The Truth About the Beholder REVEALED | To Your Eternity [SPOILERS]

[@godsspear]

You ask an interesting question about the knockers--"Did the BHG create them?" I remember from the second (or third?) episode of the animated series when BHG introduced Fushi to the knockers. He said, "This is your enemy. It is a failure of life." That supports the idea that he did create them. Every creator has a trash pile of ideas that started strong but failed to work as planned. Knockers have a cruddy version of Fushi's ability to mimic and reproduce living and inanimate things. I can imagine that they were an early attempt to create a Fushi.

[@scarrius6590]

It could also be another celestial's creation. To either destroy the world or just for amusement similar to BHG.

[@zawwin1846]

BHG is pure fae or spirit. In order to create the world he had to take and trap the fae into mortal limitations. The knockers are fae that hope to free the stuck fae by killing them. When you kill someone, their fae is released and return back into its natural form.

[@supernaturalawesome1]

I think BHG likely created the knockers to provide conflict and growth for Fushi. They precipitated his travels and need to protect others. It makes sense.

[@JamesCameronWayaway-oc5mb]

Man shows us what's it really like of being a god/immortal

[@lukespetschanel]

Well i think fushi is incarnation as bhg and thats why bhg created him in first place

[@phillipwalters9462]

Wow some guy in the anime stab the beholder, see I know better the scary thought of stabbing being such as that almost level of the true Creator, bliss anime, spoiler alert

[@MersadieOlit0n]

Satan is not real satan is resistance the knockers are the resistance to test fushi

[@johnreedy2608]

I think bhg created the nokkers to get fushi off his ass

[@kameronmurphy4150]

Chad dad

[@thunderbudy]

Nah that’s god homie G

[@suryajeet2519]

You waste a lot of time before reaching to main topic .

[@guankzmm4176]

My brother in Christ there are time stamps

[@ergohash2517]

when BHG forgot Fushi i shed a tear

[@edwardsutherland8240]

Mans was so bored of being a god he ended up living a boring normal life.

[@tomsmasher7457]

I'm just going to copy and paste my theories here on what knockers are and the ultimate ending of TYE (we're on the final part now the future arc. Oima said there would be three parts to the entire series; past, modern, and future, so this should be the last part): After chapter 164 I have come up with a theory of the ending of TYE and Fushi and the knocker's existence. TYE is super interesting in the way that it parallels paradises. To the Beholder, he said that his world was "perfect" regardless of the tragedies. Pain and suffering are part of existence and though perhaps to a human a sad existence is not perfect, the world itself is a perfect existence to a god like the Beholder. To knockers, the perception of pain is unbearable and must not exist. Something that really caught my interest was when the Beholder told Fushi that if he inherited the Beholder's powers Fushi can make them - things that can do anything. Things that can live forever - as in a perfect paradise without pain nor suffering. However, this parallels to the Knocker's belief in perfection - a place without pain nor suffering and is what they have been fighting for, while our MCs have been fighting for a tougher existence - which is a super interesting parallel. My belief are that Knockers are fye from the gods/spirits/entities from the outside world where the Beholder used to exist or else were created by the entities outside in another world where there is no concept of pain nor suffering - a paradise (it also really interests me that in the first chapter of the story the nameless boy conceptualizes paradise the whole time as something he was trying to reach. I feel that an interesting theme of the story is creating your own paradise, as in no paradise is ever perfect even one without pain nor suffering, but what you accept is itself finally a paradise.) The gods/entities or their creations were knockers who attempted to free the bodies of the Beholder's worlds into their own paradise where pain does not exist. When fye escapes from the Beholder's world it goes into either one of two things; reincarnation or into the other world/the outside concept where the Beholder once lived. We have seen reincarnation in the series as stated by how Hayase has been reincarnated many times in the series, however this is probably not exclusive to her. We have seen the Beholder reincarnate Pioran as a horse but we have also seen (presumably separately) Hanna who seems heavily hinted to be an incarnation of Parona due to her interactions with March, her bad eyesight (which Parona was hinted to have and the only reason why she struggled with bows except for heavy bows), and how Mizuha was attracted to her much like Kahaku was attracted to Parona-Fushi. However, Fushi himself is immortal obviously, but why is that? I think there is another explanation besides the Beholder creating a unique, immortal, perfect object. I think that the reason why is that Fushi lacks "fye" as noted throughout the series. He cannot (romantically) love like others do and he has never cried over the death of anyone close to him. His emotions are even strange - he cannot completely relate to other people's emotions which is probably one of the reasons why despite having lived for hundreds of years he is still quite naive because he cannot relate and learn as others do. Due to Fushi lacking fye unlike other living objects, he cannot escape from the world of the Beholder and will stay there no matter what form he takes or how gruesome a death he has. I also think that if this is true, it would be thematically appropriate and interesting as it would mean that what the knockers were doing could be seen as wrong by forcing fye that had chosen to live in the Beholder's world to live in theirs by killing them and releasing them into the outside universe. If Fushi had decided to take the Beholder's powers and force them to stay in a paradise without suffering he would have been doing the same thing as the knockers and trapping their fye there, forcing them to stay. My belief is that the ending of TYE will involve Fushi finally developing his own fye somehow. He will eventually find a lover that he would come to romantically love and genuinely cry over the death of and will come to develop his own fye through pain and suffering which is what deters away Knockers to begin with - as growth starts with challenge. And when he comes to develop his own fye through love, he can decide to finally leave the world of the Beholder alongside with his immortal companions. I feel that his love will likely be with a member of the Hayase bloodline (unfortunately for some fans) because I feel that is where it has built up to with Mizuha and Kahaku. In fact, it could be with Mizuha who wishes to always stay young and perfect (though it is possible she is already dead from old age, but maybe instead she will ask Fushi if she can be revived. I found it odd that no other character in the modern age has done this.) TL;DR, Knockers are fye from the gods/entities from the outside world in which there are many worlds that exist without pain/suffering. Fushi lives forever as a living object because he does not have fye. He will somehow develop fye on his own through a deep connection with another person (true love) and will then be able to die alongside with his companions.

[@donotreadmyprofile9373]

bro if his romatic lover is one of hayase's bloodline i'd be so disappointed

[@wassupitsme-ob2tv]

Bro- THAT'S A LOT OF THEORIES I DIDN'T EXPECT THAT AT ALL

[@oraleestabien]

whats Fye??

[@canadiantoast7331]

I AINT READING ALLATHAT

[@KizumiMayori]

​@@oraleestabien Just think of it like a soul

[@pentagram3]

Dude created Fuji just to start his own highschool anime. He's just like me fr

[@jackaboynaylor9273]

The power fantasy part of my brain is kinda pissed he didn’t accept his powers and what’s up with that doll thing ain’t that the one fushi fell in love with?

[@hear-and-know]

I imagine that if BHG created the knockers intentionally, it was as adversity to help Fushi grow. How would an eternal being cherish his memories, if they couldn't be taken away from them? That is the biggest pain of loss that Fushi could feel. Plus, they are the only creatures which can give Fushi some trouble. So again, growth through struggle/stress. But I wonder. If BHG's purpose was to create Fushi to protect the world... And he has the power to create something out of nothing... Then why not create a tremendously large amount of "Fushis" to make defeating the knockers easily? [Edit: probably because it would defeat the purpose of growth through struggle.] I guess it's really about growth. The short story "the egg" by Andy Weir is along those lines - the goal of the created is to evolve until it becomes the creator.

[@blu1871]

this explanation from the anime sounds very nice

[@ganangsumarsono5124]

Beholder is kind of entity with Almighty boredom complex disorder... What what what why he has such of that agenda? ??.. Just like our realms actually this story from this anime.. Well done for the author of this manga.. He's done his research with deep to study Almighty..

[@flexabramovich4557]

I think BHG will be reborn, since its power cannot go anywhere. And there are a dozen other gods

[@ReiRei12]

Is this a separate chapter on it's own. Because I read chapter 164 but there wasn't any origin story that the Beholder told

[@snaplordmeep6748]

BHG sounds to me like a warhammer 40k fan. Specifically one with a 3d printer and a lot of minifigs. I say this because they live for building words a setting, kinda reminds me of BHG

[@basspig]

Fushi is the best choice for God like power. Fushi is uncorruptable.

[@thunderbudy]

I thought knew he was god since the beginning

[@sageotter]

Maybe it’s one of the other beings that came into existence as BHG. A legit storyline from supernatural but it could work.

[@Kilarion]

In my opinion BHG must've wanted something that we humans always possess a life that we live for just like what BHG's creations

[@Kilarion]

Prolly the knockers are some sort of "test" or toys thatBHG created for fushi to "train with" but became out of control?

[@lumweshok7107]

Well since BHG created the world I think the other entities like him probably made the knockers because they were jealous of his work

[@PairFreebird]

So that basically dragon's dogma?

[@Magikct]

So it's like God and jesus. Same same but different

[@Komega01]

BHG is still around if fushi didnt take the power and he gives it up where does it go?

[@Vix2066]

I'm sad season 2 is over😔

[@fs-ks7fm]

Wait, you found out that he's a God just now?

[@jacobanderson9530]

Nice video. what background music are you using? :)

[@SquireG]

I gotchu Nsr ost - city streets Persona 5 ost - layer cake Madoka Magica ost - I miss you Shibayan records - campo de girassol

[@DaleyDale]

I like the narrative that he all do this basically like a gamer watching a twitch stream of somebody else playing all because he is BORED.... which also plays in a religion aspect that maybe god doesn't do anything with all these catastrophe on earth and bad guys killing innocent people because he just like to observe how everything will play out. We are all just an Entertainment.

[@rgx4306]

So basically God vs nokkers who was a fallen angel, fallen creation, used to help humanity grow stronger in consciousness. Always thought TYE was Christian based.

[@strahinja9803]

So how nokkers start existing nobody know haha

[@Alpha-wj4ho]

No I did the research and think about it the nokkers are like gushing they can transform and create some what so what if another god wanted to kill fushi with the nokkers and take down the beholder

[@NemeiCat]

Spoiling the name in the title nice

[@donotreadmyprofile9373]

i doubt bhg is the author lmao

[@Butterflymoonie]

Interesting!

[@POKETHEB3AR]

how do you not have 1000 subs yet, you're good.

[@POKETHEB3AR]

You are gonna go far

[@strahinja9803]

He was bruh to me haha