The Worst Doctor Who YouTubers

Welcome to Movie Rewind. If you are a fan of movies or TV then you have come to the right place. Please be sure to like, comment and subscribe in order to receive great and maybe even improved quality content in the future.
Doctor Who is one of the longest running sci-fi shows in the world, with fans being treated to over sixty years of the Doctors adventures in time and space. The size of this show can be reflected in its online community which features a wide variety of opinions and views on the show, though its fair to say that the fandom will never agree on everything. However in recent years it is fair to say that certain KZbin channels have taken a more toxic approach to Doctor Who, with some branding any new developments in the show as 'woke'.
Hope you enjoyed the video and we will see you in another one :)

[@SupaKen74]

Can I recommend the Council Of Geeks. They are very critical of Doctor Who- but it CLEARLY comes from a place of love and Fandom. They have a lot of valid points to thier critique, many of which I often disagree with and that's why I watch. Because they are one of the only KZbinrs I see who are critical of Who were it doesn't come from close-minded bigotry. And I love it when I agree with them. Alternatively when I watch these hate channels and the anti-wokers say something that I might actually connect with or even agree with, I feel like I need a shower afterward.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

That just makes you extremely childish. You hate agreeing with anti-woke people because you're too dense to see beyond your awful ideology. Have you ever tried not being a man-child? Or learning how to spell *Super?

[@AtlasGuitar]

Totally second this recommendation. Probably the only channel I regularly watch regarding Doctor Who content. It's nice to be able to see someone discuss their own viewpoint while clearly being an actually intelligent person capable of recognizing nuance. To me, the real reason to watch or listen to what other people think about a piece of media is to be able to analyze - and therefore appreciate - that media from a new perspective, and you really don't get that from bigots pushing their "anti-woke" narrative for money.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

@@AtlasGuitar Got to love pretentious simpletons like you lauding their non-existent intelligence.

[@andrewsmart4491]

remember they are not the council, they merely chair the meetings 🙂

[@chrisgorton4577]

I am a 60 year old Classic Who fan, born in Derby, England. I have no wish to insult. Classic Who and I grew up together. You missed the best years to be a fan. No insult or condescension. Doctor Who isn't made for me now. I have moved on with my collection, which is here in Florida with me. You don't have to be a fan of what is to be a fan of what was. I am totally cool with that. We all have our time. I wish you all the best.

[@Bman-dr8hx]

I just started my first time going through Classic Who, I only finished the, An unearthly child serial. It's hard to get use to the serial format. What I've seen in Classic it still to me seams the same as in New Who, and #NewNewWho and I don't dislike the now 3 eras of Doctor Who. I'm also like what's the point of going through Classic Who not because I don't like it, but because you can't see all of it with the missing episodes.

[@Shawn4168]

Well said. Classic Who was before my time but I was a big fan of the series revival for a number of years. Started to lose interest early in the Capaldi era but every time we got a big change in the series I've watched for a bit again to see if I can regain my love for the show. I don't want to hate it, every time I watch I genuinely hope that I can love it as much as I used to, but I just can't. I love Jodie Whittaker, I love Ncuti Gatwa, I think that they've both done a fantastic job in the role, I just cannot get past the writing. Even the new Tennant episodes were a struggle for me and he was my favorite Doctor. I'm not going to sit and trash the show or demean anyone who does enjoy it, I'm just going to make peace with the fact that it's no longer the show that I loved and look back fondly on the years that it was.

[@ChristyAbbey]

I'm 59, and it was for sure made for me. But everyone has their own thing, and that is way cool.

[@dasmysteryman12]

I have to sincerely salute you, sir, because you managed to decide not to watch modern Doctor Who with maturity and acceptance. If only more people would act like you, people wouldn't have this kind of discourse.

[@chrisgorton4577]

@@dasmysteryman12 Thank you for your kind words.

[@Bman-dr8hx]

I do not mine people not liking Doctor Who. What I do Mind is that they say it's trash and say they are leaving the franchise, but after the next season airs there back trashing it again.

[@HishamA.N_Comicbroe]

Literally. You only see hate comments under the new stuff.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

​@@HishamA.N_Comicbroe Yeah, because it's crap.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

People are allowed to keep up with it and criticise it. Most of these people are lifelong fans so of course they're going to find it hard to let go.

[@parabot2]

I know people who test and review cars , good cars and bad cars it's their job . These youtube make a living reviewing Sci - Fi etc good and bad . Get it ? Got it ? OK .

[@RobinTheMetaGod]

Their job is to review the bad.

[@IsaacWhittakerDakin]

It's funny how these youtubers constantly preach "freedom of speech" but as soon as you criticise their channels its suddenly illegal! 😅

[@TheArchieTheory]

Hey, I watch your videos!

[@IsaacWhittakerDakin]

@@TheArchieTheory Thanks

[@ogrimtodeshammer2739]

What are you taking about?

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

Literally who has said it should be illegal to criticise them? If you progressives constantly have to lie then just admit you have no points.

[@MostlyBritish_Gaming]

I watched a few of will of the fans live streams. And started commenting in the chat proving his every point he made wrong about "woke"dr who wrong. He continues to ban me from the chat.

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

I don't mind those fans who drop off the show because they don't like it anymore. It happened part way through Smith's era. And then there was a bigger drop a series into Capaldi's era. The difference with those guys was, they dropped the show, and just forgot about it. These guys hate the show, and continue to watch and fuel their own hatred by getting others to join in on the hate. So bizarre.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

Yeah, how dare they be indignant that a show they once loved, and has been a big part of their lives, is being ruined by progressive stupidity. If you can't understand why they find it hard to quit then you're a bit dense.

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

@@sopronunciareglignocchi7255 they fuel their own cycle of hatred though. If it's a show they love, then they should know to be open about every new era and Doctor. Part of the whole show's identity is change. And if an era isn't for you (Smith and Whittaker for me) then just hold out and be open for the next one that comes along. That's if you "love it so much". These guys were hating and Whittaker before she was actually in the show - already calling the end before her first line! That is not a true fan, at least, not someone who has followed what the show has always promoted. And "progressive stupidity"? You say "progressive" as if it's an insult.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

@@mahfuzurchowdhury2765 Progressive is an insult and they criticised the casting (and rightly so). They also criticised the advertising and all the quotes coming out from interviews. To try and pretend that they were blindly being negative is wholly dishonest.

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

@@sopronunciareglignocchi7255 yes, they "criticised" the casting, but for what reason? Just having the Doctor be woman, or the Doctor being black, does not automatically mean the show is now over. The Doctor's character is not inherently a white male. At least modern interpretations, there is no clear way to say "this" or "this isn't" the Doctor. Also, do you know what the word "progressive" means?

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

@@mahfuzurchowdhury2765 Yes I know what progressive means, as in the political sense. They didn't just criticise the casting based on immutable characteristics. However, yes the Doctor should be a white male because that's how he was designed and he's rooted in the British identity and culture.

[@FIZZGIG-RARF]

The viewing figures had nothing to do with race. The main complaint that is deterring viewers is the writing.

[@joylindadichamounix]

The BBC thought it was over when Colin Baker became The Doctor. 37 years later..........

[@daviddreyton8586]

I mean I'm not totally disagreeing with you but considering his tenure only last 2 years and after his successor the show was cancelled for 16 of those 37 years, that's not really a good example.

[@joylindadichamounix]

@@daviddreyton8586 Wokeness is fad. I am Gen-X. I watched The Tom Baker years with my Silent Generation Aunt. There are enough of us who want to straight, white Dr. (or black but not over the top). Sean Pertwee is an actor & looks like his Dad. Maybe someday..... I will watch the classics & cross my fingers.

[@MeghanTheShade]

I'm kinda curious now as to who you think the best Whovian reactors are on the platform.

[@90sArchive]

It takes a lot to admit that your views in the past were wrong. Something these KZbinrs will never do. Hopefully the saddos won't harass you for this video. And if they do, who cares what they think! You're a likeable person who isnt a hateful weirdo, they're just jealous.

[@MidnightChimey]

The thing is they literally can't admit to being wrong, ever, even if they wanted to. Their audience is an outrage train that needs to keep being given fuel, and if they stopped or had a moment of introspection even for just one second, they would lose their audience.

[@adamwalkervfx]

Hey! How come I'M not on the list? :P

[@paganartisanwitch]

I have noticed people are quick to jump on bad episodes and ignore good ones like Boom

[@MostlyBritish_Gaming]

Booms a banger!

[@tenhayz1889]

They dont ignore it, they just take a few sentences out of context and cry about how woke it is, whatever woke means in their rotted brains, or nitpick things that they wouldnt criticize in "better" episodes

[@lbricks7631]

Thankyou for making this video. Some of these comments are awful, but you keep it up lad.

[@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o]

I can't believe that it's almost a decade since Thirteen's era began.

[@dark_ops1651]

what are you talking about, it hasnt even been 6 years yet

[@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o]

@@dark_ops1651 that’s why I said almost 😉 And hasn’t it been 7 years already since 2017? 2024 - 2017 = 7

[@dark_ops1651]

@@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o Well I thought you meant the beginning of S11 which was October 2018 I think. But either way, Twice Upon A Time was a christmas special so literally a week away from 2018. It hasn’t been even 7 years from any metric.

[@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o]

@@dark_ops1651 oops, sorry. My mistake, then ☺️

[@dark_ops1651]

@@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o It's no problem, I don't know why I was being so annoying about it 😭

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

I quite like your views on Doctor Who. It seems like it lines up with my views on the show too. Would love to see more Doctor Who videos from you.

[@HolsovanUltimate]

Every. Single. One. Of these anti-woke channels are the cancer of youtube. And I dont like either side, but my reasoning isnt for any political stance or social stance. I just find it freaking annoying. Its constant bickering and complaining. Then they go and review bomb shit with the same "the message" quote. And i'm sick of seeing that comment every single effing time. It ruins entertainment. People are not allowed to enjoy it, cause they butt into everything. They are the exact same thing they claim to be against.

[@dasmysteryman12]

This comment 💯

[@dasmysteryman12]

What’s worse is that some of them will do the same thing to shows like the new Fallout series that aren’t even explicitly “woke”, and their only enjoyment comes from hating something unreasonably.

[@HolsovanUltimate]

@@dasmysteryman12 You wanna know the funny thing about that. Some of them did that weeks before the launch. And once the series released, they completely 180'd and posted praise about it like they didnt just bash it for several weeks. Complete tools.

[@NebLleb]

As someone who fell victim to their grift... Anti-SJWs are their own worst enemy. END OF.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

So they're cancerous because they share a negative opinion of it? Are you brain-dead? All they do is criticise things they don't like and explain why - they don't orchestrate review bombings as you've just lied. They merely show the ratings as proof that their opinions aren't solitary.

[@Morphstock]

You are spot on about Boles trek (I've seen the odd bit of Nerd rotic and I'm not really familiar with the others). He doesn't review , just rants , and clearly it panders to an audience. It's interesting to see that his early videos are nothing like this, he clearly hit on shouting the loudest about "wokery" and found it got him a following. Personally I wasn't a fan of Jodie's run , but not because it was "woke", and I did commengt a few times on his channel but he revealed his hand in his non-review of Demons of the Punjab where he admitted he hadn't properly watched it, misinterpreted what it was about regardless, and then started spouting racist conspiracy theories. He's a grifter, he isn't worth bothering with.

[@millythespugwit9051]

Love the vidyah, feel like we don’t see much folks finally criticise these lot. Which is good to see a bit of a rise against these hateful voices. Subscribed!:)

[@TheGerkuman]

Funny how as soon as you make a video like this, fans of those channels you dislike magically appear to tell you you're wrong. it's almost like they're being told to.

[@JoeTheUberGeek]

or there is this thing called KZbin recommendations... just a thought.

[@TheGerkuman]

@@JoeTheUberGeek I can see that accounting for some of it, but there's so much doctor who content out there. Unless you're saying that nerdrotic and bowlstrek fans are being recommended the video because they're mentioned, and if that's true, then the algorithm needs tweaking.

[@mw56101]

KZbin suggested this to me so it probably does need tweaking

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

How dare people disagree with you. Please grow up.

[@thecloudtherapist]

"Nerdrotic is bringing his own political views of the show". What do you think ReTarD is doing to the series?

[@Alpha-oo8]

Wait… we are allowed personal opinions?

[@Irisishunter]

Not sure why this video was recommended to me, but you seem a really likeable guy. I used to love Doctor Who but only made it 20 minutes into her first episode. Adults using the word "fam" bit of a eye roll turn off. Saw the trailer of the new Doctor but the passion is gone, don't think it is for me so not watched any

[@Kryojenix]

Your opinions are factually correct. I pronounce it to be thus. Oh, except the bit about not liking Series 11 and 12. It's harder to enjoy them, but there's good stuff in there if you focus your mind on it.

[@lbricks7631]

Nerdrotic says Doctor Who is imposing it's political agenda onto its viewers, saying thats wrong, before promptly doing it himself. His genuine belief in his own hypocrisy is just a joke.

[@MostlyBritish_Gaming]

Nerdrotic is a racist though who hates black and gay.

[@Ostermond]

He and the rest of those “Fandom Menace” types are a genuine plague with their bullshit “culture war”.

[@simonrodgers2375]

Difference being Nerdrotics is Nerdrotics, you know what to expect. Doctor Who though has changed over the years and is clearly trying to groom children with over sexualised material.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

He never said it's wrong, just that he disagrees with the progressive nonsense and that the writing and everything else is suffering, which it is. Please be honest.

[@jonylawson73]

He is Incredibly funny and witty tho

[@Nine1215]

Being negative about something is the easiest and lazinest thing to do.

[@Nine1215]

@@magellanthecat Get lost, hater

[@cheapfinish6224]

@@magellanthecat You listen to Big Finish, so you should know. They peaked back in the 2000s

[@jeremyallen5974]

That explains why the idiots who make this trash always resort to screaming ist words at people for having the audacity to say the show is dumb because the writing is straight up garbage

[@hinkelstein69]

which is why this is a video about the "worst dr who youtubers"

[@lRlMlGl]

Haven't they just stopped with the show very recently or is that just me?

[@josephf.4540]

I was literally calling out every one of those KZbinrs before you said them! I agree 100%. I’ve been a fan of Doctor Who since the 70s and I’m an American. Do I like all the new episodes? No. But the show has to attract new audience to survive. It is not “my show“, so I enjoy the episodes that I enjoy, and the ones that I don’t I scratch off my rewatch list.

[@williamhowe1]

I'm all for criticism but being negative for negative's sake is just wrong.

[@TomoBakerinio]

They are just negative for the sake of it because they know their fans will watch them and it's so easy to hate on something for the sake of it.

[@williamhowe1]

@@TomoBakerinio And there's the "almighty" algorithm to keep in mind.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

​@@TomoBakerinio No, they're negative because of how crap Doctor Who is now. Have you ever bothered to watch their videos? Who am I kidding, a progressive challenging their delusions...

[@mr.vanillamilkshake3]

On the flipside, we have another great Doctor Who KZbinr out there: MrTardis, who, beyond doing some great takes on various Doctor Who media, also has fun reacting to terrible Doctor Who KZbinrs. I wonder if you'd be willing to share a livestream together?

[@movierewind2017]

I would never turn down the opportunity to do a livestream with Mr TARDIS!!

[@davidblyth6886]

​​@@movierewind2017trilbe is controlled opposition and an insincere grifter who praises eveything

[@Divasdinosaursanddemons]

Mr Tardis tried to smear someone as a pedophile and frequently lies and is a hypocrite.

[@Trev359]

IMO MrTardis is one of the worst youtubers of all.

[@EddGorenstein]

Can you add me to the list next time you do one of these? Pretty pwease? 🥺

[@RealReaper]

It's always nice to meet a fan 👍

[@michaelmcdade1680]

Thanks for mentioning the first KZbinr that you mentioned.

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

A guy who worked in the film industry and had his own comic shop... so basically someone who knows what he's talking about. No wonder you don't like him! LOL

[@sebastianimation6100]

@@user-un9go4qe5i He's also a guy who sold drugs to children, his pure ignorance about everything he talks about it one of the least problematic things he does

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

@@sebastianimation6100 LOL. Yeah, whatever. Try again.

[@sebastianimation6100]

@@user-un9go4qe5i Look up "Nerdrotic Meth", though i doubt you'd be able to understand why it's a bad thing

[@90sArchive]

​@@user-un9go4qe5iNerdrotic is literally comic book guy from The Simpsons except he isn't fat.

[@danielwilliamson6180]

I am a long-time Whovian. Doctor Who is my favourite TV show and it's one of the reasons why I love fantasy and science fiction in general. David Tennant is my favourite Doctor Who and Karen Gillan is my favourite companion, and my favourite aliens/robots are the Cybermen, and I also like the Ood. When Jodie Whittaker was announced as The Doctor back in 2017, I was so mixed on it. My concerns about The Doctor becoming a woman were that it may not work and that it could ruin Doctor Who. The Jodie Whittaker/Chris Chibnall of Doctor Who was terrible. Jodie Whittaker was the worst Doctor Who ever. She really didn't suit the role and the 13th Doctor was poorly written. All of Jodie Whittaker's episodes apart from Power of the Doctor were so bad. The Timeless Children was without a doubt, the worst ever episode of Doctor Who. Because of it, I passed on Series 13. I recently watched all the 60th anniversary specials and I enjoyed them. The Star Beast was good, not great. Wild Blue Yonder was great. The Giggle was good, and The Church on Ruby Road was surprisingly good. Ncuti Gatwa so far hasn't been too bad as The Doctor, and he has great chemistry with Millie Gibson. When I first heard about Ncuti Gatwa, I thought he could bring something new to Doctor Who. Doctor Who is a TV show that's not for everyone and maybe there are KZbinrs and people who really don't understand Doctor Who and have to go be negative about it. People are entitled to their own opinion. If you don't like Doctor Who, then don't watch it. Not fair for them to go and call people and fans of Doctor Who "idiots". I am giving new Doctor Ncuti Gatwa a fair chance. Is Doctor Who a show that is worth still worthing? Best watch the new series of Doctor Who on Disney+ and decide for yourself.

[@MrTrevcarter]

SO glad you're bringing this up. These negative reviews are spoiling everyone's enjoyment of the show. The new season has been written off by so many and not an episode has been broadcast!!! These arseholes need to just be quiet. I've been a viewer since 63 and I'm loving the change. If you don't like Russell's writing don't tune in. Simple! Enjoy episodes 1 and 2.

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

How are these negative reviews spoiling everyone;s enjoyment of the show? Are you serious? Surely the relentless shoehorning into it of dangerous propaganda and ideology is what's ruining everyone's enjoyment of the programme?

[@sebastianimation6100]

@@user-un9go4qe5i "dangerous propaganda and ideology" you seem like the kind of person to shoot themselves in the foot and blame others for it

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

@@sebastianimation6100 Odd thing to say. Made no sense at all. Try harder.

[@90sArchive]

​@@user-un9go4qe5iOf course you don't understand their comment. A caveman has more going on in their head than you 💀

[@quantumvideoscz2052]

"Criticism must be quiet!" Fascist much?

[@blade122]

None of these people pretend or don't know how TV figures work. The broadcast and iPlayer might be down, but it was still the 4th most watch on the first Saturday, so a lot of programmes except Eurovision must have had lower numbers.

[@n.s4122]

I did not the like the Space Babies and liked Devil's Chord but saying Doctor Who is dead is taking it too far. These people are dismissing people who do like it by saying they are not real fans. Is it wrong to like the new Doctor Who. Aside from the Space Babies, I have been liking the new era.

[@tenhayz1889]

I agree Space Babies was not great, I think it worked okayish, but Devil's Chord was pretty cool Imo, I love the performance from Jinkx. Boom is even better and 73 yards might be a new classic if RTD is right

[@Prince__Teclis]

I consider people that say Doctor who is dead the same I do as people that say Jesus is returning soon. They've been saying it so long and yet nothing.

[@Problembeing]

Most of these channels arent even Doctor Who channels. You do realise that, right? No, you dont.

[@DaDaPieGaming]

don't be gaslit into thinking everything you said in this wasn't a totally normal response to the videos you've seen. Most people have the same response to the youtubers that you pointed out

[@RobTFilms]

I occasionally watch some of the videos from these sorts of creators and find them a hilarious watch tbh. great video, man!

[@phlippy]

Thanks for calling out some of these terrible people

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

Follows Noah Samsen, thinks other people are terrible. Grow up you sadcase.

[@theunknowncommenter725]

None of these people are terrible. That's a funny way of defending the terrible people who are actually ruining Doctor Who.

[@phlippy]

@@theunknowncommenter725 nobody's ruining DW. And in my mind, exploiting discrimination for clicks and views makes you a terrible person.

[@RobinTheMetaGod]

You are the reason modern media is bad.

[@johna5635]

Trouble with the Doctor Who fandom these days is a title such as this could be a video made by raging bigots who can't tolerate ordinary fans enjoying the show - or it could be a fair critique of raging bigots! Glad I risked clicking the link!

[@RobinTheMetaGod]

The complaints are valid.

[@Scorpio9809]

I never understand people going on about DW being woke, sci-fi is inherently progressive and political as a genre and you will struggle to find many pieces of sci-fi media that don't have some political leaning

[@HishamA.N_Comicbroe]

They were literally talking about feminism in the 3rd Doctor era lol.

[@theunknowncommenter725]

THE MESSAGE is being pushed at the expense of good storytelling.

[@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o]

I mean, just look at War of the Worlds, Brave New World, 1984! These three classics of sci-fi alone are some of the most political ones out there! Then we have Star Trek that has always been political, as has Doctor Who! Star Wars was inspired by an anti-Vietnam-war sentiment!

[@raiblast]

@@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o War of the wolds was written in the 1800s...it actually sparked a lot of scientific discoveries trying to match technology it described. Our cell phones were given rudimentary form. It was also suddenly aired on radio broadcast like actual news and people thought it was real. This was small scale, but it also shows you how involved people can get in a story. Doctor Who since Jodi has...bitched about doing stupid shit that anyone could of saw coming, berating half of the population, targeting the very people who make the show possible, discrediting the entirity of the franchise up until Jodi's era, and just saying "FU Males! Also, our mega queen was a male, but she's better cuz she's no longer a male." I think i see a difference in story telling.

[@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o]

@@raiblast How small-minded must you be to view the sheer presence of a female lead to mean „FU males!“??? Yes, Jodie’s era does have flaws but it’s definitely not having a female lead. And what is that „stupid shit that anyone could of saw coming“? Also, targeting the very people who make this show possible? Who’s that supposed to be? Men? You do realize the hat there are plenty of women involved in the production, right?

[@lloroshastar6347]

Some of these guys are so sensitive they send their minions into the comments to harass you lol why are people who think they are part of the 'superior race' so sensitive?

[@sectraaaaaa]

no idea why i was recommended this (never really got into dw) or why i watched it in full but good on you for calling these people out. really sorry your comments are filled with pretty hateful people

[@42romojv]

I hated the Jodi era for the most part , with a few episodes that were good but so far I am loving the new episodes

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

The new episodes are crap. Are you mentally challenged?

[@sammythygamer5622]

I love the new episodes. What do you think of boom?

[@joshsipe5216]

Great video and don’t let the hate get to you.

[@thethinkingcatakaneonormie3527]

I have no optimism with RTD being back my advice look at the last 6 episodes of his run and i think this will not improve and really the best doctor who period was 1970-74 mainly because you had a director as a producer and a television writer as script editor, i think Show runners are a terrible idea as its not creative.

[@worthybutter2004]

Yeah, why couldn’t they have hired someone new to take the wheel?

[@cuppajoememes4834]

Great video, deserves loads more views.

[@deadtree_who]

I watched this expecting to see my channel here!😆

[@rogvortex58]

Glad I don’t watch any of these people. They only care about the views not whether Doctor Who is actually good or not.

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

Just like RTD then! LOL

[@mekonta]

So basically they care about DW when it’s not good. That seems a fair assessment.

[@rogvortex58]

@@mekonta “not good” is a matter of perspective.

[@darrenbradleytwin]

@@mekonta ''Good'' is also a matter of perspective.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

You progressives really hate having your stupidity challenged, don't you?

[@Problembeing]

Thanks for the list. I'll check out the ones I've missed and give them a subscribe.

[@PrimevalMudd]

It's just a grift ‐ there are more views and money in being negative than positive. I don't think (m)any of them actually think the things they say. I certainly hope that they don't!

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

They're not really being negative though... just honest.

[@RobloxDoctorWhoNexus]

They are, youre obviously a fan of em...​@user-un9go4qe5i

[@spex76]

Is that your excuse because those people are more popular? Perhaps it's because they're telling the truth and not simping for narcissistic perpetual victims. Yeah we know, everyone's an IST and a PHOBE! Welcome to Leftist BizarroWorld 🤡

[@zocialix]

@@user-un9go4qe5i Honest about what smart-ass?

[@CardiffOneOne]

@@user-un9go4qe5i Honest?? Get real, these boneheads don't know the meaning of the word.

[@frippp66]

there certainly are plenty to choose from

[@British_Rogue]

You sound jealous.

[@mrmister3782]

I'm gonna be honest Doctor Who died for me when I saw Jodie Whittakers episodes (Maybe it already begun in Capaldis last season), and no, it was not because of her. I hated the timeless child and it's just another thing which just makes no sense for me, just like the war doctor. I don't understand how some fans actually liking and support this stuff. It just makes the character more and more unnecessarily complicated. Someone, I think it was RTD already said it was difficult to write for Doctor who because the doctor is always the smartest person in the room and knows everything. If I'm looking at the early episodes of classic who that wasn't the case at all. The Doctor was usually just as smart as his companions and most of the questions like "Why he left his home planet" got more simple answers like "He was bored and wanted to explore the universe". Now he is basically became space jesus since David Tennant. The new showrunners ruined Doctor Who. Right now I'm just disappointed with what they're doing with this show. They could do so many things with the show, but instead they always repeat everything.

[@scouseofhorror104]

My dad's never kept up with Dr Who as such. I showed him a trailer for the Ncuti series, his eyes widened and he said "I'm watching that! When does it start?!" ...HE'S 89 ffs!

[@HishamA.N_Comicbroe]

Based.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

​@@HishamA.N_Comicbroe More like low IQ.

[@sopronunciareglignocchi7255]

Your dad either has mental problems or this is a lie.

[@sammythygamer5622]

I didnt enjoy jodies erra, but i beleived she could of been a great doctor, but chriss chibnal went too big storywise and fell too far. He didnt develop the companions well or the doctor well. They gave the show to someone who writes filler episodes. There were episodes i liked. Paraxius and rosa.

[@Knaveofspades6]

There is a very big difference between being influenced by politics and ramming messaging down viewers, especially children's throats. It is night and day.

[@MCU_Spidey_2099]

Will of the fans is one I found I dislike too

[@UranusMcVitieFish-yd7oq]

Oh here we go, the "Doctor Who has always been political" argument. Ok, explain to me how the apartheid allegory that is The Mutants is in anyway similar to say the pronouns scene in the Star Beast?

[@tvc1569]

so essentially politics is fine unless its something you disagree with (and btw i find the pronouns scene was handled terribly)

[@chrispalmer7893]

The reason this argument is popular is because it is true. Yes, in the past, the messages were a little better cloaked, but that's more about how the TV landscape has changed over the years. Barry Letts was openly left-wing and would have dearly loved to have been far more explicit in the messages he was forced to promote through subtlety (he was proud of those moments when he did sneak something through). Sylvester McCoy has said that he was only interested in the role because he saw Doctor Who - both the character and the show - as standing opposed to Thatcher's government. Maybe it's just that today, with a political discourse that is significantly more infantile and less nuanced than in the past, messaging needs to be more overt. There's also a certain haze of nostalgia over all of this - from a modern perspective an anti-apartheid message seems safe and tame; it was much braver at the time when it wasn't such a given that everyone is anti-apartheid. It was doubtless seen as an example of what people like to call "wokeness" today (and have previously called "political correctness") at the time. Most likely, fifty years from now the "pronouns scene" will seem pretty innocuous (as it does to many of us already). Worth noting that even though you've asked for the similarities, I find the differences between your two examples far more illuminating: (1) I'm guessing you agreed with the anti-apartheid message in the Mutants but not so much what was being expressed in the "pronoun scene" (2) The Mutants was criticising another country and culture, the "pronouns scene" can be taken as an attack on our own and is inherently more provocative

[@GrabAStackofRocK]

Pronouns and mutants are both scary to the weak?

[@chrispalmer7893]

@@GrabAStackofRocK Well, there's that... Tempting to cail it paranoia, but I guess there's nothing paranoid about a bigot's genuine fear of being correctly identified as a bigot.

[@quantumvideoscz2052]

@@chrispalmer7893 The reason it's popular is because it's both true AND disingenuous. You can be "political" in so many ways it's ridiculous. What people are complaining these days is WHAT politics are present and HOW they are handled. But that can never be admitted by the defenders of the current run because that would take an argument from them.

[@glitchedgirI]

Thanks for calling out these bigots. It's not a fair argument if you just make antisemitic or racist or transphobic or homophobic comments the entire time.

[@888bangthory]

Mr Tardis is another one that irks me, he goes on and on about these channels gaslighting and being disingenuous but he does the exact same thing from the opposite side , repeatedly characterising people he doesn’t like or agree with as conservatives/Tories

[@zocialix]

If the boot fits? He's completely spot on, look at the people like Nerdrotic bolsters and you get a clear idea of the things they believe. Increasingly conspiritorial reactionary christo-fascist nonsense about the collapse of social cohesion of modern western society cause of: 'prorgressive agendas and wokeness' - blah blah blah...

[@phlippy]

Except he actually has evidence for it, the behavior of the people he criticizes like Bowlestrek is pretty blatant

[@cheapfinish6224]

MrTARDIS is just controlled opposition.

[@MysteriousStranger42]

Mr TardAss

[@Mimicloo]

I just hate how a lot of people are rage baiting for the views. A lot of these people couldn’t care less about the show and just want people giving them views. I also hate how these videos are making normal people not want to watch the show. A lot of people will hear “doctor who is bad now” and just accept it as a fact.

[@allenrhys844]

Just like this video. His bigotry is showing.

[@triplejazzmusicisall1883]

I hope you do not mind but part of your very balanced, honest and reflective post really struck a chord with me I so strongly agree with. Not only in context of DW but all aspects of human daily life. Thank you for you video. It is superb. Transcript section... 12:08 you know and that's what I don't 12:10 understand fair enough there are genuine 12:13 people out there in the Doctor Who 12:15 Community who if you did not like the 12:17 jod whiter era which I did not you are 12:20 called racist and sexist but the same 12:23 time there are other people in the 12:26 Doctor Who Community who believe that if 12:29 you do enjoy certain elements of Doctor 12:31 Who then you are woke and you're not a 12:34 true fan and I just think that all of 12:36 this toxicity surrounding the show needs 12:40 to stop we need to start respecting each 12:42 other's opinions Spot on. I did not like Chibnall's era for lots of reasons none of which had to do with a female Doctor. The dialogue from Rose and Donna at the end of the Star Beast was imo a double standard. Yet these are just opinions and the latter just on a two minute section of an episode. I may or may not enjoy the new era. After all we do age and throughout our lives we have our favourite moments and that can include tv shows. Those who enjoy this new era may not like DW if it is screening in another thirty years. To use my favourite line in DW from my personal favourite Doctor, '...."We are all different people all through our lives, and that's okay, that's good. You've got to keep moving so long as you remember all the people that you used to be.' Yet moving forward does not mean you have to like everything but equally one has to accept change and that for others it is a blessing.

[@gavkenny]

Agreed. I did not like much of the 13th Doctor's time in the Tardis as I really don't like Chris Chibnall's writing, but it doesn't mean I will go and make pictures on thumbnails of videos with Jodie and googly eyes and continuously call her 'The first female Doctor' in an ironic way. Honestly as soon as I see a Dr Who channel with Woke in its title or 'The Message' I know not to look at it.

[@triplejazzmusicisall1883]

@@gavkennyI completely share your opinion. Cheers.

[@TheWatcher5292]

You forgot votesaxon07

[@mahfuzurchowdhury2765]

Guys, if you agree with him, make sure to like this video!

[@aidangordon4544]

You seem like a nice person

[@francisgrizzlysmit4715]

spot on mate

[@Cringeharvester]

Love the video but you need a better intro mate lmfao 😅

[@Kryojenix]

0:30 ...or Season 40

[@TheVonhouser]

I'll be honest, I'm not the hugest fan of the recent episodes, but people acting like it's the anti-Christ is just stupid. Ncuti needs a bit of time, that's it. So far, I'm all right with it. It's a bit cringe at times, like the Beetles dance number, but Mystro was a great villain. You also shouldn't be insulted just for liking these new episodes. It's just TV, the right-wing love propagating the idea of propaganda whilst loving to enforce their ideas in their work, (literally look at anything made by Daily Wire.) You can't write something without some kind of political bias, and societal cultural differences.

[@brucewayne7838]

episode 1 total viewers 4.01 million !. episode 2 total viewers 3.91 million ! no total for episode 3 at the moment but a huge drop overall and i guess they will go lower as it goes on. this is not looking good at all for doctor rwanda as the first couple of episodes usually see the highest when a new doctor is introduced.

[@LeviPennington-vv2kq]

5:26 That is a valid criticism. If you believe that the show is promoting a false worldview, then you can criticize that

[@jonsmith2832]

Bigotry is not valid criticism

[@Ibalistic_hedge]

Admittedly the Star beast was pretty bad. And in all fairness 2023s Christmas special has been rated by critics and fans as one of the worst Christmas special’s in the shows history. The ratings just aren’t good at the moment. They are better than the chibnal eras ratings, but that’s not really saying anything.

[@barryhomeowner9293]

I'd put it top 50%, easily

[@Ibalistic_hedge]

@barryhomeowner9293 that’s great and I didn’t think it was awful however, the majority didn’t like it and I can see why.

[@floydian2007]

You forgot Rabbi and a certain Irishman. The former in particular is I think the worst out there.

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

Why? Because he/they tell the truth? Actually, along with Nerdrotic and Type40, they are the best. Honest instead of just toeing the woke, rainbow, hate-mob line. Too many phony fans out there who only watch it because the Doctor is gay, black, trans, or a woman.

[@chrispalmer7893]

@@user-un9go4qe5i You really need to stop equating "truth" with "shit you agree with". Not remotely the same thing. And as for "hate-mob" - it's the anti-woke idiots that start from the incredibly disrespectful point of assuming that people who disagree with them don't really think or believe what they claim to think or believe. I'm more than happy to assume that you're every bit the ignorant bigot you present yourself as.

[@granvillesimmons6033]

That "rabbi" is a foul-mouthed Nazi. Not much of a holy man.

[@RobloxDoctorWhoNexus]

​@@user-un9go4qe5i I was wondering why you were mindlessly defending the youtubers. You're clrarly ahuge bigot. Just admit youre a neo-nazi.

[@mattthesilent777RED]

Rabbi Tzvi Lebetkin? I got booted out for hating on his thumbnails. I share his most of his opinions but I'm liberal and even a radical compared to him

[@bananess_]

A have a ton of writing criticisms for the show, and I think it died in 2017, but I don’t really care too much for the “woke” stuff. My criticisms all lie in the writing and the scripts etc. it annoys me that people that only complain about the wokeness get in the way of any actual substantive criticism.

[@barryhomeowner9293]

And you manage to hold that opinion without going "RIP DOCTOR WHO IT'S GONE WOKE NOW THEY GOT TRANS PEOPLE" every 5 minutes on instagram, presumably, something that seems to elude these fuckers

[@TomoBakerinio]

It did not die in 2017 when Whittaker took over. In fact, the first episode of Series 11 attracted 8M overnight figures and got to consolidated ratings of 10.96M views. I mean yes, it was slowly dropping episode to episode but they were still the highest since 2013/14. Realistically, the show "died" (dropping figures even more) in 2020.

[@bananess_]

@@TomoBakerinio personally for me, it dies when the writing quality is bad, not when less people are watching.

[@dc6521]

1: all of them

[@ponchoman49]

Impressive viewing figures. You've got to be kidding as they are literally half of Jodie's lowest figures and streaming was very much going on during her run. Just saying

[@autumnmatthews3179]

I clicked on this video by chance and I have to say I agree with everything you say. I've only heard of Nerdrotick however it's spelt. I would have included the Rabbi to be honest. I'm a trans woman and I know plenty of people out there hate everything about me (and they're entitled to their views), but as great as it was to have recognition and representation I think the trans element in the 60th specials were a bit clumsy and over the top. I don't enjoy the Chibnall era but it's not because of Jodie, it came down to the writing for me. When Ncuti was announced I checked out Sex Education and for a supporting actor he stole every scene, I'm overjoyed that he's the Doctor because he's a fantastic actor.

[@user-or3oe4cq6m]

This season sucks balls.

[@andrewsmart4491]

If race isn't important why are so many articles introducing Ncuti Gatwa as the first black Doctor Who, instead of introducing him as award winning actor Ncuti Gatwa?

[@JRHainsworth]

Because he's the first black doctor.

[@electricxbull7858]

Tabloids are the ones who keep doing that. The shows hasen't mentioned his race once.

[@JRHainsworth]

@@electricxbull7858 Yeah the only time his race has been mentioned so far was when Ruby had to give a visual description to the guy in the pub.

[@Face2East]

@@JRHainsworth well .. apart from Jo Martin . So their sales gimmick is just emperors new clothes. It allows them to play the race card if the viewers tank.

[@cameronjosephvideos5942]

@@Face2East Let's rephrase that. Ncuti is the first black Doctor that matters.

[@DJ-LD]

I really don't think their fans to begin with. Not in the your different so you aren't a true fan, but in the I've seen your content enough and seen people who actually enjoy the show or know what their talking about to see you don’t actually care enough to be a fan of the show. You're only talking about it because its becoming more present in media again and too many people keep giving you the benefit of the doubt. Playing on one of the fundamental teachings of the show itself inorder to get away with it, then go convince people who are openly trusting to just warp them until they become the opposite of what they enjoyed so much in the first place. Open brainwashing through sheer hate. These 'creators' are daleks with cybermen worth ethics.

[@user-un9go4qe5i]

The real fans are the ones upset at the way the programme is being used as a pawn in a silly little game. Surely that's obvious...?

[@GrabAStackofRocK]

@@user-un9go4qe5i you could always watch Duck Dynasty instead.

[@RobloxDoctorWhoNexus]

​@user-un9go4qe5i No, the real fans are people who don't discriminate. Now how back o fox news and Facebook you wrinkly sack of bigotry.

[@DJ-LD]

Yes? Are you implying that the people he's talking about aren't the ones fueling the 'silly little game' by making stuff up and being openly hateful about everything and just using doctor who or marvel as labels rather than actual criticism on those two things.

[@90sArchive]

​@@user-un9go4qe5iThe real fans aren't bigoted creeps

[@pandaphil]

Thanks for this. I can't understand spending your life this miserable, and trying to make others as unhappy as they are.

[@rnw2739]

We aren't the ones deliberately setting out to destroy quality and beloved TV shows..... thats you people.

[@pandaphil]

@@rnw2739The best to to kill a tv show is to keep doing the same thing over and over.. Can't keep living in the past little fella.

[@rnw2739]

@pandaphil Dr Who never did the same thing over and over again, senile little man.

[@pandaphil]

@@rnw2739 Who's "you people"?

[@doctorwhy6366]

‘Influenced by politics’ isn’t the same thing as being political propaganda

[@Zaymont720]

I agree there. Especially when it is forced heavily

[@user-lk2zz5fy6b]

The mor u point ( single out) racist tha mor u become seen az…

[@Charlatan-Parodyman]

The writing is Shiite, anyone saying it was dead was correct. The writing is Shiite. And this is the worst Dr. Who channel

[@johnnyfreespeech5815]

I think the show has fallen off a cliff in recent years. The writing has become very poor. I stopped watching after Jodie’s second season and even then I was going weeks or even months at a time between watching episodes. Aside from the poor writing, I think it’s impossible to refute that they’ve gone overboard with divisive identity politics in recent times. The ratings have been declining for a reason.

[@whovian59]

I agree with you 100% on these toxic KZbinrs. Particularly the vile content spewed by Nerdrotic and Bowelstreak. It’s all about click baiting and appealing to the lowest common denominator. I recently stopped following a contributor simply because they invited Nerdrotic on their show. They won’t miss me, but if everyone stuck to their principles and did the same, they’d notice! My message is don’t even click on a contributor with whom you fundamentally disagree otherwise you’re giving them what they crave - attention! 💙➕🔷

[@theunknowncommenter725]

Neither of those guys are toxic. They just prefer to be honest and funny.

[@user-je4kb9ny3w]

Rtd specifically said he was pushing an agenda.

[@user-je4kb9ny3w]

I have said before I do not care the color or gender, though I admit that I was disappointed when a woman was cast - though I've come to like her as the doctor. However the writing was, like the marvels movie, trying to make women too perfect, far smarter, not that she was smarter in a different way. That as a woman she had a different perspective that helped her intuitively win the day. And now every episode seems to be placing lgbtq+whatever at the forefront. I recall Capt Jack Harkness and he's gay or bi, his sexuality was not pushed down people's throats. Whenever his sexuality was mentioned it was a genuine progression of the story. No one would care if ncuti is gay, that's who he is. But now we need know everything about everybody even though nobody asked. I would have been fine if jinx was in the episode, but we have a modern day conversation occuring in 1920s. Had there been a phrase that said, ' I cant wait till you catch up to the future. Or something like that. It wouldnt be throwing gender affirmation down the audiences throat, it would just reference what's going on now. Rtd was a good writer when he brought the show back in 2005. Now he has gotten unbearable and terrible at storytelling. Sadly. I will always be a Whofan, but I wish I didn't have to wait for good stories to be told again.

[@theunknowncommenter725]

I don't watch Doctor Who but I love Nerdrotic, Reaper, and Clownfish TV ripping on Nurse What because everything that has happened to the former Doctor Who sounds absolutely horrible.

[@kobeangelesd]

You legit have no say in it as you just said you don’t watch it.

[@macmoore4599]

Is Mr Tardis on this list?

[@RichardFraser-mn5pe]

Are you stupid? Just asking.

[@qnebra]

Propably not, as he fit politically into what Movie Rewind likes

[@lbricks7631]

Mr Tardis is fucking excellent, what are you on about mate. I love his Doctor Who reviews, so in-depth.

[@quantumvideoscz2052]

@@lbricks7631 He calls anyone who disagrees with him a fascist. Since when does that make one excellent?

[@macmoore4599]

@@lbricks7631Well it's his inconsistency and Flip-Flopping opinions based on what ever Twitter is supporting/cancelling.

[@richardashton5015]

Well why didn't you put yourself as number one.

[@Problembeing]

"We need to atart respecting each othets opinions" - after youve gone into a diatribe against anyone expressing their opinion in the way that they vhoose to un a free society. You lack logical consistency, dear chap.

[@evie._.lake20]

I don't mind Nerdrotic. But fair opinion

[@lawsonrg01]

Thanks, I needed to sub to Reaper, 👍

[@skinner219]

FACTS!

[@granvillesimmons6033]

If they have come to despise Doctor Who, I wish they would just go watch some old Roseanne reruns while listening to Horst Wessel Lied, and leave the rest of us to enjoy the new series.

[@CaptDingDong]

The problem with that idea is that for 10 years now and counting, we can't go on to watch ANY other show without the wokesters running over to hijack those programs, too. If you like DEI saturated ideological media, fine, just don't ask the rest of us to.

[@spex76]

If all the KZbinrs that you're so dismissive off left, the show would have virtually no one watching. You'd be crying for them to come back. 🤡

[@granvillesimmons6033]

@@spex76 Not according to a number of major publications in Great Britain, and not according to Disney's viewership numbers. If you hate Doctor Who now ( if you ever were actually a fan, as a great many posting the nastiest comments on KZbin are not at all.....and a number of them have even admitted it), then go watch the Roseanne reruns. Let the rest of us enjoy the new series.

[@spex76]

@@granvillesimmons6033 The gaslighting is strong with you, my disingenuous little friend.

[@spex76]

@@granvillesimmons6033 You could throw some ISTs and PHOBES along with that Roseanne comment and really get some mileage out of it. It looks very copy and paste at the moment. Whatever you decide, enjoy the show since you're a real fan. 😉

[@MerryOlSoulGigglesmith]

The viewing figures proves them correct and you wrong Even gay and trans people say doctor who is pathetic now Funny isn't, i belive it should be a human right that we all get to express our opinions, positive and negative. And yet your fans would like people silenced. Sad.

[@jackscave518]

I have that same poster haha

[@nigelrhodes4330]

I think anyone can tell these are ideological oppositions you hold against these KZbinrs, I think it would be much better if you just came out and said that rather than waffle on for ten minutes, I would have a lot more respect for you if you did. It is fine to be ideologically opposed to someone it is just disingenuous the pretend you are not and that is why this is a poor video.