There Might Be Hidden Planets Inside Black Holes

Thanks to Scopely for sponsoring this video - Download Star Trek Fleet Command on iOS & Android and battle in the Star Trek universe here: pixly.go2cloud.org/SH2rJ
Get my new book Bread and Circuses: bit.ly/breadandcircusesbook
Listen to my new podcast Random Interesting Facts: bit.ly/RIFThoughty2
Or watch it on KZbin: bit.ly/RIFPodcastYT
Thoughty2 Audiobook: geni.us/t2audio
Thoughty2 Book: geni.us/t2book
Support Me & Get Early Access: bit.ly/t2club
Thoughty2 Merchandise: bit.ly/t2merch
Follow Thoughty2
Facebook: / thoughty2
Instagram: / thoughty2
Website: thoughty2.com
About Thoughty2
Thoughty2 (Arran) is a British KZbinr and gatekeeper of useless facts. Thoughty2 creates mind-blowing factual videos about science, tech, history, opinion and just about everything else.
#Thoughty2
Writing: Steven Rix
Editing: Giselle Hannah Santos

[@Thoughty2]

Download Star Trek Fleet Command on iOS & Android and battle in the Star Trek universe here: pixly.go2cloud.org/SH2rJ

[@WyldWolfDragon]

I'll consider it. uwu

[@stevezonneveld5171]

Well if you get right down to it..... with a super massive black hole at the center of our galaxy. Would that not make our galaxy the accretion disk? And everything in it its solar system????

[@arzachelh.1328]

Why isnt it far shrek?

[@lordbendtner6404]

Alternate title what if Blackbeard from one piece awaken his devil fruit n decided to do it

[@gshii8593]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZ-ZgqSfpL15iMk Finally its hereeeе

[@pipisugbo]

Thoughty2 signing off his videos with the idea of existential demise for humanity in the next 100 years, followed with wink and a smile...gets me every time 🤣🤣🤣

[@Chris-hx3om]

Yep, I give it 150-200 years, tops. The planet is kicking us off, and there's sod-all we can do about it...

[@abandonedhope2606]

@@Chris-hx3om bruh we getting evicted so soon? crap, our kids and grandkids.

[@karlhans6678]

i hope it does

[@vlada]

​@@Chris-hx3omfind yourself a safe space and crayons: conditioning has worked too well on you with all the climate doomsayers and chicken little creating a generation of emotionally incontinent hysterics.

[@bumblebeegamerreal]

Man, you gotta respect him for exploring the possiblities people don't think about that often

[@tuffin6275]

That's simply not true what if suddenly all of our air turned into poison

[@onion7484]

@@tuffin6275 then you and I would not be here right now

[@tuffin6275]

@@onion7484 XD give us a chance

[@asmrmy9664]

I ain't gotta Respect Shit, JACK!

[@Pr0toPoTaT0]

Man I just love watching these what if videos stoned. I mean I feel like he made a video about a what if that apparently wasn't even a possibility at all but I didn't know black holes had stuff orbiting it just like the sun. Can you freaking believe that. Like space is so unknown. And if you think about it, look how little we progressed before like a few hundred years ago. I just think people back then were lazy maybe? Or just not very smart. I mean I like to think maybe Jesus is real sometimes but then I think if that was true, we would have real hoverboards by now. Like I'm sorry, but they barely have good scooters. And driverless cars. That shit has been expected. But what if aliens came and gave us all this smart knowledge instead of Jesus. And what people really think is the Bible, is a story of a bunch of people following around an alien. Like abraham probably an alien told him you should show me what you're really willing to do for the continuance of your life and the rest of humanity. I mean what's more believable, that there's some other more advanced life forms or that there's an almighty being behind the creation of the whole universe like its a fucking puppet factory and studio all in one. What would it look like to him? Probably a big black ball right? Fucking dumb. Now I can get behind some aliens being like hey check out this cool thing that makes water into wine but the whole time they did it like a magic trick so they didn't know how just to make them feel more powerful. What if Mark Zuckerberg was an alien really trying to collect as much information on us to send back home. I wonder if that would be good or bad for us as a human race

[@jedus007]

You have an incredible way of narrating everything, it is a pleasure watching you. Great video

[@Mike--Oxmall]

I like to imagine him saying okily dokily

[@Neon_Wolf_Pack]

Ok ❤️🧍🏼‍♀️❤️💚💚💚💚💚💚💖💖💝💖💖♥️

[@kamikaze4867]

@@Mike--Oxmall lmao same

[@stillprophet7529]

In all my years of watching Space videos in my freetime, being the massive nerd that I am, I've never heard anyone suggest using the CMB as an energy source, love it!

[@herrschmidt5477]

because it's bs like he explained it, too.

[@garetclaborn]

@@herrschmidt5477 that is not what was said

[@violatethemagistrate]

Make sure you check out the 'Event Horizon' YT podcast if you haven't. Interviews with some very interesting people.

[@clintelkins9630]

@@herrschmidt5477 it's all about *balance* Intense *balance*

[@YounesLayachi]

Ikr !

[@WyldWolfDragon]

Can't wait to visit my favorite Blanet from the Black Holar System of the Bilky Bay Balaxy

[@nostalgia3979]

That comparison between the rhino and the grain of sand absolutely blew my mind.

[@mustertherohirrim7315]

More planets than grains of sand on Earth.

[@MeganVictoriaKearns]

​@@mustertherohirrim7315 more planets than atoms on Earth

[@seanpbarry]

Merry Christmas Aaron, nothing like the thought of the sun turning into a black hole to raise the Christmas spirit LOL. Thank you for all your interesting videos that have got us through covid and looking forward to more in 2022, enjoy your Christmas mate!

[@morchel332]

this is blasphemic.... hell will come upon earth disk.

[@AuRowe]

His name is Aaron🤯thought it was 42

[@kenpatner]

*Arran...

[@morchel332]

@@kenpatner fake name...

[@carlospenalver8721]

If the suns core began to spin light speed causing inertia to reject light from escaping thus causing a collapse and in turn stopping light from escape while grabbing everything around it and also condensing most it’s matter then yeah. We wouldn’t have to think about it anymore. 😁 Merry Christmas from me too Aaron

[@mellamosteve331]

What if we, the entire observable space, are inside a black hole so massive that our size is negligible

[@Wtfukker]

we are negligible regrardless of the large scale structure of reality. ;)

[@101Mant]

As far ad we can tell we cab move freely in any direction which would not be possible inside the event horizon. So our observations are incompatible with our us being inside based on our current understanding.

[@garetclaborn]

@@Wtfukker we are significant

[@garetclaborn]

there is a region, for some black holes, which is beyond the event horizon but not falling into the singularity. this region scales with the mass of the black hole in a way that makes your scenario possible

[@energeticstunts993]

yeah there is a theory about it actually, in a blackhole massive enough, spahgettification may not occur as violently and therefore it's safe

[@pepelimantour3757]

Love your channel only because of your wonderful delivery and story telling ability. Your Music choice is fantastic, I normally dislike any music combined with oratory. However you do it brilliantly. Keep up the good work. Cheers from South Africa pepe

[@mattchew69er]

I’ve always wondered if a black hole is a teleporter for the multiverse or it’s fun to think about dark energy life

[@umbra9029]

Don't forget that white holes exist too :)

[@JaredHardy001]

What a great way to start Christmas eve, black holes.

[@papatraildoc]

This is your best one yet, Aaron... Fantastic!!! Thanks for all you do, and have a wonderful holiday season.

[@steveross8364]

Hi Thoughty! How about doing a video on the FAILED STAR Jupiter and what would happen if it suddenly decided to ignite? Now that would be interesting.

[@jamx02]

Jupiter is *not* a failed star. Calling Jupiter a failed star is like calling an rc car a failed Humvee. Brown dwarfs are failed stars and the *smallest* ones are 14 times the mass of Jupiter. Jupiter has nowhere near the amount mass required to start fusing.

[@steveross8364]

@@jamx02 Well that's one opinion. The scientific community is divided on the subject with many considering all gas giants as 'failed stars' or 'stars in waiting'. While I'm not doubting the points you make, it would be an interesting 'what if' video either way IMHO, just like this one.

[@ilarious5729]

It's not a failed star, it's a very succesful planet thank you very much 😤

[@steveross8364]

@@ilarious5729 lol. Very droll. Gas Giant actually. Don't light a match...

[@JessicaZane4realz]

That question is already more interesting than anything I did so far this year.

[@Ice.muffin]

So depressing.

[@MultiAlanR]

I now have Black Hole Sun by Soundgarden in my head. Great song 🎵

[@W1LDTANG]

Thanks for that, after reading your comment, I do as well.... Lmao 😂🤣😂....................... Merry Christmas! 🇺🇸🐍🇺🇸

[@jrichard88]

First thing that popped into my head when I saw the title.

[@Amaranthine1000]

I got Supermassive Blackhole by Muse stuck in my head the moment he mentioned supermassive.

[@xiro6]

i wonder how the "sound" behaves on the events horizon.

[@gromeka]

All that song makes me think of is tripping my balls off. 😂 Lmao.. listening to that song on acid is a whole ass EXPERIENCE, I'll leave it at that!! 😵‍💫🤣😂 Lol

[@tobylaird6937]

Would like to give you a massive thanks Thoughty2, I've enjoyed your videos for a long time and have been a subscriber since your early youtubing days. Great to see that you have reached so many subscribers and also keep up the great work. Thanks for all of the incredibly interesting videos.

[@therealtimray]

I've heard these theories before, however, I really like the way you explained it in this video. Thanks !

[@itsdaz1894]

I'm more and more excited for every new video and find myself searching your channel Multiple times a day. Keep it up!

[@athys3650]

Absolutely love this man's videos

[@alphacause]

Answer to the question posed by the title: It would make the song by Soundgarden, "Black Hole Sun" even more cool!

[@supernovaempress7311]

LOVE YOU, T2❣️ l truly enjoy watching each and every one of your videos. Like peanut butter and jelly, hamburger and french fries or in your case, tea and a biscuit, lol, the highly accurate information is educating and the sarcastic humour/ jokes are funny as he**. Keep up the awesome work.👍🏼

[@BB-km1yx]

I already know this is going to be a banger

[@bloodlessillnesses]

16:45 Even if we only have that left, with channels like yours, I'm happy we were able to create this, and make such art and memories with the short time we had. Apocalypse could come tomorrow, and I wouldn't fret. Proud of my brothers and ancestors

[@ImprovementGang]

Never thought about this possibility. However, these videos keep opening up my mind to more possibilties.

[@drewsify552]

One thing I’ve thought of about what we consider a habitable planet, is that it’s based solely off earth. We only have life on earth as an example, but there could be alien life that survives on completely different things.

[@almighty3946]

Merry Christmas Thoughty2

[@chrisglaze658]

That was a great episode! not sure how I missed this back in Dec. Awesomeness dude!

[@aceferreraprolexplayz7257]

This is my first time I watch a video and Being 36 Second Ago Lol

[@Larkstream]

Literally just watched 3 videos all uploaded within a few minutes of me finding them. What's going on lol

[@timb2895]

@H*T conten what the frick?

[@masterred8958]

Ok

[@masterred8958]

@@timb2895 Some Spammers Spamming

[@Larkstream]

@@masterred8958 just report it, it'll get removed eventually. Damn KZbin bots!

[@lilyisvibing]

Your videos are always so interesting and they always keep my mind off sad things. Thanks for making such great and amazing content!

[@GingerGuyGames]

Merry Christmas Thoughty2 🎄

[@blackenedheart9592]

This is one of his best videos. Very interesting and informative. I love learning new things about outer space

[@xavierninetwofourfiveone6901]

With the JWST having launched, I cant wait for future space videos from you. Just like all you videos they're amazing, but the new discoveries shall make it even more so.

[@vernonvouga5869]

I enjoy your snarky humor in commentary involving the universe, you should do more videos like this.

[@berniewighton1496]

brilliant as always Thoughty2

[@ayeshafarooq7453]

I would literally love to sit and have a conversation with this dude. We could just talk about space and its endless possibilities all day.

[@grahamwells173]

Love your videos bro they are very informative and dam great British sense of humour

[@Evangeline-Katherine]

I've been subscribed to this channel since 2017,,, 🥰❤️ and this is the right video for the right sponsor,,,, 🤗🤗🤗❤️

[@michaelmpole2152]

Thoughty2 notification is the best feeling ever

[@kyreyes4289]

One of my favorites 👏🏽 this was great

[@drcgaming4195]

gotta hand it to you to give everyone an existential crisis just before christmas

[@benmcreynolds8581]

Black holes are the perfect example of: " It's not the size that matters, it's whats on the inside that counts." 👍 Take notes guys, that's how the ancient Greeks thought.

[@lynndurbin9403]

Great video! Thanks for sharing, lots to think about!

[@oxylol_]

Thoughty2 making our day better

[@paulhernandez987]

I've watched all his videos, so I'm basically a scientist now.

[@Dark0neone]

I've been in the pool before so I'm basically an Olympian.

[@gaminglichgamer4035]

The gravity would be essentially the same.Gravity works the same with black holes as it does with everything else,the planets will continue the orbit the black hole as normally,except without the sun we'll still all die.

[@Kenjuudo]

This is hands down your best video yet.

[@eleshasmith6064]

Brilliant work as usual.

[@LazyDaze86]

Hmmm. This brings a valid question to the table. As we all know, there is a super massive black hole at the center of the the galaxy...being a spiral galaxy...who's to say we are not caught within the accretion disc of said black hole as well the possibility of experiencing time dialation. Would we even truly know if we were?

[@Diree]

The bigger question is: Would or should we even care? These are things no mortal being will ever "solve" in its life time. And looking at our species, before we get to the bottom of this or before this knowledge becomes relevant we'll have either died out or bombed ourselves back into the stone age repeatedly.

[@herrschmidt5477]

uhm...because we orbit around the sun. And we don't get shred by plasma and a radioactive h-bomb mixer. And we are "some" light years away from the center. And i guess you mix up gravity and accretion disc..?

[@jamx02]

We aren't orbiting the SMBH in the middle of the milky way, only stars within 27 lightyears are gravitationally bound to it. I've said this before, but if you ever hear someone talking about how galaxies orbit around black holes, please personally slap them in the face for me because this is very false. Sgr A* (smbh) could disappear right now and it would make no difference in the milky way.

[@tylermonday3558]

@@Diree Why shouldn't we care? It's searching for answers that we believed unanswerable that has brought us where we are. We will likely never have the answer to many questions, but we also could find it, or our children, or perhaps 100 generations down the line. If we never question it however, there is no chance of finding an answer. No reason to not question, search for an answer, but be prepared to not find the answer.

[@bluefrenk1750]

IN MY EYES INDISPOSED IN DISGUISES NO ONE KNOWS

[@lukesouthall3275]

HIDES THE FACE

[@aevvah_flxwer8550]

LIES THE SNAKE

[@NathanVarghese430]

Happy late new year Arran!Wish the best for you and your channel mate.

[@technicaldifficultysupport]

Best video in a while. Thanks for all the hard work.

[@ink7180]

If Earth was in the Goldilocks zone of the accretion disc, would it still have day or night? Considering that we would be surrounded by high speed contents of the disc that is constantly producing friction, so heat and light. And if we don’t have day or night anymore, should we still have time zones?

[@basstard13]

Not as day and night as we know them in my opinion. Depending on the light emitted by the accretion zone material and if the planet was spinning on its own axis, one could have different lighting conditions, as in maybe the inner part of the accretion disk would be spinning faster and thus emitting more light than the outer part so if the planet was spinning, you're get more light when facing the brighter side obviously. So no, you wouldn't have days and nights as I understand it.

[@harkamelrandhawa7125]

Awesome video completely mind blowing. Aaron must have an IQ of 200+. I was thinking the observable universe is expanding faster than the speed of light so it's impossible to see what is beyond that horizon. Could there be multiple universes occurring similar to ours beyond this horizon? Is impossible to imagine and see but it's awesome we could see as much as we can. Merry Christmas and god bless everyone. Maybe if possible in near future Aaron could look into and share his ideas on god and maybe cosmic destiny or destiny of humanity or something. Anyway love these videos. I think internet/KZbin came about to host them.

[@BoostDesignsOfficial]

These are the videos I subbed for

[@eggbirdtherooster]

Massively interesting! Thanks!

[@headshot6959]

Great video, funny as always but a planet would not become a brown dwarf if it's mass became too large. Unless the planet you were referring to was a gas giant comprised of hydrogen and helium. If the planet was solid like Earth, Venus, Mars etc - it would never become a brown dwarf due to a lack of essential light elements required for sustainable fusion, it would never achieve 'ignition.'

[@boxoftin]

Yeahh i was thinking that too

[@headshot6959]

@@boxoftin I think thoughty2, or 'foughty2' as the man cannot pronounce a 'th' is insufficiently versed in physics. Nor his team.

[@Sumcant]

What if Uranus was a black hole?….

[@calledbythegrave9491]

So this is thoughtys idea of a merry Christmas video hahah! Aaron you're the best! Happy holidays mate!

[@mikeedwards2384]

Great video food for thought over the holidays lol Merry Christmas Thoughty 2

[@cashobuyer]

Considering the hypothesis that the planets as they a drawn into the black hole are literally torn apart atom by atom as they approach the event horizon, I very much doubt the possibility of them existing as anything that closely resembles what we know as a planet once on the other side of the event horizon... I'd love to know your thoughts on this everyone.

[@garetclaborn]

well being ripped apart by gravity doesn't necessarily happen at the event horizon. for a supermassive blackhole it happens quite a ways in beyond the event horizon. for stellar mass blackholes it happens even before you reach the event horizon.

[@energeticstunts993]

true, but at some point we will come to a point where living around a black hole is the only way our species will be able to survive by harvesting the energy of the blackhole. Also there are safe distances where you could orbit quite nicely around blackholes without running too much into risks. My question is however, if all the blackholes die through hawking radiation or everything is turns into iron 56 and then also fades through hawking radiation, there will be NOTHING in the universe anymore. All matter would be gone, what is our species then gonna do by then? Except for quantum fluctuation there won't be anything. Also sidenote, there's a very good chance the big bang happened due to quantum fluctuation, if this stuff intrests you, there is an amazing youtube channel that coverse quantum mechanics: kzbin.info/www/bejne/d5zaYnmHmL6Ya7c

[@garetclaborn]

@@energeticstunts993 well, turns out we detect minute amounts of protons popping into existence "spontaneously" from virtual particles at a certain rate per cubic lightyear in intergalactic voids. given that proton decay has been shown not to follow the standard model -- I'd argue that with such a sweaty empty space the full heat death scenario is actually off the table as per iron 56 and hawking radiation great thought though. i can only speculate what fusion may be like near the singularity

[@aerindinescarro47]

Well that doesn’t mean the matter doesn’t still exist on an “other side” for it to ball back up into planetoids hypothetically, life existing on them is a whole other can of worms, but I feel that’s far more unlikely

[@cashobuyer]

Thank you all so much for your perspective on my comment. Brilliant to read x

[@sussekind9717]

Even if a planet (blanet) were able to find the right orbit around a black hole, with just the right size, just the right amount of energy, to keep water liquid, it would still have one major problem that you neglected to visit. Radiation. If you look at a black hole through a radio telescope, there are extreme amounts of radiation around the black hole. Since carbon based life forms that rely on DNA for not only life, but also for reproduction, it would be terminal, before it even got started. If life were to arise in such a place, it would have to be a completely different form of life.

[@joesphjoeastar6024]

Wouldn't the beings bodys like be made for that radiation

[@adama4669]

God forbid we orbit a big ball of radioactive plasma instead.

[@Chris-hx3om]

"one major problem" Just one?????

[@Censeo]

Ok, so mutations would occur much more frequent if time passed like here, but with time dialation it might occur about the same rate as here.

[@hippis563]

Good vid Toughty2 keep it up and merry-x mas !

[@kahiakola8879]

Always mind blowing thank you

[@IronWolf123]

Could time relativity make objects older than the Big Bang?

[@Flank.Sinatra.]

Pass the blunt

[@marshallstan8979]

I would say no but also yes, time is percetion. And if youre perception is that on millers world things can be omder than the big bang

[@herrschmidt5477]

@@marshallstan8979 .....jeah...because if something that created another thing didn't happen the created thing will be older....that makes so much sense ._. maybe stay with making silly 1 minute dance "moves"

[@dryb3301]

No , never

[@Censeo]

Whatever time dialation and perception of time, earth orbit compared to the age of the universe has the same ratio I think.

[@jefschobert9765]

I've flown through the sun in an astral projection and found it is a black hole seen from the inside. On the other side is a super Earth. Of course "imagination" lol

[@ten-dimension9390]

5:05 man this animation is hilarious. Neptune saying: "Glad you are not much of a sucker" and blackhole replying "Thanks" 😂

[@hunchofondcolesparrot3495]

Merry Christmas 🎅 🎄 everyone ❤

[@Ggdivhjkjl]

Thumbs up if you're not watching from Earth!

[@Rofriends]

Not funny man... You know i got stranded in my last mission

[@legendlizard]

@@Rofriendswomp womp

[@jodiel3628]

First!

[@MrAbkejoe]

Darn ya beat me, well played

[@max-jx5ne]

You are

[@jodiel3628]

I’ve never actually been first but today was different 🤪🥰

[@matt29131234]

Man your videos are always amazing. Thank you 🙏

[@tristandoerksen6678]

Interesting and hilarious! Couldn't help laughing every time you said 'Blanet'

[@MowiWowi]

Your channel is my absolute favorite on YT no bull

[@takster050974]

Interessant video thanks. 😀👌🏻

[@dennisripley7529]

This guy had voice that I could listen to for hours. Like Morgan freeman but british! Love the vids!

[@Alalpog]

Merry Christmas!!

[@monaxey]

This might be the single best video I have ever watched and I mean it.

[@lynxluciferian382]

Mate what a video, you're the man

[@MasterDk78]

I love it, what an awesome vid! well done!

[@jaelhardin6401]

I love thoughty 2 and his accent

[@ilirhaveriku9749]

Truly mind blowing.

[@lewistremonti7827]

This is the sorta thing that will keep me up at night the sheer size of space blows my mind to the point I can’t comprehend it 🤯

[@angrypossumsx1259]

Hey Thoughty that was pretty cheeky slipping in a 2nd spruik for Fleet Command ;)

[@Sid29]

More such videos please. These are better than watching horror or tragedy related videos.

[@Thomas-yr3id]

Happy Christmas Everyone

[@RafiBarides]

Another excellent video.

[@LilLingLing6789]

Merry Christmas Adam all the best to you and yours and to everyone else who helps make these videos ❤️

[@EEE_MMM]

*Enters Google mode* Did you mean Arran? */Google mode off*

[@CrimsonLadyVT]

Happy holiday Arran! 💛

[@roukioo]

I love this guys videos they keep me entertained I stay up watching them

[@lokei7565]

What's up my dude. Love your videos bro

[@lifeadventureswithjeremyca590]

Awesome, and insightful knowledge on blanets, and blackholes!!! Thanks for sharing!!!!$😎🚀❤🌠🤙🏽

[@omkarkulkarni1621]

great work

[@sabishiihito]

Soundgarden immediately popped into my head when I saw this title.

[@libertycentral6564]

Great video!

[@edholmes8726]

Amazing video!

[@danielpistola]

another great video!

[@tristanp7416]

“Things are about to get seriously weird” Star Trek game ad starts

[@pauldavidson4977]

100 trillion years? Well that gives me just enough time to take a hot bath. Love your research.

[@brettpearce8843]

This was a great watch after just seen the film look up.

[@matthewgiles3499]

Love ya vids quality 😊