LE SSERAFIM (르세라핌), THE SHOW CHOICE! [THE SHOW 230509]

[@차누-b5n]

진짜 라이브 박살났다,,,,

[@TaylorLeeKnow]

To the future inspiring idols , you just need the visuals, a good height and great dancing skills. Forget about the vocals, it will be done by the music editors 🤣

[@Alanie715]

CRYING 😭😭

[@rainbowlovez]

😂😂

[@marcusmeins1839]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHHAHA!

[@koreanimmersion3608]

who knows, dancing might not even be a mandatory requirement by then LOL.

[@septindruru1904]

Lol😭😭😭

[@Bibbibbipbip]

Vocal training>>>>Abs training

[@iqraansariivrollno1721]

So true😂😂

[@strawxella0309]

I laughed when I see this comment 😂 so real

[@rainbowlovez]

😂

[@Verowinday777]

LL! vocals aren’t going to keep you healthy!

[@strawxella0309]

@@Verowinday777 then don’t be an idol , they need to learn how to sing as well not only dance

[@jinsouloutdidurfaves]

they seriously have unforgiven vocals.

[@midastouchedd]

Chaewon’s good and stable

[@jinsouloutdidurfaves]

@@midastouchedd fr chaewon ate

[@1uveriii]

As if u can actually sing

[@jinsouloutdidurfaves]

@@1uveriii i'm a trained singer and also trained in musical arts. if u can't handle criticism then gtfo cuz that is not even a proper comeback lmao

[@sharmarkeismail4698]

@@jinsouloutdidurfaves damn you cooked with this comment😂

[@감자-e2r]

팬들도 들으면서 숙연헀을듯..

[@고독쓰]

초상집 분위기

[@TENlOOl]

레전드영상...또 보러 왔음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ절대 삭제안됐음 좋겠다

[@GhuIam-e-Mustafa]

I’m sorry but Sakura being in this industry for 10 years really should get her vocals better

[@ClubPuguin]

Well because most of that time the industry she was in didn't put importance to it or care to train it.

[@r_milk2614]

日本のアイドルは歌上手い子少ない

[@chaeyoungish_]

True... I can sing better than sakura😂

[@minho566]

​@@chaeyoungish_ That's funny.

[@ninahess7738]

Frr

[@oei-fo6gb]

3:15 게사리 - 레쓰게사리 - 미루코아페새겨도난쏘리

[@user-fy3ek6bn6f]

아니 이 레전드 좌표가 베댓에 있어야지

[@runing_pham]

개웃기넼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@dffsrtewtgsegsgss]

아씨발 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@붕어빵123]

4:15

[@seulki7028]

3:20 십며니 - 되면나 - 밸랜나머댄씽대랠라 - 타버빠결

[@pinkneon5534]

The one with short hair with bangs is the only one who can sing the others were heard like a screeching.

[@Yestry_Oinnie]

its Chaewon

[@Rainienuabo]

Yunjin used to be in theater and was an opera singer, she was also stable so Idk why you only praised Chaewon.

[@Yestry_Oinnie]

@@Rainienuabo Yunjin wasnt really this stable at easy encore stage

[@00B.]

​@@Rainienuabobro being an opera singer doesn't mean you're automatically stable and that you're supposed to be praised. In this case she wasn't. All of them were OK for a karaoke night and terrible for a paid job as singers.

[@Kuromiicollector_]

@@Rainienuabothat’s not a reason for them to praise her at this moment. We’re talking about an encore, not an opera. We praised her for her opera performance but she wasn’t as stable for this performance. That’s ok. There are off days.

[@galerights8983]

why is sakura always on the verge of tears when singing

[@Tysnotdead]

HELP

[@exquisitelytae3050]

You would be too if you sounded like that 😭

[@tp5487]

I think its cuz she's a nasal singer But other nasal singers arent this bad tho lol

[@exquisitelytae3050]

@@tp5487 nah her nasally tone has nothing to do with shakiness and squeakiness. Even when she speaks her voice is hella shaky.

[@Leo_nardo135]

😂😂😂

[@엉덩일흔드록바-m1t]

마케팅을 너무 잘했네...라이브가 처참하다..컨셉은 독기인데 그렇지 못한 실력...어쩜 좋아

[@febrieds8019]

fr ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@strwbey_sweetsuga_]

Hazlo tu entonces, canta y baila al mismo tiempo

[@Polygondian]

estan literalmente paradas @@strwbey_sweetsuga_

[@yerination8531]

@@strwbey_sweetsuga_this was the encore, where they didn't have to dance

[@strwbey_sweetsuga_]

​@@yerination8531 despues de que ellas haigan bailado no han tenido tiempo en tomar aire (respirar) aparte es una coreografía difícil y fuerte .

[@yagirlani1656]

Chaewon had the most stable and in sync singing voice out of all of them. Sad she only had 2 main solo lines only

[@halatiny6537]

Why are you trying to compare them and put the rest down

[@nora_mk]

@@halatiny6537 cause the rest did awful?

[@kpopzyyy_]

@@nora_mk yunjin and eunchae were good? Now you ain’t excepting everyone to sound EXACTLY like the studio version cause no group can do that 💀

[@nora_mk]

@@kpopzyyy_ when did I say that they're supposed to sound EXACTLY like the studio version?

[@nora_mk]

@@kpopzyyy_ Yunjin did good tho. Eunchae did good enough. But the other two sucked. And yeah I don't expect them to sound EXACTLY like the studio version but they atleast should know how to sing lmao. Their vocals were so unstable even the jobless people on streets sing better. They sucked despite having vocal trainings lmao you can't make any excuses for them. And if you think that they sound good then it's just your blind obsession honey.

[@Tean-tm2lg]

Yunjin and Chaewon are the saving grace of Le Sserafim.

[@IhsanPutradana]

le sserafim member ; yunjin , chaewon , eunchae the rest r back dancer tbh

[@남명-i7l]

개밥에 도토리

[@romasa831]

@@IhsanPutradanashut the hell up man

[@g.k44]

​@@IhsanPutradana😭😭😭😭🤣🤣🤣

[@justifiedprblm]

​@@IhsanPutradana ni boti keknya gempur banget ye ngehate fimmies, udah denger perform GDA mereka live di jakarta? apa kuping lu pura pura budek? siapapun lu semoga penyakit julid ke idol gue cepet ilang ye, amin

[@kimyeontan1422]

chaewon omg such a beautiful voice

[@동-y2e]

1위 시켜주는 이유가 1위할만한 애들인지 검증하기 위한 자리인듯...

[@febrieds8019]

imo even they're being idol they deserve to be model

[@masoud6920]

옛날에는 분명히 1위 축하용 뒷풀이 무대였는데....

[@retrievezz]

ㄹㅇㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@강태현을사랑합시다]

ㄹㅇ;;

[@airpracio8319]

Chaewon's voice is really stable though

[@Rh_richelle]

인정인정

[@남명-i7l]

노

[@lua-user]

Yes

[@napperforlife2020]

as it should be. but only one

[@dscollections]

I'm surprised with Kazuha and Eunchae 💖 more lines for you on next comeback please 🙏

[@김민주-r6e]

3:12 이때부터 ㅈㄴ 대환장이네 허윤진 가사 저는 거 수습 안 돼서 괜히 목소리 크게 내는 거 공수치 오지는데 뒤 파트 사쿠라 염소 목소리 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 얘넨 뭐냐

[@Kooyoungari]

그와중에 이름 김민주임 ㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@Kaisen.1028]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@d1wns9ud]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ팀킬ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@wannabe0740]

이번에 이지 활동때도 1위앵콜때 가사 한번 절던데...본인 노래인데 왜그러는거임...

[@이지스v]

다음부턴 회사 후보정팀이 올라와서 앵콜무대 불러라.

[@x-dheosaurbrgdyh]

와.. 진짜 깜놀.. 심사할 때 그렇게 엄격했던 방시혁이 프로듀싱한 그룹 맞나요 ? 박진영 비 라이브 보고 많이 배워야겠다... 참고로 그 두분은 40 50대임

[@sinceritychoi6746]

곡 자체가 부르기에 까다로운편도 아니고 음역대도 걸그룹 노래치고는 낮은데 라이브가 이렇게 불안정하면 이건 진짜 연습이 부족했다고 밖에 할 수가 없음

[@itzy4676]

박사 납셨네

[@bh6057]

​@@itzy4676 팩트인데 뭘 그럼

[@hesham-r9r]

​@@itzy4676Yes, that's the truth.

[@sleepingirl.]

​@@itzy4676지랄을 아주

[@larpy]

Yes very bad singers lol 😅embarrassing. These days so many idols don’t even have to sing well. They only need to dance well. Don’t tell me they’re nervous because every single encore they sing off tune. Unstable vocals. Even in survival show there singing isn’t good. The basic skill is vocals if you’re an idol

[@jake-mc7jy]

사쿠라 무슨일..

[@Lcdmha26]

과연 저 무대가 서바이벌 무대였다면 심사위원들이 뭐라했을까.. 그리고 관객들은 어떤 점수를줬을까..

[@angelf722]

Boys Planet already gave a perfect example of that. It's all visuals and dance they're obsessed seen from the line up ssjsjs

[@ZDubbed]

@@angelf722 so true ㅠㅠ

[@Kaisen.1028]

그렇게까지해서 까내리노 ㅋㅋ

[@h_blues]

@@Kaisen.1028 까는게 아니라 팩트임 ㅋㅋ

[@uareverystupid7285]

@@angelf722 ar u kidding me?top 9 of boys planet can sing lol

[@enterprise01]

이게 내가 르세라핌을 빨 수 없는 이유임 보컬이 개박살났음 그것도 단체로

[@KimkimSouth]

except chaewon, and eunchae didn't do bad for this one, compared to her other ones and the burp winging skills

[@tallSmmsorn]

사쿠라 허윤진 홍은채는 못하고 채원 카즈하는 그나마 1인분 한것 같음

[@theonlymai]

they improved in MTV push, fearnada and weverse con 🔥🔥

[@KimkimSouth]

@@tallSmmsorn kazuha? have you seen coachella? only chaewon did decent

[@낮말은새가듣고]

ㅈㄹ한다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ​@@tallSmmsorn

[@권서현-d7q]

라이브ar, 후보정에 속지말고 이게 진짜 르세라핌 수준임

[@zodiac270]

붕어 뻐끔뻐금 장위엔잉 빠는 다티나네

[@jaehakim8290]

이곡자체가 음피치부터 고음도 없고 단조루운곡인데 음정이 다들 넘 흔들린다..

[@PiggiesInTheRain]

Chaewon was perfect, Yunjin is an opera singer so of course she can sing, it was just a bad day, Eunchae and Kazuha do well in their parts on other stages, they are clearly nervous, and Sakura needs to improve but she’s also clearly nervous (anyone can sing “now now now”)… so basically they aren’t all main vocal material, but you know damn well they’re better than this, especially Yunjin

[@송민호-k7o]

@@PiggiesInTheRain잘한영상이 어디있나요?ㅋㅋㅋ

[@jisha_uhh]

Stop glazing ​@@PiggiesInTheRain

[@Mika_ducka]

근데 고음만 못하는게 아니라 다 못함ㅋㅋ ​@@Corncrete-k3k

[@sorigwan]

카즈하가 생각 보다 랩을 개잘하네 톤도 특이하고 ㄷㄷ 근데 보컬 파트는 채원이 나눠 주자 그냥 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@아가리또-j3n]

ㅇㅈ

[@arain7703]

@@김한나-s9l 사쿠라는 성대의 한계인같음 말할때도 목소리 떠는데 노래한다고 안떨리겠음? 비주얼멤버로 있는게 나음

[@헤님님]

사쿠라는 몇년 전 프듀랑 아이즈원 활동도 하고 이제 르세라핌으로 데뷔한지도 벌써 1년인데 아직도 저 정도면 걍 실력이 없는거임..진짜

[@totorrrrooroo8238]

걍 ㅈ됐구먼 뭔 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@삼다수-n5t]

@@헤님님 사쿠라는 당장 아이즈원이 데뷔도아님…

[@once_sharrron]

I love eunchae and chaewon because they so cute and I love le sserafims songs a lot, I fall for them more knowing they're one of the stable singers on their groupp (its my first time watching encore from them)

[@ristocrats247]

That was bad experience.should hve watched different encore,not this one.

[@MY_aespalover]

이게 잘한거냐😢😢

[@rachieese]

manchae is so surprising! She’s already so good at dancing and variety, now it’s singing! she’s gonna become a monster in a couple of years!!!!

[@hazwanisani114]

Chaewon 2:20 - 2:28 sounds exactly like studio version 🤌

[@yaya-hv1re]

근데 아이돌들은 춤 을 빡세게 추니까 노래 깔고 부르는거 어느정도 이해해주는건데 그냥 서서 부르는것조차 못하면......심지어 연습도 많이 했을텐데..

[@sannmayy]

It's a video that will motive anyone to audition and become a idol

[@kimtaehyungry7085]

LOL

[@qd-wm1ic]

😆🤣

[@TaylorLeeKnow]

Jail

[@momo-o9m3h]

No u did not- 🤣🤣🤣

[@lll3069]

I know that some people would call me mean, but when my niece told me how nervous she was about her singing test (it was a music class and she has to sing+play one instrument), I show her this video and some of other similar encore videos and told her: "This is a legit professional and popular group. Sweetweart, you can do it!" XD

[@JannypetKz]

Congratulations girls 🏆🎉 Yunjin's voice so powerful 😈😈

[@moepyaesoneoo9421]

I am surprise by Eunchae vocal .Eunchae vocal is so sweet😍

[@nunukkusuma8415]

Good job eunchae 👏

[@Spicy4urh2rt]

즈하는 목에 힘을 너무 줘서 성대 전체를 딱붙이고 쌩목으로 노래를 하네 그래서 소리도 밖으로 잘 못나오고 안에 머무는거 같아ㅠㅠ 춤연습 만큼이나 노래연습도 더 많이해서 다음컴백때 기대할게!! 응원해!!!

[@suumergensuumergen4464]

이때 카즈하 목 아파때요

[@지용-v8r]

발성이 부족해서임

[@totorro2828]

​@@suumergensuumergen4464 아그래요? 인이어가 고장나거나 갑자기 노래불러서 성대가 놀라진 않았던가요? 하이브계열 가수들 항상 그러던데 ㅠ

[@solidstatesociety907]

앵콜 무대 한번 마음에 안 들었다고 방구석 트레이너님께서 직접 고귀하신 피드백을 전달하시네 ㅋㅋ.. 앵콜 무대는 어디까지나 팬들과 함께 자축하는 무대지 본 무대에서 잘하고 사고 안치고 팬들에게 잘하고 이러면 본업 할 만큼 하는 건데? 니네들에게 직장상사가 니는 왜 일 그따위로 하냐 평소에 노력을 안하냐 너네 부모가 그렇게 가르쳤냐 이렇게 단정짓는 식으로 평가질해대면 기분 안 나쁨? 남에게만 지독하게 엄격하고 자기 자신에겐 한없이 관대한 그런 역겨운 심보 계속 부리면 니네들 인생에 다 업보로 돌아갈 거임

[@TVhongkacola]

@@solidstatesociety907 처망한 그룹 팬들이 지들 자체 화력으로는 르세라핌 아이브(전에 분탕질 친거로 앎)랑 승부가 안되니 에스파 끌고 와서 확전 유도중 ㅋㅋ

[@user_0913]

사쿠라는 언제 잘함? 데뷔 10년 넘었잖아 한 40년 기다려야하나?

[@itsmeliza3700]

😂😂😂😂

[@vvizone_cupid]

But poor Sakura :(

[@카리나-o2n]

아닞ㅋ

[@wannabe0740]

대기만성형이랍니다 걸어온 커리어 무시 ㄴㄴ^^

[@강미래-q6s]

이인간들은 아이돌 괴롭히려고 태어난인간 같아요 평생 악플중독자로 살아라

[@allanmhanson]

Eunchae was really good to be the only debuting idol. Lets give her some time, her voice is beautiful.

[@julia_park]

03:11 허윤진 조아해서 이 파트 엄청 챙겨보고 그랬는데,,,,, 이 랩 절고 철없이 외쳐대는부분,,,,ㅠ 담 앨범은 보컬 연습 마니하자.. 이어지는 사쿠라부붕까지 충격이야

[@이서현-b7z]

절 수는 있죠

[@박순철-o4h]

@@이서현-b7z 절었는데 너무 장난스럽게 대처해서 실망한듯

[@이서현-b7z]

@@박순철-o4h 표정에 약간 당황한 느낌이 있는 것 같은데

[@마이러브핸썸남]

​@@박순철-o4h앵콜에서 무슨 실망까지야;;;;

[@user-bv4gt1vk2k]

​@@박순철-o4h근데 앵콜이 원래 취지는 즐기는 무대였고 3세대쯤 아이돌 실력논란부터 갑자기 검증의 장으로 바뀐 거라...애매함

[@ooi_io]

이런 시련도 실력 키워서 이겨내야 진정한 독기 그룹이라고 생각함 다음 앨범에도 그대로라면 독기고 뭐고 다 갖다 버려야 할 듯

[@김지환-g6s9t]

그땐 독기 말고 도끼로 두개골을 갈라야....

[@assertivertfl]

​@@김지환-g6s9t 뭘 ㅋㅋㅋ 오바한다 또..

[@user-ttgur5gh8l]

@@김지환-g6s9t지환아....

[@kanyeye_77777]

@@김지환-g6s9t 찐따 지환이

[@totorrrrooroo8238]

이게 시련임? 소속사 초신성 스타터패키지로 데뷔했는데 지금까지 독기니 뭐니 언플 ㅈㄴ해대다가 그냥 뽀록난건데ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@SY-ql8zr]

Sakura😂😂😂 her fans always say it’s not fair that Sakura has few part in the group. Did they listen to her sing?😂 few part and still perform so bad

[@user-tw8wz8zw9i]

김채원 나락감지 표정이 개웃김 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅠㅠ 멱살캐리하느라 수고가많다 우리채원,,

[@밍닝-z7y]

그니까네...ㅋ큐ㅠㅠ으앙 ㅜ

[@Ddkndldnxsldmdm]

​@웰컴 투 네버랜드 그럼 님 개 같은 사람이 네요 ㅋ 채원이 겁나 잘해 그리고 님은 뭐 르세라핌 보다 잘하기는 하세요?

[@나경이-i6x]

@만성 현기증 형욱씨 허윤진은 음색이 ㅈㄴ 개사기임… watch me now 할 때 개좋아서 놀람 ;

[@나경이-i6x]

@웰컴 투 네버랜드 돌려까기까지는 아니고 ㅎ 허윤진은 음색 자체는 좋은데 실력이 좀 모자란 거지 음색이 ㄹㅇ 좋아서 실력은 좀 덮을 수 있음 근데 김채원은… 저 중에서는 잘하는 거지만 에스파나 엔믹스 이런 데 끼면 좌절할 듯…

[@최강부캐]

​@@Ddkndldnxsldmdm 가수랑 일반인을 비교하는거 실화? 솔직히 김채원 허윤진 빼곤 일반인 이 더 잘하는사람 많을듯

[@haleycho6443]

어우.....노래 어쩌면 좋아......1위할때 실력점수도 넣어줘라...

[@retrievezz]

@@loveiz4ever 미친ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 최종점수 68점! 탈락!

[@별빛-v7s]

@주책바가지 아니 개웃김 ㅋㅋ

[@별빛-v7s]

@@retrievezz 이거 보고 육성으로 터짐 ㅋㅋ

[@lenin-stalin-ussr]

​@주책바가지 ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@mangmangmanghat]

@주책바가지 20점 이하로 나오면 활동 접게 하면 더 웅길듯

[@Seaeeeee]

이래서 콘서트 할수있음.....?

[@김민성-j8j6y]

ㄹㅇ ㅌㅋ

[@Lololo3342]

콘서트때 라이브 안하는거 아녀

[@Mika_ducka]

아니요...

[@l.622]

ㅋ ㅋ ㅋ ㅋ ㅋ ㅋㅋ ㅋ

[@leedocoquette]

yes sakura let's go study your vocals

[@moresupriya003]

Look zuha her trainee period is just 3 month and she has developed singing and rap better after fearless. Zuha fighting. Lesserafim congratulations🎉🎉🥳🥳

[@misseden0218]

Owing to her years in ballet, Zuha has developed insane work ethics. She's a hard worker and her level of dedication to her craft is admirable.

[@moresupriya003]

@@misseden0218 I totally agree with you

[@이름성-d9m6h]

음정 다 틀렸는데 억빠 사이비 광신도급이네

[@m.mikrokosmos1736]

Lmao she didn’t even sing in the right tune

[@moresupriya003]

@@m.mikrokosmos1736 how do you know about her. The fact that she had less trainee period still she is doing her best. You can't understand her dream can make her to quit ballet and flew another country although she didn't even speak korean. Every thing is possible when you have strong determination about your dream. Only person can understand her which are less talented but their determination and hard work is make dream successful. Just think about when you comment on someone

[@mytotoll2116]

카즈하 노래는 영~아닌데 랩할때 목소리도특이하고 진짜듣기좋다독특하고 랩찰떡

[@pdq8137]

ㅇㅈ

[@---hi7eq]

랩으로는 ㄹㅇ 개간지인데 노래부를때는 음.. 그냥 고음 안되는 일반인이 쥐어짜는거같음

[@길길-b2c]

호흡이 딸리는듯 ㅋㅋ그전 앨범에선 잘했던거 같은데 소화도 못하는데 왜 파트를 많이 줘서

[@sh-ye3kz]

목소리가 ㄹㅇ 랩에.최적화됨 노래는 음.. 싶은데 랩은 좋음

[@세은-v6c]

일본인 아이돌중에 보컬 잘하는 사람 몇 못봄 ㅠㅠㅠ 랩 잘하는 사람은 꽤 있어도,, 발성 자체가 케이팝이랑 안어울리는건가🥲

[@hightouch3986]

Eunchae and chaewon are great.

[@emina008]

Unforgiven vocals 🥲🤯

[@jaredtzp7466]

😂😂😂😂

[@timomeelo2971]

hybe should invest more on their vocal, no shade they're good and will be unstoppable id that vocal is met 🫶

[@nunukkusuma8415]

Everyone so good For Eunchae I am proud of you 💙😊 Good job 👍👏

[@theanyeanng5334]

omo chaewon is real fairy with good vocal good visual good dance skill she is so so perfect

[@ObieOne2002]

Wish there was a 3rd member that was as vocally talented as yunjin and chaewon. Chaewon is an ace.

[@jass254]

@@ObieOne2002 it was garam

[@itsjininotjinni]

shes really good but I think sakura need to improve her vocal. hybe need to give her very good vocal teacher

[@jass254]

@cherryl haven't you heard of her lines in their debut album? she's really good

[@ffion4278]

@@jass254 not at all lmao

[@qwerasdf-yx2rk]

이야 국내에서 가장 성공한 댄스팀이다 가수는 아니니까

[@Tilltheendoftime-m3h]

아니 소속사에서 애들 기본 발성도 안시키고 데뷔시키네 너무 어이가 없어서 채원이 잘함

[@lee_seo_jun]

팬인데 쿠라 노래 계속 안는다고 힘들어하는거 봤는데 계속 안느니까 어떻게 해야할질 모르겠다 팬인데도..좀 슬프네

[@tk-rl6zz]

하이브한테 부탁인데 독기컨셉 3번 연달아 했으니까 이제 다른거 하면 안됨?? 멤버들 성격이나 케미가 좋아서 마음은 가는데 소속사에서 미는 컨셉이랑 실력의 괴리감이 너무 커서 피어나로서 공수치 옴

[@이시안데뷔해]

3부작 앨범이라 피어리스안티언포까지 끝일 듯 ㅇㅇ

[@c.h2132]

기라성같은 케이팝 선배들이 다 닦아논 케이팝아티스트로서의 음악성이나 색깔로 좋아하는게 아니라 성격이나 케미가 좋아서 팬된다음 실력딸리는데 1위 시켜주려는게 고대로 일본화되고 있네 아이고 아이돌 판치던 시절 나가수 만들어서 케이팝계 기강다져놨는데 다시 유아기로 퇴보하는군 😅 하 코노가면 방구석 일반인 가수들이 의외로 예쁜애들도 있고 더 잘부름....

[@itzy4676]

메일 보내세요

[@dlwnghdl]

그래서 그런 컨셉을 했는데도.. 라이브가 조옽 돼쓰요;;;

[@teddytpleata]

코노 옆방이라는 표현보다 더 정확한 말이 없다

[@gayatrig1346]

Chaewon carrying the whole team like the queen she is👑 Manchae shocked me she's so good

[@25thoctober]

The bar is in hell

[@rglovw]

eunchae, yunjin, and chaewon did really good in this encore, while sakura and kazuha need vocal training, tho they were good too! not much people can sing that good so

[@Engene4enhylen4ever]

There were times when Eunchae's voice cracked a lil but she was still good ❤ But sakura and kazuha on the other hand need vocal training. 😭😭😭😭😭 It reminds me of the ot6 era's garam and yunjin and chaewon were leading in vocals ❤😭❤😭❤😭❤😭❤😭❤😭❤

[@loliithaay]

ngl the whole team sounded out of breath except chaewon :/ but yunjin n eunchae did ok

[@angelf722]

@@loliithaay ok is an overstatement they were both off pitch but i guess you mean okay in the sense that they didn't sound like dying frogs like the others?

[@tightnari]

eunchae is SO stable im so proud of her. goodjob manchae!!!

[@alicianovena5422]

Yess truee

[@yoongyus]

this song suits her voice tone perfectly more than any other member so its not as hard for her, still she SLAYEDD

[@emoonemon]

Yeahhh her voice

[@3minutesideas491]

Like literally 3:23 is pure vocals

[@VibePolice]

Here sir, you dropped this 🧢 😅

[@지로-n2s]

노래 넘 좋은데 앵콜 라이브 머선일....

[@아둥버둥]

동창회 노래방 온 기분이야

[@EJ-wn3my]

Wow Kazuha you surprised me😮 Her rap sounds exactly like studio version and her vocal really really improved a lot 👏👍

[@FOHaab]

Is this a joke?

[@brojakeilysmbro]

I hope this is sarcasm

[@misc0615]

Chaewon too good as usual that no one even mentions it anymore 🥲

[@구미마이-q6g]

No one mentions it because it's always natural that Chaewon is good at it!

[@sudenur493]

I personally think she is the most stable

[@mariafatma6656]

Totally agree! Chaewon was the most stable followed by Eunchae in my opinion. Regardless, kudos to them for actually giving us live vocals.

[@kimjess4513]

There are many comments about her tho …

[@chenwon2829]

cause she only has 2 lines one the very beginning and one at the very last 😅

[@mireYANG97]

Congratulations babies!! You deserve it... Zuha improved so much! Her vocals are so good on this encore... She is working hard to show us her amazing talents 💗

[@아령하새요]

앵콜 논란 터지니까 아예 대놓고 음 낮은 이지(easy)리스닝으로 컴백하는거 겁나 속보이네 ㅋㅋ

[@witchfloo3117]

All of your vocals improved so much. Kazuha, Eunchae and Sakura great job !!

[@berryberry_lux6582]

The vocals , doubting how good they sound in tracks vs life 🥹🔪

[@eonnimeylaadysta]

EUNCHAE SO STABLE

[@Dino_Pregnants]

Yessss ❤❤

[@soyarbx]

To be honest, I was a little shocked.. I understand that their voice was shaking, but their vocals just tear me apart..

[@andwillcome]

춤 안추고 부르는건데도 이러면..ㅜ 보컬 연습도 챙겨 하이브...

[@fim5705]

Skr looks so nervous but she did good vocal esp when her nerves calmed down.

[@Ohchaehyun2286]

2:36 nÖw now now

[@justiceforashgoton4427]

This is why most 5th gen group are now focusing on vocals too because people are expecting too much in vocals too and they tired hearing funny encore too

[@ssnehaha]

despite being in the dancing industry most of her life and only having a training period of about three months kazuha did exceptionally well for this encore, there is always room for improvement but im so proud of her for trying and improving daily, i feel so happy to see her confidently showcasing her vocals, i love you kazuha 🤍

[@aldonovendi3748]

eunchae and kazuha vocal 🔥🔥 they improve so much!

[@PlNKUHOSHI]

Realy? Kazuha is getting a lot of crap from K-netizens because of this encore... As much as I like her she didn't sound too good here.

[@ginkachi2810]

bffr

[@Telegater]

​@@PlNKUHOSHIYea but kazuha is the sub vocalist for a reason cuz she has low vocal ability. But Sakura is like one of the main vocalists she should be better

[@kijoringgg1765]

Kazuha's vocal surprisingly good!!! Congrats lesserafim for unforgiven first win 🎉🎉🎉

[@evy8352]

sakura: the worst, totally out of breath, sounds like shes suffering kazuha: so bad it hurts my ears, sounds like a cat being beaten eunchae: sounds like my smoking aunt yunjin: totally out of breath, good voice tone tho chaewon: good and stable them harmonizing = my ears exploding

[@Nina-xo555]

Literally is hybe not embarrassed??

[@anayanasir1113]

Yall are srs saying this like u guys can sing any better, their gaining millions not even knowing yall are barking abt their voices and yall are laying ur fat asses on the bed hating.

[@aaf.visual]

Why is this so true 😭

[@nisansalajayaweera9762]

You are overreacting, it's not bad . The harmonization is so good and yunjin and eunchae was good too .

[@Voimis]

facts 😂

[@fss1452]

Their voice so unforgiven

[@satuderajat6166]

idk.. at this stage i think like some of them seemed burderned with their own part 🥲

[@angelf722]

@@satuderajat6166 yeh cos they can't sing

[@satuderajat6166]

@@angelf722 bitter facts tht often make people close their eyes. especially the fans ._.

[@gaeik_ch]

맞는말 ㄹㅇ

[@dance4ever940]

are u kidding me? I don't like criticizing ppl but ur videos u posted on KZbin are unforgiven/unforgivable too. like 12 yr olds can edit better than that. would u like it if people spam commented on ur sorry videos w/ negativity? and u look older.... so to be writing these type of comments as an older adult to like 15- 18 year olds is really sad...

[@ishanschapter]

Yunjin hair is looking so cool

[@ibelieveinmiracle]

Wow Eunchae sounds so stable and confident, I’m really surprised, she’s so good (and others are good too of course)

[@schmidt188]

so many koreans hated her vocals here for some reason while praising kazuha's lol. chaewon & eunchae were the most stable ones without any question

[@pingmeup-kk5ns]

i disagree. yunjin and chaewon are the only literal vocals. eunchae and kazuha have rooms of improvement and sakura, she is clearly not a vocal but she is better than what she was at the start of her kpop career. chaewon and yunjin should be the one to sing challenging lines, kazuha, sakura and eunchae should be the one to sing the normal lines, kazuha and even sakura can do the rap if needed.

[@Everythingz127]

The others are giving me headache 😂😂

[@Youth-l7d]

3:30

[@leedocoquette]

cap

[@inxypinxy_stories]

Chaewon is so stable and Yunjin's note at 2:33 was very well executed! So proud of all of them! 💙💙💙

[@npcmaiko]

she knew she killed that 🤣🥶🥶

[@_zuko.]

TOP TEIR

[@Teresahkp]

Yunjin live is still 🔥 😅

[@CrownPrinceEdvin]

Yunjin best vocalist

[@reredemzz]

@@CrownPrinceEdvin in the group yeah 💀

[@wony_ill2]

that’s why stable vocals are important in encore 😊

[@chai8058]

Most especially on encore. Where they don't need to dance hard. It's their time to show their vocal colours. A bit disappointed but not to the girls. 😅😅😅

[@kpopie569]

​@@chai8058 yunjin and chaewon were only good, but eunchae is improve

[@satuderajat6166]

say it louderr

[@Blaze72sH]

What do you mean by "stable"?

[@Virag0.0]

Tbh I think they just need to have fun but yeah

[@minachan-y7r]

their vocals literally unforgiven lol

[@aldwin08sls]

Exactly hahaha

[@xxkeooo8558]

, 🤫🤫🤣🤣

[@lisaadams7339]

😂😂😂 no but yunjin, chae and eunchae are okay but Sakura and Kazuha need vocal training.

[@aldwin08sls]

@@lisaadams7339 yunjin also sound bad… she like out of tune. The maknae and leader is better

[@delune1329]

​@@aldwin08sls you are literally tonedeaf, darling...she is the most correct in pitch here

[@thoseriseofkingdomsadswith972]

Yunjin was NOT this bad back in P48. Her classical training hasn't translated to pop music back then too, but she didn't sound like this. What the heck happened.

[@NgocMinh-zl1ej]

You know, she was trained by Hybe in these years. They are the best of ruining artists' voice

[@thoseriseofkingdomsadswith972]

@@NgocMinh-zl1ej She sounds stuffy..like she's singing into a pillow. It's so weird.

[@llll-h3c1b]

쿠라야 더연습하자

[@Greenaura101]

😢😢😢😢 そうですね

[@ramahamaedeh7518]

She absolutely can’t sing so training won’t help

[@おいこう-q1k]

전반적인 실력이 딸리니 라이브 ar없는 mr 생라이브에서는 멤버들이 화음이나 코러스를 넣는 것이 아니라 떼창을 함! 그나마 노래가 되는 허윤진하고 김채원도 다른 셋이 못해서 잘해 보이는 거지 저 실력이면 다른 걸그룹에서 서브보컬 정도 밖에 못함.

[@heartbeat7223]

Chaewon sounds like the studio version

[@_Gilles_]

People forget she's a great singer in general

[@xepchember]

WOOWWW THE NEW STANDARD FROM SOURCEMU, anyone can be an IDEL as long as you have a beautiful face 😅

[@kkuralesserafim8674]

Sakura be calm, we believe in you🤗 you did very well 💖

[@wiseone4751]

FIGHTING YUNJIN! CHAEWON! EUNCHAE! KAZUHA! SAKURA!!

[@xianxiannn]

Cheawon

[@KAM20-gz3wy]

도대체 사쿠라는 어떻게 하이브로 재데뷔한거냐 ㅋㅋㅋ 노래 춤 비주얼 다 아이돌하기엔..

[@empty-gz2ye]

그저 일본 영업용임ㅋㅋ 르세라핌 미래로 봐서는 완전 마이나스

[@user-toZzhang]

@@empty-gz2ye일본도 김채원이 인기 탑임

[@SW-xz8hk]

@@user-toZzhang일본은 사쿠라가 탑맞음 당장팔로워 순위만봐도 사쿠라가 1위임

[@봄-x8g5m]

진짜 내가 막귀라 음정 흔들린다는 게 뭔지 몰랐는데 ㅠㅠ정말 미안하지만 이거 보고 알겠다 ㅠㅠ

[@knowlesknowles1356]

Kazuha raw vocals is soo goooood!!!! Omg!!! She is the main attractor for me... Lesserafirm whole encore is beautiful Edit: Fighting Sakura, Chaewon, Yunjin, Kazuha and Baby Eunchae

[@고독쓰]

엔믹스가 진짜 쩌는거네 ㅋㅋ

[@Kpopsocute1]

ㄹㅇ ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@joycemendes7568]

babymonster too

[@성이름-e3f3u]

ㅇㅈ ㅋㅋㅋ

[@reindeerage]

Tea

[@RH-xp7ju]

@@joycemendes7568no

[@ladrajustineo.9249]

LIVE VOCALS! 🔥

[@jh01284]

사쿠라 노래 개사리부분은 언제 들어도 개웃기네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠ 예~개사리개사리~

[@James_McAvoy]

진지하게 쪽팔려..... 해외팬들도 노래실력 용서못한다고 비꼬잖아

[@merlindaputriec]

Kkkkkkk😂

[@кошенятко-у4к]

stop be obsessed with other’s opinions, why koreans always like that 🤡🤡🤡

[@ristocrats247]

@@кошенятко-у4к you know its bad when both korean and international are criticizing them 😂

[@кошенятко-у4к]

@@ristocrats247 I know. It just infuriates me when Koreans say that this or that group is a disgrace to Korea because it is. Something similar happened when Karina from aespa got into a relationship. she was forced to apologize and her apology became popular abroad. Koreans hated her for this and began to ask her to apologize for disgracing Korea.

[@ristocrats247]

@@кошенятко-у4к that was just her felt guilty and it wasnt the same.she didn't need to apologize tho

[@javender0333]

kazuha really surprise me a lot....Just WOW!!!!👏👏👏👏👏

[@samanthakim5035]

Fr!

[@fiammatoscana]

Fearnots have really low standards 🧐🙄

[@javender0333]

@@fiammatoscana such an honor to be chosen thru all the comments here..and to even know the fandom name kudos👍

[@javender0333]

@@fiammatoscana ㅅ ㅂ

[@replay1257]

다른 영상 어디서 본 댓글인데 라이브 잘하는 여돌 엔믹스 왈: 쪼그려 앉아서 걸어가면서 매일 몇시간씩 노래 연습했다 남돌 인피니트 왈: 기마자세하고 노래 연습했다. 내 돌이 라이브를 잘하면 욕먹을 일이 없어서 편안한데, 이 그룹은 인기에 비해 실력이 너무 터무니없어서 팬들이 쉴드치기 바쁘네.. 근데 그게 쟤네한테 좋은게 아님 저정도로 죽을듯이 노력해야 실력파 소리듣지

[@lukaslourd]

Their vocals are UNFORGIVEN! 🔥🔥❤

[@fsh2ldib]

Sakura chan fighting, belive your self, your voice is so calm and to great dont worry.