Anonymous Atheist Attempts To Outsmart A Muslim! Muhammed Ali

[@TheMuslimLantern]

Brothers and Sisters! Don't forget to Like, Comment and Share the video to help us reach more people so you can share in the reward in sha Allah! Support Me and The Channel: www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=9NUGVQNWSZHEY www.patreon.com/TheMuslimLantern

[@nourmallette809]

😀masha'allah masha'allah brother Muhammad I am so delighted and in uogh Listen to your lectures. May.Allah's blessings and Mercy and goodness Pour down on your life. May.Allah grant you more knowledge . To spread the truth and may Allah grant Jannatul Firdaus Ameen 💕 May.Allah proctet and end The bombardment and the slaughter on our brothers and sisters in Palestine and Lebanon and Syria. AMEEN

[@sabira2778]

JazakAllah kheir for what you are doing.

[@aswadsaswad1759]

Which one, Shivaji?!

[@Braun-x8h]

Please i write to you on Instagram. I have to ask you something Mohammed!!

[@frankvee2799]

you dont allow people to talk .... atleast allow people to speak

[@n0ne0ne]

when Muslim Lantern posts, first we like the video then we watch it 😃

[@proudmusli_mah]

💯

[@rizwandurrani3392]

I thought i am only one ha😅😅

[@Jaden7Yugi]

thank you.. idk how but i always forget to like.. nice seeing impactful comments

[@AbdiHassan-uz3wg]

Always. Alhamdulilah

[@Tislyfe]

💯

[@8L8_Ash]

it always start with "I ACTUALLY have some medical background" then quickly turns to "I'm not claiming to be an expert" 😂😂😂😂

[@SaadMuslim20]

When he first said that, I took him seriously But after listening to him for a while, I realized that he was not sincere.

[@nasiruyusuf8782]

The atheist guy lied

[@StarGate960]

What a jokesss 🤣🤣🤣 They just ignorant and live in ignorancy They think they smart enough

[@mcegypt20]

Yea by medical background he probably worked in a healthcare facility, not actually doing anything medical. I’ve heard this sooo many times 😂😂😂

[@lepyaondaclouds1854]

Idk why but somehow 'they' have the same copy paste vibe, it's either what they say or the way they talk😂

[@altafwali24]

Atheist: I have done complete research. Muhammed: asks a basic question about it. Atheist: I meant I will now do a research 😂😂😂

[@reesecane7878]

😂😂😂

[@faizsheikh9442]

🤣

[@yasa8368]

😂😂

[@Exहिन्दूआनंदवंशी420]

😂

[@saraeltahir1419]

Atheist: I don't claim to be an expert 😂😂😂

[@bocarndiade4959]

BTW a Senegalese muslim here! Love you and the work you are doing for the ummah for the sake of Allah brother Mouhamed! May Allah reward you immensely

[@birahimfall1899]

Mbokkou bi...👍

[@bocarndiade4959]

@@birahimfall1899 yeah mbokk mi, magui ziar

[@zoualpha4142]

@@bocarndiade4959 Gnogui Ziar 🇸🇳

[@annoraboketto523]

“God is uncreated” A very simple statement yet atheists fail to comprehend no matter how many PhD they hold.

[@_DaMan_]

@@Flex-cx7ujassumed naturalism is such a cancer, it plagues today's societies and academia

[@BigG627]

@@Flex-cx7ujexactly. There has to be a beginning or we can NEVER exist because then the question would be “who created god, who created that god, who created that god? “ it will keep going. There has to be something Uncreated and that’s god

[@polopolomay1]

@@annoraboketto523 To be fair the guy wasn't saying that humans literally created God or have the power to create God but that throughout human history, humans have authored texts and oral traditions regarding notions of god and presented them to the masses who believed it to be true.

[@westmirrow3486]

He said he´s an agnostic atheist, not an atheist. Like many people in these comments, i did not know of such a thing, but i have now educated myself and now understand. An agnostic atheist does not believe in the existence of any god, but also believes that if a god existed, we currently don´t have any way of knowing it. A quick search on google does wonders. In other words,the agnstic atheist is not questioning God as a concept, but rather specific gods , in this case, he is doubting if allah is real.

[@undercoveragent9889]

If God is 'uncreated' then God is 'yet to exist'. I am an atheist and I do get it. You literally believe in the existence of a being you claim is 'yet to exist'. But hey, if everyone understood logic and reason then there would be no need for Priests, Imams or Rabbis, would there?

[@gherrocrucible]

Actually.... in my testimony I remember believing in a God at the age of 4, and the funny thing is as a catholic I was opposed to the idea of Jesus as God. My heart rejected the idea and Allāh 18 years ago guided me to Islam and my heart accepted and understood what I had known all along.

[@hanantermizi6106]

MasyaAllah :)

[@PriestlySadduseesStartdJudaism]

welcome brother al hamdullilah only allah knows whats gone and what is to come between the heavens al hamdullilah

[@suzi9708]

Alhamdulillaah

[@Mayyah690]

27:10 “Ok, anyway…” He was not listening to understand at all 😭😂

[@MSA_madi]

At least maybe someone sincere listen and got enlighten. And appreciate the answers.

[@Mayyah690]

@@MSA_madiyes our Brother always explains concepts well Alhumdulilah, so hopefully people benefit from them. Some of this Mark guy’s responses were pretty funny though😅

[@polopolomay1]

He said "ok, anyway" because he started to say something then decided to move on to say something else. It wasn't in disregard for what the brother was saying.

[@insanityfreedom2953]

@@polopolomay1yeah but he didn’t acknowledge anything what ali has said, come on he asked questions and ali answer it but he is only said ok, he is too egoistic to acknowledge his argument has been countered

[@polopolomay1]

​@@insanityfreedom2953 You confuse ego with lack of faith. The premise of his inquiry was how can you, given all the similarities throughout human history regarding mankind and its notions of god, be sure what you believe is true? So when the brother brings proofs from the Quran and Hadiths, its insufficient to someone who is questioning the veracity of these texts. One can't be "countered" or intellectually beaten into faith.

[@OnDeenObito]

Believing the universe came from nothing is like expecting a book to write itself without an author.

[@deenszxking6818]

Basically atheist believing in magic, poof! There it is, the universe.

[@flashhtony2948]

That's a good analogy.

[@Assyaroni]

Good one

[@Fbcsporting]

Damn that hits

[@mornotafi]

🤦

[@DimsHanf]

I click ..i play it .. before sister from YEMEN arrive

[@maximus9146]

🤣...💀

[@muksumularafin7798]

😂😂😂😂

[@mamadou38]

😂😂

[@Mm-ij9il]

ههههههههههههههههههههههههههههه قويه قويه

[@88Grimmjow]

Loool

[@Shahid_0969]

Agnostic Atheist 🥸

[@talhajamalkhan7834]

exactly

[@suzan_sheikh]

😂😂😂

[@ahmedmohsin8689]

😅 I’m sayin.. like what does that even mean?

[@mohamedelkayal8871]

​@@ahmedmohsin8689someone who doesn't believe in the existence of any god or gods but remains open to the possibility that there might be such a thing or things.

[@M.G-Hassan]

Agnostic means nothing if someone strongly affirms a stance

[@theonewhoknocks1822]

Muslim latern is a brother who strongens my iman when I listen to his unbreakable arguments. May allah honour and reward him abundantly.

[@Abu3ilm]

When bro came in with the script, he didn’t even focus on the convo. He was giving a presentation just like we did in school🤣

[@koolersoul7674]

And then the lantern schooled him

[@westmirrow3486]

What are you talking about? It was a civilized discussion and he interrupted the Muslim Lantern very little, nor was he arrogant

[@westmirrow3486]

@@koolersoul7674 The Muslim Lantern made a few false claims, first by misrepresenting the result of the studies on innate belief, and then later by saying that embryology in the quran does not resen´mble what galen write hundreds of years before as Mark claimed. I have now found a website which contains the book galen wrote, and indeed, the resemblances are strong

[@shuhaiblmp5532]

Please give link to that website

[@AbirRee]

😊 بارك الله فيك اخي محمد و أعلى مقامك في الدنيا و الآخرة و جزاك خيرا عن دعوتك للطريق المستقيم

[@GuidancetowardsTruth]

Pray for Muslims around the world 🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@chirag7673]

Yeah Allah hu Akbar boom 💣💥💥

[@GuidancetowardsTruth]

@@chirag7673 Can't blame u Media tried their best to spread lies May God guide us

[@KardKardus]

May Allah streghten our faith and keep us on the rigth path, aameen

[@diwakarkc3997]

@@GuidancetowardsTruth All were praying and are praying and at the end they bow down to non Muslims for good and medicine, look at Middle East. If there is almighty god they believe they would be the best people but are fighting for food and medicine.

[@kb4432]

"No soul can believe except by God’s will, and He brings disgrace on those who do not use their reason." The Noble Quran 10:100

[@kb4432]

˹They are˺ those who remember Allah while standing, sitting, and lying on their sides, and reflect on the creation of the heavens and the earth ˹and pray˺, “Our Lord! You have not created ˹all of˺ this without purpose. Glory be to You! Protect us from the torment of the Fire. Quran 3:191

[@truthteller1977]

❤❤❤

[@truthteller1977]

@@kb4432❤❤❤❤❤

[@HADYJALLOH]

YOU MUST ALWAYS USE REASON TO HELP YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU TALKING ABOUT

[@undercoveragent9889]

That is the same as: believe or die. Sounds a lot like coercion to me.

[@BrockInTheWorld]

Muhammed: Proves Islam is the truth clearly and logically. Atheist: Ok Anyways…

[@basichumanrights.]

@@chirag7673yeah okay just go take a shower I can smell it from my screen

[@ED-TwoZeroNine]

No he doesn't.

[@basichumanrights.]

@@chirag7673 WHY DID YOU REEDEM IT?

[@VinexAesthetics]

@@chirag7673You got 23 comments on this channel trying to hate, maybe find a better profession?

[@baklavalover2000]

@@chirag7673this is your god🐮?

[@nonongquinto8345]

As salamu alaikum watching from Manila Philippines🇵🇭

[@wakeup6953]

🇵🇭🇶🇦

[@user-kc3qz2vx8o]

Walaykum mussalam warRahmatullahi wa Barakatuh, kabayan 🇵🇭🤝

[@hkballer13]

Walaikum as-salam, I can't wait to visit in December inshallah.

[@ahintofhish07]

🇵🇭🇺🇸

[@Ex-hindu_Fahim]

Walaikumussalam❤

[@yungdawwg7081]

this the most polite atheist i've seen in this channel, this is the type of conversations i like to see, specially in the topic of religion because its a topic that requires rational and intelligent takes which require conversational manners and mutual respect for each side to present his argument and response uninterrupted. And Alhamdulilah since we are standing on the truth so there is no fear because the truth can never be "debunked" and it will always prevail Inshallah.

[@westmirrow3486]

also found the discussion very civil with much mutual respect. But it´s not good that The Muslim Lantern wrote that he is an atheist despite the fact that he said hat he is ah´n agnostic atheist. I didn´t know that was a real thing and had to do some research. It is an actual philosophical position held by many people, including Dr. Bat Ehrmann and it is very different from a simple atheist. I also thought it was a shame that The Muslim Lantern did not let him open what he had researched and present it. This would have helped clarify the debate between Galen vs Quran. I have now done my own research on the matter and have posted a side-by-side comparison in another comment above

[@yungdawwg7081]

Hello my brother@@westmirrow3486, i can see why he didn't acknowledge Mr Mark as such an agnostic atheist considering the topic they were about to discuss and not to mention the importance of clarifying the position held by both parts, so classifying him as an atheist is a generalization that abbreviates the pov's held by that person, which is not believing in god and i'm sure you can see the commonalties between both stances. Not to defend Mohamed Ali, but he is a fallible human being, i agree that he could've labeled him as he stated but i don't think its a major thing that affects the main topic and conversation. Secondly, again, i think that someone as mohmaed ali that has been in this field for a long time developed some boundaries influenced by the patterns he notices from his encounters, and i think one of them is sincerity, which the lack of it was apparent when Mr Mark responded with "anyway" after a long response to what was suppose to be a question out of an uncertainty, 27:04 . And Also he stated many times that the purpose of those conversations is not to debate, but rather to take inquiries from sincere people and hopefully clarify any misconception. Not to mention that he explained the views of Galen and highlighted the differences between them and the Quran which was relatively brief, And i also agree with you on this one too, he should've let him use all his ammunition and debunk it all at once, but i think he saw the insincerity and decided not to, because those individuals do not care about the truth rather they stick to what they fits their views and standards. Even thought as viewers we would've liked to get it all, but at the end of the day M.A is a human being who has a life as well, and he too put the time and effort to research and look through those things and rationalize a conclusion, so we should do the same. lastly, i couldn't find the comment you mentioned, i would've liked to read it. Sorry for the long comment, i tend to do that a lot. Wish you all the best my brother, regards

[@westmirrow3486]

@@yungdawwg7081 Thanks for the reply bro.

[@rosesalleh2207]

You’re such a smart and sharp guy who can debunk just any argument.. may Allah protect you bro Muhammad.

[@AbedMuslim]

لا إله إلا الله

[@Spm1610]

Oooh the silver play button sure makes a nice background (missing the kitab shelves though). Barakallahu fiik brother! Hope your dawa can reach more people and inspire us fellow muslims to keep learning 🙏🏻

[@Believer610]

One of the most respectful and least arrogant “agnostic” atheists I have ever seen. Great discussion. May Allah reward brother Mohammed for his dawa

[@emooshamaaa736]

but he is not listening 😢

[@Believer610]

@@emooshamaaa736 I understand as he was more on the defensive side. But he listened in some instances.

[@polopolomay1]

Listening doesn't equate to instant belief.

[@westmirrow3486]

@@polopolomay1 I also found both to be very respectful to each other despite their differences

[@WestMan161]

Very great discussion. Brother Mohammed is amazing on catching every single point and have a meaning answer for it. Mashallah

[@ummabudee]

بارك الله عليهما

[@SyedBadruddinShah]

@TheMuslimLantern - You are the best! Hands down. May Allah bless you with the best always.

[@sgyoldman9582]

Thanks

[@kingwahib1145]

27:09 he was refuted so brutally, all he had left to say was “anyway” lmaoooo 😂😂😂 I love MAs reaction “what do you mean anyway?” 😂😂

[@westmirrow3486]

So many proofs were offered by The Muslim LAntern that i don´t think he would have been able to address them all one by one. Thats probably why he decided to address only one

[@Jozef_Malik_]

Salam alaykom bro mohamed Jazak allah khayeer wa wafagak Salam from Sudan 👋

[@taufiqrl]

Alhamdulillah for Islam

[@sakawan78]

I like his smile he gives them 😄😂

[@Strangerinthisworld19]

The Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) encouraged the offering of 12 Sunnah rak'ahs daily, which are known as the Sunnah Mu'akkadah (emphasized sunnah prayers). "Whoever prays twelve rak'ahs during the day and night, a house will be built for him in Paradise." - Sunan Ibn Majah 1140 These 12 rak'ahs are broken down as follows: 2 rak'ahs before Fajr 4 rak'ahs before Dhuhr and 2 rak'ahs after Dhuhr 2 rak'ahs after Maghrib 2 rak'ahs after Isha These Sunnah prayers are greatly rewarded and help increase one's spiritual connection with Allah.

[@ummabudee]

بارك الله فيك ووفقك الله

[@Naazziiaa]

Salaam alaykom and free Falastine 🇵🇸

[@salvatorearanzulla9104]

alaykum salam

[@yaramustafa8811]

Walakom alsalam warahmat Allah wabrakato

[@gharbe93]

Atheist will challenge you. when you respond to his argument. He will say “anyway” and try to find another argument. He want to find a single fallacy and do not care about the truth

[@Sifat-y9t]

Moon came down to the Earth and two sides of the Mountain .... Is it True ? Is there any witness evidence other than Muslims to claim this event ?

[@westmirrow3486]

The Muslim Lantern spoke for almost 10 minutes non-stop giving proofs of islam. Mark could not address all of those points, and i think that is why he said "anyway " and decided to address one single proof

[@rebeccab4560]

Respectful convo ❤

[@westmirrow3486]

I thought so too

[@mehdibow]

ALLAHU AKBAR best explanation I ever heard

[@SL00M11211]

الله يجزاك خير يا محمد ويضاعف لك الأجر اسأل الله أن يثبتك على الحق ويجعلنا وإياك من الذين يدعون إلى الله بالحكمة والموعظة الحسنة.

[@wakeup6953]

Allhamdullilah we have brother Muhammad ☝️

[@fazeelalaher6250]

He was well mannered. Hope muhammed educating him will give him food for thought

[@westmirrow3486]

We need more of such civil discussions with mutual respect

[@SaadMuslim20]

Alhamdulilah for everything

[@KazlyKasKazan]

This is a true gentlemen discussion. Cheers!

[@westmirrow3486]

I´m glad more people appreciate a civil discussion like i do. Too much negativity on the internet.This was indeed a breadth of fresh air. Very civil, non-disruptive and mutually respecful

[@101CreeperEater]

Allahuma barik brother Muhammed, you caught onto the weak arguments in a manner I didn't even think about.

[@westmirrow3486]

I like the Muslim Lantern and have watched many of his videos, but he made a few false claims here. First by misrepresenting the results of the studies on innate belief in God as Mark rightly suggested, but also by claiming that Galenic embryology and Quranic embryology have nothing in common. They do. I was truly thinking of converting to islam, but this discussion has made me realize that i know too little of islam and need to do more research. Some of the answers The Muslim Lantern gave here were really not convincing. I have posted a detailed breakdown of the discussion above

[@Abdur-Rahman862]

​@westmirrow3486 an honest person only needs one proof. A person of desire will not believe even if given thousands.

[@westmirrow3486]

@@Abdur-Rahman862 In other words, what you are saying is that if a person is unconvinced about a proof for islam e.g. embryology, the only possible reason is that they are dishonest?

[@furkanaydin1190]

Barakallah Brother Muhammed thanks for uploading a new video.

[@garethbale1008]

Assalaumagaleikum from Kazakhstan!!!

[@zonnorainmohamedyassin4221]

" _I don't know if a god exists, but I don't believe in one._ " • _An Agnostic Atheist_ 🥴 " _O Allah, give guidance to all not yet Muslim and let them embrace Islam_ ” • *_Zonnorain_* ♥️

[@katiawojcik962]

I was like this before I accepted Islam... it just means you can't arriculate or defend why you believe it is true and are searching... other than being a muslim this is the best way to be because Allah guides those who want to be guided. May Allah keep us on the straight path and guide those who are searching.

[@zonnorainmohamedyassin4221]

" _Dear @@katiawojcik962, Alhamdullilah, Ameen_ " • *_Zonnorain_* 🤍 يَا مُقَلِّبَ الْقُلُوبِ ثَبِّتْ قَلْبِي عَلَى دِينِكَ " _O Controller of the hearts, make my heart steadfast in Your religion._ " • *_Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ)_* ♥️

[@zonnorainmohamedyassin4221]

" Dear @@katiawojcik962, Alhamdullilah, Ameen " • *_Zonnorain_* 🤍 يَا مُقَلِّبَ الْقُلُوبِ ثَبِّتْ قَلْبِي عَلَى دِينِكَ " _O Controller of the hearts, make my heart steadfast in Your religion._ " • *_Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ)_* ♥️

[@zonnorainmohamedyassin4221]

​@@katiawojcik962 " _Alhamdullilah, Ameen_ " • *Zonnorain* 🤍 يَا مُقَلِّبَ الْقُلُوبِ ثَبِّتْ قَلْبِي عَلَى دِينِكَ " _O Controller of the hearts, make my heart steadfast in Your religion._ " • *_Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ)_* ♥️

[@vortexvampire]

بارك الله فيكم... اللهم اغفر لوالدينا و ارحمهما و اجمعنا معهما في الفردوس الأعلى مع الأنبياء و الشهداء و الصالحين و جميع موتى المسلمين.. اللهم احقن دماء المسلمين و انصرهم على من عاداهم.. رب إني مسني الضر و أنت أرحم الراحمين... لا إله إلا أنت سبحانك إني كنت من الظالمين..... ...... .... ...

[@acefula6585]

He's polite and well mannered at least 👍🏾

[@aBBB321]

At least this guy showed some humility.. May Allah guide him

[@EmadGGs]

Liked, commented this comment, subscribed with notis on. If you haven’t already, do it to support the Muslim lantern 🙌🙌

[@naishanoor4730]

🙌 🙌

[@tayyabiqbal4926]

I don't know why I click this channel's video without a second even first thought 😅 and haven't regret it so far. Allahumma barik!🌻

[@ichimon7186]

My brain lagging when he say Agnostic Atheist😅

[@thomashardy7961]

It's like saying 1+1=7

[@azmanabas8425]

Just like 3 in 1 god

[@polopolomay1]

Just a clumsy way to say "I don't believe in God as you describe it."

[@polopolomay1]

@@joerdim I surmised the meaning based on the individual terms: Atheist, not holding a theistic belief, and agnostic, not believing that knowledge of a god has been revealed or can be known. These terms are generally in opposition to systems of religious belief. There is, however, a standard definition: "Agnostic atheists are atheistic because they do not hold a belief in the existence of any deity and are agnostic because they claim that the existence of a divine entity or entities is either unknowable in principle or currently unknown in fact."

[@polopolomay1]

@@joerdim Being one of them and having just seen some of your other comment interactions, I'll take that as a compliment. That said, it is unfortunate that the exchanges on this subject are more like those of contentious sports fans than they are a beneficial volleying of ideas and information between naturally competitive sides.

[@KasaAmiel]

Mark have a good manners. Good for u 🤝

[@omarz2145]

Man will be questioned in his grave and his response will be "anyways."

[@bolajiayoola5179]

Masha’Allah. May Allah increase you in knowledge and perverse you upon goodness.

[@doubleshot9535]

NEW SET UP LETS GO!!! ALLAHUMABARIK

[@pvsd_cs]

been waiting for this, was the last bit of it on stream thank you so much

[@azizbirmingham8056]

Well done brother Mohammed ❤

[@RememberQuranAlways]

Mashallah always to the point.... Love u for shake of Allah.. May Allah increase you and all muslims in knowledge

[@relakonecorner]

Did these people seriously believe that Allah Azzawajala created us without any purpose and that we would not be brought back to Allah Azzawajala to be held accountable according to our deeds? Tsk, tsk, tsk... 🤦🤦🤦

[@OFB307]

These Atheist believe that a religion HAS to be man made but the universe just happened to be on its own lmao.

[@shadyallawaty6908]

Atheist thinks hes mysterious 😂

[@ahmedmohsin8689]

😅 he does give off that vibe

[@mustafaacar8514]

He was civilized and respectful nonetheless.

[@shadabkhan-sy3sp]

​@@mustafaacar8514Naah he was subtle in his insults.

[@polopolomay1]

The host felt he was well-mannered and thanked him for such behavior. You should humble yourself. It's decently clear that he doesn't question God as much as he does the veracity of those who claim to follow it.@@shadabkhan-sy3sp

[@nemospodcast6766]

WalahI love this brother, and I love listening to this brother!

[@truthseeker31000]

I jumped on the notification

[@RedaReda-vl9ff]

Islam is the truth and Muhammad is the prophet and messenger of GOD,only ALLAH is worthy of worship,only one GOD,peace be upon Ahmad

[@ayanokojisenpaionce3092]

جزاك الله خيرا

[@MdSohanurRahman-vv1eb]

Lost ground from my feet after listening someone can be a agnostic atheist 🤯🤯🤯.

[@redred333]

A beautiful discussion. May Allah guide us all.

[@westmirrow3486]

At least someone else who found the discussion beautiful like i did. We need more of such discussions.

[@Rehfayi]

If you believe you're benefiting knowledge from Muslim lantern videos, kindly like the video each time before watching. It is the little effort we can do to benefits him. Jazakallah khair

[@angelosaleh8344]

Allahu Akbar ❤

[@rajibhossain8311]

Mark reminds me of the movie Matrix 🎬

[@fxorigins6624]

He took the wrong pill 😂

[@rajibhossain8311]

@@fxorigins6624 😀

[@Angellss4319]

Love the new setup 🩵🩵🤍

[@NaRa..7]

Mark Claiming prophet Mohammed take knowledge from everybody, an Muslim lantern said you will be seeing wrong in the whole Quran. And later on Mark doing the same about embryologie and you see him making wrong assumptions. 😂

[@westmirrow3486]

Since Mark has not posted information on Galenic embryology in the comments as he said he will i did some research and this is what i found. Here is Galenic Embryology vs Quranic Embryology side-by-side. (Galen von Pergamon died in the year 199.) The source of the information on galenic embryology is the collection of Galens works called “Galeni de Semine” which was originally in Greek. It was later translated into Syriac by Sergios von Resh Aina, who died in 532 in Konstantinopel, almost a century before Muhammed was born. Syrian was a main language in the Middle East, similar to English today. Here are the embryonic steps by Galen and the Quran side-by-side 1. The first is that in which, as is seen both in abortions and in dissection, *the form of the semen prevails*. Quran (Yusuf Ali translation from Quran dot com): Man We did create from a quintessence (of clay); Then We placed him *as (a drop of) sperm* in a place of rest, firmly fixed 2. . But when it has been *filled with blood* , and heart, brain and liver are still *unarticulated and unshaped* yet have by now a certain solidarity and considerable size, this is the second period; the substance of the foetus has the *form of flesh* and no longer the form of semen Quran (Yusuf Ali translation): “Then We made the sperm into a *clot of congealed blood* ; then of that clot We made a (foetus) lump” 3. The third period follows on this, when, as was said, it is possible to see the three ruling parts clearly and a kind of *outline, a silhouette* , as it were, of all the other parts. You will see the conformation of the three ruling parts more clearly, that of the parts of the stomach more dimly, and much more still, that of the *limbs*. Quran (Yusuf Ali translation): “then we made out of that lump bones and clothed the bones with flesh”…..(I never heard of such a stage in modern embryology) 4. The fourth and final period is at the stage when all the parts in the limbs have been differentiated; and at this part Hippocrates the marvellous no longer calls the foetus an embryo only, but already a child, too, when he says that it jerks and moves as an animal now fully formed.” Quran (Yusuf Ali translation): “ then we developed out of it another creature” I think Mark was correct. They are similar, and The Muslim Lantern claimed that Galen believed that the embryo came from menstrual blood, but this does not seem to be accurate. Galen was a proponent of he two-seed theory, and believed that females ejaculated a type of sperm from the ovaries. He differed with Aristotle on this point

[@bettajanggut2852]

Watching from Malaysia 🇲🇾🇲🇾

[@eldagon9306]

Actually, this ayat in Quran about clothing bones with flesh is my favorite scientific, so to say, argument from Quran. It's because many people are trying to attack Islam on this ayat, but they themselves don't know how to do research. Actual scientific data tells us that bones are indeed formed prior to muscles. It's so profound, how could Prophet Muhammad, Alaymin as-Salatu was-Salam, know this? It's impossible without Allah's help, and it is indeed Allah's speech!

[@natachaumar5052]

Indeed I am coming to know this. To write a fact in its simplest form and yet remain perfectly accurate is so difficult for any human. I can't see any human coming up with anything written better than this. It makes me wonder and want to know more.

[@JALILAHLatif]

MashAllah tabarak Allah sir fantastic reply amazing job 👏may Almighty ALLAH Bless you always and guide you always all the best 🤲👍👌👍❤❤❤

[@Sher245]

This Athiest had really good manners. May Allah guide him!

[@rebeccab4560]

Yasss ML keeping me happy this week alhamdulillah!

[@Preachmuslim]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته

[@salvatorearanzulla9104]

عليكم السلام ورحمه الله وبركاته

[@muhammadalikhan5588]

Thank you so much Muhammad Ali your channel and you is a hidaya to everyone who is born Muslim and want to become Muslim alhamdulillah suma alhamdulillah

[@TheKingofdans]

I like this guy, he's more respectful and soft spoken

[@Djibouti613]

Machallah! May Allah keep increasing your knowledge. Very good pedagogy and patience brother!

[@MSalman1]

Mohammed, there is an echo due to empty room I guess, maybe add those foam pads that dampen sound

[@ZakariaAmal-d5c]

Akhi you are the best keep going !!

[@masana_]

Well, he was at least quiet polite.

[@souhaa_ly]

زادك الله علما ونفع بك الإسلام والمسلمين

[@zamaniahmad3920]

Around 2:00 - “worship cow and the religion is earlier than Islaam” - WRONG. Prophet Adam the FIRST of mankind worshipped and SUBMITTED to the One True God. SUBMIT, SURRENDER, OBEDIENCE, SINCERELY (to attain) PEACE, one word in Arabic is ISLAAM.

[@heIlno7708]

Ur so patience, this man need second or third explanations to understand a thing

[@katiawojcik962]

It is not pathetic to need things explained a few times... instead of being negative towards someone, say alhamdulilah that the Truth came so easily to you. It may be that he will be greatly rewarded for continue to seek and struggle, Allah knows and we do not. It is very poor manners to abuse those who came with good manners.

[@suzan_sheikh]

Love you brother ❤

[@LimaTheBeamer]

Jazak Allah Khayr

[@JadenClarkJC]

Inshallah Mark will watch this video back and see that he did not listen. Alhamdulillah Islam will help you reflect and guide you to contemplate new information before jumping to new questions. This is another reason why knowledgeable Muslims will tackle the premise of disputes instead of the small nick picky arguments

[@saranpatel1114]

Alhamdulillah. Guidance comes from Allah swt

[@westmirrow3486]

Are we watching the same video? He listened and did not interrupt. He asked questions relevant to the discussion and in the end The Muslim Lantern even acknowledged his good manners and thanked him for this.

[@faisalsediqi6120]

جزاکم الله خیرا اخی محمد

[@SaleemKhan-gg1ne]

My Allah SWT bless Brother Muhammad Ali. BarakAllah feekum for your video can’t wait until next one.

[@bhk6091]

الحمدلله الذي هدانا لهذا، وماكنا لنهتدي لولا أن هدانا الله

[@YEAGERlST]

If you read this; Say "SubhanAllah" 33x Say "Alhamdulillah" 33x Say "Allahu akbar" 34x May Allah reward you.

[@suspectingislam]

Muslims believe in spells and magic 🪄 words !?!? 😮

[@malla_ahmad917]

@@suspectingislam what ? no . "SubhanAllah" is an Arabic phrase that translates to Glory be to God and "Alhamdulillah" is an Arabic phrase meaning "praise be to God" and "Allahu akbar" is an Arabic phrase, called Takbir, meaning "God is greater" or "God is [the] greatest" and the '' 33x '' means repeating it 33 times and the same to (34x)

[@malla_ahmad917]

@@suspectingislam and about that we believe in magic yes, it's true we believe in magic but doing magic or become a magician it will make you a kafir , kafir is an Arabic term in Islam which refers to a person who disbelieves in Allah

[@suspectingislam]

@@malla_ahmad917 but u say majic words for good fortune. It’s ok cause u say them to God ??

[@malla_ahmad917]

@@suspectingislam man its not a magic words?

[@mouhameduzi667]

Didn’t expect Muhammed Ali to talk about my country Senegal 🇸🇳😅❤️

[@ibrahimdeniz7308]

Guys if you dont like the video bc you dont want it in your folder: Like as many comments as you can it boosts the algorithm as well, it counts as engagement too

[@ahmad_2027]

Bruh, is this guy's brain even working, its like nothing Muhammad Ali is saying is going into his head. Is he even listening?

[@jwjagian6790]

It is Allah who erected the heavens without pillars that you [can] see; then He established Himself above the Throne and made subject the sun and the moon, each running [its course] for a specified term. He arranges [each] matter; He details the signs that you may, of the meeting with your Lord, be certain. Allah The Praiseworthy QURAN (13:2)

[@rajababy2009]

and in this century they came to know that Universe is the fabric of space and time Wrape with each other Just like a building blocks ALKHAMDULLILAH

[@randomrfkov]

​@@rajababy2009 Don't believe anything scientific astronomy philosophical rambling either. Most of them are unverifiable conjecture.

[@Moonlight-777]

"Creating "gods" " 🤦🏻‍♀️ AstaghfiruLlah Wa Atubu Ileihi. AlhamduliLlah for Islam, Wallahi☝🏻🤲🏻

[@OfficialOspo]

This is what i imagine the Nigerian prince that tells me i've won 1 million dollors in my email looks like

[@didyouprayyour5prayers996]

Dont forget your 5 daily prayers today

[@abdelhadibs405]

May Allah bless you