Is It REAL or CAKE Challenge!

[@TheIcingArtist]

Did you get a better score than us?? 😅 Thanks to Care/of for sponsoring this video! For 50% off your first Care/of order, visit bit.ly/47tFNK7 and use code ICINGARTIST

[@rachaelsecka8620]

I played with my daughter and hand on heart I guessed them all correct she said I cheated her because my hobby is cake making wish I was that creative 😂

[@Nika44]

Nope, not better, I also guessed 2 but last one was WOW!! I was 100% sure that it was a wase not the clock thing, last one was simply amazing

[@jalisaking2046]

I got 4, the gnome one was tricky

[@vampqueen]

I got 3 right. I said it was number one on the last go.

[@lizajane2971]

I got all except the last one! I also guessed 2 for that one 😊

[@i-janadeny]

You should definitely consider this kind of challenges in future it is so much fun and totally different than other youtubers.

[@TheIcingArtist]

LOVED doing this video!! I have so many ideas for more challenges!

[@pooydragon5398]

@@TheIcingArtist Try with Natalie Sidesurf as well! She is soo good

[@spr15]

​@@pooydragon5398yeah I have been waiting for her collab with Natalie

[@Sponggybobbie]

She copied faze rug

[@x4m1r4N]

@@pooydragon5398 Agree, Natalie Sideserf is so good. This one, I can easily recognise it. Probably, we have a close up view.

[@iEatcandy.]

THAT LAST 1 was INCREDIBLE, it would've been my last guess. I guessed the rest, however the house & gnome I was quite divided. SHE'S SO TALENTED.

[@bobbiec2829]

Same! It was pretty amazing!

[@punkrockprincess0818]

it was the painting on the gnome that did it for me

[@ashleywildman8293]

I got all of them right! We were able to see them closer up with out distractions though 😂

[@spr15]

I still got two wrong 😂😂

[@christinemcdougall6476]

I also got them all right.

[@kanditraxel]

Me too! The eggs were pretty off, lol

[@sharonhill2602]

I thought it was easy, I’ve only ever gotten a couple wrong on the show too.

[@nichola90]

I got them all right too

[@cookieguygaming]

We need more Icing Artist game shows these seem like such fun videos that can have so much done with them.

[@TheIcingArtist]

YAAASS!! I honestly had a blast with this video and want to do so many more game show style challenges!

[@cookieguygaming]

@@TheIcingArtistimagine like a wheel of fortune, where if you guess the sentence correctly you get to each cake, but if you don’t you have to smash your face in a cake lololol

[@ControversyCupcake]

@@cookieguygamingthats is actually a really fun idea

[@Clarky1951]

Well I only got one!! 😫 The egg carton. The last antique cake was insane!!! April did an amazing job on all the the fooler cakes. Totally impressed. Uber talented 👍👍

[@TheMaryWriter]

I got them all right, but think that we had an advantage seeing it up close. The sandal and egg were most obvious because there were structural parts that were just a tad off. The others I picked up by color and the way the light hit the object, though it could very well be the way the camera picked up the colors. This would be an awesome series. Even though I guessed the last one right away it was incredibly impressive and I would love to see more amazing cakes and artistry. Also, the banter between you all is really fun. Thanks for making me smile today.

[@Imjustkendall]

Stop judging

[@electricmushyy]

NOT THE TILTSCAPE 😂😂😂😂😂😂 I absolutely loved this video idea!!! So fun!!!

[@TheIcingArtist]

bad things happen when the tiltscape is off!

[@rainysunflower384]

The texture and brush strokes on the gnome were just perfect. April is so talented!

[@tangerine_grunge]

JonnyCakes and Icing Artist collab when?!

[@AnneliseStafford]

Yes I’d love to see them make cakes together instead of just guessing

[@ArtsyMario]

YES! That would be a fun collab! I hope they do one!

[@BernieBuble]

Or Sideserf!

[@DiogoChris]

I feel like watching ✨Natalie Sideserf's✨ videos made me an expert on this 😂 Good game❤

[@JodiLeaSnakeQueen]

💯

[@Leanne_w]

Yeah these ones don’t look realistic to me. Natalie’s are way better

[@rosemarychurchill]

You definitely should bring in Natalie Sidesurf to do this next. Weldone

[@AprilJulianCakes]

I’m ready for the rematch Laurie and Kevin!! 😂 🍰

[@TheIcingArtist]

This challenge was INSANE!! I can't imagine what you would do for a rematch! 😅

[@lindseybotelho]

You're incredibly talented ❤

[@AprilJulianCakes]

Thank you so much Lindsey! 🥰@@lindseybotelho

[@pick2206]

it was so hard to tell the difference! googoo 👍👍

[@deborahjames3113]

That was insane!!! Thank you to April for the incredible work you put in for our entertainment! this was a really fun video that we got to participate in

[@Leah57320]

I'm surprised that I got 5!! I love how Laurie and Kevin have a cake break after each round with such joyful amusement❤, thank you!!!hope everyone laughed as hard as i did!!😅❤😊

[@ErinChamberlain]

The last round was absolutely insane! No idea! What a great job!! I love that show lol

[@cailin12]

This & buying cakes from 3 different bakers are my favorite videos! So much fun to watch 16:32

[@suecampbell4811]

This should be a monthly series! 1 - it's entertaining, 2 - it helps fans see the bakers guest on your vlog, 3 - it is nice to see you should your love of baking in a different way from baking for us. You did great! (I don't need to see flashing lights or you guys spinning - I have vertigo - but I liked looking at the screen when you were at the guessing/revealing stages. Maybe those things don't add a lot of value to the vlog - you could get a few seconds to guess and compete that way too!)

[@annierism]

You should collab with Natalie Sideserf. She does incredible hyperrealistic cakes. Love her cakes. Love yours too of course. 😜

[@OfficialPotato1]

The 1st one seemed to obvious which made me guess 3 too, she did great! By making it look so much like a cake that I thought it was too obvious and guessed a different one! 🎉

[@Leena79]

I got all but two correct. I was torn between the poutine and the meatball sub, and chose wrong. In the last round, the scale looked sus, but so did the urn ( which I picked). But these were all insanely convincing. I love Is it cake, it was cool to see the artist behind all those creations.

[@TheIcingArtist]

April killed these challenges and they were SO hard to guess in person (even up close!)

[@marinastrassburger6332]

I would love to see a side by side tutorial video where she teaches you how to create a realistic dupe. Maybe even include Kevin, seeing how some of his past decorating attempts have been pretty good. It’d be fun to see how it comes out.

[@kierancampire]

Obviously we see them all up close but I did get them all right! Thing is, on the actual show if I got distracted and didn't see the ones they were working on, I was fooled many times on the show with having no idea what was and wasn't cake!

[@Nurse4llie]

The only one I guessed wrong was the one that we got three seconds to look at them. Props to Kevin for getting that one! I thought it was the Big Mac. I also think the audience got a bit more of the closeups! She did amazing. I love is it cake!

[@ChineloMark-gd7nl]

Laurie always makes my day. Thank you Laurie and Kevin for all the effort you put in

[@Struck-Lucky]

This was fun to do along with you! I got every category right except antiques. That was lovely detailing on the last cake, major props to April for all of these!

[@taram9098]

Love the show on Netflix and she was one of favorites contestants!!! This was soo good ! It was so hard to guess they all looked so real!

[@lakewolfsunrise2523]

I got all correct. Watching Natalie's Sideserf's vids definitely helps. 🎉

[@Aceofstars16]

There were one or two that I was going back and forth on, but having the zoomed up look and watching SideserfCakeStuido for a few years probably helped in differentiating them 😂

[@hana67432]

I love watching is it Cake, It’s so interesting to watch, Your Is It Real or Cake Challenge Video is a Awesome Idea, Please do more of these Videos with Kevin and April also Laurie, Thank you. 😃

[@Glowritz1]

Love this! Next time before cutting they should be allowed to examine it up close (but not be able to change answers)

[@ENTREPRE-MOMMY]

Ok, so I mean this in the nicest way possible. Her blending skills are a bit sloppy at times so I guessed right on all but the gnome one. I think Natalie Sideserf would be great to have on because she really pays attention to detail and is perfection when it comes to anything cake. This lady is sweet and has a nice smile, but hyper realistic cake is not really her thing. Please don't be offended.

[@samanthadean1083]

I wanna see a challenge video between April and Sideserf Cake Studio!!! ❤️❤️❤️👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@xyliadetering]

The only one wrong and I’m honestly surprised I even got one right lol. The cap in the first one just looked like it could be cake to me

[@shauxuhrwilsongrim]

I lost the last one. Not complaining though, that was awesome! The others were incredible too, but I've had some practice watching Sideserf Studios 😉

[@RJsyiyia]

I got 3! That scale totally had me fooled and I went with you and Kevin on thinking the urn was cake. She is a fantastic cake artist!

[@lucaspippet7155]

I was SO shook by that fibal obe though!! My jaw actually dropped 🙀

[@mrscb5303]

Please do this again! You two were adorable. I got all of them but nobody was throwing stuff at me or spinning me around 😉🤣 Absolutely mind blowing cakes. I picked the fried because I figured they wouldn’t have showed you a “messy” box. It was to perfectly real, if that makes sense. Totally fun!! Hope you guys enjoyed it too I am crossing my fingers for a Halloween challenge soon 🧡🖤🧡🖤🧡

[@dianemcq64]

So much fun to watch and guess along. Astounding cake artistry. OMG. 🍰

[@zzbayan]

I will admit, I was fooled beyond my expectations. Amazing work by April!

[@caylahcoffeen8125]

I guessed all of them right! The clock face on the last one did look painted on. So detailed!

[@nousername334]

Omg you should do more of these. Do a fall one. With different pumpkins, candles, Halloween decorations etc. Would be fun.

[@laurawright-king5046]

I got them all except the egg one, very cool and super artistic and that you can eat it is the best part

[@punkrockprincess0818]

Got all of them almost right away w/o the closeup but I watch Is It Cake? very often (even though it's only two seasons), it's incredible to see what people can make.

[@lilbfly02]

I missed EVERY SINGLE ONE 😂 Please make more of these videos! 🙇‍♀️ AMAZING talent. Hands down respect!!!

[@BamitekoMartins]

Hi laurie you are the best baker and cake decorator l know of❤❤😊😊🎉

[@lindasingleton3072]

I love all of your videos, but this has been one of my favorites so far. I love 'Is it cake?', but man they drag it out and do so much that isn't necessary and can be super corny to be honest. Having this real video, with no fake scripts or filler videos, so good. Then the decorater going over it with us. Love. More of these!!!

[@misst2017]

Fun! I actually got them all right except for the last I was so torn between #1 and #2.

[@Kaylee_eeee]

I got them all except the last one, I really thought it was the gold thing. Wow. Incredible what can be done with cake.

[@autumn_hibbs]

I got all of them right without stopping or going back throughout the video

[@susansprigg7665]

My child loved watching is it cake. Also enjoys watching the icing artist. We did really well together and enjoyed this collaboration, thank you xx

[@brandy6603]

This was so fun to watch!!!! 😁👏🏼 the last one got me good!

[@sunnysxdeYT]

This was SUCH a good video idea! I loved that Kevin was in it! How did you get him to agree haha?? I would love to see more of this!

[@earlleary]

Ok..... this one got me as well you guys ! Lol! I only scored a 2 also. 1. Shoe ✔️ 2. Mushroom House ❌️ 3. Bag of Sugar ❌️ 4. French Fries ✔️ 5. Gold Vase ❌️ This was fun! You guys are an absolute joy to watch ! I love your personalities, including Achie, he is such a good furbaby, I just love him to pieces! Have a beautiful day , ❤

[@kendramanuel968]

That second round smoked my head for sure! I thought it was the cottage and I was confident

[@b.j.mosley2926]

While we were on vacation my husband pulled this show up on the tv just to show me but all 3 of us got so into we needed up watching all the episodes through out our 4 day vacation lol. Than I watched it when the second season came out with my niece since we both love baking. She said I so good at picking them to bad it is not a real job lol.

[@adelinesadventures5196]

I got all of them right! Hahaha maybe I should go on a show for that😅

[@laurelstanard5200]

I loved Is is cake and April's duck cake on the show was absolutely amazing!!! So much talent!

[@itsali1290]

I absolutely love your videos!

[@IceNixie0102]

I got 3. Missed the gardening (it was a toss up between the gnome & fairy mushroom, and I chose wrong) and the last one.

[@michmoe85]

I got all of the right. It was even harder to see on my phone screen. But you can tell by the way it’s shaped and the coloring. They all look amazing though!

[@Rain_boot]

First one: I guessed between 1 and 2. Second one: I guessed 2 Third one: MAYBE 3? or 4. Fourth one: 3?? or 4. Fifth one:1 or 2. This was such a cool video! had fun playing along.

[@Rivenmoxie]

As someone who notices details… i got all of them and watching their shock for the last one was funny cause i knew.. but sooooo well crafted!!! All the cakes!!!

[@ashleigh9255]

This is the perfect video because I've just finished binging all seasons of is it cake

[@yolandaponkers1581]

I adore her!! Please have her back!!

[@KD-vg1kh]

The last one was the only one that tripped me up lol I thought it nvsaid nah it’s 2 😂😂

[@indigoeye3874]

I got 2 as well, the first one and the last one. I couldn't believe some of the other ones were cakes! The fries especially.

[@HisBlueEyedBlondie]

How did Kevin have the willpower not to even take a nibble? This was a great challenge. What fun!

[@dg912]

Why didn’t he taste them?

[@rebeccamiller3248]

Got all 4. Learned a lot watching you and Kevin and Archie.

[@teresahalliday3680]

This was great fun! Her cakes are amazing! I got all but the last one (without distractions but in real time)

[@karenritter2574]

I've got every single round wrong 🤣🤣🤣🤣 totally amazing

[@princessofdeath4300]

I got all but the first one. This was a lot of fun to watch.

[@jfcfanfic]

The last one was the only one I missed. So much fun.

[@PurpleCinnamon-Land-Of-Misfits]

Round two so you can break the tie is a must this was so nuch fun to watch ☺️

[@Standinthegap4ever]

Where was Archie when they were flinging all the toys at you? 😂

[@alyssagentry9412]

I love that show, i usually do pretty good on guessing the cakes

[@margarethawolfe7989]

The poutine and antiques as easy for me

[@MrsLyds]

I found them all but one the antiques I was between 1-2! Pretty good job though

[@robinhoogewerf6712]

I got the last one right! I also got 2 of the rest right but of course I wasn't spinning or having stuff thrown at me.

[@TheKmcannon]

That was awesome. I think this might be my favorite video yet.

[@TheIcingArtist]

yay!! I hope everyone loves it so we can do more videos like this!

[@maribottoms8973]

We had the advantage of no distractions and being able to zoom in. That was AWESOME!

[@Brandi_the_Baker]

Me and my husband love watching “Is it cake”.

[@lyrics4life616]

I got all 5. Very surprising considering that I've never made a cake a day in my life!! :)

[@JennasMusic76]

This was so fun, I only missed number 2 I feel the garden items were hard, I love this and would love to see more of these videos.

[@ajaymurali3839]

I missed only the garden decor one and the only reason I scored so much is coz of the close up shots. I could not have done it without that. We neeeed a johnycakes collab ❤

[@kristen4050]

This is how your kids don't eat your treats. "Mom, what do you have?!" "Oh, nothing.. just a shoe"

[@dancesmokesmile344]

I got them all right! But I still haven’t been fooled on the show either though 😅

[@mikeywiththecamera]

My mind is completely blown by that scale at the end! That is true art!

[@grungophone1615]

I got all except the last the scale was INSANE so good!!!

[@nakazora]

I got 3 right - the shoe, the eggs, and the poutine. The last round really got me I genuinely thought it was the chalice thing as well.

[@allisonb8912]

Got them all except the garden round. I thought it was the little house!

[@anakhanair_]

I got the last one wrong, i also guessed 2 and i am still in awe of the pure skill it takes to make cake look like an inedible object.

[@mistybollinger3312]

This was so much fun!! And I was right there with yall on that last one I thought it was the bug gold thing too!! I was absolutely blown away when she said it was the scales!! Would definitely love to see more shows like this one!!! 😁😁

[@Bucka1500]

I love this video❤️we definitely need more of these,i was playing along too and it was so fun😂

[@famoushollywood]

My choices: Black cap, House, Eggs, Fries, Scale= 3 right I would love to do this with my boyfriend! We love the show!

[@mindyourbusinessfr]

I got it all right, I love that show so this was so fun to watch!!! Love ittt

[@lorraineupton1116]

I got all of them apart from the last one which I thought was number 2 the scales was amazing. I love your videos.

[@jennypaxson3030]

That last one was hard. I thought it was the box. That was amazing

[@jaimieliebig1874]

I guessed all five, that was fun.. you should definitely do it again

[@GrimmDemon]

I got 4 out of the 5 right, I thought it was the golden vase on the last one. I definitely think it is easier to pick out the cake when the items are all different in a selection, unlike on the show "Is It Cake?" where the cake is hidden amongst the objects it is supposed to look like.