The Voice - Celtic Woman (Lisa Kelly Ft. Susan McFadden)

[@gregbass7564]

It is remarkable that Susan can fit that song so well right down to each beat, but there is only one Lisa Kelly and this song will always be her signature moment in Celtic Woman.

[@galwayj6991]

greg Bass Agreed, and not only is it her signature solo, but IMO it's the best solo in CW history.

[@kristyk2826]

greg Bass The first time I have ever been able to listen to the whole song (Sung by CW that is) is when Susan sang it. Not a fan of Lisa K. I cringe when she hits high notes

[@ThePerksdeLeSarcasmeSiorai]

Kristy K Too bad for you but Lisa Kelly was the one who brought this song to the whole new level of rising popularity thanks to her pure and haunting voice. In fact, the success of Celtic Woman was partially due to her "cringeworthy" high notes (according to your definition) in this signature song. Much better than the original performance of Eimear Quinn. Lisa Kelly was the reason why I and many became fans of Celtic Woman and her contribution to the ensemble is never insignificant and trivial (8 out of 10 years of Celtic Woman's existence). This song is based on Celtic paganism and Lisa Kelly perfectly portrays that image of a Celtic goddess speaking to mankind (just an analogy for I am a non-believer). I take it that Lisa's voice, which is classically trained instead of Susan's musical training, is not your cup of tea but it does not mean that it's a cringeworthy performance. Having said that, I personally enjoy Susan's rendition as well but it does not bring out the "chilling and haunting quality" that I look for in this song. It's good but not unique anymore. Have a wonderful day

[@kristyk2826]

To each their own lol. Feel better after typing all that?

[@florentinb3166]

to each their own ..to each their own meaning each their own selves, meaning not determining if another individual is feeling better. lol It's not about how someone feelings in action, but only how they feel who sings lovelier for them whether it's Susan, Lisa K, Alex or Lynn. = )

[@achiivement]

I think we all can agree Lisa will always be the original voice, but having Susan's version mixed with Lisa's makes it twice as epic as it already is

[@lostsoul_2024]

Lisa is Lisa. Period. This will always be her song.

[@samuelresz71]

Wow. Both are amazing. I did not think anyone could match Kelly, but McFadden does an amazing job. In fact, I think her voice is more powerful. However, I still like Kelly's version the best. There is something very special about her voice.

[@petermcfarlane5643]

The Celts have the best music. Magnificent.

[@chrislovato3362]

Dear sweet mother of god, hearing them both hit out the last note was AMAZING! Lisa's high note was pure soprano, and Susan just belts it out. It's brilliant.

[@briansoule7563]

This...is spectacular. And as wonderful as Susan is, Lisa is THE Voice. The first time I saw Lisa sing this I sat there with my mouth open in amazement and haven't stopped loving CW since. Great job on the "duet".

[@Spacelord2525]

You too? I 1st saw them on PBS. I was about to change the channel when she started to sing. I realized several minutes later that I was sitting there, still holding the remote up, with my mouth open.

[@alexus330]

0

[@ianyoud1]

Definitely in love with Lisa's voice it stunning

[@brittanyneiswinger3561]

I remember listening to Lisa's version back in 2010. It was awesome.!!!

[@henningiversen9987]

lisa kelly is the best voice celtic woman ever had

[@galwayj6991]

How right you are. I think for many she was the heart and soul of the group, and it just hasn't been the same since she left.

[@Irishsong22]

It will always be Lisa's song in my heart, but great job!

[@AlsatianK9]

Lisa Kelly's voice gave me goosebumps

[@Seraphatum]

Both are the voice of the past that always is calling and of the future that will bring us back to this masterpiece

[@bruceobrown534]

I have seen this video many times and every time it brings tears to my eyes. 2 of the greatest of the Celtic Women sharing THAT song is just incredible. Thanks for the memories!!!

[@richebuton4799]

lisa's voice is dramatic! Lisa is the best.

[@rolandochico5665]

Lisa is truly The Voice❣️

[@AishiBhattacharyaOfficial]

Both are incredible artists (however like most of the people I feel that Lisa owns this song in every way) However, keeping aside all comparisons the true artist to be talked about is you who has done an amazing job blending their melodies together. Thank You so much.Keep on making such awesome videos.!!!

[@calumhieu]

Awww thank you sooo much for such kind lovely words!! xx

[@yamahawr450f2003]

Lisa, the voice! Susan, the beauty...

[@george-pj7gi]

Beautiful voices and beautiful women, what a combination

[@jianhualiu1553]

They are epic and welcomed forever 🎉😮.

[@rmettig]

PLEASE SOMEONE MAKE THIS HAPPEN!!!! IT'S PERFECT!! And my favourite part about the transitions is when Mairead's playing, because it shows that, no matter how many years apart, somethings never change. Sinceriously, brilliant work!

[@macaelatice-loma1048]

totally her era ran until the middle-end of the Destiny tour... Mairead was the longest ever original 5 to perform for CW!! and honerable mention to Ray Fean her sidekick... hes been in as long as she was... ya know i have a feeling that Ray left due to Mairead leaving for her own career... im sorry but the drummer that came after him is nowhere near as energetic and funny as he is... still love the group!!!!

[@roselaurelafortune3308]

I can never get enough of that song. That's my phone ring tone for over 15 years now. I never get tired of it.

[@cliffmoher1096]

Wow, what a magnificent job you've done! The pitch-perfect pairing of two enormously talented and beautiful ladies. Almost made me cry!

[@calumhieu]

+John Edwards thank you for your lovely words x

[@roqueocasio1223]

Beuatiful way to show both of them perform, the voice is one my favorite songs from lisa kelly along with caledonia

[@enolamsamoht]

That was incredible. I miss lisa so much! Along with all the rest of the original girls too. But for me Lisa Kelly has always stood out.

[@jennaketchell9012]

Thuam X a good 😊 she doesn't know what

[@danielscallon7515]

I was impressed. I didn't think that would work, but it really was a fresh hearing of The Voice, one of the most powerful songs I've ever heard.

[@moshezig1]

magnificent

[@reverie77988]

what's amazing is that Mairead is there, years apart, playing the violin equally perfect

[@macaelatice-loma1048]

same here girly im 23!! small world aint it :D

[@7160mb]

I love them especially this song *The Voice" Its magical!!

[@lovelygivan1442]

I don't carw who does it. This is a BEAUTIFUL SONG!

[@TheTiredRedhead]

This. Is. Absolutely. Phenomenal!!! The transitions are flawless and this made my heart happy! I adore this song and this is just... WOW!

[@siranta]

two angels right from the kingdom of heaven came down to earth to bring celestial joy to the humans.thank you angel-ladies!!

[@AndreNitroX]

This song and their voices is pure magic!

[@witchywoman2008]

Susan has a stunning voice, but nobody can sing The Voice the way Lisa did. She really was the voice. However, if they were going to give the song to anyone now Lisa's gone, I can't think of anyone who would do it better than Susan. Her version is stunning.

[@eggmine130]

Took the words right out of my mouth!!

[@redsupersaiyan3120]

witchywoman2008 why did Lisa leave??

[@eggmine130]

She left like anybody who has been in a job for a while and wanted to move on to greener pastures. She lives now in the U.S. I love the original five of the Celtic Women, especially Lisa Kelly and Chloe Agnew. But I think I will also like Susan McFadden.

[@tavs28]

The one who actually sings it the best is Eimear Quinn

[@lemonrealsqueeze6826]

Alex, she's the second CW to sing it after Lisa K and filling in for Susan.

[@YE55iR]

I can't stop listening to this. You made them blend very well together :) thank you!

[@calumhieu]

OMG you guys just made me cry!! Thank you so much for your support xx

[@LizWilliamsWildflowerLiz]

Could you possibly do one with Caledonia as well? This is amazing!!!!!!!

[@eggmine130]

Hmm... why are you thanking us for our support? Isn't that something Lisa Kelly or Susan McFadden should say? Just wondering ...

[@huevitopipihead]

Lisa is the best singing this lovely song

[@nguyendoan4163]

Wow! this is just amazing. Thank you very much for posting this beautiful version between two members from Celtic woman. Anyway, Lisa Kelly is always my favorite singer of all time.

[@jennaanderle7667]

Omg I absolutely love both of them! They are so amazing! This is so beautiful! Love it!

[@margaretejacob9075]

Música maravilhosa... cenário lindo.... apresentação belíssima ameiii 😍😍😍😍😍👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@potterslove]

Awesome job merging these two performances together. I love this song and got hooked on it when I saw Lisa Kelly perform it, but I like Susan's version just as much. Best of both worlds.

[@kristyk2826]

I never liked this song, until I heard Susan sing it. Very well put together video! Susan wins the Voice battle for me :)

[@ThePerksdeLeSarcasmeSiorai]

Kristy K All of the viewers and likes (12,100) on Lisa Kelly's original video strongly disagree with you. Lisa Kelly has been and will always be the front runner.

[@kristyk2826]

I do not care about what 12k other people think.

[@macaelatice-loma1048]

@@kristyk2826 good for you!! everyone has opinions and thats ok!! personally i prefer Susan's Caladonia more then Lisa K but others say different and im not going to hear them either!!

[@kristyk2826]

@@macaelatice-loma1048 Agreed! LK's voice makes me cringe at high notes lol. That's the nice thing about being human-we all have different tastes :)

[@ConnorRunda]

I love how no matter what, Máiréad Nesbitt is smiling, and jovially dancing around. Amazing how some parts of us never change.

[@macaelatice-loma1048]

yep thats just Mairead!! love our energetic pixie :D

[@mamagibbs5246]

Wow! Beautifully done. That made me cry.

[@stevekandt4812]

This sent chills down my spine. Beyond description in it's beauty and power.

[@hulyaeroz7821]

I love your voice dear Lisa. Unforyunately I couldn’t love new team. Love from Türkiye 🇹🇷❤️

[@hansdroedel5587]

This is really cool what you did here!!!!

[@calumhieu]

many thanks hans droedel ^^

[@cakesadako375]

a voz de lisa voa pelos ventos até seu coração

[@АлексейБаталов-у1з]

Какие нежные , чистые и высокие голоса !!! Превосходно !!! Алексей Баталов 4 . Стихи Ру .

[@celticcontemporary4526]

Though I commend Susan on a job well done, this song (or at least this style of it) will definitely always be Lisa’s. I feel like the mistake on David’s part was having them try to sing in the exact same style; Susan had to go on after a performance like Lisa’s. In this song style, Lisa is truly “the voice” while Susan is more of just an echo trying to catch up with the original. Susan sounded much better in the 2017 live recording, because they changed the style of the song’s instruments to better suit her voice. It was never that Susan wasn’t good; her voice is just different than Lisa’s and the two shouldn’t be compared to each other. Away from that, the editing on this video is spectacular and the seamless transition from one lady to another is just flawless. (Sorry for my bad English. It’s not my first language.)

[@calumhieu]

Celtic Contemporary totally agree with you! Susan did a great job on the new version!

[@divergenttardis7378]

Based on your comment, your english is exemplary! It is indistinguishable from a native English speaker.

[@celticcontemporary4526]

Divergent TARDIS Thank you very much.

[@GilGurArieh]

I did the same thing with the multiple versions of "You Raise Me Up" This is simply beautiful

[@jenniferwilson2838]

WOW!!! This is amazing!! It is seamless editing and a super neat contrast of how Susan and Lisa sing/sang the song. Congrats on such a great job! I will listen to this and watch it over and over!!!

[@calumhieu]

Thank you so much for your kind Jennifer xx

[@planetmundi6315]

Sem palavras cantam demais, bem que as duas podiam ter cantado juntas no Celtic Woman !

[@johnfayezshawky6790]

The song is truly stunning, With all my respect to Celtic Woman.. You are the artist for making this beautiful contrast. Thanks so much, Young man for giving my favorite song a different taste! :)

[@johnses79]

Какое красивое совмещение двух песен!

[@hannabelle7112]

Mind Blowing combining the two of them together🙂 Well Done indeed❤️

[@ladyalmathea7610]

The ending tho! It was so beautiful! It was so in sync!!

[@teacherpoako]

great singers!

[@geoffchaboude9050]

Lisa Kelly is absolute proof that Angels are real

[@lieuwina]

well done! you have edited this very well. I do like Lisa's version, though I do think the other lady did it outstanding too. To me though this song I will always relate to Lisa Kelly.

[@yvonnewilliams6748]

This was wonderful and beautifully done..Thanks Manh !!!

[@keithbuck2424]

Susan look amazing woman xx

[@tc2tc2tc]

*An ingenious masterpiece in edited synchronisation.* *Rare and remarkable talents indeed in matching, in overlaying and in timing the contents... thereby bringing out the best of both artists in Lisa Kelly and Susan McFadden.* *Wonderfully created excellence.*

[@safiabah4832]

Thank you for making it available on mobile! You're amazing!

[@lesleyfrolloandhooklover6615]

I love this song from Celtic Woman it has such a power in the song 🎶, and Meraied with violin 🎻 adds a beautiful melody 🎵. They should really do a duet together, but this is beautiful together.😍😍👏🏻👏🏻

[@FaithFeline]

Wow this was truly stunning. Amazing editing well done its just beautiful.

[@rockyjr.1821]

Great music

[@ScarlettCrystal2009]

This...is...AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@jiaqiniu130]

That was perfect editing. Best of both singers

[@bonbonl6434]

So so beautiful

[@dedtellebella]

Brilliant!! Hieu, you have a real gift for editing and realizing what sounds good together! What you've done here is AMAZING!

[@calumhieu]

dedtellebella what a lovely comment thank you!!!

[@calumhieu]

Aww thank you!! xx

[@sargintrock2538]

Celtic Woman and a Bernard Cornwell novel! Life is GOOD!

[@lapislazzuli5787]

I'm crying... Wow 💚

[@stacyk123]

THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!! I wanted so badly for Lisa to make a guest appearance for the 10th anniversary tour so they could do a duet of this song (and Caledonia) and you edited it together just how I imagined the duet would be.

[@calumhieu]

+Stacy Koopmann Thank you Stacy, I really like the idea!!!

[@abhideepsingh4484]

They have amazing command over their voices. And background instruments just make it even more nicer.

[@JC-km2io]

You sir, did an amazing job with this video.

[@laurenmontera9516]

Soprano goals 💗

[@cazcam2000]

I love the way you put this together, you did an excellent job. As to who's best, the answer is... Both! They both have their strong and weak points, so ten out of ten to both ladies. Lisa has always been my favourite Celtic woman, but Susan did an amazing job taking over and filling the massive hole that Lisa left when she departed. Both ladies are top notch professionals!

[@Eshta93]

sounds REALLY REALLY great !

[@francisbusa1074]

She's wonderful! For me, this is the Voice of God's Spirit calling to me.

[@Syltiaana]

Beautifull frndition of my all ti e favorite celtic Woman song. Susan and Lisa do a lovely job..myt in my mind ths will always be "Lisa'S song. She brings a richness and enotion to the songs that falls slat when sung by any other atrists...

[@CatoMeador]

Great job, Young Man!!

[@animegirl687]

Well done! The edits you made are flawless. A duet with these two lovely ladies needs to happen!

[@joyce2624]

I love this!

[@foto2mn]

Omg'sh... This was amazing! Thanks for putting this together.

[@kaylove8663]

This is Lisa's song period no one can sing it like her

[@Mellaconnell]

they are both incredibly angelic

[@lisannevaneijk8509]

Wow! This is amazing! Just awesome! You did a really good job :)

[@brunohrlima]

Perfect!!!

[@galwayj6991]

Wow this was fantastic! Fair play to you!

[@billadams484]

Lisa Kelly is so beautiful and what an amazing voice........

[@JC-km2io]

This would truly make an awesome duet!

[@Darkswordz]

God was having an especially good day when he created Lisa Kelly.

[@rickmulligan1894]

Nice job; I absolutely love this!! 🎄🎄

[@cleverhfreitas]

Genial! Bravissimo!

[@bobkaegi4595]

Lisa Kelly, was, is, and will always be "The Voice". There is no more Celtic Woman...

[@jackavery7179]

This is amazing

[@RZ3347]

Perfect! Good job!

[@mackie012003]

Amazing match up.

[@johnses79]

Это просто прекрасно!

[@vidworxsfx]

Fantastic job, nicely done edit. I have to agree with some of the others here, I also feel Lisa's version is by far the best.

[@ianyoud1]

Lisa’s voice is amazing definitely the better of the two but I really love this song ❤️

[@annamariaporeba9862]

Well done