LOTR Tribute | Stories

[@DeduceHearts]

Don't be afraid to edit with other things, series, movies...you made an amazing video with LOTR 💙 we love your style, all that you create! Thanks to you for this masterpiece.

[@Punydoctor]

weirdo Thank you so so much!!❤️❤️

[@starkilr101]

Hearing the late professor’s voice is soothing. We all wish we could’ve met him. May we all be able to see the dear old man in the next life. Thank you, Professor Tolkien.

[@R4Y2k]

This task was appointed to you... and if you don't find a way, no one will... even the smallest person can change the course of the future" Tolkien was a wise man. When destiny calls, you don't run from it. You embrace it and you fight until there's no more fight left in you. Not for yourself, but for all of us.

[@fernwhite9158]

My Jordan Peterson senses are tingling

[@someinternetguy1065]

Lord or the Rings becomes really sad in certain moments when you realize it was heavily inspired from WW1. Sometimes it seems like Tolkien was talking directly to other soldiers through the pages

[@katiematkowski7478]

This is my favorite comment on this masterpiece of a tribute.

[@Hetty1204]

I both love and hate watching videos like this because they fill me with a sense of such sorrow, a longing for a world that doesn't exist but they also make me feel like I'm home.

[@Punydoctor]

Ow I know exactly how you feel!

[@hiraeth51]

This is one of the most beautiful tributes i've ever seen.

[@Punydoctor]

Thanks a bunch!

[@southernlady5085]

So true. Well balanced mix of clips from the movie and interview clips with Tolkien. What a great man, one very much needed in his day to remind all that there is good in the world worth fighting for. In my book, Tolkien is a real modern saint. His tales of Frodo and Bilbo and their respective journeys have touched so many lives! Does anyone know if he’s in the process of canonization by Rome? (For those who aren’t aware: Tolkien was a very devout Catholic.)

[@benjaminthibieroz4155]

"Some people doesn't like the Lord of the Rings. I don't know why. But it makes me sad."

[@starkilr101]

A man worth remembering for sure

[@TheBebuchis]

I love the clips of Tolkien himself talking in this, really encapsulates something special. Probably why there isn't a single person who watched this video and down voted it.

[@roybatty5592]

Sam’s monologue is perfect. Tribute to imagination, stories and strugle to be pure.

[@heididages7915]

"Be at peace of son of Gondor" That is the best, the worst and the saddest part of all of this!

[@gmrenz3618]

I watch this video at least 6 times a year, I love Lord of the Rings and this is without doubt the best LotR tribute on youtube. Thank you for sharing this with the world.

[@Punydoctor]

Good grief what kind words! Thank you so so much!

[@dadi199411]

I love how much they focus on the eyes in those close ups. Even when they don't talk they can say a thousand worlds.

[@seangaming5480]

Love the inclusion of the clips from Tolkien!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you!!

[@sophx1269]

this has been out for years but i can’t stop crying at this it’s absolutely beautiful

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so so much!

[@AlvarCreations]

Absolutely amazing. Brilliant tribute still after 6 years.

[@aliss1325]

This made my start crying as soon as it started. I love this song. Really special edit.

[@Punydoctor]

Aww thank you so much!

[@skytpe6096]

Still watching this time to time. When I get sad or need to see LOTR. Today I am not well and sharing it with this video. Thanks for the good collage

[@katiecooper1387]

This is so beautiful! It's happy and it's sad and it's inspirational! I love the voice overs. I think it's so cool you got Tolkien's voice in here. This is such a great tribute to his work, and I had tears in my eyes by the end. Thank you for making this!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much for your very very kind words❤❤❤

[@HarshavardhanRD]

why does this vid not have millions of views? its a masterpiece!!

[@moirajepson3234]

I not even going to lie I cried

[@southernlady5085]

So very well done. Thank you. Needed this today. Fighting my own Orcs in the form of autoimmune illnesses. My husband is my Sam. Everyone needs a Sam.

[@z4eth]

This is the most beautiful amv I have ever seen. I can't stop watching it. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@Punydoctor]

Sorry for such a late reply, but thank you so much!

[@vivsb5040]

*WORDLESS ADORATION*

[@rebelxoswald]

Thank you for making this! It's beautiful! The books and movies mean a lot to me. And personally, I think it's fantastic for you to spread out the content you want to make. To explore more. You have every right to. And if someone doesn't like it then they haven't seen the same talent I have. Thank you again for making such a beautiful tribute to a classic trilogy both in movie and books.

[@Punydoctor]

Your comment honestly made my day! Thank you so incredibly much for your kind words and for taking the time to write them. You have no idea how much it means to me that someone actually enjoys my content. It really means the world to me. So, thank you so much!

[@rebelxoswald]

I'm just glad to see someone else who appriciates these stories as much as I do and turns it into art. :)

[@heatherwilson2208]

I don't think anything can ever top LOTR for me. They were the first big novels I read as a kid, and I grew up watching the movies. They are a part of me, in a way nothing else can be.

[@nixutree1578]

I know this video has been out for years but thank you so much for making this. This tribute to LOTR has genuinely made me cry, it's that beautiful.

[@Punydoctor]

Aww thank you so much! That people still watch this video years after it's been posted, means a lot to me. So thank you for your kind words!

[@j.0995]

I am starting a tradition for every year I watch this movie and read the books. I grew up with the lord of the rings and it will never be forgotten. Never. This was beautiful. Thank you so much. 😢❤️😭❤️❤️

[@Punydoctor]

Oww thank you so much!

[@fernwhite9158]

Thank you for making it, from the bottom of my heart.

[@Punydoctor]

Aww thank you so much for watching it!❤❤☺

[@fernwhite9158]

@@Punydoctor I've read your description and I want you to know you should have more confidence in your skills, they're admirable. I really would like to see more of your Lord of the Rings videos 😊

[@Punydoctor]

@@fernwhite9158 ow🥺 thank you so much!

[@roybatty5592]

Best lotr tribute. One of the greatest stories ever written by man.

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you very much!

[@Sarapontmercy]

this made me cry way more than I needed to... beautiful

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much for your kind words, Sara🥰🥰❤

[@conorlamere399]

I recently watched the Extended Editions (at long last) and it's amazing that some of these key story moments were cut from the shorter versions I grew up with.

[@chickenlittle_jae7979]

So beautiful!!! it's so emotional... GREAT

[@Punydoctor]

amelia_ bla Thank you very much❤️❤️

[@chickenlittle_jae7979]

Punydoctor Thank YOU for the Video!!!😍👍👍

[@tastypeppermint8061]

Oh man... This was so powerful and it made me cry... Thank you. What a beautiful video.

[@ohifonlyx33]

I knew this would make me cry. 30 seconds in, I proved myself correct and I haven't yet stopped crying. Man LOTR knows how to bring out the tears. Also... I'd love to know where you got your copy if you don't mind.

[@moirajepson3234]

Same

[@edwin.a.1156]

it is a legal requirement to click whenever lotr gets recommended by youtube

[@darkness_mustpass]

Thank you for this beautiful video!❤️

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you for watching it! It means the world to me!

[@secretlyad0g]

Beautiful...truly just heart-warming and yet makes me hurt, these stories mean so much to me. I feel lost whenever I finish the books or films once again, yes, I may read the appendices etc. However....this tale alone, of The Hobbit and LOTR is what I grew up with, what brought me hope and happiness when I was depressed. I sat in the school stairwells reading them and holding the books so close to me wherever I went 💚🌿 It is easy to say Tolkien is one of the most brilliant and influential fantasy writers, none will ever exist again like him!

[@TheFoxofKnowledge]

It's quite surprising that there aren't alot of LOTR videos (or at least proper ones). The most viewed is only 60k and rest is an average of 5k to 10k. It's really well edited. My only critique would be the transitioning and colour used for this project, but that is just me and my personal style in editing. You deserve at least 50k views

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you very very much!

[@CumhurYalcn]

This is incredibly beautiful my friend. And my sincere thanks, from the bottom of my heart.

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you very much for your kind words❤

[@benpearson2299]

Don't worry about the views, you deserve millions of views. Your work is beautiful and inspiring, don't be afraid of trying new styles of video, in the words of the wise and great Gandalf 'fly you fool'

[@Punydoctor]

Ben Pearson Aww Thank you so much! You have no idea how much this support means to me, so thank you. Thank you so incredibly much❤️

[@benpearson2299]

Punydoctor more than welcome, keep flying you beautiful hooman

[@ParanoidOwlet]

I love you so, so much for this work. thank you.

[@Punydoctor]

paranoidowlet Aww thank you so very much for watching and for your kind words!

[@WillMunny22]

Puny this was pretty good. There are many LOTR youtubers, i never seen anything from you before. I wasn't disappointed. I wouldn't mind seeing another, maybe a part 2 or even a tribute to The Hobbit trilogy

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you very much! Problem atm is law school tbh haha - that's why I don't get around to editing that much lately! But once again, thank you!

[@εὐδαιμονία-φ4ε]

What is this wetness in my eyeeees 😭😭😭 Great video! ❤

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so very much!

[@jasoncreedfilms]

This is fucking beautiful! Thank you for taking the time to make this. This is special.

[@Punydoctor]

Oww thank you so much for your kind kind words!!!!!!!!!

[@golwenlothlindel]

wow. Even today too few people understand stories, despite how important stories have become in modern popular culture. More people need to read Tolkien’s essays, particularly “On Fairy-Stories”. He understood, in a way that few others have, why we make stories and what they do for us.

[@LauraFringe-m3x]

Absolutely brilliant, its a masterpiece, so heartfelt.

[@mondasdolan]

Best Lord of the Rings tribute EVER

[@Punydoctor]

mondasdolan Thanks a bunch!

[@casxsunshine]

This is the most beautiful and heartbreaking video I've ever seen😿😿😿💞💞Thank you

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much haha

[@lety04]

This is stunning😢😍😍😍❤❤❤

[@Punydoctor]

GRYFFINDOR PRIDE Thank you so much!

[@lety04]

Punydoctor you're welcome❤You did an amazing job

[@albertoaparicio2728]

One of the best lotr tribute videos i've ever seen

[@Punydoctor]

Aww thank you so much!

[@gabrielbrollo1515]

This video saved my day. Thank you

[@chloeshippey3363]

that was so beautiful i literally bawled. thank you for creating a stunning tribute to my most favourite passion of all time. Lord of the Rings ❤️

[@Punydoctor]

Aww thank you so much!

[@eddiejacobsson3895]

Woooooow I can't belive that this really exists❤😭❤😭 I love it, best I've seen! I'm crying my eyes out😭❤❤❤❤❤

[@Punydoctor]

Aw thank you so much!

[@lety04]

THIS HURTS.SO MUCH.BUT IT IS ALSO SO BEAUTIFUL❤

[@Punydoctor]

Aww thank you so much!

[@lety04]

@@Punydoctor you're welcome❤

[@instridewith_life]

This is hecking beautiful!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much!

[@weltenleser]

This tribute is simply wonderful. Thank you.

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so very much!

[@brianwahle40]

Absolutely incredible tribute my man, made me tear up. loved it cause it focused on the stuff I love most about the LOTR, friendship, loyalty, courage...

[@ArtePoeticaTV]

I have three accounts on KZbin. I left and I entered the three to be able to like this video. ..Thank you.

[@Punydoctor]

That means so much to me, thank you!

[@thelordoftheundead]

The best from LOTR I've seen. Great work mate.

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much!

[@Drstarberry1]

This is one of the most beautiful tributes I've ever seen and I wanna say thank you for making this. Don't be afraid to explore! This is beautiful!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you! Comments like yours mean the world to me❤

[@contrapasso]

This was just lovely.

[@Punydoctor]

Oww thank you!

[@samuelleask1132]

This is awesome

[@LyricalLinder]

Holy crap! That was great! I always enjoy your videos, but this one made me tear up, and I loved it!

[@Punydoctor]

LyricalLinder Aww thank you so much!

[@sarahbartholomew3691]

This is lovely. Thank you so much.

[@Rossjmann]

This is honestly just perfect

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much❤❤

[@mikypera]

Only 800 views? I don't get it. Excellent video

[@Punydoctor]

Miquel Pera aww thank you so much! I think it has to do with the fact that most of my subscribers subscribe for DW content and not anything else. If you ready the description box you’ll see what I mean. Once again, thank you❤️

[@mikypera]

Punydoctor I see what you mean.. Anyway, you have one susbcriber more now!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much!

[@Asheathsa22]

This is the best KZbin video I've ever watched 😭😍🙌🏻💛

[@Punydoctor]

Ashleigh Louise Thank you so much!

[@drieslaenen2112]

Truly amazing video!!!!!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you!

[@minivercheevy4828]

2020 and I'm crying ♥️

[@darkfaerie145]

beaaaaaaaauuuuuuuuuuuuutiful video with beeeeeeaaaaaauuuuuutiful coloring and visuals. well done!

[@Punydoctor]

darkfaerie145 Thank you so much!❤️

[@lety04]

HAPPY BIRTHDAY J.R.R TOLKIEN,THANK YOU SO MUCH,SO MUCH❤

[@eriknordgren1289]

This was a great video! Almost a year later but this is great editing. Totally deserves more credit.

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much! Your comment made my day❤

[@od5578]

This is so beautiful 😭❤️

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you!

[@BeatrizGF1]

Incredible video! Great job! I love your videos!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you very much!

[@BeatrizGF1]

[@conorhouston69]

Don’t be afraid of people disliking your videos Amazing work and keep going From, Like 180

[@Punydoctor]

Conor Houston Thank you very much!

[@onlycrazy7258]

OMG I LOVE THIS SO MUUUUUCH 😍😍😭😭 that makes me love you even more 😭💗💗

[@Punydoctor]

Only Crazy Thank you so much!❤️❤️

[@maryhufflepuff]

This is so beautiful 😍💔

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you so much!

[@HannibalHanslaughter]

aaaaaaaaaw that was lovely

[@Punydoctor]

Hanibal Channiblo Thank you very much!

[@bradleynathaniel-thomas]

Great video, don't be afraid to make the videos you want. It's your channel after all.

[@Punydoctor]

Bradley Thomas Thank you so much for your kind words and support!

Great

[@NitinChauhan-vh2yk]

The vocals of the song dull the vibe for my liking but I still love it because why not! It's LOTR and it's a good edit!

[@Punydoctor]

Lol, thanks! I think🤔

[@0201Cosmic]

omg you broke me

[@niningsetia4213]

Love you all❤️❤️🌲🌹🙏🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@RobinRozendal]

Love your edit! However, the sound could be better, seems like you pushed it too much or something... it might hold back your views. Maybe you could fix that? Just wanted to let you know, because your storytelling is awesome :-D !!

[@Punydoctor]

Thank you very much! The problem is that I can't remove the background music, so I have to edit the shit out of the file. I know it sucks but honestly it's the best that I can do

[@RobinRozendal]

But maybe put the volume a little lower? (I'm a video editor for a living, so I know a little bit about this stuff) Ah, and, did you put audiofilters on the voices, to suppress the music? that might explain it... Maybe next time you could try and use a little less filters. Just a thought! And I only say this because I really enjoyed your video, just want to help :-)

[@Punydoctor]

@@RobinRozendal Of course, I appreciate the advice! I used an app to reduce the background noise, but I won't be editing for a while now anyways because I'm currently studying law :)

[@RobinRozendal]

Ah, on to more serious business :-) Haha! Well, good luck, and I hope you also keep editing sometimes ;-)

[@sinabayat3654]

Frodo wouldn't have gone far without Sam

[@krumbers]

Frodo wouldn’t have gotten far with out Sam...

[@americannacho]

imagine being a frodo

[@danamal4897]

I wish my videos was as good as yours

[@skytpe6096]

Man ı made a substitle to your video. Can you accept it?

[@barriebutsers7488]

0 disslikes