Taaleemi Idaaro’n main Zombies ki Paidawaar | Hashir Ibne Irshad

کیا ہمارے تعلیمی ادارے سوچنے والے شہری پیدا کرنے میں ناکام ہیں؟ کیا شدت پسندی کی لہر ان اداروں سے اٹھ رہی ہے؟ حقوق دانش میں ہمارا حصہ کیا ہے؟ کیا قصور وار ادارہ ہے، استاد، طالب علم یا معاشرہ؟
حاشر ابن ارشاد: ماہر تعلیم انسانی وسائل اور مالیات، تربیت کار، ایک استاد، ایک لکھاری۔

[@LuckySidhu-ln6vk]

Bhot aacha discussion hain .

[@prasantadatta5151]

Critical thinking, very illuminative.Thanks from a professor.

[@nissarguru-xg1wx]

Great lecture! Islam neither gives the freedom to think nor the freedom to express. If Islam gives these two key freedoms, it will get hit for a six. And unless we have these two critical and basic intellectual freedoms there is no way to be among the leading nations of the world.

[@gudsabhati7346]

I am indian and I am consumer of intellectuality and I found this channel very helpful,,,thank you

[@anilkchopra9120]

I agree

[@anilkchopra9120]

What a nice programme ❤❤❤❤❤

[@ghulamawliya5316]

This channel is providing discussions on great topics. We are grateful to all those who contribute to this.

[@captsudarshan]

I was very pleased to see Shakil Chowdhari saheb in the audience. I a big fan of him too.

[@AbhaySingh-ke7ej]

OMG just 3k views , as an INDIAN i will also teach critical thinking in my academy from next session thanks sir.

[@Naveedirshad]

Low subscribers reflects that what we want to see on social media. I found this channel very helpful and informative. Everyone should join for character building and improved thinking. Good initiative by Dr. Parvez Hoodbhoy.

[@drshailendersingh9297]

Thank you very much for bringing such kind of versatile teacher, it’s amazing to listening him Dr P H sir, so proud of you 👍

[@JD_Rockets]

Nice step by you the Balck hole As an indian 🇮🇳 appreciate it 😊

[@geetaprabhakar4261]

Very eye opening, very good lecture 🙏🙏We lndians should learn from him 👍👍

[@freedomfighter695]

Awesome lecture....most useful youtubechannel of pakistan 🇵🇰

[@krupadave1975]

Graffiti on the black board is always creative. Kudos to the artist.

[@MadugalaEshwar]

Wonderful conversation... worth listening

[@Bengalifirst]

This topic and discussion is so much relevant to India! I hope our culture also changes over time . Thanks for the great lecture . Respect from India 🇮🇳 .

[@Bengalifirst]

@Syedbakeruddin Bekar your surname says bekar what more can I say !! Lol 😂

[@pschhu]

GREAT PRESENTATION WITH POSITIVE APPROACH. HE DOES NOT EXPECT ANYTHING FROM PAKISTANI GOVERMENT AFTER LOT OF EFFORT BUT STILL HE EXPECT SOMETHING FROM SOME PAKISTANI PEOPLE TO CHANGE MINDSET WITH SMALL CULTURAL CHANGE.

[@irfanhaiderabidi512]

Sir Hoodbhoy I'm highly indebted to you for providing a platform for the intellectually blinds like us to learn, groom, think critically and come out of cages. Wishing you good health and long life so that you can carry on enlightening the critically paralyzed and stereotypical minds.

[@AbdulMajeed-tu2ft]

We should endeavor to make such versatile personalities our heroes rather than the so-called Ghori and Qasim. lot of respect sir.

[@pratiksingh4588]

Loved the lecture!!! 🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@avinashavalaskar957]

I would love to see these thought provoking debates, discussions & lectures.. Thanks Parvezji for this initiative. We respect you...

[@saurabhshukla1111]

Nice ..vichar rakhana aur us vichar ko samjhana hi sayad kathin hota hai kisi bhi intellectual ke liye par ye disscusion ak najariya deta hai ki hame kis tarah un muddo pr sochana jo hamare subconscious me culturally ja chuke hai 👍👍

[@captsudarshan]

Doctor Saheb, bahut accha laga. Kindly keep the good work going. Love you and all the speakers who come to The Black Hole.

[@tahirmirza8521]

Absolutely brilliant lecture. You are my "educated" hero.

[@khanjunaidullah424]

Mr. I I. Hashir Really this kind of Lacture we NEED Thanks for YOU & Allah Bless You ; Also Thanks T B H & of course Our Real Hero Dr.Perwaiz Hud-bhoy

[@Therealpak]

Quite interesting session it was and salute for making bold statements in society like us

[@skagraw2]

Sir, you have amazing observations mostly. I wasn't expecting a Pakistani teacher has so much in depth knowledge. My view is raising questions, challenging status quo, solving the problem you see around you is the key to progress.

[@aminafarialazfar9067]

Insular

[@aishasiddiqa2902]

What do you mean by you were not "expecting a Pakistani teacher has so much in depth knowledge."??? You realize it's insulting?

[@skagraw2]

@@aishasiddiqa2902 as i understand about islam, Quran forbids to accept anything other than what is written in it. Anyone going against Quran is mated with lethal and gruesome attacks. So, Pakistan being an Islamic state, I wasn't expecting Pakistan govt would allow such studies. That's the reason I got this as a pleasant surprise.

[@aishasiddiqa2902]

@@skagraw2 idk how to answer you bhai but Pakistan main religion main bhi milawat kar di hai. Do you know it’s in Islam that one should also look/learn about other religions? Kon follow karta hai isko? Our problem is lack of education. Do you know what I used to do in madras when my mom would send me to learn Quran and it was only for an hour or so? Wash his dishes lol and I never got to finish Quran but at home, I was taught to respect everyone regardless of their religion/culture or how they look. I also have a lot of questions when it comes to Islam and that doesn’t make me a bad Muslim but how many Muslims are following the good things that Islam teaches them? And no, not every Pakistani is sent to Madras for education.

[@skagraw2]

@@aishasiddiqa2902 hmm... I don't buy milawat in Islam theory. Yes, it is possible some Muslims may not follow all the rules, all the time. You may be allowed to learn culture and religion but only to ensure you either kill or convert them.

[@desidesigning]

Absolutely outstanding 👏. A breath of fresh air in such a suffocating environment of Pakistan. Well done The Black hole 🕳.

[@loveearthly]

Most engaging format, and far reaching beyond Pakistan.

[@satishchandrapant1748]

Nice discussion not only Pakistani benefited with it but also useful to we Indian

[@sunilmalik9488]

"498 out of 500 comments were from Indians"..... is a true statement. I have been noticing that any sensible Pakistani is folloed much more by Indians than Pakistanis. Some of the social insights are so eye opener. As long as society is dominated by religious leaders the progress is very much questionable. Though we are seeing religious extremism in India but that is reactive attitude against Pakistan. We would love to see upliftment of Pakistani society which in turn will calm down attitude amongs neighbors of Pakistan.

[@kishorchaudhari9445]

Against Pakistan and previous government impisement policy n corruption

[@rajeshpatil6463]

Sunil ji, you said right. But we need to alert for not converting our Indian society hardcore religious like Paskistani society

[@aamirali138]

Very insightful. I belong to rural area of Sindh but I am feeling a change in my thinking religiously and culturally.

[@ASMReating597]

bilkul sahi baat hai Hashir sab. There is no hope

[@GhulamMurtaza-ty6lm]

Such a lovely and informative session it is. Such type of discussion is necessary for the revolution and evolution.

[@krishnamurthykrishnaiyer8719]

Brilliant speech. I agree hundred percent with him.

[@KararaJawaab]

*_Mínd Boggling. Bahot Kuch Síkhne Ko Míla. Aur Maine Ek Líst Bna Lí Hai. Unpr Research Krungà. Thank You Irshàd Sír.🇮🇳-_* *_Ab To Apke Sare Vídeos Dekhna Padega._*

[@mayurmistry1977]

HE IS INSPIRING... WONDERFUL THOUGHTS.

[@chotavladimir]

Happy birthday dr.saab....god bless u....kash aap jaise aur bhi hote aapke mulk me...

[@shaziaakbar298]

بہت عمدہ گفتگو۔👏👏👏👏

[@krupadave1975]

Hashir bhai is ruthlessly realistic.

[@karamjsrihal4631]

Lots of respect for this man

[@rs4249]

Excellent discussion. Thoroughly enjoyed it. I think every country should have parenting schools where would be parents should undergo training how to groom their still unborn kid(s). Apart from this, the religious education and religious rituals should be age restricted. We must understand that praising God shouldn't be 24 hrs affair. A few minutes of our chosen period in 24 hrs should be enough for that. That question regarding people on the other side of the line was one of the most important ones which needs serious deliberation.

[@manjot24]

Strongly recommend the name, of the programme be changed to 'Glimmer of Hope', because even a small lingering tantalizingly , spurt of hope ,even if it is far in the future, can help you face the trials in between.Pakistani civil society feel for you.

[@raziagauhar9018]

زبردست پروگرام ! حاشر صاحب بہت عمدہ دلنشین انداز میں اپنی بات کرتے ہیں ۔ کاش ایسے لوگ حکومت سازی میں بھی شامل ہوں

[@pavonekumar8454]

Fantastic interaction and thought provoking ,,Even i am happy that i could see Shakhil Choudhary Sir in the questionnaire,,

[@sharjeeljawaid]

"Whatever you do shall be insignificant, but you must do it" (M K Gandhi)

[@munish259272]

Nice quote

[@qazwsx25321]

Best lecture in the black hole first time

[@rajeshpatil6463]

Thank you Dr Parvez Hoodbhoy Sir, for creating such a wonderful, knowledge giving platform which not only nurture our thoughts in Science but also in History, Socialogy & Geopolitics of South Asea. I am from India. I am very delighted Sir for inviting Hashir Sir, Shakil Chaudhari

[@indigenous_clips]

Love this informative channel. I try to watch whole episodes mostly seriously. Thanks from India ❤️

[@balajzafarr]

A ray of Hope! 💞

[@AbrarAhmad-mz8vl]

Mind opening - we should have each perspective

[@Waqar_Ahmed75]

Enlightening discussion. Thank you The Black Hole. We need more such amazing talks for Pakistan.

[@tqm790]

Wonderful lecture sir..

[@umargul1112]

Nice and effective lecture 👍.,..

[@ManmohanSingh-li8tr]

Very informative discussion, keep this great discussions going on. 👍From fellow Indian Punjab

[@englishwithmuzammal3596]

With due respect, such an educated guy, and he is giving us an ambiguous talk, revolving around atheism in disguise. Critical thinking, if you ask me, is a skill acquired through knowledge, experience, observations, failures, timely success, etc. This guy should have informed us about the education system producing zombies; nevertheless, he diverted it to faith and religion in the education system. Well, If a child fails, it's the failure of the institution is a layered question; There are many deep questions that need to be asked. One of them is that if you find a student not doing well in the class, it is the responsibility of the teacher to inform the academic supervisor who should share it with the principal who should compare notes with parents to figure out what the reason is behind this. If the child is just willing not to study, sick, and any other cause, it should be removed through proper planning. Then there is, I think, no point that a student can be failed academically. This is just one simple example of something that is doable at the beginning, which is to a large extent impossible as schools intend to pass the children no matter what way is taken. I don't think schools can teach us; I have seen doctors opting for home-schooling for their children in other countries, and this is my personal experience. Learning comes when someone wants to curiously learn, to voluntarily visit the school, and many more like these. This is a vicious circle when it comes to finding solutions. What I learned in school never helped me but the self-learning I have been doing assisted me a lot. By the time I finished the highest degree, I came to know I have been swindled. This can help, according to my knowledge, qualify for the job interview, nothing else. However, what worked for me was the self-studied knowledge and experience gained on a personal level. Thank you for reading. I might be amiss; I am open to other notions.

[@creativeash4210]

Good to read

[@sandipbhattacharyya7540]

Very thought provoking.... Worth listening...

[@reflectedthoughts3376]

For the first time I think i wasted my half an hour on this channel. Other videos of the same channel were really useful.

[@WorldOfMountains]

حاشر صاحب نے ہماری طرزِ تعلیم کا درس کا حشر کر دیا ہے

[@muhammadazeemqureshi]

great discussion.

[@melodiciousstudio9847]

I want sir hashir to come here where my father and other people conduct literary n scientific discussions. All are the students of Rahman sudiquee and youngsters are eager to meet you. It's shaheed Gali muzaffarabad

[@geetaprabhakar4261]

❤❤❤

[@jayprasadsingh]

Great Prospective sir.

[@roozamin9015]

you all are lovely people

[@ManjitKUMAR-vs3ex]

One of my school friends is running a school on the same system and its name is Munni international school..

[@HOG1070]

Brilliant

[@safarzindgihae553]

بہترین ❤

[@anujay81]

44:40 This situation, getting up to PhD, is a result of lack of job opportunities, then how one can get practical experience. So create job opportunities in industry by promoting industrialization not real estate ventures only.

[@karimhussain4004]

great sir g

[@alirazasyed2763]

Happy birthday sir perwaiz

[@huskiesofthenorth7359]

My teacher

[@nalinikoutha2091]

He is the first guest I have seen talking about patents and innovation. Unfortunately pakistan has not signed the PCT treaty even now whereas even GCC is member. India challenged some portions of GATT and even changed its law way back in 1970 to incentivse pharma industry and the result is here to see. Pranab mukerjee was the commerce minister at the time of signing GATT and there was lot of opposition by Left, but India went ahead and signed the treaty and we are reaping the benefits.India has introduced a specific section in its patent law in 2005 that blocks western monopoly on evergreening of patents. now many countries are introducing the law. I think pakistan needs to join mainstream of world if it want to develop

[@indigenous_clips]

Deep understanding. Intellectuals.. Should include human psychological aspects too Sir. Feels good to see that such kind of intellectuals are also there in Pakistan 💐 love from India ❤️

[@VidyaPai-c8b]

👏👏👏🙏

[@melodiciousstudio9847]

Masail ko pehchanny ki slahiyat he unko thek krny ka treqa b jantti hai

[@mariammalik2962]

Most inspiring

[@jasha9sandhu]

Basically equating #Islamism ( & its effect on society) with #WitchCraft

[@imranfarooqui4240]

Zabardas 👍👏

[@fahadjanjua5140]

Great

[@ZameerKhan-rv6wp]

One MBA make a stall fr tea and popular in many country airports have tea stall and leave the study beacues curriculum compose last fifty year ago.

[@gauravmathur3142]

How can you have critical thinking with Islam?

[@grihapravesham]

Dr Parvez Hoodbyoy Sir Namaste, I am a big fan of your's, please visit India, we want to meet you and learn from you sir 🙏🏼.

[@balajzafarr]

Ap jese Pakistan ma ni nzr aaty 🥲😂

[@rumz345]

@@balajzafarr ap jese jeene jo ni dete

[@balajzafarr]

@@rumz345 Hoodbhoy is my hero!

[@kashifalibhutto1632]

excellent

[@secretpower1178]

Educational system in pakistan is the worst. I do not know about the system of other provinces of pakistan but in Balochistan still in govt schools till metric all the subjects are in urdu language except english subject physics, chemistry, bio, math all are in urdu language but in colleges suddenly all the subject change into english language. Which is very difficult for students to learn science or math in such an advance english language. And the fact till the master degree students do not know what is his/her professional career. Till metric bio, chemistry, math, physics compulsory and there are no concept of arts, or IT, commerce education. Suddenly in colleges/universities all subjects divided in different fields....

[@simlyexplain]

What do you think of Takhti and Kaainati Salman Hameed work on youtube

[@salahuddinayyubi1181]

بلی کا رستہ کاٹنا یا آنکھوں کا پھڑکنا، ان کو عقائد نہیں کہتے ۔یہ توہمات ہیں ۔

[@AHMEDNOMANSADIQ]

Superb

[@ibratnak]

Don't agree with the competition part. The primary purpose of schools in underdeveloped countries should be to create individuals who can quickly start exporting their skills to rich country or can migrate to other countries on the basis of their skills. Pakistanis don't stand a chance in both since our graduates aren't as competitive as Indians or Chinese.

[@akbarkanji5368]

AJWA KHAJOOR IS GOOD FOR HEART AND IT IS SUNNAT SO IF A DOCTOR IS RECOMMENDING IT IS GOOD

[@amandeep9930]

There is a cultural shift in educated Hindus in India. Today of you'll talk about Manusmriti to an educated Hindu who follows Vedanta philosophy he/she will quickly try to disown Manusmriti. Hindus are slowly trying to distant themselves from caste system.

[@jamshedfbc]

👍❤

[@roozamin9015]

how we can share your thoughts and views in Pashtun belt cz of taliban islam

[@kashifalibhutto1632]

plz bring asim sajjad sb to the table

[@MaradonaVsPele]

498 out of 500 comments are from India!!!

[@manishkumar-ou4dt]

Agar aise 10 program pure Pakistan me tv par chale to kuch baat bane

[@javedsiddiqui1870]

what is the name of that test again? "Butler Parry"???? I can't find it on the internet. The speaker spoke so fast - pta nhn kya masla hai hamara.... amreekan itna ruk ruk kar boltae hain angraizi laikin hum log itna taiz bolaingae kae yaar alfaaz hee kha jao

[@gulzarasghar1890]

حاشر صاحب،مجھے آپکےبیشتر خیالات سے اتفاق کرنے کے باوجوداس بات سے مجھے شدید اختلاف ھےکہ ھماری تعلیم،قانون یا ھماری ھر پالیسی سیکولر ھو۔ پاکستان کا جواز ھی باقی نہی رھتا۔پاکستان۔ایک نظریاتی ملک ھےاقلیتوں کوان کے حقوق دیئے جاسکتے ہیں۔ کسطرح ایک نظریاتی ملک کو سیکو لر بناسکتے ھیں۔ دیگراپکےاس لیکچر میں بہت سے موضوعات کوچھیڑا گیا۔اپ all know man بنےبات برائے بات کرتے جارھے ھیں آپکیexpertise کیا ھے?

[@beaconlifesciences2427]

امام احمد رضا بریلوی سو نکات پیش کرتے ہیں زمین ساکن ہے ۔کیا یہ تو ہین سائینس نہیں ؟ایک خاص طبقہ جو جی میں آئے بولتا چلا جائے ۔جبکہ اگر سائنسی بنیادوں پر رد کیا جائے تو توہین مذہب ہو جاتاہے ۔

[@faheemhussain8827]

Ahmad Raza koi nabi hai nauzubillah? Woh ghalat kehte hein un ka opinion bilkul baseless hai.

[@aashif8697]

@@faheemhussain8827 to kaunsa Mohammad ne he science bata diya, Zakir Nalayak ko sun sun kar Jahil Momin Quran bhi science nikal rahe 🤣

[@pillar1154]

Einstein bhi kehta ha Zameen static ha. Einstein k according " every motion is relative": Earth Static ha relative to observer on earth while in motion relative to an observer in a place such as on 🌞. We are on earth so earth is static w.r.t us

[@kunaalparikh8796]

T

[@engr.awaisali7476]

Onon ki pta bechary non🤤😆😋

[@bushanmehra9885]

there good,bad and society,good can become bad and bad become and society is society,problem with pakistan is that neither good nor bad and never been society,a persian poem fits perfectly on pakistan. khist awal gar nihad mehmar kaj... ta suriya mirawad diwar kaj.. translation. when the first brick of a foundation has been putten bented. you can take that wall to the star ,but it will stay bented.

[@samkedar]

Does a Christian in Indian subcontinent consider any European big shot as their hero? Then just why and how can you consider invaders as hero. What religion they belonged to or you belong to now, how is that relevant?

[@abdulqureshi4914]

i think your experiance is the urban problem and you should do research on the rural problem . i think pakistan have to develope the rular economy . pakistan will have to progress in agriculture and related economy . first you have self sufficient in food . the result of expatriate money in the city made the politician and beuracracy rich and resulted in hollow economy of country . china first develope his agri/economy and the america / china policy help for the gdp increase of china . same is with india . we have miss the boat you have to go back. keep think ing on these

[@quddusquddus136]

How is it possible to talk of "critical thinking" when the students in universities have never made themselves familiar with more than one or two books? In a book "Beyond Belief", the revolutionaries---educated in London---had been immersed in books by African revolutionaries and Marxist manifestos. The writer Naipaul observes that, being from Pakistan, they hadn't taken the time to read books by 19th century writers like Ivan Turgenev. A book like "Fathers and Sons" could had made more sense to these revolutionaries since a feudal background of the Russian book would have been more relevant. The problem is not the absence of critical thinking. The problem is the absence of intellectual life. Since there has never been an intellectual life, there is an absence of vigor. Even a good teacher is not going to go very far with the students with a dismal background. Those students, with little learning, reached a ghastly end in the Naipaul's book.

[@muhammadnaeemshabbir9827]

How can I attend this Live? Please share the details