but this one make sense and it's truthful on what the survivor said. Really bizarre case. With more people inside the house?

[@Wherethedeadwalk]

How could they not decide for the charges? It’s very obvious she’s guilty

[@Sharonmxg]

in criminal court the criteria for admissible evidence is very hard to meet. What often seems to an observer as clear connections between evidence and perp, actually proving those connections, beyond a reasonable doubt is a lot harder than it looks. It is incredibly frustrating to watch happen this way. All that said, That lady's lawyer must have been very persuasive in making her look like she was under duress.

[@iamV10010]

@@Sharonmxg thank you for being a voice of reason and explaining this. I've served on a jury before and it was a very eye opening experience.

[@jonnylumberjack6223]

@@Sharonmxg We don't know anything about the relationship between her and her boyfriend, or any of her own history. Presumably the jury do know about all that, and it must have been pretty impactful. Some people are incapable of standing up to their abusers, no matter the situation. Seems the jury, or at least some of them, came to the conclusion she was one of those people. It's nice to see some common sense in the comments, instead of instant judgement and hatred.

[@CourtneyTunbridge79]

@@Sharonmxg Well said. But its still pretty crap when there is a victim and a witness who are stating that Heidi was a very willing participant and they arent believed. I especially feel sorry for the victim, to be r.a.p.ed and tortured and then to have your testimony effectively disregarded would be extremely upsetting, as it stands she has no justice for what has happened to her. Fingers crossed the next jury puts more weight towards the victims account, the witnesses account and the fact that Heidi left the house for a period of time but didn't get any help and then later exited the house on police command with possession of the gun/murder weapon.

[@bfb187]

Good lawyer will paint a picture of acting under duress, show her as a victim. The police and landlord would have confirmed in court she was a victim of domestic abuse too…. Not defending her, obviously I don’t know the case but a good lawyer can do wonders and all they need to do is create doubt.

[@lefroy1]

Who hears a 'very loud and very definite cry for help', then tentatively sits down on a pile of laundry?

[@mollysmith605]

A drug addict who was promised money and / or drugs to help clean a house.

[@rudeinterplanetjanet]

I think you tend to disbelieve you heard what you thought you heard. And if you need money you maybe more likely to not believe what you heard.

[@sbrooke210]

I don’t understand how the oblivious homeowner had no idea what was going on in his house and where were these traumatized teenagers the entire time? These events were happening on multiple floors and the woman who he asked not to have anyone over had four different people over and he just has no clue?

[@CN-ek7nb]

Maybe they were not home when all happened

[@sbrooke210]

@@CN-ek7nb uh did you read or listen to the story?!!? 🤣

[@porfiriato84]

Yeahh I was thinking the same. This case had a lot to process but for that man to not know wtf was going on in his house is actually terrifying lol

[@staysea71]

There is way more to this story than covered on here. To anyone wanting to learn more, research the case online. The full story is even more crazy.

[@BarbaraP-bg5br]

Where can I find the story at. I use to date Carey Hammond. And he wasn't that kind of man. But prison changes people and so does lovev

[@WhisperingWitchASMR]

Suffice it to say, there’s a very good chance they didn’t pass that property inspection from the landlord.

[@bbyjscx]

Oh wow I had never heard of this, what a crazy case! Thanks for the video.

[@bbyjscx]

@user-zr5fz3kp7e where?

[@kennywilkinson913]

Happy new year everyone. Spent the evening with my mum and then watching truly criminal. Life's so much easier when you don't feel entitled, lie or murder anyone.

[@JustAnotherNerd850]

I’m from Evansville and know where this happened. Crazy to think something like this occurred in my own hometown.

[@danlhendl]

From where did they select the jury? A trailer park with a meth lab? Just a lucky guess

[@fredajordan5704]

Dani ; You might not even be that wrong about it....This jury was unworldly and more than strange, simply incompetent, and so was the judge. Good luck tax payers, this`ll gonna take a while here....

[@brucej.willson4764]

No, a crack house in the hood of Gary, Indiana.

[@heytam7162]

Happy New Year ladies. Thank you for all you do 🌺🇦🇺🦘

[@youtuber6193]

This is crazy. The fact that a man and his 2 teenage children were in the house and completely unaware that they had a dead body and a woman who had been tied up and tortured under the same roof as them and they were unaware. Completely bizarre. It’s quite likely that Carey and Heidi and were going to kill Cynthia too so they would’ve been waking up to a really awful scene if she hadn’t have escaped (although I guess they did anyway).

[@fredajordan5704]

KZbinr : In many many households chaos, loud noises, no kind of order or discipline is an evey day thing, Kids grow up to it and get used to it, thinking this is how it must be....And my thought is this went on for quite some time, too....

[@megatherion2695]

Frogs don't wear underpants

[@marcj4788]

Happy new year truly criminal, and your subs ❤🎆🎉💚🎆🙏

[@funlovingg363]

Happy new year 🎉❤

[@mountainman4859]

So they’re in the middle of having murdered someone and raping and torturing another - and she asks a friend to come help her clean? And then they let her run out the front door? And the man and his children upstairs don’t call the police but he tells his kids to hide? This is why you can’t let a homeless person into your home. You never know how stable they are, or what evil they might bring with them.

[@twistylox]

So, it's the homeless that cause these type of problems. Good to know, bc I thought it was the criminal element and not the lack of income of a person that should cause distrust. Forgive this facetious reply, but I loathe when people use opportunities to stereotype others they have disdain for ... ~ sincerely, a homeless person

[@SKC193]

Or anyone! Not just homeless!

[@christina12311979]

@@twistylox I mean, there is stereotyping and the truth. Anyone can cause problems and it doesn't matter who they are which is why you never let anyone let alone a homeless stranger move into your home. your home is your safety.

[@twistylox]

@@christina12311979 yeah, I almost said that. Let me just make it plain; a person is who they are based on many things. Homelessness, alone, is not what makes one untrustworthy, and more likely to kill you. And because one is housed doesn't mean they're less likely to ... Be Well

[@that1mikey]

Thank you always for the amazing uploads. Happy new year truly criminal team 🎉

[@andysmith5997]

Happy New Year to you both. I hope 2023 brings you every success. Thank you so much for your efforts again this year.

[@sidstovell2177]

Excellent work as always. Thank you.

[@micktaylor9332]

Is it me or does Indiana come up again and again and again on crime channels? It's like there's something in the water there that turns people into killers.

[@joebean3399]

Indiana is a scary place.

[@ChrisCosat]

Florida is up there as well.

[@sauce1232]

Indiana is 17th in the US homicide rate stats

[@windsofmarchjourneyperrytr2823]

I'll take country parts of IN over the "best" parts of Chicago ANY damn day. NY, too. They let criminals do whatever they want there.

[@heartbeatsdrum]

Wow, this was a wild one. Thanks for the upload today!

[@paddy160160]

This channel is second to none, fantastic videos, please keep them coming!

[@leo0986]

He came out like that as he wanted to be shot, saves him getting life in prison

[@ltheri64]

I love this channel. The stories are ones I haven’t heard a thousand times before and are handled very nicely.

[@fredajordan5704]

Lori Smith Absolutely.

[@nicky7096]

Great work on this ladies. Really appreciate the hard work you put into these cases 🤩 Happy, healthy & safe new year ❤

[@luisaruizgarcia4340]

Gotta love police making excuses after killing a human while they are investigating a murder case. Makes so much sense

[@Jebbreh]

He should have came out with hands up. Instead of coming out with something in his hands. It's common sense.

[@esther804]

Stupid juries, they have witness testimonies and all the evidence yet they think she is not guilty.

[@whatsinaname3561]

In March this year (2023), she was found guilty of all charges after the jury deliberated for 10 hours. She got 65 years in prison.

[@CourtneyTunbridge79]

Happy new year girls, hope this is another awesome year for you both and for the channel.

[@tinaschamp5772]

Can’t wait for the new trial!!! Interesting story, thank’s. Y’all do a great job!!! ❤

[@CourtneyTunbridge79]

What a bat shit crazy case, how on earth did that jury deadlock??? There is no way she is innocent, at one stage she was able to leave the house by herself yet didn't go for help, to me that makes her complicit. Unbelievable. I sincerely hope the lady that was r.a.p.ed and tortured gets all the help, support and love that she needs to recover from this disgusting traumatic event, I also hope that one day she will be able to find love again seeing as her partner was also murdered. Unreal. I hope the teenagers didn't get exposed to what happened in that house and aren't to shook up by the experience with the police and the shooting.

[@ericalexander5890]

An important fact to keep in mind about this case and the jury's performance: the people in the jury are from Indiana. Not exactly a bastion of intelligence located there.

[@ar4203]

I dont think people shpuld say that the fact she left/retiurned without getting help is 100% withput a doubt evidence of guilt- we KNOW people often do this if they fear for the safety of someone else being held. There has to be more evidence than that

[@fredajordan5704]

@@ericalexander5890 If the issue wasn`t that important it would be laughable....Sadly it`s not ONLY in Indiana that ppl. are either unworldly or simply incompetent in any way.

[@boop7313]

So many questions about this case. Why did she invite Cynthia over if all this was going on?? And when did the owner of the house and the teenage children get home? Or where they there during the rape and beatings? I'm so confused😵‍💫

[@Celeste-Momstuff]

To help her clean for landlord inspection. The others lived in the other half of the house, the upstairs apartment. Yes they were home part of the time but they said they didn’t hear or know anything.

[@ahzar4384]

The owner and his kids didn't get home until after 8pm according the father. The murders happened earlier that morning. So they couldn't tell anything was off initially.

[@Klara-Hvar]

I have seen this case before, there is much more behind the story, it all started in concert with drugs and snuff films and ended in catastrophic violence. They spared a trial with one murderer, but it took two trials for her to be sentenced to 65 years.

[@Tanyah-]

Happy new year Alice and Mia. Thank you for the best channel on KZbin xx

[@TrulyCriminal]

Happy New Year ✨

[@hayley44448]

Merry Christmas and Happy New year.thanlyou for the upload hayley New Zealand

[@ioanacontra5528]

I really lovd this channel and would love more content ❤️ Happy new year

[@laurametheny1008]

This is definitely new to me. Thank yoú.🙏💔 Happy New Year and stay safe everyone🎉🕊️

[@nancydaniel4716]

I absolutely love your content. Your narration is beautiful and well understood. Thank you so much. Oklahoma USA 🇺🇸 👀 ❤️

[@einienj3281]

Happy New Year Everyone! ❤️

[@Hannah-ks4mi]

Thank you Ladies and a Happy New Year to you too 💕💥💫🥳

[@hannahh6793]

Update: Heidi was found guilty on all counts in second trial. Sentenced to 65 years.

[@laykekelley756]

Its crazy this is my hometown and I currently still live here I totally didnt know about this story! Your channel is so great!

[@megadawg342]

At 14:00 the 2 pics next to each other. They look like evil.

[@patriciaoreilly8907]

Pure Evil 😈 video does not make sense 2 teenagers in the house

[@bribrifantastic]

Nicely put together

[@mandross]

Thanks

[@TrulyCriminal]

Thank you so much!

[@iamV10010]

Aww

[@gordonaliasme1104]

Thank you, Truly Criminal. Somehow your clarity makes the horrors more acceptable?

[@jenniferroach4153]

We didn’t believe her at first. But they showed up and treated it like the truth. Great job Indiana!! You put your job first! Excellent work!! You saved a few lives that night.

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

The cops seem oddly excited about what happened, referencing Dateline and the like. Even if they live somewhere that doesn't get much drama, it's inappropriate.

[@asdf3568]

She's 36 and she looks like that. Meth is a horrible drug.

[@cdd4248]

My exact thought

[@joanodom2104]

And CHILDREN were experiencing it ALL.

[@christinecauseimanevilcar4073]

Happy new year truly family ❤️🎉❤️

[@ivydickson7596]

I can't believe you are not at one million subs yet

[@ivydickson7596]

Can you do Scott Watson case in New Zealand? The biggest miscarriage of justice.

[@paulmagroin185]

So I’ve been watching quite a bit of these crime documentaries lately, and I’ve just noticed KZbin have started showing me ads about knifes, and they’re discounted. What the heck KZbin

[@jomama5186]

What is wrong with people anymore ??? I just can't understand this stuff even happening. How could anyone be like this? What causes this, or is it part of someone? Then what?? She is at least an accessory, but who even knows anymore. Sick, depraved world. 🧡 🙏

[@FlorecitaAngie]

From what I have seen with google maps 2023, the house is still the same😵‍💫, the curtains have not been changed, the house looks in bad condition, dirty, like the people who live there have no money to maintain the house🥴, what a frightening story...😲

[@leemanis9890]

She was found guilty in March and sentenced to 65 years

[@kat0726]

I don’t live far from Evansville, IN and I hadn’t heard of this case 😳

[@jessicabreen2961]

By discrediting the female VICTIM by resulted in a mistrial on the charges the surviving victim and Heidi being released that victim now could be in fear for her life! LE can’t be shocked if Heidi is ever found dead due to retaliation because of being let down! This is pathetic explanation of “justice”

[@Cyberwolf9999]

A shocking event, that he was so confident controlling 6 people 😳😢😡

[@freedomfirst5557]

Police should send in Drones to see if the house is truly clear

[@yolandawilson6619]

That would be great where and when it could be done but it likely wouldn't be feasible in most cases.

[@TriniLush7]

They can be knocked down easily.

[@Adrian-zd4cs]

All A person has to do is swat it and that's $1,000 piece of equipment gone lol

[@Go_Ask_M0m]

Hahaha. Ya. Like they have all this time to get ready and prepare for a possible hostage rescue. ​ Depending on the agency, the funding they receive and the qualifications of the tactical teams, there are MANY options. Some agencies have the SPOT officer. Some have gumption and a gun. They get shit done regardless.

[@bsqwahlE]

I think that's a great idea. Only a bad guy would swat it down. And, it's better to lose an expensive drone than a human life.

[@biged4476]

Happy New year Cheers✌

[@organismgel1043]

Whoa, this situation must be horrible for the victim's families... Those poor boys. Who knows what they witnessed, and to lose your dad and to know how disturbing his last moments alive must have felt like.

[@avnistar2703]

Wait what? What do you mean poor boys? Their father was ruled out and did not die.

[@alison4316]

Happy New Year, ladies 💝 I hope everyone has a wonderful night and an even more wonderful 2023 🎉🥳🎉

[@hightimecrime]

This case is very frustrating... How did they not find her guilty on ALL the charges?? Great video as usual friend.

[@SueGirling68]

Happy new year, I hope you have an awesome 2023. xx

[@henryklassen3362]

Happy new year!

[@banjomechanic]

The fact that she had invited over the girl who ran out seems like there is more to their agenda than we know. Seems pretty messed up to have killed a man, raped, tortured and imprisoned a woman and now she invites someone over to eat pizza and help clean? Had she not gotten away she’d be in a lot worse shape.