The vocal trinity vs Son Seung Yeon (

[@raymondsihombing955]

Son is one of the asian singer who sing with resonant even when it getting higher she use mix.

[@raymondsihombing955]

Celine F#5 in Divas 1998 was so easy plush with such great back to back runs it was so complex actually to doing such crazy fast back to back runs like that, i think..

[@starsohyang5574]

Divas 💗

[@Floptube-dp7zo]

Sonnet >

[@tasosGRvocals]

Nice video, I would like better clips for the trinity, but I didn't expect you to put, as this video was purely about making sonnet seem better. I also noticed an E5 of Celine's was recorded from my video 😅😅 Great effort nonetheless, amazing video!

[@AC-ju5yu]

Sorry, she is better.

[@brickzsparkle3673]

​@@AC-ju5yu no she's not, you're delusional..😂

[@AC-ju5yu]

​@brickzsparkle3673 Oh, I believe you. I bow to your expert analysis not my 47 years of experience. What was I thinking.

[@sonnetfan3302]

SONNET>>Whitney>>Celine>>Mariah

[@unperturbable]

Dull

[@kpoppipie]

No not really, Bigger supported range≠Better vocalist

[@sonnetfan3302]

@kpoppipie So the main point of this video is the sound that supports and resonates?

[@kimsohyangfanclub8334]

Sonnet>>>Whitney>>>Celine>>>Mariah

[@MariosPOS]

The Whitney belts you have marked in green are actually resonant

[@hopopsdhwiie1464]

Do u use KVA

[@MariosPOS]

@@hopopsdhwiie1464 You're asking me if I use a blog...?

[@avec-toi]

That's what KVA bs does to you unfortunately

[@katrina1460]

@@MariosPOS well yeah like misusing resonance and support term

[@MariosPOS]

@@katrina1460 lmaoo y'all are coming in packs

[@DaydreamCarey1234]

I actually hope you used a better clips for vocal trinity.

[@MariosPOS]

3:03 not pulled larynx, just pushed

[@todaysagoodday1862]

Almost all, if not all, of Whitney’s belts here were resonant.

[@MariosPOS]

1:39 except that D

[@MariosPOS]

oh and 4:20

[@jinji4609]

@@MariosPOS it was supported yep D5 had less round vowel but it still had strong projection

[@todaysagoodday1862]

@@MariosPOS That note was grounded.

[@MariosPOS]

@@todaysagoodday1862 You know, i'm never sure what y'all mean when you use that term. Many of you use it differently.

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

Correction 4:32 whitney's green notes here are resonant except from the last F#5 which was accompanied with a little bit of throatiness 1:58 this D5 from Celine sounds like throaty/raspy but it also may be due to her microphone 4:42 that's a resonant F5 from Sonnet but it's not really optimal compared to her amazing F5 in "Lost love" 6:13 Celine's G5 is relaxed but lacks of necessary weight to be considered as supported note

[@katrina1460]

The G5 from Celine was belted M1 it's just not compressed so it's supported

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

@@katrina1460 belt does't mean support. Celine's G5 is thin and lacks of weight/power. 6:09 Sonnet's G5 is stronger/thicker and more powerful although Sonnet's natural tone is lighter than Celine's one

[@katrina1460]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 first M1 is chest voice which is something that Celine bring, you give sohyang G#5-C6 supported when all of them are done with thinner fold closure (pure mixed voice)

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

@@katrina1460 then this G5 from Celine is def thinner than all of SoHyang's G5s bye. "Thinner vocal fold closure" but SoHyang's G#5-C6 are def thicker and more belted than some sopranos "with great chest development"

[@lakescry.]

@@katrina1460 Kaji's garbage dumb=next Only the sound matters and G#5-C6 of SoHyang do not sound thin

[@manhcuongvu8707]

1:27 link please

[@jinji4609]

Nah 4:43 is better than the note after. One of best her F5

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

Honestly it's not optimally opened so I guess it's just supported

[@jinji4609]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 most of her note are bright anyway. I don't see the much of problems and even then i dont' know how the F5 after had higher rate than her F5. Celine never really had good openness above D5. Sonnet's F5 had strong support, vibrato and amplified volume too 2:37 a bit of constriction & slightly whiny despite of good support

[@Arthy30]

Em Beltings Sonnet é muito melhor que as outras!

[@bigmamafan1773]

Whats up with intentionally choosing bad clips for some of them while giving Sonnet her best one ? Well, you did put good clips just not throughout.

[@bigmamafan1773]

Also I disagree with some of the labels you put on those notes

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

Coz Sonnet doesn't have bad moments below F5 while the trinity has. I just use 1 bad clips for MC, 3 for CD and WH, I also pick 2 bad clips for Sonnet too

[@bigmamafan1773]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 Doesn't have? At all ? Idk if I agree but alright 🤷‍♂️ got you

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

@@bigmamafan1773 even her "worst" Eb5 in Let It Go is just pushed a little bit. Her technique is very healthy and sustainable, that why's she is really consistent up to F5/F#5

[@vyeagra420]

Bc they are biased lol,they are tryna make that flop they stan look good out of the vocal trinity💀💀

[@lorence.julongbayan]

3:52 link please..

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4GcYZd3g5J-b5o

[@MariosPOS]

0:57 girl....

[@GarageStudio7]

Right 😅 Then proceeds to pick Son Seung's best and tuned vocals.

[@mimilovelly8843]

​@@GarageStudio7mariah garbage belting is the one with dub and never dare to sustain belt above eb5

[@kimcarson4219]

My vocal trinity are Patti Labelle, Whitney Houston, Barbra Streissand

[@vyeagra420]

Waiting for eydie gorme vs sohyang headvoice btw💖

[@vyeagra420]

@@avec-toi this papers and Planes person called eydie's iconic "ill take romance" D6 shrill lmaoooo💀👎,they said it was horrible

[@avec-toi]

@@vyeagra420 Exactly 💀 it's used to the post production used by kpop singers unfortunately. They aren't used to raw powerful singing 💀

[@MariosPOS]

2:30 that's a bit tight

[@Xelth4]

There is no f#5 belt in Whitney's run to you are 4:19

[@lilith5656]

0:43 Micless your ass 🤣, full room revarb

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

You can keep pissing on Mariah Carey's small and lazy Make it happen C#5 without fancam reverb which is nowhere near to Sonnet

[@Trick6666]

I have to agree to disagree XD, I think all the notes in here are very well supported, is a misconception on people that singing throaty, or high larynx happens when there's no support, actually they need a better knowledge of the voice to do, and not only support, but also a good placement, or they would go off key. Btw that Mariah G5 is a sharp F#5, a lot of people use it on their videos for some reason :p

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

Raising the larynx to the point being higher than the heaven is when ur straining Support is not just abt breath management/ inhaling or exhaling. All the noise in ur throat needs breath, by that logic u support everything when ur speaking

[@Trick6666]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 Thats not straining, a lot of singers use high larynx, its a style

[@Trick6666]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 Everything its supported, because technically what you hear is subjective. Only people with very good ear training knows what the singer is doing, and knowing what the singer is doing and replicating it with your voice, also means that singing in a way its a style. Sounding appealing its another thing.

[@MariosPOS]

0:12 and 0:27 link? Oh and 2:03

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

kzbin.infoUgkxn8h04CbSjjjX5mHtLgbf5Gyp7mFW7k7M kzbin.infoUgkxidmgmC5AsKmFbrm9qkKeXhtFVbEHa4tm kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqCzq2yenbeYg5Ym25s

[@dededejereme2284]

🙋‍♂️🙋‍♂️beautifull job ... just i see at 6.15 celine dion G5 is her note is supported for me ...G5 support

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

When u conpare Celine's G5 with ones from Whitney or Mariah, it's just relaxed/free

[@dededejereme2284]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 for you the note is not supported??? this is complicated

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

@@dededejereme2284 it's unsupported . it has vocal freedoom but lacks of necessary weight to be supported, the shouty G5 from Sonnet is stronger

[@dededejereme2284]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 it had weight on the note I think, free note, not enough for you to be ranked note supported, my ok okay thank you

[@dededejereme2284]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 people say note support ok .... ^^ and others say no... help lol

[@jaf2385]

I do agree with how you rate Queen Sohyang. But with this lady has only plain voice. Unlike the classic ones, unbeatable..

[@nknk2321]

Can I ask about supported range of the vocal trinity pls

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

Celine dion Eb3/E3-D5/Eb5-around Bb5 Mariah Carey F3/F#3-Eb5/E5-G#5 Whitney Houston G#3-E5/F5-around B5

[@Xelth4]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 Mariah has supported a D3 and a Bb5. Whitney has supported C#6 sometimes and an F3 and up to G5 as a belt. Celine has supported a C#6 as well

[@MissMartianDCAU]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 was this their peak or most current?

[@dededejereme2284]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 at the best I think with example of the G5 at 6.05 you put here, celine dion at the best is C3/G5/B5/

[@avec-toi]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 *proceeds to use the term support incorrectly*

[@madols9314]

This video is a bad version of Son Seung-yeon. Son Seung-yeon's live is really perfect.

[@MoustafaSElHassan21]

Whitney>>>>Sonnet>>>Celine>>>>>Mariah Whitney Coordination is better

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

@@MoustafaSElHassan21 not the one messing up I have nothing's belts is better than Sonnet who basically breathed Eb5&F#5 with ease

[@ranmasaotome2876]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 i see ur lies

[@Drianz5142]

​@@ranmasaotome2876Haha this is a troll channel and very pro kpop + Vietnamese lies

[@GarageStudio7]

Basically, *The Vocal Trinity* ate 👑👑👑 If you're gonna do a video like this, at least make it fair... The fact that you made this video just because I rightfully showed that The Vocal Trinity is better than Son Seung (and proceeded to pick notes from them when they aren't at their best yet picked the best notes from Son Seung) says it all. She's good, they are better.

[@mooblink4ever899]

Oh I’m not a fan of SSY but If I didn’t know all of them including the vocal trinity, I would definitely pick her first or second bc her belting is just too strong. For me it’s Whitney=SSY>Mariah>Celine. I’m talking about belting technique only cuz overall everyone in the trinity is still a better vocalist. kzbin.info/www/bejne/n4XWXptnqJKfh68 This performance from her is really good! It makes me want to explore more about her 😊

[@GarageStudio7]

@@mooblink4ever899 If you're talking about mixing, possibly, but when it comes to actual belting (M1 - TA engagement) they are stronger. Moreover, the performance you linked has a substantial amount of autotune kzbin.info/www/bejne/n4XWXptnqJKfh68m57s Even from the beginning of this video you can hear the difference in quality of belting. Not only do Celine and Mariah beat her in actual belting but putting her on par with Whitney's belts is laughable.

[@nknk2321]

@@GarageStudio7 son seung yeon is not a mixer she's a typical of high belter. Her B4 is so strong and even her C#5 belted without microphone overpowered make it happen's C#5 from Mariah Carey. Lol both Mariah Carey and Celine are inconsistent above Eb5 so how can they compete with SSY who can manage up to F5? Not mention to the fact that Mariah cannot sustain high belts

[@monaco4895]

@@GarageStudio7 lots of Mariah Carey's dubbed notes are included in this clip I would say 🥴 but she's still no match to Son Seung Yeon. This sustained F5 belted 4:28 is insane I have never heard anyone in the vocal trinity have showcased the ability to produce such a very resonant F5 like this 👍

[@GarageStudio7]

@@nknk2321 1. What you are calling "high belting" is actually a mix. One can easily hear the shift. 2. As if Mariah's undubbed C#5 in make it happen isn't more resonant. 3. "Mariah Carey and Celine Dion are inconsistent above Eb5" So false that it's is laughable. Now sure, but if we are talking about their actual primes. Mariah was consistent to F#5s and Celine was consistent to F5s. If you have to go through all of their videos and count before it clicks to you, then do so. 4. Mariah cannot sustain high belts due to vocal damage and even then she's able to actually belt higher than Son Seung with more quality and without all that nasality.

[@phucnhahuynh4477]

2:36 pushed resonance?? umm new words??? Stop make new weird words

[@jinji4609]

Resonance can have a degree of pushing and compression if you goes to large/heavy sound. It's normal

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

*stop making

[@phucnhahuynh4477]

​@@jinji4609so they should have said it clearly, because there is no such a thing called pushed resonance. "Resonant but with push" should be fine

[@phucnhahuynh4477]

​@@pigeonsandplanes5805thank you for you correction since English is not me main language but, my point still stands because if you want to debate then stop making those unrelated topic :)

[@hopopsdhwiie1464]

6:14 was a nice G5 belt, her larynx was raised because it's G5 she still carried nice weight and freedom on that note it sounds better than her F#5 here

[@dededejereme2284]

its supported note for you???

[@hopopsdhwiie1464]

@@dededejereme2284 yes

[@dededejereme2284]

people say note support ok....... ^^ and others say no... help lol

[@avec-toi]

@@dededejereme2284 her support was perfect. They are just using the term incorrectly. The note was free from unnecessary tension. This video is biased af.

[@dededejereme2284]

@@avec-toi it's really hard to understand lol

[@liamdo151]

Belting: Song Seung Yeon >>>>>>>> Whitney > Mariah > Celine

[@allykelly]

How

[@drianppppp502]

🤣

[@MariosPOS]

No

[@FJEAN-sb8km]

Whitney >> Celine ≥ Sonnet >mariah . just my opinion

[@esphyalquiza4746]

Sonnet.. Celine.. Whitney.. Mariah...

[@jejemon123]

Her voice is good but she pronouce wrong.

[@joshuarexrode8533]

So basically the whole purpose of this channel is to pick the best notes from Korean singers, and the worst notes from others to make the Korean singers look better?

[@madols9314]

what kind of bullshit?? That's not what you Filipinos do

[@watchitever]

Actually that's not even the best of Son.

[@avec-toi]

Basically

[@Xelth4]

and all thes kpop singers sound good and "resonant" thanks to the annoying mic reverb. Girl not even mariah, whitney and celine have resonance which is squillo...all these kpop singers wouldn't have resonance in the slighest concerning that not even whitney has squillo-resonance

[@pigeonsandplanes5805]

When I say "resonant", I mean the sound is so clear, forward and round. I don't care about those stuff like "squillo/true ring etc.." Lol do u notice that even the studio effect cannot fix high larynx yells from some divas?

[@MariosPOS]

Squillo is resonance, but resonance is not squillo. Epilaryngeal narrowing is not necessary for resonance.

[@danial11]

"All the kpop singers sound good and resonant thanks to the annoying mic reverb"..... Girl do you even watch the video until the end.....how you gonna explain when Song seung yeon do acapella and still have resonance ....How about that Honey mic reverb effect doesn't work like that.......we can know if the notes actually resonance or strain.....mic reverb effect cannot hide that Either you're deaf or hater🙄

[@dededejereme2284]

@@pigeonsandplanes5805 at 6.15 celine dion G5 is her note is supported for me ...G5 support

[@dededejereme2284]

@@MariosPOS at 6.15 celine dion G5 is her note is supported for me ...G5 support